← Back to 舊五代史

卷六十六 唐書42: 列傳18 安重誨 朱弘昭 朱洪實 康義誠 藥彥稠 宋令詢

Volume 66 Book of Later Tang 42: Biographies 8 - An Zhonghui, Zhu Hongzhao, Zhu Hongshi, Kang Yicheng, Yao Yanchou, Song Lingxun

Chapter 66 of 舊五代史 · Old History of the Five Dynasties
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 66
Next Chapter →
1
使 使 使
An Chonghui came from a line of great chiefs among the northern tribes. His father Fuqian was a Hedong general who perished in the relief of Yan and Yun. Chonghui had served at Mingzong's side since before he took the throne. When Mingzong held Xingzhou, he appointed Chonghui Central Gate commissioner. For more than ten years he followed Mingzong on campaign; trust never wavered, and his exertions were beyond measure. At the Ye city crisis, his service in securing the throne stood above all others. When Mingzong took the throne, Chonghui headed the Privy Council and soon also held the post of senior general of the Left Army Guard. (The text below is lost.)〉 Mingzong sent the Uighur envoy Hou San post-haste to his homeland. At remote Liquan County there were no relay mounts; the magistrate Liu Zhizhang was out hunting and failed to provide horses promptly, and Hou San reported the delay at once. Mingzong flew into a rage, had Zhizhang shackled and sent to the capital, and meant to put him to death; Chonghui pleaded for him calmly, and Zhizhang was spared. On a visit to Bianzhou, Chonghui urged using the occasion to strike Wu, but Mingzong hesitated. Later Minister of Revenue Li Lin relayed a Wu spy's message: "Xu Zhigao wishes to submit Wu as a tributary state and asks for Lord An's word as assurance." Li Lin at once brought the spy before Chonghui. Chonghui was delighted, took it for truth, and gave the spy a jade belt to carry to Zhigao as token—worth a thousand strings of cash.
2
使 使 使 便 使
For four or five years as Privy Council commissioner he held power alone; none among the guards, tribal leaders, imperial kin, or inner circle dared meddle in affairs. His brother governed Zhengzhou, his sons held Huai and Meng, and he was chief councilor himself—responsibilities beyond his gifts; many said ruin was inevitable. Soon a clerk, younger brother of Li Qianhui, declared in public: "I hear a fortune-teller say his rank is beyond telling—he is about to lead troops against Huainan. A military officer secretly reported this, and it greatly troubled the emperor. Mingzong told Chonghui, "I hear you have gathered partisans and bought weapons on the sly, planning to take Huainan yourself—is that true?" Chonghui, in alarm, replied, "Only Your Majesty orders campaigns and commanders; this must be schemers' work—I beg you to trace whoever said it." Next day the emperor called An Congjin, Yao Yanchou, and others and asked, "Someone accuses An Chonghui of hoarding arms to harm the realm—what shall we do?" They answered, "This is schemers' slander, meant to part Your Majesty from a loyal veteran. Chonghui has served you thirty years, rising from nothing, never stinting loyalty—why would he rebel now! We stake our families on it—there is no such thing." The emperor's suspicions eased. Chonghui three times asked to leave office; the throne refused. He pleaded again in audience: "Grant me a post in one circuit to still the talk. Mingzong was annoyed. Chonghui kept petitioning until Mingzong snapped, "Go then—I have others! He sent Martial Virtue commissioner Meng Hanqiong to the Secretariat to discuss Chonghui with the chief ministers. Feng Dao said, "If you mean to spare Lord An, let him leave the Privy Council. Zhao Feng said, "Great ministers must not be shifted lightly—you misspeak, sir." They told Hanqiong to report, "The decision is yours, Majesty, but do not lightly move a great minister." Fan Yanguang was then made co-commissioner; Chonghui kept his post.
3
綿 西 使 使西 使 使
Eastern Chuan's Dong Zhang held difficult country and defied control; when Wuyou Yu was sent to Mianzhou, Zhang's suspicions deepened and he imprisoned Yu and rebelled. Shi Jingtang's expedition into Shu stalled on bad passes and broken supply lines; Mingzong worried, and Chonghui volunteered to go west. Next day he rode out with a few escorts, covering hundreds of li a day; western governors were terrified. Cash, grain, and fodder were rushed by night wherever he went; men and horses littered the roads dead beyond count, and the people groaned under it. At Fengxiang, commissioner Zhu Hongzhao welcomed him to his private quarters; wife and children served food with deepest respect. Over the meal Chonghui said, "Yesterday slander nearly destroyed me; only the Emperor's grace spared my house. He wept. After he left, Hongzhao reported, "Chonghui spoke bitterly in resentment; keep him from the front lest he steal Shi's command. Xuanhui commissioner Meng Hanqiong, back from the west, also denounced Chonghui. Chonghui had reached Sanquan when orders recalled him to court. Passing Fengxiang again, Hongzhao shut him out; in fear he raced on, and before the capital an edict made him Hedong commander. At his post he could not rest easy and asked to retire. When the edict issued, sons Chongzan and Chongxu fled to him at Hedong. At their arrival Chonghui cried, "How did they get here? His family asked why; he said, "I know—they did not choose this; someone sent them. I owe the state only my death—nothing more to say! Next day an imperial messenger came and wept long at the sight of him. Chonghui said, "Speak your errand—do not pity me so. The messenger said, "They say you hold the city in rebellion!" Chonghui said, "One death cannot answer my debt—I have failed emperor and kin; how dare I rebel and trouble the court and your sleepless nights—my guilt would only multiply!"
4
使 使 使 使
Zhai Guangye was dispatched to Hedong to probe rebellion and kill him if guilt were found. Li Congzhang surrounded the house with troops yet bowed in the courtyard; Chonghui descended to return the bow, saying, "Grand Mentor, too much honor. Mid-bow Congzhang smashed his head with a mace; his wife rushed to shield him crying, "Lord An need not die yet—Grand Mentor, why such haste!" He shattered her skull too, stripped them both, and left husband and wife naked in the hall, blood flooding the court. Next day the deputy asked leave to clothe the bodies; only after urgent pleas was it allowed. His estate proved worth only a few thousand strings; critics said he had saved the dynasty yet aimed too high, clung to power, failed to court the literati or plan for safety, indulged his pride, and was ruined. (The 《Supplement to the History of the Five Dynasties》: When Meng Zhixiang was seizing Shu he asked to move his family. Privy Council commissioner An Chonghui ruled and refused; Zhixiang said, "I see. He secretly sent a hundred taels of gold; Chonghui, pleased, memorialized for him and won permission. When his kin arrived he laughed to his officers, "The world fears the Privy Council as unmatched—yet a hundred taels of gold buys it off; nothing to dread. He then held the mountains and refused obedience. (The 《Lost Texts of the History of the Five Dynasties》: Mingzong ordered Zhai Guangye and Li Congzhang to kill Chonghui at his Hedong mansion; Congzhang felled him with a mace; Chonghui said, "I die without regret—only that I did not help the Emperor kill the Prince of Lu; he will plague the court hereafter. He died as he spoke. I note: the 《Veritable Records of Mingzong》 was edited under Emperor Qingtai; the Prince of Lu is Qingtai. The historians evaded taboo and would not name him plainly. Alas, Chonghui's loyal resolve is lost to the record!)〉
5
使使使 使 西 西 使 使 使 使 使 使 使 使
Zhu Hongzhao was from Taiyuan. His grandfather Min and father Shuzong were both staff officers of the Taiyuan command. He served Mingzong as guest-reception officer in the prince's domain. Tiancheng 1 he became Literary Thought commissioner; after two years as Eastern Chuan deputy he was Left Guard senior general and Inner Guest Service commissioner. Year 3 he became Southern Xuanhui commissioner. At Mingzong's southern suburban sacrifice Hongzhao was grand inner custodian and made acting Grand Mentor. He took Fengxiang; Shi Jingtang's Shu campaign stalled; An Chonghui volunteered to go west. At Fengxiang Hongzhao met him on the road, lodged him at his mansion, and had wife and children bow and toast his health. He secretly told Jingtang, "Lord An comes to oversee the army; he acts rashly—if he reaches camp the men may rally to him and you will collapse without fighting. Turn him back at once—he will not dare advance, and all will be safe. Jingtang, terrified, burned camp and retreated the same day. Chonghui, hearing this, dared not go west and turned back east. Passing Fengxiang again, Hongzhao shut him out. When Chonghui fell, Hongzhao came to court as Left Martial Guard senior general and Southern Xuanhui commissioner. Changxing 3, month 12, he replaced Kang Yicheng at Xiangyang. Year 4 the Prince of Qin Congrong was marshal and spoke threats; ministers feared and sought posts away from court. Commissioners Fan Yanguang and Zhao Yanshou wept daily for release; Mingzong refused in anger. Yanshou's wife the Princess of Xingping pleaded within; Yanguang used Meng Hanqiong and Consort Wang—both won leave. Soon Zhao Yanshou went to Bian; Hongzhao was recalled from Xiangyang as Privy Council commissioner with co-chief councilor rank. Month 10 Fan Yanguang went to Changshan; Feng Yun shared the Privy Council with Hongzhao; they joined Kang Yicheng and Meng Hanqiong to plot the Prince of Qin's death. Emperor Min's accession Hongzhao credited to himself; he dictated policy; after the general amnesty he jumped from co-chief councilor to chief councilor. He always distrusted the Prince of Lu, widened the breach, and brought disaster. At the Prince of Lu's arrival in Shan, Emperor Min panicked and meant to flee; he sent an urgent hand edict to Hongzhao to act. General Mu Yanhui was at his house and said, "They summon in haste—the blame is mine; what now? My daughter is your son's wife—fetch her at once lest she be harmed. Messengers followed; Hongzhao drew his sword, wept, and went to the rear court to die; his family restrained him. Pressed hard, Hongzhao cried, "Brought to this pass!" He threw himself into a well. An Congjin killed Feng Yun, took Hongzhao's head, and both were rushed to Shan. Later Han Gaozu posthumously made him Minister of Works.
6
使 使 使 西
Zhu Hongshi's origins are unknown. A career built on valor brought him to Horse Army commander in the Changxing era. As marshal the Prince of Qin favored his daring; seasonal gifts outdid other commanders. Under Privy Council commissioner Hongzhao's peak power, Hongshi treated him as kin and they largely agreed. Hongzhao told him of the plot to kill the Prince of Qin; Hongshi raised no objection. Kang Yicheng's son served the Qin mansion, so he straddled both camps. At the assault on the Duan Gate Meng Hanqiong sent Hongshi's cavalry out the Left Flank Gate against the prince; Yicheng thereafter bore a grudge. Emperor Min's accession made Hongshi proud of commanding the troops; he would not defer to Yicheng. Yingshun 1, third month, day xinyou: Yicheng marched; the emperor visited the Left Treasury to pay the troops in person. Yicheng and Hongshi argued strategy face to face in the treasury, (The 《Ouyang History》: Hongshi saw no fighting spirit in the men while Yicheng marched them all west and suspected treachery.)〉 Hongshi said, "We have sent army after army against the rebels; now at a small defeat not a rider returns. Hold the palace guards at the gates—they will not dare charge in; then plan our next move—that is the whole strategy. Yicheng snapped, "Say that and you are the rebel." Hongshi shouted, "You are the rebel—not I!" Their voices rose louder. The emperor summoned them; Hongshi pressed his plan and said, "Yicheng accuses me—by his deployments he is the rebel. Emperor Min could not judge; he ordered Hongshi killed. Yicheng soon surrendered the guards to the Prince of Lu; posterity called Hongshi's death a miscarriage of justice.
7
使使 使 使西使 使使 使
Kang Yicheng, style Xinchen, came from the three northern tribal groups. Young he rode for the Martial Emperor; entering Weibo with Zhuangzong he became a Swift Cavalry officer and rose to command the household guard. At Tongguang's end he followed Mingzong against Ye; mutineers pressed Mingzong to rule and he refused. Yicheng urged, "The throne ignores peril and the soldiers' pain, drowning in sport and wine. Follow the crowd and we live; hold to loyalty and we die. Mingzong took his counsel and trusted him with his inmost thoughts. At Mingzong's accession he became acting Minister of Works, governed Fu, and kept the Swift Cavalry. Soon he commanded the Sacred Guard and held Bin. At Bian he pacified Zhu Shouyin and became Horse Army commander and Jiangxi commissioner. Back in Luoyang he held Horse and Foot command and Heyang. Late Changxing he became co-chief councilor. (The 《Idle Talk from the Jade Hall》: Changxing-era commissioner Kang Yicheng once took a man from a great house as yard servant and had him lightly beaten. One day pitying his age he asked his name: "Kang. Further questions on home, kin, and children revealed his father; they embraced and wept; all who heard were astonished.)〉 Late Changxing he became co-chief councilor.
8
使 使使使 使 使 使 使 沿
Yao Yanchou came from the three Shatuo tribes. Young he rode for Mingzong and rose to company rank. At Mingzong's accession he held Cheng and commanded Heyang horse and foot. With Wang Yanqiu he pacified Wang Du at Ding and received Shou and Foot Army deputy command. Yang Yanwen's Hedong revolt made him Foot commander and deputy pacifier; he crushed the rebellion. Tangut raiders struck the Uighur tribute mission; Yanchou camped at Shuofang, hunted rebels and bandits, recovered the tribute camels, horses, and gems, and returned with chiefs captive. Soon he was commissioner of Bin. Ordered to secure Salt Prefecture, the tribes fled; over a thousand captives were restored to their homes. He joined the Yanzhou commissioner, (Two characters are missing in the original.)〉 to attack Xiazhou; months passed without success; the army withdrew. Under Emperor Min he attacked Fengxiang with Wang Sitong as deputy pacifier. When the palace guard broke, Yanchou tried to flee downstream but soldiers seized and handed him over. The Last Emperor was at Hua; he was jailed and killed. Later Han Gaozu posthumously made him and Wang Sitong Palace Attendants.
9
Song Lingxun's origins are unknown. In the prince's domain Lingxun served as guest officer, literate and courteous in all he did. In Changxing the prince held great commands; Lingxun became chief adjutant, won repute in border affairs, and earned deep trust. At accession Zhu and Feng ruled and ousted old companions; Lingxun was sent to Cizhou. In exile at Wei Lingxun sent daily runners to inquire after him. Hearing of the murder he mourned half a day and hanged himself.
10
The historian says: Even hewing for a master carpenter cuts the hand—how much more wielding imperial punishments! Ancient worthies in high office humbled themselves, disclaimed ownership, served the public, and shunned private gain—only then did they survive. What sort of man was Chonghui to escape death? As the proverb says, "Do not lead the power—you will bear the blame. Does this not fit Chonghui! From Hongzhao on, none could guard the realm or steady the state—they fell one after another; who else was to blame? Only Lingxun, honoring old grace, died by his own hand in grief—a name that endures.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →