← Back to 史記

孫子吳起列傳

Biographies of Sun Tzu and Wu Qi

Chapter 65 of 史記 · Records of the Grand Historian
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 65
Next Chapter →
1
使使 使使 西
Sun Wu, known as Sun Tzu, was a man of Qi. He presented his military strategies to King Helü of Wu. King Helü said, “I have read all thirteen of your chapters. May we try drilling the troops on a small scale?” He replied: “Yes.” King Helü said, “May we try it with the palace women?” He said: “Yes.” So he was permitted to do so. One hundred eighty palace ladies were selected. Sun Tzu divided the women into two teams, appointing the king's two favorite consorts as captains of each team, and ordered all of them to carry halberds. He asked them, “Do you know where your heart, your left hand, your right hand, and your back are?” The women said: “Yes.” Sun Tzu said, “When I say forward, look toward the chest; when I say left, look to the left hand; when I say right, look to the right hand; when I say back, look behind you.” The women replied: “Yes.” Once the regulations were promulgated, he set up the executioner's axe and halberd, and repeated the commands three times while explaining them five times. Then he beat the drum for turning right, and the women burst out laughing. Sun Tzu said: “If the regulations are unclear and the commands unfamiliar, it is the general's fault.” He repeated the commands three times and explained them five times again, then beat the drum for turning left, and the women burst out laughing once more. Sun Tzu said: “If the regulations are unclear and the commands unfamiliar, it is the general's fault; once they are clear but not followed, it is the officers' and soldiers' fault.” He was about to execute the two team leaders. King Helü watched from the terrace above. When he saw that his beloved consorts were about to be executed, he was badly alarmed. He hurriedly sent a messenger down with orders, saying: “I already know the general can use troops. Without these two consorts, my food has no flavor. Please do not execute them.” Sun Tzu said: “I have already received the command to serve as general. When in the army, there are some of the sovereign's orders that a general does not accept.” He proceeded to execute the two team leaders as an example to the army. He appointed their deputies as team leaders, then beat the drum again. The women moved left and right, forward and back, kneeling and standing—all conformed perfectly to the rules and regulations. None dared make a sound. Then Sun Tzu sent a messenger to report to the king, saying: “The troops are now well-ordered. Your Majesty can come down to observe them. Whatever you wish to use them for—even charging into water or fire—they will do it.” King Helü said, “General, please retire to your quarters. I do not wish to come down and observe.” Sun Tzu said, “The king only enjoys the theory but cannot put it into practice.” Thus, Helü knew that Sun Tzu could command troops, and at last he appointed him general. He broke the powerful state of Chu in the west and entered Ying. In the north he awed Qi and Jin, making his name illustrious among the feudal lords—Sun Tzu played a role in this.
2
使
More than a century after Sun Wu died, Sun Bin appeared. Sun Bin was born between A and Juan. He, too, was a descendant of Sun Wu's lineage. Sun Bin had once studied military strategy together with Pang Juan. After Pang Juan entered Wei's service and became a general under King Hui of Wei, he considered himself no match for Sun Bin and secretly summoned him. When Bin arrived, Pang Juan feared that he was the better man, resented him, and had him punished by amputating his feet and branding his face, intending to keep him hidden from sight.
3
使使 使
When a Qi envoy came to Liang, Sun Bin, then serving as a convict laborer, met him secretly and persuaded him. The Qi envoy thought him extraordinary and secretly took him back to Qi. The Qi general Tian Ji treated him well and hosted him as a guest. Tian Ji often raced chariots with the Qi nobles and wagered heavily. Sun Bin saw that their horses were not very different in speed and were divided into upper, middle, and lower grades. So Sun Bin said to Tian Ji, “My lord frequently wagers heavily on the races. I can make you win.” Tian Ji believed him and wagered a thousand jin with the king and the nobles. When it came time for the race, Sun Bin said: “Now use your lowest team against their highest, your highest against their middle, and your middle against their lowest.” When the three races were over, Tian Ji had lost one but won two, and in the end he won the king’s thousand jin. So Tian Ji recommended Sun Bin to King Wei. King Wei questioned him about military strategy and appointed him as his teacher.
4
Afterward, Wei attacked Zhao. Zhao was in dire straits and requested aid from Qi. King Wei of Qi wanted to appoint Sun Bin as general, but Sun Bin declined, saying, “A man who has suffered punishment cannot serve.” So they appointed Tian Ji as general and Sun Bin as advisor. Sun Bin rode in a supply wagon, seated there and making plans. Tian Ji wanted to lead troops to Zhao, but Sun Bin said, “One who untangles a snarl does not seize the fist; one who rescues a brawl does not strike the head. Strike where they are exposed and hit the void; block their form and check their momentum, and they will resolve themselves. Now Liang and Zhao are attacking each other—their light troops and elite soldiers must be exhausted outside, the old and weak weary inside. My lord would do better to lead the army swiftly toward Daliang, occupy its roads, and strike where Wei is exposed. They will surely abandon Zhao and come back to save themselves. In this way we can lift the siege of Zhao in one stroke and take advantage of Wei's exhaustion.” Tian Ji followed this advice. Wei indeed abandoned Handan, fought Qi at Guiling, and was badly defeated.
5
使 西 使
Thirteen years later, Wei and Zhao attacked Han, and Han urgently appealed to Qi. Qi sent Tian Ji as general, and he marched straight toward Daliang. When the Wei general Pang Juan heard this, he left Han and returned, but the Qi army had already passed by and gone west. Sun Bin said to Tian Ji: “The troops of the three Jin states are fierce and brave by nature, and they look down on Qi. Qi has a reputation for cowardice. Good warriors exploit the enemy's momentum and guide it to their own advantage. The Art of War says: one who races a hundred li for advantage will lose his general; one who races fifty li will have only half his army arrive. Have the Qi army enter Wei territory and make ten thousand cooking fires; the next day, make five thousand; the day after that, three thousand.” After Pang Juan had marched for three days, he was delighted and said: “I knew the Qi army was cowardly. After only three days in our territory, more than half their soldiers have deserted.” He abandoned his infantry and pursued them with his light elite, doubling the pace of the march. Sun Tzu calculated their march route—they should arrive at Maling by dusk. The Maling road was narrow, with many obstacles and defiles on the sides, suitable for ambushing troops. They stripped a large tree white and wrote on it: “Pang Juan dies beneath this tree.” Then Sun Bin ordered ten thousand of Qi's best crossbowmen to lie in ambush on both sides of the road, setting the signal: “When you see fire at dusk, all fire together.” Pang Juan indeed arrived beneath the stripped tree at night, saw the pale writing, and lit a torch to read it. Before he had finished reading the writing, the Qi army's ten thousand crossbows all fired, and the Wei army fell into chaos and scattered. Pang Juan knew his stratagems were exhausted, and his army was defeated, so he cut his own throat, saying, “Now I have made that boy famous!” Qi pressed its victory, completely destroyed the Wei army, captured Crown Prince Shen, and returned. Sun Bin thereby became famous throughout the world, and his military strategy was handed down through later ages.
6
Wu Qi was a man of Wei who loved military affairs. He had once studied under Zengzi and later served the lord of Lu. When Qi attacked Lu, Lu wanted to appoint Wu Qi as general, but because Wu Qi had married a Qi woman, Lu suspected him. Wu Qi then sought to establish his reputation, so he killed his wife to show that he had no tie to Qi. Lu finally appointed him as general. As general, he attacked Qi and greatly defeated them.
7
Some men of Lu spoke ill of Wu Qi, saying, “In his conduct, he is a suspicious and cruel man. In his youth, his family had accumulated a thousand jin. He sought office but did not succeed, exhausting his family fortune. When the villagers laughed at him, Wu Qi killed more than thirty of those who had slandered him and went east through the Wei city gate. He bid farewell to his mother, bit his arm, and swore: “If I do not become a minister or chancellor, I will not return to Wei.” So he served Zengzi. After some time, his mother died, but Wu Qi did not go home. Zengzi despised him for this and broke off relations with him. Wu Qi then went to Lu, studied military methods, and served the Lord of Lu. The Lord of Lu suspected him, so Wu Qi killed his wife to seek the generalship. Lu is a small state. If it wins renown for victory in battle, the feudal lords will covet it. Moreover, Lu and Wei are brother states, yet if my lord employs him, that is to abandon Wei.” The lord of Lu grew suspicious and dismissed Wu Qi.
8
Wu Qi then heard of Marquis Wen of Wei’s worthiness and wished to enter his service. Marquis Wen asked Li Ke: “What kind of man is Wu Qi?” Li Ke said: “Wu Qi is greedy and fond of women, but in using troops, even Sima Rangju cannot surpass him.” Marquis Wen of Wei therefore appointed him general, attacked Qin, and captured five cities.
9
When Wu Qi was general, he shared clothing and food with the lowest soldiers. He did not lay out mats when sleeping, did not ride when marching, personally wrapped the provisions, and shared hardship with the soldiers. When a soldier had a festering sore, Wu Qi sucked out the pus for him. When the soldier’s mother heard this, she wept for him. Someone said: “Your son is a soldier, and the general himself sucked his sore. Why do you weep?” The mother said: “It is not that. In previous years Lord Wu sucked my husband's sore, and my husband fought without turning back until he died on the battlefield. Now Lord Wu has sucked my son's sore as well. I do not know where my son will die. That is why I weep for him.”
10
西
Marquis Wen considered Wu Qi skilled in using troops, incorruptible, fair, and fully able to win the soldiers’ hearts, so he appointed him governor of Xihe to resist Qin and Han.
11
西
After Marquis Wen of Wei died, Wu Qi served his son Marquis Wu. Marquis Wu floated down the Yellow River, and in midstream he turned to Wu Qi and said: “How beautiful are these mountain and river defenses! This is Wei's treasure!” Wu Qi replied: “It depends on virtue, not on natural defenses. In ancient times the Three Miao tribes had Dongting Lake on the left and Pengli Lake on the right. They did not cultivate virtue and righteousness, so Yu destroyed them. Xia Jie resided with the Yellow River on the left and Mount Tai on the right, Yique Pass to the south and Yangchang to the north. He practiced unbenevolent government, so Tang exiled him. King Zhou of Yin had Mengmen Pass on the left and the Taihang Mountains on the right, Changshan to the north and the great river flowing south. He practiced unvirtuous government, so King Wu killed him. From this we can see that it depends on virtue, not on natural defenses. If my lord does not cultivate virtue, everyone aboard this boat will become your enemy.” Marquis Wu said: “Excellent.”
12
西 使 西
Thereupon Wu Qi was appointed governor of Xihe, and he gained great renown. Wei appointed a chancellor: Chancellor Tian Wen. Wu Qi was displeased and said to Tian Wen: “May I compare achievements with you?” Tian Wen said, “Very well.” Wu Qi said: “Commanding the three armies, making soldiers gladly die for you, and keeping enemy states from daring to plot—who compares to me?” Tian Wen said: “I do not match you.” Wu Qi said: “Managing the hundred officials, drawing close to the people, and filling the treasuries—who compares to me?” Tian Wen said: “I do not match you.” Wu Qi said, “Guarding Xihe so that Qin troops dare not advance east, and making Han and Zhao come as guests—who compares to me?” Tian Wen said: “I do not match you.” Wu Qi said: “In these three matters you are all below me, yet your position is above mine. Why?” Tian Wen said, “The lord is young, the state is unsettled, the great ministers are not yet attached, and the people do not yet trust—at such a time, should the state be entrusted to you? Or should it be entrusted to me?” Wu Qi was silent for a long time, then said, “It should be entrusted to you.” Tian Wen said, “This is why I stand above you.” Wu Qi then realized that he was not Tian Wen’s equal.
13
After Tian Wen died, Gongsun became chancellor, married a Wei princess, and plotted against Wu Qi. Gongsun's servant said: “Wu Qi can be easily removed.” Gongsun said, “What is to be done?” His servant said, “Wu Qi is frugal and takes pride in his reputation. My lord should first speak to Marquis Wu, saying, “Wu Qi is a worthy man, but your lordship's state is small and borders powerful Qin. I privately fear that he may not remain devoted to Wei.” Marquis Wu will immediately say, “What then?” My lord should then say to Marquis Wu, “Try offering him the princess in marriage. If he is devoted, he will certainly accept. If he has no intention of staying, he will certainly decline. Use this to test him. My lord should summon Wu Qi to your house, and then have the princess show anger and treat you contemptuously. When Wu Qi sees the princess treating you with contempt, he will certainly decline.” So Wu Qi saw the princess treating the Wei chancellor with contempt, and he indeed declined Marquis Wu's offer. Marquis Wu suspected a plot but did not fully believe it. Fearing punishment, Wu Qi left and went to Chu.
14
西 使
King Dao of Chu had long heard that Wu Qi was worthy; when he arrived, he was made chancellor of Chu. He clarified the laws, made the orders precise, abolished superfluous offices, dismissed distant members of the royal clan, and used the savings to support and train fighting men. His aim was to strengthen the army and break the influence of itinerant persuaders who argued for vertical and horizontal alliances. In this way, he pacified the Baiyue in the south; to the north, he annexed Chen and Cai and drove back the three Jin; in the west he attacked Qin. The feudal lords feared Chu’s strength. For this reason, the nobles of Chu all wanted to harm Wu Qi. When King Dao died, the royal clansmen and great ministers rebelled and attacked Wu Qi. Wu Qi fled to the king's corpse and threw himself upon it. Those who attacked him shot and stabbed Wu Qi, and also struck King Dao. After King Dao was buried, the crown prince ascended and ordered the chief minister to execute everyone who had shot at Wu Qi and struck the king’s corpse. More than seventy families were executed, and their clans were exterminated, for shooting at Wu Qi.
15
The Grand Historian says: The military works commonly cited in the world all discuss Sun Tzu’s thirteen chapters and Wu Qi’s Art of War. These circulate widely, so I will not discuss them here. A saying goes, “Those who can act are not necessarily able to speak; those who can speak are not necessarily able to act.” Sun Bin clearly outplotted Pang Juan, yet he could not escape early from the disaster of mutilation. Wu Qi explained to Marquis Wu that terrain was less important than virtue, yet when he put his ideas into practice in Chu he was harsh, cruel, and lacking in benevolence, and so he lost his life. Alas!
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →