← Back to 宋書

卷七 本紀第七 前廢帝

Volume 7 Annals 7: Emperor Fei I

Chapter 7 of 宋書 · Book of Song
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 7
Next Chapter →
1
Emperor Fei I was named Ziye; his childhood name was Fashi. He was Emperor Xiao Wu's eldest son. He was born on jiashen day in the first month of the twenty-sixth year of Yuanjia. While the future Emperor Xiao Wu held Xunyang, Ziye stayed behind in the capital. In the thirtieth year, when the emperor marched in to punish the assassin prince, Ziye was held prisoner in the attendants' sub-bureau; more than once he was nearly executed, yet in the end escaped unharmed.
2
[1]殿
After Emperor Xiao Wu succeeded, Ziye was made crown prince. At first he had not yet moved into the Eastern Palace, so his tutors and the two palace guard commandants all took up duty at Yongfu Palace instead. In the second year of Daming he took up residence in the Eastern Palace. [1] In the fourth year he heard lectures on the Classic of Filial Piety in Chongzheng Hall. In the seventh year he underwent the coming-of-age ceremony.
3
[2]
On gengshen day in the intercalary fifth month of the eighth year Emperor Xiao Wu died, and the crown prince succeeded that same day. A general amnesty was proclaimed throughout the realm. Grand Preceptor Liu Yigong, Prince of Jiangxia, stepped down as Director of the Masters of Writing and was named Supervisor of the Masters of Writing; General of Agile Cavalry Liu Yuanjing was appointed Director of the Masters of Writing. On jiazi day the post of Recorder of the Masters of Writing was created, and Grand Preceptor Liu Yigong, Prince of Jiangxia, was made Recorder of Masters of Writing Affairs. General of Agile Cavalry Liu Yuanjing was granted the privilege of an office equal to the Three Dukes. Liu Ziren, Prince of Yongjia and Administrator of Danyang, was appointed Inspector of Southern Yuzhou. [2] (End of note.)
4
[3][4] 貿 便
On xinwei day in the sixth month an edict declared: "Though my person is slight, I have long since inherited the great enterprise, reverently wielding Heaven's majesty and facing the sacred mandate with awe. Following the settled order of my forebears and taking past models as my daily guide, I might truly have folded my hands in silence, guarded what was already won, and let good customs endure for generations. Yet the throne has only just been announced and the realm has only just changed hands; my virtue is not yet clear, and I am still blind to the Great Way. I mean to proclaim a wise standard and extend this simple compassion—let every responsible office be consulted and the people's hidden hardships investigated in detail. Tortuous ordinances and secret statutes burden government; [3] market tolls and lease taxes meant for a moment's need are twisted by corrupt clerks who manipulate the written law and wield power arbitrarily, while the qi and celestial signs fall out of alignment [4] and bias and excess grow worse by the day. Corvée and punishments should be eased and lightened to relieve the people's urgent distress. The various offices of the imperial household need not be numerous; carved inscriptions and seal-cut ornament have no place today. All alike should be merged and cut back, to answer the people's wishes. Princely trade in goods is forbidden altogether. Outside the capital, let detailed lists be prepared and reported to the throne." On wuyin day Huainan Commandery in Yuzhou was restored as Nanliang Commandery, and Xuancheng was split off again to re-establish Huainan Commandery. On gengchen day Yuan Tanyuan, Administrator of Nanhai, was appointed Inspector of Guangzhou.
5
西 使
On jihai day in the seventh month of autumn, Liu Zixun, Prince of Jin'an, General Who Pacifies the Army and Inspector of Yongzhou, was reassigned as Inspector of Jiangzhou; Central Army Guard Zong Que became General Who Pacifies the West and Inspector of Yongzhou; Liu Yu, Prince of Xiangdong, General Who Pacifies the North and Inspector of Xuzhou, became General Who Protects the Army; and Liu Chang, Prince of Yiyang, General of the Central Army, became General Who Conquers the North and Inspector of Xuzhou. On gengxu day the state of Pohuang sent envoys bearing tribute. The Honored Empress Dowager was elevated to Grand Empress Dowager, and the empress to Empress Dowager. On yimao day the northern and southern imperial speedways were abolished. Institutions changed since the Xiaojian era were restored to the Yuanjia standard. On bingchen day the late Consort Xian was posthumously honored as Empress Xian. On yichou day Liu Ziluan, Prince of Xin'an, General Who Pacifies the Army and Inspector of Southern Xuzhou, was relieved of his concurrent post as Minister over the Masses.
6
[5] [6] [7]
On dingmao day in the eighth month, General Who Protects the Army Wang Xuamo was appointed General Who Pacifies the North and Inspector of Qing and Ji provinces. [5] On jisi day Xiao Hui Kai, Inspector of Qing and Ji provinces, was appointed Inspector of Yizhou. On jichou day [6] the Empress Dowager died. Prolonged rain fell in the capital region. On gengyin day [7] censors were sent out with office heads to give relief wherever it was needed.
7
祿
On xinchou day in the ninth month, Liu Yu, Prince of Xiangdong, General Who Protects the Army, was made chief General Who Protects the Army. On guimao day Liu Zunkao, Left Vice Director of the Masters of Writing, was promoted to Special Advance and Right Grand Master for Splendid Happiness. On yimao day Empress Wenmu was enshrined at the Jingning tomb.
8
[8]
On jiaxu day in the tenth month of winter, Liu Xiuren, Prince of Jian'an and Minister of Ceremonies, was appointed General Who Protects the Army. On wuyin day Zong Yue, General Who Assists the State, was appointed Inspector of Sizhou. [8] On gengchen day overdue rents from the seventh year of Daming in Yang and Southern Xuzhou were remitted.
9
[9]
On yiyou day in the twelfth month, Yan Shibo, Right Vice Director of the Masters of Writing, was confirmed as Vice Director of the Masters of Writing. [9] On renchen day the commanderies of the capital region were made Yang Province, and Yang Province was renamed Eastern Yang Province. On guisi day Liu Zishang, Prince of Yuzhang, General of Chariots and Cavalry and Inspector of Yang Province, was appointed Minister over the Masses while retaining Yang Province.
10
In the previous year and again this year the eastern commanderies suffered severe drought; in the worst-hit districts a sheng of grain cost several hundred cash, and even in the capital the price rose above a hundred; six or seven out of every ten people starved to death. Since the Xiaojian era mints had also been set up to cast coin, which led the people to counterfeit it in turn; the currency grew ever smaller and more debased, and commerce ground to a halt.
11
On yiwei day, the first of the first month of spring in the first year of Yongguang, the reign title was changed. A general amnesty was proclaimed throughout the realm. On yisi day the provincial relay stations were abolished. On wuwu day Liu Yu, Prince of Xiangdong, was made General of the Guard and Inspector of Southern Yuzhou; Liu Xiuren, Prince of Jian'an, became chief General Who Protects the Army; Liu Xiuyou, Prince of Shanyang and Supervisor of the Masters of Writing, was appointed Inspector of Yuzhou; Liu Xiufan, Prince of Guiyang, became Central Army Guard; and Liu Zifang, Prince of Xunyang, was transferred from Southern Yuzhou to Eastern Yang Province.
12
祿 [10]
On yichou day in the second month, the field stipends of provinces, commanderies, and counties were cut in half. [10] On gengyin day two-zhu coins were cast.
13
On jiachen day in the third month, Linjiang Commandery was abolished.
14
On jihai day in the fifth month, Sui Commandery in Yingzhou was transferred to Yongzhou. On bingwu day Zhang Mu, Rear Army Major, was appointed Inspector of Jiaozhou.
15
西 [11]
On jisi day in the sixth month, Liu Daolong, Left Army Chief Clerk, was appointed Inspector of Liang and Southern Qin provinces. On yihai day Zong Que, General Who Pacifies the West and Inspector of Yongzhou, died. On renwu day Liu Yu, Prince of Xiangdong, General of the Guard and Inspector of Southern Yuzhou, was reassigned as Inspector of Yongzhou. [11] Liu Yuanjing, Director of the Masters of Writing and General of Agile Cavalry, was also made Inspector of Southern Yuzhou.
16
[12] 宿[13] 西
On xinyou day in the eighth month of autumn, Colonel of Fast Cavalry Dai Faxing was found guilty of a crime and was ordered to take his own life. On gengwu day Yan Shibo was promoted to Left Vice Director of the Masters of Writing, [12] and Wang Jingwen, Director of the Ministry of Personnel, was made Right Vice Director. On guiyou day the emperor personally led the palace guard and executed Grand Preceptor Liu Yigong, Prince of Jiangxia; Director of the Masters of Writing and General of Agile Cavalry Liu Yuanjing; Left Vice Director Yan Shibo; [13] and Director of Justice Liu Deyuan. The reign title was changed to the first year of Jinghe. Civil and military officials were granted two ranks of advancement. Liu Xiuren, Prince of Jian'an, was made General Who Pacifies the West and Inspector of Yongzhou; Liu Yu, Prince of Xiangdong, General of the Guard, was restored as Inspector of Southern Yuzhou. On jiaxu day Liu Zishang, Prince of Yuzhang, Minister over the Masses and Inspector of Yang Province, also took charge of the Masters of Writing; Shen Wenxiu was appointed Inspector of Qingzhou; and Cui Daogu was appointed Inspector of Jizhou. On yihai day an edict declared: "In former times rulers fixed their spirit in stillness—at Panxi the Way was praised; they steeped their minds in the search for talent—at Fuyan worthies aided the transformation of the realm. I hold the three extremities and the winds are clear throughout the realm; with axe and lightning I have cut down the guilty, and at the hour of mao justice was done. I mean to look up and proclaim the legacy of my forebears and look down to extend the bright fortune of the throne; night after night I dream of the cauldron in the kitchen, and when I think of the plank road I do not forget the hour before dawn. Let every commandery and kingdom be searched and every district recruited: those of filial heart and loyal integrity, who dwell apart in seclusion, who practice trust and righteousness, who are pure and upright and set an example for others, who are cultured and learned, or who are capable in affairs and can govern the people—all should be commended and promoted according to their talents. Thus officials will perform their duties and the human order will be set right. Those in charge should examine each case carefully and report what accords with my intent." Shen Qingzhi, Duke of Shixing, was appointed Grand Marshal; Wang Xuamo, General Who Pacifies the North and Inspector of Qing and Ji provinces, was made chief General Who Protects the Army. On gengchen day Stone City was renamed Changle Palace and the Eastern Palace quarter was renamed Weiyang Palace. Eastern Yang Province was abolished and merged back into Yang Province. On jiashen day the northern residence was renamed Jianzhang Palace and the southern mansion was renamed Changyang Palace. Liu Ziyuan, Prince of Shaoling, General Who Conquers the Champions, was appointed Inspector of Xiangzhou. On bingxu day overdue rents before the eighth year of Daming in Wu, Wuxing, Yixing, Jinling, and Langya were remitted. On jichou day the northern and southern imperial speedways were restored.
17
祿西 西 西
On guisi day in the ninth month the emperor visited Hushu, where imperial music was performed. On wuxu day the emperor returned to the palace. On gengzi day Liu Ziren, Prince of Yongjia, was transferred from Southern Yanzhou to Southern Xuzhou; Liu Zizhen, Prince of Shi'an and Administrator of Danyang, was appointed Inspector of Southern Yanzhou. On xinchou day Liu Ziluan, Prince of Xin'an, General Who Pacifies the Army and Inspector of Southern Xuzhou, was stripped of rank and ordered to take his own life. On bingwu day Xue Andu, Inspector of Yanzhou, was appointed General Who Pacifies the North and Inspector of Xuzhou. On dingwei day Liu Yu, Prince of Xiangdong, General of the Guard, was granted the privilege of an office equal to the Three Dukes; Liu Zunkao was made General Who Pacifies the West and Inspector of Southern Yuzhou; and Yin Xiaozu was appointed Inspector of Yanzhou. On wushen day Liu Yuangu, former Inspector of Liang and Southern Qin provinces, was restored to that post. On jiyou day the emperor marched against Liu Chang, Prince of Yiyang, General Who Conquers the North and Inspector of Xuzhou, and the court went on full alert. Liu Chang fled to the northern barbarians. On xinhai day Liu Xiuyou, Prince of Shanyang, General of the Right and Inspector of Yuzhou, was promoted to General Who Pacifies the West. On jiayin day Yuan Yi, Chief Clerk of the Pacification of the West, was appointed Inspector of Yongzhou. On wuwu day Liu Kaokao, Director of the Left Household, was appointed Inspector of Yizhou. That same day the alert was lifted and the emperor went to Guabu. Private coinage by the common people was permitted.
18
西 [14]
On guihai day in the tenth month of winter, Xuzhou was granted a partial amnesty. On bingyin day the emperor returned to the palace. Liu Xiuren, Prince of Jian'an, was appointed General Who Protects the Army. On jimao day Wang Zao, Administrator of Dongyang, was thrown into prison and died there. The palace woman Xie Guibin was made Lady, granted Tiger Guards with leather quivers and halberds, an imperial carriage with dragon banners, and imperial escort whenever she went abroad—in truth she was Princess Xincai. On yiyou day Liu Xiuyou, Prince of Shanyang, General Who Pacifies the West and Inspector of Yuzhou, was promoted to General Who Pacifies the Army and granted the privilege of an office equal to the Three Dukes. [14] (End of note.)
19
祿 [15] 祿
On renchen day in the eleventh month, He Mai, General Who Pacifies the Barbarians, was imprisoned and died. Shen Qingzhi, who had just been appointed Grand Marshal, died. On renyin day Lady Lu was installed as empress, with music performed in all four side chambers of the palace. An amnesty was granted in Yang and Southern Xu provinces. Liu Xiuren, Prince of Jian'an, General Who Protects the Army, was also made Special Advance and Left Grand Master for Splendid Happiness. Liu Xiufan, Prince of Guiyang, Central Army Guard, was transferred to another post. On dingwei day a prince was born, the son of Liu Sheng of the Palace Treasury. [15] A general amnesty was proclaimed throughout the realm. Crimes of corruption, defilement, licentiousness, and theft were all remitted. Those who had become heirs to their fathers were granted one rank of nobility. On renzi day Liu Xiuren, Prince of Jian'an, was promoted to General of Agile Cavalry and granted the privilege of an office equal to the Three Dukes. On wuwu day Liu Jingyou, Prince of Nanping, Liu Jingxian, Prince of Luling, and Liu Jingyuan, Marquis of Annan, were all ordered to take their own lives.
20
By then the emperor's cruelty and perversity grew worse by the day; executions followed one after another, and throughout the bureaucracy no one could be sure of keeping his head. Earlier a rumor had spread: "A Son of Heaven will arise in Xiang." The emperor planned a southern tour of Jing and Xiang provinces to counter the omen. He meant to execute his uncles first and only then set out on the journey. The future Ming Emperor secretly allied with his close attendants Ruan Tianfu, Wang Daolong, and Li Dao'er and with eleven of the emperor's own attendants, including Shou Jizhi and Jiang Chanzi, to depose him together. At midnight on wuwu day the emperor was in the Bamboo Grove Hall at Huilin Garden, shooting at ghosts. Shamans had said that the hall was haunted:" so the emperor had gone to shoot at them himself. Shou Jizhi entered with a drawn knife, Jiang Chanzi following as his second. The emperor tried to flee; Jizhi pursued him and struck him down. He was seventeen years old. The Grand Empress Dowager issued an order:
21
To the Minister over the Masses, the chief General Who Protects the Army, and the Eight Dignitaries: Though Ziye was the eldest son of the proper wife, from childhood he showed a vicious and poisonous nature; his want of benevolence and filial piety was evident even in his earliest years. When Emperor Xiao Wu died, the throne passed to him by right of succession. From the moment the imperial coffin lay in state, his face was bright and untroubled; though Heaven's punishment had struck the imperial house, his wanton joy only grew. Forced by court and family to restrain himself, he had not yet shown his full cruelty; but his savage brutality could not be held back, and in a single day he unleashed catastrophe, slaughtering the chief ministers and destroying his own supporters. Ziluan and his brothers had been the late emperor's favorites; nursing old resentments, he had them savagely executed without cause. Chang, a close kinsman who should have been a bulwark of the throne, was attacked and punished without cause. Princess Xincai was torn from her husband's family and shut away in the inner palace, while a false report announced her death. Mourning had barely begun when its rites were cast aside; through long nights of drunkenness every affair of state was neglected. Court worthies and old ministers he cast aside like rubbish. Music never ceased; rare delicacies filled every table. He reviled his ancestors and forebears for sport. His wanderings knew no limit; his lewdness and excess knew no bounds. He feasted in the imperial tombs and plotted to open the graves. He slaughtered the innocent and seized women by force. He raised up false charges, and no one knew who would be struck down next. In taking concubines and installing an empress, his celebrations exceeded all precedent. Imperial kinsmen and close relatives he treated like servants, beating and dragging them with no regard for rank. The house of Nanping alone he singled out for especial cruelty. He turned against Heaven and extinguished moral principle; his open violence took ten thousand forms. Harsh punishments and cruel ordinances knew no limit; even Jie of Xia and Xin of Yin would not suffice for comparison. Throughout the court everyone lived in dread and no one was safe; the people were in turmoil and did not know where to turn. His conduct was more beastly than a beast's; his crimes were beyond numbering. The founding emperor's enterprise was on the verge of ruin; the offerings at the seven temples were nearly cut off. I am old and gravely ill; each day I foresee the poisoned cup; anxiety consumes me with every drip of the water clock, and my life will not long endure. Since the opening of the age, nothing like this has ever been heard of. Near and far alike yearn to rise against him; nine houses in ten.
22
General of the Guard Liu Yu, Prince of Xiangdong, is descended from the dynastic founder; Heaven endowed him with heroic sagacity, and Emperor Wen cherished him above all other princes. I recognized his keen intelligence early and treated him with especial honor. He carried out his great design in secret; men of righteousness rallied to him; the tyrant has fallen, his severed head on the white banner; the altars of state are renewed and the ancestral temple secured; the hearts of men and spirits alike turn to him, and the great mandate is duly his. His merit and virtue are lofty; the great enterprise is his to receive; let him follow the precedents of Han and Jin in ascending the throne. Those in charge should examine the old statutes and carry them out without delay.
23
I, who have outlived my allotted years, have met this hundredfold calamity; whenever I revisit these events, though I live I am as one dead. What is to be done! What is to be done!
24
西
The deposed emperor was buried west of the southern suburban altar in Moling County, Danyang.
25
西 殿 [16] [17] [18]
From childhood the emperor was impatient and harsh; in the Eastern Palace he was often rebuked by his father. When Emperor Xiao Wu toured the west, Ziye submitted memorials on his daily routine; his calligraphy was careless, and the emperor rebuked him for it. Ziye submitted an apology, and the emperor replied again: "Your writing does not improve—that is one thing. I hear you are habitually lax and idle, and your perversity grows worse by the day—why are you so obstinately incorrigible!" When he first took the throne and received the imperial seal, he showed no grief at all. At first he still found the great ministers and Dai Faxing hard to control; after he killed Faxing, every great minister lived in terror. Thereupon he executed the host of nobles. From Yuan Kai downward, all were beaten and dragged about. Within and without the court there was peril and dread; the palace halls were in uproar. Earlier, when the Empress Dowager's illness was critical, she sent for the emperor. The emperor said: "Sickrooms are full of ghosts—it is dreadful; how could I go there?" The Empress Dowager grew angry and told her attendants: "Bring a knife and cut open my belly—how could I have borne such a son!" Several days after the Empress Dowager died, the emperor dreamed that she said to him: "You are unfilial and unkind; you were never fit to be a ruler. Zishang is as foolish and perverse as you; he too is not what fortune and the throne can sustain. Emperor Xiao Wu was cruel and extinguished the Way; his crimes bound men and spirits in resentment; though his sons were many, none had Heaven's mandate. The great fortune turns where it belongs; it should return to a son of Emperor Wen. When the Prince of Xiangdong later succeeded, he was indeed a son of Emperor Wen. Therefore the emperor gathered his uncles in the capital, fearing trouble if they remained in the provinces. The Princess of Shanyin was licentious beyond measure; she told the emperor: "Your Majesty and I, though man and woman differ, both owe our bodies to the late emperor. Your Majesty has ten thousand women in the six palaces, yet I have only one husband. How unfair that things should have come to this!" The emperor thereupon provided the princess with thirty male favorites; she was advanced to Princess of Kuaiji Commandery with precedence equal to a commandery prince, a fief of two thousand households, [16] one set of imperial music, and twenty guards with ceremonial swords. Whenever the emperor went out, court ministers commonly rode in the same carriage with him. Because Chu Yuan, Director of the Ministry of Personnel, was handsome, the princess asked the emperor to let him serve her, and the emperor consented. Yuan served the princess for ten days, was pressed on every side, and swore he would rather die than submit; only then was he released. The eunuch Hua Yuan'er, whom the emperor favored, rose to Attendant Cavalier and was made a general with a commandery attached. From youth the emperor loved reading [17] and knew antiquity well; he composed the eulogy for his father and various other pieces that often showed real literary talent. Because Emperor Wu of Wei had had a General of Opening Mounds in the Middle and a Colonel of Touching Gold, he established the same two offices. Liu Xiuren, Prince of Jian'an, and Liu Xiuyou, Prince of Shanyang, were placed in charge of them. [18] His other deeds are set forth separately in the various biographies.
26
The historian remarks: The deeds of the deposed emperor are set forth in this chapter. When King Wu of Zhou counted the crimes of King Zhou of Yin, he could not exhaust one part in ten thousand; when Huo Guang set down the faults of the Marquis of Haihun, he could not list one hair's breadth in a thousand. An emperor of only middling talent who committed one such fault would suffice to destroy the altars of state and defile the ancestral shrines; how much more when all these evils were gathered in a single body! That he perished when he did was itself a mercy.
27
Textual collation notes
28
「Moved out to reside in the Eastern Palace」: all editions omit 「ju」; the character is restored from Yuan Gui 256.
29
「Liu Ziren, Prince of Yongjia, Administrator of Danyang, was made Inspector of Southern Yuzhou」: Ziren's biography reads 「Southern Yanzhou」 instead.
30
「Burdensome and harmful to good government」: all editions read 「make」 for 「harmful」; emended per Yuan Gui 191.
31
「The qi and celestial markers are at cross purposes」: all editions read 「mysterious」 for 「cross」—likely a graphic confusion; corrected here.
32
「Wang Xuamo was made General Who Pacifies the North and Inspector of Qing and Ji」: all editions insert eleven spurious characters after 「General Who Pacifies the North」. Ziluan's biography never makes him Inspector of Qing and Ji, while Xuamo's biography says he was transferred there at this time. The text is emended accordingly.
33
「Jichou day」: all editions read 「jiwei」. That month's dingmao was the first day; the twenty-third was jichou—neither jiwei nor yichou occurred. Corrected per the Veritable Records of Jiankang and the Comprehensive Mirror.
34
「Gengyin day」: all editions read 「gengzi」. That month's dingmao was the first day; there was no gengzi. The day after jichou (the twenty-third) was gengyin (the twenty-fourth). Corrected here.
35
「Zong Yue was made Inspector of Sizhou」: the book often miswrites his name as 「Song Yue」; corrected per his biography. Similar cases below are emended directly without separate notes.
36
「Yan Shibo was made Vice Director of the Masters of Writing」: all editions add 「Left」; the Southern History has none. Li Ciming's Notes on the Book of Song: 「「Left」 is intrusive; delete it per the Southern History. 」At that time only a single Vice Director was appointed, with no left-right division. 「Left」 is deleted per the Southern History.
37
祿祿 殿 祿 祿 祿
「Field stipends … reduced by half」: the Song, Three-Dynasties, Beijian, and Mao editions and the Southern History read 「field stipends」. The Palace and Bureau editions read 「field rent」. The Veritable Records of Jiankang reads 「stipend ranks」. A general halving of land rent empire-wide is not something a feudal ruler would do; this must mean halving officials' field stipends in provinces, commanderies, and counties. Hence the Veritable Records of Jiankang's wording 「stipend ranks」.
38
「Liu Yu … Inspector of Southern Yuzhou, was changed to Inspector of Yongzhou」: all editions omit 「Southern」. Emperor Ming's annals show him as Inspector of Southern Yuzhou, garrisoning Gushu, in Yongguang 1. The Monograph on Provinces and Commanderies shows Southern Yuzhou at Gushu, while Yuzhou never used Gushu as its seat. 「Southern」 is restored per Emperor Ming's annals.
39
「Left Vice Director Yan Shibo」: all editions drop 「Left」; restored per the Southern History, as noted above.
40
西西 西西
「General Who Pacifies the West … made General Who Pacifies the Army」: all editions read 「North」 for 「West」. The ninth-month xinhai entry and Xiuyou's biography both have 「West」; corrected here.
41
「Son of Liu Sheng of the Palace Treasury」: Yuan Gui 197 and 207 agree with this annals. The Treatise on Omens, Xiuren's biography, the Song Summary, and the Southern History annals write the name as 「Liu Meng」 (blind); Xiuren's biography in the Southern History writes it as 「Liu Meng」 (cover).
42
「Fief of two thousand households for bathing and maintenance」: all editions read 「marquis」 for 「receive」. Emended per the Imperial Readings 152.
43
「From youth the emperor loved reading」: all editions read 「lecturing on books」; emended per the Southern History, Yuan Gui 192, and Imperial Readings 128.
44
「Jian'an and Shanyang princes were placed in charge」: all editions omit 「Xiuren … Prince of Shanyang」; restored per the Southern History. Zhang Hui's Corrections in Reading History: 「The Prince of Jian'an is Xiuren; Xiuyou is the Prince of Shanyang. The Southern History's 「Liu Xiuren, Prince of Jian'an, and Liu Xiuyou, Prince of Shanyang, were placed in charge of them」 is correct.」
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →