← Back to 宋史

卷四百七十二 列傳第二百三十一 姦臣二 蔡京弟:卞 子:攸 翛 族子:崈 趙良嗣 張覺 郭藥師

Volume 472 Biographies 231: Treacherous Officials 2 - Cai Jing and younger brother: Bian, sons: You, Shu, descendant: Chong, Zhao Liangsi, Zhang Jue, Guo Yaoshi

Chapter 472 of 宋史 · History of Song
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 472
Next Chapter →
1
::::
Cai Jing; younger brother, Bian; sons, You and Shu; clansman, Chong; with appended biographies of Zhao Liangsi, Zhang Jue, and Guo Yaoshi
2
調 使
Cai Jing, whose style name was Yuanchang, came from Xianyou in Xinghua prefecture. He earned his jinshi degree in the third year of the Xiuning era, served as sheriff of Qiantang and judicial reviewer in Shuzhou, and rose through several posts to Attendant Gentleman. After returning from a mission to the Liao, he was appointed a drafter in the Central Secretariat. His younger brother Bian was already a drafter. By custom, colleagues entering office were ranked by seniority, but Bian asked to be placed below Jing. The two brothers jointly controlled imperial drafting, and the court regarded it as a mark of honor. He was transferred to Attendant Drafter in the Dragon Diagram Hall and appointed prefect of Kaifeng.
3
使 使
Near the end of the Yuanfeng era, as senior ministers debated the succession, Jing sided with Cai Que and tried to destroy Wang Gui so he could claim credit for settling the question, but failed. When Sima Guang took power and revived the corvée system, he set a five-day deadline. His colleagues protested that it was too harsh, but Jing alone met the deadline and converted hired service in every metropolitan county without exception. He went to the Secretariat to report to Guang, who said delightedly, "If everyone obeyed the law as you do, how could the policy fail?" Soon afterward censors charged that Jing was devious and was undermining the law. He was sent out to govern Chengde, then reassigned to Yingzhou and later transferred to Chengdu. The remonstrator Fan Zuyu argued that Jing should not be employed, so he was made transport commissioner for the Jiang-Huai-Jing-Zhe region and later prefect of Yangzhou. He served in Yun prefecture and Yongxing, was promoted to expositor academician in the Dragon Diagram Hall, and again governed Chengdu.
4
Early in the Shaosheng era he returned to the capital as acting Minister of Revenue. Zhang Dun sought again to change the service law and set up a deliberation office, but debate dragged on without resolution. Jing told Dun, "Simply take the finished Xiuning statutes and enforce them. What is there to debate?" Dun agreed, and the hired-service system was settled at last. Guang and Dun had stood on opposite sides of the corvée and hired-service laws. Within a decade Jing took up the matter again and finished it with ease. The two men leaned on each other to get their way, and perceptive observers could already see their duplicity.
5
When Bian became Right Vice Director, Jing was made a Hanlin academician, concurrent imperial reader, and compiler of the national history. When the Wen Jifu affair broke out, Jing was ordered to pursue it to the end. He arrested the inner attendant Zhang Shiliang, forced him to recount Chen Yan's actions, and immediately secured convictions for treason, while also impeaching Liu Zhi and Liang Tao. Yan was executed, and the other two died in exile as well. Their descendants were all barred from office. Wang Yansou, Fan Zuyu, and Liu Anshi were banished even farther away. Jing coveted real power in government. Zeng Bu, who controlled the Bureau of Military Affairs, resented him and secretly argued that with Bian already in a supporting post, Jing should not be promoted alongside him but only to Hanlin Academician-in-Waiting.
6
殿 殿
Tong Guan went to the lower Yangzi region as a palace supply officer to hunt for rare books, paintings, and curios. He stayed in Hangzhou for months, and Jing kept him company day and night. Every day Guan sent painted screens, fans, belts, and the like into the palace, along with messages that carried Jing's views to the emperor. From this the emperor began to favor Jing. The Imperial University erudite Fan Zhixu was also close to Xu Zhichang, registrar of the Left Avenue, who used ritual water to enter the Yuanfu Rear Hall. Fan cultivated him deeply and told him of Jing's ambitions, saying that nothing important could be done unless Jing became chief minister. Soon palace women and eunuchs were all praising Jing in one voice. Fan Zhixu was promoted to Right Remonstrator, and Jing was recalled to govern Dingzhou. In the first year of Chongning he was transferred to Daming. Han Zhongyan and Zeng Bu were at odds and plotted to bring Jing in as an ally. He was again appointed Hanlin Academician-in-Waiting. Emperor Huizong wished to revive the policies of the Xi and Feng eras. Deng Xunwu, an attendant gentleman, sided with Jing and presented a chart titled "No One Can Help" to show how few allies the reformers still had. Huizong then decided to use Jing. After Zhongyan was dismissed, Jing was made Left Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs and soon replaced Zeng Bu as Right Grand Councilor. On the day of his appointment he was given a seat in the Yanhe Hall. The emperor told him, "Shenzong created new laws and institutions, and my father continued them, yet they were overturned twice and the state's course remains unsettled. I wish to carry out the aims of my father and grandfather. What counsel do you have for me?" Jing kowtowed and pledged to serve unto death. In the first month of the second year he was promoted to Left Grand Councilor.
7
調 仿
Jing had risen from exile, and once he gained power the whole realm watched what he would do. In secret he seized the slogan of "continuing the legacy," constrained the emperor, and, following the old Regulations Office model, set up a Deliberation Office at the Metropolitan Secretariat with himself as superintendent. More than ten allies, including Wu Juho and Wang Hanzhi, served on its staff. Major areas of policy—the imperial clan, redundant offices, state finances, commerce, salt administration, taxation, and local government—were each placed under a trio of directors. Every measure he introduced came out of that office. Following proposals by Feng Xi and Qian Yuzhi, he again deposed the Yuanyou empress. He abolished the civil service examinations and ordered every prefecture and county to adopt the Imperial University's three-college selection system. An outer college was built south of the capital to receive scholars from across the realm. He extended the square-field land survey across the empire. He imposed a state tea monopoly over seven circuits in the Jiang-Huai region, with the government itself acting as trader. He overhauled the salt certificate system and voided every old certificate. Wealthy merchants who had held certificates worth hundreds of thousands of strings were ruined overnight; some drowned themselves or hanged themselves in despair. Zhang Zai, judicial intendant of Huaidong, saw their suffering and memorialized that the new law was harming the people. Jing was furious and stripped him of his post. He then minted ten-cash coins and used the case to implicate all of Zhang Zai's younger brothers. Because censors such as Shen Ji displeased him in handling legal cases, six of them were detained and demoted. Chen Zhenghui, son of Chen Guan, was tattooed and exiled to a coastal island for submitting a memorial.
8
西
In the south he opened Qianzhong and built Jing prefecture. When the Yao of Chenxi rebelled and killed the magistrate of Xupu, Jing offered rich rewards: three hundred bolts of silk and an official rank to anyone who killed a tribal leader, without requiring proof of who had actually rebelled. The prefect of Jingnan, Ma Qi, said, "There are native Yao and Yao living on provincial lands. We do not even know which group has rebelled. If rewards are handed out by the head, innocent people are bound to be killed." Jiang Zhiqi, who controlled the Bureau of Military Affairs, feared to cross Jing and reported that Ma Qi was disloyal to the state. Jing dismissed Ma Qi and sent Shu Dan in his place with orders to exterminate every Yao band. In the west he recovered Huangchuan, Shan, and Kuo and seized the territories of Zangke and Yelang.
9
使
He promoted Tong Guan to a frontier military commissionership, and afterward Yang Jian, Lan Congxi, Tan Zhen, and Liang Shicheng followed the same path. Every provisional appointment was converted into a regular post, until the institutions of the founding emperors had been swept away entirely. He also wanted military power and the loyalty of the officer corps concentrated in his hands. He made Chan, Zheng, Cao, and Gong the Four Supporting prefectures, each with a garrison of twenty thousand men, and appointed his relatives Song Qiaonian and Hu Shiwen as their prefects. Palace guards who had been pressing for a monthly stipend of five hundred cash suddenly had it raised tenfold to secure their loyalty. With power and favor firmly in his grasp, no one inside or outside the court dared criticize him. He rose through several posts to Minister of Works and was enfeoffed as Duke of Jia.
10
祿
Once elevated, Jing grew greedier still. He already drew a grand councilor's salary, yet also claimed the nominal stipend of Minister of Works along with grain, beans, firewood, and attendant rations as before. Although such payments were usually commuted to cash, he insisted on receiving them in kind. He merely filed routine approval memorials, and the emperor never knew.
11
殿 使
By then the Yuanyou ministers had been exiled, demoted, or killed until almost none remained, yet Jing was still unsatisfied. He ordered their offenses ranked, placed Sima Guang at the head, and labeled them the Treacherous Faction. The list was carved in stone at the gate of the Wende Hall, and Jing himself wrote a great stele that was sent to every prefecture. Earlier, after an eclipse at the end of the Yuanfu era, the court had solicited opinions, and many memorials had defended the policies of Xiuning and Shaosheng. Jing then registered Fan Rouzhong and others as a second list of malign officials. In all, 309 men on the two lists had their descendants barred from office in the capital and its vicinity. In the fifth year he was promoted to Minister of Works, Defender-in-Chief with Three-Duke honors, and military commissioner of Anyuan, and his enfeoffment was changed to Duke of Wei.
12
使
Peace had lasted so long that the treasuries overflowed. Jing preached the doctrine of Abundance, Success, Ease, and Greatness, treating offices and wealth like dirt, and the savings of many reigns were squandered. At one grand banquet the emperor brought out jade bowls and goblets and told his chief ministers, "I would like to use these, but I fear people will say it is too extravagant." Jing replied, "When I was envoy to the Khitan, they showed me jade plates and bowls from the Later Jin and boasted that the Song had nothing like them. Using them now for a longevity toast would be perfectly proper." The emperor said, "My father built a small terrace that cost only a few feet of timber, yet he was flooded with remonstrances. I am very afraid of such criticism. These vessels have been finished for a long time. If criticism flares up again, in time no one will remember when they were made." Jing said, "If a matter is reasonable, much talk is nothing to fear. Your Majesty ought to enjoy the tribute of the realm. Why fuss over a few jade vessels?"
13
西 使
In the first month of the fifth year a comet appeared in the west with a tail that stretched across the sky. Because critics attacked the faction stele, the emperor abolished everything Jing had established. Jing was dismissed from office and made Defender-in-Chief with Three-Duke honors and commissioner of the Central Taiyi Palace. His faction secretly worked on his behalf at court, and in the first year of Daguan he was again appointed Left Grand Councilor. When Nandan submitted its territory, he was promoted in one leap to Grand Commandant, received the Eight Treasures, and was made Grand Preceptor.
14
祿 祿 退
In the third year censors and remonstrators joined in denouncing his crimes, and he retired from office. He still supervised compilation of the Veritable Records of Zhezong, was enfeoffed as Duke of Chu, and attended court on the first and fifteenth of each month. The university student Chen Chaolao submitted a follow-up memorial listing fourteen crimes of Jing: blasphemy against Heaven, deceiving ruler and father, building secret patronage networks, treating offices lightly, expanding expenditures, changing laws, reckless innovations, encouraging flattery, silencing remonstrators, inflaming factionalism, encouraging frantic office-seeking, exalting Buddhism and Daoism, exhausting the realm with construction, and boasting of grand foreign campaigns. He begged that Jing be cast into a distant place to ward off evil spirits. When the text circulated, scholars copied it eagerly and treated it as an unofficial veritable record. In the fifth month of the fourth year the comet reappeared between the constellations Kui and Lou. Censor Zhang Kegong charged that during eight years as chief minister Jing's power had shaken the realm, that he squandered state funds with careless rewards, traded offices for private loyalty, used the Directorate of Works to repair his mansion, and commandeered transport barges to ship ornamental stones. He built a pagoda in the name of praying for the emperor's longevity to magnify the mountain at Linping; and under the pretext of irrigating fields he released floodwaters to fulfill the omen embedded in his native place name, Xinghua. His Buddhist name was "Sending Back," and his gate was called "Facing the Capital." The square-field survey harassed people secure in their livelihoods, and the round-earth prisons gathered criminals from relocated prefectures. His disloyalty and misconduct ran to dozens of charges. Earlier the censor-in-chief Shi Gongbi and attending censor Mao Zhu had impeached Jing repeatedly without success. Now he was demoted to Junior Guardian of the Heir Apparent and sent to live in Hangzhou.
15
西 使
In the second year of Zhenghe he was recalled to the capital, resumed assisting government, was enfeoffed as Duke of Lu, and came to the Metropolitan Secretariat every three days to conduct business. After Jing left office, many school officials inside and outside the capital set examination topics drawn from current politics. Su Chou, academic superintendent of Huaidong, sought to curry favor and proposed seizing five years of examination questions to see which candidates had leaned against Jing. More than thirty men lost their posts as a result. Originally, by state regulation every edict was debated by the Secretariat and Chancellery before an academician was ordered to draft it. By the Xiuning era there were handwritten edicts issued from within the palace that bypassed Secretariat and Chancellery review, probably because powerful ministers were manipulating the process in secret. Jing, fearing remonstrance, had secret drafts submitted as imperial brush writings and begged Huizong to copy them out personally. These were called Imperial Brush Handwritten Edicts, and anyone who disobeyed them was punished for violating regulations. Great and small affairs alike were carried out through them, and some did not even sound like the emperor's own writing. No one below dared object. Imperial relatives and favored ministers then competed to obtain such edicts, even having the inner attendant Yang Qiu write them on their behalf, earning the nickname "Writer Yang." Jing disliked this too but could not stop it.
16
He then revised official titles again, renaming the grand councilors as Grand and Junior Chancellors, styling himself Duke Chancellor, and placing all three departments under his control. He posthumously enfeoffed Wang Anshi and Cai Que as kings. Department clerks no longer kept salary quotas straight, fifth-rank posts ran into the hundreds, and some men held more than ten stipends at once. Attending censor Huang Baoguang criticized this and was immediately exiled to Zhaozhou. He promoted his former clerk Wei Bochu to head the Monopoly Bureau. Wei fabricated commodity money certificates worth a million strings and presented them to the throne. Huizong was delighted, showed them to his attendants, and said, "This is the Grand Preceptor's provision stipend for me." He then promoted Bochu to Attendant Drafter in the Huaiyou Hall.
17
使
Jing often told the emperor that the treasury now held a surplus of fifty million strings, enough harmony to expand music, and enough wealth to supply ritual. On that basis he had the Nine Cauldrons cast, the Bright Hall built, the Square Mound repaired, Daoist abbeys established, the "Great Splendor Music" composed, and the Mandate Treasures ordained. He appointed Meng Changling Director of Waterways, excavated the three mountains of Dayi, built the Tiancheng and Shenggong bridges, and launched vast public works employing some four hundred thousand men. The people of the Yellow River valleys were destitute and desperate, yet Jing complacently compared himself to the sage ministers Ji, Qi, the Duke of Zhou, and the Duke of Shao. He also wanted to enlarge the palaces to win the emperor's favor and summoned Tong Guan and four others, hinting at how cramped the inner palace had become. They all obeyed. Each man did what he could and competed to make his projects more lavish, grand, and vast. Work began on Yanfu Palace and the Jinglong River, and eventually the Genyue mound project followed.
18
His sons You, Shu, and Xiu, along with You's son Xing, all rose to Grand Academician and were treated like chief ministers. Tiao married Princess Maode of the imperial house. The emperor visited his mansion seven times and lavished gifts on him beyond reckoning. He was told to sit and pass the wine cup, in a manner that roughly followed family etiquette. Servants held high office, concubines were ennobled as ladies, public opinion turned ever more against him, and even the emperor grew weary of him.
19
使
In the second year of Xuanhe he was ordered to retire from office. In the sixth year, with Zhu Mian paving the way, he was brought back to head all three departments. By then Jing had held power four times. His eyes had failed and he could no longer manage affairs himself, so everything was decided by his youngest son Tao. Whatever Jing was supposed to decide, Tao decided for him and even entered court to report in his place. Whenever he came to court, attendants and lower officials bowed to greet him while he whispered in their ears. Dozens of clerks followed carrying documents. He then pursued illicit profit at will, manipulated power in secret, and abruptly promoted his wife's elder brother Han Liu to Vice Minister of Revenue. Through secret plotting he drove out court officials, created the Xuanhe Treasury Tribute Office, and seized gold, silk, and state reserves from across the realm to fill the emperor's private coffers. Chief ministers Bai Shizhong and Li Bangyan could do nothing but carry out his paperwork, and they could not endure it. His elder brother You also exposed the affair. The emperor was furious and wanted to exile Tao, but Jing begged hard for mercy. Tao was ordered to suspend court attendance and remain at home, while Han Liu was banished to Huangzhou. Soon afterward Tao was stripped of his post as imperial reader and his bestowed jinshi decree was revoked. Jing retired as well. Bai Shizhong and others had memorialized to dismiss Tao in order to undermine Jing, yet Jing showed no intention of leaving. The emperor sent Tong Guan to tell Jing to submit a resignation memorial. When Guan arrived, Jing wept and said, "Why will Your Majesty not keep me on for a few more years? Someone must be slandering me." Guan replied, "I do not know." Jing had no choice but to hand the memorial to Guan. The emperor ordered literary officials to draft three resignation memorials for him and then issued an edict accepting his retirement.
20
覿使
When Emperor Qinzong ascended the throne, the frontier crisis grew daily worse. Jing moved his entire household south in a bid to save himself. The realm condemned Jing as the leader of the Six Traitors. Attending censor Sun Jue and others submitted fierce memorials detailing his crimes. He was made superintendent of the Palace Library at Nanjing, then demoted repeatedly to vice military commissioner of Chongxin and Qingyuan, assigned to Hengzhou, and finally transferred to Shao and Dan. He died at Tanzhou on the way, at the age of eighty.
21
退
Jing was fierce and treacherous by nature, using his wits to manipulate others. Before the throne he schemed constantly to hold his position, always preaching that the court should break free of restrictive custom and exhaust the strength of the entire realm to supply the emperor's pleasures. The emperor knew he was treacherous, dismissed him repeatedly yet brought him back, and even appointed ministers who opposed Jing to restrain him. Whenever he heard he was to be dismissed, he rushed into audience to beg for mercy, kowtowing without a trace of shame left. During the Yan Mountains campaign, Jing sent You a poem that outwardly expressed disapproval, hoping the venture would fail so he could distance himself from it. He forgot righteousness for profit, until brothers were estranged like opposing stars and father and sons were divided like enemy states. In his later years he turned his house into a private court. Office-seekers flocked to his gate, buying posts with bribes and slaves, while law and institutions became empty forms. His fear of losing power knew no bounds. His network of patronage was so deeply rooted that it could not be torn out. He ultimately brought disaster on the dynasty. Though he died in exile on the road, the realm still resented that he had never received proper punishment.
22
He had eight sons. Shu died first; You and Xiu were executed; Tao was exiled to Baizhou and died there; Tiao escaped punishment because he had married an imperial princess; the remaining sons and grandsons were banished to remote prefectures.
23
Younger brother: Bian
24
調簿 殿
Bian, whose style name was Yuandu, passed the civil service examination in the same year as Jing and was appointed registrar of Jiangyin. Wang Anshi gave him a daughter in marriage, and he studied under Wang as a result. During the Yuanfeng era Zhang Zuan recommended him as erudite lecturer of the Imperial University. He became collator in the Hall of Assembled Worthies and lecturer at the Chongzheng Hall, then rose to attendant gentleman and served as associate remonstrance official and attending censor. He did not remain long in any post, resigning each time on grounds of kinship with Wang Anshi, who was then in power. He was appointed drafter in the Central Secretariat and concurrent lecturer, then promoted to supervising censor.
25
使 使
When Emperor Zhezong ascended the throne, he was made Vice Minister of Rites. On a mission to the Liao, the Khitan had already heard of his reputation. Bian happened to be ill with a cold and was ordered carried in a white swift carriage. The protocol officer said, "This is the carriage Your Lordship rides—it is an exceptional courtesy." After returning from his mission he was made attendant drafter in the Dragon Diagram Hall and prefect of Xuanzhou, then transferred to Jiangning and served in Yang, Guang, Yue, Run, and Chen. Guangzhou was crowded with precious goods, yet he took none of them. When he left for Yue, local tribesmen cleared his path and sprinkled rose dew on his robes as a farewell gift.
26
使
In the first year of Shaosheng he again became a Central Secretariat drafter and memorialized, "The late emperor's magnificent virtue and great achievements stand above a thousand ages. To display his glory depends on the historical record. Yet the Veritable Records contain much that is doubtful and unsubstantiated. I beg that they be examined, revised, and republished so that later ages will not be misled." The court approved his request. Bian was appointed concurrent compiler of the National History. Earlier, as Wang Anshi lay dying, he regretted his "Daily Records" and ordered his nephew Fang to burn them. Fang deceitfully substituted other books instead. Now Bian retrieved them from Fang's house and presented them to the throne. He pruned facts, embellished falsehoods, and rewrote the Veritable Records and standard histories he edited. Lü Dagui, Fan Zuyu, Zhao Yanruo, and Huang Tingjian were all severely punished as a result. He was promoted to Hanlin academician.
27
In the fourth year he became Left Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs. He relied wholly on the slogan of "continuing the legacy," deceiving the emperor above and intimidating his colleagues below. Whenever he wanted to destroy a good official, he first submitted a secret memorial and then asked the emperor to issue a personal brush edict for enforcement. Even Zhang Dun, great traitor though he was, still fell within Bian's manipulations. Dun was rash and unthinking, while Bian was secretive and taciturn. In deliberations Dun would speak boldly and take charge, while Bian sometimes remained silent. Contemporaries said Dun's actions were easy to see through, but Bian's intentions were hard to discern.
28
' ' 殿
When Emperor Huizong ascended the throne, remonstrators Chen Guan and Ren Boyu and censor Gong Fu memorialized against the brothers' crimes. Guan also charged Bian with honoring a private history in a way that offended the ancestral temple. Boyu said, "Bian's wickedness surpasses Dun's. Last year thousands of sealed memorials demanded the execution of Dun and Bian. Public opinion could hardly be clearer." He then listed six great crimes: "First, falsely denying the merit of Empress Xuanren Shengle and seeking her posthumous deposition; second, all exiles since the Shaosheng era were proposed by Bian before they were carried out; third, when palace sorcery cases arose and Zhezong was uncertain what to do, Dun wanted ritual officials consulted, but Bian said, "They have already broken the law. Why consult ritual officials?" The empress was condemned on that account; fourth, compiling Yuanyou memorials into slanderous indictments that condemned thousands, a plan that came from Bian; fifth, when Zou Hao offended the throne with his words, Bian enraged Zhezong and had him exiled far away, then sought to punish relatives and friends who saw him off; sixth, when Jian Xuchen proposed a review and appeal bureau, Zhang Dun hesitated, but Bian accused him of divided loyalty until Dun dared not answer. The bureau was established that same day, and 830 households of scholar-officials were condemned. All of this was plotted by Bian and carried out by Dun. I beg that proper punishment be applied at once to satisfy the realm." He was demoted to academician of the Hall for Assisting Governance and prefect of Jiangning, then further to junior supervisor of the Palace Workshops and superintendent at Chizhou.
29
使 祿 西
After little more than a year he was recalled to govern Daming, transferred to Yangzhou, summoned as commissioner of the Central Taiyi Palace, and promoted to control the Bureau of Military Affairs. Jing was then chief minister. Bian declined the post on grounds of propriety, but was not allowed to refuse. The emperor planned to recover Huang and Shan and asked Bian whom to use. Bian recommended Wang Hou and Gao Yongnian. Together with Jing he exhausted the treasuries for frontier campaigns, hired merchants to transport grain, and no longer asked what price they charged. In Shan and Kuo grain reached four thousand cash per dou and fodder twelve hundred per bundle. The Qin region was thrown into turmoil. When the three prefectures were taken, Bian was promoted to Grandee of the Golden Girdle and Purple Clarity, but Yongnian was eventually seized under his command and forced to surrender. From then on fighting on the western frontier continued year after year. Nursing a grudge against Ren Boyu's accusations, he twisted matters to justify himself. He even tried to open a joint trial to prove his case, and many men were demoted as a result.
30
西使 殿
Bian was devious at heart and regarded everything his father-in-law Wang Anshi had done as absolutely correct. His elder brother had risen late yet ranked above him, preventing Bian from becoming chief minister himself. Their policies in the two departments therefore sometimes clashed. Jing used an inner-court order to appoint Tong Guan Shaanxi commissioner. Bian said eunuchs should not be used. Right Vice Director Zhang Kangguo cited Li Xian as a precedent. Bian replied, "Even Li Xian was a bad choice, and he at least knew something of warfare. Guan has almost no talent and will surely ruin frontier strategy in time." The emperor ordered the Secretariat to proceed anyway. Jing slandered Bian before the emperor. Bian asked to resign and was made grand academician of the Hall for Assisting Governance and prefect of Henan.
31
殿使
When the sorcerer Zhang Huai Su was exposed, it came out that Bian had long associated with him, claiming his arts were divine and that he had known Confucius and Emperor Gaozu of Han, even calling them great masters. Bian was demoted for this. Soon he was made academician of the Hall for Viewing Literature, military commissioner of Zhaoqing, imperial reader, junior guardian with Three-Duke honors, and then transferred to the eastern commission.
32
使 使
At the end of the Zhenghe era he asked leave to return home and visit his ancestral tomb. He died on the road at the age of sixty. He was posthumously made Grand Preceptor with the posthumous title Wenzheng, "Correct in Culture." When Emperor Gaozong ascended the throne, he was posthumously demoted to vice military commissioner of Ningguo. In the fifth year of Shaoxing he was demoted again to vice training commissioner of Danzhou.
33
Son: You
34
殿 殿使
In the third year of Chongning he was granted jinshi status from his post as Honglu assistant, appointed secretary gentleman, and within two years rose to associate academician of the Bureau of Military Affairs while compiling the "Institutional Essentials of Our Dynasty." When Jing returned to power, You was made Dragon Diagram Hall academician and imperial reader, directed revision of the "Gazetteer of the Nine Regions," supervised compilation of the "Six Canons," and headed the Shangqing Precious Register Palace, the Secretariat's two Daoist registrar offices, and the Ritual Regulations Bureau. The Daoist and historical offices together numbered a hundred men, mostly talented scholars from the Three Halls. Yet You, a great minister's son, led them though he knew nothing of learning, and scholarly opinion rejected him. When the Xuanhe Hall was first established, he was made Grand Academician, granted a square gold belt with ball pattern, and appointed military commissioner of Huaikang.
35
使 使
When the emperor was about to dismiss Jing, he first expelled his allies Liu Bing and Liu Huan and had censor-in-chief Wang Anzhong impeach them. You had access to the inner palace. Hearing of the move, he urgently requested a private audience and kowtowed a hundred times in plea until the emperor relented. Afterward his power clashed daily with Jing's. Shallow men sowed division between them, father and son each built his own faction, and they became enemies. You lived in a separate imperial mansion. Once he visited Jing while Jing was talking with a guest and had the guest withdraw. As soon as You entered, Jing rose abruptly, took his father's hand as if to feel his pulse, and said, "Father, your pulse is calm and slow. Are you feeling unwell?" Jing said, "No." You said, "There is urgent business in the palace." He then left at once. A guest who had been watching in secret asked Jing about it. Jing said, "You do not understand this at all — the boy wants people to think I am sick so he can have me dismissed." Within a few days, Jing did in fact retire. Because his youngest brother Tao was Jing's favorite, You repeatedly asked that he be killed, but the Emperor refused.
36
使 殿
You rose through the ranks to Commissioner with the Staff Equal to the Three Excellencies, Military Commissioner of the Zhenhai Army, and Junior Guardian. He could see the Emperor at any hour and grew ever more powerful. He and Wang Fu were let into the palace's private entertainments; at informal banquets they wore short jackets and tight trousers, painted their faces green and red, mixed with singers, acrobats, and dwarfs, and filled the air with lewd street banter meant to bewitch the Emperor. His wife Lady Song moved freely in the inner palace; his son Xing headed the Palace Domestic Service and was treated like a chief minister. Favor and trust for them exceeded even what Jing himself enjoyed. The Emperor was drawn to Daoist doctrine, and You alone peddled marvels — pearl stars and jade moons, phoenix-riding and dragon-mounting, heavenly books written in cloud script — and debated matters of divine transformation with masters such as Lin Lingsu. Temples to the Divine Empyrean and Jade Purity then sprang up across the empire. The roots of disaster began with You.
37
涿涿 退
When Tong Guan marched against Yan, You was made deputy pacification commissioner. He was childish, foolish, and knew nothing of statecraft. He thought glory could be seized as easily as snapping his fingers. On the day he departed, two beautiful consorts stood at the Emperor's side. You pointed to them and said, "When I return victorious, I ask that these be my reward." The Emperor laughed and did not reprove him. Guo Yaoshi, garrison commander of Zhuozhou, brought his eight thousand men to surrender Zhuo and Yi prefectures, and You was promoted to Junior Tutor. When the imperial army entered Yan, he was made Junior Preceptor and enfeoffed as Duke of Ying. On his return he took charge of the Bureau of Military Affairs. After Wang Fu fell from power, the Emperor meant to give You great authority, then changed his mind and only promoted him to Grand Guardian, changing his title to Duke of Yan. The Emperor wished to abdicate in favor of the heir apparent and personally wrote the words "Transfer the throne to the Eastern Palace," handing the note to Li Bangyan. Bangyan stepped back and would not take it, so it was passed to You instead. You withdrew and entrusted the matter to his client Wu Min, a Supervising Secretary, and the plan was settled.
38
Son: Shu
39
殿
Shu first entered office by imperial favor as Attendant of the Imperial Guard and Secretary, and rose to Academician of the Hall of Preservation and Harmony. In the Xuanhe reign he was appointed Minister of Rites and Palace Lecturer. By then Shu and his brothers could see that the times were turning against them. His clients Fu Moqing, Sun Fu, and others urged him again: "The empire is doomed to collapse, the Cai clan is doomed to fall — you must act at once." Shu agreed in his heart and secretly consulted with You, gradually taking more upright positions, and so came to differ from Jing. Yet they all shrank back and dared not speak plainly, and so brought in Wu Min, Li Gang, Li Guang, Yang Shi, and others to win back public opinion. He was soon made Grand Academician and put in charge of the Shrine of Sweet Springs.
40
西西 殿 使
When Emperor Qinzong came to the throne, Shu submitted a plan to raise troops in Shaanxi, asked to lead it himself, and urged the court to move west. The Emperor largely accepted his advice and appointed him governor of the Capital Prefecture. Just as the plan was nearing success, You, jealous that Shu would win credit, took advantage of the Jin capture of Junzhou and Huizong's flight south. Invoking Huizong's authority, he had Shu posted to guard Zhenjiang and changed his title to Grand Academician of the Hall for Aid in Governance. Some advised Shu that his earlier plan had already failed and that he should not go. Shu was only too glad to leave and raised no objection. Rumors reached the capital that he would restore Huizong to power at Zhenjiang. The Emperor urgently ordered Huizong brought back and demoted Shu to Vice Military Commissioner of the Zhaoxin Army.
41
When You was executed, Censor Chen Shu was about to carry out the edict when the Emperor took it and wrote at the end, "The same for Shu." Both were then executed.
42
Clan nephew: Chong
43
Chong was a clansman of Jing's. By nature he was arrogant and eccentric, and skilled at talk of spirits and demons. When he was due to inherit office by family privilege, he firmly yielded the place to his elder half-brother, and the clan praised him as virtuous. At the start of the Chongning reign, Jing's faction commended him to the court for cultivated learning and conduct. He and the commoner Lu Zhu of Quanzhou both wore Daoist robes. Summoned to court, he rose through successive posts until he was appointed Supervising Secretary and Imperial Reader.
44
殿
When Jing left office, critics attacked him, and Chong was made Gentleman Consultant of the Hall of Manifest Counsel and put in charge of the Shrine of Blessings and Prosperity. Critics again accused him of being unlearned and uncultured, of consorting with powerful locals for profit, of offering Daoist breathing techniques as counsel to the throne, and of standing in attendance in the Hall of Assembled Excellence with eyes closed as if at ease — conduct deemed disrespectful. His office was then stripped from him. Chen Zhenghui reported Jing's crimes, and a case was opened in the capital. He testified that while in Hangzhou he had daily heard Chong declare at length that Jing would yet enjoy great fortune. When the case was submitted, an edict removed Chong from the official rolls. When Jing returned as chief minister, Huizong warned that Chong must not be used, but restored him only as Compiler of the Hall of Assembled Excellence. He soon regained his Gentleman Consultant title and was put in charge of the Cave of Heaven Abode. He died in the Xuanhe reign.
45
Zhao Liangsi
46
祿 使 使 漿 殿
Zhao Liangsi was originally Ma Zhi of Yan. His family had for generations been a great clan of the Liao state, and he rose to Grandee for Splendid Happiness. His conduct was foul and his household chaotic, and respectable people would not associate with him. At the start of the Zhenghe reign, Tong Guan went on a mission and passed Lugou Bridge. Zhi visited his attendant by night, saying on his own that he had a plan to destroy Yan, and thereby gained an audience. Tong Guan spoke with him and was greatly impressed. He brought him back and changed his name to Li Liangsi. Recommended to court, he at once submitted a plan: "The Jurchens hate the Liao to the bone, while Tianzuo is dissolute and has lost the Way. If our dynasty sends envoys from Deng and Lai across the sea to befriend the Jurchens and join them in attacking Liao, that state can be taken." Critics replied that although this route had existed since the time of the founding ancestors, the region bordered foreign peoples and merchant shipping had been forbidden there for more than a hundred years. To reopen it now, they feared, would not serve China's interests. Huizong summoned him and asked why he had come. He answered, "The Liao state is doomed to fall. Your Majesty, moved by the suffering of the old subjects, should restore China's former borders, punish evil in Heaven's name, and use order to overthrow chaos. When the imperial army marches forth, the people will surely come out with food and drink to welcome it. If by any chance the Jurchens prevail, he who strikes first controls others, while he who strikes later is controlled by others — the outcomes would not be the same." The Emperor praised and accepted the plan, granted him the surname Zhao, and appointed him Secretary. From this the plan to take Yan began. He was transferred to Direct Associate of the Dragon Diagram Hall, put in charge of the Shrine of Ten Thousand Longevities, and made Compiler of the Hall of Right Literature.
47
使 使 殿祿
In the second month of the second year of Xuanhe, he was sent as envoy to the Jin state, met their ruler Aguda, and negotiated the recovery of Yan and Yun. When the mission returned, he was promoted to Gentleman Consultant of the Hall of Manifest Strategy. From then on he carried out imperial missions six or seven times, pleading earnestly and arguing hard with the Jin. He was promoted to Direct Academic of the Dragon Diagram Hall. Once Yanshan had been taken, he was further made Academic of the Hall of Extended Tranquility and put in charge of the Upper Clarity Palace, rising to Grandee of Splendid Happiness.
48
使'退 '
Liangsi said, "Not long ago in the northern state I swore brotherhood with three like-minded men — the gallant men of Yan, Liu Fan and Li Shang, and my clansman Rouji — intending to wrest You and Ji back to the court. We poured wine at the shrine of the North Pole and prayed Heaven to witness our oath: when success came one day, we would at once resign and retire, to show our true hearts. We never sought fame or fortune in the first place. Thanks to Your Majesty's majesty, today's success has come together — yet how can I break the oath of former days? I beg to be allowed to retire, to buy fields and return to farming, so that men of discernment may say, 'The man who first plotted the pacification of Yan has been granted a quiet withdrawal — a fine thing for all under Heaven.' Otherwise, if your servant dares deceive the spirits, what would I not dare to do?' He submitted three memorials in all, but an edict refused his request. Soon afterward the court accepted Zhang Jue. Liangsi objected, saying, "The state has just allied with the Jin. If we do this we will surely lose their goodwill, and later we will not be able to undo it." The court did not listen. For this he was stripped of office and demoted five ranks.
49
使 西使
In the fourth month of the first year of Jingkang, Censor Hu Shunzhi argued that he had created border troubles, ruined a century of good relations with the Khitans, brought Jin invaders down upon the realm, and spread calamity across China. He asked that Liangsi be executed in the marketplace. He had already been banished to Chenzhou. An edict ordered Li Shengzhi, Vice Transport Commissioner of Guangxi, to behead him wherever he was found, and his wife and children were exiled to Wanan Prefecture.
50
使 使
Zhang Jue was a native of Yifeng in Ping Prefecture. He had passed the highest examinations in the Liao state and served as Vice Military Commissioner of the Liaoxing Army. The townspeople killed their Military Commissioner Xiao Dili. Jue comforted those who had restored order, and the people of the prefecture urged him to take charge of its affairs. When Prince Chun of Yan died, Jue knew the Liao was doomed. He registered fifty thousand able-bodied men and a thousand horses and drilled troops in preparation. Empress Xiao sent Shi Li'ai to govern the prefecture, but Jue refused to accept him.
51
使 使 使
When the Jurchens entered Yan, they asked the former Liao minister Kang Gongbi about Jue's situation. Gongbi said, "What can he do? We should show him we do not suspect him." Jue was therefore made Military Commissioner of the Linhai Army and charged with governing Ping Prefecture. The Liao chancellor Zuo Qigong and others were about to return east. Nianhan wanted first to send troops to seize Jue. Gongbi said, "That would only drive him to rebel. Let me go as envoy and see for myself." He then went to see Jue. Jue said, "The Khitan Eight Circuits have all fallen; only Ping Prefecture remains. How would I dare harbor a different intent? The reason I have not yet laid down my arms is only to guard against Xiao Gan." He bribed Gongbi heavily and sent him back. Gongbi reported his words. Nianhan believed him, elevated Ping Prefecture to Southern Capital, and made Jue Associate Grand Counselor. Qigong, Gongbi, Cao Yongyi, and Yu Zhongwen all moved eastward.
52
西 西
At that time the people of Yan were being relocated en masse and wandered destitute along the roads. Some came to Jue to plead, "Gongbi, Qigong, and the rest could not hold Yan and have reduced our people to this. Who but you can deliver us?" Jue summoned his staff to consult. All said, "We have lately heard that Tianzuo has revived in Songmo. The reason the Jurchens hurry west toward Shanxi is that they fear the Khitans will strike from behind. If you uphold great righteousness, welcome the former ruler to plan restoration, charge Qigong and the others with their crimes and execute them, and let the people of Yan return to Yan, the Southern Court ought not to refuse them. If the Jurchens come from the west, using the troops of Ying and Ping within and borrowing aid from the Southern Court without, what is there to fear?" Jue also consulted Hanlin Academician Li Shi, who agreed. Thereupon he killed Qigong and three others, restored the reign title to the third year of Bao Da, painted Tianzuo's portrait in the main hall, and reported every matter to it before acting. He summoned the elders and told them, "The Jurchens are our enemies — how can we follow them?" Pointing to the portrait, he said, "Is this not your lord? How can you betray him? Let us covenant to die together; if there is no other choice, then return to China." The people of Yan valued righteousness and all followed him in admiration. He then sent all the relocated people back.
53
使 西 西
Shi changed his name to An Bi and, together with the former Commissioner of the Three Departments Gao Dang, went to Yanshan to persuade Wang Anzhong. He said, "Ping Prefecture has since antiquity been a strategic region — its territory spans several hundred li, with more than a hundred thousand troops under arms. Jue is a man of complete civil and military talent. If we put him to our use, he can surely shield and buttress the throne. If we do not, he may welcome Tianzuo from the west and link with Xiao Gan in the north, and become a trouble at our very elbow." Wang Anzhong strongly agreed, reported fully to court, offered to bear the responsibility himself, and ordered An Bi and Dang to proceed to the capital. Huizong handed a personal note to Zhan Du, saying, "Our dynasty and the Jin state are on terms of friendship, and our sworn pledge is weighty indeed. How can we be the first to break it? The Jin had not attacked Jue immediately because their troops were tied down in Guanzhong while Jue held Yuguan Pass. Now that they have moved east, if they return west another day, Jue's few small cities may not be easy to defend. For now the best policy is quietly to show restraint and keep him on a leash." Yet Du repeatedly enticed him and hinted that he should submit to the Song.
54
使
In the sixth month of the fifth year of Xuanhe, Jue wrote to the Pacification Commission, "The Jin rely on brute force, driving the wealthy families of Yanjing into exile and leaving only empty cities to satisfy the treaty. When I think of the great court, I know this was not without reason. Displaced people passed through our territory, and cries of grief filled the roads. The people could not endure it and agreed to resist the enemy, preserve the living, restore their homeland, and prepare defenses for the great court. I have already sent them across the border and respectfully dispatch Recorder Zhang Jun and Staff Officer Zhang Dun'gu to the Pacification Commission for orders."
55
退 使
When the Jin learned of Jue's rebellion, they sent the Prince of Zhamu with three thousand cavalry to attack. Jue met them at Yingzhou. Zhamu, finding his force too small, withdrew without fighting and wrote on the gate, "We shall return this winter." Jue falsely reported a great victory. The court made Ping into Taiping Army, appointed Jue military commissioner, made An Bi, Dang, Jun, and Dun'gu attendants in the Huaiyou Hall, and the Pacification Commission rewarded them with tens of thousands in silver and silk. When the edict arrived, Jue rejoiced and went far out to meet it. Jin spies learned of this and marched against him. Jue could not return and fled to Yan with his younger brother, carrying the edicts he had received. His mother and wife had been staying at Yingzhou and were captured by the Jin. Hearing this, his brother hurried to surrender and handed over the edicts. The Jin besieged Ping Prefecture while Jue's cousins and nephews held out. The Jin accused them of harboring a rebel and demanded supplies. After months of assault, thousands of townspeople broke out and fled rather than surrender.
56
使
After the Jin pacified the two prefectures, they demanded Jue. Wang Anzhong concealed him. As the demand grew more urgent, he beheaded a look-alike and sent the head. The Jin said, "This is not Jue. Jue is hidden in Commissioner Wang's armory. If you do not hand him over, I shall take him by force." Anzhong had no choice but to produce Jue, recite his crimes, and execute him. Jue spoke with shocking insolence. After his death they sent his head in a box. Yan's surrendered generals and the Ever-Victorious Army wept. Guo Yaoshi said, "If they come for me next, what then?" From that moment morale collapsed, and the Jin ultimately used the affair to justify war.
57
Guo Yaoshi
58
使 涿
Guo Yaoshi came from Tiezhou in Bohai. As Liao was collapsing, the Prince of Yan Chun recruited starving people of eastern Liao to strike at the Jurchen, calling them the "Grievance Army." Yaoshi was their leader. The next year two camps rebelled, and Yaoshi killed the rebel leader Luo Qing. Commander Xiao Gan kept two thousand men in four camps under Yaoshi, Zhang Linghui, Liu Shunren, and Zhen Wuchen. Chun declared himself ruler in Yan, renamed the Grievance Army the Ever-Victorious Army, and promoted Yaoshi to general-in-chief of the guards and garrison commander of Zhuozhou. After Chun died, Empress Xiao took power, Xiao Gan dominated the court, and the realm grew disloyal.
59
涿使 使使 使
In the ninth month of the fourth year of Xuanhe, Yaoshi brought his eight thousand men and the prefectures of Zhuo and Yi in submission. He was appointed observation commissioner of Enzhou. When the imperial army marched north, Liu Yanqing faced Gan at Lugou. Yaoshi said, "Gan has committed his whole army to us, so Yan must be empty. Send crack cavalry in a surprise strike and we can take it." Yanqing sent Yaoshi and other generals with six thousand men. They crossed the river at midnight and marched at forced pace. At dawn Zhen Wuchen led five thousand cavalry through the Yingchun Gate. The main army followed with orders to accept Yan submissions but slaughter all Khitan and other barbarians. Yaoshi urged Empress Xiao to surrender quickly. She secretly ordered Xiao Gan back to fight at the Three Markets. Yaoshi lost his horse and was nearly captured, then retreated in defeat, yet was still promoted to pacification commissioner of Anyuan. In the twelfth month he was appointed military commissioner of Wutai. In the first month of the fifth year he was made junior guardian with the rank and associate prefect of Yanshan.
60
使 殿 使使
He was summoned to court. Huizong treated him with exceptional honor and gave him a fine mansion and concubines. He staged water games at the Jinming Pool for him to watch and ordered nobles and ministers to host banquets in turn. He summoned him again to the Yanchun Hall in the rear garden. Yaoshi kowtowed and wept, saying, "When I was among the barbarians, I heard the Song emperor was like a god in Heaven. I never expected to see your face today." The emperor praised him warmly and entrusted Yan to him. He replied, "I am willing to die in your service." He also ordered him to capture Tianzuo to destroy Yan hopes of restoration. Yaoshi's face changed and he said, "Tianzuo was my former lord. When the state fell he fled, and that is why I surrendered. If Your Majesty orders me to die elsewhere, I dare not refuse. But to make me turn against my former lord is not how I should serve you. Please give the task to someone else." He wept profusely. The emperor took this as loyalty, removed his own pearl robe and two gold basins, and gave them to him. When Yaoshi left, he told his men, "This honor is not mine alone. It is yours." He immediately cut up the basins and distributed the pieces among them. He was made junior tutor with the rank and returned to his post.
61
When Xiao Gan raided the frontier, Yaoshi defeated him at Feng Mountain, captured Alu Taishi alive, and seized the sword tally and gilded seal bearing the honorific title of Emperor Taizong of Liao. Gan was soon killed by his own men. For his merit he was made grand tutor with the rank.
62
貿
At first Wang Anzhong governed Yanshan, with Zhan Du and Yaoshi as associate prefects. Yaoshi, holding a military commission, wanted precedence over Du. Du cited an order in the emperor's own brush writing, but Yaoshi refused to obey. The Ever-Victorious Army also ran wild with Yaoshi's support, and Du could not control them, so he reported to court. Fearing open conflict, the court swapped Du with Cai Jing of Hejian. When Jing arrived he treated Yaoshi openly, and Yaoshi respected him and restrained himself somewhat. Anzhong only flattered him, and the court indulged his every request. He stockpiled fine armor, sent retainers to trade along other routes, and presented ingenious curios to powerful nobles and eunuchs, so praise of him spread daily at court. He ruled the circuit as his own domain, raised his force to a claimed three hundred thousand men, and still dressed in the Jurchen style. Court opinion grew alarmed. He was soon made Grand Commandant and summoned to court, but refused to come.
63
耀 使使使
The emperor sent Tong Guan to tour the frontier and secretly observe his intentions, or if necessary bring him back by force. When Guan reached Yan, Yaoshi welcomed him at Yizhou and bowed twice before his tent. Guan stepped aside and said, "You are Grand Commandant now, equal in rank to us. Why this ceremony?" Yaoshi replied, "Grand Preceptor, you are like a father to me. I bow only to my father. What do I know of anything else?" Guan was appeased. He then invited Guan to review his troops in open country where no one else was in sight. Yaoshi dismounted and waved a banner before him. In an instant iron cavalry blazed on four mountains, beyond counting. Guan and his party were stunned. On returning he told the emperor that Yaoshi could surely resist the barbarians, and Cai You strongly backed him from within. A Jin envoy returning from the Tianning Festival saw Yaoshi's troops on the road and reined in his horse to give way. Local soldiers sometimes seized their sheep and carts with spears, yet none dared resist. Memorials praised Yaoshi's far-reaching reputation. You increasingly argued he could be trusted, and the interior ceased guarding against him. Repeated reports of rebellion and intercepted letters to the Jin were ignored.
64
使 使 使
In the twelfth month of the seventh year Zhan Du memorialized, "Yaoshi's gaze is unsettled and his intentions suspect. With wasp eyes and a crow's beak, he relies on favor and merit. Rebellion is already budding and his violence grows daily. I now hear he is in league with the Jin and has turned against the court. Disaster is near. I beg the court to act early." The court finally ordered an investigation, but Jin troops had already marched south, taken Tan and Ji, and reached Yutian. Cai Jing sent Yaoshi, Zhang Linghui, and Liu Shunren to resist the invaders. That evening Linghui fled. Jing and the envoys went to consult Yaoshi, who wished to surrender. Jing said, "I have sworn to die for the state. What talk is this?" He drew his dagger to kill himself. Yaoshi seized him and locked all the envoys in his house. When Wolibu reached the suburbs, Yaoshi led his officers out to welcome him and then followed him south. When news of the betrayal arrived, the emperor still kept it secret and discussed making him Prince of Yan with hereditary territory—but it was already too late.
65
When Wolibu reached Qingyuan and heard the emperor had abdicated, he wanted to turn back. Yaoshi said, "The Southern Court may not be ready. Better to press on for now." Afterward, as the Jin hesitated before the capital, demanded palace offices, and seized precious vessels and ornaments, Yaoshi guided them in everything.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →