← Back to 魏書

卷98 島夷蕭道成 島夷蕭衍

Volume 98: Xiao Daocheng of the Daoyi People, Xiaoyan of the Daoyi

Chapter 104 of 魏書 · Book of Wei
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 104
Next Chapter →
1
Xiao Daocheng of the Daoyi People; Xiao Yan of the Daoyi People.
2
Xiao Daocheng of the Daoyi People, whose courtesy name was Shaobo, came from the Chu district of Wujin in Jinling commandery. During the pseudo-Jin regime, the eastern quarter of Wujin was established as Lanling commandery and county, and his family thereafter counted as natives of Lanling. His father Chengzhi had long campaigned at the side of his kinsman Xiao Sihua and only after many years became Sihua's marshal of the horizontal field army; for his military service he entered the employ of Liu Yilong and eventually reached the post of General of the Right.
3
駿 駿
Daocheng took to military affairs from youth. He began among the miscellaneous ranks and was repeatedly sent on campaign, serving in succession as a junior commander against the southern tribes, and won notice for his stamina under harsh and demanding assignments. When Sihua took up his post at Xiangyang, he had Daocheng brought along in his train and placed him in charge of the garrison forces. He was promoted in time to Army Aide in the central corps of the Left Army. On the frontier he repeatedly harassed the border population; at Tan Embankment he once met a crushing defeat and fled the field. Under Liu Jun he held a series of frontier posts in the puppet administration, rising as far as magistrate of Jianye. After Jun's death, Ziye appointed him General of the Rear Army and gave him a place in the Direct Attendance.
4
西 便
When Ziye died, Liu Yu named him General of the Right. At that time Zixun, Prince of Jin'an and inspector of Jiangzhou, Zifang, Prince of Xunyang and grand administrator of Kuaiji, and others all took up arms. Yu promoted Daocheng to Supporting-the-State General and sent him east on campaign, where he pacified the counties in revolt. Yuan Biao, grand administrator of Jinling, Gu Chen of Wu commandery, and Wang Yunsheng of Wuxing all abandoned their posts and fled. At that time Xue Andu, inspector of Xuzhou, sent his nephew Suo'er at the head of picked troops across the Huai, and Daocheng was called up to oppose him. For his service he was enfeoffed as Marquis Who Establishes the State, with Xiyang county as his fief and an income of six hundred households. Zixun sent Zhang Yan, interior secretary of Linchuan, in through the eastern passes intending to unsettle the Three Wu region. Liu Yu dispatched Daocheng with three thousand men to take overall command under the army commander Shen Siren and block Yan, who fled at once. After Zhang Yong and Shen Youzhi were routed at Pengcheng, Liu Yu appointed Daocheng Champion General with authority over all military affairs, granted him provisional credentials, and posted him to garrison Huaiyin.
5
便
After Yu's death, Ziyu named Daocheng General of the Right Guard and Commandant of the Guard, added five hundred men to his command, and had him join Yuan Can, Director of the Masters of Writing, Chu Yuan, Protector of the Army, and Liu Mian, Director of the Army, in directing court affairs. Before long he was relieved of the guard commandancy, made a Palace Attendant, and stationed at Stone City. Liu Xiufan took up arms on the pretext of punishing Wang Daolong and his faction. After several days of preparation he marched south at the head of a vast army. Daocheng and his colleagues led their forces out to meet them in battle. Once the revolt was suppressed, Daocheng was appointed Regular Attendant of the Scattered Cavalry and Central Army Director, given overall command of Southern Yanzhou, Yanzhou, Xuzhou, Qingzhou, and Jizhou, and named Pacifying-the-Army General and inspector of Southern Yanzhou, retaining his credentials and marquisal rank. He was later promoted to duke, with two thousand additional households added to his fief.
6
殿 殿
As Liu Yu's cruelty grew worse by the day, Daocheng joined Wang Jingze of the Direct Attendance and Yang Yufu, a member of Yu's personal staff, in a plot to kill him. They installed his younger brother Zhun on the throne and changed the era name to Shengming—the first year of our Taihe era. Daocheng shifted his base to the eastern city and entered the palace hall escorted by fifty armed men. He was promoted to Palace Attendant, Minister of Works, and recorder of the Masters of Writing, named Rapid Cavalry Grand General with full credentials and provincial command, and his former enfeoffment as Duke of Jingling was increased by five thousand households. Thirty ceremonial sword-bearers were assigned to him, and he was given supervision over Yuzhou and Sizhou as well. Shen Youzhi, inspector of Jingzhou, took up arms against Daocheng, who in response led his forces into the court hall and made it his command post. Yuan Can, Minister of Works, had earlier been posted to Stone City. Holding the fortress, he joined Liu Bing, Director of the Masters of Writing, and Wang Yun, former inspector of Xiangzhou, in a plot against Daocheng and sent secret messages urging Youzhi to march down at once, planning to serve as his allies within the capital. The plot failed. Can and his son Zui were both killed. Bing and his son climbed over the wall and fled toward E'yan Lake; Wang Yun fled toward the drill ground. All were taken prisoner. Youzhi reached Xiakou, was defeated, and fled. He and his third son Taihe, a gentleman of the Secretariat, rode south alone to Huarong county, where both hanged themselves. Daocheng was next appointed Grand Commandant, his fief was increased by three thousand households, he was given forty ceremonial sword-bearers, and a hundred armed men were authorized to enter the palace hall with him.
7
殿使 殿
As Daocheng was preparing to seize supreme power, Wang Jian, Palace Attendant to Zhun, asked for a private audience and urged him on. Daocheng said, "What is it you wish to say? I shall now lay the matter before you as it stands." His words were stern, but his face showed unmistakable pleasure. Jian worked on those in high office until they assented, and Daocheng was then granted the yellow battle-axe, supreme command over all armies at home and abroad, the title of Grand Tutor, and the governorship of Yangzhou. He was allowed to wear sword and shoes in the hall, to enter court without hastening his step, and to be addressed without his name in congratulatory obeisance. Four chief clerks and marshals were appointed to his left and right, with four attendant gentlemen, clerks, and aides each. He retained provisional credentials and continued as Palace Attendant, Grand Commandant, Rapid Cavalry Grand General, recorder of the Masters of Writing, and inspector of Southern Xuzhou. Daocheng pretended to decline these extraordinary honors. The earlier appointments were confirmed anew: sword and shoes in the hall, no need to hurry in court audience, and no naming in congratulatory obeisance. He was promoted to Chancellor of State with authority over all government affairs. Ten commanderies were enfeoffed to him as Duke of Qi with the full ceremony of the Nine Bestowals, including the imperial seal ribbon and the Far Roaming cap, placing him above all princes, with the green ribbon of the chancellorship. He retained his titles as Rapid Cavalry Grand General, governor of Yangzhou, and inspector of Southern Xuzhou. He then established the Qi Terrace, appointed the full bureaucracy, made the eastern residence his Qi palace, added ten more commanderies to his domain, and was advanced from duke to king. Before long he seized the imperial title for himself, enfeoffed his former sovereign Liu Zhun as King of Runan, and Zhun died not long afterward.
8
西[1] 西 西[2]
Thereupon Emperor Gaozu ordered Prince Jia of Liang commandery to lead two generals out from Huaiyin, Prince Yuan Chen of Longxi with three generals from Guangling, [1] and Duke Xue Huzi of Hedong with three generals from Shouchun to campaign against him. Yuan Chen and his colleagues attacked the Matou garrison and captured it. Daocheng sent his inspector of Xuzhou, Cui Wenzhong, to take the Chamei garrison. An imperial edict then dispatched You Minggen of the Masters of Writing to campaign against him. He further sent Pacifying-the-South General Lang Datan with three generals from Xucheng, General Bai Tutou with two from Haixi, General Yuan Tai with two from Lian Estuary, General Feng Yan with three from Jiaocheng, and Pacifying-the-South General Heluo from Xia Cai. Cui Huijing, Daocheng's inspector of Liangzhou, sent his chief clerk Pei Shubao at the head of a force to attack Wuxing Pass City. The Di chieftain Yang Shu routed them, and Shubao retreated to Nanzheng. Prince Jia of Liang commandery defeated Daocheng's generals Lu Shaozhi and Xuan Yuandu at Xushan. The commander of the Xia Cai garrison abandoned the fortress and fled. Another edict appointed Prince Feng Xi of Changli commander of the western route and sent him with Campaigning-the-South General Huan Dan out from Yiyang, while Pacifying-the-South General Heluo marched east from Xia Cai toward Zhongli. Daocheng's Mobile Corps General Huan Kang, posted at Huaiyang, [2] was defeated. Yuan Chongzu, Daocheng's inspector of Yuzhou, attacked Xia Cai, but Prince Feng Xi of Changli routed him. Prince Jia of Liang commandery inflicted a major defeat on Daocheng's forces, took more than twenty thousand captives, and sent them to the capital.
9
使
Daocheng sent Che Senglang, an aide in the Rear Army, to present tribute at our court. Earlier Liu Zhun had dispatched the envoys Yin Lingdan and Gou Zhaoxian, but before they could return Daocheng had seized the throne. When Senglang arrived, the court seated him below Lingdan. Senglang and Lingdan quarreled over precedence, and the defector Xie Fengjun drew a blade at the court assembly and killed Senglang. An edict ordered full funeral honors and had his remains sent home.
10
When Daocheng died, his son Ze seized the throne and changed the era name to Yongming. Ze sent his Valiant Cavalry General Liu Zuan and Former Van General Zhang Mo to present tribute at our court. In the eighth year he again sent the concurrent Extraordinary Master of the Scattered Cavalry Sima Xian and the concurrent Extraordinary Gentleman of the Scattered Cavalry Yu Xi on a presentation mission. In the ninth year he sent Supporting-the-State General Liu Zuan and Direct Communication Gentleman Pei Zhaoming on a tribute mission. In the tenth year he again sent Zhaoming together with Champion Army Aide Sima Dizhi on a tribute mission.
11
殿
When Ze was still crown prince he was extravagantly wasteful, and Daocheng more than once considered deposing him; only Wang Jingze's mediation kept the peace. Ze was grasping by nature and often remarked to others, "Only Cui Huijing understands how poor I am." Ze once visited the home of his inspector of Yizhou, Liu Jun, and napped there through the day. When he woke, Jun himself presented a gold washing basin three feet across, while a favorite concubine held a gold ewer of four sheng to pour the rinse water, and the two of them made him this gift. Ze accepted the gift. Such was his greed for gain. Ze hunted without restraint. His Palace Army General Handan Chao submitted a memorial of remonstrance, and Ze had him executed.
12
In the thirteenth year he sent Pacifying-the-South Army Aide Yan Youming and Supernumerary Attendant Liu Sixiao on a tribute mission. In the fourteenth year Ze's son Zixiang, Prince of Badong, killed chief clerk Liu Yin and marshal Xi Gongmu and plotted to assassinate Ze. Ze sent Xiao Shunzhi, governor of Danyang, to campaign against him and put him to death. In the second month of the fifteenth year he sent Extraordinary Master of the Scattered Cavalry Pei Zhaoming and Extraordinary Gentleman of the Scattered Cavalry Xie Jun on a tribute mission. In the ninth month he again sent Minister of Works Aide Xiao Chen and Fan Zhen on a tribute mission. In the sixteenth year he again sent Chen with Minister of Works Aide Fan Yun on a tribute mission, and also dispatched Rapid Cavalry Merit Officer Yu Bi and Southern Yuzhou registrar He Xian. In the seventeenth year Wang Huan, Ze's inspector of Yongzhou, and Liu Xingzu, chief clerk for the Southern Man, quarreled over the culpability of the local population. Ze had Xingzu imprisoned and ordered him sent back to Jianye. Huan promptly killed him in prison and reported that he had died by his own hand. Ze in his anger sent his Direct Attendance General Cao Daogang and Cao Hu, inspector of Liangzhou, to seize Huan, who shut the city gates and resisted. Marshal Huang Yao raised forces inside the city and attacked Huan, killing him. Huan's son Su, a secretariat assistant, and Su's younger brother Bing came over to our side.
13
殿 殿
When Ze's son Changmao died, he named Changmao's son Zhaoye, Prince of Nankun, as grand heir. When Ze fell gravely ill and briefly lost consciousness, his son Ziliang, Prince of Jingling, was in the hall but Zhaoye had not yet arrived. Wang Rong, a gentleman of the Secretariat, appeared at the Secretariat gate in military dress and blocked the Eastern Palace guard from entering, intending to install Ziliang on the throne. Once Ze had regained consciousness, Zhaoye entered the hall. Seeing that Ziliang could not be enthroned, Rong changed out of his military dress and returned to his office.
14
西西 便
When Ze died, Zhaoye ascended the throne. Within a fortnight he had Rong arrested, handed over to the Minister of Justice, and executed. Zhaoye had been raised from birth by his uncle Ziliang. Yet he feigned virtue while secretly nursing base desires, sharing food, clothing, bed, and waking hours with some twenty worthless hangers-on of his personal staff. His wife, of the He clan, chose the best-looking among them and took them as lovers. In secret he extorted untold sums from wealthy merchants. As long as he still lived under the same roof as Ziliang, he could not indulge himself as he wished. After Ziliang moved to the western residence, Zhaoye lived alone in the Western Quarter. Each night he would open the rear gate and roam with his low companions to the various barracks and offices for unrestrained debauchery. He promoted every scoundrel in turn, promising that their appointments would take effect the day he faced south as emperor. He wrote out each office and title on yellow slips, which they tucked into pouches and wore at their elbows. Zhaoye's tutor Shi Renzu and the attendant scribe Hu Tianyi heard of these goings-on and said to each other, "If we report this to the two palaces, the matter will not be easily settled. But if at the barracks we are beaten by strangers, or mauled by dogs, the blame will not fall on us alone—our whole households will be destroyed as well. We are each past seventy. Is life so precious that we should cling to it?" Within a few days Renzu and Tianyi both took their own lives.
15
輿 西 使殿西 [3]
From the onset of his father Changmao's illness until his death, Zhaoye played the dutiful mourner in public, wailing beyond all propriety. Back in his private quarters he laughed and drank with his favorites, feasting on every delicacy. After the funeral he was named imperial grand heir. He cut a passage through the wall from his mother's apartments to Madame He's quarters and would stay there for hours on end whenever he went. When Ze visited the Eastern Palace, Zhaoye came forward to bow and wailed until he fainted, only to revive again. Ze stepped down from his carriage to embrace him and lavished extraordinary affection upon him. Earlier, while Zhaoye was in the Western Quarter, he had the witch Yang perform prayers to hasten his ascent to the throne. When his father died he credited Yang's magic and redoubled his devotion to her. Yang's son Min was also handsome, and Madame He was especially fond of him. Zhaoye addressed the witch Yang as "Granny." Since the Liu dynasty the people had also sung the ballad "Granny Yang's Boy"—no doubt for this very reason. While he was in the Eastern Palace and Ze fell ill, he had the witch Yang pray day and night for Ze's swift death. In a letter to Madame He he drew one large character for "joy" on the paper, ringed by thirty-six smaller "joy" characters. Ze believed Zhaoye could shoulder the great inheritance and told him: "These five years I have left everything to the chancellor; you have paid little heed yourself. After five years, do not hand affairs over to others again." On his deathbed he took Zhaoye's hand and said, "Child, if you remember your father, you must govern well." He said this twice, then died. Ziliang was then at the Secretariat. Fearful of him, Zhaoye sent Tiger Guard Commander Pan Shu with a hundred men to hold the western steps of the Hall of Supreme Ultimate as a precaution. [3] When the grand encoffinement began, he called Ze's musicians to play every sort of music. Though they obeyed out of fear, all wept and could hardly sing. Once the mourning rites were finished, he dismissed every prince to his own house. Ziliang pleaded repeatedly to stay until after Ze's funeral, but was refused.
16
便殿殿 便便 便 綿 綿 [4]
Zhaoye had long been devoted to hounds and horses. Less than ten days after his accession he tore down Ze's Zhao Wan Hall, gave the timbers to the eunuch Xu Longju for a private house, and turned the ground into a riding ring. He fell in a gallop and cut both face and brow, then pleaded illness and stayed away for days. He collected celebrated hawks and fleet hounds and fed them grain and meat. As Ze's funeral was about to leave the palace, before the bier had passed the Duan Gate Zhaoye feigned illness and went back inside. Hardly within the private apartments, he had barbarian musicians play; drums and cymbals thundered through the palace. The Minister of Works Wang Jingze asked the Commandant of Archers Xiao Tanzhi, "With things like this, should it not be a bit too soon?" Tanzhi replied, "That is surely just the palace women's wailing echoing everywhere." After the funeral Zhaoye slipped out in disguise to wander the streets and markets, and often visited his parents' tombs to join low companions in vulgar games, mud-throwing, gambling, hawking, and dog-racing—making such outings his daily habit. Great and small matters of state all fell to the Minister of Works Xiao Luan. Ze had once hoarded wealth: the upper treasury held five hundred million cash and the fasting treasury three hundred million, with gold, silver, silks, and brocades beyond reckoning. By year's end more than half was gone, lavished on lackeys and runners. By the time he was deposed, the treasuries were utterly bare. Inside the palace Zhaoye habitually dressed in purple brocade, red embroidery, motley finery, or a cap of figured silk. Editorial note [4].
17
便 殿
The reign era was changed to Longchang. Zhou Fengshu, Gentleman of the Yellow Gate, was made Champion General and Governor of Qing Province. Fengshu won favor through sycophancy, which delighted Zhaoye, but he grew domineering and unchecked. He habitually carried twenty swords, passed freely through the inner gates, and no guard dared challenge him. He liked to boast, "Young Zhou's blades do not recognize you." Xu Longju, once a fasting tutor in the Eastern Palace, rose by smooth flattery. He devised depravity to please his master, and every vulgar excess was Longju's doing. Zhaoye installed women and musicians for Longju, who lived permanently in the Hall of Manifest Pattern, wore a yellow silk cap and sable fur, faced south at the desk, and drafted imperial orders for him. Attendants waited on him as on the emperor himself. Xiao Luan pressed hard for his execution; Min and his mother were imprisoned and put to death as well. Min and his mother enjoyed Zhaoye's special favor; gifts to them emptied the treasury. Min was Madame He's favorite and always waited on her inside the palace. Luan first had the Commandant of the Guard Xiao Chen and the Northern Campaign Adviser Xiao Tanzhi seek Min's death. Madame He sat beside Zhaoye, weeping with her face covered, and told Tanzhi, "Young Yang is still a boy and guilty of nothing—how can you kill him unjustly!" Tanzhi then whispered to Zhaoye, "There is another purpose here; no one must hear of it." Zhaoye called to Madame He, "Dear, get up and leave us for a moment." Tanzhi then said, "Outside everyone says Young Yang and the empress are lovers. The rumor has spread everywhere. Nothing like this has ever been heard, and it will ruin the court." Zhaoye reluctantly agreed and soon issued a pardon—but the execution had already taken place. Liu Jun of Yi Province, returning after his term, was arrested because his gifts to the throne were deemed meager, sent to the Minister of Justice, and marked for execution. His brother Hui, a Secretariat Gentleman, offered his own life in exchange; Jun was spared but imprisoned for life. Zhaoye slept with his father's concubine Huo and brought her into the inner palace. Xiao Luan plotted deposition and entered the palace at the head of his forces. Zhaoye was then naked with Huo. Hearing soldiers approach, he seized a sword to resist Luan, and Luan killed him. A dozen or so of his attendants were killed.
18
使 殿 使
Luan set up Zhaoye's younger brother Zhaowen and took for himself the posts of Bearer of the Staff, commissioner over Yang and southern Xu, General of Agile Cavalry, Director of the Masters of Writing, and Governor of Yang, with thirty ceremonial swords and the title Duke of Xuancheng at two thousand households. He marched out to hold the eastern city with five thousand men. He executed the Prince of Poyang, Qiang, and the Prince of Sui, Zilong. He dispatched Wang Xuanyao to kill the Prince of Anlu, Zijing, Governor of southern Yan; Wang Guangzhi to kill the Prince of Jin'an, Zimao, Governor of Jiang; and also killed the Princes of Nanping, Jinxi, and Yidu, who held Xiang, Ying, and southern Yu. Luan received the yellow battle-axe and was promoted to commissioner over all armies at home and abroad, Grand Tutor, commander-in-chief, and Governor of Yang; his ceremonial swords rose to forty, with imperial parasols and drums fore and aft; he might enter the hall armed and shod, approach the throne without hurrying, and be hailed in obeisance without his name; he was made Prince of Xuancheng with a fief of five thousand households; his posts as Bearer of the Staff, Director of the Secretariat, and Director of the Masters of Writing were unchanged. He also killed Zhaowen's kinsmen: the Princes of Guiyang, Hengyang, Jiangxia, Luling, Jian'an, and Baling. He deposed Zhaowen to Prince of Hailing, who soon died. Luan then usurped the throne himself.
19
使
Luan, courtesy name Jingqi. His uncle Daocheng loved him more than his own sons. In Ze's last years he was Left Vice Minister of the Masters of Writing and enjoyed exceptional trust. After Ze's death he seized control of the government. Once Zhaoye was dead he ruled with savage monopoly and exterminated Ze's descendants. He soon took the throne himself in the eighteenth year of Taihe and proclaimed the era Jianwu. His Director of Virtue Liu Langzhi and Mobile General Liu Zhuanzhi were stripped of office and imprisoned for failing to support a nephew, who was forced to remarry with his mother. Contemporary opinion held that the decay of family duty began with Luan.
20
西
Luan executed the Princes of Xiyang, Nanhai, and Shaoling—Ziming, Zihan, and Zizhen.
21
西
In the twenty-first year our emperor marched against Luan. Luan's former Van General Han Jifang, Governor of Yiyang Wang Sizhi, Rear General Zhao Yueyue, and fifteen other commanders defected to us. Our forces routed Luan's army north of the Yangzi and took his general Wang Fubao among others. The emperor then toured the eastern Han valley and withdrew. Luan's general Wang Tanfen led over ten thousand men against southern Qing Province; Cui Sengyuan, commander of Huang Guo garrison, crushed them and took all captive. Our troops also took Xinye and beheaded Luan's Supporting State General and Governor of Xinye, Liu Ji. Luan's garrison chiefs Cai Daofu at Huyang, Cheng Gongqi at Zheyang, Hu Song, Huang Yaoqi at Wuyin, Bao Ju, and Nanxiang governor Xi Qian all abandoned their posts and fled; Yaoqi and Ju were seized.
22
西[5]
Luan also executed the Princes of Hedong, Linhe, Xiyang, Hengyang, [5] Xiangdong, Nan commandery, Baling, and Guiyang—Xuan, Ziyue, Ziwen, Zimin, Zijian, Zixia, Zhaoxiu, and Zhaocan.
23
The emperor went to Nanyang, stormed Wabei north of Wan, captured it, and Fang Boyu, Champion General and Governor of Nanyang, surrendered. At Deng city he again routed Luan's Pacifier of the North Cui Huijing and the Gentleman of the Yellow Gate Xiao Yan, taking more than twenty thousand heads and captives. Luan, stricken with fear, then fell seriously ill. He declared a general amnesty and changed the era to Yongtai. His Grand Marshal Wang Jingze rebelled at Kuaiji to kill Luan, but Northern Garrison Adviser Xie Tiao, Jingze's son-in-law, betrayed him; Jingze was defeated and killed.
24
[6]
After Luan's death his son Baojuan usurped the throne. In spring of the twenty-third year Baojuan adopted the era Yongyuan and sent Grand Marshal Chen Xianda with Cui Huijing against Macheng; our court ordered Former Van General Yuan Ying to oppose them. Baojuan sent troops to harass Shunyang; an edict dispatched Inspiring Awe General Murong Pingcheng with cavalry to repel them. Xianda took Macheng; the emperor marched south, and an edict ordered Prince Jia of Guangyang, Pacifying South General, to hold Jun Ford. Xianda was beaten, broke out by night, and fled; his Left Army General Zhang Zishun [6] was slain, and rebel commanders Cai Daofu, Cheng Gongqi, and tens of thousands more abandoned Shunyang and ran.
25
Baojuan was deranged and cruel; power lay with a clique of low favorites. His Prince of Shi'an, Yaoguang, seized the Eastern Mansion in revolt, failed, and was executed. He also killed the Right Vice Minister Xiao Tanzhi, Left Guard General Cao Hu, and Army Commander Liu Xuan. Soon after he executed Minister of Works Xu Xiaosi, Left Vice Minister Shen Wenji, and former Pacification Army chief clerk Shen Zhaolue. His Grand Marshal and Governor of Jiang, Chen Xianda, marched on Jianye, failed, and was killed.
26
[7]
Early in Jingming, Baojuan's Governor of Yu, Pei Shuye, surrendered Shouyang. Baojuan sent his Commandant of the Guard Xiao Yi as Pacifying the Barbarians General and Governor of Yu to march on Shouyang by land and camp at Little Xian. Our court sent Army Supervisor Li Huan and commanders Xi Kangsheng and Yang Dayan with troops into Shouyang. Prince Xi of Pengcheng, General of Agile Cavalry, and Wang Su, General of the Chariots and Cavalry, marched with a hundred thousand infantry and cavalry to relieve the city. Baojuan sent Hu Song and Li Jushi with over ten thousand men to hold Sihu, while Chen Bo's fleet advanced up the Huai to threaten Shouchun. Xi and Su routed them and took ten thousand heads. Chen Bo raided Huainan again; Xi beat him at Fei Ford. Our Governor of Yu, Tian Yizong, defeated Baojuan's generals Wu Ziyang and Deng Yuanqi at Changfeng. Editorial note [7].
27
便
Baojuan sent Palace Attendant Cui Huijing to lead the armies by water from Guangling toward Shouyang. Seeing Baojuan's madness and cruelty, Huijing knew he could not long survive; once given independent command he marched gladly. His son Jue, then in the Direct Attendance, arranged a secret rendezvous with him. When Huijing reached Guangling, Jue slipped out and joined him. A few dozen li past Guangling, Huijing wheeled his army about. The post lacked a commander; Chief Clerk Cui Gong admitted him, and he crossed the Yangzi to strike Jianye. Baojuan shut himself in the capital to defend it. Baojuan's Governor of Yu, Xiao Yi, defeated Huijing, seized him, and executed him.
28
便 西便 輿輿
With Huijing dead, Baojuan did as he pleased without restraint, roaming abroad daily. His favorites Ru Fazhen and Mei Chong'er, with edict-runners and sword-bearers of the inner service, held the realm's power; folk called them the "Blade Edicts." Baojuan often rode out lightly armed in military garb to their houses for drinking bouts. Whenever they had weddings or funerals Baojuan appeared in person, but cleared the streets so no one could watch, leaving only empty houses behind. His destinations were never fixed, and officials lived in dread of giving offense. A procession to the east meant clearing the western streets; setting out south meant emptying the north. If he might ride out at dawn, the night before brought forced evacuations. Runners dashed through the city, cries filled every road, and people of every age fled in panic, weeping until the ways were choked; barriers rose on every side, and none knew which way to turn. The seriously ill were hauled away in sedan chairs; those with no bearers crawled along the ditches while overseers flogged them, and corpses lined the route. He seldom returned to the palace before midnight, and his attendants looted wealthy households until nothing remained. Wang Jingbin, former governor of Weixing, had just died and lay unburied; his kin were driven away and could not keep vigil. When they returned, rats had devoured both his eyes—a horror repeated more than once. Baojuan's tyranny deepened. Though Minister of Works Xiao Yi had rendered great service, Baojuan slew him out of jealousy, together with his brother Xiao Chang, Commandant of the Guard.
29
[8]
Our Emperor Shizong ordered Champion General Xi Fayou, Governor of South Yu, to invest thirty thousand troops against Baojuan's Hu Jinglue—Assistant General and governor of North Xincai and Anfeng—at Jian'an.[8] The city fell and Jinglue was taken prisoner.
30
使
Xiao Yan, Baojuan's governor of Yong, seized Xiangyang and marched against him; Xiao Yingzhou, acting governor of Jing, joined the rebellion. In the third month Yingzhou turned on Baojuan and enthroned Prince Baorong of Nankang as emperor. Baorong then usurped the throne. Yingzhou became Palace Attendant and Minister of Works; Yan was appointed Left Vice Director, supreme commander of the punitive armies, and Grand General Who Pacifies the East, retaining his credential-bearing commission. Yingzhou asked to reduce Baojuan to Marquis of Yuyang, but Baorong refused and instead made him Prince of Fuling. Yingzhou took overall command of eight provinces and served as acting governor of Jing. Yan was granted the ceremonial yellow axe. When Xiao Yan's forces reached Hankou, the governor of Ying walled the city and held out.
31
[9] 殿
Baojuan executed Prince Zhaozhou of Baling, Marquis Zhaoxiu of Yongxin,[9] and Gentleman of the Yellow Gate Xiao Yin. As Baojuan's madness and cruelty mounted, the court and populace could endure no more. Former governor of South Qiao Wang Lingxiu and others at Stone City rallied Baojuan's brother Baoyin, marched the garrison toward the imperial city, and were joined by tens of thousands of unarmed townspeople. Night fell before they arrived; the gates were shut and the rising failed. As Xiao Yan approached Jianye, garrisons along the route abandoned Baojuan and submitted. Rebel troops burst into the palace while Baojuan lounged in the Hall of Contained Virtue, piping and singing in a woman's voice, not yet asleep. Hearing soldiers enter, he ran for the north gate to reach the inner quarters, but the Pure Radiance Pavilion was already barred. Eunuch guard Huang Taiping slashed his knee; Baojuan fell and cried, "The slaves have turned on me!" Attendant Zhang Qi struck off his head and sent it to Xiao Yan, who posthumously named him Marquis of Eastern Darkness and reduced empress and heir to common rank. Xiao Yan executed Baojuan's brother Prince Baozhi of Xiangdong, then Prince Baoyou of Shaoling, Prince Baosong of Jinxi, and Prince Baozhen of Guiyang; Prince Baoyin of Jian'an fled to our side. He soon forced Baorong to abdicate, made him Prince of Baling, and imprisoned him at Gushu. Baorong was murdered shortly afterward.
32
祿
Xiao Yan of the Daoyi People, courtesy name Shuda, likewise came from Wujin in Jinling commandery. His father Shunzhi had served Xiao Ze as Grand Master of Splendid Happiness. As a young man Yan was flighty and glib, entered service under Wang Jian's Rear Army, and rose to be Gentleman of the Yellow Gate and Junior Mentor to the Heir under Xiao Luan. In Taihe year 22 our Grand Emperor marched south and ordered a siege of Xiangyang. Yan came to its relief, was broken by Valiant Guard General Yuwen Fu, and escaped only by fleeing alone on horseback.
33
西西
Near the end of Luan's life Yan was posted out as Assistant General and governor of Yong. After Luan's death Baojuan took the throne, executed Yan's brother Yi, and dispatched Liu Shanyang, governor of Baxi and Zitong, westward—ostensibly to assume his posts, in truth to attack Yan. Shanyang was cut down at Jingzhou by Xiao Yingzhou. In Jingming year 2 Yan and Yingzhou enthroned Baojuan's brother Baorong, governor of Jing, proclaimed the era Zhongxing, and marched against Baojuan. That December they seized Jianye and killed Baojuan together with his family. Yan became Grand Marshal, Recorder of the Masters of Writing, and governor of Yang, enfeoffed as Duke of Jian'an with ten thousand households. The next year he declared himself chancellor and governor of Yang, taking ten commanderies as the Liang princedom.
34
[10]
He soon usurped the throne, named his dynasty Liang, and adopted the era Tianjian. In the fifth month Dang Fazong, commander of the Little Xian garrison on Yang, stormed Yan's Great Xian fort, routed the garrison, and sent the captive Dragon Cavalry General Zhu Pusa to our capital. Yan sent Zhang Xiao against Yang Province; our provincial troops defeated him and took more than two thousand heads. In the fourth year, third month, Prince Cheng of Rencheng, governor of Yang, sent Changfeng garrison chief Qi Daoxian against Yan's Yinshan fort; the fort fell and Dragon Cavalry General Mei Xingzu, Marquis of Duting, was beheaded; then stormed White Reed garrison, killed Pacifying the North General Wu Daoshuang and others, and took several thousand heads. Yan posted his Xu chief clerk Pan Bolian at Huailing and governor Sima Mingsu on Jiushan; Cheng's forces crushed both columns, killed Bolian, and seized Mingsu. Yan's Wu Ziyang raided Baisha; Prince Ying of Zhongshan routed him and took thousands of heads. Zhai Yuan, Yan's governor of Liang and Marquis of Pingyang, and Chen Huya, governor of Xu and Marquis of Yongchang, defected to our court. Editorial note [10].
35
In the twelfth month Xiahou Daoyuan, Yan's acting governor of Liang and Qin, surrendered Hanzhong; our court ordered Minister of Works Xing Luan to march to his support. In the second year, fourth month, Luan repeatedly routed Yan's forces, forced Jianmen Pass, and sent the captive Assistant General Fan Shinan to our capital. Luan then sent Commander Wang Zu to shatter Yan's columns and behead Assistant General Feng Wenhao and others. In the sixth month Yan's Wang Chao-zong raided the frontier; Governor Xue Zhendu of Yang crushed him and took three thousand heads. In the seventh month Wang Zu again routed Yan's main force, executing governors Lu Fangda and Wang Mingda of Qin and Liang and more than thirty other commanders, with twenty-five hundred prisoners. In the ninth month Yang Gongze of Xiang led a force against Shouchun; Yuan Song, governor of Ying, drove him off and took several thousand heads.
36
[11] 宿 [12] 宿 沿
In the third year, first month,[11] Yan's Xu governor Chang Yizhi struck Liang city and Jiang governor Wang Maoxian opened a drive on Jing, encamping at Henan city. Pacifying the South Chen Bozhi broke Chang Yizhi while Pacifying the South Yang Dayan shattered Wang Maoxian; both victories cost Yan Assistant General Wang Hua and two thousand killed or captured. Maoxian fled to the Han, and five cities were recovered. General Yuwen Fu harried Yan's Si province, took more than a thousand captives, and withdrew. In the fifth month Xiao Bing of Yan struck Huaiyang, Zhang Huishao Suyu, Xiao Mi Liang city, and Wei Rui Hefei. Pacifying the South Xi Kangsheng routed Huishao and killed Xu governor Song Hei. In the seventh month Yan's Xu governor Wang Bo'ao invaded Yinling; Prince Ying of Zhongshan annihilated him, taking twenty-five commanders' heads and five thousand prisoners. Yan posted Huan He on Gushan, Champion Huan Fangqing on Gucheng, and Dragon Cavalry Jiao Daoyi on Mengshan. In the eighth month Pacifying the East Xing Luan struck Huan He and broke his camp. General Yuan Heng seized Gucheng;[12] Commander Bi Zuxiu took Mengshan; slain, captured, and drowned along the Yi exceeded four thousand. Yan re-established Zhang Huishao at Suyu and Xiao Bing at Huaiyang. In the ninth month Commander Xing Luan crushed them, killing great general Lan Huai-gong and thirty-odd others; Huishao and Xiao Bing abandoned their forts and fled south, and the pursuit left tens of thousands dead. Yan's Central Army commander Prince Mi of Linchuan, Right Vice Director Liu Yan, and Xu governor Chang Yizhi held Liang city; Prince Ying of Zhongshan shattered them. Mi and the rest fled down the Huai; our troops chased them to Matou, where garrison chief Zhu Siyuan abandoned his post; thirty-odd Yan generals were taken and casualties passed fifty thousand. In the tenth month Ma Xianbi of Yan led thirty thousand against Yiyang; Lou Yue, governor of Ying, repelled him with provincial troops.
37
[13] 西西
In the second year, first month, Prince Ying of Zhongshan stormed Yan's Changbo garrison, inflicting tens of thousands of casualties; [13]he pressed on to take Wuyang Pass, seizing Cloud Cavalry General Ma Guang, Marquis of Songzi, Champion Peng Fan, Viscount of Qianling, Valiant Cavalry Xu Yuanxiu, Earl of Dangyang, and twenty-six other commanders, with over seven thousand prisoners; then advanced on the western gate of Huang Pass; Ma Xianbi abandoned the west gate and Li Yuanlu fled Huang Pass.
38
In the fourth year, third month, Wang Wanshou of Langye and his fellows slew Yan's Liu Xi—Assistant General, governor of Langye and Dongguan, and commander of Mount Yang garrison—along with forty-odd officers, and surrendered the city to us. Xu governor Lu Chang dispatched Zhang Tianhui, deputy of the Yancheng garrison, to reinforce them; Yan's Yuzhou had already sent two columns against Tianhui, who joined Wanshou in a pincer that cost the enemy hundreds of lives. Chang sent Langye garrison chief Fu Wenji to hold the town; Yan countered with Zhang Ji, Ma Xianbi, and others to besiege him. Our court ordered Chang forward, but Wenji, his grain exhausted, surrendered to Yan; Chang withdrew in defeat.
39
[14]
In Yan-chang second year, second month, Xu Xuanming of Yuzhou killed Yan's Pacifying the North Zhang Ji, governor of Qing and Ji, sent his head to us, and surrendered the province. In the third year, sixth month, Yan raided Jiushan; Jing governor Huan Shuxing routed them,[14] killing Tiger Guard Cai Lingsun, Champion Xi Shixing, and Upright Righteousness Lan Cisun. In the fourth year, fourth month, Yan's Ning governor Ren Taihong struck Guancheng; Yi chief clerk Cheng Xingsun repulsed him.
40
西忿
In Zhengguang 1 Yan adopted the era Putong. In year 3 his nephew Marquis Zhengde of Xifeng defected, then fled back; Yan first changed his surname to "Back" in anger, then relented and made him Prince of Linhe. In the ninth year, fifth month, Yan's Pei Sui and Yu Hong seized Shouchun's outer ramparts; governor Chang Sunzhi expelled them.
41
退
In Xiaochang 1, first month, Xu governor Yuan Faseng rebelled and held the southern city; Yan sent Prince Zong of Yuzhang to hold Pengcheng—Zong was Baojuan's posthumous child. When Yan took Jianye he took Baojuan's consort Lady Wu, already pregnant; she later bore Zong, whom Yan claimed as his own and cherished. When Zong came of age his mother revealed his true parentage; he plotted against Yan, and once posted to Pengcheng he deserted to our army when we marched against him. The other commanders fled; our forces pursued and took tens of thousands. Yan first wailed until he fainted, then, mortified, still called Zong his son and blamed "wind sickness"—to the mockery of all.
42
[15] [16] [17]
In the third month Yan's Xi Xiuru of North Liang, Marshal Yu He, and Shangyong governor Jiang Pingluo raided Zhicheng; Liang governor Fu Shuyan sent his son Jingshao to crush them, taking three thousand heads; the survivors fled. In the fourth month Yi governor Xiao Yuan-you sent Fan Wenchì to besiege Little Sword garrison;[15] Yi governor Bing Qiu sent his son Zida, and mobile headquarters Wei Zijian sent detached commander Chunyu Dan to meet them. In the fifth month Chunyu Dan shattered Wenchì's army, killing twenty thousand and capturing twelve subordinate commanders including Xiao Shicheng;[16] Wenchì himself escaped. That year Yan adopted the era Datong. Editorial note [17].
43
In the second year, seventh month, Yan's Yuan Shu and Zhan Sengzhen struck Shouchun. They also threatened Xinye; our court ordered Commander Wei Chengzu to rout them. In the third year, third month, Cheng Jingjun of Yan raided Pengcheng; mobile headquarters Cui Xiaofen and his commanders repelled him.
44
In Yongxi 1, summer, Yan's Prince Yuan Shu of Ye and Qiao governor Zhu Wenkai seized Qiao city; Southeast Route commander Fan Zihu retook it and sent Shu, Wenkai, and their fellows to our capital.
45
[] [18]
In Tianping 1, tenth month, Yan's Trustworthy Faith General Ji Geng raided a frontier post whose name is damaged in the manuscript; Commander Cao Zhongni routed him and killed army masters Shen Da and Min Zhuang. In the second year, first month, Zhan Sengzhen of Yan invaded South Yan Province and was beaten by provincial troops. Mobile headquarters Yuan Yan again defeated Sengzhen at Xiangcheng and took his prefect Yang [name damaged in manuscript]. In the second month Si governor Chen Qingzhi and Ying governor Tian Putè raided the frontier; Yu governor Yao Xiong repulsed them. In the fifth month Ren governor Huang Daoshi struck North Jiyin; Xu governor Ren Xiang defeated him. In the tenth month Liang Bingjun of Yan raided Shanfu; Ren Xiang annihilated him, taking more than ten thousand heads. In the eleventh month Yong governor Xiao Gong sent Liu Zhongli against Jing; Jing governor Wang Yuan-gui crushed him at Niuyin, killing Zhang Zhi and Wang Shixing. That year Yan renamed his era Zhong Datong. [18]In the third year, fifth month, Yu governor Yao Xiong stormed Yan's Baigoudui fort, seized it, and took North Ping governor Gou Yuankuang prisoner. In the tenth month mobile headquarters Hou Jing stormed Yan's Chucheng and took Chu governor Huan He and his brothers prisoner. In the fourth year, ninth month, Yan's Qing-Ji governor Xu Ziyan raided Yucheng; South Qing governor Lu Jingyuan repelled him.
46
[19] [20] [21] 使
Earlier Yi governor Fu He had surrendered his city to Yan; Yan sent him back with gifts to convey overtures to Duke of Qi Xianwu Wang Gaohuan and seek friendly ties. Our sovereign wished to pacify the distant marches and asked that this be allowed. In the fourth year, winter, Yan sent attendant cavalier Zhang Gao and direct-attendants Liu Xiaoyi and Cui Xiao to present tribute. In the second year, summer,[19] he again sent attendant cavalier Shen Shanqing and direct-attendant Liu Yan to present tribute. In Xinghe 2, spring, he again sent attendant cavalier Liu Bao and direct-attendant Liu Jingyan to present tribute. That winter he again sent attendant cavalier Lu Yanzi and direct-attendant Shen Jinghui to present tribute. That year Yan adopted the era Datong. [20]In the third year, summer, he again sent attendant cavalier Ming Shaoxia and direct secretary Xie Zao to present tribute. In the fourth year, spring, he again sent attendant cavalier Yuan Xia and direct-attendant He Wenfa to present tribute. That winter he again sent attendant cavalier Liu Xiaosheng and direct-attendant Xie Jing to present tribute. In Wuding 1, summer, he again sent attendant cavalier Shen Zhong and direct-attendant Yin Deqing to present tribute. That winter he again sent attendant cavalier Xiao Que and direct-attendant Lu Mian to present tribute. In the third year, autumn, he again sent attendant cavalier Xu Junfang and direct-attendant Yu Xin to present tribute. In the fourth year, summer, he again sent attendant cavalier Xiao Chang and direct-attendant He Deyang to present tribute. In the fifth year, spring, he again sent attendant cavalier Xie Lin[21] and direct-attendant Bao Zhi to present tribute. Our court also sent envoys in return. For more than a decade the southern marches knew peace.
47
[22]使 使
In the sixth year Yan renamed his era Zhong Datong, then Taiqing within the same year. [22]That year Minister of Works Hou Jing rose in rebellion, sent envoys to Yan, and begged for rescue. Yan, swayed by Jing's blandishments, broke off tribute missions. Yan's son Gang and the ministers urgently warned against it; Yan refused to listen. He then sent his nephew Yu governor and Marquis of Zhenyang Yuanming, North Yan governor Hu Guisun, and others against Xuzhou in concert with Hou Jing, and dammed the Si to flood Pengcheng. Prince Wenxiang of Qi sent mobile headquarters Murong Shaozong, Senior Pallad Gao Yue, Pan Xiangle, and others to campaign against them. Shaozong issued a proclamation throughout Yan's realm:
48
使祿
When heaven and earth stand in harmonious union, the bright sage arises; hidden destiny moves beneath all things, and every creature walks the road of change to its end. All who hold mind and bear spirit come forth blended as one; given shape and allotted life, they mingle and advance together. Thus the hidden work moves in silence, supreme virtue reaches everywhere: the people use it daily yet do not know it; ten thousand realms receive its grace yet see no mark. Is it only to clear their ears and eyes, turn their hearts, awaken them with wind and cloud, and make one their script and wheel-ruts—so that sun and moon shine without favor, rain and dew fall with equal bounty, and all are borne into the domain of benevolence and long life, gathered into the grove of blessing and rank? Since Jin rule turned crooked and the Metal mandate collapsed, the Central Plains became a battlefield and the people prey for birds and beasts; then our august Wei seized the Dark Emperor's chart, took in the Water Spirit's blessing, drove the cloud-chariot from the north and urged the dragon-steed toward the south, presented the tally to Heaven, rescued the drowning world below, slew monstrous things and stilled the floods, shifted the sacred vessel at a glance and fixed the precious mandate where it wavered—restoring order by arms, uplifting it by civil virtue—until within the seas the custom of enfeoffment returned and every head knew the mind of Yao and Shun. Beyond shifting sands and trackless wastes, outside the tables of tethered submission, in lands no regional gazetteer records and no lost classic stitches together—all tied valleys and fished mountains, leaning on wind and trusting water—alike look up to the Central State's sage and rejoice in the Great Way's going. Only the Three Wu and the Hundred Yue still block our transforming voice—not the people's fault, but blame lies elsewhere.
49
使 滿
Since the pseudo-Jin, the Liu and Xiao lines have wrought evil, usurping a corner and issuing commands as they please. Yet our forebears ruled the realm, loving the people and sparing blood: they did not exhaust every stratagem or every loyal general's army—only sent envoys, lowered a foot-long edict; though the Round Terrace was built, the yellow canopy soon departed; they granted armrest and staff and set the matter aside. Xiao Yan has always been frivolous and treacherous, his scholar's conduct beneath notice; he looks down on ruler and kin, has from youth loved turmoil and welcomed disaster, hated the upright and loathed the correct, cleverly turned others' flaws to his gain, and made a little seem much. He flatters the foolish and shallow, startling the vulgar with grand words; stirs the crooked and perverse, wielding words as weapons to awe others. Bowing low and hunching his shoulders, wagging lips and drumming tongue, he watches the court's glance and courts the idle talk of officeholders. Thus he defiled the scholar's regalia and stole a regional domain. When Baojuan grew mad and cruel and the people could not endure him, Yan lacked even the rectitude of a subject who faces north yet dares offense; he abruptly cast aside the rites binding men, leaned on demons and borrowed omens, ghost-speech and spirit-words, raised arms against the palace, overturned the court and poisoned the sovereign, bullied orphans and widows, and deafened scholar and commoner alike. Heaven did not repent the calamity; the wicked triumphed, indulging carved luxury within and cruel brigandage without. He drove the troops of a drained state and pressed a people living mouth to mouth—south beyond the Five Ridges, north guarding Jiujiang—garrisons never stood down, corvée without a year of rest. Men died beneath arrow and blade; children perished in mist and dew; mourners never ceased; the wounded never ended. Men were placed in his trust above others; he cast them down like grass. Thus obstinate sons and younger brothers ran wild in lust and cruelty; crafty petty men indulged greed to the limit. They flayed the people until little flesh remained; they gouged the common folk until marrow was wholly drained. Even tigers could not match their harm; starving wolves could not equal their ruin; the trembling Zhou remnant had nowhere to flee death. As for feigned feeling and dressed-up fraud, the instances are beyond counting. Venom filled his breast, yet he falsely honored abstinence; restless rivalry brimmed his chest, yet he pretended to rule through quiet purity. He even raised temples and pagodas on a vast scale and rebuilt terraces and halls—from Zhaoyang to Jing, pearls hung and jades joined, towers carved sharp, a thousand gates and ten thousand doors. He whipped the exhausted people until bone and sinew were spent; they dragged earth and hauled stone, dirges muffling the roads—if death could be prayed for, they would gladly call it immortality. Shallow in wisdom and loose in planning, he never measured himself. He blocked the Tongbai current and turned it to his own harm; the lost heir of Qi suddenly became a war-leader. Since records began, such a thing has rarely been heard. He cast aside the legitimate heir and elevated a foolish son; factional paths opened wide and each side glared at the other. Hatred glared and wrists clenched—nine houses in ten; many stood on tiptoe awaiting their moment.
50
Two reign-periods have passed; the royal house has known many troubles—first the alarm of rushing chariots, at last the grief of a sudden fall; the spirits were pained and enraged, the realm shook apart. Thereupon the late Chancellor, Duke of Qi Xianwu Wang Gaohuan, feeling heaven and earth's calamity and defilement, was stirred by cloud and thunder to righteous wrath; relying on lofty righteousness he led the people and exerted great integrity to accomplish the task. His design was to steady the state and fix hegemony—not merely to punish rebels and wash away shame. Sagacious strategy swirled in profusion, martial spirit crowned the age; he swept away fleeing remnants, honored the sovereign, and brought peace to the state. The Son of Heaven holds the calendar and receives the chart; heaven draws near, the sun mirrors forth; the Way follows the hidden cycle, virtue moves with the spirits. Soon the sovereign took up the wind of dancing with shields; the chief minister lightened the muster of chariots and troops; he released the southern captives and instructed them in friendly kinship; boats and carts followed upstream, rivers and roads shone, watch-pavilions faced one another, all gladly at ease—flesh restored, youth returned—without waiting for Yang Hu and Lu Kai. Though fine counsel and long reckoning began with us, war ceased and the people rested—both sides gained peace. A king's faith is bright as the four seasons—how could one be sovereign and father to others yet be two-faced in virtue, writing yet not honoring the law? How lamentable!
51
便
Hou Jing was a common laborer sprung from vulgar baseness; his person and name sank into obscurity, with nothing worth recording. Only because he was skilled at rushing errands did Erzhu favor him; the petty man stole rank and disgraced his post. At restoration, righteous banners pointed on every side; the chief evil was not to be pardoned—the guilt lay with the barbarian hosts. Jing owed his rise to another man's achievement and borrowed his strength; his master faced the day of the red neck, yet the lord he served courted clan extermination. Though he could not shield his lord left and right and repay favor with his life, he should still have worn a grim face and let righteousness show in his bearing. Yet he turned his plan for profit as fast as turning the hand, cast himself under another's banner, and gladly became a menial. Xianwu Wang cast aside his flaws, noted his small sincerity, let him reach the lowest of the five orders of rank, and placed him in the rear of a company. He joined the ranks in rapid service, hoping he would prove useful; with long whip and sharp blade our side controlled him by method. Once Guanlong's fleeing rebels were punished, in every strategic matter the vacant lands of Henan were not the main thrust of war; a thin corner-hold merely displayed banners and drums—no real effect was expected, only a roaming feint. Military affairs were largely Jing's assignment alone; overall command of armies and brigades had separate officers in charge. Yet stupidity and narrowness accumulated, arrogance and obstinacy grew extreme; he violated military discipline, still harbored divided loyalty, secretly built treason, and became the stair of rebellion. He betrayed favor and cast aside virtue, heedless of heaven's punishment; unrighteous and unkin—where kindness was thick, overturn was sure. He cast off a loving mother like shoes, abandoned a younger brother like discarded earth; sons stood in ranks, wives and nephews marched in files; he admired Jiang Er's blunt words and scorned Bo Chun's winding pleas. Leaping and rampant—whom does he think to deceive! Compared to owl and mirror-beast, different kinds yet alike in ugliness; if one wished to liken him to snake and rat, he would not even match their kind. When he entrusted himself west of the pass to bandit rebels, Baoju fixed ruler and minister, Hei Ta made brotherly kin, bestowed honor and title, and rescued him from death in heavy siege—relying on others for rescue, borrowing others' breath. Soon he forgot favor and betrayed kindness, personally seeking arms; outrage and cruelty brimmed over, and he had nowhere to turn. Taking Jinling as a marsh of fugitives and the lands south of the Yangtze as a drifting court, he offered sweet words and a humble body, advancing seasoned plans for his own survival. Deceptive words and floating talk—this is plain enough; a rebel rogue begging for his life—would he choose his tone? The great officers of the false court rejoiced in disaster and forgot righteousness; the sovereign was senile above, the ministers blind below. Driving off sparrows and removing weeds—this was never their plan; they stole treasure and betrayed their towns, drawing close like pepper and orchid. If men are without rites, how can there be a state!
52
西 [23][24]
Security and danger follow a great tendency; success and failure have constant omens—without Li Zhu's eyes or Ziye's hearing, I briefly set forth words that pierce the heart and speak plans for punitive campaign. Now the imperial Way is flourishing and bright, the royal plan truly fulfilled; the four peoples rejoice in their occupations, the hundred spirits present blessings. Though the chief minister above is gone, Yi Zhi continues the work, holding civil and martial together, tiger-gazing and dragon-rising. He drives the outstanding heroes under the sun, gathers the keen blades of an age; thrust and stab are like thunder and lightning, joined battle like wind and rain; drawing bow and leaping horse, he firmly seeks the enemy. The Rouran once suffered disunion and chaos, their realm split apart; a lone horse on a solitary campaign, they reported distress to us. Our state deeply honored neighboring ties, pitied their plight, fully performed the rites of caring for others and carried neighborly aid to the utmost; protection issued from their former lands, supplies given according to need; we preserved their perished enterprise and completed their greatest foundation. Our deep benevolence and enduring virtue are carved into their marrow; they crane their necks in longing to repay us, bound in righteousness like hand and foot. Tuyuhun hold fast to loyalty and filial piety, steadfast as glue and lacquer; from ten thousand li they look up to our virtue, tribute missions crowd the roads, marriage alliances are all proposed, and their envoys travel as though returning home. The Rouran realm borders the Yellow River on a slant, gazing toward Bin and Xia; snow flies for a thousand li, and layered ice piles deep in the hollows. The north wind turns fierce—this is truly the season for sinew bows and horn weapons; Piercing cold is at its height—exactly when felt and fur serve them best. Tuyuhun hate their villainy and rebellion; each year they raise strong armies, flooding west to Shan and raising dust through the Long Gorge. They drive the Dragon Pool breed and borrow an air of constant victory; both realms watch for an opening, expecting our armies to shift their heels. Moreover Dugu Ruyuan holds a host in the Qin heartland, drilling troops and menacing by raid. Hei Ta makes ready in the north and schemes in the west, inwardly fortifying his core; saving head and tail alike, he is worn out running to every alarm. How could they spare troops to point east and march out through Hangu Pass? Moreover, with autumn winds raising dust, the state keeps its standing defenses; at the strategic passes and rivers, where mountains and streams gird the land like a belt, fierce generals and keen troops stand rooted as peaks. [23]Again Baoju's defeat north of Heyin and Hei Ta's flight at Mangshan—[24]not a single brigade remained; each barely escaped with his own person. If they disregard their foundations and lightly rush forward, then one effort will bring lasting ease—Heaven assists us. These words are earnest as sun and moon crossing the sky; all the world knows them—the meaning is no empty phrase. Measured by this, the truth is plain to see: Hou Jing's wandering claims are nothing but vain fabrication.
53
As for Jing—a man of hemp pivots and mat windows, a vulgar fellow of the fields—he met an age of turmoil and days of reckless chase, rose among the three chief clerks, and had towns with a thousand altars opened to him; measuring his stature and his portion, he should long ago have known when to stop. Yet he bustles between flight and return, straying from the path without end—this is surely not for nothing; the matter can be weighed and exposed. Judging that his followers rebel and his kin desert him, that he can barely hold on for his life, one now hears he will abandon Xuanchi and hurry far to Pengcheng. The old villain's crafty schemes are about to move again. He will surely raise a cry of hurrying to aid them, while his plan aims at seizure: to swallow Yuanming's host, recruit people sick of cruelty, take the long Huai as a barrier, and still spread his wings for months, assuming a southern throne in borrowed name until death ends him. This is the calamity of clam and snipe—and we bear the harm.
54
Moreover the false sovereign is muddled and perverse, heedless of good neighbors; his brigand heart grows only crueler with age. He welcomes the craft of fugitive rebels and scorns faith and righteousness in wild arrogance; Heaven has abandoned his spirit and men heap up their hatred—he will soon tread the tracks of Melon Garden and follow the wheel-ruts of the Son of Hou. Now he mobilizes dogs and goats, raids the Xu region, builds ramparts and dams the rivers, and covets petty gain—if this can be borne, what outrage cannot be harbored in the breast! Arms are ominous and battle dangerous; we march only because we must. Erring on the side of court rule, I solemnly undertake the nine punitive campaigns. Hosts that could shoulder cauldrons and uproot trees, troops that leap chariots and hurl stones—drilled armor fills the roads, gathering like waves and merging like mist. Steeds marked with tiger stripes and dragon patterns, thoroughbreds from Orchid Pool and cattail tips—breathing heaven across the land, treading shadow and chasing wind—we shake the army southward and drive far to press and crush them. It is not only that the Three Wu will show rat faces and scatter like fish at one command—with this going forth, the green canopy will return. Moreover Yan is cruel in his nets toward the common folk and keeps military authority outside his grasp; his realm holds precipitous, rash customs, and frivolous sons and grandsons besides. Xiao Lun, ringleader of fierce craftiness—how could he lack a Shang Chen's wickedness; Xiao Yu, burning with thwarted ambition—surely he will summon guests like Zhuan Zhu. Outer collapse and inner rot—now is the hour.
55
This headquarters marches troops by rite and moves arms by righteousness—comforting the people and punishing crime; the principle stands firm. Whoever reads the moment and judges change, who rises abruptly like a startled magpie, establishes merit and service, leaves danger and seeks safety—the reward canon is not forgotten, and his reward will surely rise by ranks. Wherever our military authority reaches, if anyone dares resist, every boy a foot tall and above shall be put to decapitation display. Now the generals of the three rites and four righteousnesses, warriors like leopard, tiger, bear, and grizzly, deeply resent the false court's shelter of fugitives and reception of rebels, its defiance of divination and rejection of remonstrance—truly rousing this punitive campaign. None fail to hold wrath and show it on their faces, as though marching to a private feud; they would gnaw liver and wade blood without turning heel from righteousness. On the day battle is joined, affairs will move as if spirit-aided; weeds will pile like hemp in chaos—not from dawn to dusk alone. With that crooked army and endangered remnant staring at our army's edge—how is it different from a dung beetle in armor or a caterpillar raising its tail? I fear only that when banners and drums once meet, mushroom and weed alike will crumble; I forewarn your hearts in advance, that you may know it fully from brush and ink. Kings and marquises have no fixed seed—fortune and calamity follow the man; this is the season when bold men win meat on the table and stalwarts earn their enfeoffments. Winter ice can be broken—time does not return; all you gentlemen, strive to win your blessings. Where this proclamation reaches, let all declare and examine it, and know our state's intent in raising arms.
56
使 [25]
In the twelfth month of winter, Shaozong, Gao Yue, and others routed Yan's army at Hanshan, capturing Yuanming, Guisun, and others; fifty thousand were taken or slain, and those who died by freezing, drowning, or fire were beyond counting. Ashamed and remorseful, in the sixth year Yan again sent the envoy Yang Zhensun to present courtesy at the passes and beg for peace, and also sent a letter of condolence to Prince Wenxiang of Qi. Prince Wenxiang wished to win them by majesty and virtue; he permitted their envoys but did not answer their letter. Yan thereupon sent his Regular Attendant of the Scattered Cavalry Xie Ting [25] and Regular Attendant of Direct Communication Xu Ling to our court to present tribute.
57
便忿 沿
Before Ting and the others could return, Hou Jing raised troops against Yan, secretly dealing with Yan's nephew Prince Zhengde of Linhe and promising to set him up as ruler. When Jing reached Heng River, Yan ordered Zhengde to lead troops against him; Zhengde thereupon welcomed him in instead. Jing crossed the river, set him up as ruler, and pressed on toward Jiankang. Yan loved men who flattered him, and in his last years this was especially so: if anyone said the state was strong, he at once grew furious; if anyone said the court was weak, he showed delight. Thus his ministers and attendants all followed his mood, and none dared speak plainly. When Jing was first about to cross the river, every garrison along Yan's route had sent reports in succession, but Central Army Director Zhu Yi feared to offend Yan and moreover judged that Jing could not cross—so he did not pass the word along. When Jing reached Cihu, Yan was at last greatly alarmed; he ordered his Heir Apparent Gang to hold the Secretariat and entrusted all military affairs to him. He also forced residents into the city; the people then plundered one another, and it could not be stopped. Yan ordered Direct Attendant Supervisor Yu Jingmao to pardon the criminals of the Two Forges, the Imperial Workshop, and the Coinage Office, and the prisoners held by Jiankang and the Minister of Justice, intending to drive them into the city as defenders. The convicts set fire to the forges and at once scattered and fled. Worried and at wit's end, Yan could only order his kings, dukes, and the rest to camp separately at the gates; he requisitioned money hoarded in the temples, all of it sent into the Accumulated Virtue Yang Hall to fill the military stores.
58
便 殿西
Once Jing arrived, he besieged the city at once, set fires, dug a long encirclement, and built earthen mounds to attack Yan. Yan likewise raised mounds inside the city to answer them. Yan ordered civil and military officers to haul earth, each man charged twenty piculs; thereupon his kings, marquises, and court nobles all shouldered carrying poles themselves. Xiao Gang also wished to shoulder loads himself, but collective counsel held that this would show too much abasement, and he desisted. Whenever Yan recruited men to sally forth, he had no proper commands; they might win briefly at first, but always turned and fled in the end. Jing proclaimed, "The city is not without vegetables—only without sauce," to mock them. Yan's Grand Provisioner and his soldiers had no fuel; they then stripped the Secretariat, the Arsenal, and the Left and Right Treasuries to supply themselves. Though relief from Yan's provinces and garrisons did arrive, Jing's encircling palisade was deep and firm, and inner and outer were cut off. Yan repeatedly sent men out to fight, and they were constantly seized by Jing. A boy asked to use flying kites to carry messages; Gang thereupon made ropes several thousand zhang long, tied paper kites to the ends, bound letters on their backs, and wrote on the kites' mouths: "Whoever catches a kite and delivers it to the relief army will receive a hundred taels of silver." Gang went out from the Hall of Supreme Ultimate and lofted them on the northwest wind, releasing several kites in succession; Jing ordered horsemen to shoot them down, but in the end none reached the relief armies.
59
宿
Famine struck Yan's city; men ate one another; rice sold for eight hundred thousand per dou, and human flesh was mixed with ox and horse meat for sale. Soldiers set up a market before the Virtue Yang Hall; one ox brought three thousand bolts of silk, one dog twenty myriad in cash. All smoked rats and caught sparrows to eat; by then sparrows and rats were gone, and the dead lay pillow upon pillow. At first, when men stole fish from the palace ponds, Yan was still furious and ordered them handed to the Minister of Justice; soon afterward the ponds were emptied overnight. Such was his failure to grasp what the moment required.
60
西 便 使 西便 使 便
Jing besieged long without taking the city; though Yan's outer relief was plentiful, each force pulled apart, with no overall command, jealous of one another, and unwilling to strike hard. Only Yan's son Prince Lun of Shaoling fought another decisive battle at Zhongshan, was defeated, and fled. Jing's grain was running low, and he thereupon deceived Yan into seeking peace. Yan believed him, ceded four provinces west of the river to Jing, enfeoffed him as King of Shouyang, and continued sending court tribute. After he and his men had sworn a blood oath, Jing falsely withdrew his army to Shitou. Yan then ordered the relief armies to withdraw; at first they refused the edict, and only after a second command did they obey. Yan again ordered the relief armies to give Jing three hundred boats; Jing still thought it too few, and Yan ordered two hundred more delivered. Yan's Marquis of Yong'an Xiao Que and Standard Bearer General Zhao Weifang were men of real courage and stratagem, and Jing feared them. Jing then said to Yan, "Que and Weifang have been cursing you from across the river, saying, 'The Son of Heaven himself made peace with you—I will never let you go! I dare not leave now; if you summon these two men into the city, I will lift the siege." Yan again sent envoys to summon Que and the others, but they would not obey. Yan then wrote in his own hand to the armies, saying, "If Que will not enter, you should deliver him by military law." Que and the others had no choice and thereupon went to Yan. Jing again said to Yan, "Word has just come from the west that the northern army has taken Shouchun and Zhongli; I now have nowhere to set foot; I beg to borrow Guangling and Qiao province for the moment, and when the campaign retakes the two cities, I will return the province." Yan assented again. Outwardly Jing spoke of peace while watching for slackness; Yan and his court trusted Jing's deceit and had all weapons gathered in and put away. When they later learned it was false, they set up defenses again in still greater disarray than before. As the city grew ever more desperate, Yan and his court, at wit's end, again sent envoys to Jing. Jing deceived them again, saying, "The season is hot now and I cannot leave at once; I only beg to remain in the capital and serve the court." Yet he mustered his full strength for a great assault, and in the third month of the seventh year he took the city at last.
61
使
From the time Jing reached Jiankang, he let his soldiers plunder far and near until the storehouses were swept utterly bare. Jing then came with several hundred horsemen to see Yan, sobbed and wept, begged for incense to become his ritual adoptive son, and restored Yan as ruler. He had Zhengde send a memorial saying, "Formerly I was seized by Jing and made to administer the realm; I could not decline, and provisionally held all affairs—now that Jing has entered as aide, I beg to end this usurpation and return the king to his residence." From the time Jing besieged Jiankang, swelling sickness spread through the city; the dead followed one upon another, and with no planks left for coffins, men hollowed pillars instead. Outside the Yunlong and Shenhu gates, corpses lay in heaped layers; blood and filth pooled across the ground until no path remained. When Jing entered the city he gathered every corpse and burned them; smoke blotted the sky, and the stench carried for dozens of li. At first the city held more than a hundred thousand men and women; when it fell, barely two or three thousand remained, and all were sick—it was Heaven's annihilation. Before long Jing starved Yan to death. For more than a hundred days Jing besieged Yan; yet Yan's son, Inspector of Jing and Prince of Xiangdong Yi, and Inspector of Yi and Prince of Wuling Ji each clung to his own forces and looked on while Yan's life hung by a thread, never marching to his aid. From Jing's crossing of the river until the city's fall, Jiangnan's people and Yan's princes, consorts, princesses, and noble heirs were seized by Jing's troops or sold one another into slavery; those who drifted into our realm numbered in the hundreds of thousands. Famine and death followed until the ground was strewn with corpses, and the lands east of the Yangtze became a ruin.
62
便 便
Yan had long exalted the Buddhist teaching. At Jianye he built Tongtai Temple; at his old residence, Guangzhe Temple; on Zhongshan, Great Aijing Temple; and he also kept the two Changgan temples—every project strained craft to its limit and emptied the treasury, and the people groaned under it. He once held a great fast and gave his own body to Tongtai Temple as a temple slave; his ministers thrice memorialized in refusal, and then officials throughout the court pooled jewels to ransom him. Whenever Yan worshipped the Buddha he put off his court robes and wore a Gandharan kasaya. He required princes, marquises, and noble sons to take Buddhist precepts; whoever practiced with exceptional zeal he promptly styled a bodhisattva. His officials in memorials and letters also addressed him as "Emperor Bodhisattva." Every inspector and grand administrator under Yan, on first taking office, was charged a presentation gift: a rich tribute meant he was deemed competent; a meager one marked him weak and indolent. Hence his governors and defenders competed in levies, stripping commoners to fill their own coffers—concubines by the score, fine grain and meat, gold and brocade. The people groaned in bitterness and could scarcely live. When he drafted troops they had to be chained; otherwise they fled at once. Kings, marquises, and magnates were profligate beyond measure; brothers, sons, and nephews might keep a thousand concubines, even passing them among one another as gifts. Customs collapsed and the bonds of rule were upheld no better than this. Yan, claiming to keep the precepts, would not even offer penned livestock at sacrifices to his ancestors; men whispered that though he played king, his ancestral temple in truth received no blood sacrifice. Before Yan's fall, Tongtai Temple suffered calamity, and the stone qilin before his grandfather's tomb vanished overnight; those who read omens knew his end was near. Jing set up Yan's son Gang, then soon killed him as well. Yan's kin were slaughtered to the last.
63
The historiographer comments: The two Xiao houses fought in the mud as if over a snail's horn—one line barely three reign-periods, another ruler not living out his span—yet each stole a name on the Yangtze marches and styled himself king; search remotest antiquity and nothing like it was ever heard. Goujian once sent tribute and prolonged his house; Fuchai strove for supremacy and died afterward—set these two marauders against Wu and Yue, and are they not the lesser?
64
Collation Notes
65
西 西 西
"Prince of Longxi Yuan Chen with three generals set out from Guangling": in all editions Chen is written Cao; juan 7, Part One, Basic Annals of Gaozu, eleventh month, day guichou of Taihe 3 records Chen. Per juan 15, biography of Prince of Chenliu Yuan Qian: Qian's elder brother Yan's son Kun was enfeoffed Prince of Longxi; on Kun's death his son Chen inherited the title. There is no other Prince of Longxi Yuan Cao. Cao is a corruption of Chen; emended here on the authority of the annals. Below, "Yuan Cao and others attacked their Matou garrison" is emended likewise.
66
"Daocheng, Mobile Raider General, Huan Kang at Huaiyang": the sentence is ungrammatical. Juan 7, Part One, Basic Annals of Gaozu, second month, day gengxu of Taihe 5 places jipo ("struck and broke") before Daocheng; in this biography po has shifted after the clause as po zhi, so ji must have dropped before Daocheng.
67
使殿西
"He sent Tiger Vanguard Central Commandant Pan Shu leading a hundred men to encamp on the western steps of the Hall of Supreme Ultimate to guard against them": Nan Qishu juan 40, biography of Prince of Jingling Ziliang, and juan 56, biography of Lü Wendu, write Pan Shu as Pan Chang; Nanshi juan 44, Ziliang's biography, agrees. Here Shu should be the corruption Chang.
68
綿 綿
"Often wore purple brocade and red embroidered mixed garments or brocade caps": Nanshi juan 5, Basic Annals of Qi, Part Two, reads "wore new red and purple brocade garments, brocade cap, red gauze drawers, and mixed-color open jacket." Here "purple cotton" should be the corruption "purple brocade."
69
"Beheaded their Left Army General Zhang Zishun": juan 7, Part Two, Basic Annals of Gaozu, third month, day jihai of Taihe 23 has Zishun as Yuda; Nan Qishu juan 26, biography of Chen Xianda, has simply Qian. Zizhi Tongjian juan 142 〈p. 4438〉 Examining Variants says: "The Book of Wei has 'Zhang Qianda'"; thus the transmitted Book of Wei Basic Annals reading Yuda is wrong. This biography's battles between Qi and Liang are mostly stitched from annal entries; here Zishun is probably also a corruption of Qianda, but shun and da are far apart in sound and form, and it is unclear how the error arose.
70
"Inspector of Yu Tian Yizong defeated Baojuan's generals Wu Ziyang and Deng Yuanqi at Changfeng": all editions write Deng Yuanqi as Liu Yuanchao; juan 8, Basic Annals of Shizong, ninth month, day yichou of Jingming 1 has Deng Yuanqi. The affair appears in Liangshu juan 10, biography of Deng Yuanqi, except Tian Yizong is written Tian Kongming, and it says Liang won. Here Liu Yuanchao is the corruption Deng Yuanqi; corrected now.
71
"Inspector of Southern Yu Xi Fayou with thirty thousand men besieged Baojuan's Supporting-the-State General, joint grand administrator of Beixin and Anfeng commanderies Hu Jinglue at Jian'an City": all editions lack Cai after Beixin; Qian's Textual Variants juan 28 holds Cai dropped out. Nan Qishu juan 57, Account of the Northern Barbarians, correctly reads Beixin Cai. This book, juan 71, biography of Xi Fayou, says: "He was gradually promoted to grand administrator of Anfeng and Xincai commanderies, garrison commander of Jian'an; Xiao Baojuan sent Hu Jinglue to replace him." Thus Jinglue's office was Fayou's former office. Xi's biography dropped Bei; here Cai dropped out. Qian is right; supplemented here on the authority of the Account of the Northern Barbarians.
72
"Marquis of Yongxin Zhaoxiu": Nan Qishu juan 40 and Nanshi juan 44, biography of Ziliang's son Zhaozhou, write Zhaoxiu as Zhaoying—this biography is probably wrong.
73
[]
"Yan's Inspector of Liang and Marquis of Pingyang Kaiguo Hou Zhai Yuan, Inspector of Xu and Marquis of Yongchang Kaiguo Hou Chen Huya came to surrender": Chen Huya is Chen Bo's son; in the preceding year, eighth month, he had already followed his father in surrendering to Wei—this entry is very doubtful; see collation note [8] in juan 8.
74
宿宿宿退
"Third year, first month": what follows narrates Liang generals Chang Yizhi attacking Liangcheng, Wang Maoxian attacking Jingzhou, General Who Pacifies the South Chen Bozhi striking Yizhi, and Yang Dayan striking Maoxian—all tied to the first month. Per juan 8, Basic Annals of Shizong, Chen Bozhi's strike at Chang Yizhi falls in the second month of that year; Wang Maoxian's attack on Jingzhou in the fourth month; Chen Bozhi had already surrendered to Liang in the third month. The present passage strings these together under "and routed them utterly," so the narrative is unclear. This biography's battles are mostly annal entries stitched into prose, and errors are common—for example, below the fifth month has Liang generals "Xiao Bing raiding Huaiyang, Zhang Huiniao raiding Suyu," while the eighth month again records "Yan also sent Zhang Huiniao to encamp at Suyu, Xiao Bing at Huaiyang." In fact from the fifth month, when Liang took Huaiyang and Suyu, until the ninth month they were defeated and withdrew—it was not two affairs but clumsy annal stitching. Such errors are not listed exhaustively here.
75
"General Yuan Heng captured Gucheng": all editions write Heng as Chang. Juan 8, Basic Annals of Shizong, eighth month of Zhengshi 3, and juan 65, biography of Xing Luan, read Yuan Heng. Here it should read Yuan Heng; the Song block print altered it to avoid Song taboo—reverted now.
76
"Captured Yan's Changbo garrison with casualties in the tens of thousands": juan 8, Basic Annals of Shizong, first month, day bingshen of Yongping 2 records "tens of thousands" as "a few thousand." Changbo is a small garrison, and juan 19, Part Two, appended biography of Prince of Nan'an Yuan Zhen, biography of Yuan Ying, says "Ying reached Changbo; Ma Guang fled by night and entered Wuyang"—there was no great battle; how could casualties run to tens of thousands? Here wan ("ten thousand") should be the corruption qian ("thousand").
77
"Inspector of Jing Huan Shuxing inflicted a great defeat": juan 8, Basic Annals of Shizong, sixth month of Yanchang 3 has Nan before Jing. Qian's Textual Variants juan 28 says: "It should read 'Southern Jing'; the character 'Nan' dropped out." Per juan 101, Account of the Man, Huan Shuxing was Inspector of Southern Jing; Qian is right.
78
"Yan's Inspector of Yi Xiao Yuanyou sent generals Fan Wenchì and others leading troops to besiege the Xiaojian garrison": all editions write Yuan as Run; juan 9, Basic Annals of Suzong, fourth month of Xiaochang 1 has Yuan. Qian's Textual Variants juan 28 says: "'Run' should be 'Yuan.'" Juan 71, biography of Chunyu Dan, also writes Xiao Yuanyou for this affair. Yuanyou was a son of Xiao Yi; among the brothers the upper character of each name was Yuan. Yi's sons Yuanye, Yuanzao, and Yuanming—in the Liangshu, avoiding Tang taboo, Yuan is routinely changed to Shen; this Yuanyou was also changed to Shenyou 〈see Liangshu juan 3, Basic Annals of Emperor Wu, sixth month of Datong 3 and seventh month of Datong 5〉 The Nanshi simply drops Yuan and uses only the lower character: Yuanyou is given singly as You 〈see juan 51, appended biography of Prince of Changsha Yi, section on his sons〉 Here Run is the corruption Yuan; Qian is right; corrected now.
79
"Captured his second-rank general Xiao Shicheng and twelve others": all editions write Cheng as Long; juan 9, Basic Annals of Suzong, fifth month of Xiaochang 1 has Cheng. Juan 71, biography of Chunyu Dan, and juan 87, biography of Hu Xiaohu, record this affair as Xiao Shicheng; here Long is the corruption Cheng; corrected now.
80
"That year Yan again changed the era name to Datong": "that year" here follows the preceding text as Xiaochang 1 〈525〉 , but adopting the era Datong actually corresponds to Wei Xiaochang 3 〈527〉 the third month—this is an error.
81
"That year Yan again changed the reign title to Zhongdatong": Zhang Senkai says: "The first year of Zhongdatong in Wei terms is Yong'an 2 〈529〉 ; the 'that year' meant here is actually Tianping 2 〈535〉 ; Liang changed the era to 'Datong,' not 'Zhongdatong.' The prior passage omitted recording the change to Zhongdatong; here Datong was mistaken for Zhongdatong—both are wrong."
82
"Second year, summer": the prior entry records Tianping 4 and the next Xinghe 2; thus "second year" here means Yuanxiang 2. In the eleventh month of Yuanxiang 2 the reign title was changed to Xinghe; this entry is in summer, before the change, hence it still says "second year." Above, the two characters Yuanxiang must have dropped out.
83
"That year Yan changed the reign title to Datong": Zhang Senkai says: "That year 〈Xinghe 2, 540〉 is the sixth year of Liang Datong, not the inaugural change of the era."
84
使
"He also sent Palace Attendant-in-Ordinary Xie Lin": all editions write Lin as Lan. Zhang Senkai says: "'Lan' should be 'Lin'; the Liangshu biography of Xie Lin 〈juan 47〉 proves it." The biography says "Lin, styled Xiru," and also relates that Ruan Xiaoxu said he was "a match for Master Lin's birth," "and so he was named 'Lin.'" His mission to Eastern Wei also appears in that biography. The character Lan is a corruption of Lin; Zhang is right, and we emend here according to the main biography.
85
The text says that in the sixth year Yan changed the era name to Zhong Datong and in the same year to Taiqing. Zhang Senkai argued: "The Zhong Datong change should correspond to the fourth year of our Wuding era 〈546 CE〉 ; the fifth year adopted Taiqing, and the sixth year was Taiqing year 2. The era was not first changed to Zhong Datong in the sixth year, nor were both names adopted in a single year."
86
The phrase rendered "ji zhi yue li" should read qi zhi: "ji" is a mistake for qi, meaning chess, and zhi means to stand facing each other. The expression qi zhi appears in Records of the Three Kingdoms, juan 15 (Biography of Liang Xi), juan 25 (Biography of Gaotang Long), and juan 58 (Biography of Lu Xun). It means to stand in confrontation like pieces on a chessboard. The Book of the Later Han, juan 100, Biography of Zheng Tai, likewise has ji zhi, and Liu Bin also argues that ji should be qi.
87
The text says Yan then sent his Regular Attendant of the Scattered Cavalry Xie Ting; all editions write Ting as Ban. The juan 104 preface of this book, Northern History juan 56, Northern Qi History juan 37 (Biography of Wei Shou), and Liang History juan 38 (Biography of Zhu Yi) all have Xie Ting. Here Ban is a corruption of Ting, and we emend accordingly.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →