← Back to 宋史

卷四百〇八 列傳第一百六十七 吳昌裔 汪綱 陳宓 王霆

Volume 408 Biographies 167: Wu Changyi, Wang Gang, Chen Mi, Wang Ting

Chapter 408 of 宋史 · History of Song
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 408
Next Chapter →
1
Wu Changyi, Wang Gang, Chen Mi, and Wang Ting
2
Wu Changyi, styled Jiyong, was a native of Zhongjiang. Orphaned in childhood, he and his elder brother Yong rigorously made their own way in the world, refusing to follow prevailing fashions. Whenever he obtained works by Cheng Yi, Zhang Zai, Zhu Xi, and others, he would study and interpret them tirelessly. In the seventh year of the Jiading reign (1214) he passed the jinshi examination. Hearing that Huang Gan, prefect of Hanyang, had inherited Zhu Xi's teaching, he went to study under him.
3
調 使 調 鹿仿簿 使 西
He was appointed assistant in the Minzhong guard office. Cao Yanyue, transport commissioner of the Lili circuit, heard of his ability and put him in charge of the grain-purchase stations. There was a famine that year. When officials proposed buying grain upstream, Changyi asked that tens of thousands of piculs stored in the local granary be released first and gradually repurchased to make restitution. His plan was adopted. He was transferred to serve as instructor at Meizhou. The scholars of Meizhou had long favored Su Shi's school of learning. Changyi lectured on the classics instead, erected shrines to Zhou Dunyi and to Hao, Cheng Yi, Zhang Zai, and Zhu Xi, posted the White Deer Grotto Academy regulations, imitated the Tanzhou libation ceremony, put the ritual vessels in proper order on the register, and scholarly practice was thoroughly transformed. Pacification commissioner Cui Yuzhi recommended him, and he was appointed magistrate of Huayang County. He restored the county school, attracted scholars from all quarters, spent two hundred thousand strings of surplus funds, and purchased fertile fields as a reserve against drought. As vice-prefect of Meizhou, he wrote ten chapters of Bitter Words, expressing very thorough concern for the security of Shu. While acting prefect, he kept the troops under strict discipline. Soon afterward he served as acting prefect of Hanzhou. By precedent, acting officials received stipends and gifts equal to those of regular appointees; Changyi ordered these cut in half. He audited the military registers, established community granaries, and brought prefectural administration fully up to standard. Zhao Yan'a, military commissioner of Xingyuan, proposed accepting the Jin general Wuxian in the east and allying with Qin and Gong in the west. No one else dared object, but Changyi alone took up his brush and argued forcefully that the plan was wrong. Before long Wuxian was defeated, and the people of the two prefectures did in fact revolt.
4
By censorial precedent, each season the censor went to the prison to inspect the inmates. At the time a dispute arose over fourteen thousand mu of land in Changzhou and several hundred mu in Pingjiang, implicating more than a hundred people. When he examined the documents, he found that the claimants were Zhao Shanxiang's sons Ruchao and Ruzi. The prefecture and county dared not decide the case, so Changyi submitted successive memorials impeaching them until they were removed from office. Repeated thunder sounded in winter, and heavy rain and snow fell in spring. Changyi stayed in the fasting palace, drafting memorials by candlelight. He spoke on every matter touching the emperor's own conduct, palace favorites and private interests, and court appointments. He also wrote: "Generals who defy orders, private audiences granted to imperial consorts, the reuse of old faction members, and frontier disasters—all stem from this class of hidden influence." He went on: "Nowadays the emperor holds court at dawn, yet from time to time there appear notices that he is not attending to affairs;" "from his private residence come requests for leave, and sometimes reports that he has not entered the audience hall." Above, there are signs that the emperor is slipping into indulgence and idleness; below, there is no spirit of united respect and harmony among officials. Within the palace, favored attendants pursue private ends and eat away at the ruler's judgment; outside it, the emperor's sons and younger kinsmen lack restraint and burden court administration. Loose talk and slander abound, and favor and bribes are openly reported. How can one expect the great harmony of the Xiao and Shao music?
5
Concerned that affairs in Shu were on the brink of collapse, he submitted four proposals: put planning on a solid footing, scrutinize rewards for merit, investigate the true state of the army, and cultivate a reserve of commanders. At the time prefects of Guo and Langzhou who had fled were promoted in rank. Li Wei, prefect of Suining, and his son received rewards though their footsteps never reached the frontier. Zhao Kai, who had incited mutiny in the army, and Zhu Yangzu, who had abandoned his city, were not punished at all; and military commissioner Zhao Yan'a was old and failing in judgment, while his son inflicted cruel punishments and took bribes and the troops would not obey orders. An Guizhong, shamed at being impeached, maneuvered for reinstatement and sought to recall men from the banishment rolls to replace the frontier command—Changyi submitted forceful memorials attacking each of these abuses.
6
He also spoke at length on affairs along the three frontiers: "At court today the hundred officials are at ease. Talk outruns action, and empty paperwork obstructs real work." Redundant spending on empresses' kin and princely palaces, the routine paperwork of the various bureaus, leisurely transfers among officials, non-routine petitions from the circuits, construction projects, seasonal banquets and excursions, Shenxiao prayers and exorcisms, great ritual gifts and grants, and ornamental displays of good government—all continued as in normal times. Yet methods for training troops and securing provisions, and for repairing chariots and preparing horses, were neglected entirely. He cited the disasters of the Jingkang era and spoke through tears.
7
He was appointed Vice Minister of the Court of Judicial Review. He repeatedly memorialized asking to resign, but was not permitted to do so. When Du Fan reentered the Censorate and attacked Vice Grand Councilor Li Mingfu, opponents said that Changyi and Fan were close and must be acting in concert. Changyi was slandered repeatedly and, as Acting Vice Minister of Works, was sent out to assist the military affairs of the Sichuan Pacification Commission. People said, "This is like Li Gang being sent to save Taiyuan." "Taiyuan could not be saved; Li Gang was sent out only because he favored war." Changyi replied, "It is the ruler's command. I must set out at once." He wrapped his bedding with high resolve and set out through the pass. Suddenly he fell ill, and on the road his condition grew grave. When the emperor heard of it, he appointed him Hanlin compiler in the Secretariat Pavilion and transferred him to Jiaxing prefecture. Changyi said, "Because of illness I cannot go back to save my parents. I fail the emperor above and my own conscience below. If I abandon the distant post for a nearby one, abandon danger for safety, what will people say of me?" He declined four or five times, and critics accused him of shirking duty.
8
殿 殿
He was transferred to Ganzhou, declined the post, and served as Right Culture Hall compiler in charge of Hongqing Palace. He was promoted to judicial intendant of Eastern Zhejiang, declined, and was appointed prefect of Wuzhou instead. Wuzhou reported drought, and the people looked to him day and night. He could not bring himself to decline the post after all. He reduced his escort and official expenses, sent aides to summon county magistrates to tour the fields, and remitted eighty-one thousand piculs of grain and more than two hundred fifty thousand strings of cash. He was promoted to compiler at the Hall for Assembling Excellence. When he died, he was granted retirement with the title of Baozhang Pavilion attendant.
9
Changyi was upright, stern, and dignified, daring to speak out on public affairs, and well versed in regulations and statutes. He once compiled the origins and outcomes of memorial proposals by ministers of the Zhihe and Shaoxing eras. He titled it Stored Mirror. He also compiled the successes and failures along the Shu routes from Zhou and Han down to Song, and the places where armies were raised and wealth extracted, titling the work Mirror of Shu. His Memorial Proposals, Lectures on the Meaning of the Four Books, Oral Expositions of the Village Compact, Records Heard from Various Elders, Rites Discussed at the Guest Terrace, and collected writings circulated in his day.
10
Earlier Changyi had entered the Censorate on the same day as Xu Qingsou and Du Fan. All three were men of integrity known throughout the realm, and people everywhere looked to their example. Some even composed a Three Remonstrators Poem in their praise. Yet after only seven months he was transferred, and all regretted it deeply. He was later given the posthumous title Loyal and Stern.
11
調
Wang Gang, styled Zhongju, was a native of Yixian County and the great-grandson of Bo, who had held the post of document signer at the Bureau of Military Affairs. He entered office through his grandfather's yin privilege. In the fourteenth year of the Chunxi reign (1187) he passed the selection examination and was appointed revenue recorder of Zhenjiang prefecture.
12
沿 便
When Ma Datong was stationed at Jingkou, he was forceful and self-willed. Gang alone refused to bend his views to please him. Some officials proposed circulating the Huai region's iron cash exchange notes along the Yangzi coast. The court ordered Datong to take the lead in implementing the plan. Gang wrote to him: "On the frontier they use iron cash because they fear copper currency leaking abroad." Private coining is widespread, so money is cheap and goods dear. If market stations no longer took interest in iron cash on receipts and disbursements, if the old four-color purchase system were strictly upheld, if smelting quotas were fixed without seeking surplus profit, if private coining were sternly suppressed, and if payments to frontier garrisons were made no differently than to troops in the interior, without converting at iron-cash rates, the people of the Huai region would find their own remedy. Why harm the inner commanderies? Datong then saw the point. He passed the Hunan transport office examination as well. Gang laughed and said, "How can this be enough to serve the world and benefit the people?" He then devoted himself to serious study, mastering past and present and probing principle to its roots; and pondered deeply the foundations of learning.
13
調 宿
He was appointed magistrate of Pingyang County in Guiyang Command. The county bordered stream gorges where Man and Yan peoples lived. Gang won them over from the first with kindness and good faith. Penal levies had plagued the county for thirty years. As soon as Gang took office, he reported to the censorial offices and had them abolished. Guiyang Command annually presented more than twenty-nine thousand taels of silver, of which Pingyang County was responsible for two-thirds. Gang said that formerly silver mines had been abundant and prices low, so the quota could barely be met. Now the local deposits were exhausted and silver had to be bought in other commanderies at more than double the price. He petitioned urgently for a sharp reduction in the quota. During a famine year, a man named Cao Wu in a neighboring county gathered ruffians to cross the border, forcibly borrowing grain and breaking open granaries. His band numbered more than a thousand and was backed by troops from the Jietou and Niuqiao forts. The region lay among countless mountains, and no previous magistrate had ever ventured there. They did not expect Gang to come, but when he did they came out together to meet him. Gang had already prepared wine and food. He ordered them: "How dare you make trouble? Those who submit will be fed; those who resist will be executed." He spent the night in the fort, summoned the fort officers, and rebuked them for failing to keep order. They prostrated themselves in terror and begged for death. He caned the eight ringleaders, released grain, and sold relief grain at fair prices, and the people were restored to peace.
14
使 使
He was appointed magistrate of Jintan County, but because of a kinship taboo was transferred to Yiyang County instead. His father Yihe had served as investigating censor in charge of the You Shen Observatory. He soon mourned his father's death. When the mourning period ended, he was appointed magistrate of Lanxi County, where his judgments seemed almost uncanny in their accuracy. In a drought year the prefecture relied on organizing mutual aid among the wealthy. Gang said mutual aid was meant to supplement the charity granaries, and applying it wholesale was not true relief for the poor. He asked to borrow Ever-Normal granary funds as capital for relief sales so that grain could circulate and aid the needy in turn. He also personally urged wealthy households to dredge ponds and build weirs, greatly expanding irrigation works. The hungry earned their food by labor, and very many lives were saved. Prefect Zhang Yi and the circuit envoy ranked Gang the foremost in famine relief in the circuit. He left office after speaking out on policy. The people of the district threw themselves before his carriage to plead his case, but Gang firmly stopped them.
15
西 使使 使 使沿
He next served as magistrate of Taiping County and was assigned to handle documents for the Two-Zhe transport office, but before he could take up the latter post he mourned a close relative and was promoted to supervise the Western Treasury of the Left Storehouse at the capital. When the Jurchens killed their ruler Yunji and enthroned a new emperor, they sent envoys to announce the succession. Some officials at once wanted to send tribute missions. Gang said: "The envoy's title is disrespectful. He should be stopped at the border. For the moment order the Left Treasury to examine precedent and make arrangements, or detain him at the Jingkou headquarters and have Chuyi instruct him: 'Your reign title and personal name both violate our dynasty's taboos. The annual tribute was increased by your former ruler. Now that the throne has changed, it should revert to the Longxing and Dading precedents.'" 'Only after this matter is settled should envoys for New Year's Day and the emperor's birthday be dispatched.' Delay for months while we choose frontier generals to repair fortifications, streamline the army, and stock provisions, until the border stands in an posture that cannot be violated. Let them fight among themselves, and then strike with full force from behind. The court approved his plan.
16
西 西 使 西
He supervised the Eastern and Western treasuries and also handled affairs for the Various Offices Audit Bureau. Selected as prefect of Gaoyou Command, he took leave of the emperor and said: "Yangzhou and Chuzhou should each station twenty thousand troops to strengthen their defensive posture, with Gaoyou serving as the home-base fort." Gaoyou is blocked by water on three sides; its lakes and marshes are deep and difficult, and cavalry cannot operate there. Only the southwest route runs straight toward Tianchang with no natural defenses. He therefore went sixty li from the city to plan defenses according to the terrain—dredging ditches and moats in some places, setting ambushes in others—to block the approach. He also feared that the lake could provide a route into the Huai River. He recruited five thousand naval troops, built a hundred vessels, and stationed three forts as a guard against surprise attack. The farmland of Xinghua bordered the sea. Fan Zhongyan had once built dikes to keep out salt tides, and prefect Mao Zemin had installed stone culverts to regulate the transport canal's flow. After many years these works had fallen into ruin, and Gang enlarged and repaired them. The circuit envoy reported his work to court. Gang was raised one rank and appointed intendant of Huaidong Ever-Normal granaries. Transport of Huai rice across the Yangzi was forbidden. Gang reflected: "When alarm comes to the Huai region, homes cannot be preserved. In lean years people wander with nowhere to return. In good years they might recover a little—yet harsh prohibitions divide regions against one another. Is this how a parent official should act?" He asked that three hundred thousand piculs be purchased at Jinling to open transport to western Huai, and five hundred thousand at Jingkou to open transport to eastern Huai. He also said: "Grain reserves in the Two Huai cannot be too large, while reserves in Sheng and Run cannot be too small." Pingjiang had millions of piculs in store, piled year upon year until the grain turned red and rotted. He proposed that grain be issued according to how long it had been stored, to supply the capital offices and armies. Annual grain transport due to reach the capital along the Yangzi should be stored at Jingkou and Jinling for relay shipment. Granaries in the Two Huai and the central capital region should also purchase grain broadly to replenish their stocks.
17
使西 使
The pacification commissioner asked Gang which defensive measures should come first. Gang said: "The Huai region has long been called a treasury of wealth. It has ironworks in the west and abundant fish and rice in the east—enough for self-sufficiency." Western Huai has many mountains and eastern Huai much water—enough for self-defense. If the Two Huai could truly be united as one, with troops and resources pooled and their defensive strength combined, they could hold their own even without relying on Jiangsu and Zhejiang. In the dynasty's flourishing age, frontier stores sufficed for ten years; In the Qingli era, a single garrison in Zhongshan still held 1.8 million piculs. We should now follow the precedents of earlier reigns: let merchants bring grain to stores near the frontier, and issue credit for money and goods at the capital. Grant rank to those who deliver grain, keep faith with them, and contributors will surely multiply. Frontier stores will not lack for abundance. Prefectural forbidden troops were never meant for corvée but only drew rations from outside the circuit. Today they are not used for battle but put to labor service. In emergencies garrison defense relies solely on the main army, whose men count the days until rotation and never settle into local conditions. How can this compare to local troops raised on the frontier, with their families and ancestral graves there, defending of their own accord? Select the strongest men, expand their registers, attach them all to Imperial Front Army rolls, and issue certificates to help prefectures supply their clothing and grain—on the model of the Shanyang Martial Vanguard. Then the frontier need not draw troops from the Yangzi, and the Yangzi need not send palace guards. With living certificates and rotating duty, labor and expense would both be reduced.
18
使 便
At the time someone proposed that the Pacification Commission buy wasteland broadly for garrison farming. Gang argued: "Barren land is easy to obtain, but labor and irrigation cannot be completed quickly. People abandon property and deceive officials; good fields are never really secured; public funds are wasted, and reclamation fails." Better to urge the people to cultivate all idle fields, assist them when streams and canals are blocked, turn poor soil fertile, and let the people build up surplus stores. Chao Cuo's policy of grain delivery for ennoblement and our dynasty's convenient-purchase system embody this approach. The Pacification Commission saw that the plan was useless and abandoned it.
19
殿
Huaidong's salt monopoly had once produced half the empire's revenue, but over the years abuses multiplied, capital was eroded, and the treasury was drained. The office owed the two general headquarters more than five hundred thousand strings, saltern households two hundred eighty thousand, and had borrowed five hundred thousand from court. When the commissariat restored salt certificates, the old rule forbidding merchants to advance note money left the salt office unable to meet its obligations. Gang exposed hidden abuses: empty quotas, false disbursements, and fraudulent transfers. He blocked every scheme, and revenue turned from deficit to surplus. After repaying all debts, he still yielded three hundred thousand strings, which he placed in a reserve treasury to cover future shortfalls in salt capital. He added fifty new salterns, restored all stations to the Qiandao-era quota of 3.9 million piculs totaling thirteen million strings, and ranked officials by performance. Gang practiced restraint and led by example, declined mutual gifts between censorial and prefectural offices, and alone raised station officials' salaries to support their integrity.
20
西
He was promoted to Vice Director of the Ministry of Revenue and appointed overall director of Huaidong military horses and financial levies. The frontier relied heavily on living certificates. Monthly stipends for Shandong submission rose by 330,000 strings and 60,000 piculs of rice. Zhen and Chu prefectures newly recruited ten thousand crossbowmen, all dependent on the general office. Meanwhile Western Zhe salt profits owed more than seven hundred thousand strings, and transport from various prefectures did not arrive on schedule. Gang verified accounts against reality, cracked down on delays, and organized supplies so that provisions did not run short.
21
He reported illness and asked to retire. He was appointed Hanlin compiler in the Secretariat Pavilion and prefect of Wuzhou, then judicial intendant of Eastern Zhejiang. He declined each post repeatedly but was not permitted to withdraw. While reviewing prisoners in Wuzhou, he found a slave who had seized a blade to kill his master, failed to find him, and killed the master's son instead. Officials had concealed the facts and falsely implicated others. Gang ordered the slave beheaded at once. He released prisoners wrongly held at Quzhou. A thief named Zhong Baiyi in Taizhou was not an accomplice in the crime, but the district captain, coveting a reward, rashly reported to the Pacification Commission. Gang said: "Punishing thieves must be strict, but how can charges be fabricated to secure a conviction?" The sentence was reduced from death as a result. While praying for rain at Longrui Palace, a vermilion serpentine creature coiled on the altar for three days. Gang said, "I want only rain. Do not make a wonder to mislead the people." Before he had finished speaking, a great thunderstorm broke, and the year brought an abundant harvest.
22
西 使
He was promoted to compiler at the Brilliant Chapter Hall, appointed prefect of Shaoxing, placed in charge of the Eastern Zhejiang Pacification Commission, and also served as judicial intendant. He inquired into the people's hardships and was especially urgent in abolishing abuses. Xiaoshan had an ancient canal connecting west to Qiantang and east to Taizhou and Mingzhou. Sand had silted it for more than thirty li, and boats stuck fast. He dredged more than eight thousand zhang, rebuilt the river-mouth sluice to keep silt out and control the flow, and paved the towpath with brick all the way to the city. He built a rest lodge every ten li. He named them "Bestowing Water" lodges and placed them under Daoist clergy. Thereafter travelers by boat and cart, by day or night and in any season, crossed with ease and forgot their fatigue in joy. Subordinate counties bordered the sea, and sixteen townships of Zhuji bordered the lake, where marsh irrigation brought great benefit. Powerful families had privately built dikes to enclose lake land as fields. Once the lake's flow was confined, water could not drain away. After even moderate rain, towns and fields were flooded. Coastal areas relied on ponds for protection, but dikes easily collapsed and salt tides ruined crops. Tens of thousands of mu were lost each year, and rent remissions ran into the tens of thousands. On Gang's recommendation, an edict ordered the Ever-Normal intendant to reclaim encroached fields. Every specious claim was sternly rejected, and lake fields began to be restored; and the prefecture set aside thirty thousand strings for repairs, so that coastal fields became secure. Gang said, "This prefecture commands the sea route and closely guards the capital, yet its military rolls are thin and weak." He recruited naval troops and fork-handlers, trained them intensively, and assigned them no other duties. He built more than a thousand spacious, solid barracks, increased armor and weapons, and his military reputation became formidable. He concurrently served as acting Minister of Agriculture, then was made compiler at the Dragon Diagram Hall and continued in office.
23
殿殿 殿 殿 宿
When Emperor Lizong ascended the throne, Gang was appointed Right Culture Hall compiler, promoted to Hall for Assembling Excellence compiler, continued in office, and further made Baomo Pavilion attendant. In the third year of Baoqing a great flood struck. Gang distributed more than thirty-eight thousand piculs of grain and fifty thousand strings for relief, remitted more than sixty thousand piculs of rent, and the starving were suddenly revived as in a normal year. Yue had general aggregate account items totaling 410,000 strings, of which 250,000 were empty quotas dating from the Shaoxing era. Successive prefects, fearing shortfalls, had falsely inflated them with funds nominally for repairing the spirit palaces. Gang said, "Falling short of targets is a small fault; deceiving superiors is a great crime." He gathered the facts and reported them to court. An edict remitted ninety-five thousand strings, and long-standing abuses were thereby exposed.
24
退
In the first year of Shaoding he was summoned to the temporary capital. At audience Gang said: "Officials put profit before duty and personal interest before the state. Compliance, laziness, retreat, and corruption prevail, and they deceive one another. Something must be done to change this." The emperor said, "I have heard your governance is excellent. How are the people faring in Yue?" He replied, "Last year there were floods, and Zhuji suffered most. This year we have had a fair harvest. For ten years the region has been at peace—all through the court's virtue. What strength have I?" He was appointed Acting Vice Minister of Revenue. After several months he memorialized to retire. He was specially granted two ranks, retained as Vice Minister of Revenue, and given a gold belt. When he died, many in Yue shed tears on hearing the news, and some gathered to weep at temples and shrines.
25
Gang's learning had deep foundations. He was widely read and had studied every subject—military affairs and agriculture, medicine and divination, yin-yang theory, music, and calendrics; his mind was keen and sharp, and he decided affairs on the spot. In Yue he held four seals at once. Though documents piled like mountains, he governed with concise control of detail, finished business in no more than twenty quarter-hours, and kept the public court as calm as still water. If a humble official or clerk spoke one word that hit the mark, he readily accepted it. In writing he excelled at policy argument, citing past and present with forceful, expansive eloquence. He disliked luxury in dress and furnishings. His carriage and equipment he would not replace even when worn. His writings included Collection of the Forgiving Studio, Record of the Left Treasury, and Random Preserved Records.
26
西
Chen Mi, styled Shifu, was the son of Chief Councilor Chen Junqing. In youth he studied under Zhu Xi, who regarded him as exceptional. As an adult he studied with Huang Gan. Through his father's yin privilege he served as salt-tax officer in Nan'an, Quanzhou, supervised the Southern and Western Outer Muzong Courts in turn, and was appointed magistrate of Anxi County.
27
殿宿 簿
In the seventh year of Jiading (1214) he entered service as supervisor of the Memorial Transmission Court. At the time no one dared speak boldly. Mi submitted a sealed memorial: "Palace feasting sometimes knows no limit. Untimely gifts are lavished in vast numbers. The emperor eats frugally while consorts still demand fresh delicacies. The frontier is in crisis yet stored supplies are squandered. Palace discipline has not been set right." Great ministers appoint only kin or old associates. Those in power choose men easy to control. Censors select the cautious and silent. Capital and military clerks are all intimates. Greedy officials always get their way; upright men invite resentment. Court authority has been divided up." Salt certificates are changed, paper money manipulated, frontier offices created—officials cling to their own views and constantly lose popular support. Defeated generals leap to high office. Vulgar men long govern the capital. Veteran generals who held the line are demoted for minor faults. Palace guards without battlefield merit are promoted for pretended diligence. Commands, punishments, and rewards run contrary to justice. If inside and outside can be disciplined and order restored, and heaven still withholds rain, I ask to accept the punishment for lying to the throne. When the memorial arrived, Chief Councilor Shi Miyuan was displeased. But the empress was celebrating her birthday and the three guards were presenting gifts—and on this account those gifts were halted. Soon he was transferred to registrar of the Directorate of Armaments. In the ninth year, at his rotation audience he said:
28
The ruler's virtue lies in clarity, the minister's heart in fairness, and the censor's words in directness. Your Majesty governs diligently yet achievement is not realized. You are personally frugal yet revenues are not ample. You love the people yet real benefit does not reach them. This is truly because superiors and subordinates deceive one another and devote themselves to concealment. Memorials in the suggestion box and sealed pouches allow people to speak fully. Your Majesty entrusts nearby ministers to select among them—showing intent to act on what is said. Yet the responsible offices take only memorials attacking the emperor personally or shifting blame to local officials, spread them throughout the realm, and present them as the government's response. Now the land is parched for a thousand li and locusts darken the sky. Yet some still conceal the truth, claiming drought is no disaster and locusts do not harm crops. Other deceptions may be imagined. I therefore say the ruler's virtue lies in clarity.
29
忿 宿 使
The great ministers' conduct has gradually diverged from their beginnings. Those who proposed seeking candid advice are driven off on other grounds. Remonstrating officials who speak too directly are transferred to other posts. The loyal and indignant are labeled disloyal. The blunt and direct are accused of seeking fame. Those whom popular resentment targets are promoted in succession. Those whom public opinion favors are gradually pushed aside. One man's promotion was of someone who had once inflated others' crimes to satisfy colleagues' private grudges; another's promotion was of someone who had cited ancient precedents to gloss over recent heavenly portents. Men of upright integrity and high reputation are long cast aside for private dislike, while old traitors and long-standing villains are restored through clever pleas. If ministers truly blocked the gate of favoritism and closed evil paths, appointments would be fitting and hearts would be won. I therefore say the minister's heart lies in fairness.
30
Censors and remonstrators in normal times never stand apart. When affairs arise they dare not speak fully. When the Jurchens reopened relations—a matter most vital to the state—attendants and students alike argued forcefully to aid court policy. Only those charged with remonstrance did not utter a word. Under the capital, embezzlement reached tens of thousands—no one could touch the culprits; while in the prefectures and counties, the slightest fault was seized upon to satisfy quotas. What ministers wished to do was carried through; those they disfavored were pushed aside. Under Emperor Renzong there was ridicule of a chief councilor who followed censors' lead. Now there is mockery that censors dare not disobey the Secretariat. Is this what the founders intended when they established these offices? I therefore say the censor's words lie in directness.
31
These three matters are where the pivot lies. May Your Majesty repent and make your virtue shine forth to oversee all officials. Ministers and censors should also act with fair hearts and upright integrity to fulfill the hope for good government. In pointing out abuses, this memorial was even more forceful and cutting than his earlier one.
32
鹿 仿鹿
Mi then asked to be dismissed and returned home. While on leave he was promoted to Vice Director of the Court of the Imperial Treasury but declined the post and was appointed prefect of Nankang Command. When he went to bid farewell to Shi Miyuan, Miyuan said, "Your words are forceful and apt, but I am too foolish to act on them. I am deeply ashamed." On reaching his post he found the year had brought severe crop failure. He memorialized to remit nine-tenths of the tax levy. When refugees gathered in crowds, he put them to work building river dikes and provided them with food. He restored the White Deer Grotto Academy and debated the classics with his students. He was transferred to serve as prefect of Nanjian. There was severe drought and plague. He remitted overdue taxes totaling several hundred thousand strings, reduced new levies by one-third, and personally led his staff door to door distributing money, grain, and medicine. He founded Yanping Academy, following the White Deer Grotto regulations in full.
33
He was appointed prefect of Zhangzhou but had not yet departed when he heard that Emperor Ningzong had died. He sobbed for many days. Before long he requested retirement. In the second year of Baoqing he was appointed judicial intendant of Guangdong. He submitted three memorials declining the post and never took office. He was appointed Hanlin compiler in the Secretariat Pavilion and placed in charge of Chongxi Observatory. He accepted the temple appointment but declined the official title. When he died, his rank was advanced one grade in recognition of retirement. Students of the Three Academies petitioned to recall Mi to office, but he had already been dead for a month.
34
使
Earlier, when Mi was at court, Vice Director Ding Huang was sent as envoy to the Jin. Mi sighed and said, "Our hereditary enemy is not yet avenged. How can we act cordially?" In his farewell poem he wrote the line, "In a hundred years can China truly have no men?" Several years later, hearing that the region beyond the passes was unsettled, he wrote to Huang: "Though Shu is far from the frontier passes, they are in reality one body." Recent events are chilling to the heart. They are all the fault of scholar-officials. Is this not because the path of bribery never ceases? Huang was convinced by his words.
35
殿 稿
Mi was by nature firm and resolute and especially devout in his faith. He once wrote An Inscription on Vermilion and Ink, saying that vermilion belongs to yang and ink to yin, using them to measure the balance between principle and desire. He said that in office one must be like Yan Zhenqing, at home like Tao Qian, and he deeply admired Zhuge Liang, who at death left his family no surplus wealth and the treasury no surplus cloth. Whether he truly lived up to his words, at the beginning of the Duanping reign Palace Attendant Censor Wang Sui was the first to speak: "Mi served the former emperor with forthright remonstrance but did not live to see the renewal of sage rule. He should be honored after death to encourage all who serve as subjects under heaven." The emperor was moved and ordered him posthumously granted the title of compiler at the Dragon Diagram Hall. His writings included Questions and Answers on the Meaning of the Analects Commentary, Extracts of the Three Commentaries on the Spring and Autumn, Reading the Comprehensive Mirror Outline, and drafts of Excrescences on Tang History in several tens of chapters, kept in his household.
36
Wang Ting, styled Dingsou, was a native of Dongyang. His great-grandfather Wang Hao had led troops to suppress Fang La and received an official appointment for his merit. Ting in youth had an unusual spirit. He failed the civil service examination, turned to the military examination, and in the fourth year of Jiading passed at the peerless extraordinary grade. Qiao Xingjian, examining candidates as chief examiner, said with delight, "I have found a commander for the court."
37
沿使 調使
He was granted the rank of Bearer of Credentials and joined the army at Ezhou. Commander Zhong Xingsi, garrisoning the frontier, requested from the Bureau of Military Affairs that Ting serve as army funds-and-grain officer. Overall director Qi Kui entrusted Ting solely with training and reviewing the General Effectiveness Army. Soon he was entrusted to command troops defending Huangzhou. Vice Pacification Commissioner along the Yangzi Li Fu recruited him to his staff. When troops in western Huai rebelled, Li sent Ting to summon and instruct them. On military affairs Ting held nothing back. He said: "When recruiting sons of good households, one must not let connections and favoritism flood the ranks. Defending the Yangzi depends entirely on regular troops. Volunteers and militia can serve only as vocal support." Yet the so-called main army has many weak and sick men, and its weapons are damaged and worn. How can this not lead to defeat? Troops transferred to defend the river should be housed on the riverbank so they can concentrate on defense. Since company regulations have been abandoned, in peacetime there is no way to audit empty registers and false claims or correct deserters who stir trouble. In emergencies there is no way to test their will to fight together or bind those who flee the line and refuse to advance. This is why Master Wei Liao wrote orders binding companies and squads, and why the Grand Duke called company law essential. Victory in war does not depend on numbers but on whether training and drill are thorough. Then the outcome can be foreseen.
38
滿 使
The commander recommended him, and he was summoned for examination as Gate Guard Attendant. At audience he said, "The theory of recovery has two aspects: planning and opportunity." But where is today's planning? Prefects and magistrates are meant to govern the people, yet benevolent care is not extended to them; generals are meant to command the army, yet they do not comfort and guide their troops. State finances are not ample, yet the abuses of paper money grow worse; military stores are not abundant, yet the harm of government grain purchases grows only more cruel. Government land lies waste. The people are ruined by taxes and corvée. Court cases mostly end in wrongful conviction. The selection bureau mostly delays appointments. Recommendations carry no penalty for falsehood, so the greedy draw their kind into office; investigations are not impartial, and humble officials are easily punished in chains for giving offense. Speaking of prefectural accounts, they are wasted on bribery; speaking of battle merit, it mostly goes to intimates and old friends. As for settling surrendered troops in the interior, it nurtures tigers and leaves calamity behind. Treating the enemy lightly and opening the frontier is feeding tigers with flesh. When planning itself is so unsatisfactory, how dare I lightly advance a theory of recovery to mislead Your Majesty? What I have presented should be broadcast to all officials within and without, that they may abandon old abuses and plan anew. Once planning is established, then with the righteous banner raised all circuits may advance together. My strength is still robust, and I wish to serve in the vanguard. I ask only that Your Majesty be firm and strive to achieve it. The emperor praised his words as worth adopting. He was promoted to Martial Achievement Grandee, appointed prefect of Haozhou, and granted a gold belt. On reaching the prefecture, he cut unnecessary expenses, purchased grain, and bought horses to prepare against emergencies. Soon he was assigned to Anfeng Command. Officials memorialized: "The people are very settled under Wang Ting at Hao. He should not be lightly transferred." An edict ordered him to serve again at Hao. He carried out his duties well and was specially promoted within the lateral ranks. Various commissioners repeatedly recommended him.
39
沿使 使
When northern troops reached Fuguang, its people fled in panic along the roads. Court opinion held that Ting could hold the place, and he was appointed prefect of Guangzhou while also serving as frontier overall patrol commissioner. Braving snow he traveled by night and raced to the prefecture by forced marches. He sent out scouts, put battle equipment in order, fought a great battle at Xieling Bridge, and the people of Guangzhou were secured. Supervisor Wei Liaoweng sent a letter of comfort and gave one hundred thousand strings to reward his army. Ting was summoned to court and soon appointed prefect of Jizhou while still governing Guangzhou. Ting firmly declined. Chief Councilor Zheng Qingzhi and Pacification Commissioner Shi Songzhi both wrote repeatedly urging him to stay. Ting refused and said, "Scholar-officials should let the age follow the Way, not let the Way follow the age."
40
西西
He was again appointed Gate Guard Attendant, then prefect of Dazhou and General of the Right Encampment Guard while also governing Qizhou. He did not take up the posts. Soon he was promoted to Vice Overall Commander of Huai West horse and foot armies and Vice Commander-in-Chief of Huai West mobile armies. He submitted ten proposals concerning the mobile armies. No response was given. He was appointed intendant of Chongxi Observatory. As prefect of Gaoyou Command, a refugee named Bang Jie gathered three thousand men as bandits. Ting destroyed their ringleaders and the rest dispersed. At the time an expedition was debated and many favored peace. Ting argued: "Better to send scouts to observe the enemy. Only if there is no other way should we act;" "otherwise we will needlessly shake our own foundations—the outer enemy has not yet arrived while our own forces will suffer first." All armies marched out, but Gaoyou delayed, and the region relied on this for its security. From this he fell out with prevailing opinion, and his slanderers grew more numerous.
41
沿使沿 使
He was appointed intendant of Yuntai Observatory. Those in power scheduled a discussion of frontier affairs and said the court would soon appoint him to Qi'an. Ting said, "Autumn defense is already urgent. Frontier commanders should not be changed at the last moment. Why not wait a little?" He was then granted Acting General of the Left Leading Army Guard and appointed planning officer for the Vice Pacification Commission along the Yangzi. Ting compiled Record of Frontier Regions along the River and presented it to court. Pacification Commissioners Dong Huai and Deng Yong repeatedly recommended him. He was assigned to Shouchang Command, then transferred to Qizhou, where he built school quarters and erected shrines to loyal ministers. He once sighed and said, "The Two Huai are the fence, the Great River is the gate, and the capital region is the inner hall." If the fence is not secure, the gate is in peril. If the gate is in peril, how can the inner hall long remain secure? He therefore wrote to Chief Councilor Du Fan, asking to survey the Yangzi and assess the terrain, and proposed three new fortresses: Qichun at Longyan Rock, Anqing at Mengcheng, and Chuyang at Xuanhua. No response was given. He died.
42
When his father divided the family estate, Ting alone yielded his share to his elder brother. He treated his clan with kindness and once instructed his sons and younger kin: "Exhausting principle and fulfilling nature is the root of learning." His Jade Stream Collection circulated in his day.
43
The historians comment: Wu Changyi sought the Way in the southeast—how diligent he was! His achievement was deep and pure, and what appears in his practical accomplishments shows that his learning had no admixture. Wang Gang's enduring benevolence in Yue shows that the ancients were right when they said to choose the worthy and employ them long. Chen Mi, though a chief councilor's son, shone with the directness of his remonstrance, and that light endures today. Wang Ting was versed in military theory yet held that one cannot let the Way follow the age. This is what the ancients meant when they sought commanders who "expound the Rites and Music and honor the Odes and Documents."
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →