← Back to 舊五代史

卷六十七 唐書43: 列傳19 豆盧革 韋說 盧程 趙鳳 李愚 任圜

Volume 67 Book of Later Tang 43: Biographies 19 - Dou Luge, Wei Shou, Lu Cheng, Zhao Feng, Li Yu, Ren Huan

Chapter 67 of 舊五代史 · Old History of the Five Dynasties
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 67
Next Chapter →
1
Dou Luge — a forebear in his line had served as prefect of Tongzhou; the ancestral name is not preserved in the received text. His father Zan was prefect of Shu. (The Xuanhe Calligraphy Catalogue notes that his pedigree is lost.)〉 In his youth Ge lived through war and exile, taking refuge in Fu and Yan before moving on to Zhongshan. Wang Chuzhi honored him and brought him onto his staff, where he gained a reputation for polished memorials and dispatches. At a peony festival he wrote a poem that, through mulberry and ramie, gently admonished Chuzhi. The verse was so refined and archaic in tone that Chuzhi came to esteem him ever more highly and promoted him to adjutant of the military commission. Yet he ran his household without discipline. When he alone sought an audience with Chuzhi, the lord, worried that his own governance might be at fault, came to remonstrate with him. Ge put away his tablet and came out to receive him — only to ask a military appointment for a favorite.
2
駿
Near the end of the Tianyou reign, as Emperor Zhuangzong prepared to take the throne, he looked for chief ministers. Lu Zhi recommended Ge as a scion of a great house, and he was summoned and appointed Left Chief Minister of the Mobile Imperial Secretariat. At the opening of the Tongguang era he was made Grand Councilor. Once he entered the highest councils, affairs were often in disorder; in drafting ranks and offices he would reverse precedence, and Secretariat officer Xiao Xifu repeatedly corrected him. Ge made the changes without show of resentment. When Zhuangzong first secured Bian and Luoyang, Ge recommended Wei Shuo, hoping that Shuo knew how the court worked and would share the burden of office with him. After Shuo took office he again occupied himself with pedigree and rank, and his manner was careless and flippant; public resentment fell on Ge. Moreover, both Ge's and Shuo's sons were appointed Reminders, father and son holding office together — a thing people ridiculed — so their posts were changed to outside Secretariat members. Ge asked that Shuo's son Tao be made an academician of the Hongwen Institute; Shuo asked that Ge's son Sheng be made an academician of the Jixian Institute. They traded favors like peddlers in a market, and thoughtful observers were disgusted. After Ge himself became chief minister, he did not make recommending the worthy and encouraging ability his concern, but devoted himself solely to alchemical refinement in search of the art of long life; He once ingested cinnabar, vomited blood for days, and was near death before he recovered.
3
使 使便 便祿 便
Early in Tiancheng, as Zhuangzong was to be interred, Ge was appointed commissioner for the imperial tomb. When the spirit tablet had been installed in the ancestral temple, he stayed in his private house, waiting only for a frontier command. After days without news, relatives and friends pressed him to go to court. An Chonghui humiliated him before the court, saying, "You still bear the title of tomb commissioner. Without waiting for a new appointment you walk into open court — as though you thought a man from the marches could be fooled." Those who already watched him with suspicion heard this and looked for a chance to strike. Earlier Xiao Xifu had hoped for a post as straight remonstrator; Ge had once blocked him. He now submitted a memorial charging Ge and Shuo with making shift for their own comfort and serving the ruler without due propriety. He further accused Ge of letting tenant retainers commit murder and of fraudulently claiming first place in the jinshi examination. Ge was therefore demoted to prefect of Chen and ordered sent off immediately by post relay from wherever he was. Later Zheng Jue, Ren Huan, and others submitted three memorials in succession asking that the later order not stand. An edict was then issued: "Dou Luge, Wei Shuo, and the like, as chief ministers holding the scales of power, would sometimes sit stiffly and call themselves subjects, sometimes report affairs with a half-smile — discourtesy to the ruler that the world could not abide. Ge, meanwhile, had temporarily delegated profitable authority and helped himself to salary and emoluments: every civil and military official was paid from the fifth month onward, but he and his son alone were paid from the first. Shuo, for his part, held a weighty post yet threw the great administrative framework into disorder. Greedy for glory in granting hereditary privilege, he scrambled the proper order of sons and grandsons in the ancestral halls; sold offices to enrich his household and traded the personal names recorded on orders and registers. Their shameful conduct piled up in plain sight and public anger rose together. Though they were sent to regional governorships, this was meant to answer criticism, not as excessive punishment. Ge is demoted to Army Adjutant of Feizhou; Shuo to Army Adjutant of Yizhou — both as supernumerary posts with regular status — and both are to be sent off immediately by post relay from wherever they are." Soon they were reduced to long-term exiles registered as commoners of Lingzhou, with local chiefs ordered always to know where they were. In the summer of the second year of Tiancheng an edict ordered the prefect of each place where they were held to supervise and grant them death by their own hand; their families were banished at once as well.
4
His son Sheng had risen to proofreader in the Secretariat and wore gold and purple insignia, but these too were soon stripped from him. (The Baojin Studio Calligraphy Eulogy preserves Dou Luge's "Letter on Fields and Gardens," in which he writes that his correspondent Great Virtue wants a residence; he has no estate near the capital, and though Fuzhou has two or three manor farms, the common people have rented them for years. The Prince and Great King have repeatedly written to claim them, yet Ge returned them to the registered households — not wishing to seize from exhausted commoners and fearing that ignorant men might falsely shelter others to evade corvée, and so forth. Yue Ke comments: This letter was exchanged with a monk. In fearing powerful feudatories and avoiding the net of punishment he was as cautious as if treading on thin ice — yet in the end he was still banished to Yelang for indulging tenant retainers who killed, suffering precisely what he had feared. Truly, a chaotic age is no place to live. At that time Fu was held by Gao Wanxing, who bore the titular ranks of Grand Preceptor and Director of the Secretariat and was enfeoffed as Prince of Beiping — the "Prince and Great King" of whom Ge spoke. His offices had been granted under the Liang; though the Tang mandate was renewed, the court could not inflict the disgrace of stripping his girdle ornaments, while he usurped tribute and clutched a commander's baton — Tang's loss of vigor had been long in the making.)〉
5
使
Wei Shuo was the son of Wei Zhou, military commissioner of Fujian. (Editor's note: the text below is defective.)〉 When Zhuangzong secured Bian and Luoyang, Shuo and Zhao Guangyun were appointed Grand Councilors by edict on the same day. Shuo was by nature cautious and grave; in office he usually stirred up no incidents. Guo Chongtao then held real power; Shuo and his colleagues only followed along and had nothing to say about what the government did right or wrong. Someone had told Chongtao that appointments had grown wildly lax — candidates using others' credentials, borrowing fathers' or brothers' qualifications, while clerks took bribes to pass false claims. Chongtao then submitted a detailed memorial on the abuses. Later, at the suburban sacrifice to Heaven, among thousands of ritual officers many held forged or improper commissions. When retention and dismissal were decided, countless appointment documents were defaced, and rejected candidates wailed outside the capital gates. Critics also argued that abuses had accumulated for years, yet to purge them so thoroughly at a stroke risked abandoning the spirit of renewal that forgives past faults. Shuo then shared chief-ministerial rank with Guo Chongtao yet could not stand firm and stop the purge, and he drew considerable criticism. When Shuo's kinsmen and associates told him of the criticism, he said, "This is that Guo fellow's doing." After Chongtao was condemned, Shuo feared gossip would turn on him and had his protégés — Left Reminder Wang Song and outside member of the Ministry of Personnel Li Shenyi — submit memorials saying, "Chongtao once monopolized power, ignored precedent, blocked the path of office, and did not reward merit as he should." The memorials went to the Secretariat; Shuo and his colleagues replied with further denunciations of Chongtao, which thoughtful observers condemned. There was also a Wang Can who won favor by devious means and paid bribes to Shuo. Because his name violated Shuo's ancestral taboo, Shuo changed it to "Cao" and proposed an appointment for him in the districts near the capital. When Emperor Mingzong took the throne, Shuo often feared for his life and repeatedly sought shelter from Ren Huan, who regularly protected him. Shuo's residence had a well once shared with a neighbor; finding the mingling vulgar, he built a wall to shut it off. The neighbor brought suit. In a memorial Xiao Xifu argued that Shuo treated the well as a source of profit; when the case was examined Shuo himself could only point to a single broken cauldron — which made him look all the more false. He was first demoted to prefect of Xu, then stripped further and appointed Army Adjutant of Yizhou.
6
西 西 西
Earlier, while Shuo was at Jiangling, he knew Gao Jixing well; after he entered the chief minister's office he still exchanged letters and gifts with him. During the campaign against Western Shu, Jixing asked to attack the gorges within the passes. Zhuangzong agreed: "If you can take the three prefectures, they shall be made your dependent commanderies." When Western Shu was pacified, Jixing had achieved nothing at all. When Mingzong succeeded, Jixing repeatedly demanded the three commanderies, and the court, unable to refuse, granted them. Ge and Shuo were then in the Secretariat and took part in the decision as well. When Jixing seized and held the territories, blame fell on them alone and they were exiled to Hezhou. The following summer an edict declared: "The long-exiled commoners Dou Luge of Lingzhou and Wei Shuo of Hezhou were recently elevated to heavy responsibility under the former court, yet they cheated the public, preyed on the realm, took bribes, and sold offices. On reflection, the seeds of disorder lie in deeds still harder to forgive: the three prefectures of Kui, Zhong, and Wan border Ba-Shu and choke the routes into Jing and the south. Exploiting the capital's first efforts to restore peace, they bowed to a rebellious commander's grasping demands, ignored Our authority, and ceded territory at will. They would have opened a thousand li of territory to treacherous strongholds; and mobilized the armies and revenues of the Two Shu for years of defense. This kept Us from laying down Our arms and still forced Us to labor over strategy. Though the western stronghold of Ye was recently recovered, Gao Jixing still clings to his lair, deepening Our anxiety that steals sleep from Our meals — a plot of your villainous faction. And though you sit in places of exile, slander still flows from you. If punishment is delayed, what place is left for the loyal and worthy? Let the prefect of each place where they are held supervise and grant them death by their own hand." (Ouyang Xiu's History of the Five Dynasties: Shuo's son Tao, early in the Jin Tianfu era, served as outside member of the Provisioners Section in the Ministry of Rites and died in office.)〉
7
使
Lu Cheng came from a great Tang clan. His grandfather Yi and his father Yun both held distinguished offices through their careers. Cheng passed the jinshi examination late in the Tianfu era. When Duke Wei of Cui headed the Salt and Iron Commission, he appointed Cheng an inspector. When Emperor Zhaozong moved to Luoyang and Liu Can brought down great families, Cheng took refuge in Heshuo and wandered as a guest in Yan and Zhao, sometimes wearing Daoist robes as he sought audiences with regional lords — and was still unknown. Dou Luge wandered as a guest in Zhongshan under Wang Chuzhi; Lu Rubi came to Taiyuan. Cheng, Ge, and Rubi were all old acquaintances from court families. Cheng therefore attached himself to Ge for a time, but since Chuzhi did not treat him generously he went on to Taiyuan; Rubi recommended him, and Zhuangzong appointed him investigating officer, soon promoting him to staff adjutant. Cheng was narrow-minded and shallow, with no other real talent; he prided himself only on birth and was quick to gossip. Men of solid character especially despised him.
8
歿 使 使
Earlier the adjutant Wang Jian had followed the army as chief secretary; at the battle of Huliu he died in camp. When Zhuangzong returned to Taiyuan for a family visit he held a public feast. Raising his cup to Zhang Chengye he said, "At this gathering I shall choose a secretary — let this cup announce my choice." He then offered the cup to the inspector Feng Dao. Dao, finding the appointment out of proper sequence, refused the cup and declined. Zhuangzong said, "Do not be modest — no one is better suited than you." By seniority in office Cheng should have been secretary, and Rubi had been promoting him as well. Having lost the post, Cheng privately nursed resentment and told others, "Our lord does not value talent — he lets a village lad rank above me." Earlier Zhuangzong had summoned Cheng to his tent to draft a memorial. Cheng said, "I am unworthily famous, but I am no hand with brush and ink." From that point on he was never considered for literary posts. Zhang Chengye then controlled the Hedong regent's affairs single-handedly, and everyone feared him. By custom the staff adjutant supervised granary receipts and disbursements. Cheng appealed to Chengye: "This is not my strength — please choose someone capable." Chengye snapped at him: "You call yourself a scholar — you should wield the brush to aid our hegemonic enterprise. Ordered to draft a text you pleaded incompetence; left with duties you plead again — what are you good for?" Cheng wept as he apologized. He later served in turn as adjutant to several military commissioners.
9
紿 婿 退 沿
When the Bian general Wang Yanzhang captured the southern city of Desheng and pressed the attack on Yangliu, Zhuangzong led the army in bitter fighting. His ministers were alarmed and all urged the chief ministers to submit joint memorials asking him not to command the ranks in person. Dou Luge cited how Emperor Gaozu of Han, at Guangwu, took an arrow in the chest yet deceived the enemy into thinking he had been wounded in the foot. Cheng said, "That was Liu Bang's mistake." Everyone shrank back in alarm. Once, discussing recent great families, someone said, "The outside member Kong Minggui of Shanhe — descended from a chief minister's line and collateral kin of Confucius — surely that is splendid!" Cheng said, "He only amounts to being a descendant of Confucius — as for being splendid, I could not say." A relative had asked Cheng to lend him a donkey driver; Cheng sent a note to the prefecture ordering one supplied. When a clerk protested that there was no precedent for it, Cheng flew into a rage and had the man flogged. At that time Ren Huan served as Vice Mayor of Xingtang. As the husband of one of Emperor Zhuangzong's older cousins by the paternal line, he counted on his privileged connection and went to call on Cheng. Cheng was dressed in a crane-feather cloak and Huayang cap, lounging at his writing table while conducting business. At the sight of Ren Huan he burst out in fury: "What vermin is this, trading on his wife's influence! A chief minister requisitioning goods from prefectural and county offices — does he not even know the old proprieties!" Ren Huan said nothing and withdrew. That same night he rode hard to Boping, where he kowtowed and laid his grievance before Emperor Zhuangzong. Zhuangzong was furious. He said to Guo Chongtao, "I was wrong to make this idiot my chief minister. How dare he humiliate one of my Nine Ministers!" He ordered Cheng to take his own life at once. Chongtao was angry as well, and the affair nearly spun out of control. Only Lu Zhi's intervention — he literally stepped between them — settled matters. Cheng was demoted to Right Vice Guardian of the Heir Apparent. After Zhuangzong secured Henan, Cheng accompanied the court on the journey to Luoyang. He fell from his horse along the way and died of a stroke. He was posthumously enfeoffed as Minister of Rites.
10
殿
Zhao Feng was a native of Youzhou. In his youth he trained as a Confucian scholar. During the Tang Tianyou reign, the Yan commander Liu Shouguang drafted every able-bodied man in his domain into the army and branded their faces. Confucian scholars were appalled. Many took tonsure to escape conscription; Feng shaved his head and fled to Taiyuan as well. Before long he followed Liu Shouqi in defecting to Liang. The Liang court appointed Shouqi prefect of Bozhou and recommended Feng as his adjutant. (Editor's note: text is missing below.)〉 He served as adjutant to the military commissioner of Yanzhou. When Emperor Zhuangzong of Tang heard of Feng's reputation and secured his services, he was delighted and made him Guardian of the Imperial Procession Academician. After Zhuangzong took the throne, Feng was appointed Palace Drafting Officer. When the court entered Bian, he was reassigned as Vice Director of the Ministry of Rites. Emperor Zhuangzong and Empress Liu visited Zhang Quanyi's home. The empress said, "I lost my parents when I was five or six. Whenever I see an elderly person, I think of them and weep. Given Zhang Quanyi's age and standing, I wish to honor him as a father — to ease the loneliness of a girl without kin." Zhuangzong agreed and ordered Feng to draft the formal letter to Zhang Quanyi and set the ceremonial protocol for their relationship. Feng submitted a forceful memorial of protest. The emperor would not hear it. Early in the Tiancheng reign the post of Hall of Radiant Clarity Academician was created; Zhao Feng and Feng Dao both held it. At that time Ren Huan served as chief minister, but An Chonghui undermined him until he was removed from office and sent back to Cizhou. When Zhu Shouyin rebelled at Bianzhou, an urgent courier was dispatched ordering Ren Huan to take his own life. Afterward Feng wept and said to An Chonghui, "Ren Huan is a man of honor. Would he truly plot rebellion against his sovereign and father-figure? With punishments this reckless, how can the realm be kept at peace!" Chonghui only smiled and did not reprove him. That winter he served as acting chief examiner.
11
西 使 使
The following spring a monk returning from the Western Regions with scriptures brought back a Buddha's tooth the size of a fist — brown, stained, and fissured — and presented it to Emperor Mingzong. Feng said openly, "I have heard that a Buddha's tooth cannot be broken by hammer or forge. Let us put it to the test." It splintered the moment the axe fell. By then the palace had already spent several thousand strings of cash on offerings for the relic. When they learned it had been destroyed, the expenditures ceased. When the emperor returned to Luoyang, Feng was left to administer Bianzhou. Soon afterward he was appointed Vice Director of the Secretariat and Chief Minister. (According to Li Zhi's Collected Works of Master Guniangxi: while Feng was compiling the Veritable Records of Zhuangzong, He Ting's memorial on Liu Xu was omitted; once both men had become chief ministers, Feng was brought in to share in governance.)〉 During the Changxing reign An Chonghui was sent out to command Hezhong, and no one dared speak for him — except Feng, who argued forcefully before the throne: "Chonghui is Your Majesty's own household servant. At heart he would never betray you. For five years he wielded power and even the great submitted to him, but because he failed to guard against slander, he brought ruin on himself." Mingzong took this for factional advocacy and was displeased with the memorial. When An Chonghui was condemned, he was sent out as military commissioner of Xingzhou. When Emperor Min fell into exile at Weizhou, Feng gathered his staff and officers and said through tears, "Our sovereign has been driven from the capital and fled north across the river. Can we sit here in comfort and fail to go to him? Where is the propriety in that?" The officers replied, "We are yours to command." They were about to depart when word came that Emperor Min had been assassinated, and they abandoned the plan. Early in the Qingtai reign he was recalled to court and appointed Grand Preceptor. Before long his feet failed him and he could no longer attend court. When his illness turned grave he divined for himself with yarrow stalks. When the hexagram was cast he threw down the stalks and sighed, "No one in my family has ever lived past fifty, and all have died poor and obscure; I am already fifty, and I have risen to general and minister — how can I expect a long life!" He died in the third month of the second year of Qingtai.
12
Feng was open-handed by nature and valued honor over money. Whenever a scholar friend came to him in hardship, he gave freely of whatever he had. Men admired him greatly for it.
13
西 簿 西 便
Li Yu, courtesy name Zihui. He claimed descent from the western branch of the Pingji line in Zhao commandery. His family had been Confucian scholars for generations. His father Zhan Ye failed the Presented Scholar examination. When turmoil came he moved the family to Wudi in Bohai and raised his descendants on poetry and the classics. Even as a child Yu was unusually solemn and self-possessed. When he reached the age of serious study he read widely in the classics and histories. He admired Yan Ying and originally bore the name Yan Ping. His prose prized vigor and structure and showed the influence of Han Yu and Liu Zongyuan. He disciplined his will and carried himself with dignity. His bearing was austere and composed. He would not speak outside propriety, nor act with casual indifference. At first, pressed by poverty, Yu sought a provisional appointment. Lu Yanwei of Cangzhou made him secretary of Anling. After completing mourning for his father, he traveled to Chang'an for the examinations. But Guanzhong was in chaos, and the examinations were suspended year after year. He lived as a guest between Pu and Hua. During the Guanghua reign, Army Supervisors Liu Jishu and Wang Fengxian deposed Emperor Zhaozong and enthroned Prince Yu. For more than five months not a single regional lord came to the emperor's aid. Yu was then at Huayin and wrote to Han Jian, military commissioner of Hua. The letter read in part, "I am only a commoner from east of the Pass, fortunate enough to have learned to read and write. Whenever I see the bonds between ruler and minister, father and son, violated in ways that corrupt teaching and destroy righteousness, I am sick with rage. I would tear out my own entrails and trample them in blood before the court if that could set things right. You hold a strategic post at the gateway to the capital. Our sovereign has languished in captivity for more than a month, yet you sit by and watch these criminals without raising the banner of loyal rescue. I cannot understand it. It seems to me that the ministers at court may have the will but not the power; while the regional lords may have the power but not the will. Only you, my lord, combine loyalty and righteousness — the realm depends on men like you. When the imperial carriage was driven into exile in years past, you wept as you welcomed it home, supplied the court for years, and restored the ancestral temples. Your loyalty moved the hearts of men and is still praised in song. The present crisis is graver still. You stand at a strategic crossroads with the rank of both general and minister. More than ten days have passed since the palace coup. If you do not take the lead — issue the call, march first, and restore the rightful order — and if you hesitate, then one day the lords east of the mountains will raise the banner of righteousness in alliance and march west with drums beating. How then will you keep yourself safe? What choice will remain to you? That is the inevitable course of events. Better to send proclamations in every direction, teaching men the difference between treason and loyalty. Once your army's name resounds, the chief villain will lose heart. Within ten days the heads of those two usurpers could be displayed throughout the realm. No plan would serve better." Han Jian received the letter with great respect, but Yu firmly declined further involvement and returned to his retreat in the hills. Early in the Tianfu reign the emperor was at Fengxiang while the Bian army attacked Pu and Hua. Yu fled east to Luoyang. Li Deyu's grandson Yangu was living at the old Pingquan estate. Yu went to stay with him. He and the younger members of the household gathered acorns and carried firewood to get by from day to day. He never importuned anyone for help. In the year when Xue Tinggui, the former Junior Mentor, oversaw the examination registry, Yu passed the Presented Scholar examination; he also passed the Hongci examination, was appointed aide to the Henan prefecture, and settled at a villa in Baisha below Luoyang.
14
使 使使
When Liang plotted to seize the throne, Liu Can slaughtered court officials to curry favor. Seeing the scholar-official class turn on itself, Yu fled to Hebei and lived as a guest in Shandong with his clansman Li Yanguang. When the Last Emperor of Liang succeeded, he greatly favored Confucian scholars. Yanguang, who had long been close to him, gained appointment to lecture within the palace and repeatedly praised Yu's moral stature and erudition, comparing him to Shi Yu and Qu Yuan. Yu was summoned to audience. The emperor admired him at length and promoted him to Left Remonstrance Censor. Soon he was made Direct Academician of the Chongzheng Hall. Even when consulted on policy he maintained a grave bearing and did not flinch before the powerful. When the Prince of Heng came to court, senior ministers including Li Zhen all prostrated themselves. Yu alone gave a formal bow with hands folded. The Last Emperor rebuked him: "The Prince of Heng is my elder brother. Even I bow to him. Li Zhen and the other commissioners all bow. Why are you so insolent!" Yu replied, "Your Majesty treats your brother with family courtesy. Li Zhen and the others are your personal servants. I stand in the court ranks and have no prior acquaintance with the prince. How dare I abase myself in flattery?" Such was his uncompromising integrity. Hua Wenqi, military commissioner of Jinzhou, broke the law in office by confiscating a commoner's property. The family appealed to court, an imperial commissioner investigated, and Hua confessed his guilt. The Last Emperor, unwilling to punish a veteran of the founding days, hesitated to apply the law. Yu insisted that the crime be prosecuted. The Last Emperor issued an edict: "If I do not investigate this thoroughly, men will say I have no care for the common people; yet if I carry out the full penalty, men will say I have no gratitude for my meritorious servants. To be your sovereign — is that not a hard thing! The property Hua Wenqi seized shall be restored to the aggrieved family from official funds." During the Zhenming reign, a laborer hired by Palace Herald Li Xiao beat a lodger to death. The legal office applied the statutes and held Li Xiao responsible. Yu argued, "Li Xiao did not strike the blow himself. A hired man killed someone — how can his employer be held guilty!" For this he offended the emperor. Yu had risen from Remonstrance Censor to Vice Director of the Board of Provisioners with scarlet robes, then to Vice Director of the Board of Merits with purple robes. Now he was removed from office and served successively as adjutant to the observation commissioners of Xu and Deng.
15
西使 殿
While Yu still held an inner-court post, the Cizhou examination candidate Zhang Li came to study under him. During the Zhenming reign Zhang Li returned north from Heyang to Zhuangzong's court and was appointed a staff officer in Taiyuan. Moving in court circles, he praised Yu's moral character and spoke of Yu's essays — "Confucius Encounters," "Yan Hui's Longevity," "Boyi and Shuqi Were Not Men Who Starved" — and others. Northerners heard of them and admired Yu from afar. When Zhuangzong made Luoyang his capital, the military commissioner of Deng had Yu submit a memorial at court. The great officials received him with the same respect as before. Soon he was appointed Director of the Bureau of Receptions. After a few months he was summoned to serve as Hanlin Academician. In the third year of Tongguang, the Prince of Wei, Jiji, marched against Shu. Yu asked to serve as army superintendent and adjutant, retaining his existing post while accompanying the expedition. Public opinion held that Shu was too rugged and perilous for a headlong advance. Guo Chongtao asked Yu's counsel. Yu said, "From what I hear, the people of Shu are sick of their ruler's reckless indulgence. In a crisis they will not stand by him. We should strike while they are divided, moving like wind and lightning. They will lose heart and cannot hold the mountain passes. When the vanguard reached Guyin and collected 150,000 hu of army grain, Chongtao was delighted. He told Yu, "You read events aright — our army is saved!" The pacification adjutant Chen Yi reached Baoji, pleaded illness, and asked to stay behind with the rear guard. Yu said sharply, "Chen Yi advances when he sees gain and halts when he fears danger. The main army is crossing dangerous ground and morale is easily shaken. He should be executed as an example to the troops. After that no soldier dared hang back. At that time every military dispatch and urgent report came from his hand. When Shu was pacified, he was immediately appointed Secretariat Drafter. The army returned home, and Mingzong took the throne. Ren Huan, deputy pacification commissioner of the western campaign and now chief minister, admired Yu and repeatedly urged An Chonghui to bring him into the council of chief ministers; but Kong Xun was then in power and brought in Cui Xie to shut the door on the request. Soon he was given provisional charge of the civil examinations in his existing post, promoted to Vice Minister of War, and made Hanlin Academician Expositor. Early in the Changxing reign he was made Minister of Rituals. When Zhao Feng departed to command Xingtai, Yu was appointed Vice Director of the Secretariat and Co-administrator of Affairs, then transferred to Grand Academician of the Hall for Collecting Worthies.
16
使 使 使
In the closing years of Changxing the Prince of Qin ran wild. Powerful ministers were too busy saving themselves to speak of the state's survival or ruin. Yu was stern and uncompromising by nature and often spoke out plainly, yet no one took up his cause. Later he was made Vice Director of the Chancellery, put in charge of compiling the national history, and concurrently served as Minister of Personnel. With other scholars he completed the Record of Founding Meritorious Servants in thirty juan. Yu had never built a private mansion. Once he was made chief minister, the government lent him the Yansin Guesthouse as his residence. Once when he fell ill, the emperor sent a nearby minister to convey his sympathy. Yu received him in the central hall with only coarse straw matting for a seat. When the messenger reported this, Mingzong specially sent curtains, bedding, and cushions. (Records of Offices and Functions states: In the fourth year of Changxing Yu fell ill, and Mingzong sent a palace envoy to inquire after him. Yu's bedchamber was bare on all four walls — nothing but a sickbed with a threadbare rug. The envoy reported the whole affair. The emperor said, "How much is a chief minister's monthly salary? Yet he is worn down to this state. An edict bestowed one hundred bolts of silk, one hundred thousand cash, curtains, bedding, and thirteen sets of household goods.)〉
17
便 使 便 便
When Emperor Min succeeded to the throne, he set his heart on virtuous government. Hardly had the mourning period ended when he summoned academicians to read the Essentials of Governance from the Zhenguan Era and the Veritable Record of Emperor Taizong — he meant to bring the realm to good order. Yu privately told his colleagues, "Our lord seeks counsel yet seldom reaches us. Our rank is high and our burden heavy — the situation is troubling. What will become of the altars of state! All held their breath and dared not answer. By imperial grace he was promoted to Left Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs. Early in the Qingtai reign, when rites at Huai Mausoleum were complete, Feng Dao departed to command Tongzhou. Yu was granted the special advancement title, made commissioner of the Taibei Palace, and Grand Academician of the Hongwen Hall. Chief minister Liu Xu was connected by marriage with Feng Dao. After Dao left for his command, the two men remained in the Secretariat. On certain old arrangements that were awkward to overhaul, they debated back and forth without reaching agreement. Yu was blunt by nature and said, "Your worthy father-in-law set this up — would it not be simpler to change it! Xu resented the sharpness of his words. From then on every exchange ended in mutual refutation, sometimes rising to shouting. Before long both were removed as chief ministers and retained only their original posts. In the autumn of the second year of Qingtai Yu was already gravely ill. He mostly stayed away on sick leave and repeatedly memorialized begging to retire, but was not permitted. He died in office.
18
西
Ren Huan was a native of Sanyuan in Jingzhao. His grandfather Qing served as vice governor of Chengdu. His father Maohong fled the turmoil to Taiyuan, where he was appointed by memorial as magistrate of Xihe. He had five sons — Tu, Hui, Huan, Tuan, and Jiong — each with a striking bearing. Emperor Wu favored the family and married an imperial clanswoman to Tuan, who served successively as prefect of Dai and Xian.
19
使 姿 使 使 使
Li Siyao commanded troops at Jinyang and was on very close terms with Huan. When Siyao took command of Ze and Lu, he requested Huan as observation staff officer. Huan entered official service and was granted vermilion insignia. Huan was handsome and skilled in debate. Siyao sent intermediaries between himself and Zhuangzong. When a slight rift opened between them, Huan shuttled back and forth as envoy and constantly argued for reconciliation, restoring their bond of friendship — this was Huan's achievement. When he entered mourning for his mother, Zhuangzong recalled him to service by imperial rescript as adjutant to the Lu observation commissioner and granted him purple robes. In the Changshan campaign Siyao served as commander and died in the field. Huan took over command of all affairs. Orders continued as before, and the enemy never knew. When Zhuangzong heard of it, he doubled his rewards. That autumn he again led the Shangdang army against Changshan. Ten thousand men burst from the city; the great general Sun Wenjin fell in the fighting. As the rebels pressed our army, Huan directed cavalry against them and killed or captured a good number. He once preached fortune and calamity to those in the city. The garrison believed him and sent envoys to sue for surrender. When the city fell, apart from executing the ringleaders, all officials and their families were spared — also through Huan's protection. Zhuangzong redesignated Zhenzhou as the Northern Capital and made Huan Minister of Works, concurrently true prefect of Zhending and deputy northern regent, administering regent affairs. The next year, when Guo Chongtao took concurrent command of the region, Huan was made army superintendent and northern water-and-land transport commissioner, while still governing prefectural affairs. In the third year of Tongguang he returned to court and retained the post of Minister of Works.
20
西使 西 使 使使 使 退
When Chongtao campaigned against Shu he memorialized that Huan should accompany the expedition. After western Shu was pacified he appointed Huan military commissioner of Qiannan, but Huan earnestly declined and the appointment was dropped. As the Prince of Wei's army withdrew, having reached Lizhou, Kang Yanxiao rebelled and turned back with eight thousand crack troops to raid western Chuan. When Jiji heard of it, he sent the palace envoy Li Ting'an to summon Huan at midnight. Huan was asleep; Ting'an climbed onto his bed to tell him. Huan dressed without waiting for his belt and rushed to see Jiji. Jiji wept and said, "Shaochen has betrayed us. Only you, Vice Director, can bring him to heel. He immediately appointed Huan deputy pacification commissioner. With commander-in-chief Liang Hanyong and others he led troops against Yanxiao at Hanzhou and captured him. Soon afterward they reached Weinan, where Jiji was murdered. Huan took command of the entire army and presented himself at court in Luoyang. Mingzong commended his achievement and appointed him Co-administrator of Affairs with charge of the Three Departments. Huan selected the worthy and talented and shut the door on favor-seekers. Officials' salaries had been cut and discounted under Kong Qian. Huan held that court ministers were the ceremonial face of the state, so he treated the official ranks generously and forbade inflated valuation. Within a month the treasury was full, the court was refurbished, and both army and people were provided for. Though he cared for the state as for his own household, he was eager for fame and achievement, and therefore earned An Chonghui's resentment. Once he met Chonghui at a private residence where a courtesan skilled in song was present. Chonghui asked for her but could not have her. From that their rift grew deep. Previously envoy ration certificates had all issued from the Ministry of Revenue. Chonghui stopped this and required them to come from the inner palace instead. They disputed before the emperor back and forth several times, and in the end Huan was thwarted, (Zizhi Tongjian: An Chonghui and Huan disputed before the emperor back and forth several times, both voice and expression fiercely stern. After the emperor left court, a palace woman asked him, "With whom were you just now arguing with Chonghui? The emperor said, "The chief minister." The palace woman said, "When I was in the Chang'an palace, I never saw a chief minister or privy council commissioner dare to present business like that. They must look down on Your Majesty!" The emperor grew even more displeased.)〉 Huan thereupon asked to be relieved of the Three Departments.
21
退
In the second year of Tiancheng he was made Junior Mentor of the Heir Apparent and retired to live at Cizhou. When Zhu Shouyin rebelled, Chonghui seized the chance to falsely accuse Huan of collusion. He immediately sent a man bearing an imperial rescript to put him to death and issued an edict: "Retired Junior Mentor of the Heir Apparent Ren Huan, long honored as an old meritorious servant and once entrusted with grave duties, was granted ease in a distant post after retiring from pressing power. Yet he failed to observe ritual propriety and secretly joined Zhu Shouyin. His sealed letters did not avoid suspicion, and their tone plainly showed resentment. Since the capture of the Bian ramparts his movements have been fully traced. To show magnanimous tolerance would betray the canonical law. Yet wishing to preserve the larger principle, We punish only his person. Let him be granted death by his own hand at his private residence in his prefecture. On the day Huan received the order, he gathered his clan for a hearty drink. His composure did not falter. In the Qingtai era an imperial rescript posthumously made him Grand Mentor.
22
His son Che served the imperial court, rising to Director of the Bureau of Revenue, and died in office.
23
退
The court historian writes: Dou Luge and Wei Shuo inherited the standing of old clans and served a newly founded state. Their work fell short of completion and no conspicuous guilt was laid against them, yet powerful ministers resented them and they perished by later command with no escape. Considered quietly, their fate is pitiable. Lu Cheng's talents were so narrow — his rank and salary suited him well enough. Zhao Feng and Li Yu both rose on the reputation of literary learning to seats in the highest council. Comparing their integrity, Yu again had the advantage. Ren Huan had the talent to move across the realm and aid the world, yet lacked the wisdom to preserve himself. Even in retirement he could not escape — ah, how lamentable!
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →