← Back to 宋史

卷四百四十六 列傳第二百〇五 忠義一 康保裔 馬遂 董元亨 曹覲孔宗旦 趙師旦 蘇緘 秦傳序 詹良臣江仲明 李若水 劉韐 傅察 楊震父:宗閔 張克戩 張確 朱昭 史抗 孫益

Volume 446 Biographies 205: Loyalty and Righteousness 1 - Kang Baoyi, Ma Sui, Dong Yuanheng, Caojin Kongzongdan, Zhao Shidan, Su Jian, Qin Chuanxu, Zhanliang Chenjiang Zhongming, Li Ruoshui, Liu Ge, Fu Cha, Yang Zhenfu:zongmin, Zhang Kejian, Zhang Que, Zhu Zhao, Shi Kang, Sun Yi

Chapter 446 of 宋史 · History of Song
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 446
Next Chapter →
1
:
Kang Baoyi, Ma Sui, Dong Yuanheng, Cao Jin, Kong Zongdan, Zhao Shidan, Su Jian, Qin Chuanxu, Zhan Liangchen, Jiang Zhongming, Li Ruoshui, Liu Ge, Fu Cha, Yang Zhen and his son Zongmin, Zhang Kejian, Zhang Que, Zhu Zhao, Shi Kang, and Sun Yi.
2
西
By the Five Dynasties period, the scholar-official class's spirit of loyalty and righteousness had all but disappeared. Even at the dawn of the Song, men such as Fan Zhi and Wang Pu still fell short of the ideal—what then of lesser men? The founding emperor first honored Han Tong and then enshrined Wei Rong—acts that made his values plain enough. Afterward, officials on the northwestern frontier often showed no fear in dying against the enemy. Under Emperors Zhenzong and Renzong, worthies such as Tian Xi, Wang Yucheng, Fan Zhongyan, Ouyang Xiu, and Tang Jie led the court with blunt, loyal counsel. Officials at home and abroad then came to measure one another by reputation and integrity, and the coarseness of the Five Dynasties was left behind. Thus at the Jingkang crisis, resolute men rose up to rescue the throne, refusing to yield in the face of disaster—examples could be found everywhere. By the time the Song fell, acts of loyal integrity stood in such profusion that they fill the records—virtue that had been building for generations, not forged overnight.
3
Ordered to compile the Three Histories, we gathered scholar-officials to set the rules: loyal and righteous men of earlier ages were to be recorded plainly, without concealment. Yet dying for principle and dying in official duty should be distinguished. Those who face the sovereign's enemy without flinching, who go forth on imperial mission abroad, who hold territorial office, or who live in retirement yet rush to duty when moved—all differ in circumstance, yet in giving their lives for principle without wavering they rank among the highest exemplars of loyalty and righteousness; Those whose fortunes waver, who fall captive yet die boldly or, judging what is right, take their own lives, belong to the next rank; Those who perish suddenly amid chaos, though their deaths may seem less glorious, still differ from cowardly survival; and when the state falls and the sovereign is shamed, ministers who die though they cannot save the realm still deserve honor for their intent. When the age collapses and men efface themselves in hidden withdrawal, those who preserve their original integrity through steadfast resolve rank lower still. Commoners who speak perilous truth, local heroes, and men outside official ranks who throw themselves into righteous action—their deaths, too, are weighed on the same scale when their aim is to serve the realm. Grouped by kind and ranked in order, we compose the Biographies of Loyalty and Righteousness.
4
Kang Baoyi
5
When the Khitan army invaded in strength, the generals engaged them at Hejian. Baoyi led picked troops to the field; dusk fell, and they agreed to fight at daybreak. At dawn the Khitan had surrounded them in layer after layer. His attendants urged him to change armor and break out, but Baoyi said, "In peril one must not seek a coward's escape." With that he gave battle. For two days the slaughter was immense, and trampled dust rose two feet deep. When his men and arrows were spent and no aid came, he fell.
6
使使使西簿 使
The emperor was then at Daming. Shocked and grieved, he suspended court for two days and posthumously made Baoyi Grand Counselor. His son Jiying was appointed Commissioner of the Six Residences and prefect of Shunzhou; Jibin became Luoyuan Commissioner; Jiming, Deputy Commissioner of the Inner Parks; his youngest son Jizong, Western Head Attendant-in-Attendance; and his grandson Weiyi, master of records in the Directorate of Works. Jiying and his brothers received the edict and said, "Our father died without victory; that Your Majesty does not punish his family is mercy enough—how can we accept such extraordinary favor?" They wept and prostrated themselves, unable to rise. The emperor said with compassion, "Your father died in the state's service; his rewards should be all the greater." Turning to his attendants he said, "Baoyi's father and grandfather died on the frontier, and he too fell in battle—a house of loyalty across generations, truly admirable." Baoyi's mother was eighty-four; the emperor sent envoys to console her, gave fifty taels of silver, and enfeoffed her as Grand Lady of Chen. His deceased wife was posthumously made Lady of Hedong Commandery.
7
滿
Baoyi was careful, courteous, and hospitable, skilled in riding and archery; in the hunt he never missed bird or beast. Once he shot thirty arrows in succession, each striking the last so that they fell linked together—a feat men marveled at. He fought in many battles and bore seventy wounds. He had borrowed hundreds of thousands in public funds to reward his troops. After his death his clerks sold his valuables to repay the debt; when the emperor learned of this, he bestowed further gifts.
8
使
Jiying rose to General of the Left Guard and regimental commander of Guizhou, strict with his troops but generous to his kin; he died leaving no wealth behind.
9
退 使 殿使
While Baoyi fought the Khitan to the death and no reinforcements came, Zhang Ning of Gaoyang Pass led the vanguard and Li Chonggui the supporting force. When Baoyi was overrun, Chonggui and Ning came to his aid, fought with enemies before and behind from mid-afternoon until dawn, and drove the Khitan back. Most generals had lost men, but Chonggui and Ning brought their forces back intact. When Ning proposed reporting their soldiers' merits, Chonggui sighed and said, "Our commander has fallen—how can we claim credit?" The emperor heard and praised him. Chonggui rose to prefect of Zhengzhou and defense commissioner of Bozhou, then retired as Grand General of the Left Forest Army. Ning was made Chief Commandant of the Palace Front; at his death he was posthumously named military commissioner of the Zhangde army.
10
使 使
Ma Sui was from Kaifeng. He first served in the Dragon Guard, then as irregular attendant and Third-Rank Attendant-in-Service, and became Beijing commissioner. When he heard that Wang Ze had rebelled, he roused himself in the night; at dawn he went to the regent Jia Changchao and asked to attack the rebels. Changchao sent him into Beizhou with a surrender proclamation. Wang Ze received him in full regalia; Sui urged him on the consequences of rebellion, but Ze would not reply. Sui meant to kill Ze, but had brought no weapon. Zhang Deyi stood beside him; Sui looked to him for help, but Deyi did not stir. Sui sprang up, hurled a cup at Ze, seized his throat, and drew blood—but no one at hand came to his aid. Rebels rushed in with blades, cut off his arm, yet he still cursed Ze: "Demon rebel—I wish I could hack you to pieces!" They bound him before the hall and dismembered him. Ze, shaken and wounded in the struggle, was ill for days before he could rise.
11
使 使
When word reached the court, Renzong sighed long. He posthumously made Sui Palace Park Commissioner, enfeoffed his wife as Lady of Jingzhong County, granted her court dress, and gave office to his five sons. Later they captured Shi Qing of the Brave and Nimble Corps, who had killed Sui, and had Sui's son cut out his heart as an offering.
12
Dong Yuanheng
13
鹿
Dong Yuanheng was from Shulu in Shenzhou. He rose to Erudite of the Imperial University and served as vice-prefect of Beizhou. Wang Ze seized the city in rebellion. It was the winter solstice; Yuanheng had been at morning rites at Tianqing Abbey with Zhang Deyi when, before dawn, the revolt broke out and no one knew what to do. Yuanheng rode back at once and took his seat in the hall. A dozen rebels in armor burst in with drawn blades; his attendants fled. The rebels threatened him: "The Great King sent us for the keys to the military stores." Yuanheng struck the desk and shouted, "Who is this Great King? A demon rebel dares raise arms! I have only death to offer—you shall not have the keys." The rebel officer Hao Yong came next and pressed harder: "The treasury is the Great King's now—will you not surrender the keys?" Yuanheng cursed them with blazing eyes; Yong killed him, and the rebels rushed in and seized the keys. When word reached the court, Renzong said, "A minister who upheld the law." He was posthumously made Vice Minister of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices, and three of his descendants were given office. When the rebellion was crushed, Hao Yong was captured and executed as an offering to Yuanheng.
14
使
Cao Jin, styled Zhongbin, was the son of Cao Xiuli. When his uncle Xiugu died childless, Du Qi of the Hanlin spoke for Jin at court; Jin was appointed registrar of Jianzhou and made Xiugu's heir. During the Huangyou era he governed Fengzhou as Middle Household Attendant of the Heir Apparent. When Nong Zhigao rebelled, he seized Yong and Guan and marched on Guangzhou. When the rebels reached Fengzhou, the people had never seen war; there were barely a hundred soldiers, no walls to defend, and some urged Jin to flee. He rebuked them sternly: "I am the guardian of this prefecture—I have only death to offer. Whoever speaks of flight shall die." He ordered Commandant Chen Ye to meet the enemy, and the magistrate of Fengchuan led local militia and archers in support. The rebels outnumbered them many times over; Chen Ye's force was routed and the militia scattered. Jin led his remaining men in a last stand but was captured. The rebels forbade his execution, forced him to bow, and tempted him: "Join us and you shall have high office, command of troops, and a wife from among our people." Jin refused to bow and cursed them: "A minister bows only to the Son of Heaven facing north—would I live in shame with you? Kill me at once—that would be mercy." The rebels still spared him and put him aboard a boat. He fasted for two days, then took the seal from his robe and gave it to his attendant: "I am dying. If you find a way out, take this to the authorities." Seeing he would not yield, they killed him. He cursed the rebels without cease until death; they threw his body into the river. He was thirty-five. When word reached the court, he was posthumously made Vice Minister of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices; four sons were given office. His wife Liu died fleeing the rebels in the hills and was posthumously made Lady of Pengcheng Commandery with court dress. Xiugu was posthumously made Vice Minister of Works, and his wife Chen was enfeoffed Lady of Yingchuan Commandery.
15
When Zhigao rebelled, Lingnan was unprepared and officials often fled at the first rumor; the rebels took city after city—only Jin, Kong Zongdan, and Zhao Shidan held their posts unto death. Later, when Tian Yu pacified Guangnan, a temple to Jin was raised in Fengzhou.
16
Kong Zongdan
17
Kong Zongdan was from Lu and served as registrar of Yongzhou. Before Zhigao rebelled, white vapor rose in the prefectural courtyard and the river flooded. Zongdan read these as signs of war and warned Prefect Chen Gong in writing that Zhigao would rebel, but Gong would not listen. When Zhigao took Hengzhou, Zongdan sent his family to Guizhou, saying, "I hold office here and cannot leave—do not die with me." When the city fell he was captured. The rebels wished to employ him, but he rebuked and cursed them until they killed him. Earlier, while serving in Jingdong, he and Li Shidao, Xu Cheng, Shang Tong, and others had been informants for the supervisory commissioners—called the "Four Staring Eyes"—and were widely hated; yet in the end he showed such integrity. Zu Wuse, prefect of Yuanzhou, reported his deeds, and Zongdan was posthumously made Palace Attendant of the Heir Apparent.
18
Zhao Shidan
19
使 簿
Zhao Shidan, styled Qianshu, was the nephew of Vice Commissioner of the Bureau of Military Affairs Zhen. He was handsome in bearing and six feet tall. In youth he read widely in history and devoted himself especially to penal law. Through Zhen's privilege he entered service as master of records in the Directorate of Works and rose to investigating officer of the Ninghai army. As magistrate of Jiangshan he judged by his own lights; his clerks could not extort a single coin from the people, and goods left on the road went untouched. Recommended for merit, he became aide in the Court of Judicial Review and magistrate of Pengcheng, then Right Supporter-in-Attendance of the Heir Apparent, and was transferred to govern Kangzhou.
20
使 使 祿
When Zhigao took Yongzhou and marched downstream, Shidan sent scouts who returned reporting, "Every prefect along the river has abandoned his city and fled!" Shidan rebuked them: "Do you want me to flee as well?" He searched thoroughly, found three spies, and executed them as a warning. The rebels were already at the walls. Shidan had only three hundred men; he opened the gates, met them in battle, and killed dozens. At dusk the rebels drew back. Shidan told his wife to take the prefectural seal, hide with their son, and said, "Tomorrow they will come in force. I know we cannot win, yet I cannot flee. If you stay, you will die for nothing." He then joined Supervisory Commissioner Ma Gui in holding the city. Shidan summoned Ma Gui to eat. Gui could not eat, but Shidan alone ate his fill as usual. That night Ma Gui tossed sleeplessly on his bed, while Shidan lay down at once and slept heavily, snoring. At daybreak the rebels pressed the attack harder. His attendants urged him to withdraw somewhat. Shidan said, "What is the difference between dying in battle and dying by execution?" All replied, "We are willing to die for the realm." When the city fell, not a single man fled. When their arrows were spent, he and Ma Gui withdrew to the hall and sat down. Zhigao waved his troops forward in a roaring rush. They seized Shidan, and he cursed them: "You starving savages! What wrong has the court ever done you, that you dare rebel? If the emperor sends one regiment, not one of you will survive." Enraged, Zhigao had both of them killed. After the rebels left, the people of the prefecture built a temple in his honor. When order was restored, he was posthumously made Vice Director of the Imperial Household; his mother, Lady Wang, was granted the rank of Lady of Chang'an County with ceremonial cap and sash; and his sons, younger brothers, and three nephews were given official appointments. Shidan was forty-two when he was killed. When his coffin passed through Jiangshan, the people of that county came out to receive his funeral train, weeping and offering sacrifice along the road for hundreds of li without end.
21
At the same time one Wang Congzheng, an Eastern Head Presentation Officer and Palace Gate Usher, fought Zhigao at Taiping Field. Captured, he kept cursing the rebels; they poured boiling water over him, yet he never yielded and died. He was posthumously made prefect of Xinzhou, and two grandsons were given official appointments.
22
調簿 簿 調
Su Jian, styled Xuanfu, was from Jinjiang in Quanzhou. He passed the jinshi examination and was appointed chief clerk of Nanhai in Guangzhou. Guangzhou oversaw foreign shipping, and when merchants arrived an official was assigned to inspect their cargo. These merchants were wealthy powerful families accustomed to being received as guests. When Jian was sent to perform this duty, a merchant surnamed Fan walked straight up and took a seat. Jian questioned him and beat him with a staff. Fan complained to the prefecture, which summoned and rebuked Jian. Jian said, "The chief clerk's rank is low, but he is an officer of the district. The merchant is rich, but he is a subject of the district. What is wrong with a district officer beating a district subject?" The prefecture had no answer. Reassigned as commandant of Yangwu, he faced a notorious bandit named Li who robbed the people, and the police could not catch him. Jian tracked him down, gathered men for a thorough search, and set fire to a neighboring house to flush him out. Li broke out from the middle of the search. Jian chased him on horseback, cut off his head, and sent it to the prefectural office. Prefect Jia Changchao exclaimed in astonishment, "Would a scholar really risk his life like this?" He rose through successive posts to secretary in the Archive and prefect of Yingzhou.
23
詿使 西 使使 使
When Zhigao besieged Guang, Jian said, "Guang is my superior prefecture and lies close to my post. The city may fall at any moment, and not to go to its aid would be unrighteous." He immediately raised several thousand men, entrusted his seal to Circuit Intendant for Penal Affairs Bao Ke, marched through the night to the rescue, and camped twenty li from Guang. Huang Shimi of Guang had joined the rebels as their chief strategist. Jian captured and executed his father. Mobs of ruffians took advantage of the turmoil to turn bandit. He captured and killed more than sixty and summoned back more than six thousand eight hundred who had been misled, restoring them to their trades. When rebel momentum faltered and they prepared to withdraw, Jian sent detachments to cut off their retreat, blocking the route with rafts and logs for forty li. Blocked from advancing, the rebels detoured several miles, crossed the river, and fled west through Lian and He. Jian fought them, inflicting heavy casualties and recovering all their loot. When the other generals were dismissed, Jian alone had distinguished himself. Emperor Renzong was pleased and transferred him to Deputy Commissioner of the Supplies-Preparedness Vault and Guangdong Chief Inspector, placing him in charge of military equipment for both circuits; an imperial envoy was sent with court robes and a gold belt. When the rebels struck Yong, the commanding general Chen Shu was executed for disciplinary failure, and Jian was demoted to military aide of Fangzhou. Restored as editorial assistant, he oversaw Yuezhou's taxes for more than ten years before recovering his deputy commissioner rank. As prefect of Lianzhou, where buildings were mostly bamboo and thatch, garrison soldier Yang Xi, drunk, set fire to the camp; the blaze spread to civilians' homes, and he looted amid the chaos. Jian had him executed in the market, but was himself demoted to Chief Inspector of Tanzhou. Before long he was made prefect of Dingzhou.
24
使 使 使
Early in the Xining era he was promoted to Capital Envoy and Guangdong Controller. In the fourth year, Jiaozhi plotted an invasion, and Jian was made Imperial City Envoy and prefect of Yongzhou. Jian confirmed the intelligence and wrote to Shen Qi, prefect of Guizhou, but Qi paid no attention. When Liu Yi replaced Qi, Jian wrote to Yi asking him to halt the project. Yi refused and instead issued an official rebuke, accusing Jian of obstructing policy and forbidding him to speak out again. In the eighth year the barbarians invaded in force, claiming eighty thousand men. They took Qin and Lian and overran four Yong forts. Hearing of their approach, Jian mustered twenty-eight hundred prefectural troops, summoned capable officials and local men, instructed them in strategy, and deployed the units to defend separate sectors. The people panicked and fled in all directions. Jian displayed the official treasury and his private stores and said, "Our arms are ready and our supplies ample. The enemy is at the walls; we must hold firm and wait for relief. If even one person runs, every heart will fail. Obey me: anyone who tries to flee will be executed, along with his family." A major commander named Zhai Ji tried to slip away; Jian beheaded him as a warning, and from then on none dared stir. Jian's son Ziyuan, registrar of Guizhou, had come on official business with his wife and children to visit; he wished to return, but the invaders arrived. Jian knew he could not reason with every household and that if the prefect's family fled the city, morale would collapse. He sent Ziyuan out alone and kept his wife and children. He picked brave men to take boats and fight upstream, killing two barbarian chiefs.
25
使
Once Yong was besieged, Jian day and night encouraged his troops and used divine-arm crossbows against the rebels, killing many. Jian first asked Liu Yi for help. Yi sent General Zhang Shoujie, but Zhang dallied and would not advance. Jian also sent an urgent message in a wax-sealed letter to Circuit Intendant Song Qiu. Qiu wept when he read it and pressed Shoujie to march. Shoujie panicked, hurried to Great Jia Ridge, and fell back to defend Kunlun Pass. He suddenly met the enemy, had no time to form ranks, and his entire force was wiped out. The barbarians captured Song troops skilled at siege, bribed them to build scaling ladders and covered trench-assault engines, and Jian burned them all. Their plans exhausted, the barbarians were about to withdraw until they learned no relief was coming. Someone showed them how to fill sacks with earth and pile them against the wall; within moments the mound rose several zhang. They swarmed up like ants, and the city fell. Jian still led his wounded men in fierce mounted combat but could not prevail. He said, "Righteousness forbids that I die in the enemy's hands." He hurried back to the prefectural seat, killed thirty-six members of his household, hid their bodies in a pit, and set himself on fire. When the barbarians arrived they could find no bodies. They slaughtered more than fifty thousand people of the prefecture, stacked the dead in piles of a hundred—more than five hundred eighty piles in all—and demolished three circuit cities to fill the river. Yong was besieged for forty-two days. Food ran out and the springs dried up; people drank fermented hemp water to quench thirst; dysentery killed them in heaps; yet not one man defected.
26
使 西 殿
Jian blamed Shen Qi and Liu Yi for bringing on the invasion and failing to send relief, and wished to memorialize the throne. With roads blocked he could not reach the capital, so he posted their crimes in the marketplace, hoping word would reach the court. When Emperor Shenzong learned of Jian's death he mourned him deeply. Jian was posthumously made military commissioner of the Fengguo Army with the posthumous title Loyal and Brave. The court granted his family five mansions in the capital and ten qing of premium farmland at home, to be chosen as they wished. Ziyuan was made Western Head Presentation Officer and Palace Gate Usher and summoned to audience. The emperor said, "Yong survived because your father held it. Had it fallen as quickly as Qin and Lian, the enemy would have surged forward and neither Gui nor Xiang could have been saved. Zhang Xun and Xu Yuan once held Suiyang and shielded the Yangzi and Huai regions. Your father ranks no lower than they." Ziyuan was appointed Palace Assistant-in-Censorate and vice-prefect of Yongzhou. The second sons Ziming and Zizheng and grandsons Guangyuan and Zhiven died with Jian and were all posthumously honored. Shen Qi and Liu Yi were both demoted. After Jian's death the people of Jiaozhi plotted to invade Guizhou. After marching several miles their troops saw a great army approaching from the north and cried, "Imperial City Envoy Su leads an army to avenge himself!" Terrified, they turned back. The people of Yong built a shrine to Jian; in the Yuanyou era it was granted the plaque name Cherishing Loyalty.
27
Qin Chuanxu
28
使
Qin Chuanxu was from Jiangning. In the fifth year of Chunhua he served as inspector of the Kui and Xia passes. During Li Shun's rebellion rebel forces suddenly appeared before Kuizhou. Chuanxu led his troops in day-and-night defense. As the siege wore on and danger mounted, the senior officials all fled and joined the rebels. Chuanxu told his troops, "I am the supervisory commissioner. To die holding this city is my duty. How can I seek to save myself?" Food ran short. Chuanxu sold his personal belongings for wine and meat to reward his men, encouraged them, and all wept as they fought on. Seeing resistance was hopeless, he sent a wax-sealed letter by a secret route: "Your servant will fight to the death and vows never to surrender." When the walls collapsed, Chuanxu threw himself into the flames and died.
29
殿
Chuanxu's family lived in the Jing-Hu region. His son Shi went upriver through the gorges searching for his father's body and drowned. People said the father had died for loyalty and the son for filial piety. When the report reached court, Emperor Taizong mourned him deeply. Chuanxu's second son Xu was given office as a palace guard, and one hundred thousand cash was granted to the family. When Xu died, his younger brother Fang was appointed a Three-Rank Attendant.
30
Zhan Liangchen
31
調 使 使
Zhan Liangchen, styled Yuangong, was from Fenshui in Muzhou. He failed the jinshi examination, received office by privilege, and was appointed commandant of Jinyun County. When Fang La rebelled, his follower Hong again attacked Chuzhou; the prefect and vice-prefect both abandoned the city and fled. Another bandit, Huo Chenfu, adopted La's reign title and raided Jinyun. Liangchen said, "Catching bandits is a commandant's duty. Even if I cannot win, how can I shrink from death?" He led several dozen archers out to fight and was captured. Chenfu tried to win him over. Liangchen said, "You fools do not know enough to save your own lives, yet you think you can make me surrender? Li Shun rebelled in Shu, Wang Lun in Huainan, Wang Ze in Beizhou—they were torn limb from limb, and their families and accomplices, young and old, were all executed. The imperial army will come any day, and your flesh will feed the dogs and rats." Enraged, the rebels cut flesh from his body and forced him to eat it. Liangchen spat and cursed without cease until he died. Onlookers covered their faces and wept. He was seventy-two. When Emperor Huizong heard of it he was deeply grieved. Liangchen was posthumously made Direct Attendant, and two of his descendants were given official appointments.
32
Jiang Zhongming
33
使
Jiang Zhongming was from Taizhou. During the bandit turmoil of the Xuanhe era he fled with his elderly mother into the mountains. He suddenly met bandits on the hill east of the city. They forced him to surrender, but Zhongming, unwilling to suffer disgrace, rose up cursing them and was killed. Chancellor Lü Yihao composed a eulogy for him.
34
There was one Jiang Yu, a man of Xianju in the prefecture, learned in letters. The bandits wished to marry him to a daughter; Yu refused. They threatened him to bow, but he still would not comply. The bandits said, "I will kill you!" Yu thrust out his neck to the blade and died cursing without pause.
35
Li Ruoshui
36
調 使 退使
Li Ruoshui, styled Qingqing, was from Quzhou in Mozhou; he had originally been named Ruobing. He passed the Upper Hall examination and was appointed commandant of Yuancheng and recorder of Pingyang Prefecture. He placed first in the academic official examination, served as instructor at Jinan, and was appointed Erudite of the Imperial University. When Cai Jing returned to the chief councilorship in his later years, his son Cai Tiao held sway; Li Bangyan was aggrieved and wished to resign on grounds of illness. Ruoshui told him, "Great ministers serve the ruler by the Way, and when they cannot, they should withdraw. Why not settle the matter before the throne, so that the right to stay or go is made plain to the realm? How can you quietly plead illness and slip away, inviting the whole realm to call you a useless hanger-on at court?" He also said, "Rot has piled up for years, and good order is hard to achieve. Cuts have been ordered yet the treasury is still thin; taxes and corvée have been reduced yet the people remain exhausted; restrain the powerful and they grow bolder still; the official ranks are swollen yet never cleared. Now is the time to post relays to seek talent, open one's door to scholars, draw on whatever insight they offer, and use it to restore good government." In more than ten such points he struck deep at the ills of the day, and Bangyan was displeased.
37
In the first year of the Jingkang reign, he served as Erudite of the Imperial University. When Gao Qiu, Grand Preceptor with ceremonial honors equal to the Three Excellencies, died, precedent called for the emperor to don mourning and perform lamentation rites. Ruoshui said, "Qiu rose to high rank as a favorite, ruined military affairs, and let the Jurchens sweep in unchecked. His guilt ranks with Tong Guan and men like him. Even though he died whole, his ranks should still be posthumously stripped, to show that all have cast him off; yet the officials follow old custom and would add elaborate rites. That is no way to quiet public outrage." He submitted his memorial twice before the court desisted.
38
使使 使 退
Emperor Qinzong was about to send envoys to the Jin court to discuss redeeming the Three Prefectures with tax revenues. An edict called for men fit to serve as envoys, and Ruoshui was chosen. Summoned for audience, he was granted his present name and promoted to Assistant Drafter in the Palace Library. As envoy he met Nianhan at Yunzhong. He had barely returned when Jin troops were already marching south. He was again lent the title of Academician of the Huaiyou Pavilion and went as deputy to Feng Li. When they halted at Zhongmou, the river-guard troops panicked one another with word that Jin forces had arrived. Those around them plotted to slip away by a side road. Li asked, "What do you think?" Ruoshui said, "The garrison troops feared the enemy and broke. How can we copy them? All that remains is to die." He ordered that anyone who spoke of retreat be executed, and the company steadied.
39
Once underway, he submitted memorial after memorial arguing that peace talks could not succeed and urging that defenses be tightened. At Huai Prefecture he met the escort commissioner Xiao Qing, who forced him to turn back with him. At the capital gate Ruoshui was detained at the Chongxu Abbey while only Qing and Li were admitted. When most of what was negotiated was rejected, Nianhan pressed the siege hard. Ruoshui entered to see the emperor, reported their demands, and the emperor ordered He Li to go. He returned saying the two men wished to meet the Retired Emperor. The emperor said, "I shall go myself." The next day he visited the Jin camp and returned on their pledge of good faith. Ruoshui was promoted to Minister of Rites but firmly declined. The emperor said, "An academician and a minister sit in the same court session. Why refuse?" He kept petitioning without cease and was reassigned as Vice Minister of Personnel.
40
使
In the second year the Jurchens again summoned the emperor outside the city. The emperor was deeply reluctant, but Ruoshui, seeing no other danger, accompanied him. The Jurchens changed their plan midway and forced the emperor to change clothes. Ruoshui clung to him weeping and denounced the Jurchens as dogs. The Jurchens dragged him out and beat his face to ruin. He lost breath and collapsed. The crowd scattered, and several dozen armored horsemen were left to watch him. Nianhan ordered, "See that Vice Minister Li comes to no harm." Ruoshui refused all food. Someone urged him, "Nothing more can be done. Though you spoke harshly yesterday, the chief minister bears no grudge. Yield today and tomorrow you will be rich and honored." Ruoshui sighed and said, "Heaven has but one sun. How could Ruoshui serve two masters?" His servant also tried to comfort him: "Your parents are old. If you yield a little, you may yet return to see them once." Ruoshui rebuked him: "I no longer care for my family! A loyal minister serves his ruler; in death there is no second master. But my parents are old. When you return, do not tell them at once. Let my brothers break the news slowly."
41
More than ten days later Nianhan summoned him to discuss affairs and asked why he refused to sign the document installing a ruler of another surname. Ruoshui said, "The Retired Emperor, for the people's sake, blamed himself and abdicated. Our sovereign is benevolent, filial, compassionate, and frugal and has done no wrong. How can one lightly talk of deposing him?" Nianhan accused the Song of breaking faith. Ruoshui said, "If breach of faith is the crime, you are guiltier than anyone." He listed five offenses and said, "You are a ravening hog and long serpent, a true arch-villain. Your ruin is not far off." Nianhan ordered him dragged away. Looking back, he cursed all the more fiercely. At the foot of the suburban altar he said to his servant Xie Ning, "I die for the state—that is my duty. But how can I bear to drag you down with me?" Again he cursed without pause. The guards beat his lips apart; spewing blood, he cursed all the sharper. At last they cut his neck and severed his tongue. He died at thirty-five.
42
殿 '' ' '
Ning made it back and told the whole story in detail. When Emperor Gaozong took the throne, he issued an edict: "Ruoshui's loyal and righteous integrity is beyond compare. Learning of it, We are moved to tears." He was posthumously granted Academician of the Guanwen Hall, with the posthumous title Zhongmin. After his death a man who had escaped from the north reported, "The Jurchens said among themselves, 'When the Liao fell, more than ten died for righteousness. In the Southern Court there is only Vice Minister Li. Facing death he showed no fear and composed a final song-poem: "Raising my head I ask Heaven—Heaven gives no answer. A loyal minister dies in service—what fault is there in death?" Those who heard it were deeply grieved."
43
調 西 便 使殿
Liu Ge, styled Zhongyan, was from Chong'an in Jianzhou. He passed the jinshi examination and was appointed commandant of Fengcheng and magistrate of Longcheng. When Wang Hou governed Xizhou, Ge was recruited as magistrate of Didao and appointed supervisor of the Shaanxi Equitable-Price Bureau. Many troops were stationed along the He and Huang rivers and supplies ran short. Ge invited tribal chiefs, exchanged gold and silk for grain, and used it to feed the army, to the benefit of both public and private interests. He then became transport commissioner and was promoted to Grandee of the Palace and Compiler in the Hall for Cultivating Talent.
44
使 西
When Liu Fa died, the Tangut attacked Zhenwu. Ge served as acting military commissioner of Fuyan, sent a surprise force against them, and lifted the siege. The Tangut sent word that they wished to submit and apologize, but all thought it a trick. Ge said, "War has dragged on for years. China itself can barely sustain it—how much less a small state? Though they have just won, their forces are weary too. Fearing we will strike again, they submit to secure themselves. That feeling is genuine." He reported this in a secret memorial, and the court approved. When the Tangut envoy missed the appointed date, the generals said the Tangut had indeed deceived them and asked to gather troops and strike. Ge said, "Cross-border appointments may be delayed for other reasons." When the envoy who came to renew the request arrived, Ge warned, "The court is bent on punitive campaigns. I have pleaded for you. Do not, as before, press for annual tribute, violate the border, and invite imperial wrath." The Tangut obeyed, and from then on the western frontier was at peace.
45
殿
Ge sought to return east and was appointed Chamberlain for Attendant Readiness of the Huaiyou Pavilion and Supervisor of the Chongfu Palace. Recalled to serve as prefect of Yuezhou, he found that farmers had encroached on Mirror Lake for cultivation; the government collected rent on it, twenty thousand bushels a year. During the Zhenghe era the lake was drained for fields, expanding to six times its former area and placed under the inner palace tribute office. The rent was crushing and collection harsh, and many fled. Previously the authorities had forced neighboring households to make up the shortfall. The people complained bitterly, and Ge petitioned to have the levy remitted. When Fang La took Qu and Wu, Yue was thrown into panic. Officials fled, and some prepared boats and urged him to leave. Ge said, "I am prefect of this commandery. I should live or die with the city." He would not budge and redoubled the city's defenses. When bandits reached the walls he defeated them. He was appointed Direct Academician of the Shugu Hall and summoned as staff officer to the Hebei and Hedong Pacification Commissioner.
46
使 涿 殿 駿 退 殿
At the time frontier officials reported that the people of Yan wished to come over to the Song. Tong Guan and Cai You were just setting out when Zhong Shidao's army collapsed. Ge suspected the alarm was false and went to consult Shidao. Shidao said, "Khitan forces are still strong, yet the people of Yan have not risen. I fear frontier officials have lied and will ruin the state's business." Ge immediately rode to inform Tong and You and asked that the army be withdrawn. He also argued that Yan and Ji could not be taken; even if they were, garrisoning troops and shipping supplies would cost without limit and would crush the empire. On the return march he halted at Mozhou. When Guo Yaoshi surrendered Zhuozhou, the campaign set out again. Because Ge's views differed, he was transferred to prefect of Zhending. When Yaoshi came to court, Ge secretly memorialized asking that he be detained. The court did not reply. He was transferred to Jianzhou, then Fuzhou, and granted Academician of the Yankang Hall. Someone reported that when passing through the palace gate he had been seen petitioning the Censor-in-Chief, and he was dismissed. He was recalled to govern Jingnan. When bandits rose in Hebei, he was again put in charge of Zhending. The chief bandit Chai Hong had been a wealthy man who could not bear the levies. He gathered followers to plunder, killed patrol officers, and a control officer also died fighting him. Ge rode alone to his post, sent to summon Hong, and Hong came to submit to punishment. Ge gave him wine, asked that he be given an office, and released his followers to return to their villages. The whole circuit was pacified. Yaoshi requested horses. An edict gave him all the war horses of Hebei; when that was not enough, the levy was extended to the people. Ge said, "To strip the inner commanderies of their best horses and hand them to one surrendered general is no wise plan." He memorialized and stopped it. The Jurchens were already planning to drive south, even as the court was acceding to their request for the Yunzhong territory. Ge's spies confirmed it. He reported urgently and quietly strengthened the city's defenses to await whatever might come. That winter Jin troops reached the walls. Seeing the city prepared, they left troops nearby and drove straight inland. When they returned, they built scaling ladders and siege engines and set up a siege, feigning attack. Ge deployed powerful crossbows and shot at them. The Jurchens saw they could not force him and withdrew. Since the Jin troops came, every commandery had shut its gates and the people were trapped indoors. Ge alone let woodcutters and herdsmen go out as on ordinary days, opening and closing the gates on schedule. Emperor Qinzong approved and appointed him Academician of the Hall for Aid in Governance.
47
使 祿 使
By then the court had already agreed to cede territory to buy off the Jurchens, but debaters, seizing on the anger of soldiers and civilians, again proposed hot pursuit. Ge held that rushing into battle was wrong. At this time the generals marched to relieve Taiyuan. Zhong Shizhong and Yao Gu were defeated. Ge was appointed Deputy Commissioner for Pacification. At Liaozhou he raised and mustered troops until he had forty thousand men. He arranged with Xie Qian and Zhe Keqiu to advance together on a fixed date, but both were defeated in turn. Earlier Ge had sent another commander, Jia Qiong, out from Daizhou to hit the enemy from the rear, and had promised ranks and stipends to militia leaders, winning over several dozen chieftains. Wutai was recovered, but when word came that Qian and Keqiu had been defeated, the advance was never carried out. When Taiyuan fell he was summoned to court and appointed Defender of the Four Walls of the Capital, but the chief councillors blocked the appointment and had him removed.
48
西
Ge was grave, generous, and mild. In his dealings with others he seemed almost intimidating; yet when great affairs were at stake he was resolute and could not be swayed. Early on in Xizhou he had caught Tong Guan's eye and so had been involved in his military campaigns from start to finish. When he died loyal to the state, commentators no longer dwelt on his earlier mistakes. His sons Ziyu and Gong have separate biographies.
49
調
Fu Cha, styled Gonghui, was from Jiyuan in Meng Prefecture and a grand-nephew of Yaoyu, Vice Director of the Secretariat. At eighteen he passed the jinshi examination. When Cai Jing was chancellor, he heard of Cha's reputation and sent his son Chou to visit him, intending to marry him to his daughter. Cha refused and would not agree. He was assigned as judicial aide in Qing Prefecture, then served as assistant magistrate of Yongping and Zichuan. He entered the capital as Erudite of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices and was promoted to Vice Director in the Ministries of War and of Personnel.
50
使 使 使使 使 使 使 使 使
In the tenth month of the seventh year of Xuanhe, he was appointed escort commissioner for the Jin envoys coming to congratulate the court on New Year's Day. At this time the Jin were about to break the alliance, but the court did not yet know. When Cha reached Yan, he heard that the Jurchens were invading. Some urged him not to press on. Cha said, "Having received a mission and set out, to halt when one hears of danger — what becomes of the ruler's command?" So he continued on to Hancheng town. The envoys never came. After several days, several dozen Jurchen horsemen galloped into the lodge and forced him onto a horse. When they reached the border, Cha sensed something was wrong and refused to go farther. "In escorting envoys," he said, "by precedent one stops here." The Jurchens immediately changed his escort and marched him northeast. After about a hundred li they met the so-called Second Prince, Wolibu, leading troops on the post road, who ordered him to bow. Cha said, "If I were on a mission to a great state, I would pay respects when meeting the ruler. But I came to receive guests, and you have forced me here! And you only require me to meet the prince. However exalted the prince may be, he is still a subject. I should meet him with the rites due a guest — why should I bow?" Wolibu said angrily, "I have raised an army and marched south. What mission do you speak of? Tell me everything about your state's strengths and weaknesses, or die." Cha said, "Our sovereign is benevolent and sage. He has made peace with your great state, and envoys have traveled back and forth in an unbroken stream. There has been no lapse in virtue. The prince has broken the alliance and taken action. What does he intend? When I return to court I shall report this in full." Wolibu said, "Do you still think you can return to court!" His attendants pressed him to bow. Naked blades stood like a forest. Some dragged him to the ground until his sleeves and hem were turned upside down, yet he stood all the more upright and unyielding, arguing back and forth. Wolibu said, "If you do not bow today, even if you wish to bow later, will you be able to?" He waved his hand and ordered him taken away.
51
使 使忿 涿 使
Cha knew he could not escape. He said to his staff members Hou Yan and others, "I am sure to die. My parents have always loved me, and when they hear of it they will be deeply grieved. If by any chance you escape, please remember what I say and tell my parents, so that knowing I died for the state they may find some relief from their boundless grief." All wept. That evening he was cut off from them and was never seen again. When the Jin troops reached Yan, Yan and the others secretly inquired after him and were told, "The envoy refused to bow to the prince. Yesterday Guo Yaoshi's victory had put the prince in good humor, but the prince feared a rescue attempt and, still nursing old resentment, had him killed." The officer Wu Hanying identified his corpse, cremated it, wrapped the bones, and ordered the Tiger Wing soldier Sha Li to carry them home. When Li reached Zhuozhou, the Jurchens captured him and locked him in an earthen cell for two months. When the guards slackened, he broke through the wall and escaped, returned home, and delivered the bones to Cha's family. The deputy commissioner Jiang E, Yan, and the others returned and all could describe Cha's refusal to yield. He was posthumously granted the title Attendant Drafting in the Hall of Splendid Writings.
52
From youth Cha was devoted to learning. When peers invited him to join in amusement and play, he would not go. His writing was warm, elegant, and well measured. In ordinary life he was modest and deferential, showing neither joy nor anger. In affairs he seemed to approve or disapprove of nothing, but when something went against his mind he suddenly became unapproachable. He was indifferent to power and profit. In the capital, though old friends rose to great eminence, they rarely came to his door, and when he saw them once in a while it was only to exchange greetings and casual talk. Yet when in haste he gave his life for righteousness, he stood out so remarkably that those who heard were moved to sorrow and admiration. He was thirty-seven at the time. In the Qiandao era he was granted the posthumous title Zhongsu, "Loyal and Solemn."
53
Yang Zhen, styled Zifa, was from Guo in Daizhou. Because his archery and horsemanship were unmatched, he was made frontier patrol inspector of Anbian. When the Hedong army campaigned on the Zangdi River, the enemy held a mountain as a fortress and looked down on the government troops. The generals combined their forces below the fort. Zhen led brave men, swords drawn, in the first assault. They cut down several hundred heads, the troops pressed the victory and took the place, and his merit was ranked first.
54
Following Zhe Kechun in the campaign against Fang La, he turned from eastern Zhe and fought through to Sanjie town, taking eight thousand heads. Pursuing the attack to Huangyan, the bandit chief Lü Shinang held the Decapitated Head defile and blocked the way, rolling down stones in fierce assault. For many days they could not advance. Kechun asked for a plan. Zhen proposed sending light troops along the mountain ridge to shout from the heights and rain down arrows and stones. The bandits fled in alarm, but then set fires to defend themselves. Zhen himself wore heavy armor and, with his men, marched through the fire and broke in. He captured Shinang alive and killed thirty chieftains. He was promoted five ranks. On his return he was appointed prefect of Lin Prefecture and commander of Jianning Fort.
55
Father: Zongmin
56
西 滿
Earlier, when the Khitan state fell, its general Xiao Ni'an fled west, gathered more than a hundred thousand mixed Qiang tribesmen, captured Feng Prefecture, and attacked the walled towns of Lin and Fu. Zhen's father Zongmin, leading the military forces of the circuit, repeatedly crushed and defeated him and captured his parents, wife, and children. In the tenth month of the first year of Jingkang, when Taiyuan fell, Ni'an drove rebel soldiers from You and Ji together with Tangut and Xi troops to besiege Jianning. He knocked on the wall and said to Zhen, "Your father seized my home, broke my army, and captured my kin. I have endured until now — hurry and surrender the city, and I will spare your life." At the time the defenders numbered fewer than a hundred. Zhen promised the warriors a set reward for each head cut off. When the official treasury was exhausted, he paid with his family's clothing and earrings. Officials and soldiers were moved to fight all the harder. After more than ten days, arrows were spent and strength exhausted and the city could not be held. He and his sons Juzhong and Zhizhong fought fiercely and perished. The whole household was lost; only the eldest son Cunzhong, campaigning in Hebei, escaped. The next year Zongmin also died in service at Chang'an.
57
Zhen was forty-four at the time. In the second year of Jianyan, an edict posthumously granted him the rank of Gentleman for Military Classics. When Cunzhong rose to eminence, he petitioned the court, and the posthumous title Gongyi, "Respectful and Resolute," was granted.
58
Zhang Kejian
59
使
Zhang Kejian, styled Dexiang, was a great-grandson of Qi, Palace Attendant. He passed the jinshi examination, served as magistrate of Hejian, and was prefect of Wu County. Wu was a difficult county in Zhe. The people loved litigation, and great clans relied on power to dominate the magistracy. Magistrates followed precedent and bowed their heads, striving only not to make trouble and hoping merely to get away. Kejian judged everything by law. The cunning and slippery held their breath. The commissioner reported his conduct to the throne, and he was summoned and appointed Vice Director of the Imperial Guard. Earlier, Kejian's cousin Ke Gong had served as censor and impeached Cai Jing. When Jing again held power, he nursed a grudge against the Zhang clan and dismissed Kejian on a trivial matter. After more than a year he was reappointed prefect of Xiangfu County, served as clerk of household accounts in Kaifeng, and was commissioner for the Eastern Capital Circuit's Ever-Normal Granaries. When he came to take leave of the throne he was retained as Vice Director in the Ministry of Revenue.
60
In the eighth month of the seventh year of Xuanhe, he was appointed prefect of Fen Prefecture. In the twelfth month, Jin troops invaded Hedong and besieged Taiyuan. Taiyuan was two hundred li from Fen. The Jin sent the general Yinzhu Beijin to attack, letting his troops plunder on all sides. Kejian exerted all his strength in defense. Several dozen men from Yan who had earlier submitted and were below the walls secretly formed a faction intending to serve as inside collaborators. He arrested and executed them all. Several times he selected crack troops to harass the enemy camp and, catching them off guard, burned their palisades. The enemy, fearing this, withdrew. For his merit he was promoted to Direct Associate of the Secretariat.
61
使使 使殿 紿
In the sixth month of the first year of Jingkang, Jin troops again pressed the city. The court ordered the pacification commissioner Zhang Xiaochun's son Hao, the overall commander Zhang Sizheng, and the transport commissioner Li Zong to come to the rescue. Sizheng extorted without limit, and the people could not bear it. Kejian appealed to their sense of duty and reasoned with them, and all were willing to fight harder. Commissioner for Pacification Li Gang memorialized his labors in defending the city, and he was promoted in succession to Direct Associate of the Dragon Diagram Hall and Compiler at the Hall of Right Culture. When Taiyuan could not be held, Sizheng deceived them saying he would go out to battle, then led Hao and Zong in flight to Ci and Xi. After this the people had no firm will to resist. The garrison commander Ma Shijian cut through the gate and fled in the middle of the night. The vice prefect Han Hu likewise fled. Kejian summoned the soldiers and civilians and said, "Now that Taiyuan has fallen, I already know we are doomed. Yet in righteousness I cannot bear to fail the state or disgrace my fathers and ancestors. I wish to see this city through to the end to make clear my integrity. You all must look to your own plans." All wept and could not raise their eyes to look. With one voice they replied, "You are our father and mother. We wish to die to the last man and obey your command." Then he redoubled the drilling of troops and tightened the defense. When the enemy arrived, he personally led the officers and soldiers, armored, onto the battlements. Though they repeatedly repelled the enemy, relief troops never came.
62
使 西 殿
Jin troops captured Pingyao. Pingyao was a great town of Fen and had long resisted the enemy. After it fell first, they also coerced Jiexiu, Xiaoyi, and other counties to surrender, occupied twenty villages south of the prefecture, and made siege engines. Twice they sent envoys bearing letters to instruct Kejian. He burned them unread. He set forth in full the desperate plight and recruited men to go by hidden routes and report to the court. He received no reply. On the first day of the tenth month, the Jin added ten thousand horsemen and pressed the attack ever harder. Ten men were heard advocating surrender, and he executed them as a warning. The chieftains lined up below the wall. Kejian leaned over and cursed them to the full. A cannon shot struck one chieftain and killed him on the spot. Judging that he could not escape, he personally drafted a final memorial and letters of farewell to his wife and children, and had a soldier of the prefecture lowered by rope to carry them to the capital. The next day Jin troops entered from the northwest corner and killed the overseer Jia Dan. Kejian still led the crowd in street fighting. The Jurchens offered a reward to capture him alive. Kejian returned home, asked for his court robes, burned incense and bowed facing south, and took his own life. Eight members of his household died. The Jin general had his corpse buried with ceremony in the rear garden, bowed in array and set out offerings, and had a temple built for him. When the matter was reported, an edict posthumously granted him Academician of the Hall for Extended Health, three hundred taels of silver and five hundred bolts of silk, and a memorial tablet posted at his gate. In the Shaoxing era he was granted the posthumous title Zhongque, "Loyal and Steadfast."
63
祿 退
Zhang Que, styled Ziggu, was a native of Yilu in Bin Prefecture. During the Yuanyou era, he passed the jinshi examination. When Emperor Huizong came to the throne, he responded to an imperial summons with a memorial outlining ten proposals: execute the greatest villains, dismiss petty officials, promote the worthy and capable, lift bans on office, recall seasoned statesmen, elevate the loyal and outspoken, reduce border tensions, restore civil virtue, broaden avenues for remonstrance, and welcome frank counsel. He was thereupon enrolled on the upper register.
64
In the second year of Xuanhe, he was summoned to the capital. When the Qingxi bandits rose, Que said, "These are all the emperor's subjects—it is only incompetent officials who have stirred them up. Issue an edict of remorse and compassion, cut back non-urgent affairs, and abolish every levy beyond rents and taxes; let death be the penalty for anyone who dares furnish the court with ornamental stones and extravagant luxuries. Pacify those who were forced to join, and do not treat slaughter as achievement—in ten days the rebels can be wiped out." This offended Wang Fu, and he was made vice-prefect of Hangzhou with responsibility for Muzhou affairs. He pardoned everyone who fled back from the rebels, investigated to learn what was true and what was false, and reported his findings; the generals acted on his counsel. After the rebels were suppressed, he was appointed prefect of Fang and Fen Prefectures.
65
西 使
In the seventh year of Xuanhe, he was transferred to Jie Prefecture and then to Longde Prefecture. Jin troops besieged Taiyuan; Xin and Dai surrendered, and the garrison at Pingyang mutinied. Que submitted a memorial stating, "Hedong is the empire's foundation and the pivot of its safety and peril. Without Hedong, not only would Qin be impossible to hold—even Bian could not remain the capital. Once the enemy takes the mutinous troops, they will surely push south. Lucheng has gone unrepaired for a century, and its officers and soldiers are all posted on the frontier. Your subject was raised in the western regions and knows something of military affairs. Give me a hundred thousand Qin troops and I can still hold the enemy at bay; otherwise I have only my death to offer Your Majesty." He submitted memorial after memorial, but none received a reply. The following year, in the second month, Jin troops arrived. Seeing that the city was undefended, they urged him to surrender. Que mounted the walls to resist the siege. Someone proposed breaking out through the eastern gate and tested Que's reaction. Que angrily rebuked him: "I am a minister charged with this land. I owe the state my death—my head may be cut off, but my back will not bow." He then fought and died.
66
殿 使
When Emperor Qinzong heard the news, he grieved deeply. He posthumously granted Que the title of Direct Academician of the Hall for Venerating Antiquity, summoned his son Yi, and comforted him, saying, "Your father is this age's Zhang Xun and Xu Yuan. He found the death he sought—what more could he have wished for? If every general and every defender were like your father, would I be in the plight I face today?" He composed his face and sighed for a long while.
67
Zhu Zhao, styled Yanming, was a native of Fugu. He rose through military service, eventually reaching the rank of Bearer of Righteousness. He drifted unobtrusively through the ranks and never sought to stand out. At the end of the Xuanhe era, he served as supervisor of troops and horses at Zhenwei Fort and was put in charge of the fort's affairs. When Jin troops invaded the interior, the Tangut seized the opportunity and took every fort and town west of the Yellow River. Zhenwei lay three hundred li from Fuzhou and was the most isolated of all. Zhao led the old and young into the fort to hold it. As the enemy pressed the attack, he recruited more than a thousand of his best troops and pledged to them, "The enemy knows our strength inside the walls and looks down on us. Strike where they do not expect, and we can rout them in a single assault." That night he lowered troops over the wall by rope, closed on the enemy camp, and threw them into panic. Those on the walls beat drums and raised a clamor to press the advantage, killing and capturing a great many.
68
退
The Tangut raised siege towers, scaling ladders, and battering rams against the walls. Arrows fell like rain and the engines could not be brought to bear, yet the assault continued day and night without pause. Their chieftain Wusiqi came in armor, hiding behind felt shields, and asked to parley with Zhao. Zhao, in ordinary dress, mounted the ramparts, opened his collar, and called out, "Who is that—so timid in war! If you wanted to see me, here I am. What do you want?" Wusiqi lowered his shield and stepped forward, reciting the Song's broken promises: "Great Jin made a pact with us to attack the capital together. We swore a treaty beneath the walls and drew the river as the boundary. Taiyuan will fall any day. Every fortress in Lin and Fu has already submitted to us. On what do you rely in refusing to surrender?" Zhao said, "The Retired Emperor knows that wicked men led the state astray and has not hesitated to reform. He has already abdicated in favor of a successor, and the Son of Heaven's governance is wholly renewed. Are you alone ignorant of this?" He then produced the abdication edict and the general pardon and read them aloud. The crowd stared in astonishment and admired his courage and eloquence. By then many forts had already surrendered. An old acquaintance of Zhao spoke up from the side: "The empire is finished. Where is there left to show loyalty?" Zhao rebuked him: "You betray your duty to cling to life—you are no better than dogs and swine. How dare you try to tempt me with such talk? I have only death!" He cursed them loudly, drew his bow, and shot at them, and the crowd fled. The siege lasted four days in all. Much of the wall had collapsed, and Zhao used every clever expedient to shore up the defense—all sound in method—yet the fort could no longer hold. Zhao withdrew to the hall, summoned his officers, and said, "The fort is about to fall. Our wives and children must not be defiled by the enemy. First slay my family, then let us fight to the death with our backs to the wall. If we win, we turn east and win great glory; if we lose, our bones will lie exposed within these borders. A man's whole life's business will then be complete." No one answered. Zhao's youngest son was playing on the steps below. Zhao suddenly rose and killed him with his own hand. His eldest son looked up in shock and Zhao killed him too. He then led several soldiers to slaughter the rest of his household, lifted the corpses, and cast them into a well. The deputy commander Jia Zongwang's mother happened to pass by. Zhao rose and called out, "Old lady, you are from my home district. I do not wish to use the blade on you—please throw yourself into the well." The old lady complied, and they covered the well with earth. Officers and soldiers who had wives and children killed them all as well. Zhao said to the men, "You and I are free of all encumbrances now!"
69
A tribesman who had secretly colluded with the enemy reported, "Zhu Zhao and his men have each killed their own families and are about to sally forth. They are few, but every one of them is a man ready to die." The enemy was terrified. They bribed the garrison with rewards and were able to scale the walls. Zhao rallied his men to fight in the main street. From dusk until dawn corpses filled the road until it could not be crossed. Zhao leaped onto a horse and rode out through a breach in the wall. The horse stumbled and fell into the ditch. The enemy exulted, "We have got General Zhu!" They wanted to take him alive. Zhao glared, sword in hand, and not one dared approach. Presently he was struck by an arrow and died. He was forty-six.
70
沿使 '使'
Shi Kang was a native of Jiyuan. At the end of the Xuanhe era, he served as deputy commissioner for frontier pacification of Dai Prefecture. The Jurchens pressed the siege of Dai hard. Kang called his two sons, Jigu and Jizhe, to him at night and said, "I once told those in power, 'Yanmen controls an entire frontier route. Choose a capable commander, strengthen the garrisons, and guard against trouble before it takes shape. If disaster is allowed to flood unchecked, there will be nowhere to turn. My words were urgent, but no one paid me any heed. Now the siege is tight, outside aid will not come, and I have divined by the Liuren method that the city will fall tomorrow. I shall die in the state's service. You too must not let thoughts of wife and children make you fail the state. If you will heed me, have our families take their own lives, and then together we shall meet our righteous end." The two sons wept and said, "We obey only our father's command." The next day the city fell as he had foretold. Father and two sons broke out and fought with all their strength, and died at a corner of the wall.
71
使
Sun Yi—by what means he rose to office is not recorded. At the end of the Xuanhe era, while serving as Observation Commissioner of Fuzhou he was appointed prefect of Shuoning Prefecture and ordered to relieve Taiyuan. The enemy's strength was then at its height. Some advised that he would do better to lead his troops north and strike Yunzhong, where the enemy generals' and soldiers' families lived—the classic strategy of attacking where the foe must surely come to the rescue. Yi said, "That plan is sound, but it would defy the sovereign's command." He leaped onto his horse, broke through the encirclement to the foot of the wall, and died there when Zhang Xiaochun refused to open the gate.
72
Yi was loyal and brave by nature. He regularly spent his own wealth to reward his soldiers and could win their utmost devotion even unto death. When the Xiaorenduo raided the frontier, he dispatched a general to punish them. Yi's son marched with the army. The campaign achieved nothing, and Yi declared that his son ought to have died. When the court heard of this, it granted his orphaned family generous relief and honors. His son sent a messenger to Yi's camp to report that he was safe. Enraged that his son had failed to die, Yi submitted a memorial stating the facts, returned every grant the court had bestowed, and executed the man who had brought the letter.
73
Earlier, while Yi was in Shuoning, he recognized that Sun Gu, a man of the prefecture, was capable. He memorialized to appoint him as an aide and treated him with unusual favor. When Yi marched out, he entrusted the affairs that would follow to Sun Gu. After Yi died, enemy cavalry came to attack, and at the same time a separate appointment was made for a new prefect. The men debated opening the gates to welcome the new appointee. Gu argued in vain and sighed, "I have already pledged myself to the state, and I cannot bear to betray the trust Sun Gong placed in me. Since you will not have me, this is where I shall die." Someone raised a blade to threaten him. He showed no fear and was thereupon killed.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →