← Back to 南齊書

卷四十九 列傳第三十 王奐 從弟繢 張沖

Volume 49 Biographies 30: Wang Huan, Cong Dihui, Zhang Cong

Chapter 49 of 南齊書 · Book of Southern Qi
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 49
Next Chapter →
1
Wang Huan
2
祿
Wang Huan, whose style name was Yansun, came from Linyi in Langya Commandery. His grandfather Senglang had been Left Director of the Imperial Secretariat in the Song, with commissioner rank equal to the Three Excellencies. His father Cui had served as Gentleman at the Yellow Gate. Huan had been given in adoption to succeed his father's cousin Qiu, Secretariat Director, and therefore took the style name Yansun.
3
簿 西
Upon taking his first office he served successively as Assistant Editor in the Secretariat, Attendant in the Heir Apparent's Household, chief clerk to the Champion General in Prince Anlu's household, Groom in the Heir Apparent's Household, provincial aide in his home commandery, Secretariat Gentleman, adviser to the Minister of Works for Prince Guiyang, and Gentleman at the Yellow Gate. In the first year of the Yuanhui era he was made chief administrator to the General Who Subdues the Barbarians for the Prince of Jinxi and Interior Administrator of Jiangxia, then promoted to Palace Attendant while retaining the post of Colonel of the Footsoldiers. He was again sent out as chief administrator to the General Who Guards the West for the Prince of Jinxi, with the additional rank of General Who Establishes Valor and the posts of Grand Administrator of Jiangxia and Wuchang. He was recalled to serve as Minister of the Imperial Clan and then put in charge of the Ministry of Personnel.
4
At the opening of the Shengming era he was transferred to General Who Establishes Valor and Intendant of Danyang. Earlier, Wang Yan's father Puyao had served as chief administrator to Shen Youzhi and had long worried that Youzhi would rebel and that he would never get home. When Huan headed the Ministry of Personnel he transferred Puyao to a capital post, for which Yan felt deep gratitude. When Yan took office in Emperor Shizu's princely household, Huan's cousin Yun rose in rebellion. Shizu said to Yan, "Wang Huan is a Song imperial in-law, and Wang Yun is close kin to the rebels. Men of the same clan—how can they not harbor divided loyalties? I intend to lay the whole matter before the throne." Yan kowtowed and said, "Wang Huan is scrupulous and restrained; I warrant that he harbors no disloyal intent. My parents are in the capital—let them stand as hostages for him." Shizu thereupon dropped the matter.
5
西 使 西
He was sent out as Grand Administrator of Wuxing at the middle two-thousand-picul rank, retaining his general's title. Before long his designation was raised to General Who Subdues the Barbarians. He was then advanced in rank to General of the Left. The following year he was appointed Minister of Ceremonies and tutor to the Prince of Poyang, then moved to Palace Attendant and Director of the Secretariat while retaining the post of General of Valiant Cavalry. He was again transferred to General Who Subdues the Barbarians, chief administrator to the General Who Guards the West for the Prince of Linchuan, and concurrently Colonel of the Southern Barbarians and Interior Administrator of Nan Commandery. Huan changed posts three times in a single year. He submitted a memorial firmly declining the post of Colonel of the Southern Barbarians, writing, "Heaven and earth have only just been renewed and all things put on a fresh footing; the barbarians of Jing have submitted, and Ba and Pu are untroubled. If the border people are left to prosper in their work and the responsible offices carry out their duties, this old provincial seat of our headquarters grows more prosperous by the day. Your servant once traveled in the western regions and saw for himself how prosperity and ruin alternate; and since the recent wars, the devastation has been so severe that recovery is still difficult. Even with good government binding the wounds, the land has not yet returned to life. To carve off yet another command from the great headquarters and set up a separate colonel's office—an exalted title will not make the region stronger; in plain truth, how can splitting authority do anything but weaken it? Once resources and manpower are divided, offices and duties multiply, the people's burdens double, and paperwork becomes ever more oppressive. It is not only that your servant foresees the difficulty—I venture to believe the plan ill serves the state." His request was granted. The post of Colonel of the Southern Barbarians was accordingly abolished. He was advanced in rank to General of the Van.
6
使
When Shizu ascended the throne, Huan was recalled as Right Vice Director of the Imperial Secretariat. He was soon transferred to bearer of the staff of authority supervising military affairs in Xiang Province, with the ranks of General of the Van and Governor of Xiang Province. He was then transferred to Supernumerary Regular Attendant of the Scattered Cavalry and Governor of Jiang Province. On this occasion the military headquarters of Jiang Province was abolished for the first time. In the fourth year he was appointed Right Vice Director and provincial rectifier for his home commandery. Huan had no scholarly training but was advanced on account of his executive talent. He was promoted to Vice Director of the Imperial Secretariat while retaining his post as rectifier. The registrar Wang Zhi, acting under Ministry of Personnel Gentleman Kong Xiuzhi, had registrar clerk Yu Gongxi seek a promotion while falsely invoking Huan's authority; Zhi was dismissed from office.
7
使 使
In the sixth year he was made Supernumerary Regular Attendant of the Scattered Cavalry and General of the Guards. Huan wished to invite the emperor to visit his residence. In his later years the emperor had come to believe in Buddhism and would not have animals slaughtered for the imperial table. He sent Wang Yan to tell Huan, "These past years I have given up slaughter for my meals and no longer visit the homes of high ministers; that policy is fixed—there is no room for a sudden exception." When Wang Jian died, the emperor wished to appoint Huan Director of the Imperial Secretariat and asked Wang Yan's opinion. Yan's standing was already great, and he and Huan could not readily yield to each other; he answered, "Liu Shilong commands great prestige—it would hardly be fitting to rank him below Huan." Huan was therefore made Left Vice Director with the added post of Attendant Within the Gates, then sent out as bearer of the staff of authority, Supernumerary Regular Attendant of the Scattered Cavalry, commander of military affairs in Yong, Liang, Northern Qin, Southern Qin, Jingling in Jing Province, and Suixiang in Si Province, General Who Guards the North, and Governor of Yong Province. The emperor said to Wang Yan, "Huan's devotion to Buddhism is truly excessive. In his province he may let it interfere with his duties; when you see him, mention it in passing—but do not say it came from me." Because the garrison troops on the northern marches were mostly in rags, the emperor sent three thousand pairs of trousers for Huan to distribute among them.
8
使
In the eleventh year Huan killed on his own authority Liu Xingzu, chief administrator of the Pacification of the Barbarians. The emperor was furious and ordered Imperial Censor Kong Zhigui to memorialize the case as follows:
9
: 使
The Governor of Yong Province, Wang Huan, reported and had arrested his minor headquarters chief administrator Liu Xingzu, falsely charging that "Xingzu has incited the mountain barbarians, plotted rebellion, spread slanderous falsehoods, and spoken insubordinately." An imperial order directed that Xingzu be sent to the capital; fearing that his report would be exposed as false, Huan beat him to death in prison and falsely reported that he had hanged himself. Even now the wounds on the body are plain for all to see, and the affair has come to the court's attention.
10
: 便 便 使 使便 便 使
Xingzu's student Liu Ni was brought to the capital for questioning and testified that "Xingzu and Huan served together but could not get along. Last year Zhu Gong'en led a campaign against the barbarians and met defeat; Xingzu reported this and presented the report to Huan, who thereafter bore him a grudge. If Xingzu were truly guilty, the matter should have been known among the people; yet among the people all was calm and no such facts existed. On the eighteenth day of the ninth month two years ago, Huan sent thirty armed attendants who claimed an imperial order to arrest Xingzu and commit him to prison. A barbarian of Anding Commandery had earlier committed private graft in the prefecture; Xingzu, knowing the details of his bribes, at once submitted a written report, but Huan made no inquiry. After Xingzu was arrested, Huan still had that barbarian lead armed attendants to guard him in prison. Before he died, Xingzu scratched a secret message on a lacquered tray in prison and sent it to his family, declaring his innocence and asking them to petition that he be brought to the capital for a hearing—he would accept any punishment without regret." He also said, "Huan placed Xingzu under strict guard and cut off messengers, intending to seize an opportunity to kill him and silence him." He also said, "That was indeed Huan's intent. Huan's third son Biao was with him in the province and meddled in every decision, inciting plots to have Xingzu secretly eliminated." He also said, "Xingzu's family sent gruel in which poison had been placed; after two mouthfuls he fell ill and begged the jailer—everyone who ate of it was violently purged. Xingzu cried out, 'There is poison in the gruel!' Every household near the prison heard it." He also said, "Huan pressed Xingzu harder day by day; plainly there was no hope of survival. On the twenty-first day of the eleventh month, Huan sent prison clerks to tell Xingzu's family that he had hanged himself in prison. When the body was brought out, the family washed it together and found wounds on the neck, blackened shoulders, and shattered private parts—clearly he had not died by hanging. Family and retainers alike witnessed it—many people, not one alone." Tian Wenxi, who had remained in Yong Province, was examined again; his testimony matched Ni's in every detail.
11
: 使
Xingzu in prison had suffered bitterly while awaiting the court's mercy; having received the gracious decree, his long hope was at last fulfilled—how could he at that moment take his own life? The decree arrived on the nineteenth and Xingzu died on the twenty-first; weighed by reason and evidence, the fraud is glaringly clear. An imperial messenger was shortly to escort him to the capital, yet Huan defied the decree. Every charge of slander came entirely from Huan's own design. He slandered the late Chancellor Chen Xianda and reviled the court—nothing could be more grave. Biao had followed his father to the province without authorization and dared to violate the law—his crimes together warrant the utmost penalty.
12
西
The emperor sent Palace Gentleman Lu Wenxian and Direct Gate General Cao Daogang with five hundred palace guards to arrest Huan. He ordered Chief Administrator Cao Hu of the General Who Guards the West to march overland from Jiangling and rendezvous at Xiangyang.
13
婿 使 西
Huan's son Biao had always been fierce and violent, and Huan could not control him. His son-in-law Yin Rui, fearing disaster, said to Huan, "Cao and Lu have come without showing the true decree—I fear treachery; you should arrest them at once and send an urgent report to the throne. Huan accepted the advice. Biao at once mustered more than a thousand men in the province, opened the headquarters arsenal, issued arms and armor, drew up troops in the southern hall, closed the gates, and prepared to resist. Huan's student Zheng Yu kowtowed and begged Huan to go out and welcome the envoys from the capital. Huan said, "I am no rebel; I wish first to send a memorial in my own defense. I only fear that petty men like Cao and Lu will abuse us—so for the moment I close the gates and hold my ground." Biao then went out to fight Hu's army; his follower Fan Hu led two hundred men over to the capital forces, and Biao was beaten and fled back inside. Local men rose and attacked the western gate of the headquarters; Biao mounted the gate to fight them off and repulsed them. Huan's chief administrator Huang Yaoqi and Pei Shuye, chief administrator of the Pacification of the Barbarians, raised troops inside the city to attack him. Hearing that troops had entered, Huan went inside to worship the Buddha; before he could rise, the soldiers cut him down. He was fifty-nine years old. Biao, his brothers Shuang and Bi, and Yin Rui were seized and all put to death.
14
忿 使
An edict declared: "The rebel Wang Huan has been treacherous and perverse from youth to age. Outwardly he affected frugality and diligence; inwardly he harbored fierce malice, offending his neighbors and earning the contempt of the gentry. He was promoted for his clerical skill to conspicuous office and sent to govern Fan'e, where government and punishments fell into disorder. His third son Biao arrogantly wielded power as though father and son were equals. The former chief administrator of the Pacification of the Barbarians, Liu Xingzu, had been loyal in state service and steadfastly corrected him in every matter; Huan resented his independence, falsely charged him with slander, in rage had him imprisoned, and only then reported to the throne. We perceived Huan's foolish deceit and ordered Xingzu sent back to the capital; then, fearing that his plot would be exposed, he secretly had him killed. When the deception was exposed and the imperial messenger came to investigate, he armed his men, mounted the walls, and defied the royal command. Heaven's wrath swept like lightning and loyal men rose as one; in less than ten days the culprits were seized, the rebel regions subdued, and the lands south of the Han restored to order. Except for officials who took part in the conspiracy itself, all who were merely driven by the moment shall go unpunished."
15
Huan's eldest son Rong, Attendant in the Heir Apparent's Household, and Rong's younger brother Chen, Attendant in the Secretariat, were executed in the market at the capital. The remaining grandsons were all granted pardon.
17
Yin Rui
18
=
Yin Rui, whose style name was Wenzi, came from Chen Commandery. He was the seventh-generation descendant of Rong, Minister of Ceremonies under the Jin. At the end of the Yuanjia era in Song, his grandfather Yuansu was executed for involvement in the Taichu affair. Rui, still in the womb, was also marked for execution; his great-grandfather by marriage Wang Senglang petitioned Emperor Xiaowu on his behalf, and he was spared. Rui was versed in literary learning and gifted in speech; Minister of Works Chu Yuan held him in high regard and said, "Among the Yin family since the Jingzhou branch, none has surpassed you. Rui composed his expression and replied, "The Yin clan has declined and is truly not what it once was. If your words are mere flattery, they are not worth answering; if they are true, they are all the more painful to hear." When Huan governed Yong Province, he recommended Rui as chief administrator of his headquarters.
19
便 祿
Rui's clansman uncle Heng, whose style name was Zhaodu, like Rui succeeded to Rong's line. He was the grandson of Jingren, Minister of Works in the Song. Heng and his father Daojin both affected an antique manner, for which they were ridiculed in their day on more than one occasion. At the beginning of the Taishi era in Song, Heng served as Minister of Revenue but was impeached because his father's illness and his own frequent illnesses violated regulations on mourning and attendance. Emperor Ming's edict read, "Yin Daojin has been ill from birth; recently he has suffered no sudden illness. Heng, through foolish habit and sloth, has long obstructed proper advancement in office. He is demoted to Supernumerary Regular Attendant of the Scattered Cavalry and concurrently Colonel. Heng nevertheless served through a series of eminent posts and rose to Grand Master of Splendid Happiness with the Golden Seal. He died during the Jianwu era. The daughter of Huan's younger sister was consort to Prince Huang of Changsha. Emperor Shizu decreed, "Huan brought treason upon himself, but the Princess of Changsha's children are grown, and Huan himself was given in adoption—precedents exist from earlier ages; their ties shall not be severed. Huan's cousin was Wang Hui.
21
Wang Hui, Huan's Cousin
22
=
Wang Hui, whose style name was Shusu, was the son of Jingwen, General of Chariots and Cavalry in the Song. Upon reaching manhood he served as Secretariat Gentleman and Attendant in the Heir Apparent's Household, then was transferred to Palace Gentleman of the Secretariat. Jingwen would have granted him a leap in rank on this account, but made Hui wait a full year before accepting the appointment. Jingwen had been enfeoffed as Marquis of Jiang'an; Hui inherited his original noble rank and became a fifth-grade baron of Shiping County. He was promoted to Secretariat Assistant and Right Chief Administrator of the Minister of Works. At the end of the Yuanhui era he was appointed General of Pacifying the North, chief administrator to the General Who Campaigns North for the Prince of Jianping, and Grand Administrator of Southern Donghai, then Gentleman at the Yellow Gate, General of Pacifying the North, and Grand Administrator of Dongyang. When Shizu was General Who Pacifies the Army, Minister of Personnel Zhang Dai selected Hui as his chief administrator and presented the nomination. Emperor Gao smiled and said to Dai, "This is what one calls a man of established reputation. He was promoted to Supernumerary Regular Attendant of the Scattered Cavalry and General of Valiant Cavalry.
23
He was sent out as Grand Administrator of Yixing. He on his own authority arrested commandery clerk Chen Boxi and sent him to prison in Yangxian intending to kill him; County Magistrate Kong Huan, not knowing the charge, refused to obey Hui's order; the matter was reported to the authorities, and Hui was reduced to serving in plain clothes. He was appointed Attendant in the Heir Apparent's Household and concurrently General of Valiant Cavalry, then Chief Concurrent Palace Attendant. When Shizu went out pheasant hunting, Hui, a devout Buddhist, pleaded illness and did not accompany the imperial procession. He was transferred to Minister of the Left for the People; citing his mother's age, he asked to resign and was reassigned as General of Pacifying the North, chief administrator to the Grand Marshal, and Grand Administrator of Huailing. He was sent out as Grand Administrator of Xuancheng at the middle two-thousand-picul rank. In the first year of Longchang he was appointed General Who Assists the State and chief administrator to the Grand Tutor but declined the post. He was then made General Who Establishes Valor and Interior Administrator of Yuzhang. His designation was raised to General Who Subdues the Barbarians. He was again dismissed from office for an offense. He was appointed General Who Establishes Valor, Left Chief Administrator of the Minister of Works, Supernumerary Regular Attendant of the Scattered Cavalry, and tutor to the Prince of Sui. He was appointed General Who Subdues the Barbarians and chief administrator to the General of Agile Cavalry, then promoted to Supernumerary Regular Attendant of the Scattered Cavalry and Minister of Ceremonies. In the first year of Yongyuan he died. He was fifty-three years old. He was given the posthumous title Jingzi.
24
Hui's daughter married Zijing, Prince of Anlu, a favorite son of Emperor Shizu. When the prince took her as consort, he showed the full respect due to his wife's parents. Emperor Shizu sent Crown Prince Wen Hui to accompany the prince to Hui's house for a feast with music; dukes and ministers all came in full court dress—the age regarded it as the highest honor.
25
Zhang Chong
26
Zhang Chong, whose style name was Siyue, came from Wu in Wu Commandery. His father Jian had served as Direct Attendant. Chong had been given in adoption to succeed his father's elder cousin Jingyin, Attendant Within; his childhood name was Cha, and his father Shao's childhood name was Li. Emperor Wen of Song teased Jingyin, "How does Cha compare with Li? Jingyin answered, "Li is the sovereign of all fruits—how could Cha presume to compare?"
27
簿 西 西
Chong too showed exceptional filial devotion from youth; summoned as provincial chief clerk, he followed his uncle Yong on campaign and was appointed General Who Pacifies the Distance and Grand Administrator of Xuyi. When Yong campaigned at Pengcheng they met bitter cold and snow; seven or eight soldiers in ten suffered frozen calves and shins, and Chong lost all his toes. He was appointed Gentleman of the Imperial Carriages in the Secretariat, central army officer on the southern campaign of the Prince of Guiyang, and General Who Inspires Awe. He was offered a post as aide in the Southern Palace of the General of Agile Cavalry and Grand Marshal but declined. He was transferred to Attendant in the Western Campaign, Direct Attendant, direct military aide to the Northern Central Commander for the Prince of Wuling, and Colonel of the Long River, then appointed General of Pacifying the North while retaining his former duties. He was promoted to General of the Left Army, with the added ranks of General of Pacifying the North and General Who Assists the State. Chong had followed military life from youth, and the court valued him for his practical ability, so he served in a succession of military commands. He was sent out as Grand Administrator of Matou, then transferred to Grand Administrator of Xuyi, retaining his rank as General Who Assists the State. He was then appointed chief administrator to the Champion General for the Prince of Xiyang. In the eighth year he was made provisional bearer of the staff of authority supervising Qing and Ji provinces, retaining his general's rank. When Chong's father died, his last testament read, "Sacrifice to me only with produce of our native land—use no sacrificial animals. While stationed in the provinces, Chong each season returned to the family garden in Wu to gather fruit and vegetables and, weeping, offered them in sacrifice. He was then appointed full governor.
28
When Emperor Yulin ascended the throne, Chong's designation was raised to General Who Establishes Valor. When Emperor Ming ascended the throne, Wang Hongfan, Grand Administrator of Jinshou, was appointed to replace him. He was appointed Gentleman at the Yellow Gate with the added rank of General Who Subdues the Barbarians. When the barbarians raided the Huai and Si region, Chong was given provisional staff of authority as commander of the northern campaign in Qing and Ji provinces, retaining his former title. The barbarians massed their forces to attack Si Province, and an edict ordered troops from Qing and Xu to march out and divide the enemy's strength. Chong sent army commander Sang Xizu through Zhakou to storm the enemy cities of Jianling, Yima, and Houqiu, killing and capturing many. Together with Hongfan he sent army commander Cui Jiyan to raid the enemy city of Jicheng and hold it. Chong also sent army commander Du Senghu to storm the enemy cities of Hukeng, Fengshi, and Jiqiu and drive back captives and baggage; at Keigou enemy relief troops lay in ambush along the road, but Senghu fought fiercely and routed them.
29
That year he was appointed chief administrator to the Northern Central Commander for the Prince of Luling, with the added rank of General Who Establishes Valor. Before he could take up the post, the Duke of Fengcheng Yaochang was assigned to Yu Province; fearing that border troubles were not over, the emperor transferred Chong to chief administrator to the General Who Subdues the Barbarians and Grand Administrator of Nanliang Commandery. He was then appointed chief administrator to the Van Army for the Prince of Jiangxia. When Emperor Donghun ascended the throne, he was sent out as chief administrator to the General Who Subdues the Barbarians for the Prince of Jian'an, General Who Assists the State, and Interior Administrator of Jiangxia, acting for the Ying provincial headquarters. He was transferred to bearer of the staff of authority supervising military affairs in Yu Province and Governor of Yu Province, to replace Pei Shuye. In the end he never took up the post. The following year he was appointed commander of Nan Yan, Yan, Xu, Qing, and Ji provinces, General Who Assists the State, and Governor of Nan Yan Province, retaining his staff of authority. When Governor of Si Province Shen Xizu died, Chong was appointed commander of military affairs in Si Province, General Who Establishes Valor, and Governor of Si Province. When Pei Shuye surrendered Shouchun to the enemy, Chong was again appointed commander of Nan Yan, Yan, Xu, Qing, and Ji provinces and Governor of Nan Yan Province, retaining his staff of authority and general's rank. He accepted none of these appointments. After Cui Huijing's rebellion was suppressed, Prince Bao Yin of Jian'an was recalled to the capital and Chong was appointed commander of Ying and Si provinces and Governor of Ying Province, retaining his staff of authority and general's rank. Within a single year he had been offered four provinces in succession; only now did he finally accept appointment. That winter he was advanced to General Who Subdues the Barbarians. He was enfeoffed as Marquis of Dingxiang with a fief of one thousand households.
30
使西
When the Prince of Liang's righteous army rose, Emperor Donghun sent General of Valiant Cavalry Xue Yuansi and Bureau Supervisor Ji Rongbo with troops and more than 140 grain transports to reinforce Chong and have him resist the western forces. Yuansi and his men, mindful of Liu Shanyang's defeat, doubted that Chong would dare advance and halted at Xiakou. When they heard that the righteous army was approaching, Yuansi and Rongbo led their forces into Ying city together. At that time Fang Sengji, Grand Administrator of Jingling, having been relieved of office, was on his way back and reached Ying; Donghun ordered him to hold Lushan and appointed him General of Valiant Cavalry. Sengji said to Chong, "I have not yet received great favor from the present court, but I have indeed enjoyed the former emperor's generous grace. One who enjoys the shade of a tree does not break its branches—I wish only to offer whatever small service I can. Chong gave him his solemn pledge, and the two of them swore a joint oath. They then divided their forces to organize the defense. He sent army commander Sun Lezu with several thousand men to help Sengji hold Lushan and build fortifications along the shore.
31
西
In the second month of the following year the Prince of Liang marched out from Hankou and besieged Lushan. He sent army commanders including Cao Jingzong across the river to attack Ying; before the crossing was complete, Chong sent central army aide Chen Guangjing and others out through the gates to attack; the righteous army defeated them and Guangjing was killed in battle, after which Chong held the city and refused to come out. Jingzong thereupon occupied Shiqiao Ford and extended his camps in a continuous line down to Jiahu. Donghun sent army commanders including Wu Ziyang, Grand Administrator of Baxi and Zitong commanderies, Guang Zijin, Li Wenzhao, and Chen Huya with thirteen armies to relieve Ying; at Jiahu they could advance no farther and built a fortified camp with beacon fires, which the besieged answered with signal fires of their own. Yet the forces inside and outside each held their own positions and could not aid one another.
32
Chong died of illness; Yuansi, Rongbo, Chong's son Zi, and chief administrator Cheng Mao, who was also Interior Administrator of Jiangxia, continued to hold the city. Emperor Donghun posthumously awarded Chong the ranks of Supernumerary Regular Attendant of the Scattered Cavalry and General Who Protects the Army. Yuansi was granted provisional staff of authority under the title Ziyang.
33
The Yangtze rose in flood and the camp at Jiahu was inundated; the righteous army attacked from high-decked ships, and Ziyang's forces were routed and scattered. Lushan ran short of grain; the soldiers caught small fish on the stony shore to eat and secretly prepared light boats, intending to flee to Xiakou. The Prince of Liang ordered detached forces to cut off their escape routes and prevent any breakout. Fang Sengji died of illness; hard pressed, Sun Lezu surrendered the city.
34
使 使 使
Ying had been besieged for more than two hundred days; illness had killed members of seven or eight hundred gentry and commoner households. After Lushan fell, Cheng Mao, Yuansi, and the others discussed surrender and had Zi write to the Prince of Liang. Chong's former subordinate Fang Changyu, provincial aide of Qing Province, said to Zi, "Your father's loyalty reached to heaven, and his conduct surpassed pine and bamboo. You need only hold firm to a single course and bear the burden your father laid upon you. If heaven's fortune is not with you, dress in plain cloth and await your fate, then follow your father below. If you now follow the others' plan, not only will the people of Ying lose the man they looked up to as a mountain—you may also find that the enemy will not accept you." Two days after Lushan fell, Yuansi and the others surrendered Ying.
35
Donghun appointed Cheng Mao commander of Ying and Si provinces, General Who Assists the State, and Governor of Ying Province, and Yuansi commander of Yong, Liang, Northern Qin, Southern Qin, Jingling in Jing Province, and Suixiang in Si Province, General Who Establishes Valor, and Governor of Yong Province—both with staffs of authority. By then both Ying and Lushan had fallen; the dead lay in heaps, yet there had been no mass desertion. Men of the day compared Chong and Fang Sengji to Zang Hong in his famous siege. Sengji was posthumously appointed Governor of Yi Province.
36
西
At that time Xi Qian, Grand Administrator of Xincai, had been recommended in the Yongming era by Secretariat Gentleman Wang Rong. His father Gongmu, chief administrator to the General Who Guards the West, had been killed by the Marquis of Yufu. By then Qian was holding Pencheng; when he heard that the righteous army was marching east, he said, "Our house has been loyal for generations—I will die rather than turn." He was killed by Chen Bozhi.
37
Historian's Appraisal
38
The historian says: Shi Que abandoned his son, setting forth the warning against destroying one's own kin; Bao Yong surrendered late, showing the principle of serving the new order. Wang Huan's loyalty was truly without duplicity, and his conduct warranted the severe penalty; Zhang Chong failed to read heaven's intent and clung stubbornly to a doomed cause. The paths that led them into peril differed, but the outcome was the same.
39
The encomium says: Wang ruled the northern marches, but his son could not keep the household in order. In the end he committed rebellion and brought ruin on his noble house. Zhang's fortress was besieged to the end, and death came like tangled hemp. His awakening came too late, and clear judgment only after the fact.
40
Editorial note: removal of doubtful Qingstone variant readings.
42
Editorial note.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →