← Back to 宋史

卷四百四十五 列傳第二百〇四 文苑七 陳與義 汪藻 葉夢得 程俱 張嵲 韓駒 朱敦儒 葛勝仲 熊克 張即之趙蕃

Volume 445 Biographies 204: Literature 7 -Chen Yuyi, Wang Zao, Ye Mengde, Cheng Ju, Zhang Nie, Han Ju, Zhu Dunru, Ge Shengzhong, Xiong Ke, Zhaofan of Zhangji

Chapter 445 of 宋史 · History of Song
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 445
Next Chapter →
1
Literature, Part Seven.
2
Chen Yuyi, Wang Zao, Ye Mengde, Cheng Ju, Zhang Wei, Han Ju, Zhu Dunru, Ge Shengzhong, Xiong Ke, and Zhang Jizhi. (with Zhao Fan appended)
3
Chen Yuyi
4
Chen Yuyi, whose style name was Qufei, came of a family originally from Jingzhao. His great-grandfather Xiliang was the first to settle in Luoyang. He was thus reckoned a native of Luoyang. Yuyi possessed a towering natural talent. As a boy he already wrote with distinction and won a reputation; his contemporaries held back and none dared measure themselves against him. In 1113 he took first place in the Upper College examination and was made professor at Kaide Prefecture. He rose through the ranks to Erudite of the Imperial Academy and then Gentleman of the Talismans and Seals, but was soon demoted to overseer of the wine tax at Chenliu.
5
When the Jurchens took Bianjing and Gaozong withdrew to the south, he fled the chaos through the middle Yangtze, wandered Hunan and the lake country, and crossed the southern ranges. After some time he was recalled and appointed Vice Director of the Ministry of War. In the summer of 1131 he arrived at the court in exile. He was promoted to Drafting Attendant of the Secretariat and put in charge of imperial drafting. He was made Vice Minister of Personnel, then shortly afterward served as prefect of Huzhou with the title Academician Expositor of the Huixuan Pavilion. He was recalled to the post of Supervising Censor. His memorials of objection were learned and elegant. He was again named Academician Expositor of the Xianmo Pavilion and appointed superintendent of the Taiping Abbey in Jiangzhou. On his recall a chief minister who disliked him intervened, and he was reappointed Drafting Attendant of the Secretariat and to the Hanlin Academy. In the ninth month of 1136 the emperor traveled to Pingjiang; in the eleventh month Yuyi was made Hanlin Academician and Drafter of Edicts.
6
便 殿
In the first month of 1137 he was made Vice Grand Councilor. He sought to guide the court through moral example alone and to restore the emperor's authority and the discipline of government. At that time Chief Councilor Zhao Ding said, "Many argue that the north can still be recovered and that we should march immediately, lest posterity blame us for letting this moment slip." The emperor replied, "The late emperor's coffin, the empress dowager, and the captive former emperor have not yet been returned. Unless we treat with the Jin, there is no way to secure their release. Yuyi said, "If peace succeeds, is that not preferable to war? And if it fails, war will become unavoidable in any case. The emperor said, "That is so. In the third month he accompanied the emperor to Jiankang. The following year he escorted the court back to Lin'an. He pleaded illness and stepped down, then served again as prefect of Huzhou with the title Academician of the Zizheng Hall. At his farewell audience the emperor treated him with exceptional warmth; he then asked to retire and was made superintendent of the Dongxiao Abbey near Lin'an. He died in the eleventh month, at the age of forty-nine.
7
退
Yuyi was grave in manner and sparing of speech and laughter. Though courteous in daily dealings, he was inwardly unyielding and not to be crossed. When he recommended men to office he never mentioned it afterward, and scholars admired him all the more for that discretion. He excelled above all in poetry, giving voice to things observed and feelings stirred—clear, deep, and lingering, yet also bold and soaring—standing with Tao Yuanming, Xie Lingyun, Wei Yingwu, and Liu Zongyuan. He once wrote a poem on ink-painted plum blossoms that Huizong admired, and through it he came to the emperor's attention.
8
調西
Wang Zao, whose style name was Yanzhang, came from Dexing in Raozhou. He was precocious as a boy, entered the Imperial Academy, and passed the jinshi examination. He was posted as investigating censor at Wuzhou, then made professor at Xuanzhou, and later rose to a clerkship in the Jiangxi Education Commission.
9
When Huizong wrote the "Poem of the Monarch and Ministers' Celebratory Assembly Hall," the whole court submitted matching verses, yet none could rival Zao's response. Hu Shen was then equally renowned for letters, and people said, "The two treasures of the south—Hu Shen and Wang Zao." He was soon appointed compiler for the Nine Regions Gazetteer project and later promoted to Assistant Compiler. Wang Fu had once been his roommate and they had never gotten along. Zao was sent out as vice prefect of Xuanzhou and then superintendent of the Taiping Abbey in Jiangzhou, where he spent eight idle years and was never employed again while Fu lived.
10
殿
When Qinzong came to the throne Zao was recalled as Vice Director of the Directorate of Agriculture, then promoted to Vice Minister of Rites and Recorder of the Emperor's Actions. When Gaozong ascended the throne Zao was examined and appointed Drafting Attendant of the Secretariat. While the court was at Yangzhou Zao submitted many policy memorials. Chief Councilor Huang Qianshan took offense and, on a pretext, removed him to Compiler of the Jiying Hall and superintendent of the Taiping Abbey. The following year he was recalled as Drafting Attendant of the Secretariat and to the Hanlin Academy, promoted to Supervising Censor, then Vice Minister of War and Lecturer-in-Waiting, and finally Hanlin Academician. The emperor took a white round fan from his own hand and inscribed ten characters—"Purple edicts still bound together; yellow edict paper like the Six Classics"—and gave it to him, to the envy of the court.
11
殿祿
In those troubled years most imperial edicts passed through his pen. He once warned that the great generals, holding vast armies, were tipping the balance of power toward the provinces, and he laid out three principles for handling commanders. A decade later events unfolded exactly as he had predicted. He also argued that since the Chongning and Daguan reigns men who bought influence, fawned on eunuchs, and pushed reckless frontier wars had been rewarded with lofty titles from Academician of the Guanwen Hall down to Direct Access to the Secret Archives and ranks as high as Grandee of Splendid Happiness with Silver Seal. Though some honors had lately been stripped away, the Jianyan amnesty threatened to restore them. He urged following the founding precedent and capping such men at Grandee of Governance.
12
使
In 1131 he was appointed Academician Expositor of the Longtu Pavilion and prefect of Huzhou. Citing Yan Zhenqing's loyalty to the Tang and his former service in that prefecture, he asked that Yan be publicly honored; the court granted his temple the posthumous title Loyal and Stern. He also observed that every state in antiquity kept a history: court deliberations were entered in Current Policy Notes, and what the censors observed below the pillars went into Records of the Emperor's Actions. Arranged in sequence these became the Calendar; polished into final form they became the Veritable Record. More than thirty years have now passed without a Calendar. How can we leave posterity nothing to read? He asked permission, within the prefecture he governed, to gather documents from old families and compile edicts from 1098 onward as the foundation for a new Calendar. The request was approved. After the History Office reopened, Compiler Qi Chongli argued that a separate external bureau was unnecessary, and the project was halted. A local man named Yan Jing lodged a complaint accusing him of misallocating grain meant for the army, and Zao was demoted and suspended from office. He was reappointed prefect of Fuzhou, but Censor Zhang Zhiyuan attacked him again and he was given only a temple stipend. In 1136 Compiler Fan Chong memorialized that the Calendar was a great state document. Zao had been ordered to compile it, but the work had stalled again and might be lost. He urged that Zao be allowed to finish the project in retirement. An edict granted him a compiler's stipend from the History Office and allowed him to recruit assistants for the compilation. In 1138 he presented his compilation: edicts from 1098 through 1125, six hundred sixty-five juan in all. Zao was promoted again, and his assistants Bao Yanzu and Meng Chuyi received rank increases in varying degrees. He was promoted to Academician of the Xianmo Pavilion, and the court sent gifts of tea and medicine. He was soon made prefect of Huizhou and, a year later, transferred to Xuanzhou. Critics charged that he had once been a client of Cai Jing and Wang Fu. He was stripped of office and sent to Yongzhou, and repeated amnesties did not restore him. He died in 1154.
13
退 殿
After Qin Hui's death his offices were restored and both his sons were given government posts. In 1158, when the Veritable Record of Huizong was completed, Right Vice Director Tang Situi noted that Zao's earlier compilation of edicts had supplied seven or eight tenths of the source material and had been indispensable to the work. The court posthumously granted him the title Academician of the Duanming Hall.
14
西
Though prominent in office for thirty years, Zao never owned a house of his own. He read voraciously and never set books aside even in old age, especially favoring the Zuo Commentary to the Spring and Autumn Annals and the History of the Former Han. He excelled in parallel prose, wrote extensively, and his edict drafts were widely copied and recited. He had six sons: Tian, Ke, Dan, Bing, Lin, and Xi.
15
Ye Mengde
16
調
Ye Mengde, whose style name was Shaoyun, came from Wu County in Suzhou. He loved learning and matured early, knew the words and deeds of past sages, and could discourse without end. In 1097 he passed the jinshi examination and was posted as magistrate of Dantu. Under Huizong he was recalled from a professorship at Wuzhou to serve as compiler for Rites Deliberation and Military Selection. Recommended by Cai Jing, he was summoned to audience and said, "Emperors of old governed realms of every size by different means, yet all began by governing their own hearts first." Today the state's security, the soundness of its laws, the quality of its officials, and the people's welfare are the four great pillars of rule. Unless the ruler first governs his own heart—whether tempted by profit or ensnared by pleasure—security and danger, benefit and harm, the upright and the corrupt, and the people's welfare will all be reversed. How then can he expect real achievement? The emperor was impressed and specially promoted him to Gentleman of the Directorate of Sacrifices.
17
退 使使
Early in the Daguan reign Cai Jing returned to power and revived laws he had earlier abolished. Mengde said, "In the Offices of Zhou the Grand Steward used the eight handles to advise the king in governing his ministers. Appointment, dismissal, reward, and punishment were the king's prerogatives; the steward could counsel the king but not decide on his own." Policy is simply a matter of what is right and what is not. If something is right because Your Majesty decrees it, then what was abolished yesterday should never have been abolished; if it is wrong because it does not come from Your Majesty, then it should not be revived today. To let a minister's rise or fall decide what is permissible—is Your Majesty not still unclear in his own mind? The emperor said with pleasure, "Lately officials flock together and advance through patronage, but your words show no such calculation. He was then appointed Recorder of the Emperor's Actions. Those in power then favored men of minor talent. Mengde said, "From antiquity, appointing officials began with distinguishing the worthy from the merely capable." "Worthy" names those with virtue; "capable" names those with talent. Former kings always let virtue outweigh talent, never the reverse. Since Chongning the court had favored only those whose opinions matched its own, and the provinces only those who enforced the new laws with quick results. Men of broad capacity and far-seeing judgment were never singled out for praise. I fear talent has been valued too highly. I ask that hereafter appointments put virtue first.
18
西 使 使 使
In the second year he rose to Hanlin Academician. He spoke at length against faction among officials and the court's habit of favoring capital posts over provincial service, and asked to be the first to take a prefectural appointment. Cai Jing at first planned to make Tong Guan pacification commissioner of Shaanxi to recover Qingtang. Mengde went to Jing and asked, "Under our ancestors pacification commissioners were always sitting chief administrators—Wen Yanbo and Han Jiang were made chief ministers right in camp for that reason. A eunuch has never held the post." At the end of Yuanfeng Shenzong appointed Li Xian, and even Wang Gui fought the appointment with all his strength—as you yourself saw, sir. Yesterday, on an imperial grace, Guan was suddenly made military commissioner. Everyone knows that violates ancestral precedent, and that mistake cannot be undone. Now you would give him the powers of a chief minister as well. If he takes Qingtang, how will you handle him then? Jing looked ashamed, but in the end he used Guan and Qingtang was taken.
19
使
In the third year he was made prefect of Ruzhou as Academician Expositor of the Longtu Pavilion, but was soon dismissed and appointed superintendent of the Dongxiao Abbey. In 1115 he was recalled as prefect of Caizhou and restored as Academician Expositor of the Longtu Pavilion. Transferred to command Yingchang Prefecture, he released Ever-Normal Granary grain to relieve the people, which the granary commissioner Liu Ji resented. The eunuch Yang Jian was in power. Liu Ji squeezed the prefecture for five hundred thousand strings of Ever-Normal funds and sought to buy polished rice for the imperial gardens to curry favor with Jian. Jian sent an agent with the emperor's brush to demand rice of Suzhou quality. Mengde memorialized that Yingchang's soil could not match the southeast's and asked that grades be adjusted accordingly. His plea went unanswered. Neighboring prefectures were forcing people to pay cash to buy grain for the capital, and popular resentment was everywhere. Only Yingchang, thanks to Mengde, was spared. Li Yan was surveying public fields. A crafty clerk denounced hidden holdings, and thousands of qing in Yancheng and Wuyang were seized. Eight hundred households petitioned the prefecture. Mengde reported the case, arrested the clerk, and prosecuted him, to the great joy of the prefecture. Jian and Yan were furious. Mengde was soon made superintendent of the Hongqing Abbey in Nanjing and thereafter was repeatedly dismissed and recalled.
20
使 退
When Gaozong halted at Yangzhou, Mengde became Hanlin Academician and Lecturer-in-Waiting and was appointed Minister of Revenue. He argued that strategy against the enemy rested on three things: terrain, material strength, and morale. Terrain depends on geography; material strength on cities, supplies, and arms; morale on commanders and troops. Firm terrain permits defense, strong resources sustain the state, and high morale makes armies effective—then the enemy lies within our grasp. He urged the emperor to move south, use the Yangtze as a defensive barrier, and prepare for contingencies. He also proposed appointing senior ministers as overall commanders—one at Si to gather the Huai and eastern armies against the enemy; another at Jinling to control the Jiang-Zhe routes as a line of retreat. The memorial was submitted but received no answer.
21
殿使
When the court moved to Hangzhou he was made Left Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs and urged abolishing the ad hoc military supply offices that prefectures had set up to extort the people. The emperor replied that war and provisions were the greatest concerns and should be entrusted to separate senior ministers. Vice Director Yan Qi and Hangzhou prefect Kang Yunzhi envied him, and he clashed with Chief Councilor Zhu Shengfei. When locals petitioned against him, the emperor—recognizing his mastery of finance—named him Academician of the Zizheng Hall and superintendent of the Zhongtaiyi Abbey with sole charge of revenue for the traveling court. Mengde declined and returned to Huzhou.
22
使使 滿 使
Early in the Shaoxing era he was recalled as Grand Pacification Commissioner of Jiangdong and prefect of Jiankang, with concurrent authority as pacification commissioner over six prefectures including Shouchun. Jiankang lay in ruins, with fewer than three thousand troops. He moved Han Shiqing's forces into Jiankang, posted Cui Zeng at Caishi, and assigned Yan Gao to hold key positions. When Wang Cai, who had defected to Liu Yu, led a raid, Mengde sent Zhang Wei to induce his surrender and distributed his troops among the regular armies. The defectors Kou Hong and Chen Bi of Hao and Shou nominally accepted imperial orders but secretly dealt with Liu Yu. Mengde warned them of the consequences, and both submitted. When Liu Yu invaded, Chen Bi routed him and the Qi forces fled overnight.
23
使
In 1138 he was appointed Grand Commissioner for Pacification and Defense of Jiangdong, prefect of Jiankang, and keeper of the traveling palace. He also proposed eight measures for river defense: tighten border discipline, distribute forces, hold choke points, control shipping, organize local militia, clarify scouting, stockpile supplies, and require officials to defend their posts to the death. He identified nineteen critical crossings along the Jiankang-Taiping-Chizhou line and on the north bank, urged assembling militia to hold them, and ordered generals to coordinate a joint offensive after assessing enemy movements.
24
退 沿
When the Jin marshal Zongbi took Hanshan and pressed Liyang, Zhang Jun's armies lingered. Mengde urged him to march at once: "The enemy has passed Hanshan. If they take Hezhou, the Yangtze will be lost." Zhang Jun hurried his armies forward. Their momentum revived, and the Jin fell back to Zhaoguan. The next year the Jin invaded again as far as Zhegao. Mengde rallied tens of thousands of river militia, seized the crossings, and sent his son Mo with a thousand men to hold Majia Ford. The Jin could not cross and withdrew.
25
殿使
The Jiankang garrison had cost eight million strings and eight hundred thousand hu of rice annually, more than the Monopoly Bureau could supply. When the palace guard and provincial armies converged, Mengde took charge of transport from four circuits. Supplies held, and the generals could fight at full strength. He was promoted to Academician of the Guanwen Hall and transferred to Fuzhou as prefect and Pacification Commissioner of Fujian.
26
便 使
When the pirate Zhu Ming ravaged the coast, Mengde was ordered to take imperial guards to Fujian by express route. By recruiting, capturing, and setting bandits against one another, he suppressed more than fifty bands. He clashed frequently with supervisory commissioners, petitioned to retire, received a special promotion, and was made superintendent of the Dongxiao Abbey near Lin'an. He soon retired with the title Military Commissioner of Chongxin. He died at Huzhou in 1148 and was posthumously granted Acting Junior Guardian.
27
簿
Cheng Ju, whose style name was Zhidao, came from Kaihua in Quzhou. Through his maternal grandfather, Left Vice Director Deng Runfu, he became registrar of Wujiang in Suzhou and superintendent of the Taihu tea plantation in Shuzhou, but was dismissed after memorializing on policy. He was recalled as magistrate of Linhuai in Sizhou and rose to Vice Director of the Directorate of Palace Buildings. A court intimate recommended his literary talent, and he was made Assistant Compiler. In 1120 he presented a court eulogy, received Upper College standing, and was made Gentleman of the Ministry of Rites, but retired on grounds of illness without waiting for approval.
28
During the Jianyan era he served as Vice Minister of Rites and prefect of Xiuzhou. When the imperial procession visited, he was granted an audience. Ju said, "If Your Majesty's virtue and governance advance daily, and rewards and punishments align with Heaven above and the people's hearts below, the Zhao house will be secure and the realm firm;" "otherwise the altars will totter and the realm fall into chaos—and between the two lies no margin at all." Gaozong praised his counsel. Jin forces crossed the river, seized Lin'an, attacked Chongde and Haiyan, and sent urgent summons to surrender. Ju led his staff out of the city to Huating, leaving the military inspector to hold Xiuzhou. The court ordered him to escort gold and silks to the traveling palace. After delivering them he pleaded illness and asked to retire.
29
使
When the Secretariat was re-established early in Shaoxing, Ju was summoned as its Vice Director. He petitioned to compile the Calendar, establishing the precedent that senior Secretariat officials could take part in historical compilation. With government still being rebuilt, ministries relied on Secretariat records. Ju compiled old reports from the Three Halls into the 《Records of the Lin Terrace》 and presented it to the throne. He was promoted to Drafting Attendant of the Secretariat and Lecturer-in-Waiting. Ju argued that the state's trouble was that advisers dared not speak frankly and officials dared not accept responsibility. Counsel might be right or wrong and policies might succeed or fail—that was natural. Today dissent is punished immediately, and failed policies are blamed on whoever proposed them first. Thus even a man as clever as Chen Ping would not dare ask for gold to run espionage; nor one as bold as Lin Xiangru risk keeping the jade whole to defy Qin; nor one as skilled in finance as Liu Yan propose managing revenues to feed the armies. If no one dares take responsibility or speak fully, who in such desperate times will help plan recovery?
30
簿使 使使 祿簿 祿 使調 使
When Martial Achievement Grandee Su Yi was moved to lateral rank, Ju argued that under ancestral law civil officials from registrar of the Directorate of Palace Buildings to Left Vice Director, and military officials from Third Class Attendant to military commissioner, advanced by regular sequential promotion. Military lateral ranks from Vice Commissioner of the Palace Gate to Commissioner of the Inner Reception Bureau lay outside the merit-review ladder and required special edicts. The Yuanfeng reforms therefore made Court Gentleman through Special Advancement salary ranks, renaming posts from registrar through vice director; but deliberately did not apply salary ranks to military posts—a measure of deep significance. Under Zhenghe military titles were renamed as Gentleman and Grandee, folding lateral ranks into the regular ladder—ignorance of precedent that opened the door to favoritism. Since commissioners were renamed grandees, countless routine officials—even clerks—have been shifted into lateral ranks. Civil subordinates cannot rise above Grandee of Governance, yet military officers can rise above Commissioner of the Imperial City. What principle is that? Whether offices carry weight depends on the court. When the court values them and grants them sparingly, they remain weighty; otherwise they become cheap. Cheap offices bring no gratitude to recipients and breed resentment in those passed over—matters on which safety and ruin depend.
31
使
When Xu Fu was appointed Remonstrance Grandee, Ju returned the edict, arguing that though talented and bold, Fu's experience was shallow and his leap from provincial gentleman to remonstrance official was unprecedented since Yuanfeng. In Tang, Yuan Zhen was a mere aide in Jingnan when a sudden inner order made him a provincial drafter—throwing the court into uproar as a protégé of the army supervisor Cui Tanjun. Rumors abroad say Fu exchanges poetry with palace eunuchs, including a celebrated line on 'fish whiskers.' I fear outsiders will suspect impropriety and cast doubt on Your Majesty's virtue. If Your Majesty truly values Fu, appoint him only to the rank he has earned. The court did not respond. Two days later critics cited his abandonment of Xiuzhou, and he was dismissed to superintendent of the Taiping Abbey in Jiangzhou. After some time he was made Attendant Drafter of the Huixuan Pavilion.
32
使
In later life Ju suffered from paralysis. Qin Hui recommended him to head historical compilation as superintendent of the Wanshou Abbey and Veritable Record compiler with exemption from court attendance. Ju firmly declined. He died at the age of sixty-seven. In the Secretariat, whenever an edict troubled him he spoke against it repeatedly, without fear. His writing was elegant and profound, and widely admired.
33
調 使
Zhang Wei, whose style name was Jushan, came from Xiangyang. In 1121 he passed the Upper College examination. He was posted as magistrate of Fangcheng in Tangzhou, then made judicial officer of Fangzhou. Liu Ziyu recommended him to Zhang Jun, pacification commissioner of Sichuan and Shaanxi. He served as clerk in the Lizhou Pacification Office but left when his mother fell ill.
34
便
In 1135 he was summoned to audience and memorialized: "Last winter the Jin penetrated deep into our territory. Our armies won repeated victories, then the Jin fled overnight. They defeated themselves; we did not merely get lucky." Morale has revived somewhat, and it is tempting to strike while enthusiasm is high; that is not impossible in itself. Yet the armies are weary and the people exhausted, and an immediate offensive seems premature. I believe we should build fortified posts to hold Huainan, establish military colonies for long-term defense, ready the fleet to control the Yangtze, and with steady preparation await the enemy's next move. Jing, Xiang, and Shouchun are ancient strategic centers, and most enemy raids come through them. I urge swift selection of able generals and strong troops to garrison them and secure the upper Yangtze. He was examined and appointed Corrector of the Secretariat.
35
In 1136 there was an earthquake. Wei memorialized that in recent years taxes and exactions had multiplied, driving refugees into ditches and ruining settled livelihoods—the earthquake likely stemmed from this. I ask Your Majesty to ponder the cause of such omens, correct failures in governance, and restore the people's peace.
36
使 使 使
In 1137 he was made Collator and History Office proofreader, then Compiler. In audience Wei replied: "Wu and Shu stand in the same lip-and-teeth alliance." Sichuan is distant from the court, and the region has gone a year without a supreme commander. I have some understanding of what is at stake in Sichuan. Brave and loyal men can defend against foreign aggression, but they cannot govern and care for the local population. The court should choose from among former chief ministers someone capable of handling Sichuan affairs and appoint him. But Sichuan bears directly on the nation's fortunes, so only a trusted inner minister will do—and the urgent need now is to find a worthy Pacification Commissioner. He added: "Since the court settled in the southeast, Xiangyang and southern Jing seem to have received too little attention. The court should quickly appoint learned officials with governing and defensive ability to command both circuits, to gather refugees, revive farming, repair fortifications, build a secure base, and strengthen the upper Yangtze."
37
Soon afterward He Lun was punished for altering the Veritable Records of Emperor Shenzong; his case implicated Wei, who was demoted to Vice Transport Commissioner of Fujian Circuit. He submitted a memorial in summary: "Ancient rulers suffered from two faults—not refusing advice, but accepting it and then failing to act on it; not in ignorance of what helps or harms the realm, but in knowing and yet not caring. Your Majesty has been south of the Yangtze for ten years. Abroad there is a hostile power, at home unruly troops, and below a people driven to destitution and despair. Many have offered counsel, yet sound advice is dismissed as stale while novel theories are sought instead; many hold office, yet routine is mistaken for wisdom while ever more impractical schemes are pursued. This comes close to hearing advice without using it, and knowing what matters without truly caring. For the present, let the court devote itself morning and night to nothing else. In a few years there may yet be hope! Nothing harms a state more than factionalism. When one chief minister takes power, all his associates are appointed regardless of merit; when he falls, all are purged regardless of merit. Small wonder factions keep growing.
38
宿退使使 滿
In 1139 he was made Outer Gentleman of the Ministry of Personnel and compiler-reviewer at the Veritable Record Office. When the Jurchens broke the treaty, the emperor ordered officials throughout both secretariats to draft proclamations. Only Wei's was chosen and published across the realm. In 1140 he was promoted to Drafting Attendant of the Secretariat and co-compiler of the Veritable Record Office. He argued that Wang De had recovered Su and Bo but then withdrew on his own authority, leaving Yue Fei isolated and the Jurchens emboldened—yet Wang was rewarded with the rank of Defense Commissioner. Why punish when one should reward, or reward when one should punish? He returned the draft appointment and asked that the promotion order be revoked. Soon Right Remonstrance Officer Wan Qixie accused Wei of recommending unworthy men to repay private favors while in court service, and of feigning illness at home when frontier reports first arrived. Wei was dismissed. Shortly afterward he was reappointed prefect of Quzhou and made Awaiting-Edict of the Fuwen Pavilion. His administration was notably harsh. When his term ended he requested appointment as superintendent of the Taiping Xingguo Abbey in Jiangzhou. Peace had been restored and the court was reviving ancient ritual and scholarship. Wei composed the Poems on Restoring Antiquity in the Restoration and presented them to the throne. The emperor was about to recall him to office when he died of a back abscess at the age of fifty-three. He had a son named Changshi.
39
Han Ju, whose style name was Zicang, came from Xianjing Superintendency. He was known for literary talent from an early age. At the start of the Zhenghe era he earned provisional rank by submitting a eulogy, passed the Drafting Academy examination, received jinshi standing, and was appointed Secretariat Corrector. He was soon punished for association with Su-shi Learning and requested appointment as supervisor of the market-trade office in Pucheng County, Huazhou. He served as magistrate of Fenning County in Hongzhou. He was recalled as Compiler and assigned to collate the imperial archives. Ju reported that the state performed 118 sacrificial rites each year, 62 with music, and that the old hymn texts contained many inconsistencies. The emperor then ordered Three Academies scholars to compose more than fifty hymn texts for imperial sacrifices at the Bright Hall, Round Altar, and Square Mound, most of them written by Ju.
40
使 殿
In 1123 he was appointed Vice Director of the Secretariat. The following year he became Drafting Attendant and national history compiler, and entered court to give thanks. The emperor said: "In recent years edict writers have lavished excessive praise on those commended and excessive condemnation on those censured. Is that the proper tone of royal pronouncements? The models of the Pan and Gao documents still survive—would they read like this? Ju replied: "If drafting edicts were all that mattered, anyone literate could do the job. The late emperor did not establish the two secretariats merely to circulate documents. The emperor said: "Supervising Secretariat Attendants are indeed charged with reviewing and rebutting edicts. Ju replied: "Drafting attendants are also allowed to return draft commissions for reconsideration. The emperor said: "From now on, return any court matter you find objectionable. Soon he was also made acting director of the Hanlin Academy. His edicts were concise and dignified, and he was widely respected. Before long he was again punished for partisan narrow learning and made Academy Compiler of the Jiying Hall while superintending the Taiping Abbey in Jiangzhou.
41
When Emperor Gaozong took the throne, Ju was appointed prefect of Jiangzhou. He died at Fuzhou in 1135. He was promoted one rank upon retirement, posthumously granted Grandee of Palace Attendance, and given hereditary privilege for three descendants. Ju had studied under Su Zhe at Xu and remarked that his poetry resembled that of Chu Guangxi. Later he rose through eunuch patronage, and knowledgeable contemporaries held him in low regard. He had sons Xun and You.
42
Zhu Dunru
43
鹿祿 西使
Zhu Dunru, whose style name was Xizhen, came from Henan. His father Bo had served as a remonstrance officer under Emperor Zhezong. Dunru was known for lofty integrity. Though a commoner, he enjoyed esteem both at court and beyond it. During the Jingkang crisis he was summoned to the capital and offered a scholarly post. Dunru declined: "Deer by nature love quiet and open country. Rank and salary are not what I want. He firmly refused and returned to the mountains. When Gaozong took the throne, an edict called for talented men from among the people. Those selected were examined at the Secretariat and given office. The envoy of western Huai then reported that Dunru possessed both civil and military ability, and he was summoned. Dunru declined again. Fleeing the turmoil he stayed in Nanxiong Prefecture. Zhang Jun memorialized that he come to headquarters for consultation, but he did not go.
44
使退 便殿 祿便便
In 1132 Persuasion Commissioner Ming Nang reported that Dunru had a deep grasp of governance and talent for statecraft, and many court officials praised his quiet withdrawal from office. He was appointed Right Assistant Gentleman for Merit, and Zhaoqing Prefecture was ordered to escort him urgently to the traveling court. Dunru refused the appointment. An old friend urged him: "The emperor now seeks out reclusive scholars to help restore the dynasty. Qiao Ding was summoned from Shu, Su Kuang from Zhe, Zhang Zimu from Changlu—all won fame at court and influence across the realm. Why should you live in a thatched hut on wild greens, growing old in the mountains? At that Dunru changed his mind and accepted. When he arrived he was granted audience in the informal hall, and his remarks were clear and persuasive. The emperor was pleased, granted him jinshi standing, and appointed him Secretariat Corrector. Soon he also served as bureau chief in the Ministry of War, then became Judicial Intendant of eastern Zhejiang. Right Remonstrance and Discussion Censor Wang Bo then impeached Dunru for holding unorthodox views and associating with Li Guang. Gaozong said: "Rank and salary exist to encourage public service. When a man deserves them, a civil official may rise straight to court attendance and a military man to command of armies. When he does not deserve them, even the smallest appointment must not be granted lightly. Dunru was thereupon dismissed. In 1149 he memorialized asking to retire, and permission was granted.
45
Dunru had long excelled at poetry and yuefu songs, which were graceful, lucid, and flowing. When Qin Hui dominated the government he liked to patronize poets and literary men to adorn an age of peace. Qin Hui's son Xi also loved poetry, so Dunru's son was first made a collation officer and Dunru himself was reappointed Vice Minister of Ceremonials. When Qin Hui died, Dunru was dismissed as well. Commentators said that in old age Dunru indulged affection for his son while fearing exile, and so did not preserve his integrity to the end.
46
Ge Shengzhong
47
調 殿
Ge Shengzhong, whose style name was Luqing, came from Danyang. He passed the jinshi examination in 1097 and was assigned as judicial administrator of Hangzhou. Lin Xi recommended him for the academic and prose-poetry examinations, and he placed first in both. He was appointed professor at Yanzhou and later became Director of the Imperial Academy. When the emperor visited the Academy, most students submitted eulogies, but Shengzhong alone submitted a fu. The emperor ordered the Secretariat to rank the entries, and Shengzhong placed first. He was then made compiler-reviewer of the Calendar Reforms Office and Vice Director of the Imperial Clan Court. At first attendant ministers had supervised the Calendar Reforms Office, but now Guo Tianxin was put in charge instead. Shengzhong strongly urged that the change be reversed. He was soon promoted to Outer Gentleman of the Ministry of Rites. Censor-in-Chief Shi Gongbi reported: "The addition of hall chambers to Emperor Xi's primary temple departs from the Yuanfeng precedent. An edict ordered rites officials to deliberate. Shengzhong argued: "To grant something and then take it back is hard even for ordinary people—how much more for an imperial ancestor in Heaven! His opponents prevailed, and he was demoted to magistrate of Xiuning County in Shezhou. Later he was recalled as Outer Gentleman of Rites and acting Vice Director of the Directorate of Education. When the court ordered students to study court music and the project was completed, he was promoted one rank and made Vice Director of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices.
48
Ouyang Xiu had once compiled the rites practiced from Jianlong through Zhiping into a work of one hundred chapters titled Records of Rites Reforms at the Court of Imperial Sacrifices. The emperor ordered Shengzhong to continue it, expanding it to three hundred juan, and commanded that it be kept at the Court of Imperial Sacrifices. When the crown prince's residence was established, Shengzhong was made Preceptor. He wrote three treatises On Benevolence, On Filial Piety, and On Learning and presented them to the crown prince. He also collected examples from the Spring and Autumn period through the Warring States onward of crown princes' successes and failures, submitting several each day. The emperor praised him by edict, transferred him to Vice Director of the Court of the Imperial Treasury, appointed him Chancellor of the Directorate of Education, and soon made him prefect of Ruzhou. Li Yan's land surveys ruined many households. Shengzhong asked that improper seizures be remitted. Yan angrily impeached him, but the emperor shelved the accusation and transferred Shengzhong to Huzhou, then soon to Dengzhou. Zhu Mi had earlier asked for white magpies and the like, and Shengzhong had refused. Now Zhu Mi fabricated charges against him, and Shengzhong was dismissed and sent home.
49
During the Jianyan era Fan Zongyin became chief minister and pardoned those earlier punished for factional ties and exiled far away. Shengzhong was again appointed prefect of Huzhou. Bandits were then rampant and threatening neighboring prefectures, but Shengzhong repaired the walls, built warships, and drilled troops. Seeing the city prepared, the bandits withdrew. When famine struck he opened government granaries for relief, and the people were saved. In 1131 he requested a temple appointment and retired home. He died in 1144 at the age of seventy-three and was given the posthumous title Wenkang. His son Lifang rose to a position in imperial attendance. Sun Bin served as Right Grand Counselor and has a separate biography.
50
使
Xiong Ke, styled Zifu, came from Jianyang in Jianning and was a descendant of the Censor-in-Chief Bo. Just before his birth, a sparrow with emerald feathers flew into the chamber and settled there. Xiong Ke showed exceptional talent from childhood. As an adult he loved learning and wrote well. Hu Xian, the district erudite, took notice of him and said, "You have learning beyond your years; one day you will make your name through letters." During the Shaoxing period he passed the jinshi examination and became magistrate of Zhuji in Shaoxing Prefecture. The regional commander pressed urgently for tax collection, and every county rushed to comply. Xiong Ke said, "I would rather face punishment than squeeze my people." One day the prefecture sent aides to check for arrears while drought persisted. He wept before them and cried, "Is this really the moment to demand rent!" When circuit commissioner Rui Hui toured the county and entered his district, he told Xiong Ke, "I knew you only as a man of letters; now I see a magistrate in the old worthy mold." Rui Hui recommended him by memorial, and Xiong Ke was appointed Supervisor of the Hall of Literary Reflection at court.
51
覿覿 殿
He once submitted a piece of writing to Zeng Di, who showed it to Emperor Xiaozong. The emperor was delighted and issued a personal edict appointing Xiong Ke directly to the Hanlin Academy. Grand Counselor Zhao Xiong was greatly surprised and memorialized, "The Hanlin Academy is an elite appointment. Xiong Ke is a minor official who received it without the usual review and recommendation, and that will not satisfy critics. Let the court summon him for examination before appointing him." The emperor said, "Very well." He was made Collator and eventually rose to Acting Hanlin Academician. The emperor received him at the Hall of Virtuous Selection and said, "You draft edicts with great skill and proper style. When we have leisure, you may discuss statecraft with me."
52
退 西
Feeling he had won the emperor's trust, Xiong Ke submitted policy proposals again and again. He once argued, "Though the Jurchen are at peace with us, that peace may not hold. For now we should treat peace as a form of defense, and defense as preparation for attack." While relations remain amicable, we should prepare our defenses; they cannot stop us from doing so. Once our frontier defenses are strong, even if the Jurchen grow aggressive they cannot prevail against us. If they retreat and then turn on us, the moral blame will not be ours. Of all our defensive priorities today, none matters more than the eastern Huai region. A Jin attack across the western Huai would force them to carry their own supplies, making the campaign far harder. An attack east of the Huai would let grain ships sail straight down the Qing River, making supply much easier. The strategy for holding the Huai should prioritize land reclamation, dyke repair, and militia training. The best way to support the eastern Huai is to establish a naval force at Jiangyin that can respond quickly in crisis. A sudden new army would alarm the enemy. Better to cite the rampant piracy on the sea lanes, post an inspector to patrol the route, and increase troops year by year. Within ten years we would quietly have a full force. At the time of the Restoration, the concern was not that soldiers could not fight, but that military authority was hard to bring back under central control. Today's problem is no longer unmanageable generals but troops whose temper is easily unsettled. In the past great generals treated their men like family. Since those generals were stripped of command and Imperial Front commanders were rotated endlessly, the monopolies that once supported the troops have become bribes instead, with whatever is left skimmed away on top—how could soldiers not resent it! Commanders should be sternly warned not to exploit their men. The emperor admired his public-spiritedness and had him draft the amnesty edict for the Hall of Brightness rites. Xiong Ke said, "The two Zhe provinces face famine and locusts are rising; the amnesty proclamation should not use flowery language." The emperor praised his sense of what was appropriate. He was made Recorder and Hanlin Academician, but critics drove him out to serve as prefect of Taizhou before he received a stipend appointment.
53
使
Xiong Ke was widely learned with a prodigious memory, and from youth to old age wrote almost to the exclusion of all else. He knew Song institutional history inside out and answered every question on the spot as though the reply were already waiting. He came from a frugal family and did not change when he rose to high office. His old home was so narrow the gate would not admit a carriage, and even visiting commissioners and prefects had to dismount before entering. He admired the young scholar Wang Keqin of Linchuan and wished to marry his daughter to him but lacked a dowry. When he received a gold grant for drafting an edict, he gave it for the marriage, and people praised his incorruptible character. He died at the age of seventy-three.
54
Zhang Jizhi
55
簿
Zhang Jizhi, styled Wenfu, was the son of Vice Grand Counselor Zhang Xiaobo. By privilege of his father's rank he received the office of Master of Service, passed the jinshi quota of the Two-Zhe Transport Commission, and served as superintendent of the Pingjiang Prefecture grain office. After mourning his father's death, he was appointed superintendent of the Lin'an Prefecture inn office. After mourning his mother, he served in succession as superintendent of the Longshan tax office in Lin'an Prefecture and superintendent of the lower-city wine monopoly office in Ningguo Prefecture; signing secretary for general affairs at the Jingmen military judge's office; assistant magistrate of Wucheng; specially assigned signing secretary for general affairs at the Jiangyin military judge's office; manager of general affairs at the Ministry of Revenue Commemorative Wine Warehouse; additionally assigned document controller at the Two-Zhe Transport Commission; document controller at the temporary capital's inspection office for army-support and reward wine warehouses; superintendent of the Six Ministries gate; document controller at the Huainan East Circuit Ever-Normal Granary Office; additionally assigned as vice prefect of Yangzhou, then transferred to Zhenjiang and again to Jiaxing; registrar of the Directorate of Palace Buildings; assistant director of the Directorate of Armaments; assistant director of the Ministry of Revenue; and prefect of Jiaxing. Before he could take up the prefecture, critics had him removed. He petitioned for a stipend shrine, served as director of the Cloud Terrace Abbey, and citing age petitioned to retire, receiving the special grant of Directly Assembled Secretariat Pavilion and retirement.
56
Weizhong, styled Xiaozun, came from Yin in Qingyuan and passed the jinshi examination in 1220.
57
Zhao Fan (appended biography)
58
調簿 簿 調
Zhao Fan, styled Changfu, came from a family originally of Zhengzhou. At the start of the Jianyan era his grandfather Yang left the capital as Vice Director of the Secretariat and Commissioner of Mining and Smelting, settling at Yushan in Xinzhou. Zhao Fan received the post of prefectural erudite through his grandfather Yang's retirement privilege. He was offered posts as magistrate of Fuliang and chief clerk of Lianjiang but declined both. As chief clerk of Taihe he won the admiration of Yang Wanli. Posted as judicial officer of Chenzhou, he disputed a case with the prefect and was removed from office; people regarded Zhao Fan as a man of integrity.
59
Zhao Fan first studied with Liu Qingzhi. When Qingzhi became prefect of Hengzhou, Fan asked to serve as superintendent of the Anren army-support wine warehouse so he could finish his studies nearby. When he arrived at Hengzhou, Qingzhi had already lost his post. Zhao Fan immediately petitioned for a stipend appointment and went home with his teacher. Later Zhen Dexiu wrote in the National History, "Zhao Fan was this devoted to his teachers and friends—how could he betray his country!" He lived in retirement and submitted thirty-one consecutive annual review reports for his stipend post. When Emperor Lizong came to the throne, he and Liu Zai were summoned to serve as Grand Sacrificer of Earth. He refused, was specially granted the rank of Proposal-Discussing Gentleman and Directly Assembled Secretariat Pavilion, and declined again. He retained his stipend appointment, received formal retirement, was promoted to Order-Discussing Gentleman, and kept his Directly Assembled Secretariat Pavilion title. He died at the age of eighty-seven.
60
Even at fifty Zhao Fan continued his studies with Zhu Xi. In old age he still worried about life's final trials and named his study the Studio of Difficulty. By nature Zhao Fan was open and even-tempered, easy in company, yet resolute and unyielding in matters of principle. Grand Counselor Zhou Bida was fond of him and recommended him many times, but Zhao Fan always refused. Liu Zai said, "In a house of literary distinction, among the last exemplars of the old standard still standing, one man alone keeps scholars' hopes alive — and that is Zhao Fan." The prefect of Xinzhou, Wu Qi, asked that his descendants be granted office. The emperor ordered his son Zhao Sui to receive the post of upper-prefecture erudite, but Sui firmly declined. Another edict granted him retirement at the rank of Master of Service and one privilege appointment for a son. In 1262 compilers of the Secretariat Pavilion including Zheng Xie petitioned for a posthumous title, and he was given the posthumous name Wenjie.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →