← Back to 舊五代史

卷九十八 晉書24: 列傳13 安重榮 安從進 張彥澤 趙德鈞 張礪 蕭翰 劉晞 崔廷勳

Volume 98 Book of Later Jin 24: Biographies 13 - An Zhongrong, An Congjin, Zhang Yanze, Zhao Dejun, Zhang Li, Xiao Han, Liu xi, Cui Tingxun

Chapter 98 of 舊五代史 · Old History of the Five Dynasties
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 98
Next Chapter →
1
使 使 使使 使使
An Chongrong was a native of Shuozhou. His grandfather Congyi had served as prefect of Lizhou. His father Quan had been prefect of Shengzhou and commander of all Han and tribal horse and foot forces at Zhenwu. Chongrong was powerfully built and excelled at riding and archery. During the Tang Changxing period he served as frontier patrol commander on the Zhenwu circuit, but after committing an offense he was thrown into prison. Gao Xingzhou was then in command and meant to execute him, but Chongrong's mother appealed at court, and the Commissioner of Military Affairs An Chonghui shielded him in secret. When Zhang Jingda besieged Jinyang, Gaozu learned that Chongrong was in northern Dai and sent envoys to recruit him; Chongrong rallied border soldiers and came with a thousand horsemen. Gaozu was overjoyed and swore to reward him with land. After his enthronement he made Chongrong military governor of Chengde and eventually elevated him to commissioner and chief minister. Since the Liang and Tang dynasties, most frontier lords and prefects had won their posts through merit rather than learning how to govern; they were typically led astray by petty hangers-on, sold offices and verdicts, and squeezed the people. Nearly all bore a name for greed, though in truth half the bribes went to their underlings. Chongrong alone kept his own accounts sharp: he usually heard disputes in open court, and warehouse profits, popular levies, and corvée labor all flowed into his coffers while no subordinate office dared even look askance. Once a couple brought suit together against their son for unfilial conduct. Chongrong rebuked the youth in person, drew his sword, and told him to take his own life. The father wept and said, "I cannot bring myself to do it." His mother cursed him and, brandishing the sword, chased him to do it. Chongrong questioned them in suspicion and learned she was the stepmother. He drove her out, then shot her from behind with a single arrow and killed her on the spot. Everyone who heard of it felt vindicated. Thereafter the people within his jurisdiction took him for stern and discerning, and he won broad popular approval. Chongrong had come up through the army and suddenly acquired wealth and rank. He had also watched dynasty after dynasty vault from regional command straight to the throne, and he would say to people, "Whoever has the strongest troops and horses ought to be Son of Heaven—does the office run in families?" His petitions had also grown excessive and were rejected by the power-holders at court, so resentment festered in him. He began stockpiling outlaws, buying war-horses, and nursing an arrogant, rebellious ambition. (Zizhi Tongjian: When the emperor dispatched Chongrong to replace Mi Qiong, he cautioned him: "If Qiong refuses to step down, we will appoint you to another circuit instead. Do not seize it by force, or the trouble will only deepen." From this Chongrong concluded the emperor was timid and said to others, "Mi Qiong is only a commoner, yet the Son of Heaven still fears him—what of me, with the rank of general and minister and armies and people at my back?")〉 Once, in a violent rage, he executed his subordinate officer Jia Zhang on a charge of plotting rebellion. Zhang had a daughter. When he meant to spare her, she said, "Our family numbers thirty souls; war after war has left twenty-eight dead. Now my father is to die—why should I go on living?" She begged again and again to die, and he killed her too. The garrison populace thereafter detested Chongrong's cruelty while honoring Jia's daughter for her fierce loyalty.
2
使
During the Tianfu reign the court indulged the Khitan and sought only to keep the frontier quiet. Whenever Chongrong met Khitan envoys he would sit with legs sprawled and revile them. Once several dozen Meiling horsemen passed through his territory and spoke insolently; he had them all killed. The Khitan ruler was enraged and laid blame on the court. The court swallowed the insult and did not punish him at once. Chongrong then secretly enlisted the Tuguhun and other tribes as allies and memorialized the throne on the matter. The gist of the memorial ran as follows:
3
使 沿 使使 使
Your servant has lately received Bai Chengfu, Helian Gede, and other settled Tuguhun military governors, each leading more than thirty thousand tents of their tribes, who fled from the Yingzhou frontier to submit to the throne. After them came the raw Tuguhun together with the Hunqie and two Turkic tribes, and the northern and southern commanders of the Shatuo, Anqing, Jiufu, and others, each bringing their people, young and old, with cattle, sheep, wagons, tents, armor, and horses. Seven or eight columns in all have come to submit; all have reached Wutai and the borders of this prefecture and are now encamped. They have repeatedly reported their hardships, describing in full how the Khitan have brutalized them—seizing people at will, driving off flocks and herds, and oppressing them beyond measure. Since the second month of this year they have also been ordered to muster the able-bodied and equip men, horses, clothing, and armor, with word that they will march south in the autumn campaign. The tribes truly fear Heaven will not favor them and that, once defeated, their families will be wiped out as usual. They have therefore submitted in advance; together with the tribes attached to this prefecture, they have mustered roughly one hundred thousand able-bodied men and horses. The chieftains of the Tangut along the river and of the tribes of the fore-mountains, rear-mountains, Yili, Yueli, and others have each sent envoys bearing the commissions, patents, and banners the Khitan gave them to hand them over. All weep as they report their hardships, saying the Khitan have abused them beyond endurance; they are eager to muster armor and horses and join in the slaughter. Moreover, Zhao Chong, deputy military governor of Shuozhou, and the city's officers have killed the puppet military governor Liu Shan, pacified the garrison city, and beg to return to the court. Your servant has reported these matters in successive memorials. Yesterday I received the imperial rescript and repeated sacred instructions that in all dealings with the Khitan I must continue to defer to them, wait until they show their mettle, not provoke trouble myself, and above all keep faith from start to finish without breaking our sworn pledges. I bow to acknowledge the sage intent and ponder deeply the need to overlook faults, yet Heaven's way and men's hearts alike demand that cruelty be overcome and oppression removed. Opportunity cannot be missed, and time will not return. I venture to think that the tribes came without being summoned and Shuozhou returned without being attacked—surely this reflects the people's will and Heaven's intent alike. I further recall the military governors trapped under Khitan rule—men who earned their rank by merit, rose early to wealth, and spent their lives on the frontier, only to suffer cruelty beyond measure. They strain toward the court and long to pour out their loyalty without end; if they hear a proclamation, all will turn their blades. Though your servant is dull, I roughly know what can and cannot be done. Without regard for taboo I lay bare my loyal heart in full detail, hoping to be of some small use.
4
忿 使使
The memorial ran to several thousand characters and largely denounced Gaozu for submitting as a vassal, draining China's rare treasures as tribute to the Khitan, and abusing the Han people without end. He also set out this argument in letters sent to court nobles and regional lords alike. Gaozu feared rebellion and went in person to Yedu to admonish him by edict in ten points. The gist ran: "You are a great minister with an aged mother at home, yet in anger you refuse to weigh the cost and abandon both your sovereign and your kin. I built my foundation through the Khitan; you grew rich and noble through me. I dare not forget that—can you? Former dynasties made marriage alliances only to secure the frontier. Now I have made the whole realm their vassal, while you would resist them with a single circuit—the scales do not match. Do not bring shame on yourself." Chongrong grew ever more defiant and unrepentant. Despite the memorial, he also secretly sent men to ally with Liu Xi, the Khitan commander at Youzhou. Chongrong had his own domestic concerns; the Khitan welcomed our troubles and again meant to swallow China. Their anger at Chongrong was not their original aim either. Once Chongrong rode alongside envoys from the north, pointed at birds in flight, and brought them down at the twang of his bow. Tens of thousands of spectators cheered. The envoys gave up their mounts to congratulate him. His fame thereafter shook the north, and he told himself the realm could be settled with a single arrow. Chongrong had long been allied with An Congjin of Xiangzhou. When he heard Congjin was about to raise troops, his treacherous plot was finally set.
5
退 使 · 西 使
In the winter of the sixth Tianfu year he gathered the hungry within his borders until they numbered tens of thousands, raised banners toward the capital, and claimed he was coming to court. The court sent Du Chongwei at the head of an army to meet him, and they clashed at Zongcheng. The armies had barely formed when the rebel general Zhao Yanzhi furled his banner on the field and defected. Chongrong was fighting when he learned Yanzhi had turned on him. Terrified, he fell back among the baggage train. The imperial army struck at once and routed him in a single assault. Chongrong fled north with a dozen riders. Of his followers, in the depths of bitter winter, more than twenty thousand were slain or froze to death. Chongrong returned to his prefecture, stripped hides from cattle and horses to improvise armor, and had the people man the inner and outer walls in shifts to await the imperial army. (Song History, biography of Jie Hui: When An Chongrong rebelled at Zhenzhou and marched on the capital, the Jin army met him at Zongcheng and broke him utterly.) Hui recruited more than a hundred stalwarts from the army and raided the rebel camp by night, killing and capturing a great many. Though struck by arrows again and again, Hui directed the fight as calmly as ever, his face unshaken, and was promoted to company commander for his merit.)〉 When Du Chongwei arrived, a subordinate led the imperial army in through the West Guo water gate, killing more than ten thousand townspeople who defended the walls. Chongwei soon killed the guide and claimed the credit himself. Chongrong had several hundred Tuguhun with him hidden in the headquarters city. Chongwei sent men to seize him, beheaded him, and presented the head. Gaozu mounted the tower to review the captive and the severed heads. After the victory bulletin was proclaimed, he had the skull lacquered and sent it in a box to the Khitan. (Supplement to the History of the Five Dynasties: After An Chongrong took up his command, he had long nursed rebellious designs but had not yet acted.) Before long his stables produced a white horse with a red mane, and a black crow hatched five-colored chicks. Taking this for a phoenix omen, he joyfully declared Heaven's mandate was his and raised troops in rebellion. He ordered his army to take the Zongling road toward the capital. When the elders heard, they whispered among themselves: "This will not succeed. The king's surname is An, and they say a saddle is steady when it has a back—why not take the road through Beizhou? If he goes by Zongling, the saddle reaches the mane—is that not perilous?" Before long he met the imperial vanguard and was broken in a single battle.)〉
6
便 使 使
There was an aide named Zhang Shi who, as a kinsman, had won his favor and trust. Yanze had a son in inner palace service who never pleased him and was repeatedly flogged. Fearing the beatings, the youth fled. Qizhou captured him and sent him to court, where an imperial order pardoned him and returned him to his father. Yanze memorialized the throne asking for the full court punishment. Shi, saying it would violate ritual propriety, repeatedly urged him to desist. Yanze flew into a rage, drew his bow to shoot him, and Shi barely escaped with his life. Soon he sent men to drive Shi out of headquarters. Shi had long served as a client and Yanze entrusted routine affairs to him. The petty hangers-on had hated him for years and now slandered him, pressing him in turn: "If the secretary does not leave at once, he will surely be killed." Shi then pleaded illness to seek treatment, gathered his wife and children, and prepared to flee to Yanzhou. Yanze sent Commander Li Xing with twenty horsemen in pursuit and warned him: "If Zhang Shi does not obey, cut off his head and bring it back." Shi earnestly appealed to the prefect, who sent men to escort him to Fenzhou. Military Governor Li Zhou reported by courier. Because the court indulged Yanze, an edict exiled Shi to Shangzhou. Yanze sent his campaigning marshal Zheng Yuanzhao to court to press the matter. He memorialized in person: "If Yanze does not get Zhang Shi, I fear unforeseen consequences." Gaozu had no choice but to comply. When Shi arrived, he cut open his mouth and heart, severed his limbs, and killed him. Shi's father Duo appealed at court for justice, and the court ordered Wang Zhou to replace Yanze. When Zhou took office, he memorialized twenty-six counts of Yanze's crimes in the prefecture and reported that more than five thousand households had fled. After Yanze came to court, the penal officials Li Tao and others memorialized asking that his crimes be tried. Gaozu issued an edict stripping only one rank and one title—a judgment widely regarded as a failure of justice.
7
使 沿西 ·
When Emperor Shaodi took the throne, Sang Weihan recommended him again, and he was soon sent out to command Anyang. Once there he humbled himself before scholar-officials, and the prefecture was said to be well governed. Soon he was ordered to lead troops north to garrison Heng and Ding. Yizhou was then isolated and grain transport had broken down. The court ordered Xing, Wei, Xiang, and Wei to supply it by forced transport. The people bore loads in endless lines along the roads. Yanze often helped them along, and when he saw the weak and exhausted he had his troops carry the loads for them. When he reached the northern border he kept the people from going deep into hostile territory and sent horsemen to carry grain on horseback instead. Transport was swift and free of robbery, and those who heard of it praised him. At the battle of Yangcheng, Yanze's merit stood above the other generals. Thereafter, in repeated engagements with the enemy, he reported victory after victory to court. All said he was repaying Gaozu's grace in sparing his life and making amends for his past crimes. In the winter of the third Kaiyun year the Khitan drove south, and Du Chongwei's army halted at Yingzhou. Yanze had been won over by the Khitan and had already turned in secret. He opened relations with the Khitan and offered to serve as guide, then sent swift riders to persuade Chongwei to march west along the Hutuo to relieve Changshan. Soon he was in conspiracy with Chongwei. When the imperial army surrendered at Zhongdu, the Khitan ruler sent Yanze at the head of two thousand horsemen to rush the capital, control Emperor Shaodi, and show court and people alike an intent to preserve and comfort them. On the night of the sixteenth day of the twelfth month that year, Yanze broke through the Fengqiu gate and entered, surrounding the palace with troops. The next day he moved the emperor to the Kaifeng prefectural quarters, had all the rare goods of the inner treasury carted to his private residence, and let his troops plunder freely for two days before it stopped. (Eastern Capital Miscellany, biography of Li Chuyun: While in the capital he met Zhang Yanze's rampage. Chuyun was skilled at archery, held the lane gate alone, killed dozens of men, and the neighborhood was saved by him.)〉 Sang Weihan was then prefect of Kaifeng. Yanze summoned him to his camp and treated him without courtesy. Weihan reproached him: "Last year I pulled you out of disgrace, restored you to a great command, and gave you military authority—how can your ingratitude have come to this?" Yanze had no reply. That night he killed Weihan and seized all his household wealth.
8
使使 使 使 西 宿 使
Yanze believed he had rendered great service to the Khitan and spent day and night in wine and revelry. While serving as capital patrol inspector, he went about with several hundred horsemen in attendance. His banners bore the words "Loyal heart for the ruler," and every onlooker snickered behind his sleeve. His residence, too, was heaped with wealth like a mountain. Lady Ding of Chu, mother of Shaodi's brother Yanxu, military governor of Caozhou, was a woman of beauty. Yanze sent men to take her. The empress dowager hesitated to hand her over, so Yanze immediately had her carried off. Such was his treason against the state and deceit toward his sovereign. Within days he killed at will. When soldiers brought a prisoner before him, Yanze never asked the crime but only glared and held up three fingers on one hand. The soldiers understood and went out to cut the man in two at the waist. Yanze was at odds with the false gate commissioner Gao Xun. Drunk, he came to Xun's gate, killed his second uncle and younger brother, and left their corpses exposed outside. When the Khitan camp was pitched in the northern suburbs, Xun went to plead his wrong. The Khitan ruler was already enraged at Yanze's plunder of the capital and ordered him shackled. He also displayed Yanze's crimes before officials and people of the capital, asking, "Do Yanze's crimes merit execution?" Officials submitted linked petitions declaring his crimes unpardonable, and townspeople in the markets vied to submit petitions listing his crimes. Seeing the people's wrath, the Khitan ruler ordered him executed in the marketplace and had Gao Xun supervise. His wrist was cut to remove the shackles, and only then was he executed. Xun had his heart cut out to sacrifice to the dead. People in the market fought over his flesh and ate it. (Supplement to the History of the Five Dynasties: Li Tao often resented that Zhang Yanze had killed the Binzhou staff officer Zhang Shi and taken his wife. Tao led his colleagues in memorializing for Yanze's execution to appease the western command, but Gaozu was indulging military men and would not comply.) Before long the Khitan invaded south as far as Zhongdu Bridge, and Yanze was the first to surrender. The Khitan ruler was pleased and ordered him to lead the tribal archers of his own army into the capital first. Yanze believed his merit unmatched and, nursing an old grudge, killed Sang Weihan, prefect of Kaifeng. When Tao heard this he told his intimates: "I once memorialized asking that Yanze be executed. Now the state has fallen and Yanze acts like this—can my head still be safe? Yet nothing could be done. Who would hide in a ditch and invite disgrace?" He then wrote his own gate petition and asked to see Yanze. The petition read: "Li Tao, who memorialized requesting the Grand Preceptor's execution, hereby submits his life with this petition." Yanze read it and gladly came down the steps to welcome him. Yet Tao was still uneasy and asked again, "Has the Grand Preceptor truly forgiven me?" Yanze said, "Reading your gate petition and seeing the words 'submit life,' my anger vanished at once—what is there to worry about?" Tao was naturally witty. Knowing he would escape, he jested in an actor's lines: "Since the Grand Preceptor has forgiven me, why not bring the silk to calm my fright?" Yanze laughed loudly and in the end treated him well.)〉
9
使 使 使
Zhao Dejun, whose original name was Xingshi, was a native of Youzhou. In youth he served the Cangzhou military governor Liu Shouwen as a horseman and archer. When Shouwen was killed by his younger brother Shouguang, he entered Shouguang's service and was made an army officer at Youzhou. When Tang Emperor Zhuangzong attacked Youzhou, Dejun knew Shouguang would fail and fled to Zhuangzong's side. Zhuangzong treated him well, bestowed the imperial surname, and named him Shaobin. He served in successive prefectures, followed the pacification of Liang, and was made military governor of Cangzhou. In the third Tongguang year he was transferred to command Youzhou. When Emperor Mingzong took the throne he resumed his original surname and first took the name Dejun. His son Yanshou married Mingzong's daughter Princess Xingping, so Dejun enjoyed exceptional favor and trust. During the Tiancheng era Wang Du of Dingzhou rebelled. The Khitan sent a tiyin with five thousand elite horsemen to aid him, but at Tanghe they were defeated by Pacification Commissioner Wang Yanqiu. Rain fell in succession and the roads turned to mire. The defeated army fled north, men and horses starving and spent. Dejun intercepted them at a strategic pass, captured all who remained, and seized dozens of leaders including Teligun, whom he sent to the capital. The next year Wang Du was pacified. Dejun was made Vice Grand Counselor and soon after Northeast Frontier Pacification Commissioner.
10
使 使使西 使殿 退 使
Dejun memorialized to mobilize laborers from several Hebei commands and open a channel from Wangmakou to Youkou, linking water transport for two hundred li. He also built a fort at Yancou and garrisoned it, naming the place Liangxiang County to guard against raiders. He also built Sanhe Fort east of Youzhou, linking north to Jizhou at a point of great strategic value, so that the people of his command could again gather fuelwood and pasture their herds. Dejun governed Youzhou for more than ten years with notable good administration, rose to Honorary Grand Preceptor and concurrent Grand Counselor, and was enfeoffed as Prince of Beiping. (Liao History: In the sixth Tianzan year an envoy was sent with an edict for Zhao Dejun, military governor of the Lulong army.) In the seventh year Zhao Dejun sent tribute of seasonal fruits. Dejun had long been on the frontier and had once maintained friendly relations with the Khitan.)〉 In the summer of the third Qingtai year, Jin Emperor Gaozu rose in revolt at Jinyang. In the ninth month the Khitan defeated Zhang Jingda's army below Taiyuan. The last Tang emperor ordered Dejun to lead his army by the Feihu route and strike the rebels from behind. Dejun's son Yanshou was then Commissioner of Military Affairs. The last Tang emperor ordered him to garrison Shangdang. Dejun led three thousand Silver Saddle Khitan guards to Zhenzhou, took Military Governor Hua Wenqi with him on campaign, advanced by the Wu'eryu route toward Zhaoyi, and joined Yanshou at Xitangdian. In the eleventh month Dejun was made overall commander of all campaign armies and Yanshou Southern Pacification Commissioner against Taiyuan. Hanlin academician Lü Qi was sent with commissions and orders to reward the troops. Qi calmly conveyed the Son of Heaven's trust. Dejun said, "Since troops have been entrusted to me, how dare I spare my life?" Fan Yanguang then commanded twenty thousand troops at Liaozhou. Dejun wished to absorb his force and memorialized to join with him. The last Tang emperor instructed Yanguang, suspecting treachery, and Yanguang refused. Dejun and Yanshou led their army from Luzhou to Tuanbai Valley. Dejun repeatedly memorialized asking that Yanshou be made military governor of Zhenzhou. The last emperor was displeased and told his attendants: "The Zhao Dejun father and son insist on Zhenzhou. If they can drive off the barbarians, I would gladly yield my throne to them; but if they toy with the enemy and coerce their sovereign, I fear both dog and hare will die together." The court sent urgent edicts pressing them to advance, but Dejun hesitated and did not move. He then sent envoys to the Khitan with rich gifts of gold and coin, asking to be made emperor and promising that the Jin founder could long govern Taiyuan. The Khitan ruler refused.
11
使 西 退
When Yang Guangyuan surrendered Jin'an Stockade to the Khitan, Dejun and his son fled south from Tuanbai Valley to Luzhou. The soldiers cast away weapons and armor, trampled one another in flight, and died by the tens of thousands. Dejun's favorite general Shi Sai led light cavalry east back to Yuyang with more than a thousand followers still under him. Together with scattered fugitives they all gathered at Luzhou. That day Military Governor Gao Xingzhou also returned from the north. At the prefectural gate he saw Dejun and his son on the wall and said: "Your Highness and I are townsmen, so I speak plainly: there is not a dou of grain left in the city. Welcome the imperial carriage at once, secure your own safety, and do not invite regret." Dejun then went out with Yanshou and surrendered to the Khitan. When Gaozu arrived, Dejun and his son met him before his horse, but Gaozu showed them no courtesy. The Khitan ruler asked Dejun: "When you were in Youzhou, where are the Silver Saddle Khitan guards you raised?" Dejun pointed them out. The Khitan killed them all in the western suburbs of Lu, then shackled Dejun and his son and took them into Khitan territory. When he met Empress Dowager Shulü, he presented all the wealth of his party and registered his Youzhou fields and houses as gifts. The empress dowager said to him: "Why did you father and son go seeking a Son of Heaven for yourselves?" Dejun bowed his head and could not answer. (Zizhi Tongjian: The empress dowager asked, "What were you doing recently at Taiyuan?" Dejun said, "Following the Tang ruler's command." The empress dowager said, "You asked my son to make you Son of Heaven—what nonsense is this?" She pointed at her own heart and said, "This cannot be deceived." She also said, "When my son was about to march, I warned him: 'If King Zhao leads troops north toward Yuguan, recall him at once—Taiyuan cannot be saved. If you wished to be Son of Heaven, why not first defeat my son? Plotting more slowly would not have been too late. You are a subject who betrayed your lord, could not strike the enemy, and still wished to profit from chaos. Acting like this, with what face can you seek to live?" Dejun bowed his head and could not answer.)〉 She asked again, "Where are the fields and houses?" He said, "All are in Youzhou." The empress dowager said, "They already belong to me—why present them again?" By the summer of the second Tianfu year, Dejun died in Khitan territory. (Khitan State Chronicle: Dejun grew depressed and ate little; after more than a year he died.) After Dejun died, the Khitan ruler released Yanshou and employed him.)〉
12
使 西沿 沿 沿
At the end of the Tianfu era the Khitan broke with Emperor Shaodi. The Khitan ruler entrusted Yanshou with the southern campaign and promised him the throne of the Central Plains. Yanshou then guided the barbarian forces, nibbling away at the lands north of the Yellow River. After the Jin army surrendered at Zhongdu, the Khitan ruler ordered Yanshou to the camps to comfort the various units, bestowed a dragon-phoenix crimson robe, and had him wear it when he went. He told him, "The Han soldiers are all yours now. Comfort and reassure them in person." When Yanshou reached the camp, Du Chongwei, Li Shouzhen, and the rest all met him before his horse. When the Khitan entered Bian, tens of thousands of surrendered troops were encamped in the open at Chenqiao. The Khitan ruler feared trouble and wished to kill them all. When Yanshou heard this he hurried to see the Khitan ruler and said: "Your servant observes that until today Your Majesty fought battle after battle before finally taking the Jin state. Does Your Majesty mean to rule it yourself? Or have it taken for someone else?" The Khitan ruler's face changed and he said, "How excessive are your words! Because the Jin betrayed their pledges, I mobilized the whole state in a southern campaign. For five years we fought before gaining the Central Plains. Would I not rule it myself rather than hand it to another? What have you to say? Speak quickly!" Yanshou said, "Does Your Majesty know whether Wu and Shu fight the Jin court?" He said, "I know." Yanshou said, "From An and Shen in the south to Qin and Feng in the west, the Central Plains frontier runs thousands of li, all of it garrisoned by both realms. When Your Majesty returns home, the season will turn hot and steamy again. If Wu and Shu attack China together, who knows how vast the realm is—with what troops will you defend it? If the defenses fail, will it not be taken by others?" The Khitan ruler said, "I do not know—what is to be done?" Yanshou said, "Your Majesty's troops are hard to use in summer heat along the Wu and Shu frontiers. Better to group the surrendered troops at Chenqiao into regiments under a separate army designation and use them to guard the frontier." The Khitan ruler said, "I recall that at Huguan and Yangcheng we discussed this and failed to settle it, which led to five years of slaughter. Now that they are in hand, how can we not wipe them out?" Yanshou said, "The Jin troops now here—if they are again all kept south of the river as before, that truly will not do. I ask that their army and families be moved to Zhen, Ding, Yun, and Shuo, and that they rotate in annual shifts to guard the frontier beyond the river. That is the best plan." The Khitan ruler said gladly, "I leave it all to the King's counsel." Thus the troops at Chenqiao escaped the massacre of Changping.
13
使 使 使 使
Yanshou had long been at Bian and knew the Khitan ruler would not keep his word. He sent Li Song to ask to be made crown prince. Song had no choice but to relay the request. The Khitan ruler said, "Toward the Prince of Yan I spare nothing. Even my own flesh, if the Prince of Yan can use it, may be cut away—how much more other matters! I have heard that crown prince is a title for the Son of Heaven's own son. How can the Prince of Yan hold it?" He then ordered additional honors for the Prince of Yan. The Hanlin academician and chief drafter Zhang Li, who had come from the north, drafted an appointment for Yanshou as Middle Capital regent, Grand Chancellor, Recorder of the Masters of Writing, Commander of All Military Affairs, Commissioner of Military Affairs, and Prince of Yan as before. The Khitan ruler reviewed the draft, circled out "Recorder of the Masters of Writing" and "Commander of All Military Affairs," and handed it to the Hanlin Academy to draft the edict. He also made his son Kuangzan military governor of Hezhong. At Bianzhou, Yanshou took another younger daughter of Mingzong as his successor wife. Earlier Military Governor Zhou Mi of Yanzhou had arranged for his son Guang to marry her. The bride-price had been paid and the wedding day set, but Yanshou seized her for himself. When the Khitan ruler returned from Bian to Xingzhou, he seated Yanshou above the Khitan left and right chancellors. When the Khitan ruler died, Yanshou issued orders to the circuits styling himself provisional controller of the southern dynasty's military and civil affairs. On the first day of the sixth month that year he was shackled by Prince Yongkang Wuyu. His household wealth was inventoried and distributed among the tribes. Soon after Yanshou entered Khitan territory, he died there.
14
使
Kuangzan served through the Han and Zhou dynasties and was repeatedly appointed to military commands and army leadership. Under the imperial dynasty he held four commands: Lu, Yan, Bin, and Fu.
15
使 西
Zhang Li, courtesy name Mengchen, was a native of Fuyang in Cizhou. His grandfather Qing and his father Bao had been farmers for generations. From youth Li loved learning and showed literary talent. While still a commoner, whenever he saw local disputes he would go in person to the magistrate's office to argue right from wrong. Such was his proud spirit. At the beginning of the Tang Tongguang era he passed the jinshi examination and was soon appointed Left Remonstrator with duty in the History Office. When Guo Chongtao campaigned against Shu, he memorialized asking that Li manage military documents. When Shu was pacified, Chongtao was executed by Prince of Wei Jiji. Chongtao's close followers all fled in fear, but Li alone went to the prince's residence and wept long and bitterly. People of the time admired his loyalty. When the Prince of Wei withdrew, Li followed Deputy Pacification Commissioner Ren Yuan eastward. At Lizhou they learned that Kang Yanxiao had rebelled and seized Hanzhou. Yuan, on the prince's orders, turned the army west to attack him. Li then offered Yuan a plan: hide elite troops in the rear and first lure the enemy with a weak force. Yuan strongly approved. Yanxiao was a fierce general; Yuan was a scholar. When Yanxiao saw Yuan's weak vanguard he paid no heed. When the battle grew hot, Yuan unleashed his elite troops, broke Yanxiao, and brought him back captive. On the fifth day of the fourth month they reached Fengxiang. Inner attendant Xiang Yansi, on Zhuangzong's orders, commanded Yanxiao's execution. Army supervisor Li Yanxi had heard of trouble in Luoyang and therefore kept Yanxiao alive, partly to diminish Ren Yuan's merit. Yuan hesitated. Li said to him: "This rebel stirred trouble and delayed our return. You fought in blood to capture him—how can you disobey the edict and keep this threat alive? That is breaking the cage and releasing the tiger. If you will not decide, I will kill him myself." Ren Yuan had no choice and executed Yanxiao. At the beginning of Tiancheng, Mingzong knew his name and summoned him as Hanlin academician. Twice he mourned his parents. When each mourning ended he returned as academician and served as vice director in the Ministries of Rites and War and as drafter of imperial documents. Before long his father's concubine died. While she lived, Li had respected her for long service to his late father, and the younger sons called her grandmother. When she died Li was uncertain what mourning was proper and asked his colleagues, but none could answer. He pleaded illness, returned to Fuyang, and lived in retirement for three years without observing mourning. Judging sentiment and adapting to circumstance, the discerning approved. During Qingtai he was again appointed director in the Ministry of Revenue's Accounts Bureau and drafter of imperial documents, continuing as Hanlin academician.
16
殿 使 使 使滿
When Gaozu rose at Jinyang, the last Tang emperor ordered Zhao Yanshou to advance against him and also ordered Hanlin academician He Ning to accompany Yanshou. Li had always looked down on Ning and feared he could not manage the task, so he asked to go himself. The last Tang emperor comforted him and agreed. When the Tang army was defeated at Tuanbai Valley he fell into Khitan hands with Yanshou. The Khitan kept him in his former office and he eventually rose to Minister of Personnel. When the Khitan entered Bian he was appointed Right Vice Director, Grand Councilor, and Grand Academician of the Hall for Gathering Worthies, and followed on to Zhenzhou. When the Khitan ruler died, Prince Yongkang went north. Xiao Han came from the Eastern Capital past Changshan and led iron cavalry to surround Li's residence. Li was then ill in bed. When Han saw him he reproached him: "You told the late emperor that barbarians must not be made military governors, or the altars of state would not long endure; when the late emperor came you said I could not lodge in the great inner palace at Bianzhou; and I am military governor of Bianzhou while you sit in the Secretariat—why send me official correspondence?" Li answered in a loud voice without yielding. Han shackled him and left. (Liao History: Li answered loudly: "This concerns the great principle of the state and what binds safety and peril. I spoke truthfully. If you wish to kill me, then kill—why shackle me!")〉 Military Governor Mandale of Zhenzhou soon released his shackles. That night Li died of illness. His family cremated his bones and buried them at Fuyang.
17
Li was by nature upright and blunt, fond of wine and without restraint. When he first fell into Khitan hands he once fled south, was captured by pursuers, and the Khitan ruler angrily said, "Why did you abandon me?" Li said, "I am a Han man. Clothing and food here are not the same. Life is worse than death. Grant me the blade at once." The Khitan ruler turned to interpreter Gao Tangying and said, "I often warned you to treat this man well, yet he escaped. The fault is yours." He had Tangying flogged one hundred strokes. Such was the favor the Khitan ruler showed him. Throughout his life Li embraced righteousness and pitied talent, eager to promote others. Hearing of someone's excellence he would praise it openly; seeing poverty he would empty his purse to help. On the day of his death the scholar-officials of the central court all sighed in regret.
18
紿 使 殿 忿
Xiao Han was a chief among the Khitan tribes. His father was named Abo. When Liu Rengong governed Youzhou, Abo once raided Pingzhou. Rengong sent the fierce general Liu Yanlang and his son Shouguang with five hundred horsemen to hold the prefecture. Abo did not know this, was deceived by the locals, attended a feast of meat and wine, and was captured by Shouguang. The Khitan requested his ransom. Rengong agreed and Abo soon returned. Abo's younger sister was wife to Ambajian and mother of Deguang. Han also had a sister who married Deguang, so his people called him the imperial uncle by marriage. When the Khitan entered the Eastern Capital they made Han military governor of Xuanwu. The Khitan had not used surnames. When Han was to receive a command appointment he took Xiao as surname and Han as given name, and thereafter his whole clan bore the surname Xiao. When the Khitan ruler went north he left Han to garrison the lands south of the river. Han Gaozu had already established his title at Taiyuan. Xiao Han feared and meant to return north, worried that without a ruler in the capital the people would riot. He sent Khitan horsemen to Luoyang to welcome Mingzong's young son Prince Xu Congyi to provisionally manage the southern dynasty's affairs. When Congyi arrived, Han led the Khitan generals to bow in the hall. The next day Han carted his treasures, saddles, and bridles north. The Han people, seeing Prince Xu established, no longer rioted. His cunning plan had succeeded. At Zhenzhou Han encountered Zhang Li. Resentful over old matters, he came to Li's residence, recounted his faults, and shackled him. When Han returned home he was shackled by Prince Yongkang Wuyu and soon died in Khitan territory.
19
涿 滿
Liu Xi was a native of Zhuozhou. His father Jiyong had served successively as magistrate of various districts in the commandery. From youth Xi was famed in his district for classical learning. He once served on the staff of Tang general Zhou Dewei, later fell into Khitan hands, and the Khitan kept him in Han offices. During Tianfu the Khitan appointed Xi regent of Yanjing. He thrice oversaw the civil service examinations under the Khitan and rose to Grand Councilor and concurrent Vice Grand Counselor. He followed the Khitan into Bian and was appointed regent of the Luoyang capital. When the Heyang army rebelled, Xi fled to Xuzhou and then to the Eastern Capital. Xiao Han sent troops to support him at Luoyang. When the Khitan ruler died, Xi returned from Luoyang to the Eastern Capital, followed Xiao Han north, and remained at Zhenzhou. At the beginning of Han he fled with Mandale to Dingzhou and later died in the north. (Khitan State Chronicle: Liu Ke was Xi's son and married Emperor Shizong's younger sister, Princess of Yan.)〉
20
使 使
Cui Tingxun was a man of unknown origin. (Zizhi Tongjian commentary citing Song Bai: Tingxun was originally from Henei.)〉 He was tall and imposing, with a handsome beard. He fell into Khitan hands in youth, rose to military governor of Yunzhou, and reached Vice Grand Counselor. When the Khitan entered Bian they moved Emperor Shaodi to Fengchan Temple and sent Tingxun with troops to guard him. Soon he was made military governor of Heyang and won great popular approval. When the Khitan marched north, Wu Xingde led troops toward Heyang. Tingxun was driven off and joined the Xi king Yila in holding Huaizhou. He soon counterattacked Xingde, who came out to fight and was defeated. When the Khitan ruler died he returned to Zhenzhou. At the beginning of Han he fled with Madale to Dingzhou and later perished in the north.
21
The historian comments: The exalted dignity of emperors and kings must come through Heaven's mandate. Even men with the courage of Han Xin and Peng Yue or the power of Wu Pi and Huainan may not vainly hope for the throne—how much less the mediocrity of the two Ans, aiding each other in rebellion. It is fitting they destroyed themselves. Those who later hold strong armies and weighty commands—can they fail to take this as a warning! Yanze had the heart of a wolf cub. He died only when his crimes were full—too late! Dejun and the others were bound up with Jin affairs from beginning to end; therefore they are appended here.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →