← Back to 三國志

卷四十三 蜀書十三 黃李呂馬王張傳

Volume 43: Book of Shu 13 - Biographies of Huang, Li, Lü, Ma, Wang, and Zhang

Chapter 43 of 三國志 · Records of the Three Kingdoms
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 43
Next Chapter →
1
西 簿 使 滿 使
Huang Quan, styled Gongheng, came from Langzhong in Ba-Xi Commandery. He began as a county clerk until Yi Province Governor Liu Zhang named him chief clerk. Zhang Song, Liu Zhang’s vice administrator, urged inviting Liu Bei west to attack Zhang Lu. Huang Quan objected: “The Left General is famous as a fighter. Treat him like a subordinate and he will resent it; treat him as an honored guest and two masters cannot share one realm. Your guest would stand firm as Taishan while you teeter like a stack of eggs. Better seal the passes and wait until the world settles.” Liu Zhang refused, sent envoys to welcome Liu Bei anyway, and sidelined Huang Quan as chief of Guanghan. When Liu Bei struck, generals spread through the province. County after county yielded; Huang Quan held his walls until Liu Zhang capitulated, then opened his gates to Liu Bei. Liu Bei named him acting lieutenant general. 〈Xu Zhong remarks that Huang Quan both warned his lord faithfully and held his city—proper conduct for a minister. King Wu honored Bi Gan’s tomb and Shang Rong’s lane to proclaim loyalty—the standard Liu Bei should emulate. Promoting him to general was decent but too modest to honor such steadfast loyalty or inspire others.〉 When Cao Cao drove Zhang Lu into Bazhong, Huang Quan urged: “Lose Hanzhong and the Three Ba collapse—you would sever Shu’s limbs.” Liu Bei made Huang Quan protector of the army and marched to intercept Zhang Lu, but Zhang Lu had already doubled back to Nan Zheng and surrendered to Cao Cao. Yet the victories over Du Hu and Pu Hu, the death of Xiahou Yuan, and the seizure of Hanzhong all stemmed from Huang Quan’s original plan.
2
綿
He later held titular rank as Yi inspector after submitting to Wei and living south of the Yellow River. Grand General Sima Yi thought highly of him and asked, “How many men like you remain in Shu?” Huang Quan smiled and said, “I hardly expected such attention from you.” Sima Yi wrote Zhuge Liang: “Huang Gongheng is a blunt-spoken man who speaks of you whenever he rises or sits.” In 239 Wei’s third year of Jingchu and Shu’s second year of Yanxi he became general of chariots and cavalry with Three Excellencies protocol. 〈The Shu ji records Emperor Ming asking him which regime heaven favored among the three rivals.” Huang Quan answered: “Heaven’s omens decide legitimacy. When Mars stalled in the Heart lodger and Wei’s Emperor Wen died, the rulers of Wu and Shu were untouched—that is the proof.”〉” He died the following year with the posthumous title Marquis Jing. His son Huang Yong inherited but died without heirs, so the marquisate lapsed. Huang Quan’s son Huang Chong stayed in Shu as a masters-of-writing gentleman and followed Guardian General Zhuge Zhan against Deng Ai. At Fuxian Zhuge Zhan hesitated; Huang Chong urged him repeatedly to seize the passes before Deng Ai reached the plain. Zhuge Zhan still delayed until Huang Chong wept with frustration. Deng Ai swept forward; Zhuge Zhan fell back to Mianzhu. Huang Chong rallied the troops for a fight to the death and died in the front rank.
3
退
After Liu Bei’s death Gao Ding rampaged in Yuexi, Yong Kai bullied Jianning, and Zhu Bao rose in Zangke. Zhuge Liang marched south through Yuexi while Li Hui drove toward Jianning. County forces united and trapped Li Hui’s army at Kunming. Outnumbered and out of contact with Zhuge Liang, Li Hui lied to the rebels that Shu’s supplies were gone and he meant to defect south rather than march north again.” They believed him and loosened the siege. Li Hui broke out, routed them, drove the fugitives south to the Pan River and east toward Zangke, and linked up with Zhuge Liang.
4
綿
When the south was pacified, Li Hui’s deeds ranked first. He was made village marquis of Hanxing and promoted general who pacifies Han. After the army withdrew the tribes rebelled again and slew the garrison commanders. Li Hui led the punitive expedition himself, uprooted the ringleaders, deported chieftains to Chengdu, and levied cattle, horses, precious metals, and hides from the Sou and Pu until the treasury stayed full. In 229, after Shu ceded Jiao Province to Wu, Li Hui was stripped of his inspector’s commission. He was reassigned as Jianning administrator and returned to his home commandery. He moved to Hanzhong and died in 231. His son Li Yi inherited the title; his cousin Li Qiu, colonel of the right wing of the imperial guard, followed Zhuge Zhan against Deng Ai and died fighting at Mianzhu.
5
Lü Kai answered the manifesto:
6
Heaven has sent calamity; usurpers exploit every crack; all under heaven grit their teeth in grief. Every subject longs to spend sinew and blood to lift the nation’s woes. Your house has fed on Han favor for generations—you should rally loyal hosts, march in the van, repay the dynasty above and honor your ancestors below, and win a place in the histories. Who imagined you would kneel to Wu and Yue and forsake the trunk for the twig? Shun died on campaign at Cangwu serving the people—the classics praise him still. What shame is there if he fell by the river? Wen and Wu took heaven’s mandate before King Cheng finished the work. Our late emperor rose like a dragon; the realm turned to him; wise ministers brought heaven’s blessing. Yet you ignore how fortunes rise and fall. You stride cracked river ice while wildfire races the plain—when both melt away, where will you stand? Your father the Yong marquis kept his fief despite old grudges; Dou Rong read the signs and joined Guangwu—posterity still sings their wisdom. Chancellor Zhuge’s genius reads trouble before it blooms; he accepted the late emperor’s orphan and aids our restoration; he weighs merit above old slights. Turn your coat now, change course—you may yet rival the ancients; this frontier cannot hold you back! When Chu slighted ritual, Duke Huan of Qi chastised them; when King Fuchai seized the kingly title, Jin did not survive. Who follows a pretender willingly? Classical propriety forbids ministers from dealing across borders—hence your letters arrived unanswered. Your renewed summons stirred me past meals; I sketch my thoughts here for your judgment.
7
Lü Kai’s authority won the commandery’s trust, so he kept his honor intact.
8
Zhuge Liang had already marched south against Yong Kai when Gao Ding’s men killed Yong Kai first. At his arrival Zhuge Liang memorialized: “Clerk Lü Kai and assistant Wang Kang of Yongchang held loyalty in a besieged corner for ten years while Yong Kai and Gao Ding pressed them from the northeast. I never dreamed Yongchang’s people were so staunch!” Lü Kai became Yunnan administrator and village marquis of Yangqian but soon fell to rebel tribes; his son Lü Xiang inherited the title. Wang Kang too was made a village marquis and Yongchang administrator. 〈The Shu shifu notes that Lü Xiang later served Jin as colonel of the southern tribes and that his descendants held Yongchang for generations. When Li Xiong took Ningzhou the Lü clan refused him and held Yongchang for the Jin court. Wang Kang and his peers kept the same steadfast loyalty.〉
9
西
Wang Ping, styled Zijun, came from Dangqu in Ba-Xi. He had been raised under the He surname on his mother’s side. He later resumed the surname Wang. He went to Luoyang with Du Hu and Pu Hu as acting colonel, followed Cao Cao into Hanzhong, then defected to Liu Bei and became colonel of the standard and supporting general. In 228 he served under army adviser Ma Su as vanguard. Ma Su forsook the river for the heights and bungled deployment; Wang Ping argued repeatedly but was ignored, and they were routed at Jieting. The army fled in panic while Wang Ping’s thousand men beat drums and held line until Zhang He feared an ambush and halted. Wang Ping slowly regrouped the broken camps and marched the survivors home. Zhuge Liang executed Ma Su, Zhang Xiu, and Li Sheng and cashiered Huang Xi’s command. Wang Ping alone was rewarded with army adviser rank, command of five tribal divisions, camp duties, promotion to general who punishes rebels, and a village marquisate. In 231, during the Qishan siege, Wang Ping held the southern perimeter. While Sima Yi struck Zhuge Liang, Zhang He assaulted Wang Ping’s sector but could not break his defense.
10
退
When Zhuge Liang died at Wugong in 234 and Wei Yan mutinied on the retreat, Wang Ping crushed the revolt in a single clash. He rose to rear army supervisor and general who pacifies Han, second to Wu Yi’s chariots and cavalry command in Hanzhong, and served concurrently as Hanzhong administrator. In 237 he became marquis who pacifies Han and succeeded Wu Yi as Hanzhong commander. In 238, while Grand General Jiang Wan camped at Mianyang, Wang Ping became forward protector of the army and ran Jiang Wan’s headquarters. In 243, after Jiang Wan moved to Fu, Wang Ping became forward inspector and grand general who guards the north with overall authority in Hanzhong.
11
滿 便 便 退
In the spring of 244 Cao Shuang marched well over a hundred thousand troops toward Hanzhong with his van already through Lu Valley. Fewer than thirty thousand men held Hanzhong, and the generals panicked. Some urged abandoning the field for Han and Le cities—let Wei through while reinforcements from Fu march up to rescue the passes.” Wang Ping disagreed: “No. Hanzhong lies almost a thousand li from Fu. If they seize the passes disaster follows. Send Protector Liu Min and adviser Du Qi to hold Xingshi while I cover the rear. If they probe Huangjin I will take a thousand men downhill to pin them until the Fu relief arrives—the best plan.” Only Protector Liu Min agreed; they acted at once. Fu’s columns and Fei Yi from Chengdu arrived in succession and Wei withdrew exactly as Wang Ping predicted. Deng Zhi held the east, Ma Zhong the south, Wang Ping the north—each a name to reckon with.
12
使
Raised in camp, barely literate, he nonetheless dictated lucid correspondence. He listened to readers of the Shiji and Hanshu until he grasped their themes and argued them soundly. He kept regulations, avoided idle talk, and sat bolt upright from dawn to dusk—more clerk than bluff soldier. Petty, jealous, and self-deprecating, he diminished his own stature. He died in 248; his son Wang Xun inherited the title.
13
Wang Ping had a fellow townsman from Hanchang surnamed Gou— 〈Here the surname Gou is read like English "go" (the fanqie gloss gives an ancient hou reading), not like "jyu."〉 —named Gou Fu—who matched Wang Ping in loyalty and courage, rose to left general, and became marquis of Dangqu. 〈Chang Qu notes that when Zhang Yi and Liao Hua became grand generals, folk rhymed: “Wang and Gou led the way; Zhang and Liao followed.”〉
14
祿 綿 宿輿 使 祿
Zhang Ni, styled Boqi, came from Nanchong in Ba Commandery. 〈The Yibu tradition says he rose from poverty yet showed heroic fiber young.〉 At twenty he served as county merit officer. During Liu Bei's takeover bandits stormed the county; the magistrate fled, but Zhang Ni carried his wife through sword strokes to safety. His fame spread and the province named him attendant clerk. Local notables Gong Lu and Yao Zhou, senior officials of repute, befriended him. In 227 bandits led by Zhang Mu pillaged Mianzhu; Zhang Ni led out troops as commandant to suppress them. He judged they would melt away like a flock of birds if pursued piecemeal. So he feigned friendship and invited them to feast. When they were drunk he cut down Zhang Mu and fifty followers and destroyed their chiefs. Within ten days he had cleared the hills of the rest. A serious illness struck while his family remained destitute. He turned to Guanghan governor He Zhi—little known to him—for medical care. He Zhi nursed him back to health over several years. Such was his circle’s fidelity. As colonel under Ma Zhong he crushed Qiang rebels in Wenshan and tribal risings in four southern commanderies with repeated tactical successes. 〈The tradition adds he led three hundred men under Ma Zhong against rebel Qiang. He pushed several camps ahead to Tali. The stockade stood on sheer heights four or five li up the slope. They barred the defiles with stone gates and dropped rocks from overhead galleries. Seeing no assault path, he sent interpreters: "Your Wenshan tribes rebelled and harmed innocents; the court sends armies to destroy villains. Bow now, feed our troops, and heaven's rewards will multiply. Refuse and armies will strike like lightning—too late for regrets." The headmen accepted terms, brought provisions, and let the army through. Other bands collapsed when they heard Tali had fallen—some surrendered, others fled—and Ma Zhong's force swept through. When Liu Zhou rose again Ma Zhong led Jiangzhou troops with Zhang Ni in the van and took Liu Zhou's head. Afterward Lao rebels in Zangke and Xinggu challenged Ma Zhong; Zhang Ni enlisted two thousand surrendered warriors and sent them to Hanzhong.〉
15
祿 使
In 246 Di chieftain Fu Jian offered submission; Zhang Wei failed to fetch him on time, alarming Jiang Wan. Zhang Ni calmed him: "Fu Jian's pledge rings true—nothing else is afoot. His crafty younger brother and tribal jealousy explain the delay." Days later word came: most kin defected to Wei while Fu Jian alone crossed over. After Zhuge Liang's southern sweep Yuexi churned with revolt; successive governors died until administration shrank to Anding, eight hundred li from the seat. Court debate restored Yuexi's capital under Zhang Ni; kindness brought tribes back to allegiance. The Zhuoma tribe northward refused orders until Zhang Ni seized chief Wei Lang alive. He freed Wei Lang to rally the rest peacefully. Wei Lang became village marquis; three thousand households farmed and paid tribute. Word spread and other bands yielded. Zhang Ni earned marquis-within-the-passes rank.
16
西 使 祿宿
Suqi headmen Dong Feng and Po Qu rebelled after submitting. Zhang Ni executed Dong Feng. He spared Feng's wife, a Maoniu princess, by design. Po Qu fled westward into the frontier. Po Qu terrified every tribe; two agents feigned defection to spy on Zhang Ni. Zhang Ni bought them as double agents who murdered Po Qu. His death restored calm. He hunted down Sidu chief Li Qiucheng for Gong Lu's murder and executed him after listing crimes. Finding the county walls ruinous he first threw up a small fortress. Three years later he returned to the old capital and rebuilt it with tribal labor.
17
忿 使
Dingzuo, Taideng, and Beishui—salt, iron, and lacquer heartlands three hundred li out—had been hoarded by frontier tribes. Zhang Ni seized the districts and installed magistrates. Chief Lang Cen, kin to the Panmu king, snubbed Zhang Ni's arrival. Zhang Ni arrested Lang Cen, executed him publicly, returned the body with gifts, and cowed the clan. He lectured them on Lang Cen's crimes: "Stay still or face extinction!" They came bound hand and foot to apologize. He hosted a midday feast to rebuild trust. Salt and iron flowed again and gear grew plentiful.
18
婿
Four thousand Maoniu households under Lang Lu meant to avenge Dong Feng. Lang Lu sent Uncle Li with Dong Feng's men to scout. Zhang Ni preempted him with cattle, wine, and Dong Feng's widow bearing terms. Li and his sister accepted; they brought their warriors to Zhang Ni, who feasted them and sent them home reconciled. Maoniu gave little trouble thereafter.
19
使
An ancient highway through Maoniu to Chengdu was straight and easy. A century of closure forced travelers onto the long Anshang detour. Zhang Ni sent gifts and kinswomen to Lang Lu until the chief brought his whole household to swear alliance; the old road reopened with stations restored. He memorialized Lang Lu as Maoniu king with the Pi title and brought him to Chengdu to present tribute. Liu Shan then named Zhang Ni general who pacifies the Rong while he kept Yuexi. Seeing Fei Yi court danger by trusting every newcomer, Zhang Ni cited Cen Peng and Lai Xi: "Great power invites blades—stay wary." Fei Yi was later killed by the Wei defector Guo Xiu.
20
After beating Wei, Wu's Zhuge Ke mobilized massively for new conquests. Palace attendant Zhuge Zhan—Zhuge Liang's son—was Zhuge Ke's cousin. Zhang Ni wrote Zhuge Zhan:
21
西
Sun Liang is a boy and Zhuge Ke shoulders regency—no light burden. The Duke of Zhou faced Guan-Cai slander; Huo Guang survived Yan and Shangguan plots—only sage young rulers saved them. Sun Quan micromanaged justice to the end; handing regency from a deathbed is doubly tense. Wu temper is famously rash; leaving the boy emperor for Wei battlefields seems unsound. Even orderly Wu can err once in a hundred tries—should not the wise hedge? History mirrors the present—only you can speak plainly to your cousin. Disband hosts, farm, build virtue—strike later when odds improve.
22
Zhuge Ke ignored him and died with his whole lineage. Zhang Ni read men and moments often thus.
23
西 西
Fifteen quiet years in Yuexi. He begged recall until Chengdu summoned him. Tribes clung to his wheels, infants met him at Maoniu, and a hundred chiefs escorted him toward Chengdu. Chengdu named him general who sweeps away bandits; literati admired his fire. His blunt manners drew ridicule. 〈The Traditions of Former Worthies of Yibu states: At that time General of Chariots and Cavalry Xiahou Ba said to Ni: "Although with you, sir, I am distant and broad, yet my heart entrusts as of old—you ought clarify this intent." Zhang Ni answered coldly: "We hardly know each other—talk of hearts is premature. Let three years pass before such intimacy." Thoughtful men praised the exchange.〉 It was 254. Didao magistrate Li Jian plotted defection; Jiang Wei exploited it to march into Longxi with Zhang Ni. 〈Chronic rheumatism crippled him in Chengdu. Court skeptics doubted Li Jian; Zhang Ni insisted it was genuine. Though ill from travel he volunteered for Jiang Wei's western thrust anyway. Before marching he told Liu Shan: “I have enjoyed imperial favor beyond merit and bear a sickly frame—I dread dying overnight and failing your trust. Heaven granted my wish to join the campaign. If we secure Liangzhou I will hold the frontier for you; if not, I give my life in repayment.” Liu Shan wept at his words.〉 At Didao, Li Jian brought the whole town out to greet Jiang Wei’s host. He fought Xu Zhi at the front and died in action after inflicting more than twice his own losses. Posthumously his eldest son Zhang Ying became marquis of Xixiang and his second son Zhang Huguo inherited the title. Southern Han and Yi of Yuexi wept at Zhang Ni’s death, built him shrines, and prayed there whenever drought or flood struck. 〈The Yibu tradition says Zhang Ni looked unremarkable yet planned brilliantly, fought fiercely, served with steadfast loyalty, stood candid among colleagues, and weighed every act against precedent—so Liu Shan revered him deeply. Ancient heroes would scarcely surpass him! The Shu shifu adds that Zhang Ni’s grandson Zhang Yi became Jin’s inspector of Liangzhou.〉
24
【Closing appraisal】
25
Chen Shou judged Huang Quan broad-minded, Li Hui steadfastly honest, Lü Kai incorruptible, Ma Zhong supple yet firm, 〈The Shangshu line runs “pliant yet resolute.” Zheng Xuan glosses rao as “trainable” or “pliant.” Decisive valor is what yi names.〉 Wang Ping paired loyalty with discipline; Zhang Ni paired insight with bold action—each rose because the age demanded his gifts.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →