← Back to 魏書

卷24 燕鳳 許謙 張衮 崔玄伯 鄧淵

Volume 24: Yan Feng, Xu Qian, Zhang Gun, Cui Xuanbo, Deng Yuan

Chapter 29 of 魏書 · Book of Wei
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 29
Next Chapter →
1
Biographies of Yan Feng, Xu Qian, Zhang Gun, Cui Xuanbo, and Deng Yuan
2
使
Yan Feng, whose style was Zizhang, came from Dai. A devoted scholar, he ranged widely through the classics and histories and was versed in yin-yang lore and prophetic weft-texts. Emperor Zhaocheng, who had long known his reputation, sent envoys to receive him with full ritual honors. Feng refused to answer the call. Zhaocheng then had his forces surround Dai and told the inhabitants: "Unless Yan Feng comes, I will put every one of you to the sword." Terrified, the people of Dai sent Feng out to him. Zhaocheng talked with him at length, took great delight in him, and honored him as an honored guest. He was later made Left Chief Clerk to the Prince of Dai and joined in governing the realm. He also instructed Emperor Xianming in the classics.
3
使 退 西滿 使
Fu Jian dispatched the envoy Niu Tian to present tribute. Zhaocheng charged Feng to answer in his name. Fu Jian asked Feng: "What manner of ruler is the Prince of Dai?" Feng replied: "Mild and humane, far-sighted in counsel—a champion of the hour who constantly dreams of uniting the world under his rule." Fu Jian said: "You northerners have no plate mail or keen blades; you press forward only against the weak and run when the strong appear—how could you ever conquer all?" Feng said: "The north breeds hard men; in the saddle each warrior carries three arms and flies across the plain. Our sovereign is brilliant and bold; the north obeys him, a million bowmen answer his call, and his word is law to every camp. His host marches without the drag of wagons or camp kitchens; light and swift, it lives off what it seizes from the foe. That is why the south wears itself down while the north wins battle after battle." Fu Jian asked: "How many fighting men and horses does Dai really field?" Feng answered: "Archers in the hundreds of thousands; horses by the million." Fu Jian said: "Your count of men I can credit; a million horses is mere brag." Feng said: "East Mountain to West River along the Yunzhong is two hundred li; north to south, more than a hundred. Each early autumn the herds assemble until the valley is all but covered with horses. Judge by that, and even your messenger's tale understates the case." When Feng went home, Fu Jian loaded him with presents.
4
After Zhaocheng's death, Taizu was preparing to relocate to Chang'an. Seeing the heir still a child, Feng pressed Fu Jian: "The Prince of Dai is newly dead; his officers have fled or turned traitor; the grandson left behind is an infant with no one to raise him to the throne. Liu Kuren of the separate tribes is bold and shrewd; the Tiefu leader Weichen is sly and shifting—neither should hold power alone. Split the tribal following between them and set each to command his half. They have hated each other for years; neither will dare move before the other. That is the soundest way to secure the border. When the boy comes of age, restore the realm and enthrone him—Your Majesty would then show supreme mercy to a ruined house." Fu Jian took his counsel. Feng soon made his way back east.
5
After Taizu's accession he rose through Director of Personnel, Attendant Gentleman of the Yellow Gate, and Acting Director of the Secretariat, and was held in high esteem. Under Emperor Taizong he sat with Cui Xuanbo, Feng Yi, Liang Yue, and others to expound the classics and debate affairs of state. When Emperor Shizu began his reign, Feng received the marquisate of Pingshu and the rank General Who Pacifies the Distance for long service. He died in Shenlu year 1.
6
His son Cai succeeded to the title. He held the posts of Regular Attendant-in-Ordinary and General Who Pacifies the Distance. He died in office.
7
His son Yuansun took the succession. He rose to Administrator of Boling. He died without further office. His son Shizong succeeded.
8
Xu Qian, whose style was Yuansun, came from Dai. As a youth he showed literary gifts and mastered astronomy, star-charts, and prophetic weft-texts. When the state was founded he came in with his clan; Zhaocheng praised him, made him Director of Gentlemen to the Prince of Dai, and put him in charge of the archives. He and Yan Feng together instructed Emperor Xianming in the classics. On the expedition against Weichen he earned thirty households of retainers as a reward for service. After Zhaocheng's death, Qian went to live at Chang'an. Fu Jian's cousin Fu Luo, Duke of Xingtang, who governed Helong, asked Qian to join him there. Soon, pleading his stepmother's advanced years, he sought leave to go home.
9
使 使
When Dengguo was proclaimed he came back to Taizu. Taizu welcomed him, named him Right Major of Horse, and with Zhang Gun and others he helped build the new order. When Murong Bao invaded, Taizu dispatched Qian to tell Yao Xing of the peril. Yao Xing sent General Yang Fosong with an army, but Fosong moved slowly. Taizu had Qian draft a letter to Fosong: "To wield the Mandate against a house already failing, to strike in the name of justice against a blinded foe—no triumph ever shone outside its season, no deed ever stood outside its time. Murong Bao is lawless; he tramples our marches; his soldiers are spent; the day of his ruin is at hand—hence this embassy and this host, and I expect you without delay. You hold a frontier command and lead warriors fierce as bear and tiger; fortune offers itself—this is the hour. Strike now and the war need not be fought twice; glory to last a millennium can be won before noon. Then feast in Yunzhong, march into the Three Weis, lift the wine and toast long life—would that not be splendid?" Fosong doubled his pace and raced to the field. Taizu was delighted and enfeoffed Qian as Marquis Within the Passes. He sent Qian again to swear alliance with Fosong: "Tang of Yin bound himself at Mingtiao, King Wu of Zhou at Heyang—each invoked the spirits to witness faith. To love the humane and treat neighbors well is the ancient rule; blood was drunk and the victim cut to seal peace forever. Now that we are allied, let us speak only friendship; share each other's calamity, ease each other's grief, and make our weal and woe one. Whoever breaks this oath, let the gods strike him dead." When Bao fell, Fosong marched home.
10
退
The following year Murong Chui invaded again. Taizu told Qian: "Affairs are desperate; only you could summon Yao's host again—set out at once." Qian had not yet left when Chui retreated, and the errand was called off. Learning of Chui's death, Qian memorialized urging Taizu to ascend the throne. Taizu was pleased with the counsel.
11
祿
After Bing was pacified he was named Protector of Yangqu, Marquis of Pingshu, and General Who Pacifies the Distance. He died in office in Huangshi year 1, at sixty-three. Posthumously he received General Who Pacifies the East, Grand Master of Splendid Happiness of the Left, Inspector of Youzhou, and Duke of Gaoyang, with the temple name Wen.
12
His son Luoyang succeeded. On the campaign against Murong Bao he was Champion Major. He later became magistrate of Qi county. Emperor Taizong, honoring Qian's service, appointed Luoyang Administrator of Yanmen. Three stalks of lucky grain sprang on Luoyang's land, each with unusual furrows and fused ears; Emperor Shizu approved. He was advanced to Duke of Beidi and General Who Pacifies the South. He served eight years as garrison commander of Minglei, then died. His posthumous name was Gong.
13
His son Jisheng inherited, but the rank was lowered to marquis. He died in Huangxing year 1.
14
Luoyang's brother Anguo became Administrator of Zhongshan.
15
Anguo's brother Andu governed Guangning and Cangshui. He was also made General Who Displays Might. He received the viscounty of Dongguang. He died early in the Tian'an era. Posthumously he was General Who Pacifies the Distance, Inspector of Jizhou, and Marquis of Dongguang, temple name Lie.
16
His son Baihu succeeded. He served as Attendant Censor-in-Ordinary. Later, convicted of an offense, he was dismissed and deprived of his rank.
17
Xu Qian, whose style was Yuansun, came from Dai. As a youth he showed literary gifts and mastered astronomy, star-charts, and prophetic weft-texts. When the state was founded he came in with his clan; Zhaocheng praised him, made him Director of Gentlemen to the Prince of Dai, and put him in charge of the archives. He and Yan Feng together instructed Emperor Xianming in the classics. On the expedition against Weichen he earned thirty households of retainers as a reward for service. After Emperor Zhaocheng's death, Qian went to Chang'an. Fu Jian's younger cousin Luo, Duke of Xingtang, held Helong and asked Qian to take command there. Before long he asked leave to return, citing his stepmother's age.
18
使 使
At the opening of the Denguo era he came back to Taizu. Taizu was pleased, made him Right Marshal, and with Zhang Gun and others helped build the new order. When Murong Bao invaded, Taizu sent Qian to ask Yao Xing for aid. Xing sent Yang Fosong with an army, but Fosong dragged his feet. Taizu had Qian write to Fosong: "To strike the doomed in the name of order and attack the blind in the name of right — no one wins glory against the times or builds lasting fame out of season. Murong Bao is lawless and trespasses on our borders; his soldiers are spent and Heaven's judgment is due — I send envoys and an army and count on you to come in time. You hold a frontier command and lead troops like bears and tigers; the moment fits — now is the hour. Strike now and the war need not be fought twice; glory for a thousand years can be won in one morning. Then feast in Yunzhong, march through the three Weis, raise your cup to long life — what could be grander?" Fosong then forced a double march. Taizu was delighted and enfeoffed Qian as Marquis Within the Passes. He sent Qian again to swear alliance with Fosong: "Tang of Yin swore at Mingtiao and Wu of Zhou at Heyang to borrow the gods' witness and bind faith. To cherish the humane and be good to neighbors is the ancient model; blood-oath and sacrifice seal peace forever. After this oath let us keep amity, share disaster and pity each other's woes — one fortune, one fate. Whoever breaks this pact — let the spirits destroy him." Bao was beaten and Fosong withdrew.
19
退
The next year Murong Chui invaded again. Taizu told Qian, "The crisis is acute; who but you could summon Yao's troops again? Go at once." Before Qian departed, Chui had already retreated, so the mission was called off. When he learned Chui was dead, Qian memorialized urging Taizu to take the imperial title. Taizu approved.
20
祿
After Bingzhou was pacified, Qian became Protector of Yangqu and was made Marquis of Pingshu and General Who Pacifies the Distant. In the first year of Huangshi he died in office at sixty-three. Posthumously he was made General Who Pacifies the East, Grand Master of the Left, Youzhou inspector, Duke of Gaoyang, with the posthumous name Wen.
21
His son Luoyang succeeded. On the campaign against Murong Bao he served as champion marshal. Later he was magistrate of Qi — so the record runs. Emperor Taizong recalled Qian's service and made Luoyang administrator of Yanmen. On Luoyang's family fields three stalks of auspicious grain grew on separate ridges but with ears joined as one; Shizu was pleased. He was advanced to Duke of Beidi and General Who Guards the South. He went out as commanding general of Ming Lei, held the post eight years, and died. His posthumous name was Gong.
22
His son Jisheng inherited, but the title was reduced to marquis. In the first year of Huangxing he died — so the record runs.
23
Luoyang's younger brother Anguo was administrator of Zhongshan.
24
Anguo's younger brother Andu was administrator of Guangning and Cangshui. He was also made General Who Displays Might. He was enfeoffed as Son of Dongguang. In Tian'an year 1 he died — so the record runs. Posthumously he was made General Who Pacifies the Distant, Jizhou inspector, Marquis of Dongguang, posthumous name Lie.
25
His son Baihu succeeded. He was attendant-in-ordinary in the Personal Guard — so the record runs. Later, for a crime, he was dismissed and stripped of his title.
26
Zhang Gun, styled Honglong, came from Juyang in Shanggu. His grandfather Yi had been administrator of Liaodong. His father Zhuo was administrator of Changli. Gun began as the commandery registrar of five offices — honest, steady, studious, and gifted in letters. When Taizu was Prince of Dai, Gun was chosen as left chief of staff.
27
He followed Taizu against the Rouran. The Rouran fled and the army pursued five or six hundred li. The tribal chiefs spoke through Gun to Taizu: "The foe is far and our grain is gone; do not go deeper — turn back at once." Taizu told Gun to ask the chiefs whether killing the remount horses would feed the army three days. All said it would. Taizu then doubled the pace, caught them south of Bed Mountain on the broad red desert, and routed them. Later Taizu asked Gun, "Do outsiders know why I asked about three days' grain?" Gun answered, "No one does." Taizu said, "It is simple. The Rouran had run for days; after their herds' leavings they must halt at every water. Count their route and three days suffice to catch them. Light horse arriving suddenly will startle them into flight — that is the logic." Gun repeated Taizu's words to the chiefs; all said, "The sage's design reaches far beyond what short sight can grasp."
28
[1] 姿
Gun was constantly in counsel at the heart of strategy; Taizu prized him and honored him generously. Gun often said to others, "Yue Yi served Yan Zhao with his staff and Xun Yu gave himself to Cao Cao;[1] a lord for the age is rare, and a once-in-a-millennium chance is rarer still. Our lord's gifts tower above others and his ambition pierces the clouds — he will surely take the realm and unite the four seas. Who meets such a moment and does not rise with it is no true hero." He then pledged himself and served with whole-hearted loyalty.
29
使西
At that time Liu Xian held vast territory and a strong army across the north; his brothers had fallen out and distrusted one another. Gun told Taizu, "Xian is proud and ambitious beyond the ordinary — he dreams of rivaling heaven and earth and swallowing the world. If Wu is not joined with Yue, he will trouble us later. Use their internal strife and strike now. A lone light column may let him escape. Send word to Murong Chui to join us; attack from east and west together and he is sure to fall. Then rally the bold and win the far marches — a chance that comes once in a thousand years; do not miss it." Taizu took his advice and drove Xian off. He followed Gun again in defeating He Ne, then ordered the court to climb Wuju Mountain and feast all day. Ministers and tribal leaders asked to heap stones into a monument; Taizu had Gun write the inscription.
30
When Murong Bao invaded, Gun told Taizu, "Bao builds on Huatai and Changzi, spending treasury and strength — he is dangerous to meet head-on. I would show a weak force and fold our armor away to puff up his pride." Taizu agreed and crushed him at Canhe.
31
At the start of Huangshi he was made attendant gentleman of the Yellow Gate. Taizu marched south and camped at Zhongshan. Gun told Taizu, "Bao rests on three generations and strong walls; though your majesty will surely take him, driving the army to extremity is not a king's way. Long ago Li Yiji with one speech made Tian Heng yield; Lu Zhong's letter from afar was enough to make a man offer his head. I am no match for those men and have no clever scheme, yet under your power something may move him." Taizu agreed. Gun sent Bao a letter — so the record runs. He set out the odds of victory and defeat. Bao was terrified by the letter and fled to Helong. After Zhongshan fell, Gun entered the eight deliberations and was made General Who Displays Valor, Youzhou inspector, and Marquis of Linwei. Gun lived plainly and urged farming and silk; the people were settled.
32
忿
At the start of Tianxing he was recalled to the capital. Later he and Cui Cheng drafted a reply to Xi Hui, general under Jin's Sima Dezong, that missed the tone; Gun was demoted to clerk of the Masters of Writing. Gun had served from the founding days, trusted for talent and counsel, and gave his heart without fear of suspicion. Taizu once asked Gun about talent from the south. Gun was from the same commandery as Lu Bo and often praised him to the throne. He had never met Cui Cheng either, yet praised him on hearsay. When Zhongshan was pacified, Lu Bo raised a faction in revolt and Cui Cheng's reply was defiant; both belied what Gun had said, and he bore them a grudge.
33
西 使
Past seventy, Gun kept his whole household in quiet; he held the classics in hand, collated what had gone astray, delighted in men of talent, and guided them without tiring—the learned held him in high esteem for it. In the second year of Yongxing his illness turned grave; he submitted a memorial: "I am a mediocre man without special resolve, yet I lived when the Founding Ancestor received Heaven's mandate and the world first opened. I shared the war-mist at the start and rode through the season of revolution, trusting my wings to the sacred grove and my scales to the deep sea, and so bore favor whose glory reached within and without the court. When Your Majesty ascended the throne I still sat in counsel, yet never offered the slightest sincerity—my debt piled like mountains, my thanks spread like seas. Now my old illness lingers and my strength is spent; Heaven punishes guilt, and I am about to fill a ditch. Yet dog and horse love their master, and I dare not withhold my words. The central lands are at peace, yet the nine regions are not one: unsubmissive Qiang in the west, rebels in the south, other customs in Min and Shu, other faiths along Liao and the sea. Though Heaven has raised a bright sage to set disorder aright and ride the times, seizing the moment and steering events still demands strategy. The hinge slips easily; achievement rests on human counsel. I beg that the sagely Way be lifted high and the heart of virtue broadened, so courtesy and arms stand together and civil and martial power move as one—then the age of great peace and the cry of "How grand!" would rise again today, not only in ages past. Of old, when Zi Nang was near death, he left word to defend Ying; (record). when Xun Yan drew his last breath, his regret still lay in Qi. I am dim and weak, yet dare not forget that resolve; if my soul has spirit, I shall tie grass in the land below." Several days later he died, aged seventy-two. Later Emperor Shizu, recording old merit, sent the Grand Herald to his tomb with a patent making him Grand Mentor posthumously and titling him Duke Wenkang.
34
His son Wen served as Outer Metropolitan Food Officer and Administrator of Guangning. He passed away.
35
His son Erxing was Administrator of Changli — so the record runs.
36
簿
Wen's younger brother Kai was a provincial chief clerk — so the record runs.
37
His son Dan was learned and principled, his nature especially refined and upright — so the record runs. At first he was summoned together with Gao Yun; later he was made Secretariat Gentleman, Regular Attendant of the Unimpeded Cavalry, and General Who Establishes Might — so the record runs. He was granted the title Marquis of Rongcheng — so the record runs.
38
使
Gun's second son Du, ambitious from youth, inherited the fief as Marquis of Linwei. He was Administrator of Shanggu, then entered court as tutor to the Prince of Wuchang. He was further made Regular Attendant of the Cavalry, then commissioned with the staff of authority as commander over military affairs of Youzhou's Guangyang and Anle, General Who Pacifies the East, Metropolitan Commander of Qicheng, then transferred to Metropolitan Commander of Helong—wherever he served he won renown. On returning to court he became Metropolitan Food Officer of the Central Capital. He died and was posthumously made General Who Campaigns East and Inspector of Ji, titled Marquis Kang.
39
His son Ling inherited the fief — so the record runs. Later he was Metropolitan Director of Works at Chicheng — so the record runs. He passed away.
40
His son Zhuang inherited — so the record runs. He was a Palace Scribe — so the record runs. He passed away.
41
His son Fa inherited — so the record runs. In the Taihe era, by precedent the rank was reduced to marquis — so the record runs. In Emperor Shizong's time he was made garrison commander of Huaihuang at Jincheng — so the record runs.
42
Ling's younger brother Yan was Regular Attendant of the Cavalry, Left General, and Minister of the Storehouses — so the record runs. He was granted the title Marquis of Yongning — so the record runs.
43
[2] 殿
Yan's younger brother Bai Ze[2], at eleven, lost his mother; in mourning he was famed for filial piety. Emperor Shizu heard of it and commended him — so the record runs. Grown, he loved learning, was broadly versed, and keen in affairs of the day. At the beginning of Emperor Gaozong's reign he was made Palace Scribe, then Attendant of the Palace Bureau, greatly favored and trusted and drawn into secret counsel.
44
退 輿 退
Later the Rouran raided the border; Emperor Xianzu summoned the ministers to discuss it — so the record runs. Vice Director Yuan Muchén advanced and said: "If Your Majesty goes in person, the capital may panic; better to hold steady and keep to defense. The enemy has marched deep with no grain to follow; by my reckoning they will soon withdraw—send generals in pursuit and victory is certain." Bai Ze said: "Your Majesty, reverent and bright as Heaven, treads the tracks of former sages, yet these wild fools in their ignorance lightly violate the royal plan. The raiders toil in distant schemes while our generals feast amid nearby danger—measured by divine strategy, that cannot stand. If the imperial carriage moves now, the bandits will scatter at the banners—how could we let divine arms be checked and sit idle while the foe escapes? The honor of ten thousand chariots, walled up at home—advance and you lose a chance that can be seized; retreat and you fall short of pressing forward without rival. I beg Your Majesty to ponder this." Emperor Xianzu followed this counsel and utterly broke the barbarian host.
45
使 [3]祿
Bai Ze's original name was Zhongkui; Emperor Xianzu bestowed the name Bai Ze and took his daughter into the inner palace as a consort — so the record runs. Sent out as Inspector of Yong Province, he kept his heart clear and his desires few; officials and people were at peace under him — so the record runs. Emperor Xianzu decreed that any supervising official who in his jurisdiction received one sheep or one jar of wine would face capital punishment, and the giver would be judged as an accomplice. Whoever reported and proved guilt among officials from the Masters of Writing downward would receive office according to the rank of the official denounced. Bai Ze submitted a memorial of remonstrance: "I have seen the edict that punishes Masters of Writing and below who accept gifts with death, and gives the accuser the denounced man's post. I reflect that the triennial review of achievement, demoting the obscure and promoting the clear, is an unchanging statute and the common pattern of a hundred kings. Today's Metropolitan Bureau is the public ministers of old; all assist in the myriad affairs and harmonize the hundred duties—through them custom is leveled and the way of rule made tranquil. Even Zhou's lowest officers still had substitute fields for their labor—how much more our honored offices, serving diligently yet unrewarded; can this be called inheriting Yao and Shun and taking Wen and Wu as one's model? If the penalty of sheep and wine goes on without end, I fear schemers will watch for their chance and loyal ministers will slacken. Yet you wish affairs quiet and the people at peace, government clear and tasks simple—yet in entrusting responsibility and demanding results, the lower people are hard put to argue. [3] By my foolish reckoning, I ask that the old laws be followed, checked against former canons, salaries paid to reward integrity, the disorderly crowd removed first, and ordinary punishments never pardoned. If this can be done, the track of ascending peace may be looked for within a month, and the wind of laying aside punishments will arrive in three years." Emperor Xianzu accepted it — so the record runs.
46
西 [4] 輿 殿
At the beginning of Taihe, more than thirty men of Huai Province led by Yi Qigou plotted rebellion and meant to kill the inspector — so the record runs. Empress Dowager Wenming wished to execute the whole city's people — so the record runs. Bai Ze remonstrated: "I have heard that Heaven loves the life of things and the bright king values the people's lives; to kill one man and take the realm is not what the benevolent do. Moreover the Zhou Documents say father, son, and brothers do not share one another's guilt; now the ringleaders are torn apart and put to the sword, yet the whole city is innocent—how can extreme punishment reach so far? Do not wrong ten households—how much more a whole province; there may be loyal or benevolent men among them; if excessive punishment sweeps them in and kills the loyal and benevolent, this is why the Western Earl sighed over the Nine Marquises and Confucius turned his carriage at the river. I beg you to consider that sagely virtue is bright as a mirror and water-polished by former ritual,[4] restraining sudden wrath and checking thunder's might—then all under Heaven would know fortune. Of old King Li stopped the people's mouths and at last extinguished the house of Ji; (record). King Wen listened to cart-songs and in the end crushed mighty Chu — so the record runs. I wish you not reject words because of the speaker—leave your mind to examine them." The Empress Dowager followed this — so the record runs. He was transferred to Regular Attendant of the Cavalry and promoted to Director of the Palace Bureau — so the record runs.
47
In the fifth year of Taihe he died; an edict granted a thousand bolts of silk and three thousand shi of grain, sent an attendant censor to oversee the funeral, and by patent enfeoffed him posthumously as General Who Guards the South, Inspector of Xiang, and Duke of Guangping, titled Jian.
48
His eldest son Lun, styled Tiannian — so the record runs. Past ten, he attended at the ruler's side. He was gradually promoted to Chief Clerk of the Guard Army, Outer Attendant, then Vice Director of the Grand Granary and Grand Rectifier of Yan Province — so the record runs.
49
使 使
In the Xiping era the Rouran ruler Chounu sent envoys to court with a letter treating the state as an equal and without subject courtesy. Court discussion wished to follow the Han precedent in answering the Xiongnu and send envoys in reply — so the record runs. Lun submitted a memorial:
50
姿 使
I have heard that the sage kings of antiquity divided the land and regulated things, distinguished the chief districts, and distant wilds lay outside what government could reach. Therefore ritual has the text of a single audience, and the Documents record the matter of loose reins — so the record runs. The Founding Ancestor, with divine martial bearing and sagely design, laid out the imperial plan day by day without rest; thus a stripling's wandering soul was left on one side—also because the central lands had many troubles and urgency lay with the Hua while the Yi and Di could wait. Gaozu shed light on the central land and his enterprise towered for generations; he shook thunder's might and roused the bear-and-tiger hosts, yet was campaigning south and had no leisure to march north — so the record runs. Of old, when the old capital flared with alarm, barbarian envoys were at the suburbs; the sovereign gripped his sword and the imperial letter did not go forth — so the record runs. Emperor Shizong plotted within the tent and opened the borders, raising banners; wherever robe and cap reached, boat and cart ran ten thousand li — so the record runs. At that time the barbarians knocked at the gate, and the sovereign too followed the honored departed will. Now great brightness faces the court, grace reaches the traveling reed; the state is rich, the army strong, and those who can speak come to duty — so the record runs. What is there to fear in doing this, what is sought in acting thus? (record). In former days Xiao Yan sent envoys seeking peace with sincere respect; because his sincerity was not pure, it was suppressed and not granted — so the record runs. The former emperor cast off arms before, and Your Majesty treats the Yi after—will this not be above against Gaozu's heart and below against Shizong's intent? (record).
51
使
Moreover, though the barbarians admire virtue, they also come to observe us; awe them with strength and they may at once submit; show them weakness and covetous watching may arise—the Spring and Autumn Annals calls this "taking us as the augury." (record). Again, petty men are hard to approach and the Yi and Di have no kinship; keep them distant and they resent, draw them close and they insult—this has long been their way — so the record runs. Therefore Gaozu and Shizong knew it was so: when they came, they did not press intimacy; when they went, they did not pursue — so the record runs. The meaning of not making one rule lies here — so the record runs. Only when they come with tribute of jade and silks and bend the knee in the rites of the frontier may their labor be richly rewarded and their goods entered in the register — so the record runs. As for the king's man sent on distant service, bearing command in the barbarian court, honored as an equal and further given the favor of mutual regard—I fear it will only breed barbarian insolence and do the holy court no good. Suppose one chose the multitude and raised a worthy envoy, lent the eloquence of Li Yiji, let loose the words of Zhong Jun, leaned on the carriage rail to bring Qi down, and with a long tassel bound Yue—if it differed from former times, one would still be unwilling; how much less exalt them to utmost honor and extend them feast and friendship? I am low and foolish, yet still dare to hold firm.
52
使
If the matter cannot be avoided, an imperial edict should show the etiquette of superior and inferior, and the chief minister should send a letter admonishing them in the way of returning to obedience. If Your Majesty will hear loyal counsel and weigh my words, the throne's majesty will keep its seat at the center of the world, and imperial renown will cover every border. If you will not, nothing is gained or lost by it. Let shield and axe be danced slowly to draw them in; let civil virtue spread until the far peoples come of themselves. If their hearts stay blind and they run wild as dogs and goats, then send generals in the mold of Xin and Li, hosts like Wei Qing and Huo Qubing — still the drifting sands, purge the fugitive rebels, water horses beside Hanhai, cut stone on Mount Yanran, open protectorates and set Wu-Ji garrisons. That too would be Your Majesty's high merit, a triumph without peer. If you mean to rest the armies, cherish the people, farm the fields, and seal the marches — the long walls of statecraft — how can you let barbarian absorption wreck the rites overnight? You will be laughed at in your own day and shamed in the histories to come. Long ago Duke Wen of Jin asked for the royal burial tunnel, and Duchess Wen of Jin refused him; King Zhuang of Chu inquired after the Nine Cauldrons, and Wangsun Man turned him back. Set the present beside those tales, and I dare say Your Majesty should not take this path. You are about to sacrifice to Min and the Fu River, pay rites at Mount Heng, climb Mount Ji, look toward Cangwu — yet you would clasp barbarian kings and alien chieftains as sworn brothers and meet them as equals under one roof. How then will you trace the wide horizon of Yu's civilizing work, or walk in the high footsteps of Emperor Shun? I hold that to answer their embassy as proposed would be a grave error; to refuse it would be the wiser course. I beg a moment of your ear to weigh this humble counsel.
53
The throne did not heed him.
54
He left court as rear general and inspector of Sizhou. Recalled to court, he was made chief rectifier of Yanzhou. When Emperor Xiaozhuang came to the throne he was offered vice minister of ceremonials but declined, and was shifted to minister of grand granaries. He died in his post.
55
Lun's younger brother En served as court attendant and outer-office gentleman.
56
Baize's younger brother Ku was inspector of Yingzhou and Marquis of Yiyang.
57
Ku's eldest son Lan rose step by step to dragon-charging general and acting governor of Guangzhou.
58
使
Lan's younger brother Xiuhu was supervisor in the directorates of herds and transport, a given-office gentleman, Duke of Shanggu, and vice minister of grand granaries. He was sent to Rouxuan to inquire into the people's hardships. He was promoted to general who pacifies the north and inspector of Yanzhou.
59
西
Du's younger brother Tai was general who stabilizes the west, inspector of Jingzhou, and Marquis of Zuyang.
60
Tai's younger brother Na was general of pacifying the distance and garrison commandant of Yongcheng.
61
Cui Xuanbo came from Dongwucheng in Qinghe. His birth name broke the Founding Emperor's temple taboo; he was sixth in descent from Wei's minister of works, Cui Lin. His grandfather Yue served Shi Hu to chief clerk of the left in the secretariat and marquis within the passes. His father Qian served Murong Hui as gentleman at the yellow gate; father and son were both famed for scholarship. In youth Xuanbo showed rare brilliance and was called the prodigy of Ji Province.
62
When Fu Rong held Ji Province he honored Xuanbo, made him gentleman of the Yangping duke's household, a Ji staff officer, and head of the eastern campaign secretariat. Whether he ran affairs in the field or sat as a companion at court, every task fell into order and no decision lagged. Fu Jian, hearing of him, summoned him as attendant to the heir apparent; Xuanbo pleaded his mother's illness and would not go, and was demoted to assistant in the office for compiling the dynastic record. When Fu Pi governed Ji Province, Xuanbo served as merit-recording staff officer on the eastern campaign — so the record runs. Hao Xuan of Taiyuan, whose house was famed for judging men, said Xuanbo had king-making talent such as the age had not seen. When Fu Jian's rule collapsed he fled between Qi and Lu and was held by the Dingling chieftain Zhai Zhao and by Zhang Yuan, rebel general of Sima Changming. Hao Xuan sighed: "A man like this in a time like this — without the wind that lifts him he must sink and rise with sparrows. What a waste!" Murong Chui then made him gentleman in the ministry of personnel, left deputy director of the secretariat, and inner magistrate of Gaoyang. In every post he won praise; upright and apart from the crowd, he kept to his books even in war and cared nothing for wealth — wife and children still knew hunger and cold.
63
使
When the Founding Emperor marched on Murong Bao and halted at Mount Chang, Xuanbo left his commandery and fled east toward the sea. The Founding Emperor had long known his name, sent riders to seize him and bring him to the army gate; they talked, and the sovereign was pleased. He made Xuanbo gentleman at the yellow gate; with Zhang Gun he shared the weight of state and drafted the founding institutions. Sima Dezong of Jin then sent envoys; the Founding Emperor meant to answer and ordered the ministries to debate the state's name at length. Xuanbo argued: "The Three August Ones and Five Emperors took their titles either from the land that bore them or from the state that first enfeoffed them. Yu, Xia, Shang, and Zhou all began as feudal lords; when sage virtue ripened and the world bowed to them, they kept the old name and did not choose another. Only the Shang moved their seat again and again and added the name Yin, yet they kept both names and did not cast off the first. Hence the Odes sing of 'the hosts of Yin-Shang' and also 'Heaven ordered the dark bird to descend and bear Shang, dwelling on the vast Yin lands.' That is the point. Han Gaozu, while still king of Han, settled the Three Qin and broke mighty Chu, and so took Han for his dynastic name. Our house holds the wide northern wastes; down to Your Majesty's dragon rise the land is old but the mandate is new — at the founding of the state Dai was renamed Wei. Murong Yong too offered up the Wei lands. Wei is a great name, the foremost state of the sacred middle kingdom — the sign of revolution, the omen of a mandate fulfilled. I humbly urge that the name be Wei." The Founding Emperor accepted it. From then on tribute from the four quarters hailed the state as Great Wei.
64
使
At Ye the Founding Emperor questioned him at length on ancient matters; his answers ran clear as water and won the sovereign's praise. On the return to the capital the court halted at Heng Ridge. The Founding Emperor climbed the ridge to comfort the newly resettled people and came upon Xuanbo helping his aged mother up the slope; he commended him and gave him grain and cattle. He then ordered carriages and oxen for any migrant who could not walk the road on his own. Xuanbo was made minister of personnel. He was charged to shape ranks and offices, draft court ritual, tune the music, set laws and bans — Xuanbo trimmed the whole and fixed it as lasting pattern. When eight ministry grandees were set to mirror the eight excellencies, Xuanbo oversaw thirty-six bureaus at large, like a chief steward running the house, and the Founding Emperor relied on him deeply. His influence bent the court. Yet he lived sparely and sought no fortune — bare walls at home; he kept no carriage and walked to court morning and night; his mother was seventy and he could not set a full table before her. The Founding Emperor once had him watched in secret; learning this he prized him the more and sent rich gifts. Some mocked his harsh thrift, but Xuanbo only grew stricter.
65
The Founding Emperor often asked him of ancient ways, of enlightened kings and their institutions, of how to settle an age. Xuanbo laid out how the ancients built government, how sage rulers and worthy ministers rose and fell — and the sovereign's mind was well met. He never spoke blunt contradiction, nor fawned for easy grace. In the Founding Emperor's last years many great ministers drew rebuke; Xuanbo alone was never faulted — and that is why. Once the Founding Emperor had him expound the Han Records; when they came to Lou Jing urging Gaozu to marry the Princess of Lu to the Xiongnu, he was pleased and sighed long. Henceforth princesses were sent in marriage to tributary states, and even sons of great houses of shining name could not wed them. When the directorate of the masters of writing was abolished he enfeoffed Xuanbo as Marquis of Baima and made him general of elite troops of Zhou, ranking with old meritocrats Yu Yue and Xi Jin — yet favor ran deeper still.
66
使
When the Founding Emperor died and Taizong had not yet been enthroned, Prince of Qinghe Shao, sensing unrest, scattered wealth and silk among the court. Xuanbo alone refused. When Taizong took the throne he kept Xuanbo at the gate department and sought his counsel with open humility; because he had refused Shao's gifts, he was specially granted two hundred bolts of silk. Changsun Song and the rest were shamed. An edict sent envoys through commanderies and kingdoms to probe lawless administrators; Xuanbo was ordered with Duke of Yidu Mu Guan and others to judge them, and Taizong praised their fairness. Again he ordered Xuanbo with Changsun Song and others to sit in the hall of court and decide criminal cases.
67
西 調 便
Taizong, seeing that great clans in the commanderies preyed on the people, issued a gracious summons to bring them to court; many clung to home while their magistrates drove them on. Then idle young men stirred one another and gathered wherever they could. Brigands rose in Xihe and Jianxing, and local chiefs could not put them down. Taizong then called Xuanbo, Duke of Beixin An Tong, Marquis of Shouguang Sun Jian, and Marquis of Yuancheng Yuan Qu and asked: "We summoned violent men to the capital because they troubled the people, yet the magistrates failed to soothe them and many fled. Now the guilty are many and cannot all be killed; I wish a great amnesty to ease the matter — what do you say?" Qu answered: "If men flee though guiltless and you pardon all the same, it will look as if the throne begs its subjects. Better execute the ringleaders first and pardon the rest." Xuanbo said: "A king rules the world with the people's peace as his root — he cannot fuss over small twists of right and wrong. When zither and lute are out of tune, they must be restrung; when laws lean awry, they must be cleared away and set anew. Amnesty is not the straight road, yet may serve as expedient; from Qin and Han on none failed to use it in turn. Qu's plan — kill first, pardon after — cannot do both; better one stroke to settle the affair. If after pardon they still do not mend, execution will not be too late." Taizong took his counsel.
68
使
At the opening of the Shenrui era he ordered Xuanbo with Duke of Nanping Song and others to sit right of the carriage-halting gate and handle the weight of state. Tens of thousands of Hu households in Bingzhou raided south into the inner riverlands; General Gongsun Biao and others marched against them and were beaten. Taizong asked the ministers: "The Hu run wild and their numbers are great; Biao and his command cannot hold them. If we do not strike soon the good people will suffer deeply. Yet it is deep autumn — we cannot for small bandits raise great armies again and ruin the people's harvest. What is to be done? (record)." Xuanbo answered: "Biao's forces were not too few; they failed in deployment, and so the small bandits caught their breath. Though the Hu are many, they have no bold master to lead them — as the proverb says, a thousand slaves share one gut. Pick a great general the Hu fear and obey, give him a few hundred riders, and send him to take Biao's army in hand — when the bandits hear of it they will break at the mere rumor. Marquis of Shouguang Sun Jian had once held Bingzhou, famed as fierce and martial; the Hu feared him and bowed, and no general could stand beside him." Taizong took his counsel and pacified the Hu raiders. Soon he was made chief of the celestial department and raised to duke.
69
In the third year of Taichang, summer, Xuanbo's illness turned grave; Taizong sent Attendant-in-Ordinary Duke of Yidu Mu Guan to take his last words and sent court attendants to ask after him again and again through the night. When he died, the throne mourned him in edict, posthumously made him minister of works, and titled him Duke Wenzhen. His funeral followed wholly the precedent of Prince of Ancheng Shusun Jun. An edict gathered every minister and attached-state chieftain to the burial; save for princes of the blood, all were made to bow and escort the bier. In the Taihe era Emperor Gaozu, recording ministers of the former court, had Xuanbo given joint sacrifice in the ancestral hall.
70
Unless for court edicts or letters to the four quarters, Xuanbo never took up the brush — and so no writings of his survive. He excelled above all in cursive, clerical, running, and draft script, and the age copied him as its model. Xuanbo's grandfather Yue and Fanyang's Lu Chen were both famed for wide learning in the arts. Chen took Zhong You as his model, Yue took Wei Guan, and both studied Su Jing's cursive until each reached its utmost subtlety. Chen passed the art to his son Yan, Yan to his son Miao; Yue passed it to his son Qian, Qian to Xuanbo — so the record runs. The craft never failed from father to son. Hence in early Wei the scripts of the Cui and Lu houses were held in highest esteem. Xuanbo's running-draft hand too was wrought to rare refinement, yet no trace of it remains. His son Hao inherited the title and has a separate biography.
71
[5] [6]
The second son, Jian, courtesy name Chongliang,[5] was also called Lan. He loved learning and in youth was famed for fine calligraphy — so the record runs. At the opening of the Founding Emperor's reign[6] he rose step by step to secretariat gentleman, general who campaigns the barbarians, five-rank marquis, and a post compiling the dynastic record. He passed away.
72
Jian's younger brother Tian, courtesy name Shuxuan, childhood name Bai — so the record runs. He rose through attendant at court audience and was granted the title baron of Yimu. He went out as administrator of Shangdang, general who pacifies the south, and inspector of Yuzhou. He was raised to marquis of Yangwu. He was executed when Hao fell.
73
[7] 祿
Early on, in the chaos of Fu Jian's fall, Xuanbo meant to flee south across the Yangtze; on Mount Tai Zhang Yuan seized him. The plan failed, and he wrote a poem to grieve himself, yet dared not let it circulate, fearing blame. When Hao was put to death, secretariat gentleman Gao Yun, ordered to seize Hao's household, first saw this poem. Yun knew what it meant; Yun's grandson Chuo copied it into Yun's collected works. Long before, Xuanbo's uncle Qian had penned in his own hand the draft eulogy for his brother Hun;[7] at the opening of the Yanchang era, assistant in the office for compiling the dynastic record Wang Zunye bought books in the market and found it. Nearly two hundred years had passed since the eulogy was written; he treasured the script and hid it away. In the Wuding era Zunye's son Songnian gave it to attendant at the yellow gate Cui Jishu, and many took copies. Left grand master of the bright hall Yao Yuanbiao, famed in his day for calligraphy, saw Qian's hand and said it surpassed his own.
74
西
Xuanbo's younger brother Hui, courtesy name Xuanyou — so the record runs. In youth he had literary gift and shared renown with Bohai's Gao Yan. At first he was summoned as vice prefect of Xiangzhou and secretariat gentleman; he rose by degrees to director of the secretariat, was granted marquis of Beiqiu, and made dragon-charging general. Prince of Le'an Fan held Chang'an; Emperor Shizu, seeing Fan was young and that Han and alien alike in the three Qin leaned on rough country and were quick to turn, chose men of old loyalty and clear virtue to stand guard with him. Hui was made regular attendant of the unimpeded cavalry, overseer of military affairs in Yong, Jing, Liang, and Qin, general who pacifies the west, deputy commander, acting tutor to the prince of Le'an, and raised to duke of Jinan. In office he kept to the great outline and did not fuss over small things. By nature he loved the weave of human ties. When he received guests he might speak of days gone by or argue the way of right, guiding the young without cease from dawn to dusk. Illness summoned him back to the capital. He died in the fourth year of Zhenjun and was posthumously titled Duke Yuan. Men of standing all sighed for him.
75
西使 使西 西
At that time Cui Kuan of Qinghe, courtesy name Jingren — so the record runs. His grandfather Tong, following Jin's Prince of Nanyang Bao, fled to Longyou and then served Juqu and Li Gao — so the record runs. His father Pou, courtesy name Bozong, burned with longing for the eastern lands and often sighed: "Wind and rain dark, the cock crows without cease — that is what I hope for." When Emperor Shizu toured west, Pou gathered men of shared intent and sent Kuan to offer allegiance. The emperor commended him, made Kuan general of awesome distance and magistrate of Qiyang, and granted him baron of Yishui. He sent an envoy west with Kuan to soothe the newly submitted. Pou was summoned to the capital but fell ill and died on the road. Emperor Gaozong, because Pou's loyalty had shone in the former reign, posthumously made him regular attendant of the unimpeded cavalry, general who stabilizes the west, inspector of Liangzhou, duke of Wuling, with posthumous title Yuan.
76
[8] 西 [9] 宿 祿 貿
Kuan returned to court as secretariat gentleman, general who pacifies the north, and baron of Anguo. Before long he went out as administrator of Hongnong. When Kuan first offered allegiance he met minister of works Cui Hao. Hao was near his age and treated him with deep kindness. When Hao was put to death, as a distant kinsman newly come from the west he alone escaped punishment. He then settled in Wucheng on the old grove of the minister of works and had one son take as wife Hao's younger brother Lan's widow, nee Feng,[8] tending one another as kin. Later Kuan inherited duke of Wuling and general who stabilizes the west and was made garrison commander of Shancheng. The two Xiao passes were steep country;[9] the people were much given to robbery. Kuan was witty by nature; he drew in local magnates and chiefs of old bandit bands, befriended them, poured out his heart, and did not spurn even small courtesies. Thus he won the people's glad hearts, and none failed to answer his spirit. At the time officials had no salary and lived only on what the people gave. Kuan was skilled at soothing them and drawing gifts of courtesy; he took much, yet those who gave bore no grudge. Moreover Hongnong was rich in lacquer, wax, bamboo, and timber, and the roads ran south with merchants. His house grew rich, yet the common people were glad of it. Among the garrisons he was called able in government — so the record runs. When he left the garrison for the capital, many followed in longing, and more than three hundred brought memorials to the palace gates. When the memorials were read, Emperor Gaozu commended him. He died in the second year of Yanxing, aged sixty-three, leaving orders for a plain burial in the clothes he wore day to day.
77
椿 鹿
His eldest son Chang, courtesy name Gongshi, inherited the title; by precedent the rank was reduced to marquis — so the record runs. From attendant-in-ordinary of the masters of writing he went out as chancellor of Pingyuan. Chang was harsh and impatient; he and inspector Yang Chun repeatedly denounced each other in memorials, and Chang was dismissed. At the opening of Emperor Shizong's reign he was made administrator of Julu. When his younger brother Fei rebelled, Chang was hidden by Huangmu army commander Han Wenshu. His whole household was registered and seized; only Chang's wife, Lady Li, as a princess's niece, kept two hundred-odd slaves with their fields and houses and was spared. In the Zhenguang era a general pardon lifted the ban; Chang recovered marquis of Qijun and was made dragon-charging general and palace scribe. In the Xiaochang era he was administrator of Zhao commandery. He passed away.
78
祿 祿
Chang's younger brother Zhong, courtesy name Gonglu, was a court gentleman in attendance — so the record runs. When Fei rebelled, because he had been given in adoption to another line he was pardoned — so the record runs. He rose through secretariat gentleman, erudite of the imperial academy, right chief clerk of the ministry of personnel, general who campaigns north, grand master of the golden seal and purple ribbon, and chief rectifier of Jizhou. After Chang died, Zhong coveted his goods and accused Chang's sons Ji and two others of not being his brother's blood; the suit dragged on for years, and gentlemen despised him. Erzhu Shilong, as director of the masters of writing, memorialized to strip him of office and bar him for life from the rolls.
79
Fei loved learning and had literary gift. He rose through supervising secretary and recorder under Prince of Jingzhao Yu. He joined Yu in rebellion and was executed — so the record runs.
80
Heng's younger brother Shu was a secretariat gentleman.
81
There was also Cui Mo, courtesy name Sifan, descended from Wei's commandant of the capital Cui Yan's elder brother Ba. His father Zun was junior chamberlain under Murong Chui. His uncle Zheng was administrator of Guangchuan. Mo, at the end of Murong Xi's reign, crossed south of the Yellow River and served Liu Yu as administrator of Xingyang, garrisoning Hulao. In the Shenqi era Pingtai was pacified and Mo surrendered — so the record runs. Later he was granted baron of Wuling and made general who extends far.
82
使
At first, while Mo was in the south, his wife Lady Zhang bore two sons, Chongzhi and Jirou. When Mo reached the capital he was given Lady Jin as wife, and she bore a son, Youdu. Chongzhi and the others, their father far away, gathered goods and through men at the border plotted to ransom Mo home. Their mother Lady Zhang would often tell them: "Your father's heart is timid and by nature he lacks resolve — he will surely not come." The envoy then brought bribes to the capital to steal Mo away. Mo did think of Youdu and the rest; he pointed at Youdu and told the envoy: "How could I abandon them to sit and suffer shame and punishment? I will find you one man whose name and rank will not fall below mine." He then handed over Shen Mo. Shen Mo had been Liu Yilong's prefect of Dongjun; with Zhu Xiuzhi he held Huatai. In the Shengui era both were taken captive and brought into Wei; each was given a wife by the court, and Mo had a son named Lingdu. When Shen Mo heard of it, he abandoned wife and children and fled south of the river. Lingdu was castrated and made a palace eunuch.
83
[11]
Mo was a generous, steadfast man who sought neither glory nor gain. Cui Hao often slighted him, yet he held firm to his principles and would not bend to Hao. He was close to Cui Lin; [11] they visited back and forth as though of one family. He died during the Heping era.
84
At the opening of Huangxing, Youdu served under Murong Baiyao as a commander. At that time Jirou was chief clerk to Cui Daogu and also acted as prefect of Jinan. As the city was about to surrender, Jirou rode ahead to Baiyao's camp; Youdu too had men posted to meet him, but their paths missed and Jirou was killed in the turmoil.
85
簿
Earlier, in late Zhenjun, the emperor marched south and took Zou Mountain. Xieli, son of Mo's brother Xie, was Liu Yilong's prefect of Lu; he surrendered the commandery, received the title Marquis of Linzi, was made prefect of Guangning, and died in that post. Xieli had two sons — so the record runs. Huaishun, whose father had come into Wei, did not enter government service. When Wei took Qingzhou, Huaishun brought Xieli's coffin home and buried him there. The younger son Ci'en rose through repeated terms as commandery chief clerk; under Inspector Lu Longcheng he rebelled, mustered men at Gaoliu north of the city, and was about to storm the prefectural seat when Longcheng attacked and killed him. Huaishun fled south of the river with Chongzhi's son Huibo and others.
86
[12] 忿
When Xieli first came into Wei, his two daughters came with him; one married into the Zhang house, one became Liu Xiubin's wife and bore a son named Wenhua. [12] Xieli later had a son by a concubine, Fashi. After Xieli's death the two daughters belittled the concubine-born Fashi and kept pressing for Wenhua to inherit their grandfather's title of Marquis of Linzi. Fashi burned with resentment and stopped at nothing. When Huaishun later returned to Wei to bring back the coffin, he and Fashi met for the first time. Before long Fashi succeeded to the title; the line reached his grandson Yanzu, who in the Zhengguang era was champion general and palace scattered grandee.
87
Jirou's grandson Mu, in the third year of Zhengguang, came back from Yuzhou and surrendered.
88
Mo's grandson Jingmao served as vice-prefect of Jizhou, chief clerk of Qingzhou, prefect of Suijun, and Baron of Wucheng.
89
Jingmao's son Yanyuan succeeded. In the Wuding era he was vice marshal of northern Xuzhou — so the record runs.
90
[13] 西西
When Mu first surrendered, [13] he came with Zhang Ling of Gaoling and Guo Yun. Ling had been western-pavilion libationer on Xiao Baoyin's western campaign staff; when Baoyin rebelled, Ling became his yellow-gate attendant. After Guanzhong was pacified he returned to Luoyang and served as palace gentleman and vice-prefect of Dingzhou. When Duke Wen of Qi took power as chancellor, he took Ling into his entourage for his literary gifts. He ended as general who pacifies the south and chief clerk of the ministry of works. Posthumously he was made grand general of agile cavalry and minister of grand granaries.
91
姿
In Xianzu's reign there was Cui Daogu, styled Jijian, eighth in descent from Cui Yan. His grandfather Qiong was chariot-and-horse attache to Murong Chui — so the record runs. His father Ji moved south to Qingzhou and served as prefect of Taishan. Daogu was a son by a concubine; his elder half-brothers Youzhi, Mulian, and the rest looked down on him. Ji told Youzhi: "This boy's talent and judgment are such that he may yet lift our house — why do you treat him so lightly?" Youzhi and the others treated him all the more coldly, with hardly a trace of brotherly regard.
92
駿 駿 便駿 駿 便 簿
At that time Liu Yilong's son Jun held Xu and Yan provinces and could take men from other regions onto his staff. Ji supplied Daogu with funds and sent him south to enter service. On reaching Pengcheng, Jun made him a staff attendant. Daogu was handsome and carried himself well, skilled in archery and horsemanship and fond of military affairs; Jun came to think well of him. As the new Qingzhou inspector passed through Pengcheng, Jun said to him: "A man like Cui Daogu — how can he waste his life as a nobody? Yet the world, seeing him as a concubine's son, heaps insult on him — it is a pity." When the Qingzhou inspector took office, he made Daogu chief clerk and later chief administrator. He later served on the staffs of Yilong's sons and was sent to Qingzhou to raise troops. The chief clerk and all below came to Daogu; his brothers forced his birth mother to serve wine and food to the guests with her own hands. Daogu started up in alarm and took the tray from her, telling the guests: "We have no household staff; my mother herself does the hard work." The guests all knew what his brothers had done and rose to bow to his mother. His mother told Daogu: "I am not fit to receive such guests — you must bow in my place." The guests praised mother and son and despised the brothers.
93
Later he was made general who calms the north and inspector of Jizhou and shifted his command to Licheng. After Liu Yu killed Ziye and seized the throne, Xuzhou inspector Xue Andu joined Daogu and others in raising troops for Ziye's nephew Zixun. When Zixun fell, Daogu sent in his allegiance; Xianzu made him general who pacifies the south, southern Jizhou inspector, and Duke of Qinghe. Liu Yu sent envoys to win him back, offering the posts of former general and Xuzhou inspector. He rebelled again and took Yu's orders.
94
使 [14]
At the opening of Huangxing, Xianzu ordered southern campaign grand general Murong Baiyao to tighten the siege around him. When Baiyao assaulted the eastern suburb of the city, Daogu came out bound and pleaded guilty, writing: "I was born in the south, cut off from your transforming rule; yet your court, though I was low-born, gave me a frontier command. When the Liu house turned on itself I feared execution; I sent Cui Qizhi with a memorial of surrender, and Your Majesty in extraordinary mercy accepted me and granted rank — joy beyond measure — and I should have hurried to court. But Liu Yu soon sent envoys again and spared me from a hundred deaths. Foolishly I reasoned that, having served Liu for generations and already been spared after grave offense, to rebel again would dishonor your court even as I sought favor from Great Wei. One may call that clinging to life, but I feared Wei would not allow it. So I wavered, turned my back on heaven's light, risked death ten thousand times, and held the city in stubborn defiance. Your servant Baiyao, [14] has shown his awful might; for nearly two years his great army has sat before the walls — on the fourteenth of this month my eastern suburb fell — and by that, I trust, my loyalty to Liu Yu stands clear before Great Wei. My strength was spent; on the seventeenth I came out bound to plead guilty, and Baiyao, executing imperial grace, spared my life. This is truly Your Majesty raising the dead and putting flesh on dry bones — what heaven and earth could not do, Your Majesty has done. Even Yu Shun's sparing of You Miao and King Wen's pardon at Chong's fortress cannot match such grace. Not having yet received court orders, I cannot come in person; I respectfully send my eldest son Jinghui, offering my body to the court to lie beneath the axe."
95
西 西西
Soon Baiyao sent Daogu to the capital; the ministries investigated and reported up, and an edict spared his life. Several hundred leading families of Qing and Qi who had held the city with him were moved to Sanggan, and Pingqi commandery was set up northwest of Beixin cheng near Pingcheng. Daogu was made prefect, enfeoffed as Marquis of Linzi, and given the added title general who calms the north. Soon the commandery seat was shifted west of old Yinguan, over two hundred li southwest of the capital. Famine followed famine; the commandery starved. Though Daogu held office for years, he could not ease every district, and rebellions multiplied. He died in Yanxing at fifty.
96
When Daogu was a guest at court he lodged beside Xue Andu and Bi Zhongjing; they met at morning levees. All three had risen through military service and were old colleagues. By then Andu's spirit was failing and his warmth toward Daogu had cooled, while Zhongjing was unfailingly attentive. Daogu told Liu Xiubin and Fang Fashou: "The ancients said, 'Those not of our kind will surely differ in heart' — and it is true. Andu looks on people coldly; Bi Naya still clings close."
97
His son Jinghui, styled Wenrui, succeeded to the marquisate of Linzi and was given the added title general who calms the north. He served as eastern-campaign vice marshal on Guangling Prince Yu's staff in Qingzhou and as vice minister of the grand court. He was then made dragon-charging general and inspector of Pingzhou. He died; posthumously he kept his former rank and was named southern Qingzhou inspector, with the posthumous name Ding. His son Xiuzuan succeeded.
98
Jinghui's younger brother Jingye, styled Wenji — so the record runs. He earned separate merit; in the Taihe era he was made Marquis of Changguo and general who establishes might. He passed away. His son Xiuxu succeeded and served as outer-office gentleman.
99
Jingye's younger brother Jingyuan also won separate merit and was made Baron of Wucheng. He was eagle-brandishing general and prefect of Pingqi — so the record runs. He died in office.
100
[15]
Sengyou was son of Daogu's brother Mulian. When Baiyao besieged Licheng, Sengyou's mother, Lady Ming, and his brother Sengyuan were inside the walls. Liu Yu made Sengyou auxiliary-state general at the head of several thousand men; with Qing and Qi kin still in Licheng and Liangzou — Ming Tongqing, Ming Pusa, and others on his staff — he marched from Huaihai shouting rescue. Near Buqi he learned that Daogu had fallen and that his mother and brother were already in Wei; he halted and would not go on. When Baiyao besieged Dongyang, he asked that Jinghui be sent to win over Sengyou; Sengyou then surrendered. Baiyao sent him to court; after several years as a guest he was enfeoffed as Marquis of Tiered City. He was at odds with Fang Fashou, Bi Sa, and the rest. [15] Fashou and others charged that his surrender was insincere; he was held more than a year and freed only by a general amnesty. Later he was convicted of plotting rebellion with the monk Faxiu and was executed.
101
His son Daoning served as palace attendant.
102
殿 [16]
Sengyuan came into Wei lands; on account of his brother he was exiled to Boguli Garrison and at the opening of the Taihe era was allowed to return. Gaozu heard of his scholarship, questioned him on Buddhist sutras, and found him skilled in debate; he ordered that though still in lay dress Sengyuan receive a black cap and attend lectures in the Yongle Jingwu Hall. Later he was made gentleman of the protocol section in the secretariat. After the capital moved to Luoyang he served as chief rectifier of Qingzhou. Soon he left court as staff counselor to the eastern campaign grand general, Prince of Guangling Yu, with the added title general of illustrious martiality; he attacked sea bandits at Huangguo [16] and routed them. Xiao Luan then sent his elder clansman Huijing with a letter to Sengyuan, pleading the wrong of his coming into Wei and urging him to change his course. Sengyuan wrote back:
103
[17][18] [19]
Our lord's nature as a man leaves no dark place unlit and no small thing uncared for; in kindness there is no distance he cannot reach, in learning no canon he has not mastered — he has drained the subtlety of the Three Storehouses and the limits of the Nine Mounds. His woven prose blazes with color like the wall of the Master himself. He opened a solitary clarity of mind, traced the tracks of former kings, settled the wild marches, foretold change in the imperial foundation, renewed the central lands, and made his seat on the Yi banks. The three lights shone again with renewed splendor; the myriad things received a second birth. He sorted clans and fixed descent, grading households into first and second ranks; he arrayed offices and granted noble ranks, clearing the thread of the nine currents. Ritual and custom blazed back to life; between the Yellow and Luo the Zhou Way rose again. Lane songs and district hymns, radiant courts and tranquil gates — such flourishing cannot be told in full. Add generation upon generation of doubled glory, a domain holding the four sacred peaks, strong hosts and rich stores, men and spirits rejoicing — virtue, the Way, benevolence, and righteousness beyond naming. When a great man appears he has no fixed birthplace — how much more one who descends from the highest sage to Heaven's grandson? [17] The sovereign's younger brothers share one bearing; from the Prince of Xianyang down, none without surpassing talent; branches and leaves spread through the realm — that their fame is already fading [18] is far too soon. Scholars contend in counsel at court, soldiers show courage on the marches — [19] judge the true situation and this is fact.
104
[20] 便
Weigh that lord's usurpation and murder — known to men and spirits alike; suspicion of kin and mistrust of the noble were long ago plain far and near. Elder brother, to set your heart on rebellion — what name will stand for a thousand years? When things have no place to be used and vessels are unfit for the age, to live without stirring the world and die without a fair name — the ancients called that base, gentlemen called it shame. Here affairs are tight and arts spent; urging oneself on brings no gain — hence the proper course. With your talent, elder brother, you have long outshone our homeland — who like me does not look up to you? I never dare forget our old bond. Though two thousand li lie between us, in thought we meet as face to face; reverently I follow your example for my whole life. Now fame could be raised yet you cannot honor your kin; affairs could be changed yet you cannot shake off disgrace — that is what the age cannot understand. A gentleman at home is filial to his kin; in court he is loyal to his lord — no more. The sovereign's treatment of you, elder brother — grace that cannot be repaid, righteousness that cannot be betrayed. One's person may be given up — that is not repayment; merit does not stretch so far — that is not return. Now you could act loyally and again you will not — that is unfilial. Judged by fact, elder brother, can your refusal to change count as loyalty? As for drilling in arms and contending for mastery, you have long been unmatched; weigh safety against peril and the unlike cases have been proved; the crowd's heart has turned away — to stand alone is error. [20] I beg you to weigh this deeply. Wang Yan cut off every outside tie; his talent was not bold and bright; clinging to glory and nursing hope, he was at once put to the sword. Compared with you, elder brother, he was not one part in a hundred. Moreover the Huai frontier and the coastal garrisons bred northern champions — could you, elder brother, escape the Shouchun command? On that ground suspicion is already fixed. Moreover the house is still young; north and south have nowhere else to lodge — to whom but you, elder brother, can the weight of the founding be entrusted? The glory of receiving a fief — my humble heart has long looked for it. Now you cling to your resolve without waking, forgetting both filial piety and loyalty — Wang Yan's guilt, how could he save himself? To act when the moment shows itself — is it not now?
105
西 [21] [22] 調
The state from Chang'an in the west to Jimo in the east has forged armor and weapons to utmost solidity and keen edge, day and night without cease these several years. This mid-autumn the cloud-net will surely be cast; goods that miss the season, though precious, are not used — if you do not plan early, how will you answer for a city worth a thousand? [21] Mei Cheng said: wanting to go out yet not going out — no room for a hair between — how fine that saying! Your younger brother was struck down at the northern capital and personally bore penal summons; that the great grace reached me was luck won. Lately I have been raised again and again by clear selection, more than once — [22] the heart of dog and horse truly has its master. Though we now stand on opposite sides, the old feeling is unchanged — how much more so today? As elder brother teaches, as younger brother urges — to change the tuning is easier than turning the palm; if feeling should once go wrong, that will be fate.
106
He left court as dragon-charging general and inspector of Southern Qingzhou. After long service he was convicted of campaigning out without warrant, investigated and imprisoned; later he was released.
107
Sengyuan's first wife, the Fang clan, bore two sons, Bolin and Boji. Later he slighted the Fang and married the Du of Pingyuan. When Sengyuan was exiled he went with Du and she bore four sons — Bofeng, Zulong, Zuchi, and Zuqiu. After he returned he cast off the Fang and made his home in Qingzhou with Du and the four sons. Boji lived with his mother the Fang in Jizhou; though he visited his father, his heart stayed with his mother — filial kindness was cut off within one household. Sengyuan died aged over seventy. Bolin hurried to the funeral but dared not enter the house and wept at a Buddhist temple.
108
Bolin rose from court attendant to infantry commandant and governor of Leling, with the added title general of the central guard. Later he also served as chief clerk of Jizhou — so the record runs. When the Dacheng rebels rose, Bolin led the provincial army against them at Zhushao and was killed; he was posthumously made dragon-charging general and governor of Luozhou.
109
Boji was legal-affairs staff officer to the Prince of Jingzhao, Yu. When Yu rebelled, Boji refused to follow and was killed; an edict posthumously made him governor of Donghai.
110
便 歿 [23]
Bofeng from youth was skilled with bow and horse; grown, he was bold and powerful. From court attendant and outer-office gentleman he rose step by step to general who pacifies the distance and forward general and several times held field command. At the end of the Yong'an era he held Dan Valley with area commander Yuan Zigong and died in battle. The text is deficient — so the record runs.
111
Zulong was a staff officer in the ministry of works. Harsh and impetuous by nature, after his father's death he sued his elder brother Bolin over legitimacy of birth, each keeping sword and blade as against an enemy.
112
Zuchi, childhood name Sheke, was rough and martial and strong in the arm. Inspector Yuan Luo installed him as acting commander-in-chief and led troops against sea bandits. At the opening of the Putai era he rebelled with Zhang Senghao and besieged Qingzhou. Erzhu Zhongyuan sent a general to crush them; their heads were sent to the capital.
113
Zuqiu from youth loved learning; he studied behind closed curtains and did not vie with the world. Recommended as cultivated talent, he would not take office.
114
Sengyuan's younger cousin He was governor of Pingchang — so the record runs. The house was immensely rich yet he was stingy by nature and buried cash in hundreds of hu. His mother Chunsi longed for purslane; he begrudged the money and would not buy it.
115
His son Gui, styled Qize, stole a million in cash and fled, abandoning He. Later he was armor-office staff officer to a ceremonial peer with open office; convicted of corruption, he died at Jinyang.
116
Dong Mi came from Xuanbo's commandery. Mi's father Jing, with Cui Kangshi of the same commandery, Huo Yuan of Guangyang, and others, all spread the fame of great learning through Liaohai. Mi loved learning and inherited his father's craft. When Zhongshan was pacified he entered court as gentleman of the protocol section and drafted the rites for court audience, banquets, suburban sacrifice, and the altars of soil and grain.
117
使 使
Deng Yuan, styled Yanhai, came from Anding. His grandfather Qiang was chariot general under Fu Jian — so the record runs. His father Yi was governor of Hejian — so the record runs. When Murong Chui besieged Ye he made Yi rear general, inspector of Jizhou, and Marquis of Zhending. Yi wept and told the envoy: "My late father was loyal to Qin — how could Yi be the first to rebel? A loyal minister does not serve two lords — that is the constant rule since antiquity; I dare not accept the order." Chui sent an envoy to persuade him: "Your grandfather the chariot general and I became sworn brothers of different surnames; you are like my own son or younger brother — how can you refuse?" Yi said: "Jizhou should go to kin and the worthy; let Yi serve in another post and offer his life." Chui then used him as general of establishing martiality, governor of Hejian, and left deputy director of the secretariat — in each post he won praise. He died as inner governor of Zhao commandery — so the record runs.
118
Yuan was upright and plain by nature, his words and conduct trustworthy; he ranged widely through the classics and excelled in the Changes and divination. When Taizu pacified the central plains he was raised to gentleman of the composition office. He went out as magistrate of Puqiu, cut down the crafty and violent, and cleared away bandits. Recalled to court, he was made gentleman of the ministry of personnel. Yuan had a clear grasp of institutions and old precedent; with Cui Xuanbo of the Masters of Writing he shaped court ritual, statutes, music, and the military and state archives, edicts and policies — most of it was Yuan's hand. On the Pingyang campaign he was enfeoffed as Marquis of Hankang, then made Marquis of Xiabo and general of the central rampart. The Founding Emperor charged Yuan to compile the national record; he drafted more than ten scrolls of year-by-year court affairs only, without a settled form. Yuan was exacting in court affairs and never crossed the sovereign's will.
119
His father's younger cousin's son Hui was a gentleman in the Masters of Writing — violent, restless, and close to Marquis of Dingling He Ba. When Ba was put to death for his crimes, his kin fled to Chang'an; someone said Hui meant to smuggle them out. The Founding Emperor then suspected Yuan had known and had Yuan put to death — and afterward regretted it. All who heard of it mourned him.
120
鹿 使
His son Ying succeeded to the title. He studied at the Imperial Academy and rose step by step to secretariat attendant. Emperor Shizu ordered Grand Minister of Ceremonials Cui Hao to gather scholars to compile the dynastic history; Ying joined Hao's brother Lan and others on the work. When the court visited the southern desert, the Gaoche chief Mofu Kugan brought tens of thousands of riders driving more than a million deer to the encampment. Ying was ordered to write and set up an inscription in the southern desert to commemorate the feat. He was also made acting regular attendant and sent as envoy to Liu Yilong. He was raised to marquis and made dragon-charging general. In Yanhe year 3 he joined the campaign against the Hu rebel Bai Long. He died on the march home. His posthumous name was Wengong.
121
His son Yi succeeded. He rose to Jingzhou inspector and acting pacifying-south general. He was enfeoffed as Duke of Nanyang. He died in the Heping era — so the record runs.
122
His eldest son Liangnu succeeded. Liangnu's younger brother attended Emperor Gaozu and was given the name Shu. He served in civil posts and was praised for upright care. He was promoted to grand master of the palace and acting vice director of the court of justice. He went out as general who establishes loyalty and Qi inspector. At the first reshaping of the hundred offices, chief aides to the great ministries were given new weight. When Grand Tutor Yuan Pi went out as Bing inspector, Shu was made his chief clerk and concurrently Taiyuan administrator. Soon he was recalled as chief clerk to the minister of works and died in his post. The throne granted one hundred thousand cash and fifty bolts of cloth; his posthumous name was Zhen.
123
His eldest son Zuan was a court attendant and rose to grand master of the palace.
124
西
Zuan's younger brother Xian was court attendant, sacrifier in the minister of works' western pavilion, outer regular attendant, and Heyin magistrate. Soon he was made general who pacifies the distance and remonstrance and policy grand master. Late in Emperor Suzong's reign he was made champion general and Ying inspector. At the opening of Jianyi, when he heard Erzhu Rong had entered Luoyang and courtiers were being killed, he fled to Xiao Yan.
125
Yi's younger brother Zongqing, starting as a secretariat student, entered service as central court attendant. He rose step by step to the Masters of Writing, was given acting regular attendant, and enfeoffed as Marquis of Ding'an. He was shifted to director of the southern bureau. Zongqing spent years in the southern bureau and filed many memorials; provinces and garrisons feared him and called him fit for the post. He was raised to Duke of Nanyang, made pacifying-south general and Jing inspector, then enfeoffed as Duke of Zhao Commandery. In his province the people brought suit against Zongqing; though investigation proved the charges, he and they were utterly estranged. He was moved to Xu inspector while keeping the same army title. Before long his wife Han was found guilty of witchcraft and he was put to death.
126
Zongqing's son Boxin died with him.
127
祿
Boxin's son Yan fled south and survived. Later he was a Masters of Writing gentleman, then Changshan administrator, then pacifying-south general, grand master of splendid virtue, bearer of the staff, acting left deputy director of the Masters of Writing and mobile headquarters for Yingzhou, and again pacifying-army general. He died and was posthumously made pacifying-south general and Jing inspector.
128
Ying's younger brother Quan followed Emperor Shizu in war and rose to dragon-charging general, Yu inspector, and Marquis of Xinye. On the Rouran campaign he was executed for a breach of law.
129
His younger brother Hao died while secretariat attendant.
130
[24]
Hao's eldest son Lingzhen was a secretariat student and [24] secretariat central court attendant. He died and was posthumously made outer acting regular attendant.
131
使
His son Xian served as secretariat student and attending censor and was known for sharp judgment and care. He went out as chief clerk on Prince of Wuchang's campaign staff as general who campaigns against the barbarians. When Li Yuanhu later held Qi, Xian stayed as chief clerk and concurrently eastern Wei commandery administrator. Ten years in office under three inspectors, he was famed for clean, tireless service. The people of Qi cherished him and called him a true two-thousand-dan magistrate. On his recall he accepted heavy farewell gifts from the people, and his reputation suffered for it. Prince of Zhongshan Ying attacked Yiyang; Xian served as army supervisor. When the campaign ended he was made remonstrance and policy grand master and acting attendant at the yellow gate, assisting You Zhao as metropolitan envoy. Later he bribed Recording Masters of Writing Prince of Beihai Xiang and was moved to vice minister of the grand granary. He handled Jingzhou affairs, then was made general who campaigns against the barbarians and Ying inspector, garrisoning Yiyang. In his province he was fierce in levying taxes. He also bribed Yu Zhong and was recalled as attendant at the yellow gate. Soon he was made rear general and Henan intendant while keeping the yellow gate post. Before he could take up the post, Empress Dowager Ling held court; Yuan Zhao was made Henan intendant while Xian stayed at the yellow gate and was given pacifying-south general. For his service as Yiyang army supervisor, Xian was enfeoffed as Viscount of Anyang, estate three hundred households. Xian courted those about the throne, and so won the fief. You, Ying, Cang, and Ji then suffered great floods, repeated raids, and famine among the people. Xian was made acting Masters of Writing and acting regular attendant, bearer of the staff sent through the provinces to relieve distress where needed, and helped many. At the opening of Shengui an abscess broke out and he died at fifty-four. The throne granted three hundred bolts of silk for the funeral and one court robe; posthumously he was made pacifying-east general and Qing inspector, posthumous name Gong.
132
His eldest son Ji, styled Bosheng, had real ambition. He was a secretariat gentleman. Court debate held that Xian had not truly earned a territorial fief, so Ji was not allowed to succeed. Ji pleaded at law for a long time before succession was finally granted. He rose step by step to front general, grand master of the palace, and chief clerk of the Liang headquarters. He and Inspector Yuan Luo alike fell to Xiao Yan and died in the south.
133
His son Xiaoxu, in the Yuanxiang era, brought Ji's coffin home. In the Xinghe era he succeeded to the title. When Qi took the throne, the rank was reduced by rule.
134
Lingzhen's younger brother Lingqi was general who establishes loyalty and Qi inspector. His title was raised to champion general and he was enfeoffed as Marquis of Changguo. His rule was plain and clean, with both sternness and grace.
135
祿
His son Gongbo was right grand master of splendid virtue.
136
輿
The historiographer writes: To govern a state and tend its people, none can do without both civil and military craft. Yan Feng's wide learning won Emperor Zhaocheng's courtesy; he soothed neighbors and kept the state whole — the work of a worthy man. Xu Qian united talent and method; in the hurrying days of crisis he alone saw the hour and urged advance — as if fate itself had marked him. Zhang Gun was prized for talent and counsel and favored early; in an age without gentle government, his words drew reproach. Xuanbo's clan was great for generations and still stood at the founding; he carried the state's pivot, held the straight course and finished the work — rites worthy of the ancestral temple: could it have been otherwise? Cui Kuan and Cui Mo alike saw the hour and moved; when the Way was shut they still pledged their allegiance. Deng Yuan was upright in office and skilled with the brush; his fall was not his crime — a bitter loss!
137
Textual notes
138
Gongda gave himself to Wei Wu. In various editions "da" is written as "yuan"; Cefu juan 765 〈folio 9095〉 has "da". Note: Xun You's style was Gongda 〈Records of the Three Kingdoms, juan 10〉 ; among Cao Cao's famed counselors no "Gongyuan" is known — emended per Cefu.
139
"Yan's younger brother Baize": editions insert sun (grandson) after yan; Northern History juan 21, Zhang Gun's life, has Du's son Baize—so he is Yan's younger brother, not his grandson. The character sun is redundant and is removed.
140
使
"The common people are hard to tell apart": the line does not follow from what precedes. Cefu, scroll 541 〈folio 6485〉 has "would it not also be hard to distinguish," completing the earlier clause about quiet affairs, a clear government, simple tasks, and delegated responsibility—likely the right reading.
141
"Before the water mirror, ritual propriety": Cefu (record). 〈same scroll, same page〉 shui (water) appears as yong (lasting); yong is likely right.
142
"The second son Jian, styled Chongliang": Northern History juan 21, Cui Hong's life, reads chong (rush) as zhong (second). Note: Jian's elder brother Hao was styled Boyuan 〈juan 35, main biography〉 , and younger brother Tian was styled Shuxuan; as the second son, Jian should be styled Zhongliang.
143
"At the beginning of Taizu": Zhang Senkai writes that Xuanbo joined Wei only in Taizu's middle years, so Jian could not have entered service at Taizu's opening—likely a mistake for Taizong or Shizu.
144
"Drafted his brother Hun's eulogy in his own hand": editions corrupt lei (eulogy) to zhu (execute); emended from Northern History juan 21.
145
"One son succeeded to Haodi Lan's wife, Lady Feng": Northern History juan 21 inserts yu Hao after Hao, making "one son succeeded to Hao" the clause. Two characters may be missing, but the passage still makes sense and is left unchanged.
146
西
"Made defender of Shancheng, with the two Xiao passes steep": editions add xi (west) after zhen and drop er (two)—clear errors; emended per Cefu juan 412 〈folio 4898〉 and Northern History juan 21 — so the record runs. Northern History reads er (two) as san (three); Cefu is followed.
147
[]
"Brevet general, made inspector of Taizhou": editions read tai (Tai) as qin (Qin). Note: "the people of Hedong were famished" points to Qinzhou at Pobo in juan 106b of the Terrain Treatise—here Qinzhou should be Taizhou. Here too qin (Qin) corrupts tai (Tai). The text is corrected. See collation note [39], juan 106b.
148
[]
"Close to Cui Ze": editions corrupt ze (Ze) to yi (Yi); emended per Muzhi jishi, epitaph of Lu Lingyuan 〈plate 37〉 The change is adopted. See collation note [11], juan 32.
149
"His son Wenhua": juan 43, Liu Xiubin's life, has Wenhua as Wenye—ye is likely right.
150
殿 殿
"When Mu first surrendered": patchwork, Southern, Ji, and Bureau texts read mu (Mu) as lu (Lu); Northern and Palace editions have mu. Note: Above reads "Rou's grandson Mu, in Zhenguang 3, surrendered from Yuzhou." Mu is correct; the Northern and Palace texts are followed.
151
"Servant-minister Baiyao": Cui Daogu could not have addressed Baiyao that way. Juan 50, Murong Baiyao's life: during the Qing-Qi campaign he was right vice director of the Masters of Writing. Here the character she (director) has dropped after pu (vice).
152
"At odds with Fang Fashou, Bi Sa, and others": no Qing-Qi defector named Bi Sa is known—sa likely corrupts xue (Xue), i.e., Xue Andu.
153
"Subdued sea bandits at Huangguo": editions corrupt zei (bandit) to jie (warn); emended per Cefu juan 372 〈folio 4424〉 The change is adopted.
154
"Moreover the great man's emergence had no fixed place—how much less from sage to sage down to the Son of Heaven's line?": Cefu juan 372 〈folio 4425〉 has "Moreover the great man's emergence had no fixed place; how much less, sage after sage, down to the Son of— 〈Song Cefu reads "Heaven" here〉 the Son of Heaven's descendants?" The Cefu wording is clearer; this passage is corrupt and incomplete.
155
"What is named is nearly spent": editions corrupt jie (exhaust) to xie (scorpion); emended per Cefu 〈same scroll, same page〉 The change is adopted.
156
"Warriors prove brave on the frontier": editions corrupt yong (valor) to tong (through); emended per Cefu 〈same scroll, same page〉 The change is adopted.
157
"All turn away while one alone stays—that is absurd": Cefu 〈same scroll, same page〉 "turn away" appears as "all go," pairing with "alone remains" below—likely right. "Turn away" also makes sense and is left unchanged.
158
"How much more when whole cities are wrongly condemned": Cefu 〈same scroll, same page〉 kuang (how much more) appears as chen (sink); chen is suspected. The Song Cefu also reads kuang; the text is not changed.
159
"Promotions beyond number": editions corrupt chao jin (advance in rank) to qi ya (rise cliff), with a marginal "suspected"; emended per Cefu 〈same scroll, same page〉 Corrected, and the marginal "suspected" is removed.
160
歿
"With supervisor Yuan Zigong he held Dangu and died in battle": editions read Dangu as Shanfu; Cefu juan 425 〈folio 5055〉 has Danfu. Note: Yuan Zigong's defense of Dangu is in Zhuangdi annals, juan 10, Yongan 3.10, and his biography, juan 41. Zhuangdi annals, Yongan 3.12 renyin, is explicit: "Erzhu Zhao attacked Dangu; supervisor Cui Bofeng was killed in battle." Cefu's dan is right; gu (valley) had already become fu (father). The archetype should have matched Cefu; later copyists also changed dan to shan (single)—now corrected.
161
"Student of the Masters of Writing": editions omit shu (writing) after zhong. Note: "student of the Masters of Writing" is common; the entry on Zi Xian below says "served as student of the Masters of Writing"—shu is restored.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →