← Back to 三國志

卷五十六 吳書十一 朱治朱然呂範朱桓傳

Volume 56: Book of Wu 11 - Biographies of Zhu Zhi, Zhu Ran, Lü Fan, and Zhu Huan

Chapter 56 of 三國志 · Records of the Three Kingdoms
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 56
Next Chapter →
1
使
Zhu Zhi, styled Junli, came from Gucheng in Danyang commandery. He began as a county clerk, then earned recommendation as Filial and Incorrupt, was recruited by the province as an Attendant Clerk, and marched with Sun Jian on his expeditions. In Zhongping 5 (188 CE) he received appointment as major. He took part in the campaign against the bandit leaders Zhou Chao and Su Ma across Changsha, Lingling, and Guilin. When he distinguished himself, Sun Jian submitted a memorial recommending Zhu Zhi for acting commandant. He followed Sun Jian to the victory over Dong Zhuo at Yangren and then entered Luoyang. Sun Jian had him named acting colonel who directs the army, gave him independent command of foot and horse, and sent him east to help Tao Qian, governor of Xu Province, crush the Yellow Turbans. After Sun Jian died, Zhu Zhi steadied the young Sun Ce and threw in his lot with Yuan Shu. Seeing that Yuan Shu could never establish legitimate rule, he persuaded Sun Ce to turn back and conquer the territory east of the river. While the grand tutor Ma Midi was at Shouchun, he recruited Zhu Zhi onto his staff and then advanced him to commandant of Wu. Wu Jing already held Danyang for their side, even as Sun Ce was besieging Lujiang on Yuan Shu's orders. Liu Yao, afraid the Yuan–Sun alliance would absorb him next, began picking quarrels and driving wedges between the allies. With Sun Ce's family still trapped below the capital at the provincial seat, Zhu Zhi dispatched men to Qu'e to bring the Lady Dowager and the young Sun brothers to safety. He fed them, guarded them, and kept good order around them; the kindness was remembered in every detail. Marching from Qiantang toward Wu, he was blocked at Youquan by Xu Gong, the grand administrator of Wu; Zhu Zhi attacked and shattered Xu Gong's force. Xu Gong fled south into the hills to the bandit chief Yan Zihu, and Zhu Zhi entered the commandery and assumed the governor's office. Once Sun Ce had expelled Liu Yao, he secured Kuaiji in the east. When Sun Quan turned fifteen, Zhu Zhi put him forward as Filial and Incorrupt. After Sun Ce's death, Zhu Zhi stood with Zhang Zhao and the rest to raise Sun Quan as their lord.
2
In the seventh year of Jian'an (202 CE), Sun Quan memorialized the throne to appoint Zhu Zhi as (the commandery of Jiu Zhen—an alternate reading noted in brackets—) grand administrator with the acting title General Who Upholds Righteousness, carving out Lou, Youquan, and Wuxi together with Piling as his fiscal domain, where he installed magistrates to administer the towns. He campaigned against the southern tribes, helped secure the southeast, and mopped up Yellow Turban holdouts such as Chen Bai and Wan Bing. In Huangwu 1 (222 CE) he received the marquisate of Piling while remaining governor of the commandery.
3
覿
The next year he was named general who stabilizes the state, given the gold seal and purple ribbon, and transferred his enfeoffment to Gucheng. As Sun Quan rose from field command to kingship of Wu, he would personally come out to welcome Zhu Zhi every time Zhu arrived for audience. He clasped his tablet, bowed in return, lavished banquets and gifts on him, and singled him out for deference so marked that even Zhu Zhi's escort clerks might offer personal gifts and be received—an honor almost without parallel.
4
Sun Quan's younger brother Sun Yi had a sharp temper and often gave way to impulse; Zhu Zhi scolded him more than once and reasoned with him about what honor required. Sun Ben, Sun Quan's cousin and governor of Yuzhang, had married his daughter to a son of Cao Cao; after Cao Cao crushed Jing Province and his name thundered across the south, Sun Ben panicked and wanted to send a son south as a hostage. Hearing this, Zhu Zhi begged permission to visit Sun Ben and lay out for him how much stood to be lost or gained, 〈The Jiang Biao Zhuan preserves Zhu Zhi's words to Sun Ben: Your father the General Who Smashes Fugitives once marched in the righteous host against Dong Zhuo, and his name topped the heartland; gallant men still speak of it with pride. The General Who Pacifies Rebels carried on his work, brought six commanderies to heel, and, because you are the nearest of kin and a man the times require, had you written into the Han registers with a great commandery, joint command of two bureaus, and honors that outshone every other prince of the blood—you became the man everyone watched. Sun Quan besides is brilliant and formidable in arms, has taken up the great legacy, rallies able men, and mends the world's troubles; his hosts swell by the day and his cause towers higher—even Liu Xiu in his Hebei days never outshone him. He will finish the work of kingship and fulfill Heaven's mandate in the southeast. That is why Liu Bei, from far away, has laid bare his inmost heart and pleaded for deliverance—the whole realm knows it. Earlier, while I was still in the east, travelers' gossip said you were leaning toward another master, and the news left me heartsick. Today Cao Cao holds the hosts at bay, has all but pulled down the Han, the boy emperor is driven from pillar to post, and the black-haired millions have no refuge. The central plain is a wasteland: for miles no cooking fires, cities hollow, corpses lining the ditches, scholars groaning in the wilds, women weeping indoors—and still more troops march and famine follows. Judge from that: could they really cross the Yangzi and wrest profit from us? And you, General, at such an hour would betray your kin, spurn the one course that keeps you safe, slice flesh from your own bone, and drop it into the maw of wolves—for one woman's sake you would swap your whole strategy; a hair's miss now becomes a thousand li of regret. Would that not be a bitter loss? Sun Ben dropped the plan. Sun Quan often remarked how Zhu Zhi wore himself out in the service of the state. He lived plainly: even at the height of rank his equipage and dress were only what the office required. Sun Quan singled him out for favor, had the supervising army clerk and the metropolitan registrar take over the paperwork, and left Zhu Zhi only the rent and tax of four counties to administer. Meanwhile the great Wu lineages filled the commandery staff until the clerks ran into the thousands; Zhu Zhi still sent several hundred of them up to court every few years. Those hundreds brought seasonal tribute to the palace, and Sun Quan's gifts in reply were always munificent. Danyang's hinterland was rife with defection, and Zhu Zhi, feeling his years, yearned for home; he therefore asked to camp at Gucheng and keep the mountain Yue in check. Every elder and old comrade came to his door, and he welcomed them all to drink and feast until the whole countryside glowed with pride. He spent just over a year at Gucheng, then went back to the capital at Wu. He died in Huangwu 3 (224 CE) after thirty-one years in the commandery, aged sixty-nine.
5
西
His son Zhu Cai had already commanded troops as a colonel; when he inherited the title he advanced to lieutenant general. 〈The Wu shu adds: Zhu Cai, styled Junye, was quick-witted and a superb horseman and bowman; Sun Quan doted on him and kept him always at hand for the hunt. While still young he entered the martial guard colonelcy through his father's rank, led men on campaign, and won distinction again and again. Men at home murmured that a boy so highly placed snubbed local opinion; Zhu Cai sighed, When I first took command I believed that riding straight at the foe and catching every blade on my own shield would win me fame—I never guessed my neighbors would still judge every move I make! So he mended his manners, cultivated guests, spent freely for honor's sake without counting the cost, and took up military science until his name carried up and down the roads. He soon fell ill and died.〉 His brother Zhu Ji married a daughter of Sun Ce on Sun Quan's arrangement and likewise commanded men as a colonel. Zhu Ji's younger brothers Zhu Wei and Zhu Wansui both died young. Zhu Cai's son Zhu Wan inherited the marquisate, served as a general, and rose to general who guards the west.
6
Zhu Ran, styled Yifeng, was Zhu Zhi's nephew by his elder sister and had been born into the Shi clan. Because Zhu Zhi long had no heir, when the boy turned thirteen Zhu Zhi begged Sun Ce to let him adopt Zhu Ran as his successor. Sun Ce told the Danyang authorities to welcome Zhu Ran with the ritual sheep and wine; when the youth reached Wu, Sun Ce received him with full courtesy and congratulations.
7
西
Zhu Ran had studied the classics side by side with Sun Quan, and the two grew close. When Sun Quan assumed leadership he named Zhu Ran magistrate of Yuyao; Zhu was nineteen. He was later shifted to magistrate of Shanyin with the additional rank of colonel who breaks the charge, overseeing five counties. Sun Quan, impressed by his talent, carved Linchuan commandery out of Danyang and made him its governor, 〈Pei Songzhi remarks: that commandery was abolished shortly afterward and is not the Linchuan of later ages.〉 He was given two thousand troops. Mountain bandits erupted; Zhu Ran struck them down and had the region quiet within a month. When Cao Cao advanced on Ruxu, Zhu Ran built a great pier and fortified the three passes, and received appointment as lieutenant general. In Jian'an 24 (219 CE) he joined the expedition against Guan Yu, then with Pan Zhang pushed separately to Linju, took Guan Yu alive, and was raised to general who displays martial prowess and enfeoffed as village marquis of Xi'an.
8
"?"" "
The fierce tiger general Lü Meng was dying. Sun Quan asked him, If you do not recover, who could replace you? Lü Meng answered, Zhu Ran's nerve for holding a line is ample; I would deem him fit for the post. When Lü Meng died, Sun Quan gave Zhu Ran the imperial baton and left him to guard Jiangling. In Huangwu 1 (221 CE) Liu Bei marched against Yidu. Zhu Ran led five thousand men and stood with Lu Xun to block Liu Bei. Zhu Ran on a separate wing shattered Liu Bei's van and cut his line of retreat, and Liu Bei broke and ran. He was named general who campaigns north and enfeoffed as marquis of Yong'an.
9
退 退 退
Wei dispatched Cao Zhen, Xiahou Shang, Zhang He, and others against Jiangling; Cao Pi of Wei camped at Wan to stiffen their thrust, and their camps ringed the walls. Sun Quan sent General Sun Sheng with ten thousand men to hold the midriver islet, building palisades and a pier as an outer lifeline for Zhu Ran. Zhang He threw troops across to hit Sun Sheng, who could not hold and tried to fall back; Zhang He took the islet fort, and Zhu Ran was completely isolated. Sun Quan sent Pan Zhang, Yang Can, and others to break the ring, but the Wei lines held firm. Inside the city disease had swollen the soldiers' limbs; scarcely five thousand could still bear arms. The Wei generals piled earthworks, drove tunnels, raised lofted towers above the walls, and shot until the arrows fell like rain; Zhu Ran's men went white with terror, yet he himself sat as calmly as at a feast, showed not a trace of panic, then roused officers and men, waited his opening, and stormed two enemy camps. For half a year the Wei army invested Zhu Ran without lifting the siege. The Jiangling magistrate Yao Tai held the north gate; seeing the enemy's numbers and the thinning garrison, he believed the grain would give out. He therefore opened secret talks with the enemy and plotted to betray the city from within. The plot was discovered on the eve of the blow; Zhu Ran tried Yao Tai and put him to death. Xiahou Shang and his colleagues could not force the city, so they struck their camps and retired. Zhu Ran's name thereafter struck terror in the rival courts, and his fief was moved to the marquisate of Dangyang.
10
使 退
In the sixth year of Huangwu Sun Quan himself led a great host against Shiyang; on the march home Pan Zhang commanded the rear guard. The night march came out in confusion; the foe chased Pan Zhang, and he could not check them. Zhu Ran wheeled about to screen the retreat, letting the van ships pull far ahead before he cast off last of all. In Huanglong 1 (229 CE) he became chariot and horse general, right protector of the army, and nominal shepherd of Yan Province. Soon afterward Yan Province was reckoned to fall within Shu's partition of the realm, so the shepherd title was stripped. In Jiahe 3 (234 CE) Sun Quan and Shu agreed on a grand offensive: Sun Quan marched on Xincheng while Zhu Ran and Quan Zong took the ritual axes as left and right commanders. Sickness swept the ranks, so they never struck and fell back.
11
西 便 退 退 退 寿 忿 " 耀使忿 " " "使
In Chiwu 5 (242 CE) he led a punitive expedition into the Zuzhong basin, 〈The Xiangyang ji notes: the graph is read like the zu in zu shui, "land tax." Zuzhong stands on the Shanghuang frontier, a hundred and fifty li from Xiangyang. Under Wei the Yi chieftain Mei Fu and his two brothers camped there with over ten thousand client households, straddling the Yan and Mian valleys west of the hills in Zhonglu and Yicheng—open country ideal for mulberry and hemp, laced with irrigated fields by river and road: the fat heartland south of the Mian that men call Zuzhong.〉 The Wei commanders Pu Zhong and Hu Zhi each brought several thousand troops, and Pu Zhong sealed the narrow passes ahead of Zhu Ran. They meant to sever Zhu Ran's retreat while Hu Zhi followed Pu Zhong as a second wave. Zhu Ran's units were already strung out on other errands, and before he could recall them he took the eight hundred guards at headquarters and threw them straight into the ambush. Pu Zhong's attack collapsed, and Hu Zhi and the rest pulled back. 〈The Sun shi yi tong ping notes: both the Wei shu and the Jiang Biao Zhuan record Zhu Ran's two incursions in Jingchu 1 and Zhengshi 2, with Hu Zhi and Pu Zhong routed in the first Jingchu year. The Wei zhi copies the Wei shu and equivocates, never admitting that Hu Zhi's men were beaten by Zhu Ran and only saying Zhu Ran retired. The Wu zhi places the clash in Chiwu 5, which matches Wei's Zhengshi 3, and describes Wei general Pu Zhong fighting Zhu Ran to a Wei defeat followed by Hu Zhi's retreat. Yet the Wei annals for the young emperor and Sun Quan's memoir are silent for that year; Pei Songzhi concludes Chen Shou confused Wu's Jiahe 6 with Chiwu 5.〉 In the ninth year he struck Zuzhong again; Li Xing and other Wei generals, learning how deep Zhu Ran had pushed, marched six thousand horse and foot to sever his line of retreat, yet Zhu Ran sallied by night, met them head-on, and marched home in triumph. Earlier the turncoat defector Ma Mao had nursed a plot; when it was uncovered he was put to death, and Sun Quan nursed a deep grudge over the affair. On the eve of his expedition Zhu Ran sent up a memorial: That wretch Ma Mao dared bite the hand that fed him. If Heaven favors this expedition I mean to parade our captives the length of the river, pack the channel with trophy ships for every eye to see, and wash away the court's fury from top to bottom. I beg only that Your Majesty recall what I have said and weigh me by the result. Sun Quan pocketed the memorial and did not circulate it. When Zhu Ran presented his victory, the courtiers cheered, and Sun Quan at last poured the wine, called for music, and pulled out Zhu Ran's old memorial: He warned me beforehand; I thought the thing impossible, yet it unfolded just as he promised—a man who truly reads events. He then dispatched envoys naming Zhu Ran left grand marshal and right army adviser.
12
使 使 使 使
Zhu Ran stood under seven chi, but his presence was unmistakable. In private life he was austere: color and polish went only to weapons and armor; the rest of his wardrobe stayed plain. He remained intent from dawn to dusk, lived on campaign, and in crisis his nerve never wavered. In that calm courage he stood above ordinary men. Even in peacetime he beat the morning and evening drums without fail, and every man under canvas belted on gear and stood to ranks. He habitually wrong-footed the foe so they never knew what to expect, and his outings therefore seldom failed. Though Zhuge Jin's son Zhuge Rong and Bu Zhi's son Bu Xie had each stepped into their fathers' shoes, Sun Quan still named Zhu Ran overall commander above them. Lu Xun was gone as well; among the old guard still alive only Zhu Ran remained, and none matched his stature. For two years he lingered bedridden, then sank visibly; Sun Quan cut his own daytime meals out of grief for him. At night he could not sleep, and imperial couriers bearing drugs and broth clogged the road to Zhu Ran's house. Each time Zhu Ran's couriers arrived with word of his health, Sun Quan received them in person and asked after Zhu Ran himself. He feasted them on entry and pressed silks on them when they left. Of the founders who sickened, Sun Quan grieved deepest for Lü Meng and Ling Tong; Zhu Ran came just after those two. He died at sixty-eight in Chiwu 12; Sun Quan donned white mourning, held a state lament, and wept for him. His son Zhu Ji inherited the title.
13
The heir was his son, known as Shi Ji before the surname was restored.
14
Zhu Ji, styled Gongxu, entered the court as a gentleman through his father's rank, then received appointment as commandant who establishes loyalty. When his uncle Zhu Cai died, Zhu Ji inherited his command, followed the chamberlain Pan Jun against the Five Gorges tribes, and won a name for raw nerve. He rose to lieutenant general and camp superintendent with charge of bandit suppression, enforcing the code without bending. Prince Sun Ba of Lu cultivated him, even visiting his yamen, sitting down at his side, and offering friendship; Zhu Ji rose, stood on the floor, and refused the overture as improper. Zhu Ran died. Zhu Ji took up his father's post as general who pacifies Wei and garrison commander at Lexiang.
15
退 " " 便
The following year Wang Chang, Wei's general who campaigns south, stormed Jiangling without success and retired. Zhu Ji wrote to Zhuge Rong, the fierce tiger general: Wang Chang marched here spent and starving, his horses found no fodder, and he broke off from sheer exhaustion—that is Heaven fighting on our side. Our pursuit column is thin; feed in reinforcements behind me. I will break him from the front while you hammer him from the rear—the glory cannot be one man's; we should cleave one purpose like brothers sworn to split metal. Zhuge Rong wrote back promising to join him. Zhu Ji marched and caught Wang Chang at Jinan, thirty li from the walls; Zhu Ji opened with a victory but Zhuge Rong never moved up, and Zhu Ji later lost the field. Sun Quan heaped praise on Zhu Ji and blistered Zhuge Rong, yet spared Rong because his brother Zhuge Ke still towered at court. Zhu Ji had long distrusted Zhuge Ke and Zhuge Rong; after that battle the bad blood only deepened. In Jianxing 1 he advanced to general who guards the east.
16
使 使 西
Next spring Zhuge Ke marched on Xincheng and called for Zhu Ji's weight in the line, yet kept him half-stranded at Banzhou while Zhuge Rong doubled his jobs. That winter Zhuge Ke and Zhuge Rong perished; Zhu Ji went back to Lexiang with credentials as commander. In Taiping 2 he was named chief of cavalry. Once Sun Lin dominated the court and high officials eyed one another with suspicion, Zhu Ji feared Wu would tear apart while the north rushed through the gap, and he secretly wrote to Shu urging coordinated contingency plans. Shu answered by sending the right general Yan Yu with five thousand men to stiffen Baidi's garrison pending Zhu Ji's signal. Early in Yongan he rose to supreme grand general and commander-in-chief from Baqiu upriver to Xiling, and in Yuanxing 1 took the left grand marshal's seal where he stood. Years before, after Zhu Ran had mourned Zhu Zhi, he asked to take back the Shi surname, but Sun Quan refused; in the Wufeng era Zhu Ji petitioned again for the Shi name, and he died in Jianheng 2.
17
姿 "?"
Lü Fan, styled Ziheng, came from Xiyang in Runan commandery. As a young man he served as a county clerk and cut a striking figure. A local magnate surnamed Liu had wealth and a lovely daughter; Lü Fan asked for her hand. The mother balked, but the father said, "Look at Lü Ziheng—do you think he will stay poor forever?" and the match was made. He later fled the wars to Shouchun; Sun Ce singled him out at sight, and Lü Fan pledged himself, bringing a hundred household warriors into Sun Ce's camp. The Lady Dowager was still at Jiangdu, and Sun Ce sent Lü Fan to escort her. Tao Qian, governor of Xu Province, took Lü Fan for a Yuan spy and had the county jail him for questioning; Lü Fan's stalwart retainers broke him out and carried him home. Only Lü Fan and Sun He stayed constantly at Sun Ce's side through every hardship; Sun Ce treated them like family and brought them to the inner hall to feast before his mother. He followed Sun Ce's storming of Lujiang, crossed east with him to Hengjiang and Dangli, broke Zhang Ying and Yu Mi, took Lesser Danyang and Hushu, and Lü Fan became chancellor of Hushu. Once Sun Ce secured Moling and Qu'e, absorbed Ze Rong and Liu Yao's remnants, he added two thousand foot and fifty horses to Lü Fan's command. He later governed Wanling, crushed the Danyang bandits, came back to Wu, and rose to area commander. 〈The Jiang Biao Zhuan records a pitch-pot game alone with Sun Ce: Lü Fan said, Your enterprise swells by the day and so does your army; even from afar I hear the staff is not fully knit; let me hold the area commander's seal for a time and help you sort the ranks. Sun Ce answered, Ziheng, you are a man of standing with a large following and battlefield laurels—why demean yourself to clerk's work inside camp? Lü Fan replied, That is not the point. Those who left home to follow you are not here for wives and children; they mean to set the age to rights. We share one boat on a wide sea: one loose rope drowns everyone aboard. This is my calculus too, not only yours. Sun Ce laughed and had no answer. Lü Fan left, swapped his gown for field dress, took a riding crop, presented himself at headquarters as acting area commander, and Sun Ce gave him the tally and the whole staff. After that the host grew orderly, and stern regulations ran through every camp.〉
18
西 西 使 寿 使
Meanwhile Chen Yu of Xiapi called himself governor of Wu, held Haixi, and dealt with the magnate Yan Baihu. Sun Ce marched in person against Yan Baihu while detaching Lü Fan and Xu Yi to strike Chen Yu at Haixi, taking the head of Chen Yu's champion Chen Mu. 〈The Jiu zhou chun qiu says: in Chuping 3 the Yangzhou inspector Chen Yi died and Yuan Shu named Chen Yu acting shepherd of Yangzhou. Later Yuan Shu lost to Cao Cao at Fengqiu; the south turned on Chen Yu, and Chen Yu held the line against them. Yuan Shu fled to Yinling with smooth talk and humble phrases, yet Chen Yu misread the moment and, out of timidity, never struck while the chance lasted. Yuan Shu then massed troops north of the Huai and marched on Shouchun. Chen Yu panicked and sent his brother Chen Gongyan to beg a truce of Yuan Shu. Yuan Shu seized the envoy and pressed forward, and Chen Yu bolted home to Xiapi.〉 He also joined the attacks on Zu Lang at Lingyang and Tai Shi Ci at Yongli. Seven counties were settled; Lü Fan became general of the household who campaigns against captives, struck Jiangxia, then swung back to quiet Poyang. When Sun Ce died he raced to Wu for the funeral. Later Sun Quan renewed the Jiangxia campaign and left Lü Fan with Zhang Zhao to hold the rear. When Cao Cao came to Chibi, Lü Fan stood with Zhou Yu and broke him; Lü Fan was named lieutenant general, governor of Pengze, and given Pengze, Chaisang, and Liyang as fiscal domain. When Liu Bei visited Jing to meet Sun Quan, Lü Fan privately urged Sun Quan to hold him fast. He was later raised to general who pacifies the south and camped at Chaisang.
19
" "
On Sun Quan's expedition against Guan Yu he stopped at Lü Fan's headquarters. He told him, Had I listened to you sooner, I would be spared this grind. I go north to take him; you will hold Jianye for me. After Sun Quan crushed Guan Yu he moved the court to Wuchang, made Lü Fan general who establishes might, marquis of Wanling, governor of Danyang administering from Jianye, with command from Fuzhou to the sea, and later shifted his stipend towns to Liyang, Huai'an, and Ningguo. Cao Xiu, Zhang Liao, Zang Ba, and others invaded Wu; Lü Fan led Xu Sheng, Quan Zong, Sun Shao, and the river fleet against Cao Xiu at Dongkou. He advanced to forward general, took the baton, and traded his fief for the marquisate of Nanchang. A gale caught the fleet; thousands drowned when boats rolled; on the withdrawal he was named shepherd of Yangzhou.
20
使 使 簿
He loved pomp: even great men like Lu Xun and Quan Zong, to say nothing of younger lords, approached him with stiff formality. His house and wardrobe ran to splendor, yet he toiled at duty and kept the code, so Sun Quan prized his loyalty and forgave the flash. 〈The Jiang Biao Zhuan says informers charged Lü Fan and He Qi with finery fit for a king; Sun Quan replied, Guan Zhong once overstepped rites, yet Duke Huan smiled and bore it without losing the hegemony. Ziheng and Gongmiao commit none of Guan Zhong's sins; their gear is simply polished and their convoys smart—that only dresses the army; what harm is there to rule? The accuser never dared raise the matter again.〉 Sun Ce had put Lü Fan in charge of the books at Qu; young Sun Quan would dip into the funds for private ends, yet Lü Fan always reported each request upward and never signed off alone—so the heir once thought him tiresome. When Sun Quan governed Yangxian and skimmed the ledgers, Sun Ce sometimes audited the books; merit officer Zhou Gu would falsify the registers so no questions followed. Sun Quan had liked Zhou Gu in the moment, but once he ruled the realm he prized Lü Fan's honesty and relied on him heavily, while Zhou Gu, who knew only how to cook books, never won office again.
21
使 "!" 退 使 便
In Huangwu 7 Lü Fan was named grand marshal; the credentials never reached him—he died first. Sun Quan wore white, held a state lament, and sent envoys to confer the seal and ribbon after his death. After moving the court to Jianye he stopped at Lü Fan's grave, cried "Ziheng!" until tears ran, and offered the highest sacrifice of an ox. 〈The Jiang Biao Zhuan says: when Sun Quan first shifted the seat to Jianye he feasted his commanders and asked Yan Jun, I once ranked Lu Su with Deng Yu and Lü Fan with Wu Han, and you all demurred—now that time has tested them, what is your verdict? Yan Jun rose from his cushion and said, I failed to see your meaning and assumed Your Majesty had overstated Lu Su and Lü Fan. Sun Quan answered, When Deng Yu first met Guangwu, the emperor was still an envoy of Gengshi pacifying Hebei and holding only the grand marshal's baton—no imperial ambition yet. Deng Yu pressed him to revive the Han; he opened the first serious counsel. Lu Su is bold and far-sighted; one private word with me touched the grand strategy—like Deng Yu, hence the parallel. Lü Fan fled Yuan Shu to my brother, served my brother's separate command, begged the area command to set the army in order, and though fond of display always put the state first—Wu Han in another skin, so I named him thus. Each comparison had a point; it was no private favor. Yan Jun conceded.〉 Lü Fan's eldest son died young; the second son Lü Ju succeeded him.
22
The heir: Lü Ju.
23
使使 西 使使 " "
Lü Ju, styled Shiyi. Through his father's rank he entered as a gentleman; when Lü Fan fell mortally ill he became deputy colonel of the army and helped run the staff. After Lü Fan died he was promoted to gentleman of the household attached to the army stabilization command. He repeatedly cleared mountain strongholds in the worst terrain and never failed; he followed Pan Jun against the Five Gorges and won further distinction. When Zhu Ran besieged Fancheng, Lü Ju and Zhu Yi tore down the outer ring of fortifications, and Lü Ju came home a lieutenant general. He was called in as commander of the right wing of the horse corral, then promoted to colonel of the agile cavalry. In Taiyuan 1 a gale drove the river over its banks toward the gates; Sun Quan's inspectors found only Lü Ju launching great ships to meet the flood. Sun Quan commended him and named him general who smashes Wei. When Sun Quan fell seriously ill he named Lü Ju commander of the heir apparent's right guard. When the crown prince succeeded, Lü Ju became right general. When Wei struck Dongxing, Lü Ju marched to the relief and earned credit. The next year Sun Jun murdered Zhuge Ke and advanced Lü Ju to chief of cavalry with custody of the western palace. In Wufeng 2 he took the baton, joined Sun Jun's raid on Shouchun, and on the way back smashed Cao Zhen at Gaoting. In Taiping 1 he invaded Wei but turned back short of the Huai when he learned Sun Jun was dead and Sun Lin had seized power; enraged, he marched home intending to depose Sun Lin. Sun Lin answered with an edict through the secretariat, ordering Wen Qin, Liu Zuan, and Tang Zi to arrest Lü Ju while his cousin Sun Lu blocked him at Jiangdu with the capital garrison. His staff urged defection to Wei; Lü Ju said, I will not live as a turncoat. He then took his own life. His kin to the third degree were extirpated.
24
使
Zhu Huan, styled Xiumu, came from Wu in Wu commandery. While Sun Quan still held the rank of general, Zhu Huan served on his staff and became magistrate of Yuyao. A plague struck the county and grain soared in price; Zhu Huan split the work among able officers, fed the sick gruel and physic himself, and won the people's devotion. He rose to colonel who smashes bandits, took two thousand men, and recruited stragglers across Wu and Kuaiji until he had over ten thousand within a year. Then Danyang and Poyang bandits swarmed, stormed cities, slew magistrates, and camped in every valley. Zhu Huan led the generals in swift strikes and stamped them out. He stepped up to lieutenant general and village marquis of Xincheng.
25
使 使 " ? !" 退
He later succeeded Zhou Tai as Ruxu commander. In Huangwu 1 Wei sent Grand Marshal Cao Ren with tens of thousands toward Ruxu; Cao Ren meant to snatch the midriver islet while crying aloud that he would strike Xianxi to the east. Zhu Huan split his force for Xianxi, but scouts soon reported Cao Ren already seventy li from Ruxu on the embankment. He recalled the Xianxi column, yet Cao Ren arrived before it returned. Only five thousand of Zhu Huan's men stood ready; every general quaked, yet Zhu Huan told them, When two armies meet, the general decides the day, not the head count. You know Cao Ren's reputation in the field—how does it stack against mine? The classic rule that the invader needs twice the strength applies on open ground. It assumes no walled camps and evenly matched nerve. Their general has no genius or nerve, his men are frightened, and a thousand-li slog has broken horse and rider; Zhu Huan and your comrades are ready to meet him. We hold this high town with the river at our front and hills at our back, fresh against weary, defender against intruder—that is the posture that wins every fight. Were Cao Pi himself to come I would not fret, let alone Cao Ren! He furled drums and colors and feigned weakness to bait the enemy. Cao Ren sent Cao Tai against Ruxu town while Chang Diao, Zhuge Qian, and Wang Shuang skimmed in oiled boats toward the central islet. That islet held the soldiers' wives and children. Cao Ren camped ten thousand at Tuogao to backstop Cao Tai. Zhu Huan's men took the oil boats, others fell on Chang Diao, and Zhu Huan himself drove Cao Tai off in flames, took Chang Diao's head, dragged Wang Shuang in bonds to Wuchang, and left a thousand Wei dead in the water and dust. Sun Quan rewarded him with the Jiaxing marquisate, the rank of general who rouses martial prowess, and the titular chancellorship of Pengcheng.
26
" 便 "
In Huangwu 7 Zhou Fang of Poyang baited Wei's Grand Marshal Cao Xiu, who marched a hundred thousand men to Wancheng to receive him. Lu Xun held supreme command while Quan Zong and Zhu Huan led thirty thousand each against Cao Xiu. Cao Xiu saw the trap and should have withdrawn, yet trusted his numbers and demanded one decisive clash. Zhu Huan urged, Cao Xiu owes his post to connections, not to genius in arms. Fight him and he will break; break and he will run. His retreat must thread Jiashi and Guache—both defiles where ten thousand men felling trees could swallow his whole army. Give me my command to cut those passes and we may take Cao Xiu alive. If Heaven favors us and Cao Xiu falls into your hands, we can roll forward, seize Shouchun, clip the Huai's south bank, and eye Xuchang and Luoyang—a once-in-ages opening we dare not waste. Sun Quan first asked Lu Xun, who vetoed the scheme, so it died in council.
27
簿 " "使 " "使
In Huanglong 1 Zhu Huan became forward general, nominal shepherd of Qing Province, and took the baton. In Jiahe 6 Lü Xi, chief clerk of Wei's Lujiang, begged Wu to send a relief host and promised to open the gates. Zhu Huan and the guards general Quan Zong marched to meet him. The plot leaked; the expedition had to pull out. A stream lay a li outside the walls, thirty-odd zhang across, knee-deep in the shallows and deeper in the channel; the columns filed across while Zhu Huan alone covered the rear. The Wei governor Li Ying massed horse and foot, meaning to strike when half the Wu host was midstream. When he saw Zhu Huan's banner and credentials still on the far bank he dared not move—that was the dread Zhu Huan inspired. Quan Zong held overall command while Sun Quan also sent Hu Zong to read edicts and sit on the council of war. Because the campaign won nothing, Quan Zong proposed splitting the generals for a surprise stroke. Proud Zhu Huan hated taking orders; he confronted Quan Zong, grew heated, and argued the dispositions. Quan Zong deflected blame: The throne named Hu Zong commander; I merely agreed. Zhu Huan's fury deepened; back in camp he sent for Hu Zong. Hu Zong reached the gate; Zhu Huan stepped out, glanced at his attendants, and said, If I loose my grip, you may scatter. One man slipped aside and whispered that Hu Zong should leave.
28
使 " ""姿"
Zhu Huan emerged, missed Hu Zong, realized his own men had turned the envoy back, and cut them down. When his army adviser protested, Zhu Huan killed him too, feigned madness, and rode to Jianye for a cure. Sun Quan valued his service too much to punish him. 〈Sun Sheng cites the classic: ministers must not play tyrant or patron; doing so ruins house and state. Zhu Huan's savagery was tiger-wolf stuff—intolerable even in a prince, let alone a general? The proverb says: win one bravo and lose a kingdom—no graver fault than sparing such a crime.〉 He put his son Zhu Yi in charge of his troops, set physicians to watch him, and after a few months sent him back to the islet garrison. Sun Quan walked him to the parting rite and said, Rebels still live and the realm is not yet one; I had meant to give you fifty thousand men and a whole front of your own—if only your illness does not return. Zhu Huan answered, "Heaven gave Your Majesty a sovereign's bearing to rule the four seas; loading your servant with the work of scourging traitors will cure whatever ails him." 〈The Wu lu adds: Zhu Huan raised his cup: I march far; let me tug your beard once and I die content. Sun Quan leaned on the rail; Zhu Huan stepped up, tugged his whiskers, and said, Today I have truly tweaked the tiger. Sun Quan roared with laughter.〉
29
祿
He could not bear subordination: if orders cramped him in battle he boiled with rage. Yet he despised riches, honored duty, and never forgot a face. One glance decades ago stayed with him; he knew every face among ten thousand dependents. He fed his soldiers, carried his whole kinship on his pay, and split every stipend. When his last illness came, every tent mourned. He died at sixty-two in Chiwu 1. Officers, men, women—everyone wept for him. His house was bare; Sun Quan gave five thousand hu of salt to bury him decently. His son Zhu Yi inherited the title.
30
The heir: Zhu Yi.
31
" 便 " " 使
Zhu Yi, styled Jiwen, entered the court as a gentleman through his father's rank, 〈The Wen shi zhuan tells how Zhang Chun, Zhang Yan, and Zhu Yi, still boys, once called on Chief of Cavalry Zhu Ju. Zhu Ju had heard of their budding fame and proposed a trial: I am a dull old man who has long thirsted for word of you. The swift courser wins praise for its dash, the hawk for its strike—each of you versify whatever your eye falls on, and we dine only after. Zhang Yan sang the dog: fierce at the door, deadly in the field—like Han Lu and Song Que, names inked on the histories. Zhang Chun took the rush mat: laid in winter, bamboo in summer, yielding the seat—fit for a gentleman. Zhu Yi chose the crossbow: wood from the southern ranges, bronze from Bell Mountain—draw, loose, and drop the falcon on the parapet. The three each versified the first object they saw, finished, then took their seats, and Zhu Ju was delighted.〉 He later became colonel of cavalry, inherited Zhu Huan's command, joined Zhu Ran's Chiwu 4 strike on Wei's Fancheng, planned the breach of the outer stockade, and returned a lieutenant general. Wen Qin of Wei stacked camps at Lu'an along every choke point to lure deserters and raid the frontier. Zhu Yi led his two thousand in a night rush, shattered seven of Wen Qin's camps, took several hundred heads, and won promotion as general who displays martial prowess. Sun Quan debated tactics with him and liked every answer. Sun Quan told Zhu Ju, his kinsman and chief of cavalry, I always knew Zhu Yi was solid; meeting him he outshines even the reports. In the thirteenth year Wen Qin pretended to defect, writing secretly to Zhu Yi to ask him to ride out in person. Zhu Yi laid the letter before the throne, argued it was a snare, and warned against a hasty welcome. The edict answered, The north is still divided; if Wen Qin means to submit, you should meet him for now. If you fear treachery, set traps and stack the border with heavy arms. He sent Lü Ju with twenty thousand to back Zhu Yi; they reached the frontier and Wen Qin never came over. In Jianxing 1 he became general who guards the south. The same year Hu Zun and Zhuge Dan struck Dongxing; Zhu Yi led the river wing, smashed the pontoon, and broke the Wei host. 〈The Wu shu adds: Zhu Yi followed Zhuge Ke at Xincheng; when the siege stalled, he urged a fast return to raid Stone City, which would fall in days. Zhuge Ke wrote him down; Zhu Yi flung the letter down: You ignore my counsel for some stripling's whim! Zhuge Ke raged, stripped him of command on the spot, and packed him off to Jianye.〉 In Taiping 2 he took the baton as grand commander and marched to relieve Shouchun without breaking the ring. On the march home Sun Lin murdered him on a false charge. 〈The Wu shu says Sun Lin summoned him; Lu Kang would have held him back, but Zhu Yi said, "Zitong is kin—why doubt!" He went. Sun Lin had brutes drag him from his cushion. Zhu Yi cried, I am Wu's loyal servant—what is my crime? They hauled him out and killed him.〉
32
Appraisal
33
The historian concludes: Zhu Zhi and Lü Fan rose as old retainers; Zhu Ran and Zhu Huan won fame in battle; Lü Ju, Zhu Yi, and Shi Ji each had a general's gift and could uphold their fathers' houses. Lü Fan and Zhu Huan braved deadly ground yet died in honor; Lü Ju and Zhu Yi committed no such outrage yet perished—the difference lay in the times they met, not in their merits alone.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →