← Back to 明史

卷三百二十七 列傳第二百十五 外國八 韃靼

Volume 327 Biographies 215: Foreign States 8

Chapter 327 of 明史 · History of Ming
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 327
Next Chapter →
1
The Tartars are the Mongols—the remnant house of the Yuan. In the founding emperor’s first Hongwu year, Grand General Xu Da marched to seize the Yuan capital; the Yuan emperor slipped from Beiping north of the passes and made Kaiping his seat, while repeatedly dispatching generals such as Yisu to raid the northern border. The following year Chang Yuchun routed them; the army pushed on to Kaiping and took the imperial prince Qing Sun and Chancellor Dingzhu prisoner.
2
西 使西西 使
By then the Yuan emperor had fled to Yingchang, while his general Wang Baobao held Dingxi and plagued the border. In the spring of the third year Xu Da was appointed grand general and directed to advance from Xi’an against Dingxi. Li Wenzhong and Feng Sheng were named left and right vice grand generals, ordered out through Juyong Pass to strike Yingchang. Wenzhong reached Xinghe, seized Chancellor Zhuzhen, won another great victory over Yuan forces at Camel Mountain, and pressed on toward Yingchang. Before he arrived he learned the Yuan emperor was already dead; he advanced, laid siege to the city, and took it. He captured the Yuan emperor’s grandson Maidibaer along with the imperial women, high ministers, jewels, and court registers. Crown Prince Ayushiridara alone escaped with a few dozen riders. Meanwhile Xu Da routed Wang Baobao’s army at Shen’er Valley Pass and put him to flight. The founding emperor enfeoffed Maidibaer as Marquis Chongli and posthumously styled the Yuan emperor as Emperor Shun. Thereafter former Yuan commanders such as Jiang Wenqing and princes such as Shiduer submitted one after another. Only Wang Baobao, keeping Crown Prince Ayushiridara with him at Karakorum, defied repeated imperial summons.
3
西 西 西
In the spring of the fifth year he ordered Xu Da, Li Wenzhong, and Western Campaign General Feng Sheng to take the field in three columns against them. Xu Da took the central route through Yanmen Pass; the fighting went poorly and he fell back to hold the frontier passes. Feng Sheng’s column encamped in the west at Lanzhou. Right Vice Grand General Fu Youde pushed ahead, fighting his way to Saolin Mountain; when Feng Sheng’s forces joined him they slew the Yuan chancellor Buhua and accepted the surrender of more than eight thousand three hundred households under Shangdu Lü and his followers; then marching by Ejinay to Guazhou and Shazhou they inflicted defeat after defeat. Wenzhong marched east through Juyong to Kouwen; when Yuan commanders abandoned camp and fled he led light horse in a dash from the Luqu River, defeated Manzi Hala Zhang on the Tula, pursued him to the Arun and then to Changhai, and sent more than eighteen hundred officials, kin, and soldiers’ families to the capital as captives. Xu Da and the other columns were soon recalled. The following spring he sent Xu Da, Li Wenzhong, and others to secure the northwest frontier. When Yuan forces raided Wu and Shuo, Xu Da sent Chen De and Guo Zixing to rout them. Soon afterward Xu Da again inflicted a major defeat on Wang Baobao’s army at Huairou. Yuan raids on Baideng, Baode, and Hequ were beaten back by local defenders, but Funing and Ruizhou suffered devastation, so the founding emperor resettled their populations inland.
4
禿 西
In the summer of the seventh year Regional Commander Lan Yu took Xinghe. Wenzhong sent a lieutenant to capture and behead a tribal chief, while he led the main force against the great cliffs of Gaozhou, took them, and slew the imperial prince and minister Duoduoshili; at Zhanmao Mountain he killed the Prince of Lu and took his consort Menggutu prisoner. That autumn, moved that the former Yuan crown prince wandered the desert cut off from his father and without heirs, the founding emperor sent Marquis Chongli north with a letter of counsel. Two years later his followers Jiuzhu and others raided the western border and were beaten off.
5
使 西
In the summer of Hongwu eleven the former Yuan crown prince Ayushiridara died; the founding emperor wrote the mourning text himself and sent envoys to perform the rites. His son Togus Temür succeeded him. His chancellor Lü’er, Manzi Hala Zhang, State Duke Tuohuochi, chancellors Wanzhubuhua and Naierbuhua, and Privy Councilor Aizu held forces at Yingchang and Karakorum, raiding below the passes whenever they could. The founding emperor sent repeated sealed edicts, but they would not submit. In the spring of the thirteenth year Marquis of Xiping Mu Ying marched from Lingzhou, crossed the Yellow River, crossed Helan Mountain and the drifting sands, and at Karakorum captured Tuohuochi, Aizu, and others with all their followers. That winter Wanzhubuhua was captured as well. The following spring Xu Da with Tang He and Fu Youde campaigned against Naierbuhua, reached Hebei, struck Huishan, and took a great toll in heads and captives.
6
使 使使 使 殿 西
Wang Baobao was already dead; most of the great leaders had been subdued or had submitted at a rumor of arms—only Chancellor Naghachu, with two hundred thousand men on Jinshan, kept probing Liaodong. In the spring of the twentieth year he appointed Duke of Song Feng Sheng grand general, with Fu Youde, Lan Yu, and others leading two hundred thousand men against Naghachu, and sent back the captured Yuan general Nairuwu. Feng Sheng encamped at Tongzhou and sent Lan Yu to storm Qingzhou in a blizzard; the city fell. In summer the army crossed Jinshan; Marquis of Linjiang Chen Yong lost his way, was trapped by the enemy, and killed. Nairuwu returned and told his followers at length of the court’s kindness; then State Duke Guantong submitted. Naghachu was already shaken by Nairuwu’s report and, pressed by the main army, sent envoys under the guise of surrender to scout Ming strength. Feng Sheng sent Lan Yu to accept the surrender. When the envoys saw Feng Sheng’s host and reported back, Naghachu looked to heaven and sighed: “Heaven will not let me keep this host.” He then led several hundred riders to Lan Yu to surrender. When he tried to slip away, Duke of Zheng Chang Mao wounded him and he could not escape. Regional Commander Geng Zhong escorted him with troops to Feng Sheng, who honored him richly and had Zhong share quarters and meals with him. More than two hundred thousand of his followers surrendered in succession; when word spread that Naghachu was wounded, another forty thousand broke in panic; captured baggage and herds stretched for more than a hundred li. Feng Sheng withdrew; Regional Commander Pu Ying with three thousand horse covered the retreat and was ambushed and killed by fleeing troops. That autumn Feng Sheng memorialized the surrender of more than two hundred of Naghachu’s officials, more than three thousand three hundred officers, one hundred gold, silver, and bronze seals, one hundred twenty-five tiger tallies and plaques, and nearly three hundred horses, with congratulations. The founding emperor enfeoffed Naghachu as Marquis of Haixi, lavished gifts upon him, and appointed Nairuwu a chiliarch.
7
Once Naghachu had surrendered, the emperor, fearing remnant Yuan bands would plague the border, appointed Lan Yu grand general on the spot, with Tang Sheng and Guo Ying as deputies and Geng Zhong and Sun Ke as staff generals, and sent one hundred fifty thousand men against them. That winter Yuan generals Toto and others surrendered to Lan Yu. The following spring Lan Yu marched from Daining to Qingzhou; learning Togus Temür was at Buir Lake he took a hidden route in haste; at the Baiyanjing outpost he found no enemy and meant to turn back. Marquis of Dingyuan Wang Bi said: “We march under the Son of Heaven’s majesty with more than one hundred thousand men this deep into the steppe—if we return empty-handed, how do we answer for it?” Lan Yu dug fire pits in the earth and in one night galloped to Buir Lake. At dawn they were eighty li from the enemy camp. A sandstorm darkened the day; the army advanced undetected while the enemy stood unprepared. Wang Bi led the van in a direct assault and shattered their army, slaying several thousand grand marshals and Manzi. Togus Temür fled with Crown Prince Tianbaonu, Privy Councilor Nieqielai, Chancellor Shiliemen, and a few dozen riders; they took his second son Dibaonu, more than fifty imperial women, three thousand chiefs, more than seventy thousand people, and one hundred thousand head of livestock, then heaped and burned the captured arms. They then overran General Hala Zhang’s camp and accepted the surrender of all his followers. The northern steppe was thus pacified. When news of victory arrived the founding emperor was delighted, gave Dibaonu and the others paper money, and ordered the ministries to provide for them. When word came that Lan Yu had taken a Yuan imperial consort, the emperor was furious; the woman, ashamed and afraid, took her own life. Dibaonu spoke bitterly; the emperor sent him to live in Ryukyu.
8
西
Togus Temür fled toward Chancellor Yaoqiao at Karakorum; on the Tula River his follower Yisu Tiejier attacked him, his band scattered again, and only Nieqielai and sixteen riders remained. Yaoqiao came to meet him; they planned to join Kuokuotiemuer, but heavy snow kept them from moving. Yisu Tiejier’s men struck suddenly, strangled Togus Temür, and killed Tianbaonu as well. Nieqielai, Shiliemen, and others then submitted and were settled in Quanning Guard. Soon Shiliemen attacked and killed Nieqielai; the bands scattered; an edict ordered the Duoyan guards and others to win them over, and submissions increased. In the spring of the twenty-third year he ordered Duke of Ying Fu Youde with Beiping troops under the Prince of Yan and Marquis of Dingyuan Wang Bi with Shanxi troops under the Prince of Jin against Yaoqiao, Naierbuhua, Alutiemuer, and others. The Prince of Yan marched through Gubeikou, learned Naierbuhua was encamped at Yidu, and galloped through a blizzard to within one desert march—undetected. He first sent Commander Guan Tong, an old friend of Naierbuhua’s; at sight they embraced and wept. Soon the main army closed on the camp; Naierbuhua panicked and tried to flee; Guan Tong restrained him, brought him before the prince, who fed him, reassured him, and sent him back. Naierbuhua was overjoyed and came to submit with Yaoqiao and the others. In time Naierbuhua and others were executed for plotting rebellion, and the enemy grew weaker still. The founding emperor enfeoffed the princes of Yan and Jin as frontier lords, sent great generals yearly to patrol the border, supervised garrison farming, urged caution, and ordered raiders beaten back whenever they appeared. After Togus Temür the enemy chiefs fought among themselves; through five successions to Kuntiemuer each was murdered, and the imperial title was forgotten. Guilichi seized power, styled himself khan, dropped the dynastic name, and thereafter they were known simply as Tartars.
9
In Yongle three chieftains Saohu’er, Chahandaluhua, and others submitted in turn. In time Aruqtai killed Guilichi, brought the Yuan heir Benyashili to Beshbalik, and set him up as khan.
10
In the spring of the sixth year the emperor wrote to Benyashili: “Since the Yuan mandate ended, from Emperor Shun through Ayushiridara to Kuntiemuer there were six successions—in that brief span not one is said to have died in his bed. My father the founding emperor treated Yuan descendants with special kindness and sent those who submitted back north—as when he sent Togus Temür back to succeed as khan—a fact known on both sides of the border. My heart is the same as my father’s. The Yuan line now hangs by a thread; whether you stay or go, fortune or ruin, is yours to choose—weigh it carefully.” He would not heed it.
11
使
The next year they captured twenty-two of his followers including Wanzhetiemuer, and the emperor again sent Supervising Secretary Guo Ji with a letter. Ji was killed, and the emperor was enraged. That autumn he appointed Duke of Qi Qiu Fu grand general, with Wang Cong and Huozhen as deputies and Wang Zhong and Li Yuan as staff generals, and sent one hundred thousand picked cavalry north, warning them not to miss their chance, not to underestimate the enemy, and if the first strike failed to wait for another. By then Benyashili had already been shattered by the Oirats and had moved with Aruqtai to the Luqu River. Fu led one thousand horse ahead at a gallop and routed enemy scouts. Before the army had gathered, Fu crossed the river in pursuit on the momentum of victory while the enemy feigned retreat to lure him on. The generals cited the emperor’s orders to stop him, but Fu would not listen. Enemy forces suddenly surrounded them, and all five generals were killed. The emperor’s anger deepened.
12
西 西 使 使
The next year the emperor led five hundred thousand men beyond the passes in person. Benyashili, hearing this, was terrified and wanted to flee west with Aruqtai; Aruqtai refused; their forces scattered, and ruler and minister each became a separate faction. Benyashili fled west and Aruqtai fled east. The emperor caught him on the Onon River, and Benyashili gave battle. The emperor waved his troops forward in a fierce charge and broke them at a shout. Benyashili abandoned baggage and herds and escaped with seven riders. The Onon was where the Yuan founding ancestor had first risen. On the withdrawal they reached Jinglu Town, met Aruqtai, and the emperor sent word urging him to surrender. Aruqtai wished to come, but his followers refused, and battle followed. The emperor led picked cavalry in a shouting charge; arrows fell like rain; Aruqtai was thrown from his horse; his force was shattered; the pursuit ran more than a hundred li before the Ming turned back. That winter Aruqtai sent tribute horses, and the emperor accepted them.
13
Two years later Benyashili was killed by the Oirat leader Mahamu and his followers. Aruqtai had already sent tribute several times; the emperor had always rewarded him generously and now returned two siblings of his own blood whom the Ming had once captured. He now reported that Mahamu and others had murdered their lord and set up Daliba on their own authority, offered sincere submission, and asked to avenge his former master. The emperor approved his cause and enfeoffed him as Prince of Hening. Thereafter tribute came once or twice a year as a matter of course.
14
使 使 使使
In the twelfth year the emperor campaigned against the Oirats. Aruqtai sent his chiefs and subordinates to attend the court assembly. They received fifty piculs of grain, dried meat, wine, parched grain, and silks in varying amounts. In the fourteenth year, after defeating the Oirats in battle, they sent envoys with captives. In the nineteenth year Aruqtai’s tribute envoys waylaid travelers at the border; the emperor ordered them warned; thereafter they grew arrogant and stopped coming.
15
使 使
Aruqtai submitted because the Oirats had driven him to extremity in the south; he sought respite beyond the passes. The emperor accepted him and enfeoffed him; his mother and wife were styled Grand Lady and Lady of the prince. For several years they bred stock and grew prosperous; then they slighted Ming envoys and detained them. Their tribute envoys often raided on the return journey, and their tribes periodically probed the border passes. In the spring of the twentieth year they launched a major raid on Xinghe. The emperor then ordered a personal campaign against them. When Aruqtai heard the great army was marching, he was afraid; his mother and wife reviled him: “What has the Ming emperor done you, that you must rebel!” He abandoned all baggage and herds beside Kuoluanhai and moved his family due north. The emperor ordered the baggage burned, the herds seized, and withdrew.
16
宿 使
The next autumn border commanders reported that Aruqtai was about to invade. The emperor said: “They think I will not march again—I shall camp below the passes and wait for them.” He detached Marquis of Ningyang Chen Mao as vanguard; at Suwei Mountain they found no enemy but met Prince Yexian Tugan, who came to submit with his family and followers. The emperor enfeoffed him as Prince of Zhongyong and gave him the Chinese name Jin Zhong. Once in the capital, Prince Zhongyong repeatedly asked to strike the enemy and prove his worth. The emperor said: “Wait for now.” In the spring of the twenty-second year the Kaiping garrison reported Aruqtai raiding the border; the ministers urged the emperor to heed Prince Zhongyong. The emperor campaigned in person again; the army halted at the Tolan Namur River; spies revealed that Aruqtai had fled far away. The emperor had also grown weary of war; he issued an edict listing Aruqtai’s crimes but pardoning those who submitted and ordering that they not be killed. On the return march he died at Yumu River. Soon Aruqtai sent tribute horses; Renzong had already ascended the throne and ordered them accepted. Thereafter yearly tribute resumed as in the Yongle era. Aruqtai had been repeatedly defeated by the Oirats and his followers were scattered. His followers Badi and others submitted in succession; the court gave them offices, paper money, and orders to the ministries for their upkeep. Later submitters were all treated by the same precedent. Growing ever more pressed, Aruqtai led his followers east to the Uriyangqad and pastured along the Liao frontier. Generals asked to strike them by surprise; the emperor refused.
17
In Xuande nine Aruqtai was again attacked by Toghon Temür; his wife and children died and his herds were nearly gone; he fled with his son Shiniegan to Muna Mountain and Chaghan Nao’er. Soon the Oirat Toghon killed Aruqtai and Shiniegan; Aruqtai’s son Abuzhi’an, his grandson’s wife Sumudasi, and others, defeated and homeless, came begging to submit. The emperor pitied them and received them kindly.
18
Soon Toghon Temür captured and killed Atai and his followers. Toghon Temür was a Yuan descendant and chief of the Tartars. The Oirat Toghon, having killed Aruqtai, absorbed his following and merged the forces of the princes of Xianyi and Anle, and wished to proclaim himself khan. His followers would not allow it; he set up Toghon Temür, assigned Aruqtai’s people to him, styled himself chancellor, paid him outward deference, but did not obey his orders.
19
When Toghon died his son Esen succeeded, grew ever more arrogant, and brought all tribes under him; Toghon Temür held only the title of khan. Toghon Temür came to court with tribute each year; the emperor rewarded him more generously than other foreign states, addressed him in writing as Khan of the Tartars, and bestowed gifts on his consort as well.
20
In the autumn of the fourteenth year Esen planned a major invasion; Toghon Temür stopped him: “Our clothing and food come largely from the Ming—how can we bear to do this?” Esen would not listen: “If the khan will not act, I shall act myself.” They split forces: Toghon Temür was to raid Liaodong while Esen led his host in through Datong. The emperor marched in person and was trapped at Tumu. The Jing Emperor, who had ruled as regent, ascended the throne and honored the captive emperor as Retired Emperor. The following autumn the retired emperor returned from Esen’s custody. The affair is recorded in the biography of the Oirats.
21
After the retired emperor’s return Toghon Temür sent tribute ever more diligently. He had married Esen’s elder sister and had a son; Esen wished to set the boy up as heir, but Toghon Temür refused. Esen also suspected him of colluding with China and plotting against him; they arrayed troops and fought. Esen killed Toghon Temür, seized his family and herds, distributed them among his followers, and proclaimed himself khan. This was in the second year of the Jing Emperor. The court styled Esen Khan of the Oirats.
22
Before long his follower Alag Zhihui killed him. The Tartar chief Bolai defeated Alag, found Toghon Temür’s son Markö’er, and set him up as the Little Prince. When Alag died, Bolai and his follower Maolihai dominated the tribes, and the Tartars grew strong again.
23
使 使 便 使
In Jingtai six they sent tribute envoys. When Yingzong restored the throne he sent Regional Commander Ma Zheng with silks for Bayan Temür’s former wife. Bolai detained him but sent envoys to congratulate the emperor and offered to present the imperial seal. The emperor wrote: “The seal is already not genuine; even if it were, it is Qin’s ill-omened object—present it or not as you please. Only do not detain my envoy, lest you hasten your own ruin.” The enemy repeatedly raided the Weiyuan guards; that summer Earl of Dingyuan Shi Biao defeated them at Mo’er Mountain.
24
西 西 使 使西 西 西 使
In Tianshun two Bolai raided Shaanxi in force; Marquis of Anyuan Liu Pu was repeatedly beaten but reported minor victories. The following spring the enemy entered Anbian Camp; Shi Biao and others defeated them, but Regional Commander Zhou Xian and Commander Li Jian were killed. In the fourth year they raided Yulin again; Earl of Zhangwu Yang Xin drove them off. They entered again and were defeated at Jinji Valley. Soon they raided the Shaanxi frontier again; ministers asked that the border generals be punished, but the emperor pardoned them. In the spring of the fifth year raiders entered Pinglu City, lured Commander Xu Yong and others into an ambush, and killed them. Frontier reports grew urgent daily; Vice Minister Bai Gui and Censor-in-Chief Wang Hong were sent to inspect the armies. That autumn Bolai sought peace; the emperor sent Zhan Sheng with an edict. Bolai sent envoys with Sheng bearing tribute, asking to enter by Lan County in Shaanxi instead of the old Datong route; this was granted. Soon he again led Maolihai and others into Hexi. The following spring Gui and the others patrolled the west separately; Gui defeated the enemy at Guyuan River and Wang Hong at Hongyazi River. The emperor sent a sealed letter of commendation and ordered Bolai’s envoys to resume entering tribute by Datong.
25
西 使
Markö’er and Bolai were feuding and fighting again. When Markö’er died the tribes set up Makugürjis, also styled the Little Prince. Thereafter Tartar chiefs increasingly ruled their own domains. The Little Prince rarely had contact with China; the succession is largely unverifiable. Bolai and others sent yearly tribute yet raided repeatedly, moving below the passes, citing campaigns against the western Oirats, and repeatedly waylaid the Three Guards. In the winter of the seventh year tribute envoys reached the pass; the emperor turned them back and only stopped when Grand Secretary Li Xian intervened. In the spring of the eighth year Censor Chen Xuan said: “Among the Tartar tribes Bolai is strongest; he has secretly summoned the Three Guards peoples to camp together with him. Last winter he came to court, demanded rewards and banquets, and spied on our strength—his intent to raid is already clear. Yet our border officials are complacent; fortresses are unrepaired, arms poor, and troops undrilled; the rich pay monthly fees to live at ease while the poor flee hunger and cold. With frontier defenses neglected, what can we rely on in an emergency? I beg that frontier officials be ordered to reform these abuses thoroughly. Garrison and defense officials should be promoted or demoted in due season so the capable strive and the idle take warning. At strategic passes we should add troops, build forts, or use beacon towers as needed, send ministers yearly to inspect, and so keep the frontier prepared and raiders in check.” The memorial was noted.
26
西西
In the spring of Chenghua one Bolai induced ninety thousand Uriyangqad horsemen into the Liao River; Marquis of Wu’an Zheng Hong drove them off. That autumn they scattered in raids across Yan–Sui. That winter they again invaded in force. The emperor ordered Marquis of Zhangwu Yang Xin with Shanxi troops and Censor-in-Chief Xiang Zhong with Shaanxi troops to meet them; the raiders withdrew slightly. Soon they crossed the river bend again, besieged Huangfuchuan Fort, and withdrew only after a hard fight by government troops.
27
西
Early Tartar raids struck Liaodong, Xuanfu, Datong, or Ningxia, Zhuanglang, and Gansu unpredictably, and rarely persisted long. In early Jingtai they first raided Yanqing, but with few tribes they did not dare push far inland. During Tianshun a leader named Alach led his followers secretly into the Ordos to settle, drawing nearer the western frontier. The Ordos was ancient Shuofang commandery, where Tang Zhang Renyuan had built the three Accept-the-Submission fortresses. South of the Yellow River it ran two thousand li from Ningxia to Piantou Pass, rich in pasture; Dongsheng Guard lay beyond it. Beyond Dongsheng the country was flat and open, hiding no rider; the Ming garrisoned it early on, but later withdrew inward as the land fell empty. Then Bolai, the Little Prince, Maolihai, and others arrived in turn, taking Chinese captives as guides and plundering Yan–Sui without pause, and the frontier crisis deepened.
28
That summer they launched a major raid on Yan–Sui. The emperor made Yang Xin commander-in-chief and Zhao Sheng his deputy, sending twenty thousand capital and frontier troops against them. Yang Xin had gone to court on other business and had not yet arrived. The raiders scattered across Pingliang, entered Lingzhou and Guyuan, and drove deep into Jingning, Longde, and neighboring districts. That winter they raided Yan–Sui again; Regiment Commander Tang Yinji was killed in action.
29
使
Soon the tribes turned on one another: Bolai murdered Makugürjis, Maolihai killed Bolai, and another khan was installed. Oloroo feuded with Maolihai again; Maolihai killed the khan he had installed, expelled Oloroo, and sent tribute envoys to court. Soon they crossed the river and raided Datong. In the spring of the third year the emperor ordered Marquis of Funing Zhu Yong and others to campaign against them. Maolihai again petitioned to resume tribute, and Belunai of another branch also sent envoys to court. The emperor agreed and ordered Zhu Yong and the others to keep their armies on the frontier.
30
使
That autumn Supervising Secretary Cheng Wanli wrote: “Maolihai has long stopped sending tribute and watches our borders; his intentions are hard to read. Yet I see three reasons he can be beaten. First, our border is only two or three days’ march away — he is the intruder on our ground. Second, his endless consolidation and raiding have made him arrogant and exhausted. Third, they have lately scattered after pasture, splitting into factions whose strength is no longer united. Send twenty thousand picked troops in formations of three thousand under bold generals, enforce discipline, locate Maolihai, and strike by surprise — he will surely be broken.” The emperor approved the plan but did not adopt it. That winter they raided Yan–Sui. The following spring they invaded again. Defending generals Xu Ning and others promptly beat them back. That winter they rallied the Three Guards and invaded, wreaking havoc in Yan–Sui and Yulin.
31
使
In the sixth year Grand Coordinator Wang Yue of Datong sent Regiment Commander Xu Ning and defeated them; Yang Xin and others also won a decisive victory at Huchai Gan. Belunai and Oloroo allied with chiefs of other branches, Boluosilan and Beluohu, who also entered the Ordos to settle for the long term. With Yan–Sui in crisis the emperor made Zhu Yong general and Wang Yue his aide to meet the enemy. Zhu Yong reported victory after victory; Yue and others were promoted, and Yong was made hereditary marquis for his service — yet the enemy still held the Ordos.
32
滿
In the seventh year Zhu Yong proposed plans for attack and defense; the court judged supplies and horses too scarce for an offensive and ordered careful frontier defense instead. Vice Minister Ye Sheng then toured the frontier and, with Grand Coordinator Yu Zijun of Yan–Sui and Wang Yue, planned the frontier wall and its watchtowers and forts. That winter the enemy crossed the passes; Regiment Commander Qian Liang was defeated before Yue and the others could relieve him. Minister of War Bai Gui asked for a supreme commander devoted to the enemy; when Ye Sheng returned and Wang Yue came to court, the court met and called for a major expedition to clear the Ordos. The emperor made Marquis of Wujing Zhao Fu supreme commander over all routes while Wang Yue retained field command. The enemy overran Yan–Sui; Zhao Fu failed to stop them and was recalled, and his replacement Liu Ju achieved nothing either. As Maolihai, Belunai, and Oloroo waned, Manduul entered the Ordos as khan and Boluosilan became grand preceptor.
33
滿 滿 使
That autumn Manduul and Beluohu jointly raided Weizhou. Learning the enemy had left their camp, Wang Yue raced with Xu Ning and Regiment Commander Zhou Yu to Hongyan Lake, where the old and weak remained; they split their forces, struck from both sides, and won a crushing victory. They ambushed the enemy again at Weizhou. Manduul and his men fled in defeat, losing their herds, tents, wives, and children; they wept as they withdrew. They never again settled in the Ordos, and the frontier crisis eased somewhat; though they still skirmished on the border they dared not invade in force, and sent tribute envoys repeatedly.
34
滿 滿 滿
Boluosilan had married his daughter to Manduul and made him khan. In time he killed Beluohu, absorbed his followers, and grew ever more domineering. Toraghan and Ismayin of Manduul’s tribe plotted his murder. Manduul soon died as well; one strong chief after another disappeared, and the frontier people breathed a little easier.
35
祿 西
Eunuch Wang Zhi, favored and powerful, sought glory on the frontier; Wang Yue and Zhu Yong followed him. In the sixteenth year frontier commanders reported a likely river crossing, and Zhu Yong was hurriedly appointed general. Wang Zhi and Wang Yue reached the frontier and, ahead of schedule, routed the enemy at Weining Lake and again at Datong. Zhu Yong was made duke with a hereditary title, Wang Yue was made Marquis of Weining, and Wang Zhi’s stipend rose to three hundred shi. Soon Wang Yue replaced Zhu Yong as commander-in-chief. Ismayin and others then raided the border more often, reaching the Liao frontier. That autumn thirty thousand horsemen overran Datong in a fifty-li camp line, killing and looting tens of thousands of people and animals. Commander Xu Ning met them, was beaten, and falsely reported victory. Emboldened by their gains, they drove into the Shunsheng valley and scattered raids across Hunyuan, Shuo, and neighboring prefectures. Grand Coordinator Qin Hong of Xuanfu and Commander Zhou Yu fought hard and drove them back. Grand Coordinator Bian Yong of Shanxi, Regiment Commander Zhi Yu, and others fought hard in defense, but the raiders kept returning; until Chenghua ended there was no quiet year.
36
西
After Ismayin died the raiders again marched under the name of the Little Prince, joined by Bayan Mongke Wang. In the summer of Hongzhi one the Little Prince petitioned for tribute, calling himself Great Khan of the Great Yuan. The court, favoring conciliation, agreed. Thereafter he and Bayan Mongke Wang sent tribute repeatedly while moving through the Ordos, raiding whenever they chose. In the eighth year Yibulai Wang and other northern chiefs entered the Ordos to pasture. The Little Prince and Huosai, son of Toraghan, grew stronger together and plagued the eastern and western frontiers. That year they raided Liaodong three times with heavy slaughter and looting. The following year Xuanfu, Datong, and Yan–Sui were all devastated.
37
That autumn Wang Yue, now commanding all frontiers, led light troops in a surprise attack behind Helan Mountain and routed the enemy. The next year a large force entered Datong and Ningxia; Regiment Commander Wang Gao was beaten, Qin Gong and Vice Commander Ma Sheng hung back, and all were condemned to death. Marquis Chen Rui commanded and Vice Minister Xu Jin directed operations, but after prolonged failure both were removed; Duke Zhu Hui and Vice Minister Shi Lin replaced them under eunuch supervisor Miao Kui.
38
That winter the Little Prince settled in the Ordos again. The following spring Vice Minister Wang Ao proposed eight policies: fix strategy at court, empower commanders, enforce discipline, protect frontier people, expand recruitment, use spies, divide forces, and strike by surprise. The emperor had the relevant offices take note. Eight thousand horsemen camped below the Liao frontier, stormed Changsheng Fort, and slaughtered and looted almost everyone there. That autumn Zhu Hui sent five columns in a night raid on the Ordos, took three heads, drove off more than a thousand animals, and received lavish rewards. The Little Prince led one hundred thousand horsemen through Huama and Salt ponds, raided Guyuan and Ningxia, shook the capital region, and slaughtered with terrible cruelty.
39
西 西 退
In the fifteenth year Minister Qin Hong was placed in overall charge of Shaanxi. That summer raiders entered Qinghe Fort in Liaodong, reached Miyun, then swung west to plunder Piantou Pass. That autumn five thousand horsemen struck Chang’an Fort in Liaodong; Vice Commander Liu Xiang killed fifty-one of them and drove them off. The following year the frontier quieted somewhat.
40
歿
In the seventeenth year they petitioned for tribute and were granted permission, but never came; instead they entered Datong, killed watch-tower garrisons, and struck Xuanfu and Zhuanglang before defenders Wei Yong, Bai Yu, and others drove them back. The following spring thirty thousand horsemen besieged Lingzhou and raided the interior; Commander Qiu Yue and Commander Li Xiang drove them off. A major force invaded Xuanfu; Commander Zhang Jun was routed, and lieutenant generals Zhang Xiong and Mu Rong were killed.
41
When the Wuzong emperor succeeded, he again sent Zhu Hui and Shi Lin to the frontier. That winter raiders entered Zhenyi Station and Commander Liu Jing was killed. They broke through at Huama Pond, raided Longde, Jingning, and Huining, threw Guanzhong into turmoil, and Yang Yiqing was appointed overall commander. It was the spring of Zhengde one.
42
With Liu Jin in power, eunuchs supervised every army; Yang Yiqing was driven out, and Wen Gui and Cai Kuan took command in turn. In the second year raiders entered Ningxia, Zhuanglang, and Dingliao Rear Guard, and the defending commanders were all arrested.
43
In the fourth year Datong was raided repeatedly. That winter Cai Kuan met the enemy at Huama Pond, was ambushed, and killed. Commander Ma Ang defeated Yibolai of another branch at Mugua Mountain, taking 365 heads, more than 600 horses and animals, and nearly 2,900 weapons.
44
西禿西 使 西
The following year Yibulai of the north and the Little Prince turned on each other. Yibulai fled to the Western Sea, allied with Aertusi, bullied the dependent tribes west of the Tao, and raided again and again. Grand Coordinator Zhang Yi and Commander Wang Xun could not check them; the raids pushed ever deeper, and the border people suffered. In the eighth year, that summer, he brought a large force into the frontier valleys and sent envoys to Zhang Yi asking for pasturelands and permission to resume tribute. Zhang Yi placated him with gold and silk and told him to move on; Yibulai then swept west into Tibet and seized the region. After that Tao, Min, and Songpan knew no quiet year.
45
西西
The Little Prince raided repeatedly, and his slaughter and plunder were especially savage. He again led fifty thousand horsemen against Datong, drove toward Shuozhou, and ravaged Mayi. The emperor sent Marquis of Xianning Qiu Yue to command the defense; at Wanquan Guard three heads were taken while Ming losses ran ten times higher — yet a victory was announced. The following autumn the raiders pitched dozens of linked camps along the Xuan–Da line while a separate ten thousand horsemen swept Huai'an. Cong Lan sent urgent reports; the court put eunuch Zhang Yong over the Xuan, Da, and Yan–Sui armies, made Chief Commander Bai Yu grand general to help him hold the line, and put the capital on alert. The raiders then pushed past Huai'an toward Yuzhou and reached the south of Pinglu; Cong Lan's men had already laid poisoned food in the fields disguised as peasant rations and waited in ambush. When the raiders arrived they ate the poisoned food; the ambush burst out and many were killed. That same year the Little Prince's chief Bo'erhai, driven by internal strife, again seized the Western Sea and raided the northwest border in sudden strikes.
46
In the eleventh year, autumn, the Little Prince split seventy thousand horsemen along several routes and fought Commander Pan Hao at Jiajia Bay. Pan Hao fought twice and lost both times; lieutenant generals Zhu Chun and Wang Tang were killed. Zhang Yong met them at Laoying Slope, was wounded, and fled toward Juyong Pass. The raiders then overran Xuanfu, taking twenty forts and castles and killing or carrying off tens of thousands of people and animals. Pan Hao lost three ranks; the other commanders were demoted and punished to varying degrees.
47
西
In the twelfth year, winter, the Little Prince came through Yulin with fifty thousand horsemen and besieged Commander Wang Xun at Yingzhou. The emperor went to Yanghe, took command in person, and sent the generals to the rescue; after desperate fighting the raiders fell back a little. The next day the raiders attacked again; from morning to evening more than a hundred clashes were fought before they withdrew west. The pursuit reached Pinglu and Shuozhou, but a gale and black fog blotted out the day; the emperor turned back and ordered victory proclaimed at court. Thereafter they raided the border every year, but no longer dared a deep thrust.
48
西
In the spring of Jiajing four ten thousand horsemen struck Gansu. Commander Jiang Yi met them at Kushui mound and beheaded their chieftain. The following year they hit Datong and Xuanfu; Yibulai settled again to pasture behind Mount Helan and kept harassing the border. The next spring the Little Prince struck Xuanfu twice. Regimental commanders Wang Jing and Guan Shan were killed in turn. That autumn tens of thousands of horsemen struck the Ningxia line; Minister Wang Xian and Commander Zheng Qing routed them and took more than three hundred heads. The following spring they ravaged Shanxi. That summer they came in through the central Datong route; Regimental Commander Li Zhen drove them back. That winter they raided Datong again; Commander Zhao Yuan was killed.
49
In the eleventh year, spring, the Little Prince asked to resume tribute; denied permission, he flew into a rage and swept in with one hundred thousand horsemen. Overall commander Tang Long urged that the request be granted; the emperor refused. Tang Long fought battle after battle and won a fair number of heads and captives.
50
西
The Little Prince was then at his strongest, with more than one hundred thousand bowmen and great stores of wealth; growing weary of war, he shifted his camp eastward, took the name Tumen, and split the many tribes along the northwest border. Jinang and Anda, the Little Prince's father's cousins, held the Ordos; bold, shrewd, and eager for war, they became tribal chiefs and led one another in overrunning the borders.
51
西 西
In the twelfth year, spring, Jinang massed his followers inside the Ordos and prepared to strike Yan–Sui; when the frontier officials stood ready, he suddenly crossed the river west with fifty thousand horsemen, fell upon the tribes of Yibulai and Bo'erhai, and routed them. Bo'erhai had long plagued the Zhuang and Ning frontiers; the Yilanggu, Turfan, and other tribes all suffered under him; they once had the dependent tribesman Tiemuge ask for tribute and trade markets, but the court refused. Tang Long now argued that with Bo'erhai broken and driven far off and the Western Sea at peace, the court should stop debating offers of reconciliation.
52
西
After crushing the Western Sea tribes, Jinang and his followers slipped into Yongning in Xuanfu, looted heavily, and withdrew. That winter they struck Zhenyuan Pass; Commander Wang Xiao and Vice Commander Liang Zhen beat them at Willow Gate, pursued them to Beehive Mountain, and drowned many in the rout. The following spring they hit Datong. That autumn they came in again through Huama Pond; Liang Zhen and Commander Liu Wen drove them back.
53
In the fifteenth year, summer, Jinang camped one hundred thousand men on Mount Helan and sent detachments against Liangzhou; Vice Commander Wang Fu met them and took fifty-seven heads. They entered Zhuanglang again; Commander Jiang Yi met them at Watershed Ridge and won three battles in a row. They struck the Yan–Sui and Ningxia borders again. That winter they raided Datong again and swept the Xuan–Da line; overall commander Liu Tianhe, Governor-General Yang Shouli, and Grand Coordinator Chu Shu threw everything they had into the defense.
54
In the nineteenth year, autumn, Chu and Commander Bai Jue thrice defeated the enemy in Wanquan Right Guard and took more than one hundred heads. Liu Tianhe and Commander Zhou Shangwen routed the enemy at Blackwater Park and killed Jinang's son Xiaoshi Wang. The following spring Yang Shouli sent Commander Li Yi to meet the enemy at Zhenshuo Fort and Commander Yang Xin to Gansu; both won.
55
使
That autumn Anda and his follower Abuhai sent Shi Tianjue to offer peace at the Datong frontier; Grand Coordinator Shi Dao reported it, and the court turned them away. Minister Fan Jizu took command of the Xuan–Da armies and posted bounties for the heads of Anda and Abuhai. They then invaded in force; Anda came down through Shiling Pass and drove on Taiyuan. Jinang came through Pinglu Guard and ravaged Pingding, Shouyang, and the surrounding country. Commanders Ding Zhang and Mobile Commander Zhou Yu were killed; many officers were punished, while Jizu alone was rewarded.
56
西
In the twenty-first year, summer, the enemy again sent Tianjue to ask for tribute. Datong Grand Coordinator Long Dayou tricked and bound him, sent him to court, and falsely claimed a cunning capture. The emperor was delighted, promoted Long Dayou to Vice Minister of War, rewarded several dozen frontier officials, and had Tianjue torn apart in the marketplace. Enraged, the raiders swept in, looted Shuozhou, reached Guangwu, and drove south from Taiyuan; Qin, Fen, Xiangyuan, and Changzi were all devastated; They then turned north through Xin, Guo, and Dai and camped at Qixian. Regimental Commander Zhang Shizhong fought fiercely as the enemy closed round him in layer after layer. From mid-morning to mid-afternoon the casualties on both sides were roughly even. When his arrows ran out Shizhong was killed; centurions Zhang Xuan and Zhang Chen died with him; the raiders then withdrew by the old Yanmen road. That autumn they entered Shuozhou again. When Jinang died his sons Langtaiji and others scattered across Hexi; with their strength divided, Anda alone grew dominant and for years harassed the Yan–Sui border.
57
In the twenty-third year, winter, the Little Prince came in through Wanquan Right Guard and reached Yuzhou and Wancian. The capital went on alert.
58
鴿 使 西 退 便 西 忿
In the twenty-fourth year, autumn, Anda struck Yan–Sui and Datong; Commander Zhang Da drove him back. He struck Boju Valley again; Regimental Commander Zhang Feng, Commander Liu Qin, chiliarch Li Zan, licentiate Wang Bangzhi, and others were all killed. Governor-General Weng Wanda and Commander Zhou Shangwen then tightened defenses at Yanghe, and the raiders withdrew. The next summer Anda again sent envoys to the Datong frontier to ask for tribute; border soldiers killed them. That autumn they petitioned again; Wanda memorialized once more, and the emperor again refused. The enemy came west into Bao'an with one hundred thousand horsemen, ravaged Qingyang and Huanxian, turned east, and sent ten thousand horsemen against Jin and Yi. Governor-General of the Three Frontiers Zeng Xuan led Regimental Commander Li Zhen and others in a direct strike at the enemy base behind Mabaliang Mountain, took more than one hundred heads, and only then did the raiders pull back. Zeng proposed retaking the Ordos, and Grand Secretary Xia Yan backed the plan. The emperor was then favoring Yan and told Zeng to draw up a strategy and act as he saw fit. The next summer Wanda wrote again: "Since winter the enemy has repeatedly asked for tribute in respectful terms; it may be wise to grant it." The emperor refused and rebuked Wanda for deceit and disrespect. Zeng gathered troops, repaired the frontier defenses, and repeatedly beat the enemy back. Before long the emperor changed his mind; Yan and Zeng were condemned and executed at the western market. The enemy nursed their anger and looked for revenge; at court no one dared speak of retaking the Ordos again.
59
西
In the twenty-eighth year, spring, they struck Dishui Cliff in Xuanfu. Detachment commanders Jiang Han and Dong Yang were killed and the whole force wiped out; the raiders then overran Yongning and Datong. Commander Zhou Shangwen met them at Caojiazhuang, routed them, and beheaded their chieftain. Weng Wanda came from Huailai to reinforce; hearing the alarm, Xuanfu Commander Zhao Guozhong led one thousand horsemen in pursuit and defeated them again and again. That year the western frontier was hit five times.
60
椿 滿
In the twenty-ninth year, spring, Anda shifted his camp to Weining Lake. That summer he struck Datong; Commanders Zhang Da and Lin Chun were killed. The raiders withdrew, but sent the arrow round the tribes for a full mobilization. That autumn they followed the Chaohu River south to Gubeikou; Censor-in-Chief Wang Ruxiao led the Ji garrison troops to meet them. The raiders feigned a frontal advance with bows drawn while elite horsemen slipped through a bypath and broke the wall. Wang Ruxiao's army broke; the raiders looted Huairou, besieged Shunyi, reached Tongzhou, fanned out in four directions, and burned the canal horse yards. The capital region was thrown into panic.
61
使 軿
A great enemy force threatened the capital; Datong Commander and Marquis of Xianning Qiu Luan, Baoding Grand Coordinator Yang Shouqian, and others each arrived with armies to save the throne. The emperor made Qiu Luan grand general and put all the armies under his command. Qiu Luan and Yang Shouqian were both too timid to fight; Minister of War Ding Ruokui lost his head and shut the gates in a purely defensive stand. The raiders burned and looted for three days and nights, then withdrew. The emperor had Ruokui and Shouqian executed. As the raiders were about to leave by Baiyang Pass, Qiu Luan followed at their heels. The raiders suddenly wheeled east; caught off guard, Qiu Luan's force broke; more than a thousand were killed or wounded. The raiders then withdrew unhurriedly through Gubeikou and left the frontier. The generals collected the slain left behind and took more than eighty heads, then reported a victory.
62
退 西 西
While Altan Khan was closing on the capital, he sent in the captured stable eunuch Yang Zeng with a letter asking for tribute. Chief ministers such as Xu Jie argued that they should placate him by design, tell him to withdraw beyond the frontier, and let border officials submit the tribute request. Altan Khan withdrew and sent his son Toto to offer peace. Qiu Luan was then in power, and the court proposed opening a horse market—playing straight into the enemy's hands. Yang Jisheng of the Ministry of War memorialized against the plan, but in vain. The following spring Vice Minister Shi Dao was put in charge; the court allotted one hundred thousand taels of silver and opened markets at Datong, then at Yan–Sui and Ningxia. Two defectors, Xiao Qin and Lü Mingzhen, had fled to the enemy after criminal convictions; armed with White Lotus teachings, they and their followers Zhao Quan, Qiu Fu, Zhou Yuan, and Qiao Yuan steered Altan Khan into raiding. As soon as the horse trade ended, Altan Khan turned to raiding again. Border officials reproached him, blaming the raids on Qin and his associates. Qin claimed he possessed arts that could breach city walls. The Mongols tried the method and it failed, so they bound Qin and Mingzhen; Quan, Fu, and the others stayed hidden and refused to surrender. Altan Khan again asked to trade horses and cattle for grain and beans, sought Ming patents of office, and secretly arranged with the Hexi tribes to raid inward and break the frontier walls. The emperor was disgusted and ordered the horse market closed and Shi Dao recalled. From then on the raiders pillaged the western frontier almost daily, and the border population was driven to desperation.
63
祿 退 西 鹿
In the thirty-first year, spring, two thousand raiders struck Datong; Commander Wang Gong met them at Pingchuan Stockade and was killed. That summer they entered the Liaodong frontier from the east, besieged Company Commander Chang Lu, and trapped Commanders Yao Damo, Liu Dong, and Liu Qiji at Sandao Gully; all four were killed. Defense Commander Wang Xiang marched to their aid and fought a fierce battle at Si'er Mountain; casualties were roughly even, and the raiders withdrew. Battalion Commander Ye Tingrui brought one hundred men to Wang Xiang's aid. The next day Wang Xiang, wounds bound, intercepted the enemy again at Lali Mountain and fought to the death; when his arrows ran out, he and his three hundred officers and men all perished. Tingrui was wounded to the point of death but recovered; the raiders also pulled back. That year they struck Datong four times, Liaoyang three times, and Ningxia once. The following spring they hit Xuanfu and Yan–Sui. That summer they struck Gansu and Datong. Every defending commander who met them was beaten. That autumn Altan Khan invaded again in force, overran Hunyuan, Lingqiu, and Guangchang, and pressed hard on the passes at Chajian, Futu, and elsewhere. Brigadiers Chen Feng of Guyuan and Zhu Yu of Ningxia marched to reinforce them, fought a major battle, and drove the raiders off. The raiders split their forces, striking Yu in the east and looting Dai and Fanzhi in the west. They then encamped in the Lu and Yan region for twenty days and looted almost every town in Yanqing before shifting camp to the central frontier to threaten Jing and Yuan; only prolonged rain made them withdraw. The Little Prince also took advantage of the moment to raid, striking Chicheng in Xuanfu. Before long Altan Khan returned with ten thousand horsemen, swept through Datong, and looted as far as Bajiao Fort. Grand Coordinator Zhao Shichun went to meet them and clashed at Dachong Ridge; Commander Li Lai was killed, the army was wiped out, and Zhao Shichun escaped only with his life.
64
殿
In the thirty-third year, spring, they entered Chaigou Fort in Xuanfu. That summer they struck Ningxia again; Datong Commander Yue Maozhong was killed in an ambush. That autumn they assaulted the Ji frontier wall from a hundred directions at once. Alarm reports arrived by the dozen each day, and the capital went on full alert. Governor-General Yang Bo defended with all his strength, sent volunteers to strike their camp by night, and the startled raiders broke off and fled. The following year they struck Xuan and Ji repeatedly; Regimental Commanders Zhao Qingkui, Li Guangqi, and Ding Bi were killed in turn. The court posted fresh bounties for Altan Khan's head—ten thousand in gold and a marquisate. Capture of Qiu Fu or Zhou Yuan would bring three hundred taels of gold and a third-grade military commission. Fu and his fellows were then with the enemy; they gathered outlaws, settled at Fengzhou, walled a town, built palaces, opened irrigated fields, and called the settlement Paising. Paising is glossed in Chinese as 'house.' Zhao Quan trained the Mongols, who grew ever more adept at siege and war. Altan Khan valued him highly; before every raid he would feast at Quan's home and ask his counsel.
65
西
In the thirty-fifth year, summer, thirty thousand raiders struck Xuanfu. Brigadier Zhang Hong met them in battle and was killed in defeat. That winter they looted the Datong frontier and then Huan, Qing, and other districts in Shaanxi; Generals Sun Chao and Yuan Zheng drove them off. That year Tümen raided Liaodong again.
66
祿 便紿西 西 婿 退
The next year twenty thousand raiders split up to loot the Datong frontier, killing Defense Commander Tang Tianlu and Detachment Commander Wang Yuan. Altan Khan's brother La Bato massed tens of thousands again, entered at Heiliukou, and struck Yongping and Qian'an; Vice Commander Jiang Chengxun fought to the death. That summer they suddenly struck Maweiliang in Xuanfu; Regimental Commander Qi Mian was killed. That autumn they entered Datong Right Guard again, destroyed more than seventy forts, and killed or captured a great many people. That winter Engi, Altan Khan's son, had a concubine named Taosongzhai who had secretly taken up with the company officer Shoulingge; fearing punishment, she defected. Governor-General Yang Shun touted it as a singular coup and sent her to the capital. Engi came to reclaim her in vain, then looted Datong's stockades and forts and ringed Right Guard again and again. Frightened, Shun lied that the enemy would trade her for Zhao Quan and Qiu Fu. Minister of War Xu Lun approved the scheme; they sent Taosongzhai out of the frontier by night, tricked her into fleeing west, secretly tipped off Engi, and he seized and killed her. Having learned how useless Shun was, the raiders tightened the siege of Right Guard and sent detachments against the Xuan and Ji garrisons. The western frontier was thrown into turmoil; Right Guard's beacon chain went dark for six months. Grand Secretary Yan Song and Xu Lun debated giving up Right Guard. The emperor refused and ordered officials to raise troops and funds, replacing Shun with Vice Minister of War Jiang Dong. The veteran Shang Biao had entered the besieged city with supplies and defended with all his strength; when grain ran out they ate horses and cattle and burned houses for fuel, yet the garrison never wavered. Biao made repeated sorties and captured one of Altan Khan's grandsons, a son-in-law, and a tribal general. Then Vice Minister Jiang Dong, Grand Coordinator Yang Xuan, Commander Zhang Chengxun, and the other relief forces advanced in strength, and the siege was broken. They looted Yongchang, Liangzhou, and Chicheng in Xuanfu, besieged Ganzhou for fourteen days, and then withdrew. Tümen also struck Liaodong repeatedly.
67
使 西退
In the thirty-eighth year, spring, La Bato and Engi planned a major invasion, camped at Huizhou, and sent spies to spread word that they were heading east. Governor-General Wang Yu failed to see through the deception, hurriedly split his forces east, and changed orders repeatedly; the raiders slipped through Panjiakou in the Ji garrison, and Wang Yu was punished. That summer they struck Datong, then turned to loot the eastern and western districts of Xuanfu, camped inside the frontier for ten days, and withdrew only after prolonged rain.
68
西 西
In the thirty-ninth year the raiders massed outside Xifeng Pass, poised to strike the Ji frontier. Datong Commander Liu Han raided their camp at Huihe and forced them to pull back. That autumn Liu Han, with Regimental Commander Wang Mengxia and others, raided Fengzhou, killed one hundred fifty men, and burned Paising nearly to the ground. That year the Datong, Yan–Sui, Ji, and Liaodong frontiers were hit almost every day. The following spring the raiders crossed the frozen river from Hexi; Defense Commander Wang Shichen and Battalion Commander Li Hu were killed. That autumn they struck Xuanfu and Juyong. That winter they looted the Shaanxi and Ningxia frontier. They then split a force eastward and captured Gaizhou.
69
西 西
In the forty-first year, summer, Tümen entered Fushun and was beaten by Commander Hei Chun. That winter they attacked Fenghuang City again; Hei Chun fought for two days and nights and was killed. Hai and Jin suffered especially heavy killing and looting. That winter Altan Khan struck the Shanxi and Ningxia frontier repeatedly. Yan–Sui Commander Zhao Ke split his elite troops: Lieutenant General Li Xijing marched east from Shenmu Fort and raided the enemy camp at Banpo Mountain, while Xu Zhizhong marched west from Dingbian Camp and struck enemy horsemen at Qiaomai Lake; both columns won, taking one hundred nineteen heads.
70
退 西
In the forty-second year, spring, the raiders entered Dishui Cliff in Xuanfu; Liu Han drove them off. The raiders then shifted east and struck the Liaodong frontier repeatedly. That autumn Commander Yang Zhao was killed in defeat. Ji–Liao Governor-General Yang Xuan then imprisoned Tonghan, chief of the Three Guards, and kept his sons as rotating hostages. Tonghan was Engi's father-in-law; the court hoped to use him to restrain Engi, but all Three Guards were resentful. That winter they looted Shunyi and Sanhe on a large scale. Generals Zhao Qin and Sun Bin were killed, and the capital went on full alert. Datong Commander Jiang Yingxiong met them at Miyun, routed them, and the raiders withdrew. The emperor ordered Yang Xuan executed. The next year Tümen entered Liaodong; Censor-in-Chief Liu Tao reported the generals' defensive successes, noting that a sudden surge of seawater had drowned many raiders. The emperor said, "The sea god has shown its power." He ordered the relevant offices to offer sacrifices and report back; Liu Tao and the others were all rewarded. That winter the raiders struck Shaanxi and looted Banqiao, Xiangzhai'er, and other towns.
71
西 殿
In the forty-fourth year, spring, they struck Xiaotuanshan in eastern Liaodong; Regimental Commander Xian Bugun and Brigadier Yang Weifan were killed. That summer they struck Suzhou; Commander Liu Chengye met them and won both engagements. That autumn Huang Taiji, Altan Khan's son, led light cavalry in a sudden thrust from Ximolin in Xuanfu and looted the interior at will. Detachment Commander Jiang Rudong lay in wait at Anzhuang Fort with two hundred elite troops, suddenly encountered Huang Taiji, and closed with him hand to hand. Huang Taiji was unhorsed and swept away by his own men. Huang Taiji was badly hurt and did not regain consciousness until the following day. The next year Altan Khan raided the eastern and western border passes again and again. That summer Garrison Commander Lang Degong of Qinghe intercepted him at Zhangneng Pass and won the day. That winter Regimental Commander Cui Shirong of Datong fought the enemy at Fanpi Ridge and fell, along with his sons Dachao and Dabin. Qiu Fu had died by then, and Zhao Quan grew ever more influential among the Mongols, styling Altan Khan as emperor and erecting palaces for him. On the day set for raising the ridgepole, a sudden gale struck; the beam crashed down and injured several men. Altan Khan was shaken and never dared occupy the palace again. Vice Minister Tan Lun was rebuilding the Ji garrison's fighting strength; Quan urged Altan Khan to leave Ji alone and strike Datong instead, where the garrison was weak enough to plunder at will.
72
西
In the second year the raiders struck Chaigou; Garrison Commander Han Shangzhong was killed in the fighting. Wang Chonggu was then overseeing the western frontier as vice minister of war, while Li Chengliang held Liaodong; again and again they ambushed raiders beyond the passes. Once the raiders found the frontier prepared, their incursions grew less frequent.
73
輿 使 使 使
In the fourth year, autumn, Huang Taiji struck Jinzhou; Commander Wang Zhidao and Regimental Commander Lang Degong charged into the enemy with barely a dozen riders and were killed. That winter: Altan Khan's grandson Bahannaji, son of his third son Tiebei Taiji, had lost his parents young and was raised in Altan Khan's wife's household. When he came of age, he married a woman named Bigi. Bahannaji then betrothed the daughter of Ao'er Dusi—Altan Khan's own granddaughter, and a great beauty—only for Altan Khan to take her for himself. Enraged, Bahannaji led ten followers, including Alige, to defect to the Ming. Datong Grand Coordinator Fang Fengshi accepted the defectors and reported to Governor-General Wang Chonggu. Chonggu memorialized: "Bahannaji's surrender is not the usual case of a tribal leader arriving with a host. We should grant him office and rank, lodge and feed him generously, and provide horses and transport—all to send a message to Altan Khan. If Altan Khan grows alarmed, demand that he hand over the Banjin defectors bound and under guard; if he refuses, threaten Bahannaji's life to deter him; and if none of that works, settle him in comfort—after the Han model of dependent states among the Wuhuan—so he can rally his old followers and resettle them near the frontier; When Altan Khan grows old and dies and Huang Taiji succeeds him, send Bahannaji back so his followers can check Huang Taiji while we hold our army in reserve to back him. The throne approved. Bahannaji was made an assistant commander, and Alige a chief company commander.
74
西 使 使
Altan Khan was raiding Tibet when he heard the news and rushed back, mustering the tribes for a joint invasion; Chonggu ordered every frontier command to mobilize in defense. An envoy came to negotiate; Chonggu sent the interpreter Bao Chongde with word that the court had treated Bahannaji with great honor, and that if Altan Khan delivered Zhao Quan and the other Banjin rebels bound by morning, Bahannaji would return that same night. Altan Khan was delighted. Sending everyone else away, he said: "I do not make trouble—Zhao Quan and his crowd do. If the emperor would grant me a princely title and leave me to govern the northern tribes, who would dare make trouble? Even after I die, my grandson will inherit the title—and having eaten China's bounty, how could he betray that kindness? He then sent more envoys with Chongde to sue for enfeoffment, offered horses in exchange for Chinese iron pots, cloth, and silk, and handed over Zhao Quan, Li Zixin, and several others. By imperial order Chonggu sent Bahannaji home; the young prince lingered, wept in gratitude, bowed twice, and only then left. Overjoyed to have his grandson back, Altan Khan sent a memorial of thanks.
75
婿 使 使 使 使 使 使 西 使 西 使
Chonggu memorialized again: "If the court grants Altan Khan enfeoffment and tribute, the frontiers may know several years of peace—time enough to rebuild our defenses. If they break faith, we can fight from the treasury and strength we will have stored up—far better than spending year after year in frantic self-defense. He appended an eight-point program to his request. First: settle titles, enfeoffments, and official ranks. By tribal seniority Altan Khan stands first among them; he should receive a princely title and an official seal. Major branches—La Bato, Huang Taiji, and Jinang's eldest son Jining among them—should all be made regional commanders. Younger brothers, nephews, and grandsons—forty-six branches in all, including Ushen Da'erhan—should receive assistant commander appointments. Altan Khan's dozen-odd branches of sons-in-law should receive company command appointments. Second: fix tribute quotas. One tribute mission each year: Altan Khan ten horses and ten envoys. La Bato, Jining, and Huang Taiji eight horses apiece and four envoys apiece. Each tribal leader, graded by the size of his following, should send four horses for a large tribe or two for a small one, with two envoys in either case. In all, annual tribute horses must not exceed five hundred, nor envoys one hundred fifty. Horses should be graded in three tiers; the thirty finest teams go to the throne, the rest are purchased at graded prices, and old or emaciated animals are rejected. Of the envoys, sixty may enter the capital each year; the rest remain at the frontier. On their return, envoys may use the horse payments to buy silk, cloth, and other goods. Rewards should be paid on the same scale as for the Three Guards and the western Tibetan states. Third: settle the tribute schedule and route. In spring and at the grand assembly for the emperor's birthday, envoys, horses, and memorials should enter through inspection at Datong Left Guard, with rewards issued on arrival. Those remaining at the frontier should be sent to the appropriate cities for inspection and reward by the local coordinators and garrison commanders. Those bound for the capital should be escorted in through Juyong Pass. Fourth: establish horse markets. The rules should follow the early Hongzhi precedent for the northern Three Tribute missions. The tribes would bring gold, silver, cattle, horses, pelts, horsetails, and the like; merchants would offer satin, cloth, cauldrons, iron pots, and the like. On market days up to three hundred men may camp outside the frontier: at Wanquan Right Guard and Zhangjiakou for Xuanfu, and at Shuiquanying for Shanxi. Fifth: settle pacification rewards. Market guards should receive two bolts of cloth each; tribal leaders two bolts of satin and two of thin silk. For envoys who arrive in good faith, rewards and gifts should be added according to their rank. Sixth: settle policy on defectors. Once tribute relations are established, defectors are to be accepted whether guilty or innocent, without being turned away. Chinese captives returning to allegiance may enter only after investigation shows they committed no theft while among the enemy. Seventh: distinguish enduring principle from temporary expedient. Eighth: guard against cunning evasions and false pretenses.
76
西 西西
The memorial was received and referred to the court for deliberation. The emperor at last accepted Chonggu's advice and enfeoffed Altan Khan as Prince of Shunyi, granting him a set of red python robes; Kundulun and Huang Taiji were made vice regional commanders, each receiving a set of red lion robes and four lengths of colored silk, lining and cover; Bintu Taiji and ten others were made vice assistant commanders; Namur Taiji and nineteen others were made assistant commanders-in-chief; Da'erhan Taiji and eighteen others were made chief company commanders; Abai Taiji and twelve others were made deputy company commanders; Qia Taiji and two others were made platoon commanders. Kundulun was La Bato. The Ministry of War adopted Chonggu's plan and issued market regulations. The autumn market opened; more than five hundred horses were acquired in all, and Altan Khan and the others received graded gifts of colored silk. Jining of the western tribes and his nephew Qiejin also asked for markets; an edict granted them at Hongshandun and Qingshuiying. When the market opened, Jining was also enfeoffed as vice regional commander. Before long Altan Khan asked for a gold-letter sutra and lamas; the throne granted both. Chonggu asked again for a jade seal; the throne granted a gold- and silver-plated seal instead. In his old age Altan Khan turned fervently to Buddhism and asked to build a temple south of the frontier; the throne granted it the name Yanghua. Altan Khan often kept to distant Qingshan. He had two sons: Bintu, who lived at Songshan directly north of Lanzhou, and Bingtu, who lived at the Western Sea directly west of Hezhou. Both pressed for horse markets and were often arrogant and unruly. Altan Khan rebuked them, and they gradually grew more tractable.
77
In Wanli year six, Chengliang led Brigadier Qin Deyi and others against the enemy at Dongchang Fort, beheading nine tribal leaders and eight hundred eighty-four others; Governor-General Liang Menglong reported the victory. The emperor was delighted, offered sacrifices at the suburban altars and ancestral temple, and announced the victory at the Gate of Imperial Supremacy.
78
退
In the seventh year, winter, Tümen entered Jinchuan Camp with forty thousand horsemen. Menglong, Chengliang, and Commander Qi Jiguang had already received Grand Secretary Zhang Juzheng's battle plan in advance; fighting together in prepared defense, they forced the enemy to withdraw. From then on the raiders came again and again; Chengliang and his colleagues defeated them repeatedly, often beheading their great chiefs, and also struck beyond the passes from time to time with heavy losses inflicted on the enemy. The raiders feared them and pulled back somewhat; for his merit Chengliang was enfeoffed as Earl of Ningyuan.
79
Once Altan Khan had entered the horse markets, he dealt with the court with scrupulous care. When his men looted border villagers, he punished them and kowtowed in apology to the court; the court, in turn, richly rewarded him. In the tenth year, spring, Altan Khan died; the emperor granted seven altars of sacrifice, twelve lengths of colored silk, lining and cover, and one hundred bolts of cloth as a mark of special favor. His wife Khatun led her son Huang Taiji and the others in submitting a memorial and presenting horses in thanks; the court again granted graded gifts of silk and cloth. Huang Taiji was enfeoffed as Prince of Shunyi and given the name Qiqingha. Three years after his succession he died; the court granted the usual condolence honors.
80
西禿西 禿
In the fifteenth year, spring, his son Chelik succeeded him. His wife, Third Lady, was the granddaughter Altan Khan had seized and taken for himself; married in turn to three khans, she held real military power, guarded the frontier for China, and was feared and obeyed by all. The throne enfeoffed her as Lady of Zhongshun, and for twenty years no armies were needed from Xuan-Datong to Gansu. When Chelik moved west to the distant frontier, the Ordos leader Zhuang Tulai and others seized Shuitang, while Bushitu, Huoluo Chi, and others held the Mangla and Nie'gong valleys, repeatedly raiding the country between Ganzhou, Liangzhou, Taozhou, Minzhou, and Xining. Dozens of other tribes, at least, lurked below the passes, raiding or submitting by turns with no fixed pattern. The emperor was disgusted; in the nineteenth year an edict cut off Chelik's horse markets and frontier rewards altogether. Before long Chelik came to the frontier to surrender, led his people back east, and only Zhuang Tulai, Bushitu, and the like continued to raid as before. That winter, Ming'an and Tumei of a separate division attacked the Yulin frontier on separate fronts. Regional Commander Du Tong met them in battle, killed and captured five hundred men, and slew Ming'an.
81
禿 西 西 退 西 西
In the twentieth year, the Ningxia rebel generals Baba and others joined with Bushitu, Zhuang Tulai, and others for a major raid. Regional Commander Li Rusong routed them. In the twenty-second year, Yansui Grand Coordinator Li Chunguang memorialized: "The Ordos tribes submitted long ago, but since Ming'an was killed their bitterness for raiding runs deep. With the Western Xia faction in rebellion and tribute markets cut off, the Yan region has been embroiled year after year. Now the eastern and western tribes are all asking to submit, but Bushitu's private motives are impossible to read. The frontier is long, our troops are few, and keeping control is hard. We should read the enemy's intentions and weigh the circumstances of the moment. When the enemy invades, fight without holding back; if commanders suffer a minor setback now and then, their cases should be judged leniently. If the enemy is genuinely willing to submit, we may entertain pacification when the moment is right—but we must never neglect war readiness." The emperor ordered the Ministry of War to relay these instructions to every frontier command. That autumn Bushitu entered Guyuan. Mobile Corps Commander Shi Jian was killed in battle. Yansui Regional Commander Ma Gui met him in battle, and Bushitu did not withdraw until a month had passed. All of Shaanxi was shaken. That year the eastern chieftain Chao Hua attacked Zhenwu Fort. Regional Commander Dong Yiyuan met him in battle and won a crushing victory. The following spring, Zaiseng and others of the Song division raided Shaanxi. Governor-general Ye Mengxiong directed the defense and drove them back. That autumn Yong Shaobu of the Hai tribe raided Xining. Three Frontiers Governor-general Li Min ordered Assistant Regional Commander Da Yun, Mobile Corps Commander Bai Ze, and the dependent tribes Maqisa, Bu'erjia, and others to lay an ambush. They crushed the raiders and took six hundred eighty-three heads. When news of the victory reached court, the emperor was delighted. Because the dependent tribes had fought loyally, he also credited the former frontier commander Zheng Luo retroactively and extended rewards to Luo himself.
82
西
In the twenty-fourth year, spring, Governor-general Li Li led crack troops out in three columns beyond the passes, struck Bushitu's camp, took four hundred nine heads, and seized thousands of horses, livestock, and weapons. Huoluo Chi's followers again prowled around Taozhou. Li dispatched Assistant Regional Commander Zhou Guozhu and others to strike them at the headwaters of the Mangla River and took one hundred thirty-six heads. That autumn Zhuli Tu, Achitu, Huoluo Chi, and others joined forces to raid the west, while Chao Hua also led a large host against Guangning. The frontier garrisons met them with full force and drove them back. In the twenty-fifth year, autumn, the Hai tribes raided the Gansu frontier. Government troops beat them back. That winter Chao Hua rallied the Tuman tribes and others to raid Liaodong, killing and plundering without measure. The following summer they raided Liaodong again. Regional Commander Li Rusong led a deep strike against their camps and was killed. That winter Li and others attacked Huoluo Chi and his allies at Songshan in separate columns, drove them off, and recovered the ground.
83
禿
In the twenty-seventh year an edict restored Chelik's horse markets and frontier rewards. At that time Li and others were fortifying Songshan. The tribes broke into revolt one after another; the garrison commanders of Yan and Ning joined forces and killed or captured nearly three thousand armored leaders. The following year Zhuli Tu, Zaiseng, Zhuang Tulai, and others asked to submit, but the court refused. Frontier officials Wang Jianbin and others petitioned again on their behalf, and an edict restored tribute markets for the Ordos tribes.
84
西使
In the thirty-first year the Hai tribes repeatedly breached the Shaanxi frontier. Military Preparation Vice Commissioner Li Zishi and Regional Commanders Xiao Ruxun and Da Yun drove them back. In the thirty-third year, summer, the eastern chieftain Zaisai lured and killed Qingyun Fort defensive commander Xiong Yao. An edict cut off his horse markets and rewards.
85
西 西
In the thirty-fifth year, summer, Governor-general Xu Sanwei wrote: "The Ordos tribes and the tribes east of the river are not alike. The eastern tribes answer to a single authority; their covenants were fixed decades ago and have held for thirty years without change. The Ordos split into forty-two branches, each lord fighting the others for supremacy. Bushitu holds little more than an empty title over them. In the west Huoluo Chi is the most cunning, his demands and extortion the most insatiable; In the center Bai Yantai, nursing his father's death at Ming'an's hands, raids without fail year after year; In the east Shaji vies to control the tribute markets and runs wild alongside Chao Hua. The western frontier has been in turmoil for years. Yet though they claim a hundred thousand men, split into forty-two branches the largest bands field no more than two or three thousand riders, and the smallest only one or two thousand. We should divide their strength, accept their submissions, reward those who come first, and fight those who hold back. Even so, we must keep fighting readiness at the center of policy to uphold the empire's prestige." By then the court had already allowed Zaisai, Huoluo Chi, and their allies to reopen tribute markets.
86
西西 沿 西
Before long Chelik died without an heir. Lady of Zhongshun continued to lead her followers in paying tribute as before. In the west Yinding and Daiqing repeatedly led their followers in raids on both the eastern and western frontiers. Mengkeshili of the Yansui division also raided constantly along the frontier, using tribute demands as leverage. Bushitu sought a marriage alliance with Lady of Zhongshun; she refused. Sudai Taiji, Wulu Taiji, and other subordinate chiefs refused to yield to one another, and their court titles had long remained unsettled. In the forty-first year Bushitu finally married into Lady of Zhongshun's house. Chiefs from the eastern and western tribes all petitioned the court to enfeoff him. Lady of Zhongshun soon died. An edict enfeoffed Bushitu as Prince of Shunyi and, because Bahannibi had long served loyally, enfeoffed her as Lady of Zhongyi. Bushitu was Chelik's grandson. By the time he inherited his title his power had already waned; he controlled only the twelve tribes beyond the Shan and Da garrisons. Subordinate chiefs such as Wulu, Sudai, and Wushen Taiji commanded forces equal to the Prince of Shunyi's own. On the recommendation of Xuan-Datong Governor-general Tu Zongjun, the court granted each the usual promotions and rewards.
87
西
That year Chao Hua joined with Hudun Tu to raid Liaodong three times. Hudun Tu lived in Chahar lands and was also known as the Chahar prince—a descendant of the Yuan house. His ancestor Dalai Sun first grazed his herds outside the Xuan frontier. Altan Khan was then at the height of his power, and fearing annexation he moved his tents to Liaodong, gathered the Fuyu and other mixed tribes, and repeatedly raided west of Ji. Four generations later Hudun Tu had grown stronger still. The following summer Chao Hua joined Zaisai and Nuan Tu in a raid thirty thousand strong, pushing as far as Pinglu and Daning. They then sought pacification payments—and got them.
88
In the forty-second year Mengkeshili raided Huaiyuan and Baoning. Yansui Regional Commander Guan Bingzhong and others routed him. Two hundred twenty-one heads were taken. The following year the Chahar division raided Liaodong repeatedly. Before long they sacked Yizhou, overran Da'an Fort, and killed a great many soldiers and civilians.
89
西
In the forty-fourth year Regional Commander Du Wenhuan repeatedly defeated Mengkeshili and other Ordos leaders on the Yansui frontier. Huoluo Chi, Bai Yantai, Jining, Qiejin, Daiqing, Shaji, and chiefs from east and west alike grew afraid and petitioned one after another to reopen tribute markets.
90
西滿 滿
In the forty-sixth year the armies of our Great Qing rose up, overrunning Fushun and Kaiyuan. The Chahar tribe seized the moment to gather a host and demand frontier payments. In the west Ayun's wife Mandan also led ten thousand riders through the Shitang road to raid Baima Pass in the Ji region and the forts of Gaojia, Fengjia, and others. Mobile Corps Commander Zhu Wanliang met them in battle and was surrounded. Urgent dispatches arrived by the dozen each day, and the court and provinces went on full alert. Before long Mandan also came to the passes seeking to reopen tribute relations.
91
In the forty-seventh year Qing forces destroyed Zaisai and the northern pass chiefs Jintai Shi, Buyanggu, and others. Jintai Shi's granddaughter was married to Hudun Tu. Ji-Liao Governor-general Wen Qiu, Grand Coordinator Zhou Yongchun, and others therefore bought him off, had him join with Chao Hua and other tribes to resist the Qing armies, and paid him four thousand taels of silver. The following year—the first year of the Taichang reign—additional payments were raised to forty thousand taels. Hudun Tu then declared he would aid China—and his demands knew no limit.
92
西 西
In the first year of Tianqi, autumn, Jining raided the Yansui frontier. Yulin Regional Commander Du Wenhuan routed him. The following spring he launched a major raid on Huanghuayu in Yan'an, penetrating six hundred li deep and killing or carrying off tens of thousands of civilians. In the third year, spring, Yinding rallied his followers for another raid on the western frontier. Government troops defeated him. The following spring he tried to return to his old base and attacked Songshan, but frontier commander Feng Ren and others defeated him. That summer he joined Haixi chieftain Guliu Taiji and others in a raid on Gansu. Regional Commander Dong Jishu met them in battle and took more than three hundred heads. That year Daiqing caused a riot at the frontier over his reward payment, and local border troops killed him. Daiqing was a close kinsman of Hudun Tu. Frontier officials proposed paying slightly more than thirteen thousand taels a year in blood-money compensation, but Hudun Tu was aggrieved and more inclined than ever to break away. Before long Qing forces struck and shattered Chao Hua. His followers scattered, and half of them went over to Chahar. By then Bushitu's power had waned further still; his orders no longer carried among the tribes, and chiefs such as Gan'erma raided the Yansui frontier year after year. Qiqing Taiji, Aomu Biji, Maoqitan Biji, and others also led their bands back and forth, prowling below the passes.
93
西 西西 使
In the first year of Chongzhen Hudun Tu attacked Haracina, Baitai Taiji, Bushitu, and their allies, defeating them all. He then pressed his advantage and breached the Xuan-Datong frontier. That autumn the emperor held court on the terrace platform, summoned Governor-general Wang Xiangqian, and asked his strategy. Xiangqian answered: "The way to counter the Chahar is to set them against one another. Bushitu has already fled west into the Ordos. Baitai Taiji alone escaped with his life, while most of Haracina's followers have been captured and are of little use. Yong Shaobu is the strongest, with some three hundred thousand men. Together with Bushitu's followers, the thirty-six Doyan clans, and Haracina's remaining bands, he could hold Chahar in check. But rather than pit them against each other, it would be better to pacify them and put them to use." The emperor said: "The Chahar clearly has no mind to accept pacification. What then?" He answered: "We must win them over patiently." The emperor said: "And if they refuse to submit?" Xiangqian submitted a secret memorial. The emperor approved and ordered him to go discuss the matter jointly with supreme commander Yuan Chonghuan. When Xiangqian reached the frontier he and Chonghuan agreed on a plan: secure the west and the east would settle of its own accord; if Hudun Tu refused to submit, both fronts would be strained at once. They therefore settled on paying the Chahar eighty-one thousand taels of silver annually as a tethering payment. Datong Grand Coordinator Zhang Zongheng wrote: "The Chahar have come to Xuan-Datong and camp at New Town, barely two hundred li from Datong. Three months have passed and they still dare not advance. Starving and destitute, they are no better off than we are. The Chahar live on pacification payments. They have gone two years without receiving them; their supplies are gone, their food exhausted and horses spent, and bleached bones litter the wild. The Chahar long for submission no less than farmers long for harvest—and we shower them with silks, cattle, sheep, tea, fruit, and grain without measure. We are giving them exactly what they want. The Chahar are arrogant and insolent beyond what eyes can watch or ears can hear—and even while begging to submit they behave like this. If the Chahar's warriors and horses were well fed, how wild their depredations would be—words can scarcely describe it." Xiangqian argued: "The submission talks were nearly settled—to unravel them now would show the Chahar we cannot be trusted, and it is no way to serve the state." When the memorial reached court, the emperor sided with Xiangqian and ordered Zongheng not to dissent.
94
The following autumn Hudun Tu gathered a host at Hongshui Beach in Yansui, demanded additional payments without success, and immediately turned to raiding beyond the passes. Regional Commander Wu Zimian drove him back. Before long he went over to the Qing and joined their attack on Longmen. Before long he was defeated by Qing forces. In the summer of the sixth year, hearing that Qing armies were coming, the Chahar drove all their people across the river and fled. By then the Tartar tribes were submitting to the Qing one after another. The following year the Qing army assembled the tribes on the south bank of the Usun River and issued military regulations. Ligdan was already dead; the Qing pursued to Shangdu and took all the Chahar women, children, and followers captive.
95
祿 便
Afterward the Ordos tribes raided Ningxia, Ganzhou, and Liangzhou yearly; Chen Qiyu, Ma Shilong, Hong Chengchou, and others repeatedly defeated them. The Ordos leader Gendenma was also killed by Regional Commander You Shilu. Throughout the Ming the frontier never knew peace, and banditry swarmed across the central plains. Officials clung to the ease of tribute markets with Altan and others; seeing the Chahar run riot in the east, they paid out hundreds of thousands yearly hoping for a night’s peace and dreaming of turning them to Ming use—but never could. In the end, before the Ming fell the Chahar were destroyed first and all the tribes submitted to the Qing. State finances grew strained, frontier affairs desperate, and court debate chaotic—and the Ming became beyond saving.
96
西 姿
Tartar lands stretched east to the Uriyangqad and west to the Oirats. In the Hongwu, Yongle, and Xuande reigns the empire was at its height and largely held the nomads in check, yet loyalty and rebellion never held steady. After Zhengtong frontier defenses collapsed and imperial prestige waned. Tribal chiefs, often men of heroic stature, relied on brute force and rose in turn to challenge the Central Realm. Frontier disaster thus ran from the Ming’s beginning to its end.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →