← Back to 宋史

卷三百七十二 列傳第一百三十一 朱倬 王綸 尹穡 王之望 徐俯 沈與求 翟汝文 王庶 辛炳

Volume 372 Biographies 131: Zhu Zhuo, Wang Lun, Yin Se, Wang Zhiwang, Xu Fu, Shen Yuqiu, Di Ruwen, Wang Shu, Xin Bing

Chapter 372 of 宋史 · History of Song
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 372
Next Chapter →
1
Zhu Zhuo, Wang Lun, Yin Se, Wang Zhiwang, Xu Fu, Shen Yuqiu, Di Ruwen, Wang Shu, and Xin Bing
2
調簿 西 使
Zhu Zhuo, whose courtesy name was Hanzhang, was descended from the Tang chancellor Jing Ze; seven generations earlier his family had fled into Fujian and settled in Min County. The family had studied the Book of Changes for generations, and he enrolled in the Imperial Academy. In the fifth year of the Xuanhe reign he passed the jinshi examination and was posted as assistant magistrate of Yixing in Changzhou. As the Jin were about to strike the frontier, local people sought refuge elsewhere; Zhuo arranged boats and provisions for them, and many owed their escape to him. Soon afterward the people petitioned the prefecture about flood damage; the prefecture commissioned Zhuo to investigate, and he cut field rents by nine-tenths. The prefect was furious but could not reverse his decision. Zhang Jun recommended him; summoned to an imperial audience, he was appointed to the Fujian and Guangdong West fiscal offices. The imperial envoy Ming Nang recommended him to court again. With Liu Yu then a cause of alarm, Zhuo was granted an audience and predicted his certain downfall. Emperor Gaozong was delighted and ordered his rank advanced to he-ru status. He fell out with Chancellor Qin Hui and was sent out to serve as an instructor in Yuezhou. On Zhang Shou's recommendation he was appointed instructor to the various imperial princes' households. Hui hated discussion of military affairs; when Zhuo spoke about collecting the unburied dead on the battlefield, he offended him once more.
3
When Liang Rujia was made commissioner for the Eastern Zhe circuit, he recommended Zhuo as acting staff adviser. A band of brigands was taken; interrogation was entrusted to Zhuo. He let only two escape while releasing the rest without further questioning. He said, "When my grandfather was magistrate of Chong'an, he seized two hundred bandits, and more than seventy were put to death." My grandfather said they were starving people looting for food—how could one apply the full weight of the law to them all? He cleared them all of guilt and did not seek reward for doing so. How could I shame my grandfather by acting otherwise? He was then appointed vice-prefect of Nanjian. A band from Jian led by A Wei numbered several thousand men. Because Nanjian bordered Jian, the local troops were too weak to act; Zhuo offered rich bounties to recruit men who captured the rebels, and the district was pacified.
4
西殿 使使 稿
He was appointed prefect of Huizhou. When he took leave of the throne he mentioned his earlier prediction that Liu Yu would fall. Gaozong remembered and asked, "Where have you been held back all this time?" Zhuo answered, "Blocked by Hui." The emperor's expression darkened; he comforted Zhuo with kind words and watched him depart. Within ten days he was made Vice Director of the Directorate of Education, then Intendant for Western Zhe; the court also ruled that hereafter intendants appointed from the central government must attend morning audience on the day of appointment—arrangements tailored for Zhuo. After the audience the emperor said, "I am personally elevating you to serve as a regional commissioner, so everyone will see that posts at court and in the provinces carry equal weight." He added, "Others do not know you, but I alone do." He was appointed Right Rectifier of Writings and eventually rose to Censor-in-Chief. He once said, "The ruler appoints censors as his eyes and ears; the post is not for settling scores or venting spite—one's words must accord with Heaven's will." Whenever he drafted a memorial he rose before dawn and prayed aloud, as though Heaven itself were watching. He submitted dozens of memorials—on opening granaries, lowering rice prices, curbing private salt, auditing army rations—and as a rule burned his drafts rather than keep copies. After supervising the civil examinations he was promoted to Vice Commissioner of the Secretariat-Chancellery.
5
In the thirty-first year of the Shaoxing reign he was appointed Right Vice Director of the Ministry of Works—effectively chief minister. When the Jin crossed the Yangzi, Zhuo proposed three policies: active combat, defensive preparation, and flexible response. He argued that victory belonged to those who could adapt; the emperor strongly agreed. He also analyzed three possible enemy moves: the best for them was to consolidate by farming and building fortifications; next was steadfast defense; worst was a rash attempt to cross the river. Jin would surely take the lowest course. Events unfolded exactly as he had foretold. Shi Hao, Yu Yunwen, Wang Huai, Chen Junqing, and Liu Qi all rose through his recommendations.
6
殿 殿
After Gaozong returned to the capital from Jiankang, he contemplated abdicating the throne. Zhuo secretly memorialized, "The disaster at Jingkang came because the throne passed too hastily; why not proceed more slowly?" Uneasy in his own mind, he repeatedly asked to resign. He was ordered to take up the honorary post of Academician of the Hall for Cultivating Culture and oversee the Taiping Xingguo Palace in Jiangzhou. After Xiaozong's accession, remonstrators raised the issue, and he was demoted to Academician of the Hall of Governance. The following year he retired and died. His former rank was restored; he received a chancellor's funeral honors and was posthumously granted the title of Special Advancement. His grandson Zhu Zhuo passed the examinations in the fourteenth year of Chunxi and rose to Minister of Personnel.
7
簿
Wang Lun, whose courtesy name was Deyan, came from Jiankang. Brilliant as a boy, he could write essays by the age of ten. He passed the jinshi in the fifth year of Shaoxing, became recorder of Kunshan in Pingjiang, and later taught in Zhenjiang, Wuzhou, and Lin'an before serving as acting Rectifier of the Imperial Academy.
8
The Imperial Academy had only recently been founded, its old rules were gone, and affairs rested on clerks' ledgers—which the clerks exploited for graft. Lun straightened the procedures, and the worst abuses were curbed. He was promoted to Editor of Statutes, instructor at the princes' Great and Small Schools, and acting Secretary in the Ministry of War. He argued that Confucius's disciples and later scholars who had served civilization deserved accompanying sacrifice in the Sage's temple; with schools reopening and ritual music restored, that standard ought to be promulgated through every prefecture and county.
9
殿
In the twenty-fourth year Wei Shixun, then Censor-in-Chief, recommended him as Investigating Censor. When he disputed policy with Qin Hui and crossed him, Shixun impeached Lun, adding bluntly that his own judgment was too shallow to have recognized Lun's faults. He was removed from office as a result. A year later he was made prefect of Xingguo district. After Hui's death he was recalled as Attendant of the Secretariat, lecturer at the Chongzheng Hall, and soon acting Vice Minister of Rites.
10
In the twenty-sixth year he passed the examination for Secretariat Drafter. Gaozong took government into his own hands, reclaimed authority, and called gifted men back from obscurity; edicts flooded out, most of them in Lun's hand. Lun urged that local officials ease the people's burdens and asked that they not be constrained by five standard formulae; the emperor agreed. He was also made Court Lecturer. The emperor loved the Zuo Commentary to the Spring and Autumn Annals; Lun's lectures matched his tastes. With fellow lecturers he recommended Zheng Qiao of Xinghua for scholarship and integrity; the court summoned him, granted rank, and supplied paper and brushes to copy his historical works. He entered the Hanlin Academy as additional academician, then rose to Vice Minister of Works while keeping his academy duties. He wrote Wu Jie's spirit-road stele in a style the emperor approved, earning imperial calligraphy and praise.
11
In the twenty-eighth year he was made Vice Commissioner of the Bureau of Military Affairs. A Jin commander was preparing to break the treaty; urgent dispatches arrived from the frontier, yet Chancellor Shen Gai dared not inform the throne. Lun, Vice Commissioner Chen Kangbo, and Co-Vice Commissioner Chen Cheng told the emperor together and pleaded for defensive preparations. Soon afterward Lun fell ill with lung heat-stroke, requested leave, and the emperor sent the court physician with five hundred taels of silver.
12
使 使 使便殿 退 紿
In the sixth month of the twenty-ninth year the court debated dispatching a senior minister as envoy to gauge the enemy while reaffirming peaceful relations. Lun volunteered and was appointed Envoy of Gratitude, with Cao Xun as deputy. In Jin territory he was received with elaborate ceremony. One day he was summoned abruptly to the informal hall, where only one Jin minister attended. The ruler fired question after question; Lun answered each in order until the Jin ruler could not best him. He returned in the ninth month and told the emperor, "Our neighbor's courtesy and peaceful bearing come entirely from Your Majesty's august virtue." Chancellor Tang Situ and others congratulated him. Yet the Jin were already planning to cross the Yangzi; they had merely deceived Lun with shows of goodwill.
13
殿 祿
Lun's chronic illness flared again; he begged a post outside the capital and was made Grand Academician of the Hall for Governance and prefect of Fuzhou, with the emperor's own rhinoceros-horn belt as a parting gift. The next year he became prefect of Jiankang and custodian of the mobile palace. When the enemy struck the Yangzi, Lun sent rapid reports on defensive measures, most of which the emperor adopted. He died in the eighth month of the thirty-first year. He was posthumously granted Left Grandee of Splendid Happiness and the posthumous title Zhangmin. Childless, he adopted his brother Wang Chuo's son as heir.
14
西 殿
Yin Se, whose courtesy name was Shaoji. At the Jianyan restoration he came south from the north. In the thirty-second year of Shaoxing he and Lu You served together as editors at the Bureau of Military Affairs. Acting Commissioner Shi Hao and Co-Commissioner Wang Zushun praised their erudition; both pleased the emperor at audience and were granted jinshi standing. Xiaozong favored scholars from the northwest; in the first year of Longxing he made Se Investigating Censor, then Right Rectifier of Writings. In the fifth month of the second year he became Palace Attendant Censor. He rose to Remonstrator, but was soon dismissed.
15
退 使
After the debacle at Fuli, Tang Situ returned as chancellor; the Jin commander demanded territory by letter, and the emperor ordered court advisers and censors to debate the response. Se, then Investigating Censor, argued that the state still lacked strength and should treat with the enemy: raise the annual tribute, keep the four prefectures, and do not press for recovery of the imperial tombs—only then could peace hold. Soon Lu Zhongxian's mission was bullied by the Jin; as Wang Zhiwang was about to be sent abroad, Zhang Jun protested fiercely. As Right Rectifier, Se feared the peace would fail; he impeached Jun for arrogance, and Jun was soon driven from office. Later the court prepared to surrender the four prefectures and rewrite the state letters at the tribute level demanded—even as Jin armies crossed the border. The emperor began to regret the course. As Attendant Censor, Se demanded a special inquiry to punish everyone who resisted demilitarization or opposed ceding land—more than twenty officials in all.
16
西
With peace the urgent priority, Se was promoted to Remonstrator. Enemy strength grew; the realm was alarmed; supreme commanders resigned one after another. Petitioners denounced the peace policy and charged that "Se serves powerful ministers as their hawk and hound. Zhang Jun's loyalty is known throughout the realm, yet Se ignores public opinion and slanders him recklessly." "Every senior official he dislikes is driven out; they work hand in glove to enact treacherous plots—all deserve death." The emperor was enraged by the petitioners, yet the ministers who had backed Se and the peace policy were soon dismissed one after another. Earlier, Hu Quan had fiercely opposed the peace policy, angering the chief ministers, who sent Quan and Se to organize coastal defenses in Eastern and Western Zhe respectively. Both men took their families with them, were impeached by petitioners, and were dismissed; the full account appears in Chen Kangbo's biography.
17
Wang Zhiwang
18
使
Wang Zhiwang, whose courtesy name was Zhanshu, came from Gucheng in Xiangyang and later settled in Taizhou. His father Wang Gang passed the jinshi in the Yuanfu reign and served as vice-prefect of Huizhou before his death. Zhiwang entered service through yin privilege and passed the jinshi examination in the eighth year of Shaoxing. He taught in Chuzhou, became Registrar of the Imperial Academy, and was promoted to Erudite. After some years he became prefect of Jingmen, intendant for Hunan tea and salt, then Transport Assessor for Tongchuan Circuit, and soon Deputy Transport Commissioner and fiscal commissioner for Chengdu with authority over Sichuan tea and horses.
19
調
The court recommended his ability; summoned to the mobile capital, he was made Vice Director of the Imperial Treasury and overall supervisor of Sichuan finances. When the Jin broke the treaty, dispatches and requisitions poured in by the hundreds, and Zhiwang handled every detail without lapse. He inventoried untaxed pledges and hunted down hidden assets, raising 4.68 million strings of cash—and earned widespread resentment. He was later promoted to Director of the Imperial Treasury.
20
殿
Early in Longxing, Right Remonstrator Wang Dabao denounced him; he was made Compiler at the Hall for Assembled Eminence and custodian of the Taiping Xingguo Palace in Jiangzhou. Soon afterward he served as acting Vice Minister of Revenue and staff adviser to the Jiang-Huai command headquarters. Zhiwang disliked war by temperament; at audience he argued that a ruler's view of military affairs differs from his subjects'—one need only follow Heaven's will. "Heaven's pattern shows north and south already fixed and hard to unite: we cannot abandon the Huai and march north any more than they can cross the Yangzi and drive south." "Turn offensive strength to defense; once defense is firm, adapt to events, seize advantage, and respond accordingly." The emperor ordered the memorial kept at court. He soon entered the Hanlin Academy as well.
21
退使 使 西使 退退
Tang Situ, pressing for peace, had Zhiwang appointed Vice Minister of Personnel and envoy to negotiate with the Jin. The court then debated sending a lesser envoy to scout the enemy first, and Zhiwang was recalled. Zhiwang warned that defenses were unreliable; the emperor quickly abolished the command headquarters, named him imperial envoy for Western Huai, and on appointment promoted him to Right Remonstrator. He then memorialized that ministers clung to partisan views for private ends and begged an edict requiring even hearts in debate. Situ backed peace while Zhang Jun urged recovery; Zhiwang sounded even-handed but secretly aided Situ.
22
退
He soon went to inspect troops on the Yangzi. When the Jin invaded again he offered both peace and war plans and detailed defensive measures; before the memorial arrived he was made Vice Commissioner. After taking office he was soon also Co-Vice Commissioner of Military Affairs. As enemy columns advanced, garrisons at Hao and Chu sometimes fled; the emperor ordered Tang Situ to command Jiang-Huai forces. Before Situ left, Zhiwang was ordered to supervise instead and made Co-Commander-in-Chief. He refused strenuously and would not go. When academy students submitted a joint petition the emperor wished to punish them; Zhiwang interceded and won their release. He then went as Vice Commissioner to encourage the Jiang-Huai armies.
23
退
Talented and capable, he had kept his distance under Qin Hui—some called that integrity. In late Shaoxing he embraced peace with Situ, treating land grants to the enemy as wisdom; the more territory was ceded the stronger the foe grew—and Zhiwang was ruined by it.
24
使
Xu Fu, whose courtesy name was Shichuan, came from Fenning in Hongzhou. His father Xu Xi died in state service, so Fu received the rank of Gentlemen for Unfailing Fidelity and rose to Director of the Gate of the Capital. During the Jingkang crisis Zhang Bangchang seized the throne, and Fu retired. Vice Minister He Changyan and his brother Changchen, shunning Bangchang, both changed their names. Fu bought a maid named Changnu and, when guests came, would call "Forward!"—a pointed mockery of the He brothers. At the start of Jianyan his retirement was revoked and he received a sacrificial stipend.
25
西 便
The inner attendant Zheng Chen met Fu in Jiangxi, admired his poetry, and recommended him to Gaozong. Hu Zhiru in the Classics Lectures and Wang Zao in the Hanlin recommended him in turn, and Fu became Right Remonstrator. Secretariat Drafter Cheng Ju objected that Fu had leapt from a provincial secretaryship to Remonstrator—unheard of since the Yuanfeng reforms. "History shows that except for Yang Cheng or Zhong Fang, no one skipped the proper sequence; Your Majesty should first give him the rank he has earned." "Yuan Zhen in the Changqing era was promoted to drafting edicts—and was not unworthy." "Yet he had been a Jingnan aide; a central order summoned him straight to the Secretariat and at once to drafting edicts, scandalizing the court—rumor said the Jingnan supervising officer Cui Tanjun had pushed him." "Now Fu is said to exchange poems with eunuchs and praise their wit—perhaps not everyone knows how Your Majesty came to favor him." The emperor did not respond, and Ju was dismissed.
26
殿
In the second year of Shaoxing he was granted jinshi standing and made Court Lecturer. In the third year he rose to Hanlin Academician, then Academician of the Hall of Enlightened Governance and Coordinator of Military Affairs. In the fourth year he also served as acting Vice Commissioner. Chancellor Zhu Shengfei said, "Xiangyang on the upper Yangzi should be taken first." The emperor asked, "Why not entrust it to Yue Fei?" Vice Commissioner Zhao Ding replied, "No one knows the river's currents and hazards like Fei." Fu alone objected; the emperor ignored him. When Liu Guangshi asked to attend court, Ding said, "With a campaign under debate, a field commander must not leave his army." Fu wanted to allow it; Ding argued hard; Fu then resigned and was made custodian of the Dongxiao Palace.
27
In the ninth year he became prefect of Xinzhou. Censor Wang Ciweng charged him with neglecting the prefecture, and he was given a stipend post. He died the following year. A gifted poet, he moved in the circle of Zeng Ji and Lü Benzhong and left a six-fascicle collection.
28
Shen Yuqiu
29
殿
Shen Yuqiu, whose courtesy name was Bixian, came from Deqing in Huzhou. He passed the jinshi in the fifth year of Zhenghe and rose to vice-prefect of Mingzhou. Zhang Shou recommended him; summoned to audience, he became Investigating Censor. He criticized those in power and was promoted to Secretary in the Ministry of War, then impeached himself on the ground that wrong counsel should not be rewarded. The emperor adopted his advice and made him Palace Attendant Censor.
30
While the court was at Kuaiji, some urged retreat to Rao and Xin, with Fujian as a last refuge. Yuqiu argued that the realm's foundation lay in Jiang and Zhe and that the court should advance to Jiankang to plan recovery. He warned that Fan Zongyin was too young as chancellor and would harm state affairs. Displeased, the emperor sent him out as prefect of Taizhou with the title Direct Palace. When Zongyin fell he was recalled as Attendant Censor.
31
西 退
With army stores low, garrison colonies were debated; Yuqiu compiled ancient and modern precedents on military farming in two fascicles and sent them to the Ministry of Revenue for review. Jiangxi commissioner Zhu Shengfei had not reached Jiangzhou when Ma Jin seized it; Yuqiu blamed the loss of Jiujiang on Shengfei's delay, and Shengfei was removed. With affairs pressing and offices stalling, Yuqiu cited Yuanfeng rules allowing censors to impeach, and the emperor agreed. When he returned to the remonstrating post, some feared he would purge everyone Zongyin had appointed. Yuqiu said, "Faction has become habit: men rise or fall according to which chancellor brought them in, not whether they are fit." "We should judge men by honesty and corruption—not declare an entire administration unworthy." His argument carried the day.
32
When Lü Yihao returned as chancellor, Guard Commander Xin Yongzong, Military Affairs Commissioner Fu Zhirou, and Remonstrator Han Huang repeatedly attacked him. Yuqiu impeached Zhirou for currying favor with the Yongzong brothers to advance himself. The emperor removed Yongzong; Huang and Zhirou were dismissed soon after.
33
使 西 穿便
He was promoted to Censor-in-Chief. With the palace guard weak and generals holding private armies, Yuqiu cited Han's Northern and Southern Armies and Tang's fubing militia as mutual checks against concentrated force. "Today real military power is not at court: the Bureau of Military Affairs, the three departments' military office, and the Ministry of War merely shuffle papers." "Let great ministers restore military governance and build momentum for restoration." When Liu Guangshi of Zhexi brought silks and local gifts—the emperor had already divided them among the palaces—Yuqiu asked, "What season is this for such presents?" It was evening; the memorial arrived and the emperor ordered the gifts seized and sent back. Inner attendant Feng Yi sought a private imperial stud and opened a secret gate in the palace wall on his own authority. Yuqiu impeached him for arrogance and demanded legal punishment.
34
使
Spies reported Liu Yu building boats at Huaiyang; many wanted defenses at Xiangtou in Mingzhou. Yuqiu warned, "If enemy ships reach Xiangtou, they will be deep inside our territory." "Sea routes from Jingdong into Zhe pass Shigang in Taizhou, Liaojiao in Tongzhou, Chongming, then Pingjiang's north shore, Jinshan in Xiuzhou, and finally Xiangtou." "Liaojiao's currents are swift and treacherous—only sand pilots can navigate them." "Register sailors at Shigang, Liaojiao, and similar points, pay them well, and keep them ready for emergencies."
35
使 使
Deputy Transport Commissioner Xu Kangguo brought Xuanhe-era gold-inlaid screens from Wenzhou; Yuqiu urged, "Your Majesty is thrifty as Yu the Great; these trifles insult that virtue—burn them and demote Kangguo." The emperor agreed. Serving all three censorial bureaus, he spoke without restraint—nearly four hundred memorials, sharp and direct—so that foes and allies alike found him hard to bear. When giving instructions the emperor would say, "Do you not know Vice Censor Shen?" He was made Minister of Personnel, acting Hanlin academician and court lecturer, then sent out as Hunan pacification commissioner and prefect of Tanzhou. He pleaded illness for a sacrificial post and was allowed to retire.
36
西使
In the fourth year he became prefect of Zhenjiang and pacification commissioner for Western Zhe. Recalled as Minister of Personnel, he was made Vice Commissioner of the Secretariat-Chancellery. With the Jin about to invade, the emperor told his ministers, "I shall personally lead the Six Armies." Yuqiu agreed: "This personal campaign rests entirely on Your Majesty's decision." Resolved on campaigning in person, the emperor copied out the "Chariots in Array" and gave it to him. The emperor said, "With the two captive emperors still in the north, I humbled myself to seek peace." "Now that Yu's rebellion has come to this, how can I bear it any longer?" Yuqiu replied, "Marriage alliances are a trick the Jin have used repeatedly—they are not to be trusted." He urged that while generals held the Yangzi line the enemy moved freely on the Huai—Yue Fei should strike from upstream by a side route and force them to look to their rear. The emperor said, "That is how it should be done."
37
退
In the fifth year he also served as acting Vice Commissioner of Military Affairs. Zhang Jun, commanding on the Yangzi as a field headquarters, reported on Shao Biao of Taizhou and colony farming and asked the Secretariat to review it. The emperor agreed. Yuqiu protested, "Are the three departments and Military Affairs Bureau merely clerks for a field headquarters?" In the sixth year Zhang Jun again planned to take the field without telling his colleagues. Receiving the order he withdrew and sighed, "This is a grave matter—how can I remain in office if I am not told?" He begged a sacrificial post, resigned, and was sent out as prefect of Mingzhou.
38
祿
In the seventh year, while the emperor was at Pingjiang, he was summoned as Co-Vice Commissioner of Military Affairs; he followed to Jiankang and was promoted to Commissioner of Military Affairs. He died and was posthumously granted Left Silver Grandee of Splendid Happiness with the posthumous title Zhongmin.
39
Di Ruwen
40
調 宿
Di Ruwen, whose courtesy name was Gongxun, came from Danyang in Runzhou. He passed the jinshi but did not take office for ten years while caring for aged parents. Promoted to ritual compiler and summoned to audience, he pleased Huizong and was made Secretary. When Three Institutes scholars proposed an eastern feng, Ruwen said, "Good government values purity and restraint." "Rather than restoring the rites of the Three Dynasties, you copy Qin and Han extravagance—that is not what I desire." He was demoted to supervisor of the Suzhou tax office. Later he was recalled as Compiler and promoted to Attendant of the Secretariat.
41
使
When the crown prince received tutors, Ruwen lectured for him and was made Secretariat Drafter. Critics said he had traveled with Su Shi and Huang Tingjian and was unfit to draft imperial praise; he served as prefect of Xiang, Jizhou, and Tang, then resigned after self-defense in a thanks memorial. Soon he was appointed prefect of Chenzhou. Recalled as Secretariat Drafter, his edicts were elegant and widely praised. Ordered to compile the National History of Zhezong, he rose to Supervising Secretary. When a Goryeo envoy arrived, an edict placed him above attendants; Ruwen cited the Spring and Autumn Annals: even a king's humble messenger ranks above feudal lords. "He must not be set below nearby ministers while honored above them." The emperor restored the old protocol. Eunuch Liang Shicheng forcibly bought commoners' grave plots to expand his garden. Ruwen reported this; Shicheng persuaded the chancellor to demote him, and he was sent to guard Xuanzhou.
42
Earlier in Mizhou, Hui had been a literary officer and Ruwen had recommended him—hence Hui later favored him. Yet Ruwen was stubborn and would not bow to Hui; they shouted at each other across the desk, Ruwen even calling Hui "murky air." Distinguished in manner, learned in antiquity, skilled in seal script, he left collected works still read today.
43
使西使 使 調沿
Earlier, after Hedong commissioner Wang Xie fled home, Tokyo defender Zong Ze provisionally made Wang Shu acting Shaanxi commissioner. When envoy Xie Liang entered the pass, Shu wrote that Xia raids were minor but Jin invasion imminent in autumn—he urged Liang to raise troops, drive the Jin back across the river, and plan recovery. Liang would not agree. When the Jin invaded in force, Shu deployed troops from the river line to Fuping, holding defiles. They crossed the ice at Jining, struck Danzhou, crossed the Qingshui, broke Tong Pass, and shook Qin and Long. Shu issued proclamations along the routes to join in punishing the invaders. Jingyuan commander Qu Duan disliked serving under Shu and refused, saying he had no commission; when the commission arrived days later, he refused again. Learning that Duan and Shu were at odds, the Jin united to attack Yan-Yan. At Fangzhou Shu heard and rode overnight to Yan-Yan to block them. The Jin took Danzhou by a ruse; Shu then covered the Yan'an route himself. Duan held Jingyuan's best troops; Shu urged attack repeatedly, but Duan never moved and Yan'an fell. The account appears in Qu Duan's biography.
44
使 使 使
Hearing the siege was desperate, Shu gathered scattered troops to relieve it. Observation commissioner Wang Xie also marched from Xingyuan. Reaching Ganquan he found Yan'an gone; he gave the army to Xie and rode with a hundred men to Xiang-le to rally troops, still counting on Duan. Duan halved his escort at each gate until only a few riders reached the tent. Duan harshly questioned the fall of Yan'an and sneered, "As commissioner you know how to save yourself—do you not save the emperor's cities?" Shu retorted, "I ordered you many times and you disobeyed—who spared himself?" Enraged, Duan plotted to kill Shu in camp and seize his army; he fled by night to Ningzhou and told Xie Liang, "Yan'an was the throat of the Five Routes—and it is lost." "By the Spring and Autumn rule a minister abroad may act on his own—execute Shu." Liang replied, "If he had explicit orders that would be different; but for a subject to kill abroad is arrogance—you may do it yourself." Frustrated, Duan returned, seized Shu's commissioner seal, and detained his staff. An edict made Shu guard Jingzhao, but he had already impeached himself for misconduct and resigned. He mourned his mother.
45
When Zhang Jun returned defeated from Fuping he recalled Shu and Duan's counsel and summoned both. Shu arrived first and urged pacifying Qin and securing Shu, telling Jun to gather Xihe and Qin-Feng troops and hold the passes for a later advance. Jun refused. He begged to finish mourning; denied, he was appointed Deliberation Official by plaque. Jun feared Duan and Shu could not coexist; before Duan arrived he restored Shu but moved him to Gongzhou. Shu then told Jun, "Duan harbors rebellion." Jun also feared Duan's hold on the army and began to contemplate killing him. The account is in Qu Duan's biography.
46
使
In the fifth year of Shaoxing he left mourning to govern Xingyuan and commission Li-Kui. With few soldiers he enrolled strong men from Xing, Yang, and Sanquan—one per two households or two per three—called "righteous warriors," drilled locally and rewarded; within half a year he had tens of thousands. Jun reported this and he was promoted to Direct Academician of the Hall for Cultivating Culture. Slanderers moved him from Chengdu to Jiazhou. The next year Jun impeached him for rashness and he lost office with only a stipend. Soon offered Suining, he firmly declined and was allowed to rest.
47
使 使
In the sixth year he became Hubei pacification commissioner and prefect of Ezhou. At a banquet audience he said, "If Your Majesty only wishes to hold south of the Yangzi, nothing need be done; "but to restore the empire, Jing should be the capital." "Jing lies between Wu and Shu, commands the southern sea and the Jiang-Han, opens the Three Gorges and the Great River route to the Central Plains—what made Cao Cao fear Guan Yu." The emperor was greatly impressed. He was restored as Awaiting Instruction, made prefect of Jingnan and Hubei pacification commissioner, and again Direct Academician.
48
使 使
In the tenth month of the seventh year he was summoned as Vice Minister of War. Next spring at audience the emperor said, "When I called you, Zhang Jun was gone and Zhao Ding not yet arrived—this was my own choice, not a favorite's doing." Shu thanked him and said ten years had failed to restore the empire through partial counsel, haste, and careless rewards—right and wrong were blurred. "Reward merit and punish guilt, and who will not obey?" "Guangwu conquered by arms yet did not strip funds from non-soldiers—do not let men ignorant of war dictate war." He also traced Qin and Shu's strategic gains and losses with his hand. The emperor was delighted and that day made him Minister of War. Within a month he became Vice Commissioner of Military Affairs.
49
使 使 使 殿
When the court sought a senior minister to tour the frontier, Shu was ordered to arrange Jiang-Huai defenses. Yue Fei, pacification commissioner of Jing-Hu, wrote that if no campaign came that year he would surrender his command and retire. Shu was heartened. Back at court he denounced Jin treachery since breaking the sea treaty and cited Fei's threat to resign his command. Qin Hui was again chancellor and pursued appeasement. When Jin envoy Wulingsimou arrived, an edict recalled Shu. Shu fiercely opposed peace and begged the envoy's execution in the strongest terms. Jin sent Zhang Tonggu promising land, imperial coffins, and the empress dowager's return. Shu said, "Peace negotiations are not my affair." He memorialized seven times to resign and was made Academician of the Hall for Governance and prefect of Tanzhou.
50
使
Censor-in-Chief Gou Longruyuan impeached him as Zhao Ding's protégé who had deceived the throne. Dismissed on his way home, at Jiujiang he was stripped of rank and confined to his house. In the thirteenth year Censor Hu Ruming charged him with ridiculing policy; he was demoted and exiled to Daozhou. He died in exile. Xiaozong remembered his counsel, restored his rank posthumously, and gave the posthumous title Minjie. He had six sons; Zhiqi became Commissioner of Military Affairs in the Qiandao era.
51
殿
Xin Bing, whose courtesy name was Ruhui, came from Houguan in Fuzhou. He passed the jinshi in the third year of Yuanfu and rose to Investigating Censor with acting Palace Attendant Censor. Earlier Cai Jing replaced transport granaries with direct convoys; crews often looted, scuttled boats, and fled, leaving the Ministry of Revenue false receipts—none dared speak for fear of Jing. Bing denounced the abuses, showing 1.32 million less revenue in two years under the reform, and begged a full accounting. Huizong asked Jing, who punished Bing as obstructive, posting him to Nanjian; later he became Dongxiao custodian, then prefect of Yuan and Wuwei. At Jingkang's start he was summoned as Secretary in the Ministry of War.
52
調
When Gaozong ascended he was made Left Department Secretary but declined; soon he was raised as Direct Palace and prefect of Tanzhou. Next year Zhang Jun mobilized in Tanzhou and removed him as incompetent; summoned as Secretariat Attendant, he again declined. In the second year of Shaoxing he was again summoned as Attendant Censor. He opened by saying public justice was choked and morals decayed, then listed dozens of errors by the three departments and urged ministers to preserve open deliberation. Fujian's eight prefectures held over 180 supernumerary posts; Bing said in hard times such posts should be cut. The emperor agreed.
53
Earthquakes struck Su and Hu; the court sought opinions. Bing said, "Ministers who do not fear Heaven will dare anything." His tone was severe; Lü Yihao awaited punishment at home and Bing impeached him out of office. When Zhang Jun was recalled, Bing charged him with failure and harm to the state, and Jun was removed.
54
使
He was made Censor-in-Chief. As peace envoys were dispatched, Bing warned that the Jin were faithless and the court must prepare defense and war. Ill, he sought an outside post as Direct Academician and prefect of Zhangzhou but died before taking it. An edict praised his upright service and poverty at death, granted funeral silver, and posthumously made him Grandee for Governance.
55
The Commentary says: Qin Hui late in life promoted scholars for prestige—yet not every famous man could be co-opted. Zhu Zhuo clashed with policy whenever he spoke; Wang Lun's drafts were apt; Yin Se and Wang Zhiwang differed in character yet alike backed peace. Xu Fu finally fought Zhao Ding and blocked Yue Fei—an odd case. Shen Yuqiu opposed peace; Di Ruwen foresaw well, yet Hui counted him an enemy. Wang Shu urged Jing as capital—a vision other ministers lacked. In the matter of pleading for mercy, Shu was plainly loyal and righteous. Xin Bing's lifelong aim was integrity—how rare such men are!
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →