← Back to 明史

卷二百一十 列傳第九十八 桑喬 謝瑜 何維柏 徐學詩 厲汝進 王宗茂 周冕 趙錦 吳時來 張翀 董傳策 鄒應龍 林潤

Volume 210 Biographies 98: Sang Qiao, Xie Yu, He Weibai, Xu Xueshi, Li Rujin, Wang Zongmao, Zhou Mian, Zhao Jin, Wu Shilai, Zhang Chong, Dong Chuance, Zou Yinglong, Lin Run

Chapter 210 of 明史 · History of Ming
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 210
Next Chapter →
1
Sang Qiao (Hu Rulin)〉 Xie Yu (Wang Ye, Yi Minsheng, Tong Hanchen, and others)〉 He Weibai and Xu Xueshi (Ye Jing and Chen Shao)〉 Li Rujin (Zha Bingyi and others)〉 Wang Zongmao, Zhou Mian, Zhao Jin, Wu Shilai, Zhang Chong, Dong Chuance, and Zou Yinglong (Zhang Song)〉 Lin Run
2
西
Sang Qiao, styled Zimu, came from Jiangdu. He passed the jinshi examination in the eleventh year of the Jiajing reign. In the winter of the fourteenth year he was transferred from department director to censor and sent to inspect Shanxi. The regions under his jurisdiction were repeatedly ravaged by bandits; Qiao memorialized asking that corvée levies be remitted entirely and the families of the dead generously relieved. Regional Commander Ye Zong and others led ten thousand men to Jingjiazhuang, walked into an enemy ambush, and were routed; the bandits then pushed deep into the interior. Tiancheng and Yanghe suffered five bandit raids within two months. Grand Coordinator Fan Jizu, supreme commander Lu Gang, and their subordinates were all impeached by Qiao; Vice Commander Li Mao and Zong and six others were arrested and punished together.
3
殿 輿 退
In the summer of the sixteenth year lightning struck the Hall of Cultivation, and the throne issued an edict calling for remonstrance. Qiao and his colleagues memorialized on three matters, noting briefly that construction of the two palaces and the imperial tombs involved much embezzlement; the Jinang were running rampant and border defenses had long been neglected. At the end he said: "Your Majesty, meeting this calamity, became fearful and issued an edict for self-examination. Self-examination lies in human affairs alone, and among human affairs nothing surpasses choosing officials. Ministers Yan Song, Lin Tingzhen, Zhang Zan, and Zhang Yun all fail the state's grace above and betray public expectation below; these portents have come because of them. When the memorial was submitted, all four men asked to be dismissed. An edict ordered Tingzhen and Yun to retire while Song and Zan were kept in office as before. Song memorialized again in his own defense and also vilified those who had spoken out. Supervising Secretary Hu Rulin said: "When a great minister is impeached, he should admit guilt and seek withdrawal—that is all. Song bears a foul record and invites public censure, yet he vaunts his words in memorials of defense and secretly undermines remonstrating officials—he lacks the bearing of a great minister. The Emperor issued an edict of admonition along the lines Rulin had indicated. At that time Song had been Minister for only half a year and was still cultivating connections and burnishing his reputation to advance; the whole court still did not know his treachery—Qiao alone was the first to expose it.
4
Soon afterward Qiao inspected the capital region and cited illness. Censor-in-Chief Wang Tingxiang impeached him for evading duty, and Song thereupon framed charges against him. He was arrested and sent to the imperial prison, beaten at court, and exiled to garrison duty at Jiujiang. After twenty-six years in exile he died. At the beginning of the Longqing reign, posthumous honors and relief were granted according to regulation.
5
綿 調
Hu Rulin came from Mianzhou. From Hanlin bachelor he was appointed supervising secretary in the Secretariat of the Ministry of Revenue. In the fourth month of the twentieth year the nine ancestral temples burned. Together with his colleague Nie Jing and Censor Li Chengyun he impeached twenty-six civil and military great ministers for sluggish firefighting, Song among them. The Emperor was angry that the impeachments were incomplete and had them all sent to the imperial prison for investigation; all were demoted one grade and transferred outside the capital. Rulin was assigned as registrar of Taiping Prefecture. After his demotion he asked to be released from any quarrel with Song and instead attached himself to him for advancement. He rose through repeated promotions to Right Vice Censor-in-Chief and Grand Coordinator of Gansu. When Song fell, he was stripped of office as a member of Song's faction.
6
Xie Yu, styled Ruqing, came from Shangyu. He passed the jinshi examination in the eleventh year of the Jiajing reign. He was transferred from Nanjing censor to the northern capital. In the first month of the nineteenth year Minister of Rites Yan Song, having been repeatedly impeached and asked to resign, was comforted and kept in office by the Emperor. Yu said: "Song dresses up empty words, deceives his sovereign above, and muzzles remonstrating officials below. Moreover he cites the Bright Hall rites and the magnificent southern tour as his defense, yet says that among the officials none truly serves Your Majesty—he means to provoke the sage ruler's anger. His treachery is plain to see. The Emperor kept the memorial and did not act on it. Song memorialized in his defense and added: "Yu has attacked your minister without cease, wishing to contend with the court for victory." The Emperor thereupon sharply rebuked Yu while comforting and reassuring Song to an extraordinary degree. Two years later Song was at last made chief minister.
7
使
Just over a month later Yu memorialized: "Under the Martial Ancestor's court there was roaming dissipation and pleasure; the borders were liable to break down but had not yet broken down severely. Now, under a sage and brilliant sovereign, the borders ought to be secure yet have instead collapsed—great ministers do not plan loyally for the state, and Your Majesty has erred in whom you appoint. Ever since Zhang Zan became head of the central military administration, though he holds command of troops the realm has no troops, and though he chooses generals the realm has no generals. Some say Zan's imposing stature is enough to make him a general of good fortune. If the border alarms truly did not rise and the realm were tranquil, one might call that fortune. Now Zan has no merit yet enfeoffment favors are repeatedly added; when guilty he is not stripped of rank—this fortune is fortune for him alone, not fortune for army and state. In antiquity Shun executed the Four Malefactors and was called sage for ten thousand generations. Now Zan, Guo Xun, Yan Song, and Hu Shouzhong are the Four Malefactors of this sage age. Within a fortnight Your Majesty has already executed two of them and all under heaven calls you sage—why not deal with these two malefactors as well, banishing or exiling them, to complete the achievement of Emperor Shun? Grand Secretary Zhai Luan was raised from disgrace and entrusted with touring the borders, yet he wandered at leisure in elaborate display, lavishly consuming provisions and funds. Those who gave lavish gifts he deemed talented; those who presented licentious music he deemed reverent—so border troops grew leaner and border defenses slackened further. To tour the borders in this fashion—of what use is he! Therefore without clarifying the root of government, the realm will surely fall into disorder. Without changing the head of military affairs, military achievement will surely not be achieved."
8
When the memorial was submitted, it was kept and not acted upon. Song again memorialized in defense; the Emperor comforted him still more and Yu was rebuked again. Yet at this time, though the Emperor inclined toward Song, he had not yet deeply punished those who spoke out; Song too, having just gained power, did not dare openly entrap them, so Yu remained in office as before. Before long, on a pretext in another matter his rank was reduced. Three years later, at the great evaluation, Song secretly urged the presiding official to dismiss him. When the memorial went up, the order was to remove his name under the precedent for the greedy and cruel; Yu was cast aside and ended his life at home.
9
When Yu had first been censor, Marquis of Wuding Guo Xun presented views on current affairs, denouncing great and small officials as unfit for office and asking that eunuch ambassadors again be sent to garrison and hold command. An edict approved this. Yu submitted a memorial in opposition: "What Xun discussed in various matters was shadowy and vague, yet in restoring garrison commands his underlying intention is clear. Xun maintains relations with inner eunuchs, acting on their behalf in pursuit of office, looking to heavy bribes on another day. He also said: 'Officials are greedy and corrupt because Your Majesty has no trusted eyes and ears in the four quarters.' And he said: 'When civil and military officials harbor treachery and shirk affairs, permit inner eunuchs to impeach them, and treacherous corruption will cease of itself.' If Xun's words were true, then never were inner eunuchs so powerful as under the Zhengde reign—was that an age of supreme peace and perfect governance? Your Majesty abolished garrison eunuchs—a truly sage and enlightened policy—yet Xun slandered it as partial favoritism. Of the hundred officials at court, who is not the Son of Heaven's eyes and ears? Yet Xun slandered them as unfit for office. He wishes Your Majesty wholly to distrust the scholar-officials of the realm and rely on eunuchs alone as trusted eyes and ears—I do not know what sort of sovereign Xun takes Your Majesty to be? Supervising Secretary Zhu Longxi also spoke to this effect, and Xun's memorial was then shelved. Yu, at the beginning of the Longqing reign, had his office restored and was posthumously made Vice Minister of the Court of the Imperial Stud.
10
西
Wang Ye, styled Taomeng, came from Jintan. He passed the jinshi examination in the fourteenth year of the Jiajing reign. Appointed magistrate of Ji'an, he was summoned and appointed supervising secretary in the Secretariat of the Ministry of Personnel at Nanjing. In the ninth month of the twentieth year he and his colleagues memorialized: "Outer bandits run riot; head of military affairs Zhang Zan, supervising minister Fan Jizu, and newly transferred Vice Minister Fei Cai are unfit to bear heavy trust." The Emperor referred their memorial to the responsible offices. Two months later they again impeached Zan, and also Minister of Rites Yan Song, supervising Vice Minister Hu Shouzhong, and their collusion with the great villain Guo Xun. The mansion in which Yan Song lived had been built for him by Guo Xun's private agents. A month later, censors Yi Minsheng, Zheng Yun, and Chen Ce likewise reported that Yan Song's residence was the house formerly occupied by Sun Yun, a retainer of Guo Xun; since Yun's property had been confiscated, Song's mansion should have been included in the forfeited estate. The Emperor was enraged and stripped one rank of salary from Minsheng and the others. Yan Song went unprosecuted, yet Hu Shouzhong was ultimately punished on account of Wang Ye's memorial. The following autumn, Yan Song entered the Grand Secretariat. Chief supervising secretary in the Secretariat of the Ministry of Personnel Shen Liangcai, censor Yu Shi, and others submitted a stream of memorials impeaching Yan Song. A month later, the memorial of Shanxi surveillance commissioner Tong Hanchen reached the throne. Another month later, memorials from Wang Ye, his colleague Chen Kan, censor Chen Shao, and others also arrived. All alike charged Yan Song with treachery and greed; Ye's memorial also named Song's son Shifan, and its language was especially cutting, yet the Emperor paid no heed to any of them. Yan Song nursed a deep grudge but as yet had no way to bring him down. Long afterward he was appointed assistant commissioner in Shandong; while proceeding to the capital with his credentials he fell ill en route and arrived late, whereupon Yan Song stripped him of his post. While Wang Ye served at the Censorate he had once impeached and removed thirty-nine regional officials, and his reputation for moral courage was widely known. When he returned home his dwelling was bare and destitute; he died a few years later.
11
Yi Minsheng came from Shangyuan. Zheng Yun and Chen Ce were both from Putian. Minsheng rose to become administrative commissioner of Shandong. Chen Ce ended his career as prefect of Taizhou. Zheng Yun ended his career as a censor.
12
調
Shen Liangcai came from Taizhou. He began as a Hanlin bachelor and rose through the ranks to Vice Minister of War. In the triennial evaluation of the thirty-sixth year he filed a self-report; though already transferred to Nanjing, Yan Song appended a note to the Nanjing censorate's memorial on official omissions and had him removed from office. Yu Shi came from Guangshan. He rose to become Vice Minister of War at Nanjing.
13
西 西使
Tong Hanchen came from Qiantang. He advanced from magistrate of Wei County to censor. When raiders made a major incursion into Xuanda and Datong, grand coordinator Fan Jizu and others concealed their defeats and three times reported victories. Hanchen and others impeached them and themselves were punished. While inspecting Shanxi he directed the generals to repel Altan's forces as they pressed Taiyuan; he was at the same time impeaching Yan Song, which provoked Song's wrath. The following year Hanchen and grand coordinator Li Jue jointly verified and memorialized the failures of Fan Jizu and his colleagues. The memorial was referred to the Ministry of Personnel. Hanchen had earlier impeached Yan Song and also impeached Minister of Personnel Xu Zan, who likewise bore a grudge against Hanchen. He therefore argued that Hanchen's impeachment had been unduly delayed and that both charges should be adjudicated together. Yan Song then drafted the rescript reducing Li Jue by one rank while keeping him in post, and demoting Hanchen to director-general of affairs in the Huguang Provincial Administration Commission. The whole court knew Hanchen had been brought down by Yan Song, yet no one could save him. Long afterward he was appointed prefect of Quanzhou. When pirate raiders pressed the city, he earned merit in its defense. He ended his career as vice commissioner in Jiangxi.
14
Chen Kan came from Yuyao. He was later dismissed by Yan Song.
15
殿 便殿 調
He Weibai, styled Qiaozhong, came from Nanhai. He passed the jinshi examination in the fourteenth year of the Jiajing reign. Selected as a Hanlin bachelor, he was appointed censor. When thunder shook the Jinshen Hall, Weibai said the empire was exhausted, displacement was everywhere, yet the responsible offices still discussed raising taxes; unless the people turned to banditry, the disorder would not cease. He therefore asked to halt construction of the Shahe traveling palace and the Jinshan Merit Temple, and the punitive campaign against Annan. The Emperor largely approved and accepted his advice. Soon afterward he cited illness and returned home. Long afterward he was recalled to serve as surveillance commissioner of Fujian. In the fifth month of the twenty-fourth year he memorialized impeaching Grand Secretary Yan Song for treachery and greed, comparing him to Li Linfu and Lu Qi. He also said Song had promoted Gu Kexue and Sheng Duanming to prepare elixir prescriptions, using wicked flattery to win imperial favor. The Emperor was greatly enraged and sent officials to arrest and try him. Officials and commoners blocked the road in tears, yet Weibai's bearing remained as composed as ever. He was sent to the imperial prison, beaten at court, and struck from the rolls. He lived at home for more than twenty years. At the beginning of the Longqing reign he was summoned back to office and promoted to Vice Minister of the Court of Revision. He was promoted to Left Vice Censor-in-Chief. He memorialized asking that the Emperor hold daily audience in the convenient hall, summon the chief ministers to deliberate on state affairs, and select talented and virtuous ministers to rotate in attendance with the Confucian lecturers on duty. In palace leisure he urged careful selection of prudent, solid eunuchs to attend the imperial person, so that recreation had fixed limits and imperial outings were restrained. Except in deep winter or bitter cold, court lectures should not be suspended. The court acknowledged his memorial. He was promoted to Left Assistant Censor-in-Chief. Upon his mother's death he returned home to observe mourning. At the beginning of the Wanli reign he returned to court. He served as Left and Right Vice Minister of Personnel and spoke at length on the evils of selling offices. When censor Liu Tai impeached Grand Secretary Zhang Juzheng and Juzheng asked to resign, Weibai led the nine ministers in urging that he remain in office. When Juzheng entered mourning for his father, an edict ordered the Ministry of Personnel to instruct him to remain at his post. Minister Zhang Han consulted Weibai; Weibai replied, "Heaven's constant and earth's righteousness—how can they be set aside? Zhang Han followed his counsel and desisted. Juzheng was enraged, obtained a rescript dismissing Zhang Han, and suspended Weibai's salary for three months. He was soon sent out as Minister of Rites at Nanjing. In the triennial evaluation he filed a self-report; Juzheng had him dismissed from behind the scenes. After his death he was given the posthumous title Duangong.
16
退
Xu Xueshi, styled Yiyan, came from Shangyu. He passed the jinshi examination in the twenty-third year of the Jiajing reign. He was appointed a director in the Ministry of Justice and rose to department director. In the twenty-ninth year Altan pressed the capital. After the enemy withdrew, an edict ordered court ministers to present policies for dealing with the enemy. Many ministers offered only petty measures in reply. Xueshi said in anger, "A great villain holds the state—that is the root of disorder. If the root of disorder is not removed, how can outer threats be repelled? He immediately submitted a memorial stating:
17
使使
Grand Secretary Yan Song has directed government for ten years; his treachery and greed are extreme. Inwardly he bonds with the powerful and noble; outwardly he bands with petty men. Civil and military appointments and dismissals are mostly bought with heavy bribes, driving his followers to squeeze the army and the people and breed border troubles. With state affairs at such a pass, he still dares wrongly to cite the saying that fine weapons are inauspicious, so as to deceive the Emperor's inquiry. Recently, when the capital was threatened, he secretly shipped wealth and bribes south. Several dozen large carts and more than ten tower ships filled the roads by land and water, shocking all who saw them. He also took two thousand taels from Li Fengming, a regional commander stripped of office, to let him garrison Jizhou, and three thousand taels from Guo Cong, an old dismissed regional commander, to let him supervise grain transport. Cases like these are too numerous to recount in full. The whole court seethed with indignation, yet not one man dared openly to defy him—truly because court and provinces were entangled, superiors and subordinates colluded, and long accumulation had made his power unassailable. Moreover his son Shifan is fierce and cunning by nature and usurps his father's authority. Whatever memorial any office submits must first be cleared with father and son before it dare reach Your Majesty. How can Your Majesty fully know any of it?
18
便
Yan Song's power is enough to use others' hands to strike down his foes; his schemes are enough to strike first and control others; his influence is enough to weave alliances and entrench himself; his glib prose is enough to cover crimes and gloss over wrongs. His sharp vigilance and agility are enough to seize advantage and evade harm. Papering over faults, private deals and secret favors, pleasing looks and oily speech are also enough to win men's hearts and silence their tongues. Therefore those who criticized Yan Song before and after—though he could not openly ruin them when they spoke plainly—none failed to be struck down secretly through contrived charges at the moments of transfer and triennial evaluation. Such as the former supervising secretaries Wang Ye and Chen Kan, censors Xie Yu and Tong Hanchen, and the like—at the time they too were spared; where are they now? If Your Majesty truly dismisses the Song father and son and separately appoints loyal and capable men in their place, outer troubles will naturally be pacified.
19
The Emperor, reading the memorial, was somewhat moved. The Daoist adept Tao Zhongwen secretly told the Emperor that Yan Song stood alone in utter loyalty, and that Xu Xueshi had merely nursed a private grudge and manufactured a quarrel. The Emperor thereupon flew into a rage and had him sent to the imperial prison. Yan Song, ill at ease, asked to resign; the Emperor issued a gracious edict to comfort and reassure him. Yan Song submitted a memorial of thanks, feigning to ask that Yan Shifan be allowed to retire to his native place; the Emperor would not allow that either. Xu Xueshi was in the end struck from the rolls. Those who had first impeached Yan Song—Ye Jing, Xie Yu, and Chen Shao—were all from the same district as Xu Xueshi; contemporaries called them the "Four Remonstrators of Shangyu." At the beginning of the Longqing reign Xu Xueshi was recalled as vice director of the Nanjing Transmission Office. Before he could take up the post, he died. He was posthumously granted the title Vice Minister of the Court of Revision.
20
殿
Earlier, Xu Xueshi's elder clansman Yingfeng had been promoted to Secretariat Drafter for his skill in calligraphy and served in the Hall of Unceasing Ease—all through Yan Song's patronage. Yan Song suspected Xu Xueshi's memorial had been prompted by Yingfeng; when the triennial evaluation came, he had the Ministry of Personnel dismiss him. Yingfeng went to the Yinghe Gate to bid farewell; a special edict kept him in office, and Yan Song's rage grew worse still. Several years later, for a mistaken transcription in a roster document he slandered him to the Emperor and in the end had him beaten to death at court.
21
Chen Shao ended his career as prefect of Shaozhou.
22
祿使祿使 西
Li Rujin, style Zixiu, was a native of Luanzhou. He passed the jinshi examination in the eleventh year of Jiajing. He was appointed investigating magistrate of Chizhou, then summoned to serve as supervising secretary in the Secretariat of the Ministry of Personnel. Lu Jie, grand coordinator of Huguang, was recalled to the Ministry of Works as a director and the like once the Xian Mausoleum works were completed. Rujin argued that Jie had long offended public opinion and ought not assist the Minister of Works, and jointly impeached Ministers Gan Weilin and Fan Jizu for neglect of duty. The memorial was not accepted. After three promotions he rose to chief supervising secretary in the Secretariat of the Ministry of Revenue. When Minister of Revenue Wang Gao was imprisoned, Rujin and his colleagues Zha Bingyi of Haining, Xu Yangzheng of Maping, Liu Qizong of Baxian, and Liu Lu of Zhangqiu jointly memorialized: "The Vice Commissioner of the Two Huai, Zhang Lu, sent envoys to the capital and widely cultivated connections and patronage. Men such as Vice Minister of Rites Yan Shifan and Assistant Intendant Hu Kui all took bribes and accepted private entreaties, and there is proof. Yan Shifan usurped his father's authority and was insatiably gluttonous for bribes. The memorial also implicated Granary Commissioner Wang Hui. Yan Song submitted a memorial in his own defense and also sought help from palace eunuchs to inflame the Emperor's wrath. The Emperor rebuked them for speaking on Wang Gao's behalf, ordered Rujin beaten eighty strokes at court and the others sixty, and banished them all to clerkships in Yunnan and Guangxi. The following year Yan Song again used the triennial evaluation as a pretext and stripped Rujin of his office. At the beginning of the Longqing reign he was restored to his former office. Before he reached the capital, he died.
23
Zha Bingyi rose from investigating magistrate of Huangzhou to left supervising secretary in the Secretariat of the Ministry of Revenue. He repeatedly offered forthright counsel on affairs of the day. He ended his career as prefect of Shuntian. Xu Yangzheng advanced from Hanlin Bachelor through right supervising secretary in the Secretariat of the Ministry of Revenue. During the Longqing reign he rose to Minister of Works at Nanjing.
24
祿
Liu Qizong was first appointed investigating magistrate of Quzhou. He was summoned to serve as supervising secretary in the Secretariat of the Ministry of Revenue. When Yan-sui was on the verge of famine, he requested treasury funds for relief. He ended as director of the Liaodong Stud Farms. Liu Lu was promoted from the Messenger Office to supervising secretary in the Secretariat of the Ministry of Revenue. After his banishment he resigned of his own accord and returned home.
25
使
Wang Zongmao, style Shiyu, was a native of Jingshan. His father Qiao had served as Provincial Administration Commissioner of Guangdong. His uncle Ge had served as Minister of the Imperial Stud. Zongmao passed the jinshi examination in the twenty-sixth year of Jiajing and was appointed Messenger. In the thirty-first year he was promoted to censor at Nanjing. At that time everyone who impeached Yan Song, sooner or later, met disaster; Shen Lian was even banished to farm as a tenant at Bao'an. Inside and outside the court men feared his power and clamped their mouths tighter still. Zongmao had long nursed indignation; scarcely three months after taking office he submitted a memorial saying:
26
Yan Song is by nature a sycophant, scant in integrity and thin in shame. He has long held the reins of state, wielding blessings and terrors as he pleases. From every corner of the realm within the seas, none fail to resent him. Whenever the Ministries of Personnel and War make selections, he requests twenty appointments on his behalf; each man pays a bribe of several hundred taels and may choose his own desirable post. Thus civil officials, military officers, and generals all issue from his gate. This is Yan Song's first crime against the state.
27
He appointed his private creature Wan Cai as Director of Merits. Whenever an outside official was transferred or promoted, conduct and ability went unexamined and seniority uncounted—only bribes mattered. Thus upright men could not be put to the state's service. This is Yan Song's second crime against the state.
28
In past years, when men impeached him, he secretly shipped his household wealth south; cartloads of treasure were beyond counting. Gold, silver, and human figures—many stood two or three chi high. Even down to chamber pots, these too were made of gold and silver. Does Your Majesty's palace also possess such vessels? This is Yan Song's third crime against the state.
29
西
He has planted fertile fields across several commanderies of Jiangxi. Behind his mansion he piled stone into a great vault and filled it with gold, silver, and precious curios, laying up wealth for his descendants for a hundred generations. Yet state accounts and the people's suffering he does not heed in the least. This is Yan Song's fourth crime against the state.
30
He keeps more than five hundred household slaves, coming and going through the capital lodges. Wherever they went they harassed relay stations and abused residents; local officials all seethed with anger yet dared not speak. This is Yan Song's fifth crime against the state.
31
Your Majesty's table from the Grand Steward's kitchen numbers scarcely a few dishes, yet Yan Song exhausts every rare delicacy. Exotic products from distant regions—none fail to reach his table. Thus the nine regions and ten thousand states serve Yan Song more lavishly than they serve Your Majesty. This is Yan Song's sixth crime against the state.
32
When in past years raiders pressed on the capital region—just when court and country were gripped by fear—Yan Song's greed and license grew worse still. Folk songs and ballads spread through the capital and reached the desert. The people within the seas all pray Heaven for his early death, yet Yan Song remains complacent and knows no limit. This is Yan Song's seventh crime against the state.
33
He recruited more than thirty court gentlemen as sworn sons and godsons. Men such as Yin Geng and Liang Shaoru had long since been exposed. These men are robbers in official dress, yet all serve as his claws and teeth, fanning his cruelty, so that the court's grace and wrath no longer issue from Your Majesty. This is Yan Song's eighth crime against the state.
34
What the realm relies on for peace is wealth and arms. When incompetent civil clerks leave his gate through bribes, they must strip the people—from a hundred they seek a thousand, from a thousand they seek ten thousand; how can the people not be ruined? When incompetent military officers leave his gate through bribes, they must bite into army rations—sometimes leaving ranks unfilled, sometimes missing pay days; how can the troops not be exhausted? Recently earthquakes have shaken the four quarters—the omen reads as subordinates monopolizing power. Ask today who monopolizes power—can any exceed Yan Song? Your Majesty's treasury can scarcely supply the borders for one year, yet Yan Song's hoard could fill the stores for several years. Rather than open orders to sell offices and peddle ranks to aid the borders, why not remove this vermin that harms state and people, confiscate his household property, and ease the distress? In recent years, Your servant has seen, all who criticized Yan Song either died under the court rod or were sent to border garrisons. Your servant too has family and life—would he not cherish them?—yet he dares provoke the wrath of the throne and touch the blade of the power-holding minister? It is only that Your servant has received the state's grace generation after generation and cannot bear to see the ancestral realm ruined by the thief Yan Song.
35
When the memorial arrived, Zhao Wenhua of the Transmission Office secretly showed it to Yan Song; it was held several days before being forwarded, and thus Yan Song was able to prepare his ground beforehand. Thereupon, on the charge of slandering a great minister, he was banished to assistant magistrate of Pingyang County.
36
祿
When Zongmao submitted his memorial, he was certain he would die. When he was merely demoted, he left the capital calmly. Half a year after taking up his post, he returned home to mourn his mother. Yan Song, unable to vent his rancor, stripped Zongmao's father Qiao of office. Qiao in the end died of indignant distress. On the day Yan Song was dismissed from the chancellorship, Zongmao also died. At the opening of the Longqing reign he was posthumously granted the rank of Vice Director of the Directorate for Imperial Sacrifices.
37
Zhou Mian was a native of Zixian County. He received his jinshi degree in the twentieth year of Jiajing. He was appointed an erudite of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices, then promoted to probationary censor on the Guizhou circuit. When the rebuilt Imperial Ancestral Temple was finished and the spirit tablets were enshrined, the Emperor intended to send officials to sacrifice in his place. The censor Yan Maoqing argued that this should not be allowed. The Emperor grew angry and issued a handwritten edict of several hundred words to admonish the court, adding that anyone else who colluded with the throne for reputation would be punished without mercy. The whole court trembled and none dared speak again, but Mian alone submitted a defiant memorial disputing the policy. The Emperor was furious and at once had Mian cast into the imperial prison and flogged. In the end, because his words were forthright, he was released and restored to his post. At that time the heir apparent had lived eleven years, yet still had not been brought out of the palace to receive instruction. Mian urgently argued that the heir's education could not be delayed, begging for an early imperial edict and careful selection of attendants. The Emperor was enraged again and demoted him to clerk of Tonghai County in Yunnan. Though banished far from court, Mian remained generous in spirit and unbowed.
38
After several promotions he rose to director in the Bureau of Military Appointments. Yang Jisheng impeached Yan Song and the affair of Yan Xiaozhong's fraudulent merit, and his language also touched Ouyang Bijin. Bijin memorialized in defense, and the memorial was referred to the Ministry of War. Mian memorialized:
39
Obeying Your Majesty's command, your servant has examined the twenty-seventh-year report from the Office of Transmission: Xiaozhong was sixteen, and having failed the military metropolitan examination he petitioned the military headquarters of the two Guang provinces for service. Soon after, Bijin and regional commander Chen Gui reported that the Li rebels had been pacified and sent Xiaozhong to announce victory; he was granted the post of acting battalion commander in the Embroidered-Uniform Guard. Within a month Yan Hu claimed that his elder brother Xiaozhong had once taken seven heads and that the combined merit entitled him to an acting vice battalion commandership. Now Xiaozhong suffers a chronic illness, and Hu asks to hold the post in his place. Your servant suspected fraud and was about to verify the facts before reporting. Song's son Shifan then composed a draft himself and handed it to your servant, directing him to answer evasively. Your servant examined the draft and found it for the most part absurd, reckless, and contradictory, and asks leave to refute it point by point.
40
If Xiaozhong had passed the military provincial examination, why was there at first no dispatch document from his native registry, and why is he now called a commoner with no mention of that examination? If Xiaozhong were truly Hu's elder brother and Shifan's son, then all of Shifan's sons were still young and none bore the name Xiaozhong. If Xiaozhong had truly taken seven heads, the report at the time said he was only sixteen—how could he have gone into battle? Why had none of the commanders at headquarters reported such captures, while the chief minister's grandson alone was called the bravest in the three armies? If Xiaozhong faced the enemy and wounded shins and arms, the time from battle to reassignment was less than a month—how could news from armies ten thousand li away have arrived so fast? If Xiaozhong came to the capital because his wounds were grave, why on the day Hu asked to replace him did he report only that he could not take the post? If Xiaozhong's command should be handed on, the victory report covered only him personally, and by precedent there was no hereditary succession. If his merit should be counted together, precedent required a memorial of request first—why rely only on the transmission report and compel the responsible official to obey?
41
使
Your servant has investigated thoroughly: at first no one named Xiaozhong went to headquarters for service, and Hu is not Xiaozhong's true younger brother. The name was invented, the heads were purchased, and there was not the slightest truth in it. Bijin was Song's fellow townsman and Gui was related to Shifan by marriage; they fawned on one another and together practiced deceit. If your servant did not speak, how would Your Majesty learn of their treachery? Moreover, since antiquity within the dynasty, no chief minister's son or grandson has been sent to a military headquarters to serve. Now Song not only petitioned to send men to headquarters but invented false names and broke the ancestral institutions—can Jiang Yingkui, Tang Guoxiang, and their like be blamed for imitating him? Your servant's office is directly concerned and duty forbids concealment; I beg special investigation and correction, so that all under Heaven may know clearly that the court has merit that cannot be seized by fortune and laws that cannot be broken. Though your servant should offend and die for it, he would have no regret.
42
When the memorial was submitted, his forthright voice shook the court. Song and his son were greatly afraid and worked hard to smooth matters over. The Emperor accused Mian of retaliation, cast him into the imperial prison for torture, and reduced him to commoner status. After Mian had been punished, the minister still memorialized in reply as Shifan directed. At the opening of Longqing, when straight-speaking ministers of the previous reign were honored, Mian was recalled as Vice Minister of the Court of the Imperial Stud. He was overtaken by mourning for his mother, had not assumed the post, and died.
43
Zhao Jin, whose style was Yuanpu, was a native of Yuyao. He received his jinshi degree in the twenty-third year of Jiajing. He was appointed magistrate of Jiangyin, then summoned to serve as a Nanjing censor. When there was alarm on the rivers and seas, officials proposed establishing a regional commander at Zhenjiang. Jin said: "Petty raiders do not warrant deploying heavy forces." The Emperor then dropped the plan. Soon after he memorialized: "For several hundred li across Huai and Yan the people mostly hire themselves out as laborers; I beg that rents and corvée be eased and that court ministers be appointed to oversee local officials in their relief." The request was approved. When campaigns began, people who paid grain and horses could receive posts in the Embroidered-Uniform Guard; Jin urgently argued that this should not be permitted. He was soon sent to inspect troops in Yunnan.
44
On New Year's Day of the thirty-second year there was a solar eclipse. Jin took it as Heaven's response to powerful traitors corrupting government and hurriedly memorialized impeaching Yan Song's crimes. The gist read:
45
Your servant observes a solar eclipse on New Year's Day—an omen most extraordinary. Moreover Shandong, Xu, and Huai have suffered great floods year after year, earthquakes have been frequent everywhere, and calamities do not arise without cause. Formerly the founding Emperor Taizu abolished the chancellorship and dispersed its powers among the ministries, with foresight for later ages most profound. Today's Grand Secretariat bears no title of chancellor yet holds its substance—this was not the founding Emperor's intent. Not long ago Xia Yan, greedy and violent by nature, acted arrogantly within it. Now Grand Secretary Song, another villainous flatterer, has succeeded him, relying on favor to swell his power, stealing authority and indulging his desires; nothing great or small escapes his sole decision. Whoever opposed him was surely struck down; the hundred offices looked to the wind and trembled. Affairs of the realm were not first heard at court but first heard in the Grand Secretariat. Officials who came to report waited in ranks at his gate; bribes requested as gifts piled in rolls within his chambers. Dismissals and promotions in the Bureau of Personnel, appointments and removals in the Ministry of War—all followed his will. Border commanders who failed in duty mostly stripped military funds to bribe Song's household; without merit one could still be rewarded, and with guilt one could escape punishment. Even enfeoffments for imperial clansmen and meritorious kin, and posthumous honors for great civil and military ministers—their delay, grant, or denial all turned on the thickness of bribes. Even men who curried favor and pressed for advancement debased themselves without shame. Their titles were unfitting and integrity was swept away—there are things your servant cannot bear to recount.
46
稿 使 使
Your Majesty, Heaven-granted in sacred intelligence, holds the regnet alone and believes that grant and denial rest with the throne, memorial replies with the ministries, and that Grand Secretaries merely draft edicts for imperial approval. The ministries' memorial drafts all take orders from Song—how would Your Majesty know of them? Now Yan is punished while Song spreads his evil: Yan was violent and shallow, his evil easy to see; Song is soft, flattering, and deep in scheming, his evil hard to discern. Song watches for chances to ingratiate himself, seeming loyal and diligent; his fawning and sidelong flattery seem respectful and obedient. He plants private men in key posts, spies on every official's movements, and strikes first to control them—so few of his deeds are exposed. He lavishes bribes on those close to Your Majesty; whatever Your Majesty's movements and intentions may be, he learns them first, and so much accords with Your pleasure. Sometimes he watches what the sacred mind favors and acts accordingly to serve his private ends; sometimes he seizes what the occasion affords and stirs it up to unleash his malice. If Your Majesty reflects on it, the origin seems to arise from court; if all under Heaven points to it, the affair does not seem to come from the Grand Secretariat. If Your Majesty penetrates it in the sacred mind, the ministries bear Song's punishment in his stead; if unhappily it passes to later generations, Your Majesty bears Song's guilt in his stead. Does Your Majesty truly regard Song as worthy? Since Song entered government, he has repaid only favors and grudges and gathered only bribes and goods. Officials fear the disaster of secret strikes, and loyal words dare not be spoken plainly; the four quarters learn corruption, and the lanes and alleys grow more wretched day by day.
47
Recently, since the gengxu year, outer enemies have grown rampant. Your Majesty once recruited the realm's brave to fill the armies, exhausted the realm's wealth to pay rations, searched out hidden talent to appoint generals, granted extraordinary rewards, and exercised immeasurable authority to admonish within and without. Yet among border officials there has finally been none to ease Your Majesty's worries that keep you sleepless till dawn. This is because powerful ministers act for private ends, officers and troops follow the fashion, taking extortion as their task and factional striving as their skill. It has brought it about that above the court, the unworthy are employed and the worthy are passed over; rewards do not match merit and punishments do not match crimes. If Your Majesty wishes to attain great peace, then the hundred officials are insufficient to bear virtue at your side; if you wish to check barbarian raiders, then officers and troops are insufficient to repel insult at the borders. Resources are already exhausted, yet outer calamity has not yet reached its end; The people are exhausted past endurance, and there is fear that internal upheaval may be about to erupt. Your Majesty embodies supreme sagacity and has toiled over the myriad affairs of state without rest for thirty-two years now—yet the realm stands in such peril. If not for Yan Song's treachery, what could have brought us here?
48
使使
I beg Your Majesty to heed Heaven's warnings, ponder the subtle purpose of our ancestors' legislation, remember that authority must not be shifted, reflect that order and discipline must not be thrown into chaos, and immediately dismiss Yan Song to answer Heaven's signs—then the court will be restored to clarity and the laws made whole again. Even if the frontier raiders rage unchecked, I know they will not be difficult to subdue.
49
使 西
By then Yang Jisheng had been severely punished for impeaching Yan Song, and the Emperor was nursing his wrath, waiting for the next memorialist. Zhou Mian too had been imprisoned over his challenge to false merit claims, and Zhao Jin's memorial arrived at that very moment. The Emperor flew into a rage, wrote a personal endorsement on the memorial accusing Jin of deceiving Heaven and slandering his sovereign, dispatched agents to seize him, and again comforted Yan Song with every possible kindness. Jin then journeyed ten thousand li to answer the summons, repeatedly tumbling from the prison cart, and several times nearly died on the road. Once he arrived he was cast into the imperial prison for interrogation, beaten forty strokes of the cangue, and stripped of office to live as a commoner. His father Kun, then Guangxi Participating Administrator, likewise submitted his resignation and was removed from office.
50
祿
Jin remained at home for fifteen years until Muzong ascended the throne and restored him to his former post. He was promoted to Vice Minister of Rites and, before he could take up the appointment, advanced to Minister of Imperial Entertainments. Jiangyin had been sending ten thousand jin of young hairtail each year as tribute; he memorialized to cut the levy in half. In the first year of Longqing, as Right Assistant Censor-in-Chief he pacified Guizhou, routed the rebels, and captured Long Dezha of the Miao and his fellows. The An clan's Pacification Commissioner had long been proud and defiant, but he feared Jin and submitted to his command. He entered the capital as Minister of Justice and later served as both Left and Right Vice Minister of Works. On one occasion while acting head of the ministry he became embroiled in a dispute.
51
西 西
In the second year of Wanli he was transferred to Right Censor-in-Chief at Nanjing, then made Minister of Punishments. When Zhang Juzheng entered mourning, the senior ministers at Nanjing debated submitting a memorial to keep him in office. Jin and Minister of Works Fei Sanyang objected and put a stop to the plan. He was transferred to Rites and then to Personnel, both appointments in Nanjing. Jin found Zhang Juzheng overbearing and often spoke against him. When word reached Juzheng, he had supervising secretary Fei Shangyi impeach Jin for preaching Neo-Confucian learning and Chan doctrine and meddling rashly in state affairs; Jin then asked to retire. After Juzheng's death, supervising secretaries and censors recommended him in turn, and he was restored to his former post. In the eleventh year he was recalled and appointed Left Censor-in-Chief. At that time the court was seizing Zhang Juzheng's estate. Jin said: "When Shizong confiscated the Yan Song household, the harm spread across the prefectures of Jiangxi. Juzheng's private wealth may not have rivaled the Yan family's, but if the search is pushed further, I fear the Three Chu will suffer tenfold what Jiangxi endured. Moreover, though Juzheng did monopolize power, he harbored no treasonous ambition. He upheld the young sovereign and labored day and night; the realm within and without grew calm—achievements that ought not be wholly erased. His hereditary privileges, posthumous honors, and his sons' offices have already been revoked—that is punishment enough. I beg Your Majesty to show special mercy and lighten the penalty somewhat." The memorial was not accepted.
52
滿 調
After six years at the second rank he was made Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent; soon afterward he was further named Minister of War while continuing to head the Censorate. Jin picked out several worthwhile proposals from the censors' sealed memorials and asked that the throne order them implemented. Sichuan investigating censor Luo Zun resented Jin and, seizing on a procedural clause, memorialized calling him a traitorous minister. Censor Zhou Xidan and supervising secretary Chen Yujiao refused to support Zun; they submitted memorials in turn refuting him, and Zun was transferred to service outside the capital. When the Emperor went to the imperial tombs, Jin was again entrusted by edict to remain and guard the capital. That winter he went home to observe mourning for his stepmother. In the nineteenth year he was recalled and appointed Minister of Punishments. He was seventy-six years old and twice begged to decline the post, but was not allowed. He died at Suzhou on the journey to his post. He was posthumously made Junior Grand Guardian with the posthumous name Duansu.
53
Throughout his life Jin held to stern integrity, was a devoted follower of Wang Yangming's teaching, and in instructing others made personal conduct the foundation. When Wang Yangming was enshrined in the Confucian temple, Jin had helped bring it about. At first he crossed Yan Song and suffered grave punishment. On his way to Guizhou he passed Yan Song's home district, saw Song's grave by the roadside, was moved to pity, and instructed the local officials to guard it. Later he offended Zhang Juzheng and was dismissed; when Juzheng's estate was seized, he again intervened on his behalf. For this people praised Jin as a man of true magnanimity.
54
Wu Shilai, styled Weixiu, came from Xianju. He passed the jinshi examination in the thirty-second year of Jiajing. He was appointed magistrate of Songjiang Prefecture and served as acting prefect. When pirates raided the district, villagers fled toward the city with wives and children in tow; Shilai took them all in. The mercenary troops were violent and prone to looting; Shilai bound their leaders with kindness, and when any transgressed he punished them on the spot—none dared make trouble. When bandits assaulted the city, a sudden downpour collapsed several zhang of the wall. Shilai blocked the breach with elite cavalry, rushed repairs, and in three days the wall was whole again; the bandits then withdrew.
55
使
He was promoted to supervising secretary in the Bureau of Punishments. He memorialized for the dismissal of Minister of War Xu Lun, Xuanda Grand Coordinator Yang Shun, and investigating censor Lu Kai. All were Yan Song's creatures, and Song hated him bitterly. An envoy was about to be dispatched to Ryukyu, and the mission was assigned to Shilai. In the third month of the thirty-seventh year Shilai submitted a bold memorial impeaching Yan Song, saying: "Not long ago Your Majesty erupted in anger and had the border officials who bungled the campaign arrested; every heart in the realm rejoiced. Those border officials hollowed out the army and paid tribute to the chief minister—that is crime enough. Yet the chief minister took their bribes, conspired with villains, and deceived his sovereign—can he alone go unpunished? Yan Song has directed the government for twenty years; every civil and military appointment passes through his hand. He secretly allowed his son Shifan to enter the forbidden precinct and draft replies to memorials. Shifan then traded on his father's power, jerking his chin at the high ministers and treating generals as servants; gifts heaped up like mountains, yet he was never satisfied. He installed his favorites Wan Cai as Director of the Bureau of Appointments and Fang Xiang as Director of the Bureau of Military Appointments; for every act and every promotion they first sought Shifan's leave and only then submitted the request. Your Majesty believes the ministries deliberate on their own—how could you know it is all the private will of Yan Song and his son! I will not rehearse every other charge here. Men such as Zhao Wenhua, Wang Ruxiao, Zhang Jing, Cai Kelian, Yang Shun, and Wu Jiahui—some pleaded for their lives, some for promotion—all wrung the people dry for private gain and drained the treasury to enrich the powerful. Your Majesty has already seen through a few such cases. Remonstrating officials too—supervising secretaries Yuan Hongyu and Zhang Deng, censor Wan Minying—have raised these matters again and again. Yet for the most part they only hinted and circled; none struck directly at Yan Song and his son. I hold that to root out evil one must strike at the root. The frontier languishes because the armies are exhausted; the armies are exhausted because officials are corrupt; officials are corrupt because the chief minister is greedy. Unless Yan Song and his son are removed, Your Majesty may labor from dusk till dawn, yet the frontier will never be saved."
56
使 使
That day Zhang Chong and Dong Chuance impeached Yan Song on the same day as Shilai. Chong and Shilai were both pupils of Xu Jie; Chuance was Jie's townsman; Shilai had earlier served at Songjiang—Yan Song therefore suspected Jie had orchestrated the attack. He secretly memorialized that the three had conspired on the same day and must have had a patron, and that Shilai had dreaded the Ryukyu mission and seized on the memorial to escape it. The Emperor believed him, sent all three to the imperial prison, and rigorously interrogated them for the mastermind. Near death, the three still would not confess, saying only, "The spirit of the dynastic founder taught your servant to speak thus. The interrogators then reported that the three had masterminded one another. An edict sent all three into miasmic exile; Shilai was banished to Hengzhou.
57
調 調
At the start of Longqing he was recalled and restored to his former post. He was promoted to supervising secretary in the Bureau of Works. He memorialized in detail on river control, and recommended Tan Lun, Yu Dayou, and Qi Jiguang for service at the Ji garrison to train frontier troops locally and spare the other commands constant redeployment. The Emperor approved every proposal. He was appointed to pacify and administer Yunyang. Vice Censor-in-Chief Liu Bingren had been impeached and was due for transfer; Shilai said Bingren had recommended the eunuch Li Fang and lacked a statesman's dignity, and Bingren was dismissed on that account. The Emperor's mourning period had long ended, yet he had never spoken at court; Shilai submitted nine memorials on preserving the throne's stability, and the court acknowledged them. Soon afterward he was made Vice Director of Shuntian Prefecture.
58
使
In the second year of Longqing he was made Right Vice Censor-in-Chief at Nanjing with command of the Yangtze fleet. He was transferred to Grand Coordinator of Guangdong. Before he departed he recommended fifty-nine subordinate officials. Supervising secretary Guang Mao and others impeached him for reckless recommendations. Gao Gong then headed the Ministry of Personnel and had long disliked Shilai; Shilai was demoted to Vice Commissioner in Yunnan. He was impeached again by Han Ji, a supervising secretary and Gao Gong's pupil, and dismissed to live in retirement.
59
使
In the twelfth year of Wanli he was at last restored as Vice Commissioner of Huguang. Soon he was promoted to Left Director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices and later served as Left Vice Minister of Personnel. In the fifteenth year he was appointed Left Censor-in-Chief. The Earl of Cheng Yi, Liu Shiyan, clung to his crimes and repeatedly defied court orders; Shilai impeached him and he was sent to the appropriate office for trial. At first he shot to prominence through blunt remonstrance, and his name resounded through the court. He suffered setback after setback and languished in obscurity for more than ten years. In his later years he could not hold his ground and wound his way deferentially among those in power. He was impeached in turn by Rao Shen, Xue Fujiao, Wang Linzhi, Shi Menglin, Zhao Nanxing, and Wang Jiguang, and Shilai too repeatedly asked to resign and go home. Before he left the capital, he died. He was posthumously made Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent, with the posthumous name Zhongke (Loyal and Respectful). Soon Yu Kongjian of the Ministry of Rites impeached him, and his posthumous name was stripped away.
60
Zhang Chong, style Ziyi, was a native of Liuzhou. He received his jinshi degree in the thirty-second year of the Jiajing reign. He was appointed a principal clerk in the Ministry of Punishments. Outraged that Yan Song and his son were throwing government into chaos, he submitted a defiant memorial impeaching them. The gist ran:
61
滿
I observe that Grand Secretary Song in rank has reached the summit of subjecthood and in wealth surpasses all under Heaven. His son is a vice minister; his grandsons serve in the Embroidered Uniform Guard and as Secretariat drafters; his clients pack the court ranks, and every marriage tie wears purple or scarlet. Even dogs and horses know how to repay their master—yet Song does not. Your servant will address this through the three great policies: frontier defense, finance, and talent.
62
What the state relies on as its screen and rampart are the frontier commands. Since Song took up the Grand Secretariat, civil and military officers and generals have advanced chiefly through bribery. At first they did not examine merit or credentials—only pull strings, and appointment followed. Afterward they did not weigh merit or seniority—only keep the gifts flowing, and promotion came out of turn. Under the pretext of repairing the frontier and building forts, commanders who lost armies saw their sons ennobled, and those who killed recklessly were transferred and promoted. They openly slandered and deceived one another, trading offices back and forth. Thus the forefathers' two-hundred-year plan for frontier defense was utterly ruined.
63
使
Each year the Ministry of Revenue disbursed frontier pay—originally to feed the troops. Since Song came to power, silver leaves the revenue office in the morning and by evening enters the villain's mansion. Four parts reach the frontier; six parts are presented to Song. Whenever I pass Chang'an Street, I see at Song's gate nothing but envoys from the frontier commands. Before they see the father, they first present gifts to the son. Before they see the son, they first present gifts to the household staff. The retainer Yan Nian's wealth already exceeds several hundred thousand taels—Song's household may be imagined from that. Private hoards overflow; half of it is army provisions; Frontier soldiers freeze and starve, with no assurance of the morrow. Thus the army the forefathers nurtured for two hundred years was utterly drained and weakened.
64
使
Frontier defense was already in ruins. Frontier stores are already empty—if talent alone were enough to serve Your Majesty, there would still be little to fear. Since Song came to power, he has scorned offices and titles while privately filling his purse. Shifan, cunning and treacherous by nature, leans on his father's tiger-and-wolf power to seize authority and profit—beasts clawing, crows snatching. Shameless men hurried to his door in an unbroken stream until it became the prevailing wind, like a fever in the land. Thus the talent the forefathers cultivated for two hundred years was utterly corrupted.
65
使
Song's malice is enough to overturn men, his deceit enough to bewilder the age, his eloquence enough to disorder government, and his talent enough to advance villainy. Those who sided with him he drew to his knee; those who differed from him he cast into the abyss. He clamped shut the mouths of all under Heaven so none dared speak, while his wickedness grew day by day. This is why men of loyalty and righteousness clench their fists in fury and harbor a grief that will not pass. If Your Majesty would truly dismiss and reprimand him to satisfy public wrath, frontier officers and soldiers would double their spirit without a battle, and the hundred offices would renew their governance without a command.
66
When the memorial was submitted, he was arrested, sent to the imperial prison for interrogation under torture, and then banished to garrison duty at Duyun.
67
When Muzong succeeded to the throne, he was recalled as a principal clerk in the Ministry of Personnel and soon promoted to Vice Minister of the Court of Judicial Review. In the spring of the second year of Longqing he was appointed Right Vice Censor-in-Chief and grand coordinator of Nan and Gan. Within his jurisdiction Mount Wanyang straddled the borders of Huguang, Fujian, and Guangdong—a former bandit haunt where merchants from every quarter cultivated indigo. At this time bandits came out to plunder, and Chong sent the garrison commander Dong Long to suppress them. Long announced he would search the mountains, and all the indigo growers were terrified. The bandits incited them, and they mustered more than a thousand men. The Ministry of War ordered two grand coordinators to deliberate on whether to pacify or suppress them; only after a long delay was a plan settled. The fierce bandit Huang Chaozu of Nanxiong raided county after county and swept into Huguang; his power burned bright. Chong campaigned against him and captured him. He was transferred to serve as grand coordinator of Huguang. He was recalled and appointed Minister of the Court of Judicial Review, then promoted to Right Vice Minister of War. He returned home to care for his parents.
68
At the start of the Wanli reign he was restored to his former office and put in charge of grain transport on the Grand Canal. He was recalled as Right Vice Minister of Punishments, but refused to accept the post and sent repeated memorials begging to retire. He died at home. At the start of the Tianqi reign he was posthumously made Minister of War, with the posthumous name Zhongjian (Loyal and Uncomplicated).
69
Dong Chuance, style Yuanhan, was a native of Huating in Songjiang. He received his jinshi degree in the twenty-ninth year of the Jiajing reign. He was appointed a principal clerk in the Ministry of Punishments. In the thirty-seventh year he submitted a defiant memorial impeaching Grand Secretary Yan Song. The gist ran:
70
Song is wilfully wicked and misleads the state—has Your Majesty not already seen through his treachery? Only because he assists in government has he still been treated leniently and told to reflect and reform. Yet Song is heedless of warning, and his ingratitude grows deeper. Each day he holds office, the empire suffers a day's harm. Your servant grieves in secret.
71
Frontier grand coordinators and commanders who wish to win the troops' utmost effort must have funds to spend. Today frontier pay costs a million taels a year—and more than half is bribed to Song. Hence the soldiers starve and weaken, and bandits drive deep inland. This is his first crime: ruining frontier defense.
72
簿 使
The Ministries of Personnel and War carry their selection registers to Song for him to fill in. The bureau directors Wan Cai and Fang Xiang gladly take his orders, no different from camp runners. Capital street talk even calls them the "civil-and-military house stewards." This is his second crime: selling offices and ranks.
73
Vice Minister Liu Boyue, touring the departments to collect timber, extorted private wealth and magistrates' bribes and carted them to Song's house without cease. Other officials who broke rules and seized by force what they offered Song are beyond counting. Song's private hoards are richer than the public treasury. This is his third crime: gnawing at the state's finances.
74
Zhao Wenhua was banished for his crimes; Song seized his baggage, worth tens of thousands, yet sent men to escort him south. He intimidated prefectures and counties, impressed private labor, and threw roads and relay posts into turmoil, wasting public and private funds. This is his fourth crime: shielding the guilty.
75
Provincial and circuit offices everywhere send seasonal gifts by the thousand—they must squeeze the common people. The people's wealth is daily exhausted while Song's hoard daily grows. Then by water and land, cart and boat, they carried it back to his home district—not a month without traffic. Wherever they passed they demanded supplies; their force was that of tiger and wolf. This is his fifth crime: harassing the relay system.
76
Song long held heavy power—touch him and you burn. Shameless men seeking advancement clung to his stench and swarmed his gate like deer to a salt lick. Hence scholar-official conduct decayed day by day and official integrity died day by day. This is his sixth crime: ruining talent.
77
Song wields sole power through concealment and deceit; life and death, grant and seizure—all follow his whim alone. Shifan, a worthless son, again steals authority and helps the evil along. Father and son run riot in cruelty; within and without the court, all choke on rage. When there is such a minister, the state's law cannot bear it. Your servant holds office in the Ministry of Punishments and ought to interrogate wickedness. If Your Majesty would truly not spare the Yan clan to answer the empire, then what death would your servant spare to answer the powerful villain!
78
When the memorial was received, he was sent to the imperial prison. He was banished to garrison duty at Nanning.
79
When Muzong ascended the throne, he was recalled to his former post. He rose through the ranks to director. In the fifth year of Longqing he was promoted in succession to Vice Censor-in-chief of the Nanjing Court of Judicial Review, then to Vice Minister of Works. In the first year of Wanli he was at once transferred to the Ministry of Rites. Censorial officials impeached Dong Chuance for accepting bribes, and he was dismissed and sent home. In disciplining subordinates he was excessively harsh and was ultimately killed by a household slave.
80
Zou Yinglong, courtesy name Yunqing, was a native of Chang'an. He passed the jinshi examination in the thirty-fifth year of Jiajing. Appointed as a courier, he was promoted to censor. Yan Song had monopolized government for a long time; court officials who attacked him invariably met with disaster, and one warned another not to speak. Yet Yinglong knew the Emperor's favor had secretly shifted, and that Song's son Shifan was growing greedier and more unrestrained—an opening by which he could be attacked and removed—so he submitted a memorial saying:
81
使
Vice Minister of Works Yan Shifan, riding his father's power, seeks profit without end. He usurps bestowal of ranks and rewards and amasses bribes far and wide. He has ruined the selection system so that the marketplace of office is open for all to see. Petty men rush to compete, and the prices they demand grow ever greater. Criminal Affairs bureau director Xiang Zhiyuan bought a transfer to the Ministry of Personnel for thirteen thousand taels of gold; examination graduate Pan Hongye paid twenty-two hundred taels for a prefecture. When junior officials and district clerks can bribe by the tens of millions, how can one know any limit for grand ministers and frontier governors?
82
In ordinary times those who trafficked in illicit gifts and served as go-betweens for him number no fewer than a hundred or more; worst among them are his sons the yishiwei Yan He and Secretariat drafter Yan Hong, the household steward Yan Nian, and his client the Secretariat drafter Luo Longwen. Nian was especially insolent and cunning; shameless literati even addressed him as "Mr. Crane Mountain." On Song's birthdays Nian would present ten thousand taels in congratulatory gold. When slaves and attendants grow so rich and extravagant, what must their master be like?
83
Though the Song father and son were originally registered in Yuanzhou, they widely bought fertile fields and fine mansions at Nanjing and Yangzhou—doubtless several dozen properties—managed by the brash bondservant Yan Dong. By extortion and seizure they stirred resentment that pierced to the bone. If they profit thus abroad, what must they be like in their home districts?
84
Strangest of all: when Shifan was in mourning for his mother, the Emperor, considering Song's advanced age, specially allowed him to remain and nurse his father, ordering He to escort the coffin south. Shifan instead gathered pleasure companions and kept bejeweled concubines, ever dancing and singing in drunken revelry, till human decorum was extinguished. As for He's shamelessness, he treated his grandmother's funeral as a rare windfall. Wherever they passed they threw the courier stations into turmoil and demanded payment under every conceivable pretext. Every agency groveled before them; entire prefectures were drained empty.
85
Today floods and drought strike again and again, and alarms multiply north and south. Yet the Shifan father and son daily practice extortion, while inside and outside the hundred offices none fail to squeeze the people's fat to fill those ravines and gullies. How can the people not grow poor? How can the state not grow sick? How can Heaven-and-man portents not come one upon another? Your servant asks that Shifan's head be cut off and hung in the marketplace as a warning to ministers who are brutal, overbearing, and disloyal. If a single word of your servant proves false, I willingly accept public execution. Song, who dotes on this wicked son and has drawn bribes to trade in power, should likewise be promptly sent home to his fields to cleanse the foundations of government.
86
退 調
The Emperor had already known something of Shifan's licentious conduct during mourning and inwardly detested it. It happened that the Daoist Lan Daoxing, who gained favor through planchette divination, was secretly asked whether his chief ministers were worthy. Daoxing fabricated spirit-writing that fully described how the Songs father and son manipulated power; the Emperor therefore grew distant from Song and relied on Xu Jie. When Yinglong's memorial arrived, he compelled Song to retire, sent Shifan and the rest to the imperial prison, and promoted Yinglong to Secretary in the Office of Transmission. Yet though the Emperor had dismissed Song, he still remembered Song's help in cultivating the mysteries and was listless and unhappy; he wrote in his own hand to instruct Xu Jie: "Song has retired and his son has paid the penalty; whoever dares speak again shall be executed together with Yinglong. Yinglong was in deep dread for his life and did not dare take up his post; only with Xu's mediation and protection did he finally assume office. Censor Zhang Chong, inspecting salt in Hedong, did not know the Emperor's intent and memorialized: "Your Majesty has already conspicuously promoted Yinglong, while Wang Zongmao, Zhao Jin, and others who first exposed the great villain have not been summoned—this is rewarding the man who mended the chimney while slighting those who warned of the fire. The Emperor was furious, had him seized at once, beaten sixty blows, and reduced to commoner status. After a long while, when Shifan was executed, Yinglong at last felt secure.
87
西
At the beginning of Longqing he was made Vice Censor-in-chief to oversee salt colonies in Jiangxi and south of the Yangzi. He was transferred to Vice Minister of Works. Mu Chaobu, Prince of Qian who guarded Yunnan, was arrogant and unruly; court discussion favored sending a senior minister of prestige to rein him in, so Yinglong was changed to Vice Minister of War with concurrent appointment as Vice Censor-in-chief and Pacification Commissioner of Yunnan. On arrival he exposed Chaobu's crimes, and Chaobu was ultimately arrested. When Wanli began its reign, bandits of Tiesuo Ravine rose in revolt and were pacified. Soon after, the tribal chieftain Mei Fa rebelled; combining native and Han troops he advanced to punish them, beheading and capturing more than a thousand each.
88
退
Yinglong had talent and spirit; he first won fame by impeaching Yan Song and swiftly rose to conspicuous station. When he served as Director of the Imperial Sacrifices and inspected sacrificial animals at the Northern Suburb, the Eastern Depot eunuch Feng Bao had himself announced and escorted in; his guide led him before the altar to burn incense face-on, just like the Son of Heaven. Yinglong was greatly alarmed and impeached Bao for presumptuous arrogance; Bao bore a deep grudge. At this capital evaluation he filed a self-report; Bao secured his dismissal and he was ordered to retire. The native chieftains Pu Chongming and Chongxin, brothers, were at feud. Chongming brought in Zhuang troops from Guangnan as allies; Chongxin in turn summoned Annamese troops. The Annamese troops later withdrew but the Zhuang troops remained; Yinglong ordered his deputy Yang Shoulian to go suppress them. Shoulian plundered villages and hamlets and killed people. The Zhuang rebels seized the chance and twice defeated government troops; people blamed Yinglong. Yinglong heard he had been dismissed from office and, without waiting for his successor, went straight home. His replacement Wang Ning wished to claim the credit himself and strove to exclude Yinglong. Supervising Secretariat drafter Pei Yingzhang then impeached Yinglong for bungling affairs. Investigating censor Guo Tingwu had never favored Yinglong; his inquiry endorsed Ning's account. Yinglong was then struck from the registers and died at home.
89
西歿
In the sixteenth year Shaanxi Pacification Commissioner Wang Xuan reported that after Yinglong's death his bequeathed fields amounted to less than a few mu and his remaining house to no more than a few bays; no posthumous honors had been granted—the court and countryside alike resented it. The Emperor ordered Yinglong's office restored and granted him funeral rites.
90
西
Zhang Chong was a native of Xincheng in Jiangxi. He passed the jinshi in the thirty-eighth year of Jiajing. While in the censorate he dared to speak forth. At the beginning of Muzong's reign his office was restored. He repeatedly memorialized against eunuchs and once impeached Grand Secretary Gao Gong. When Gong re-entered the Grand Secretariat and took charge of the Ministry of Personnel, Chong had already been promoted to Vice Director of the Court of the Imperial Stud; he was dismissed for lack of caution and sent home. In the Wanli reign he rose in stages to Vice Minister of Works.
91
祿
Lin Run, courtesy name Ruoyu, was a native of Putian. He passed the jinshi in the thirty-fifth year of Jiajing. Appointed magistrate of Linchuan. While on business at Nanfeng, bandits suddenly arrived; he devised a plan to repel them. Summoned and appointed Nanjing censor. Yan Shifan set out wine and summoned Run; Run's debate flowed like wind and Shifan inwardly feared him. When the banquet ended he had a guest tell him, "Vice Minister Yan thanks you, sir; do not needle current affairs. Once Run took office he first charged Academician Shen Kun with killing without authority and had him brought to justice. He then impeached Vice Censor-in-chief Yan Maoqing on five counts; Yan Song shielded him and no inquiry was made. Dian Mu, director of the Princely Establishment of Yi, was lawless; though repeatedly impeached he did not reform, and Run impeached him again. Dian Mu repeatedly memorialized in his defense, slandering Run for private motives. Ministries and supervising offices together memorialized that the prince resisted court orders and intimidated censorial officials. Shifan accepted his bribes; the Emperor merely issued an edict of rebuke. Run then said the imperial clansmen had proliferated and annual stipends could not keep pace; he asked that adaptation be urgently discussed. The Emperor had the responsible agencies assemble for deliberation.
92
西 使
It happened that the Emperor followed Zou Yinglong's advice and banished Shifan to garrison Leizhou while his follower Luo Longwen was sent to garrison Xun. Shifan remained at home and did not report to his post. Longwen visited the place of exile once, then fled back to Huizhou and repeatedly traveled to and from Jiangxi to plot with Shifan. In the winter of the forty-third year Run inspected river defenses on patrol, learned the facts in full, and hurried a memorial saying: "Your servant, patrolling the upper Yangzi, made thorough inquiries among the river pirates and found they had all taken refuge in the homes of the fugitive soldier Luo Longwen and Yan Shifan. Longwen has chosen a site deep in the mountains, rides in a carriage and wears python robes, and harbors a heart unwilling to submit while trusting in rugged terrain. Shifan night and day with Longwen rails against current policy and stirs the people's hearts. Recently, under the false name of building a residence, he has gathered braves to more than four thousand men. Travelers on the roads are terrified; all say trouble may erupt at any moment. I beg that criminal law be applied early to cut off the root of calamity. The Emperor flew into a rage and at once issued an edict ordering Lin Run to arrest them and escort them to the capital. Shifan's son Shaoting served in the Embroidered Uniform Guard; on hearing the order he rushed word to Shifan and urged him to report to his exile post. Within two days Lin Run had already raced there. Shifan could not get there in time; he was shackled and marched off, and Luo Longwen was likewise seized at Wuzhou. The court then fully prosecuted every crime of the two men, and both were put to death.
93
Lin Run was soon promoted to vice commissioner in the Nanjing Secretariat for Promoting Governance and later served as vice minister of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices. In the first year of Longqing he was appointed Right Assistant Censor-in-Chief and grand coordinator of the Yingtian prefectures. His subordinates feared his formidable reputation and all trembled before him. When Lin Run took up his post he governed with leniency and fairness, enacted many measures of real benefit, and officials and people alike gladly submitted. After three years in office he died at his post. He was only forty years old.
94
When Xinghua in his home district was overrun by Japanese pirates, he submitted a special memorial requesting a three-year remission of taxes and corvée and the release of treasury funds for relief. His countrymen were deeply grateful. When his coffin was borne home the people lined the road for forty li, set up mourning stations, and wept and made offerings for three full days.
95
Commentary: Emperor Shizong was no mediocre or timid sovereign. Yet Yan Song held the chief ministership for more than twenty years, his greed beyond all measure. Critics came one after another—expelled, banished, sent to their deaths—yet bore it as sweetly as honey, and still could not stir the sovereign's heart to a single moment of clarity. Emperor Dezong of Tang said, "People call Lu Qi treacherous and wicked; I scarcely notice it at all." Each ruler thinks his own minister virtuous, as if treading the same rut—how endlessly one must sigh! Yan Shifan's downfall began with Zou Yinglong and was brought to completion by Lin Run. Their loyalty did not exceed Yang Jisheng's, nor were their words more blunt and forceful than Shen Lian's, Xu Xueshi's, and the rest—yet through them the arch-villain lost his head. Perhaps when evil piles high the man is undone, and Zou and Lin's impeachments merely struck at the appointed hour!
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →