← Back to 明史

卷一百十四 列傳第二 后妃二

Volume 114 Biographies 2: Empresses and Consorts 2

Chapter 114 of 明史 · History of Ming
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 114
Next Chapter →
1
Empress Zhang (posthumous name Xiaokang), consort of Emperor Xiaozong; Empress Xia (Xiaojing), consort of Emperor Wuzong; Empress Chen (Xiaojie), consort of Emperor Shizong; the deposed Empress Zhang; Empress Fang (Xiaolie); Empress Dowager Du (Xiaoke); Empress Li (Xiaoyi), consort of Emperor Muzong; Empress Chen (Xiao'an); Empress Dowager Li (Xiaoding); Empress Wang (Xiaoduan), consort of Emperor Shenzong; Consort Liu (Zhaohui); Empress Dowager Wang (Xiaojing); Noble Consort Zheng; Empress Guo (Xiaoyuan), consort of Emperor Guangzong; Empress Dowager Wang (Xiaohe); Empress Dowager Liu (Xiaochun); Imperial Concubine Li Kang; Imperial Concubine Li Zhuang; Selected Attendant Zhao; Empress Zhang (Yi'an), consort of Emperor Xizong; Imperial Concubine Zhang Yu; Empress Zhou (Min), consort of the Chongzhen Emperor; Noble Consort Tian.
2
Empress Zhang, known posthumously as Xiaokang and consort of Emperor Xiaozong, came from Xingji. Her father Luan had entered the Imperial University as a tribute scholar from the provinces. Her mother, née Jin, dreamed that the moon entered her womb, and afterward bore the future empress. In the twenty-third year of the Chenghua reign she was selected to be crown prince's consort. The same year, when Emperor Xiaozong ascended the throne, she was formally installed as empress. The emperor lavished favors on her kin: Luan was posthumously made Duke of Chang; her brothers Heling and Yanling became Marquis of Shouning and Baron of Jianchang; a family temple for the empress was raised at Xingji on a grand scale and took years to complete. Heling and Yanling were entered on the palace register and let their households profit by fraud; ministers inside and outside the court spoke out repeatedly, yet the emperor took no action out of regard for the empress.
3
When Emperor Wuzong came to the throne, she was honored as empress dowager. In the twelfth month of his fifth year, after the pacification of Prince of An's rebellion, she received the elevated title Empress Dowager Cishou. When Emperor Shizong inherited the throne, she was styled Holy Mother, with the added honorific "Zhaosheng Cishou." In the third year of Jiajing the title was further extended to "Zhaosheng Kanghui Cishou." Later she was addressed instead as the emperor's aunt. In the fifteenth year the honorific was expanded again to "Zhaosheng Gong'an Kanghui Cishou." She died in the eighth month of the twentieth year and was given the posthumous title Empress Xiaokang Jingsu Zhuangci Zheyi Yitian Zansheng Jing; she was interred with the emperor at Tailing and received temple enshrinement.
4
使
Early on, when the Empress Dowager of Xingguo arrived at court as a prince's wife, Empress Dowager Zhang still dealt with her by the old rules of precedence, and the emperor took strong offense. When the emperor attended court, the empress dowager treated her with renewed haughtiness. When Yanling, the empress dowager's brother, was accused, the emperor found him guilty of treason and condemned him to death; the empress dowager was trapped and could see no way out. At the birth of the heir apparent Aichong, she requested an audience to offer congratulations, but the emperor refused to receive her. She sent envoys to ask again, but he would not allow it. Grand Secretary Zhang Fuling also interceded for Yanling; the emperor replied in his own hand: "The realm belongs to the Founding Emperor, and Emperor Xiaozong upheld the Founding Emperor's law. You fret over hurting your aunt's feelings—do you not fret over hurting the Founding Emperor and Emperor Xiaozong in their ancestral shrines?" Zhang Fuling memorialized again: "When Your Majesty first took the throne, you followed my counsel and styled her Aunt Empress Dowager; the court blamed Your Majesty then, and has not stopped since. Now ministers high and low say nothing at all—they would almost welcome the empress dowager's dishonorable end, the better to magnify Your Majesty's blame. Treason, once proved, demands the extermination of the whole clan—is Empress Dowager Zhaosheng not herself a Zhang? How can Your Majesty resolve this!" During the winter review of prisoners, the emperor again meant to put Yanling to death, but once more held back on Zhang Fuling's plea. Soon afterward a schemer named Liu Dongshan denounced a conspiracy, and Heling too was arrested and thrown into the imperial prison. The empress dowager humbled herself in worn garments on a straw mat to beg for mercy, yet he would not heed her. In time Heling died of illness in custody. After the empress dowager's death, the emperor finally had Yanling executed; the full account appears in the Biographies of Imperial Affines.
5
Empress Xia, posthumous name Xiaojing and consort of Emperor Wuzong, came from Shangyuan. In the first year of the Zhengde reign she was formally made empress. In the first year of Jiajing she received the elevated title Empress Zhuangsu. She died in the first month of the fourteenth year, was interred with the emperor at Kangling, and enshrined in the ancestral temple. When the ritual officials first proposed funeral observances, the emperor said: "A brother-in-law owes no mourning dress to a sister-in-law; with both empress dowagers still living, I shall wear green, while officials and commoners shall observe mourning as for an empress dowager." Minister of Rites Xia Yan replied: "If Your Majesty, invoking the exemption between sister-in-law and brother-in-law, refuses white mourning, the ministers cannot attend court in white; we beg that audiences be suspended for now." The emperor agreed. When the posthumous title was debated, Grand Secretary Zhang Fuling argued: "The late empress was Your Majesty's sister-in-law, not a primary empress of earlier reigns; two or four characters would suffice." Li Shi held that eight characters were appropriate." Censor-in-Chief Wang Tingxiang, Vice Minister Huo Tao, and others protested: "She was still the emperor's consort—why treat her differently!" Xia Yan collected opinions and memorialized: "Antiquity favored simplicity in posthumous titles; later ages lengthened them out of loyal affection—that is all. We live in the present and should follow present practice. The late empress deserves the same style of posthumous title as primary empresses of past reigns; two, four, or eight characters lack ritual warrant." The emperor refused and ordered the matter debated again. The ministers asked to follow Zhang Fuling's recommendation. The emperor said: "Use six characters—it suits the yin number." She was then given the posthumous title Empress Xiaojing Zhuanghui Ansu Yi. In the fifteenth year the emperor decided Zhang Fuling had been mistaken and decreed: "Empress Xiaojing's posthumous title is inadequate and does not honor her as consort of Emperor Wuzong." It was revised to Empress Xiaojing Zhuanghui Ansu Wencheng Shuntian Xiesheng Yi.
6
殿 殿
Empress Fang, posthumous name Xiaolie, was Emperor Shizong's third empress and came from Jiangning. Nearly ten years into his reign the emperor still had no son. Grand Secretary Zhang Fuling urged: "In antiquity the Son of Heaven, on installing an empress, also filled the six palaces with three ladies, nine consorts, twenty-seven attendant ladies, and eighty-one royal wives—to secure the succession. Your Majesty is in his prime; he should seek virtuous ladies widely for the sake of an heir." The emperor agreed. In the third month of the tenth year she was invested together with ladies Zheng, Wang, Yan, Wei, Shen, Lu, Shen, and Du as nine consorts, wearing the nine-pheasant crown and full ceremonial dress, with secondary jade scepters and gold-plated investiture scrolls, their regalia one-fifth below the empress's. On the appointed day the emperor, in full ceremonial dress, reported to the Grand Temple, then changed to the leather cap, presided at Huagai Hall, issued the decree, and sent senior ministers to conduct the investiture. After investiture she accompanied the empress in paying court at the Hall of Imperial Ancestors. When the rites ended, the emperor in the leather cap received congratulations from all officials—a ceremony invented for the occasion. After Empress Zhang was deposed, Fang was made empress; Lady Shen became Chen consort and Lady Yan Li consort. Formerly, installing an empress required homage only at the inner temple. Now he ordered the ritual officials to draft rites for the empress's temple audience. The ministers argued that the Son of Heaven fills the three palaces to sustain the ancestral cult and that the Book of Rites prescribes a temple audience; they studied the classics and the Collected Rites of the Great Ming and submitted a draft protocol. On the appointed day the emperor led the empress to the Grand Temple and the lineage temple. Three days later an edict went out to the whole empire. The following day titled ladies attended court in audience.
7
宿
In the twenty-first year palace maids led by Yang Jinying plotted to assassinate the emperor; he survived only because the empress rescued him, and her father Rui, Baron of Taihe, was raised to marquis. Consort Cao was beautiful and greatly favored; she was made Duan consort. That night the emperor slept in Consort Duan's quarters. Jinying and her accomplices waited until the emperor was deep asleep, then looped a cord about his neck; they tied a knot that would not tighten, and he did not die. Their accomplice Zhang Jinlian, seeing the plot fail, ran to warn the empress. The empress hurried in, loosened the cord, and the emperor came to. She ordered the eunuch Zhang Zuo and others to seize palace women and torture them at random, alleging that Jinying's party had attempted regicide and that Consort Wang Ning was the ringleader. She also claimed that although Consort Cao Duan had not joined the plot, she had known of it. The emperor was shaken and speechless; the empress issued orders in his name to seize Consort Duan, Consort Ning, Jinying, and the rest, who were all torn apart in the public square. More than ten of their kinsmen were put to death as well. In truth the consort had known nothing of the plot. Only much later did the emperor learn she had been innocent.
8
殿殿
On the yimwei day of the eleventh month of the twenty-sixth year the empress died. An edict declared: "The empress lately saved Us from peril and aided Heaven in our distress; bury her with the rites due a primary empress." Her tomb was named Yongling in advance; she received the posthumous title Xiaolie; the emperor personally set the funeral rites, more lavish than before. When the rites were finished, an edict went out to the whole empire. At the end of the mourning period ritual officials proposed placing her tablet in the eastern side chamber of the Hall of Imperial Ancestors; the emperor said: "A side chamber there is improper—enshrine her at once in the Grand Temple." Grand Secretary Yan Song and others proposed a place in the eastern wing of the Grand Temple after Empress Rui, with a canopy in the Xian Temple to the right of the imperial ancestress, following the rite of enshrinement with a husband's paternal aunt. The emperor replied: "Enshrinement is too weighty a matter to settle by expedient. An empress is not an emperor but one who shares his shrine—there is a fixed order; what rite offers sacrifice in one place while keeping the tablet in another! Remove Emperor Renzong from the temple and enshrine her in the new order—at Our own place in the sequence; do not confuse the rites." Yan Song objected: "Subjects dare not propose a new order of enshrinement; moreover, yin cannot take yang's place." For the present he was told to place the tablet beside Empress Rui.
9
殿 滿 殿
In the tenth month of the twenty-ninth year the emperor still meant to enshrine her in the Grand Temple and ordered the matter debated again. Minister Xu Jie argued against it; supervising secretary Yang Sizhong sided with Xu; no one else spoke. The emperor saw how the court stood. When the memorial arrived, it read: "The empress rightly held the central palace and deserves enshrinement, but to alter the temple order so hastily—your subjects not only dare not, they truly cannot bear it. Set her place in the Hall of Imperial Ancestors instead." The emperor flew into a rage. Xu and Yang said in alarm: "The Zhou built nine temples with three zhao and three mu. Our dynasty's temples share one hall with separate chambers, unlike the Rites of Zhou. All nine chambers of the Grand Temple are full; for Your Majesty's sake Renzong ought to be removed—that goes without saying—but that is for sage sons and grandsons on another day. We are told the Xia kept five temples, the Shang seven, and the Zhou nine. Rites follow principle—five may become seven, seven nine, and beyond nine more may be added. Add two chambers each to the Grand Temple and the Hall of Imperial Ancestors to enshrine Xiaolie, and Renzong need not be removed; Empress Xiaolie can at once take her rightful place facing south, and Your Majesty avoids any appearance of removing an ancestor in advance." The emperor said: "As subjects, when removal or enshrinement is called for, you may press your case as hard as you like. If the rites are truly right, why shrink from acting now!" Xu and his colleagues then reconvened the court and memorialized: "The Tang, Yu, and Xia kept five temples, and their sacrifices reached only four generations. The Zhou built nine temples with three zhao and three mu, yet even when brothers succeeded one another, six generations could not all be housed. Renzong is now Your Majesty's five-generation ancestor; on Your Majesty's account Renzong ought by rite to be removed, and Empress Xiaolie ought by rite to be enshrined. Remove Renzong and enshrine Empress Xiaolie in the Grand Temple's ninth chamber." They then submitted the prescribed rites for removal and enshrinement.
10
殿
They soon asked for death-anniversary sacrifices; the emperor, still smarting from the earlier dispute, replied: "Xiaolie was a successor empress, and the ruler she served was an adopted heir—skipping the anniversary sacrifice is acceptable." Xu pressed harder still; the emperor said: "Only the Son of Heaven may debate rites. The empress belongs in the temple beside my chamber, yet the rites officials claim the time is wrong—nothing but polished excuses to mislead the court." He then told Yan Song and the others: "The rites officials go along with me only grudgingly. If you cannot bear to remove Renzong, set up a separate shrine for the late empress for now and leave the final arrangement to your ministers later. On her death anniversary, offer a single cup of wine—that will not wound anyone's feelings." The rites officials dared say no more and asked only to carry out the edict. He granted their request. Two years later Yang Sizhong, in a congratulatory memorial, hit a taboo and was beaten with the stick and struck from the rolls. At the start of Longqing, on the same day as Empress Xiaojie, she received the elevated posthumous title "Empress Xiaolie Duanshun Minhui Gongcheng Zhitian Weisheng," and her tablet was moved to Hongxiao Hall.
11
殿
Empress Dowager Du, known posthumously as Xiaoke and birth mother of Emperor Muzong, came from Daxing. In the tenth year of the Jiajing reign she was made Lady Kang. In the fifteenth year she was promoted to consort. She died in the first month of the thirty-third year. Muzong was then Prince of Yu living in his mansion; Minister of Rites Ouyang De laid out the mourning rites, asking for five days' court suspension, with the prince presiding and wearing the severest three-year hemp mourning prescribed in the Founding Emperor's Record of Filial Affection. The emperor said one must respect the superior status of the ruler and father. Grand Secretary Yan Song said: "The Founding Emperor ordered Prince Zhou Xu to wear three years of severest hemp mourning for Grand Consort Sun as for a nurturing mother. That same year the Record of Filial Affection was finished and became standard practice; such cases had been rare ever since. When one arises now, it should set a precedent for generations to come." The emperor ordered the precedent of Noble Lady Zheng followed: two days' suspension of court. She received the posthumous name Rongshu and was buried at Jinshan. When Muzong took the throne she was given the posthumous title "Empress Dowager Xiaoke Yuanchun Ciyi Gongshun Zantian Kaisheng," reburied at Yongling, and her tablet placed in Shenxiao Hall. Her father Lin was posthumously made Marquis of Qingdu, and his son Jizong was appointed to inherit the title.
12
Empress Li, known posthumously as Xiaoyi and consort of Emperor Muzong, came from Changping. While Muzong was Prince of Yu she was chosen as his consort and bore Crown Prince Xianhuai. She died in the fourth month of the thirty-seventh year of Jiajing. The emperor ruled that the ministry's use of "died" was improper and ordered it changed to "deceased"; she was buried at Jinshan. When Muzong took the throne he gave her the posthumous title "Empress Xiaoyi" and made her father Ming Marquis of Deping. When Shenzong ascended she received the elevated posthumous title "Empress Xiaoyi Zhenhui Shunzhe Gongren Litian Xiangsheng Zhuang," was buried with him at Zhaoling, and enshrined in the Grand Temple.
13
Empress Dowager Li, known posthumously as Xiaoding and birth mother of Emperor Shenzong, came from Huoxian. She served Muzong while he was Prince of Yu. In the third month of the first year of Longqing she was made Imperial Noble Consort. She bore Shenzong. When he ascended the throne she was honored as Empress Dowager Cisheng. By old custom, when a new emperor took the throne the empress became Empress Dowager; if the birth mother also held that title, an honorific epithet distinguished the two. Then the eunuch Feng Bao, currying favor with the Noble Consort, pushed through Zhang Juzheng a joint elevation: the empress was styled "Empress Dowager Rensheng" and the Noble Consort "Empress Dowager Cisheng"—from the outset they were equals. Rensheng lived in Ciqing Palace; Cisheng in Cining Palace. Juzheng asked that she oversee the emperor's daily life, and she moved to the Palace of Heavenly Purity.
14
使 西 殿
The Empress Dowager raised the emperor with considerable strictness. If he neglected his books, she had him kneel for long stretches. Before each lecture session she often made him play the lecturer and recite a lesson in front of her. On court days, at the fifth watch she went to his bedchamber, called "Rise, Your Majesty," had attendants help him sit up, brought water to wash his face, and led him to the palanquin. The emperor treated her with scrupulous deference, but inner officials acting on her orders often abused her authority. Once, drunk at a private banquet in the western city, he ordered an attendant to sing a new song; when the man refused, the emperor struck him with a sword. Attendants pulled him off; he then jokingly cut the man's hair. The next day, hearing of it, she sent word to Juzheng to submit a sharp remonstrance and draft a self-reproach edict for the emperor. She also had the emperor kneel and listed his offenses one by one. He wept and promised to mend his ways before she relented. In the sixth year, as the emperor's grand wedding approached and she was to return to Cining Palace, she told Juzheng: "I can no longer watch over the emperor day and night; you personally received the late emperor's trust—guide him daily and honor the charge the late emperor gave you at his deathbed." In the third month "Xuanwen" was added to her titles. In the tenth year "Mingsu" was added. In the twelfth year she joined Empress Dowager Rensheng on a visit to the imperial tombs. In the twenty-ninth year Zhenshou Duandian was added. In the thirty-fourth year Gongxi was added. She died in the second month of the forty-second year and received the elevated posthumous title "Empress Dowager Xiaoding Zhenchun Qinren Duansu Bitian Zuosheng"; she was buried with the emperor at Zhaoling and separately enshrined at Chongxian Hall.
15
使
She was stern and clear-minded by nature. In the early Wanli years she backed Zhang Juzheng; he matched names to realities and nearly restored prosperity and strength—and her role was the largest. Before Guangzong was named heir, supervising secretaries Jiang Yinglin and others petitioned for his appointment and were demoted; the Empress Dowager was displeased when she heard. One day, as the emperor attended her, she asked why. The emperor said: "He is the son of a palace woman." The Empress Dowager flared up: "You are a palace woman's son too!" Terrified, he prostrated himself and did not dare rise. Within the palace, palace women were called "capital people"; the Empress Dowager had risen from that rank herself, which is why she said it. Guangzong was thereby made heir. When officials asked that the Prince of Fu leave for his fief—with a date already set—Noble Consort Zheng wanted to delay until the next year, citing the Empress Dowager's birthday. The Empress Dowager said: "Should my Prince of Lu also come to offer birthday wishes!" The Noble Consort then dared not keep the Prince of Fu any longer. Censor Cao Xuecheng was sentenced to death for speaking out. Pitying his elderly mother, the Empress Dowager appealed to the emperor and he was pardoned. Her father Wei was made Marquis of Wuqing. When members of her household once broke the law, she had eunuchs rebuke them but still handed the offenders over for punishment. Yet she was devoted to Buddhism; temples sprang up across the capital at a cost of tens of thousands each, and the emperor gave without counting. While Juzheng lived he raised the matter once but could not stop it.
16
調
Empress Wang, known posthumously as Xiaoduan and consort of Emperor Shenzong, came from Yuyao and was born in the capital. In the sixth year of Wanli she was invested as empress. Dignified and careful by nature, she won Empress Dowager Xiaoding's affection. While Guangzong was crown prince, he faced repeated crises; she shielded and cared for him throughout. Noble Consort Zheng held the emperor's exclusive favor; the empress did not compete. She held the central palace for forty-two years and was known for her kindness and filial devotion. She died in the fourth month of the forty-eighth year and received the posthumous name Xiaoduan. When Guangzong took the throne she received the elevated posthumous title "Empress Xiaoduan Zhenke Zhuanghui Renming Pitian Yusheng Xian." The emperor soon died; when Xizong ascended, her empress regalia was at last conferred, she was buried with him at Dingling, and her tablet was enshrined in the temple.
17
便
Invested on the same day as the empress was Consort Liu, styled Zhaohui. Under the Tianqi and Chongzhen emperors she often lived in Cining Palace and held the empress dowager's seal. Careful and warm by nature, she nurtured the princes with affection. The Chongzhen Emperor honored her as a great imperial dowager. Once at the New Year audience she came to court; the emperor sat informally and soon fell asleep. She warned attendants not to wake him abruptly and told the Director of Imperial Wardrobe to guard him carefully. He soon woke, straightened his robes, and apologized: "In the Divine Ancestor's day the realm had few troubles; now hardship is everywhere; for two nights I have gone over documents without sleep—in your presence I was too exhausted to keep myself upright." The Grand Consort wept at his words. She died in the fifteenth year of Chongzhen, at the age of eighty-six.
18
Empress Dowager Wang (Xiaojing), birth mother of Emperor Guangzong. She began as a maid in the Cining Palace. She was no longer young when the emperor passed through Cining, took her secretly to bed, and she conceived. By established custom, when a palace woman received the emperor's favor, gifts were always bestowed, and eunuchs of the Imperial Secretariat recorded the date and what was given as verification. The emperor wished to conceal the affair, so those at his side kept silent. One day at a banquet hosted by Empress Dowager Cisheng, the topic was raised. The emperor gave no answer. Empress Dowager Cisheng had the Inner Daily Records fetched to show the emperor and spoke gently: "I am old, and still have no grandson. If the child is a boy, that will be a blessing to the dynasty and the realm. A mother rises in station through her son—why cling to differences of rank?" In the fourth month of the tenth year she was created Consort Gong. In the eighth month Guangzong was born—the future crown prince and eldest son. Soon afterward Noble Consort Zheng bore the third imperial son and was raised to Imperial Noble Consort, while Consort Gong was passed over. In the twenty-ninth year the eldest son was formally named crown prince, yet she remained without further rank. In the thirty-fourth year, after the birth of a great-grandson and the granting of an honorific to Empress Dowager Cisheng, she was finally promoted to Imperial Noble Consort. In the thirty-ninth year, as she lay dying, Guangzong secured permission to see her, but found the gate still barred and broke the lock to enter. Her sight was failing; she seized Guangzong's sleeve and wept: "My son has grown so tall—what regret can I have in dying!" With that she died. Grand Secretary Ye Xianggao argued: "The crown prince's mother has died—the rites ought to be generous." The emperor did not respond. He memorialized again, and only then was approval granted. She was posthumously titled Imperial Noble Consort Wensu Duanjing Chunyi and interred at Tianshou Mountain.
19
殿
At Guangzong's accession he proclaimed: "Having taken up the foundational inheritance and coming to rule all under Heaven, I trace the wellspring of my fortune—and no debt is greater than that owed my birth mother, Imperial Noble Consort Wensu Duanjing Chunyi. In the Eastern Palace I could not care for her comfort; now within the inner palace I can only mourn over daily offerings. To express the depth of filial devotion I owe her, I must begin with the ancient rites of honoring a royal mother. Let the Ministry of Rites follow the precedent set when our imperial ancestor Emperor Muzong honored his birth mother, Consort Rongshu Kang, deliberate fully, and report back." Before this could be enacted Guangzong died; when Xizong ascended the throne, she received the elevated posthumous title Empress Dowager Xiaojing Wenyi Jingrang Zhenci Cantian Yin Sheng, was reinterred at Dingling, and given offerings in the Fengci Hall. Her father Tianrui was created Baron of Yongning.
20
Noble Consort Zheng (posthumous honorific Gongke), a native of Daxing. Early in the Wanli reign she entered the palace, was created noble consort, bore the third imperial son, and was raised to imperial noble consort. The emperor doted on her. Officials outside the palace suspected she intended to name her own son as heir. Ministers repeatedly debated succession; thousands of memorials piled up, denouncing the inner palace and assailing the men in power. For the most part the emperor ignored them. From this sprang the great calamity of partisan factional warfare. In the spring of Wanli 29 the eldest son moved into the Xiying Palace; in the tenth month he was named crown prince, yet suspicion did not end.
21
使
Earlier, while serving as provincial surveillance commissioner, Vice Minister Lü Kun had compiled Illustrations and Explanations of Women's Virtues in the Inner Quarters. Eunuch Chen Ju obtained a copy and presented it to the emperor. The emperor gave it to the consort, who had it reprinted—Kun had nothing to do with that. In the autumn of the twenty-sixth year someone anonymously composed a postface to Illustrations and Explanations of Women's Virtues in the Inner Quarters, titled Discussion of Youwei Jiyong; it circulated widely in the capital, arguing that Lü Kun's book opened with Han Empress Ma the Mingde, who rose from palace maid to empress—a pointed allusion to the consort—and that her reprinting was meant to lend credence to naming her own son as heir. The essay posed its argument as a dialogue under the pseudonym "Zhu Dongji." "Dongji" stood for the Eastern Court—the heir apparent. The title Youwei alluded to a memorial on peril that Lü Kun had once submitted; by borrowing his name it offered satire—in essence, sedition posing as prophecy. The consort's brother Guotai and nephew Chengen, recalling that Censor Dai Shiheng had once impeached Lü Kun and that Fan Yuheng, magistrate of Quanjiao, had also impeached the noble consort, suspected those two were the authors. The emperor heavily punished the two men but ignored the seditious text itself. More than five years later A Continuation of the Youwei Jiyong Discussion circulated again. By then the crown prince was already named; Grand Secretary Zhu Geng obtained the tract and reported it to the throne. The tract cast its argument as a dialogue under the name "Zheng Fucheng." "Zheng Fucheng" meant that the Zheng family's Prince of Fu was destined to succeed. It declared in essence: "The emperor named the Eastern Palace heir only under compulsion; one day the heir will surely be changed. Its especial use of Grand Secretary Zhu Geng was a coded hint at replacing the heir." The language was especially wild and seditious; contemporaries called it a demon book—a text of sedition. The emperor flew into a rage and ordered the Embroidered Uniform Guard to hunt down the authors with all speed. After a long search a man named Jiao Shengguang was seized and executed; the full account appears in the biographies of Guo Zhengyu and Shen Li.
22
In the forty-first year, company commander Wang Rigana lodged a report of treason, alleging that men such as Kong Xue had used witchcraft against the Holy Mother and crown prince—and implicating the consort as well. Grand Secretary Ye Xianggao persuaded the emperor to stay calm and speed the Prince of Fu to his fief, quieting public uproar. The matter died down. Later came the Club Assault affair: Section Director Wang Zhicai memorialized on Zhang Chai's case, implicating eunuchs Pang Bao and Liu Cheng of the noble consort's household; court opinion boiled over. When the noble consort heard of it, she wept before the emperor. The emperor said: "This talk outside the palace will not easily die away—you had best go yourself and appeal to the crown prince." The noble consort went to the crown prince and poured out her grief. The noble consort kowtowed, and the crown prince kowtowed in return. The emperor again assembled the ministers before the memorial tablet of the Cining Empress Dowager and had the crown prince issue orders forbidding guilt by association; Zhang Chai's case was finally closed. At Shenzong's death his final injunction was to create the consort empress. Vice Minister of Rites Sun Ruyou objected, and the plan was abandoned. After Guangzong's death, rumors spread that the consort and Selected Attendant Li, dwelling together in the Qianqing Palace, meant to rule from behind a screen; the talk subsided only slowly.
23
She died in the seventh month of Chongzhen 3 and was posthumously titled Imperial Noble Consort Gongke Huirong Hejing; she was buried at Yinquan Mountain.
24
Empress Guo (posthumous name Xiaoyuan), consort of Emperor Guangzong, came from Shuntian. Her father Weicheng was ennobled when his daughter rose in rank—first as Baron of Boping, then as marquis. At his death her elder brother Zhenming inherited the title. In Wanli 29 she was formally installed as crown prince's consort. She died in the eleventh month of the forty-first year and received the posthumous name Gongjing. At Xizong's accession she received the elevated posthumous title Empress Xiaoyuan Zhaoyi Zhehui Zhuangren Hetian Bisheng Zhen, was reinterred at Qingling, and joined the imperial temple rites.
25
殿
Empress Dowager Wang (Xiaohe), birth mother of Xizong, came from Shuntian. She served in Guangzong's Eastern Palace as a selected attendant. In Wanli 32 she was promoted to Lady of Talent. She died in the third month of the forty-seventh year. At Xizong's accession she received the elevated posthumous title Empress Dowager Xiaohe Gongxian Wenmu Huici Xietian Jusheng, was reinterred at Qingling, and given offerings in the Fengxian Hall. In the third month of Chongzhen 11, while adding honorific titles for Empress Dowager Xiaochun, jade registers and seals for the empress and Empress Dowager Xiaojing were recovered from the Directorate of Imperial Manufactories; only then were officials ordered to present them at the temple. Wang Ti'gan, a follower of Wei Zhongxian, was found guilty of negligence and condemned to death. Fully eighteen years had passed since those titles were first granted.
26
西 西
Empress Dowager Liu (Xiaochun), birth mother of the Chongzhen Emperor, came from Haizhou; her household was registered at Wanping. She first entered the palace as a palace lady. In the twelfth month of Wanli 38 she bore the future Chongzhen Emperor. Soon afterward she fell from Guangzong's favor, was punished, and died. Guangzong later regretted the matter, fearing Shenzong would discover it; he ordered the inner palace to keep silent and had her buried on Western Hill. When he came of age and was enfeoffed as Prince of Xin, she was posthumously created Consort Xian. While living in the Xunqin Palace, the future Chongzhen Emperor asked his attendants: "On Western Hill, is there the tomb of Prince Shenyi?" They answered: "There is." "And beside it, is there the tomb of Lady Liu?" They answered: "There is." He secretly sent money for offerings again and again. At his accession she received the elevated posthumous title Empress Dowager Xiaochun Gongyi Shumu Zhuangjing Bitian Yusheng and was reinterred at Qingling.
27
He was five when he lost his mother; he asked those around him for her portrait, but none could be found. Imperial Concubine Fu Yi had once entered the palace as a palace lady alongside the empress dowager; now living in the inner quarters, she claimed intimate knowledge of the empress dowager and said that among palace women there were those of similar appearance; the empress dowager's mother, the Grand Lady of Yingguo, was told to guide the painters until a likeness met with the emperor's approval. When the portrait was finished, it was escorted through the Zhengyang Gate with full imperial ceremony. The emperor knelt to receive it at the Meridian Gate, had it hung in the palace, and called old palace women to judge it—some said it resembled her, some said it did not. The emperor wept openly, and every woman of the inner palace wept with him.
28
殿殿 殿殿 殿殿 殿 殿
By established custom, on a birth mother's death anniversary no rites were performed and mourners did not wear blue. In the sixth month of the fifteenth year, moved by devotion to his mother, the emperor proposed honoring the seven birth and stepmothers of prior reigns together in a single temple, to fulfill his filial intent. He then held audience at the Dezheng Hall, summoned grand secretaries and ritual officials, and asked: "The Grand Ancestral Temple allows one empress per emperor, and the collateral temples follow the same rule. Seven birth and stepmothers from prior reigns may not share in those rites; even within the palace the Fengxian Hall offers them no sacrifice. What can be done? Vice Minister of Rites Jiang Dejing replied: "Beyond the Fengxian Hall stands the Fengci Hall, erected to enshrine stepmothers and birth mothers alike. Though it was abandoned, the precedent can be restored." The emperor said: "Beyond the Fengci Hall lie the Hongxiao, Shenxiao, and Ben'en halls as well." Dejing said: "We ministers are not fully acquainted with the inner court's regulations. Emperor Xiaozong had built the Fengci Hall, which was dismantled in the Jiajing reign. Whether any remnant of its original site survives is now unknown." The emperor said: "The Fengci Hall is gone; only the Fengxian Hall can still be enlarged." A separate hall was then established to honor Empress Xiaochun together with the seven empresses.
29
西 西 殿
Lady of Imperial Favor Li was a consort-attendant of Emperor Guangzong. At that time two Li consort-attendants served in the palace, known as Eastern Li and Western Li. The Lady of Imperial Favor was Western Li, the favorite of the two; she had once helped raise both Emperor Xizong and the future Emperor Zhuanglie. When Guangzong ascended the throne he was already ill. Summoning his ministers, he received them in the warm pavilion, leaned on his armrest, and ordered that the consort-attendant be promoted to Noble Imperial Consort. The consort-attendant sent the young Xizong out and said: "I want to be made empress. The emperor made no answer. Vice Minister of Rites Sun Ruyou submitted a memorial: "The posthumous titles of the two empress dowagers, the primary consort, and the imperial ladies have yet to be announced. There is no harm in waiting until the four state mourning rites are complete. Before long the emperor died, but the consort-attendant remained in the Palace of Heavenly Purity. The court outside grew frightened, suspecting she intended to rule from behind the curtain. Grand Secretary Liu Yipao, Minister of Personnel Zhou Jiamo, Yang Lian of the Bureau of War, Censor Zuo Guangdou, and others memorialized in vigorous protest, and the consort-attendant was moved to the Hall of Benevolent Longevity. The full account appears in the biographies of Liu Yipao and Yang Lian.
30
使 殿 使
When Xizong ascended the throne, he issued an edict denouncing the consort-attendant for abusing the empress dowager until her death and for scheming to rule from behind the curtain. Censor Jia Jichun, however, submitted a memorial in the consort-attendant's defense, and he and Zhou Chaorui quarreled on without end. The emperor issued another edict: "On the first day of the ninth month my late father passed away. After the ministers entered the palace to mourn, they asked to receive me in audience. The consort-attendant kept me in the warm pavilion. Only when the eunuchs of the Directorate of Ceremonies pressed again and again was I allowed to emerge. She consented, then changed her mind, and sent Li Jinzhong and others time after time to bring me back. Even when I reached the vermilion steps of the Palace of Heavenly Purity, Jinzhong and his men still clutched my robes and would not let go. Hardly had I reached the outer palace gate when messengers were sent again and again telling me to go back and not proceed to the Wenhua Hall. This the ministers saw with their own eyes. From the consort-attendant's actions it is plain she meant to seize control of my person and rule from behind the curtain. My late father had entrusted me to the consort-attendant's care; my food, drink, and clothing were all gifts from my grandfather and father. Yet the consort-attendant treated me with contempt and cruelty, and day and night I wept. My late father recognized his mistake and often tried to comfort me. Had I not left the palace in time, her minions would have gathered in force, and God knows what would have become of me. Having beaten the empress dowager to death, the consort-attendant knew herself guilty; she posted palace women to spy on me and forbade me to speak with the empress dowager's old attendants—any who did were seized at once. The court outside could hardly know the full measure of my suffering. Yet you ministers, forgetting the empress dowager, took the consort-attendant's side instead, spreading reckless slander until rank and justice were overturned. Where was principle? Where was law? I now withhold the consort-attendant's title and honors, to console the empress dowager's spirit in Heaven; Yet I shall provide generously for the consort-attendant and my eighth imperial sister, in dutiful fulfillment of my late father's wishes. You ministers should understand my heart in this. Afterward repeated edicts censured Jichun, and he was stripped of his official status and dismissed.
31
西 西 西
At the time Xizong had just ascended the throne and relied on Eunuch-Director Wang An of the Directorate of Ceremonies; hence these edicts took the form they did. In time Wei Zhongxian came to dominate and corrupt the government. In the fourth year the consort-attendant was ennobled as Lady of Imperial Favor Kang. In the fifth year the Three Dynasties Essentials was compiled; Yang Lian, Zuo Guangdou, and others were condemned and executed. Jichun was recalled—a far cry from the earlier edicts. Long afterward she died at last. Lady of Imperial Favor Zhuang Li was the woman known as Eastern Li. Gentle and reserved, she seldom spoke or laughed. Her rank preceded Western Li's, yet she never won comparable favor. Emperor Zhuanglie lost his mother young and was raised by Western Li. When Western Li later bore a daughter, Guangzong transferred the young prince to Eastern Li's care. In the second month of Tianqi 1 she was granted the title Lady of Imperial Favor Zhuang. Under Wei Zhongxian and Madame Ke, who resented her integrity, many of her ceremonial honors in the palace were stripped away, and she died of wounded pride. Early in the Chongzhen reign, an edict granted her younger brother Cheng Dong fields and estates.
32
西
Consort-attendant Zhao had held no title during Guangzong's reign. When Xizong ascended the throne, Zhongxian and Madame Ke, who despised her, forged an edict ordering her to take her own life. She arranged on a table the gifts Guangzong had given her, bowed westward to the Buddha, wept bitterly, and hanged herself.
33
Empress Yi'an Zhang, consort of Emperor Xizong, was from Xiangfu. Her father Guo Ji was ennobled as Marquis of Taikang when his daughter's elevation brought the family honor. In the fourth month of Tianqi 1 she was formally invested as empress. Stern and upright by nature, she often spoke to the emperor of the misconduct of Madame Ke and Wei Zhongxian. She once summoned Madame Ke, intending to hold her accountable under the law. Madame Ke and Wei Zhongxian turned on her and falsely claimed the empress was not Guo Ji's daughter, nearly swaying the emperor's belief. In the third year the empress became pregnant. Ke and Wei expelled every palace woman who was not their own and replaced them with their creatures, ultimately costing the heir his life. Once when the emperor came to the inner quarters, he found the empress reading. He asked what she was reading. She answered: "The Biography of Zhao Gao. The emperor said nothing. An anonymous placard then appeared at the palace gate denouncing Wei Zhongxian's treachery; he suspected Guo Ji and the expelled officials were behind it. His allies Shao Fuzhong and Sun Jie sought to exploit the affair to launch a sweeping prosecution, wipe out the Donglin faction, and use Guo Ji to undermine the empress, hoping ultimately to install Wei Liangqing's daughter on the throne. Liu Zhixuan, assistant prefect of Shuntian, learned of the plot and was first to impeach Guo Ji; Censor Liang Menghuan followed suit. Only when others intervened was the scheme halted. When Xizong lay dying, it was the empress who thwarted Wei Zhongxian's conspiracy and ensured the throne passed to the Prince of Xin. Emperor Zhuanglie honored her with the title Empress Yi'an. In the third month of the seventeenth year, when Li Zicheng took the capital, the empress hanged herself. In Shunzhi 1 the Shizu Emperor ordered her buried with Xizong in his mausoleum.
34
Lady of Imperial Favor Yu Zhang was a consort of Emperor Xizong. She was forthright and unyielding by nature. Madame Ke and Wei Zhongxian, resenting her independence, shut her in a separate palace and cut off her food and drink. When rain fell, she crawled to drink water from the eaves and died. There was also Lady of Imperial Favor Hui Fan, who bore Crown Prince Daohuai; when the child did not survive, she fell from favor once more. Lady of Imperial Favor Li Cheng, sharing the emperor's bed, secretly interceded for Lady Fan. Madame Ke and Wei Zhongxian learned of this and, enraged, confined Lady Li Cheng in a separate palace as well. She had hidden food under the eaves; though shut away for half a month she survived, and was demoted to the rank of palace maid. Early in the Chongzhen reign their titles were all restored.
35
Empress Min Zhou, consort of Emperor Zhuanglie, came from a Suzhou family that had moved to Daxing. During the Tianqi reign she was chosen to enter the household of the Prince of Xin. At the time Empress Zhaohui Liu of Shenzong held the empress dowager's seal; all inner-palace affairs were decided by Empress Zhang of Xizong. By custom, when the palace selected candidates for an imperial wedding, one empress was chosen with two noble ladies as attendants; if a girl was chosen, the empress dowager veiled her with a green gauze scarf and fastened a gold and jade bracelet on her arm; if she was not chosen, a slip noting the date was tucked into her sleeve and she was sent home with a gift of silver. Empress Yi'an thought the girl too slight; Empress Zhaohui said: "She may be slight now, but she will surely fill out in time. On that basis she was invested as consort of the Prince of Xin. When he ascended the throne, she was made empress.
36
殿 使使
The empress was strict and self-restrained by nature. Once, with rebels pressing hard, she said quietly: "We still have a home in the south. When the emperor pressed her, she fell silent; she had evidently been thinking of flight to the south. In other matters of government she never intervened. Consort Tian, favored and imperious, was held in check by the empress through strict observance of ritual. On New Year's Day the cold was bitter. When Consort Tian came to court, her carriage was halted beneath the corridor. The empress waited a long time before taking her seat, accepted the bow, and then immediately stepped down without another word. When Consort Yuan came to court, by contrast, they greeted each other warmly and talked at length. Consort Tian heard of this and was bitterly resentful; she wept before the emperor. Once in the Jiaotai Hall the emperor quarreled with the empress and shoved her to the floor. In her anger she refused to eat. The emperor repented and sent a palace envoy with a sable rug as a gift, asking after her health. Consort Tian was soon banished to the Qixiang Palace for some offense and went uncalled for three months. One day, while attending the emperor at the Yonghe Gate to view the flowers, the empress asked that Consort Tian be summoned. The emperor would not agree. The empress immediately sent a carriage for her, and they were reconciled as before. With rebels ravaging the realm, the emperor lived on vegetables alone. Seeing the emperor grow thinner day by day, the empress prepared a meal to bring him; just then a memorial arrived from the Lady of Ying: "I dreamed last night that Empress Dowager Xiaochun returned, spoke of the emperor's wasting away and wept, saying, 'Tell the emperor for me: do not eat too sparingly. The emperor entered the palace with the memorial just as the empress arrived with the meal.' Moved by thoughts of Xiaochun and the empress's care, he showed her the memorial; they bowed, raised their chopsticks, and wept face to face until tears brimmed over the table.
37
At dusk on the eighteenth day of the third month of the seventeenth year of Chongzhen the capital fell; weeping, the emperor told the empress: "All is lost." The empress kowtowed and said: "I have served Your Majesty eighteen years, yet you would not heed a single word of mine—and so we have come to this." She embraced the crown prince and the two princes, wept bitterly, and sent them from the palace. The emperor ordered the empress to kill herself. The empress went to her chamber and closed the door; a palace woman came out to report that the empress had received the decree. The empress died before the emperor. The emperor also ordered Consort Yuan to hang herself; the cord snapped, and after a long while she revived. The emperor drew his sword and struck her shoulder, then struck down several favored consorts; Consort Yuan alone survived. When the Shizu Zhang Emperor took the throne, she was posthumously titled Empress Zhuanglie Min and buried with the emperor in Consort Tian's mausoleum precinct, called Siling. The authorities were ordered to provide Consort Yuan with a residence and maintain her for life.
38
姿 紿 紿
When the rebels entered the palace, a palace woman surnamed Wei cried out: "We shall surely be defiled by the rebels—let those with resolve act now." She leaped into the Imperial River and died; within moments one or two hundred followed. A palace woman named Fei, sixteen years old, threw herself into a dry well. The rebels fished her out, saw her beauty, and fought over her. Fei deceived them: "I am the eldest princess." The rebels did not dare molest her and escorted her to Li Zicheng. Zicheng had palace eunuchs examine her; she was not the princess, and he gave her as a reward to a company commander named Luo. Fei deceived Luo again: "I am truly of the imperial blood; I cannot yield to force—General, choose an auspicious day for the wedding rites." Luo was delighted and set out wine for a great feast. Fei hid a sharp blade; when Luo was drunk she cut his throat and killed him instantly. She said to herself: "I, a weak woman, have killed one rebel chieftain—that is enough." She then cut her own throat and died. Zicheng, hearing of it, was greatly shocked and ordered her properly buried.
39
西 輿
Imperial Noble Consort Gongshu Tian came from Shaanxi; the empress's family was from Yangzhou. Her father Hongyu, elevated by his daughter's rank to Left Chief Commander, loved dissolute pleasures and was known as a swaggering rake. She was born slender and beautiful, quiet by nature, accomplished in many arts, and served the Chongzhen Emperor when he was Prince of Xin. In the first year of Chongzhen she was made Li consort and then promoted to imperial noble consort. The palace had covered passages; in summer when the emperor traveled in his carriage, the imperial canopy still passed through the midday sun. She ordered rush matting spread overhead so that all who followed could rest in the shade. She also replaced the junior eunuchs who carried the sedan with palace women. The emperor heard of this and judged her observant of propriety. Once, for some offense, she was sent to a separate palace to reflect on her faults. The fifth imperial son she bore died in the separate palace, and she fell ill. She died in the seventh month of the fifteenth year. She received the posthumous title Imperial Noble Consort Gongshu Duanhui Jinghuai and was buried at Tianshou Mountain in Changping—the site of Siling.
40
The eulogy reads: Empress Gao followed the Founding Emperor through every hardship, helped bring the great enterprise to completion, set the maternal standard for the realm, and her benevolence shone forth. Empress Wen followed—benevolent, filial, generous, and harmonious; her influence transformed the inner palace, and later generations inherited her example, so that domestic governance was solemn and orderly. Commentators hold that Ming domestic discipline far surpassed Han and Tang—it was no empty boast. The noble consorts Wan and Zheng likewise plotted no dark schemes and meddled not in succession politics; they merely, through excessive favor, drew slander upon themselves. The Book of Changes says: "Regulate the household, and remorse disappears." Overstep those bounds, and remorse will come too late. How far-reaching the sage's warning!
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →