← Back to 新唐書

卷一百零五 列傳第三十 長孫無忌從父:敞 從父弟:操 子:詮 族叔:順德 褚遂良 韓瑗 來濟 李義琰從祖弟:義琛 上官儀

Volume 105 Biographies 30: Zhangsun Wuji and uncle Chang and uncle Cao, son Quan, young relative: Shunde, Chu Suilang, Han Yuan, Lai Ji, Li Yiyan's nephew Yi Chen, Shang Guanyi

Chapter 105 of 新唐書 · New Book of Tang
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 105
Next Chapter →
1
::::::::
Zhangsun Wuji; his father's elder brother's son Chang; his father's younger brother Cao; his son Quan; his clan uncle Shunde; Chu Suiliang's great-grandson Qiu; Han Yuan; Lai Ji and his half-brother Heng; Li Yiyan and his son Chao and his cousin Yichen; and Shangguan Yi.
2
Zhangsun Wuji.
3
Zhangsun Wuji, whose style name was Fujii. He was quick-witted by nature and widely read in books and history. When Emperor Gaozu's army first crossed the Yellow River, Wuji went to pay his respects at Changchun Palace and was appointed staff officer on the Weibei campaign. He followed the Prince of Qin on military campaigns with distinction and was promoted in succession to Director in the Ministry of Justice and Duke of Shangdang County.
4
使 便 使 便
Crown Prince Li Jiancheng poisoned the Prince of Qin, who fell gravely ill, throwing the entire household into alarm. Fang Xuanling said to Wuji, "The seeds of disaster have already been sown; ruin will follow in no time. Those who pursue a great design must set aside petty scruples—this is why the Duke of Zhou punished his brothers Guan and Cai. They then went in together to inform the prince and urged him to strike first and kill Jiancheng, but the prince would not agree. Wuji said, "Your Highness, what sort of man do you consider Shun to have been? The prince replied, "Deeply wise and civilly brilliant—as a son he was filial, as a ruler he was benevolent. What more is there to say?" Wuji answered, "If he had been trapped in a well and never come out, could he still have been called filial? If he had not lowered the granary roof, could he still have been called benevolent? Avoid the heavy blow, accept the light one—there is sound reason in that." The prince still could not decide. As the crisis intensified, the prince sent Wuji in secret to summon Fang Xuanling and Du Ruhui to finalize their plan. Wuji joined Yuchi Jingde, Hou Junji, Zhang Gongjin, Liu Shili, Gongsun Wuda, Dugu Yanyun, Du Junchuo, Zheng Rengong, and Li Mengchang in suppressing the uprising and restoring order. When the prince became crown prince, Wuji was appointed Left Guardian of the Heir. When the prince ascended the throne, Wuji was made Minister of Personnel; ranked first in merit, he was enfeoffed as Duke of Qi. Because Wuji was the empress's elder brother and had been his friend since youth, the emperor's favor and reliance on him grew daily, and Wuji was often admitted to the inner bedchamber. He was promoted to Right Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs. The Türkic qaghan Jieli had sworn alliance with the Tang but his realm was in turmoil, and the generals urged an immediate campaign against him. The emperor reflected on their recent blood oath: to refrain would be to miss the moment, yet to attack would be to break faith. Uncertain, he consulted his senior ministers. Xiao Yu said, "It is the way of statecraft to join with the weak and strike the faltering—an attack would be expedient. Wuji said, "Our present aim is to keep the sword sheathed. Let us wait until the barbarians come to us, and then we may strike. If they weaken and cannot even come, what more do we need? I believe it is better to hold our forces in check and honor our pledge." The emperor said, "Well said." Yet in the end he did subdue the Türks.
5
使
When some said Wuji's power had grown too great, the emperor showed him the memorial and said, "Between us as ruler and minister there should be no shadow of doubt. If each of you keeps what he hears to himself, that is how courts go blind. He then displayed it to the whole court and declared, "My sons are still young. Wuji has rendered me great service, and I regard him as a son. To drive wedges between kin and to set newcomers against old companions is disloyalty, and I will have none of it." Wuji himself feared that his rank had grown too high and proud. After such remarks were repeated, he was relieved of the vice directorship and given the title of Grand Master of Splendid Happiness with the status of the Three Dukes. He, together with Fang Xuanling, Du Ruhui, and Yuchi Jingde, was granted a hereditary commandery dukedom for one son each in recognition of their founding merit. He was enfeoffed as Minister of Works and put in charge of the Chancellery and the Department of State Affairs. Wuji declined, and through Gao Shilian he added that as an imperial in-law occupying one of the Three Ducal posts, critics would say the emperor was favoring his wife's clan. The emperor replied, "I appoint men solely by talent. Without it, even a kinsman as close as Prince of Xiangyi Shenfu would not receive office rashly; but where there is talent, even an adversary like Wei Zheng I do not cast aside. If I wished merely to shower my empress's brother with honors, wealth, and titles, who could object? It is because he unites civil and military gifts that I made him chief minister. Do any of you disagree? Wuji still refused. An edict answered, "The Yellow Emperor had Li Mu and became foremost among the Five Emperors; Yu of Xia had Gao Yao and became the ancestor of the Three Dynasties; Duke Huan of Qi had Guan Zhong and became leader of the Five Hegemons; I have you, and thus the realm was settled. Do not decline further! The emperor also recalled how they had shared hardship together and how he had owed his survival to Wuji. He composed the "Ode to the Majestic Phoenix" as a gift and praised his achievements.
6
使
The emperor wished to grant his meritorious ministers hereditary prefectures. In the eleventh year of Zhenguan he issued an edict to the relevant offices: "By the aid of bright spirits and worthy assistants, I have overcome many trials and brought order to the realm. In hardship all shared their strength; in peace to enjoy the rewards alone is something I will not accept. A prefect is the modern equivalent of the feudal lords of old; the title differs, but the charge of oversight is the same. Wuji and his fellows have shared my fortunes through good and ill, stood firm in peace and peril, and their fine deeds are engraved on my heart. Let them be granted domains under a system of hereditary succession. Wuji was made Prefect of Zhao, with Zhao as his ducal domain; Fang Xuanling Prefect of Song, with his domain at Liang; Du Ruhui, posthumously Prefect of Mi, with his domain at Lai; Li Jing Prefect of Pu, with his domain at Wei; Gao Shilian Prefect of Shen, with his domain at Shen; Hou Junji Prefect of Chen, with his domain at Chen; Daozong Prefect of E, Prince of Jiangxia; Xiaogong Prefect of Guan, Prince of Hejian; Yuchi Jingde Prefect of Xuan, with his domain at E; Li Ji Prefect of Qi, with his domain at Ying; Duan Zhixuan Prefect of Jin, with his domain at Bao; Cheng Zhijie Prefect of Pu, with his domain at Lu; Liu Hongji Prefect of Lang, with his domain at Kui; Zhang Liang Prefect of Li, with his domain at Yun. Fourteen men in all. The remaining officials' fief incomes were not yet included. Wuji and the others declined, saying, "We have braved hardship in Your Majesty's service. Now that the realm is united, we truly do not wish to be sent far from your side to govern distant prefectures in perpetuity, as though we were being exiled. The emperor said, "I meant these domains to make your descendants long-term bulwarks of the realm. If you disdain this oath sworn over mountains and rivers and turn resentful instead, how can I force domains upon you?" The plan was abandoned. Later the emperor visited his residence and bestowed graded rewards on every member of the household, from kin to in-laws. After some time he was promoted to Minister of Education.
7
殿
After Crown Prince Chengqian was deposed, the emperor wished to install the Prince of Jin but had not decided. In the Hall of Two Principles, after dismissing the court he kept Wuji, Fang Xuanling, and Li Ji to discuss the succession and said, "I have three sons and one younger brother, and I do not know whom to install. My heart is unsettled. He then threw himself on the bed, drew his girdle knife, and turned it on himself. Wuji and the others rushed to restrain him, wrested away the knife and handed it to the Prince of Jin, and asked whom the emperor wished to install. The emperor said, "I wish to install the Prince of Jin. Wuji said, "Your command is received. Whoever dissents shall be executed!" The emperor turned to the prince and said, "Your uncle has agreed for you. You should thank him at once." The prince bowed. The emperor then said, "You agree with my intent—what will the realm say? They answered, "The prince has long been known throughout the realm for benevolence and filial piety. Surely there will be no dissent; and if there is any dissent, we deserve a hundred deaths before Your Majesty. The succession was thus settled. Wuji was made Grand Preceptor of the Heir and Associate with the Three Departments at the rank of the Three Dukes—the title "Associate with the Three Dukes" dates from this appointment. When the emperor again wished to install Prince Wu Ke, Wuji secretly remonstrated and stopped him. When the emperor campaigned against Goguryeo, Wuji was ordered to serve as acting Palace Attendant. On the emperor's return, Wuji resigned his tutor's post, was relieved of Grand Preceptor of the Heir, and held the distant post of Military Governor of Yangzhou.
8
The emperor once asked at leisure, "They say that when the ruler is sage the minister is upright, yet men often fail to know themselves. You should speak frankly of my faults and merits. Wuji replied, "Your Majesty is divinely martial and sagely cultured, surpassing all ages, and your nature accords with Heaven. We are too dull to discern any fault." The emperor said, "I hoped to hear of my faults, yet you only flatter one another. I shall appraise each of you in turn and use that to admonish you." He said, "Gao Shilian is alert of mind and unwavering in crisis—what he lacks is blunt forthrightness. Tang Jian is eloquent and skilled at smoothing disputes over wine, and his words are pleasing—but in twenty years of service he has never once spoken on affairs of state. Yang Shidao is cautious and never errs, but he is timid and inexperienced and cannot be relied on in a crisis. Cen Wenben is sincere and generous; writing and debate are his strengths, and his plans are far-sighted—he will not fail the realm. Liu Ji is firm and upright; his counsel is useful, he does not lightly promise others, and he can remedy his own lapses. Ma Zhou is keen and upright; in judging men he follows the straight path, and every man he has recommended has suited my intent. Chu Suiliang is blunt and bright, learned, and devoted to me like a bird clinging to its perch—I cannot help but cherish him. Wuji is quick and agile in counsel and skilled at avoiding suspicion—among men of old there is none to compare; but commanding troops in battle is not his strength."
9
殿
In the twenty-third year of his reign the emperor fell gravely ill and summoned Wuji to his bedside. He took Wuji's hand and stroked his jaw; Wuji wept, and the emperor, overcome with emotion, could say no more. The next day Wuji entered with Suiliang to receive the imperial testament. The emperor turned to Suiliang and said, "I owe this realm to Wuji. Assist in governing, and do not let slanderers destroy him. Shortly afterward he died. They were at a detached palace when the crown prince was overcome with grief. Wuji said, "The late emperor has entrusted the ancestral temples and the altars of state to Your Highness. You should ascend the throne at once. He kept the death secret, did not announce mourning, and urged an immediate return to the capital.
10
The crown prince ascended the throne and became Emperor Gaozong. Wuji was promoted to Grand Marshal and acting Director of the Secretariat, while retaining charge of the Chancellery and the Department of State Affairs. He firmly declined the Department of State Affairs, and his request was granted. When the emperor wished to install Lady Wu as empress, Wuji firmly declared that it could not be done. The emperor secretly sent him more than ten cartloads of treasures and silks, visited his residence in person, promoted all three of his sons to Masters of Palace Attendance, and Lady Wu's mother came again to plead at his door. Xu Jingzong repeatedly urged him on, but Wuji sternly refused. The emperor and empress summoned Wuji, Suiliang, and Yu Zhining and said that the empress had no sons while Lady Wu had a son, and that they were determined to install her. Wuji, having already remonstrated several times, said, "The late emperor entrusted Suiliang. Your Majesty should consult him. Suiliang argued with all his force that it could not be done, but the emperor would not listen.
11
使 使 使
Once Empress Wu was installed, she resented Wuji for accepting imperial gifts yet refusing to support her. Reading the empress's intent, Jingzong secretly had a Luoyang man named Li Fengjie accuse Wuji of treason, and together with Palace Attendant Xin Maojiang he went to investigate and fabricate a case of rebellion. The emperor was alarmed and said, "Surely some reckless man is fabricating discord—it cannot be so. Jingzong replied in full, "The evidence of rebellion is already plain. If Your Majesty cannot bring yourself to act, it will not be a blessing to the realm." The emperor wept and said, "My house is cursed. Princess Gaoyang, my own sister, once plotted rebellion; now my uncle does the same. How can I again shame the realm before all the world? What am I to do?" Jingzong answered, "Fang Yiai is still wet behind the ears; he rebelled at a woman's instigation—how could he have accomplished anything? Wuji is a cunning and formidable man whom the realm fears and obeys. If he should rise in secret rebellion, whom would Your Majesty send against him? If you do not act at once, I fear he may raise his sleeves and summon all who share his evil intent—and the ancestral temples will be in peril. Has Your Majesty forgotten the house of Sui? Yuwen Huaji's father had been chief minister, his brother married an imperial princess, and he himself commanded the palace guard. Emperor Yang trusted him completely—yet he rose as leader of the rebels and the Sui was destroyed. I urge Your Majesty to decide at once." The emperor still hesitated and ordered a further investigation. The next day Jingzong declared that Wuji's guilt was clear and requested his arrest. The emperor wept and said, "If my uncle is truly guilty, I absolutely cannot bring myself to kill him. What will posterity say of me? Jingzong said, "Emperor Wen of Han's uncle Bo Zhao had served him faithfully since the days in Dai, yet when Bo Zhao was later convicted of murder the emperor, unwilling to bend the law, had court ministers go in mourning dress to weep for him. Bo Zhao killed himself, and good historians do not fault the emperor for this. Now Wuji has forgotten the late emperor's kindness, abandoned Your Majesty's closest kin, and sought to overturn the altars of state and ruin the ancestral temples—is he to be compared only with Bo Zhao? By law his five clans should be exterminated. I have heard that he who fails to decide when decision is required invites disaster upon himself. Seize the moment and act swiftly; delay will surely breed disaster. Wuji plotted with the late emperor to win the realm, and the world submits to his cunning—he is of the same breed as Wang Mang and Sima Yi. Now the conspirators themselves have confessed—why hesitate any longer?" In the end the emperor never questioned Wuji in person. An edict was issued stripping him of office, title, and fief, placing him at Qianzhou on the salary of a first-rank military governor, with troops dispatched along the route to escort him; his son Chong, Director of the Secretariat, and others were exiled beyond the Lingnan passes; his younger cousin Zhiren, Prefect of Yu, was demoted to Assistant Military Governor of Yizhou. Several months later another edict ordered Li Ji, Xu Jingzong, Xin Maojiang, and others to reinvestigate the treason case. Jingzong ordered Yuan Gongyu of the Court of Judicial Review and Censor Song Zhishun to conduct violent interrogation at Qianzhou. Wuji hanged himself; Chong was spared death; his clan nephew Xiang was executed; his clan brother Si was exiled to Tankou—in all, his close kin were banished.
12
At first Wuji and Suiliang devoted themselves wholeheartedly to the state and took the realm's safety upon themselves, so that the Yonghui era retained something of the Zhenguan spirit. The emperor also honored his senior ministers and listened deferentially to their counsel. The laws and institutions were upheld—these two men maintained them. Once they disagreed over the deposition and installation of empresses, wicked ministers plotted in secret while the emperor listened to the wrong voices. In the end Wuji was destroyed, and from then on power passed to the house of Wu and the state nearly perished.
13
In the first year of Shangyuan his offices and titles were posthumously restored, and his grandson Yuanyi inherited the enfeoffment. Wuji had long since prepared his tomb within the precinct of Zhaoling, and now he was permitted to be reburied there. In the third year of Kaicheng, Emperor Wenzong issued an edict saying, "Whenever I read the national history and come to Grand Marshal Wuji's case, I cannot help but put down the scroll and sigh. Let his descendant Jun be appointed Magistrate of Yishi."
14
Paternal uncle by father's brother: Chang.
15
Younger paternal uncle by father's brother: Cao.
16
His younger paternal uncle Cao, whose style name was Yuanjie. His father Lan had been Grand Minister of Education under Northern Zhou and Duke of Xue. Cao was a learned man. At first Emperor Gaozu appointed him Army Staff Officer of the Gold Bureau in the Chancellor's Office. Before long he was made acting Prefect of Yuzhou. He followed the Prince of Qin on campaign, constantly attended at his side, and shared in secret plans. When transferred to Shaanzhou, where the city had no wells and the people toiled at drawing water, Cao channeled the river into the city, to the great benefit of the populace. When he resigned to mourn his mother, elders kept vigil at the palace gate praising his kindness. When mourning ended he was enfeoffed as Baron of Leshou County. As Prefect of Qi, Yang, and Yi, his performance ratings were always the highest, and edicts praised him. At the beginning of Yonghui he died while serving as Prefect of Shaanzhou. He was posthumously made Minister of Personnel with the posthumous name An, and a musical escort was granted for his burial until mourning ended.
17
Son: Quan.
18
滿 滿
His son Quan married Princess Xincheng. Quan's elder half-sister was the wife of Han Yuan. When Wuji fell from favor, Quan was exiled to Xizhou and killed by officials eager to please the court. Quan had a nephew named Zhao Chiman who was skilled at calligraphy and mounted archery, strong enough to wrestle tigers and run down horses, yet benevolent and humble toward scholars. In the capital, high and low alike admired him. As Chief Administrator of Liangzhou, he once chased wild horses and shot one—the arrow passed clean through—and the frontier people feared and submitted to him. When Quan was banished, Xu Jingzong feared Chiman's talent and had him pursued to the capital for interrogation and torture. Chiman's countenance never changed, and he said, "You may kill my body, but you cannot twist my words! The officials wrote a confession for him, and he died in prison.
19
Clan uncle: Shunde.
20
宿 使
Wuji's clan uncle Shunde. Shunde had served the Sui as a Right Merit Guard. When called up for the Liaodong campaign he fled to Taiyuan, where he had long been treated with favor by Emperor Gaozu. When Taizong was about to raise troops, he ordered Shunde and Liu Hongji to recruit men in the countryside, claiming to prepare against bandits, until they numbered in the tens of thousands, then formed ranks and encamped. When the Grand General's Office was established he was appointed Army Commander and distinguished himself in pacifying Huoyi, Linfen, and Jiang Commandery. With Liu Wenjing he attacked Qu Tu Tong at Tong Pass. When Tong tried to flee to Luoyang, Shunde pursued him to Taolin, captured him, and presented him as a prisoner, thus securing Shaan County. For his many achievements he was promoted to General of the Left Majestic Tiger Guard and enfeoffed as Duke of Xue. In suppressing Jiancheng's remaining faction he received a fief of twelve hundred households, was granted palace women, and was ordered to lodge in the Inner Secretariat. Soon he was impeached for accepting bribes. The emperor said, "Shunde is a founding merit and an imperial in-law; his rank and position are already as high as they can be. If he would learn from history and serve the state well, I would share the treasury with him—how did he come to be known for greed? He then bestowed several tens of bolts of silk to shame and admonish him. Vice Director Hu Yan of the Court of Judicial Review said, "Shunde broke the law through bribery and cannot be pardoned—why bestow gifts on him again? The emperor said, "For a man of shame, receiving such a gift is worse than execution; but if he cannot feel shame, he is no better than a beast—what good would killing him do?"
21
使
When Li Xiaochang plotted rebellion, Shunde was implicated for associating with him and was struck from the registers to become a commoner. More than a year later the emperor reviewed the portrait gallery of meritorious ministers, saw Shunde's image, and took pity on him. He sent Yuwen Shiji to look in on him and found Shunde drunk and disheveled. Shunde was then recalled as Prefect of Zezhou and his title and fief were restored. Shunde had always been unrestrained and extravagant, but from this time he reformed his conduct in office and was known for severity and clarity. Previously local officials had freely exchanged gifts and favors; Shunde prosecuted them without mercy and became known as an excellent official. Former prefects Zhang Changgui and Zhao Shida had seized several tens of qing of fertile land in the prefecture; Shunde confiscated it and gave it to poor households. Soon he was implicated on accumulated charges and returned to private life. When he lost a daughter and fell gravely ill, the emperor looked down on him and said to Fang Xuanling, "Shunde has no firm spirit—he falls gravely ill over a daughter's death. Why should he be pitied? Before long he died. The emperor sent an envoy to offer condolences, posthumously made him Military Governor of Jingzhou, and gave him the posthumous name Xiang. In the thirteenth year of Zhenguan he was enfeoffed as Duke of Pi. During Yonghui he was additionally posthumously granted the title of Grand Master of Splendid Happiness with the status of the Three Dukes.
22
Chu Suiliang.
23
Chu Suiliang, whose style name was Dengshan, was the son of Regular Attendant of the Palace Secretariat Chu Liang. At the end of the Sui dynasty he served Xue Ju as Attendant of Affairs. When Ren'guo was pacified he was appointed Army Staff Officer of the Armor Bureau in the Prince of Qin's household. During the Zhenguan era he rose in succession to Attendant of Daily Affairs. He was widely versed in literature and history and skilled in clerical and regular script calligraphy. Taizong once sighed and said, "Since Yu Shinan died, there is no one with whom I can discuss calligraphy! Wei Zheng introduced Suiliang to the emperor, who ordered him to attend at calligraphy. The emperor was then avidly collecting old works of Wang Xizhi, and the realm competed to present them, yet none could authenticate them. Suiliang alone judged their provenance, and never misattributed a single piece.
24
In the fifteenth year, as the emperor prepared to perform rites at Mount Tai and arrived at Luoyang, a comet appeared in the Supreme Palace Enclosure and encroached on the Official's Seat. Suiliang remonstrated, "Your Majesty has settled disorder and restored proper order, with merit surpassing antiquity. Just as you prepare to announce completion at Mount Tai, a comet suddenly appears—Heaven's intent is not yet aligned. Emperor Wu of Han deliberated for years before performing the Mount Tai rites. I urge Your Majesty to consider the matter more carefully. The emperor took heed and issued an edict canceling the feng and shan rites.
25
使
He was promoted to Grand Remonstrance Official and concurrently put in charge of the daily affairs records. The emperor asked, "You keep the daily affairs records—may the ruler generally view them? He replied, "Today's daily affairs records are the left and right historians of old. Good and evil must be recorded to warn the ruler against unlawful acts. I have never heard of a Son of Heaven viewing the histories himself." The emperor asked, "If I commit faults, will you surely record them?" He replied, "Keeping to one's office is more binding than keeping to abstract principle. My duty is to carry the brush—the ruler's every act must be written down." Liu Ji added, "Even if Suiliang did not record it, the people of the realm would." The emperor said, "My conduct rests on three principles: first, to observe the successes and failures of former ages as a great mirror; second, to advance good men and together complete the way of governance; third, to drive away petty men and not accept slanderous words. If I can hold to these and not fail, I also wish that the historians will have no evil to write of me."
26
使
At this time Prince Wei Tai received ritual rank and stipend equal to the legitimate heir, and no minister dared remonstrate. The emperor casually asked his attendants, "What matter today is most urgent? Cen Wenben spoke generally of ritual and righteousness as most urgent, but the emperor found this inapt and was not satisfied. Suiliang said, "The four quarters now look up to your virtue—who does not follow? Only the crown prince and the princes ought to have clearly fixed ranks. The emperor said, "That is exactly so! I am fifty years old and grow weaker by the day. Though the eldest son holds the vessel of succession, my younger brothers and branch sons still number fifty, and my heart is constantly troubled by this. Since antiquity, when imperial clansmen were not well nurtured, ruin followed in succession. Select worthy men to tutor and protect them for me. When men serve princes too long, familiarity breeds flattery and improper intentions arise. Order that princely household officials may not serve beyond four performance reviews, and establish this as a statute." The emperor once wondered aloud, "Shun made lacquer vessels and Yu carved sacrificial stands—more than ten remonstrators would not cease. Why make such a fuss over small things?" Suiliang said, "Carving and polishing harm farming, and embroidery injures women's work. This is the beginning of extravagance and the gradual approach of ruin. If lacquer vessels are not stopped, they will be made of gold; if gold is not stopped, they will be made of jade. Remonstrators therefore cut off the source and do not allow it to open. Once the flood runs unchecked, nothing more can be done." The emperor praised and commended this.
27
仿 ' '
At this time, though the princes were still young, all were assigned as military governors and prefects in the provinces. Suiliang remonstrated, "The two Han dynasties governed through commanderies and kingdoms together, mixing in Zhou institutions. Now prefectures and counties follow Qin-style administration, yet princes still in tender years are all appointed prefects. Your Majesty truly means to use closest kin to defend the four quarters. Even so, a prefect is the teacher and leader of the people. With the right man the people are at ease; with the wrong man households are worn to exhaustion. Therefore Emperor Xuan of Han said, 'Those who govern with me—are they not the good two-thousand-bushel officials?' I say that princes who have not yet come of age should remain in the capital for the time being, be taught the classics, revere the imperial majesty, and dare not violate prohibitions. Once nurtured into virtue and capacity and truly fit to govern a prefecture, they may then be dispatched. The emperors Ming and Zhang of Eastern Han loved their younger kinsmen. Though each prince had a state, the young generally remained in the capital and were trained in ritual. Through their reigns the princes numbered in the tens and hundreds, yet only two were ruined through evil. The rest, nourished by harmony and shaped by teaching, all became good men. This precedent has already been tested. I urge Your Majesty to consider it. The emperor praised and accepted this.
28
After Crown Prince Chengqian was deposed, Prince Wei Tai attended the emperor closely, and the emperor agreed to install him as heir. He told the ministers, "Tai yesterday threw himself into my arms and said, 'Today I have finally become Your Majesty's son—it is a day of rebirth. I have only one son; when I die, I shall kill him and pass the realm to the Prince of Jin. I deeply pity him.' Suiliang said, "Your Majesty misspoke. How can a lord of the realm kill his beloved son and give the realm to the Prince of Jin? Your Majesty formerly made Chengqian heir, then again favored Tai—the line between legitimate and secondary heir was never clear, and confusion has continued to the present. If Tai must be installed, the Prince of Jin must be set apart elsewhere." The emperor wept and said, "I cannot." He then ordered Zhangsun Wuji, Fang Xuanling, Li Ji, Suiliang, and others to settle the succession and install the Prince of Jin as crown prince.
29
At this time flying pheasants repeatedly gathered in the palace, and the emperor asked, "What omen is this? Suiliang said, "In the time of Duke Wen of Qin, a boy transformed into a pheasant. The female cried at Chencang and the male at Nanyang. The boy said, 'He who obtains the male shall become king; he who obtains the female shall become hegemon.' Duke Wen then dominated the feudal lords and first established the shrine at Baoji. Emperor Guangwu of Han obtained the male, rose from Nanyang, and won the four seas. Your Majesty was originally enfeoffed in Qin; therefore both male and female appear, announcing your bright virtue." The emperor was pleased and said, "In establishing oneself, one cannot be without learning. Suiliang is truly a widely learned gentleman!" Shortly afterward he was appointed Guest of the Heir.
30
使 退 使
Xueyantuo requested a marriage alliance. The emperor had already accepted their betrothal gifts, then broke off the engagement. Suiliang said, "Faith is the root of all things and what the people turn to. King Wen kept his promise even to dry bones; Confucius said to abandon food but preserve faith—such is its value. Xueyantuo was formerly but a minor chieftain. When the imperial army marched north and swept clear the desert passes, its might extended beyond the borders while grace bound the inner tribes. Thinking that the remaining bandits needed a chieftain, the court issued an imperial edict with drums and banners and installed him as qaghan. The grace shown him is boundless as Heaven. He repeatedly sent envoys requesting marriage at court. Your Majesty had already openly promised, and he came to the Northern Gate to present tribute food. Now to advance and retreat at a whim in a single morning—what is spared is little and what is lost is great. Faith is impaired before the barbarians, resentment is just arising, and this can scarcely instruct frontier troops or encourage military affairs. Moreover, north of Longsha the tribes are as numerous as cattle hair, and China cannot strike them all down. Just as defeat may come from the north, so Rouran may rise, the Türks perish, and Xueyantuo flourish. Therefore the men of old kept the outer realm light and the inner realm strong, embracing the barbarians with virtue. If evil is done, let it be among the barbarians and not among the Chinese; if faith is broken, let it be on their side and not on ours. I urge Your Majesty to judge and decide. The emperor did not accept this.
31
忿 忿 使 使 使
When the emperor wished to campaign personally against Liaodong, Suiliang firmly urged against it: "One defeat, and the army must be raised again; raised again, it becomes an army driven by wrath. An army driven by wrath—victory and defeat cannot be assured. The emperor agreed that this was so. But then Li Ji disparaged his plan, and the emperor's mind was fixed on the eastern campaign. Alarmed, Suiliang submitted a memorial: "I ask to compare this to the body. The two capitals are the heart and belly; the four borders are the hands and feet; remote alien lands at the ends of the earth are scarcely parts of the limbs at all. The king of Goguryeo was installed by Your Majesty, and Yeon Gaesomun killed him. Punishing his rebellion and leveling his land cannot be neglected, but send one or two careful generals with a hundred thousand elite troops under soaring banners and cloud chariots, and it can be taken as easily as spitting. Formerly Hou Junji and Li Jing were ordinary men, yet they overthrew Gaochang and bound the Türks. Your Majesty need only give the signal and point the way, and the merit returns to your sage brilliance. The fierce warriors and loyal ministers who followed Your Majesty to pacify the realm still have strength undiminished. They can be commanded as Your Majesty wishes. I have heard that east of the Liao there are floods, with three feet of mud on level ground, and that Daifang and Xuantu are coastal wastelands vast and desolate—decidedly not where the emperor's six armies ought to march. At this time the emperor was set on total conquest and did not heed this. He was promoted to Vice Director of the Yellow Gate and participated in governing affairs. Yeon Gaesomun sent envoys presenting gold tribute. Suiliang said, "In antiquity, when punishing regicide, one did not accept bribes. Lu accepted the tripod of Zou into the Grand Temple, and the Spring and Autumn Annals rebuked this. The tribute Yeon Gaesomun presents is that of a disloyal subject and cannot be accepted. An edict approved this, and his envoys were handed over to the officials.
32
調西 西西
After the emperor pacified Gaochang, a thousand troops were levied each year to garrison there. Suiliang remonstrated repeatedly against this, but the emperor's intent was to take the Western Regions and he ignored the advice. When the Western Türks raided Xizhou, the emperor said, "Formerly Wei Zheng and Chu Suiliang urged me to install Qu Wentai's sons and younger kinsmen. I did not use their plan, and now I regret it. The emperor set up a separate courtyard beside the sleeping palace for the crown prince. Suiliang remonstrated, saying, "Close friends who associate too deeply easily grow resentful; father and son who linger too long in affection often accumulate faults. The crown prince should be allowed to return periodically to the Eastern Palace, be near his tutors, and devote himself to learning so as to broaden his virtue." The emperor followed his advice. When his father died he resigned to mourn, but was recalled from mourning and appointed Director of the Secretariat.
33
As the emperor lay gravely ill, he summoned Suiliang and Zhangsun Wuji and said, "Emperor Wu entrusted Huo Guang, and Liu Bei entrusted Zhuge Liang—I now entrust you. The crown prince is benevolent and filial. Devote yourselves fully to assisting him. He told the crown prince, "With Wuji and Suiliang present, you need not worry." He then ordered Suiliang to draft the edict. When Gaozong ascended the throne, Suiliang was enfeoffed as Duke of Henan County and then advanced to Duke of a commandery. On account of an offense he was sent out as Prefect of Tongzhou. After two years he was recalled as Minister of Personnel, Associate with the Three Departments at the rank of the Three Dukes, Supervisor of the national history, and Guest of the Heir. He was promoted to Right Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs.
34
使 使 殿
When the emperor was about to install Lady Wu as empress, he summoned Zhangsun Wuji, Li Ji, Yu Zhining, and Suiliang. Some said Wuji ought to remonstrate first. Suiliang said, "The Grand Marshal is the state's chief maternal uncle. If things go against his wish, the emperor will be reproached for abandoning kin. They also said Li Ji was highly valued by the emperor and ought to speak up. Suiliang said, "That cannot be. The Minister of Works is the state's chief founding merit. If things go against his wish, the emperor will be suspected of rejecting his meritorious ministers." He said, "I received the testamentary edict. If I do not exhaust my counsel, I cannot face the late emperor in the afterlife." After they entered, the emperor said, "No crime is greater than cutting off the succession. The empress has no son, and now I wish to install Lady Wu—what do you say?" Suiliang said, "The empress is from an eminent clan and served the late emperor. When the late emperor was ill, he took Your Majesty's hand and told me, 'My son and daughter-in-law I now entrust to you!' His virtuous words are still in Your Majesty's ears—how can they be suddenly forgotten? The empress has no other fault and cannot be deposed." The emperor was displeased. The next day Suiliang spoke again and said, "If Your Majesty must install a new empress, please choose another from an eminent clan. Lady Wu formerly served the late emperor and shared his bedchamber. To install her now—what will the eyes and ears of the realm say? The emperor was ashamed and fell silent. Suiliang placed his court tablet on the palace steps, knocked his head until it bled, and said, "I return this tablet to Your Majesty and beg to retire to my fields. The emperor was furious and ordered him led out. Lady Wu called from behind the curtain, "Why not beat this brute to death? Wuji said, "Suiliang received the testamentary charge. Even if guilty, he shall not be punished." Li Ji's opinion differed, Lady Wu was installed, and Suiliang was demoted to Military Governor of Tanzhou.
35
In the second year of Xianqing he was moved to Guizhou, and before long demoted to Prefect of Aizhou. Suiliang inwardly feared disaster and worried that he could not clear his name even in death. He submitted a memorial saying, "When Chengqian was deposed, Cen Wenben and Liu Ji argued that the Eastern Palace could not be left vacant and that the Prince of Pu ought to dwell there. I firmly contested this on principle. The next day, entering with the imperial guard, the late emperor kept Wuji, Fang Xuanling, Li Ji, and me to settle the succession and install Your Majesty. At that time we received the testamentary edict. Only Wuji and I were present. Your Majesty was wailing in mourning dress, and I immediately memorialized requesting that you ascend the throne before the late emperor's bier. At that time Your Majesty embraced my neck. Wuji and I urged an immediate return to the capital, the announcement of mourning, and the restoration of order within and without. My strength is small yet my burden heavy, and I constantly bring sorrow upon myself. In my remaining years I beg Your Majesty's pity. The emperor was weak and muddled, pulled by Empress Wu, and to the end did not heed this. After more than a year he died, aged sixty-three.
36
使
Two years later Xu Jingzong and Li Yifu memorialized that Zhangsun Wuji's treasonous plot had all been incited by Suiliang, and his offices and titles were stripped. His two sons Yanfu and Yancong were exiled to Aizhou and killed. The emperor issued an edict permitting his family to return north. During the Shenlong era his offices and titles were restored. Emperor Dezong posthumously granted him the title of Grand Marshal. During Emperor Wenzong's reign, an edict appointed Suiliang's fifth-generation descendant Qian as Captain of Linyou. Annam Observation Commissioner Gao Pian reported that Suiliang had been buried in Aizhou, with two sons and one grandson buried alongside him. In the ninth year of Xiantong an edict sought his descendants to escort the remains home for burial at Yangdi.
37
Great-grandson: Qiu.
38
Suiliang's great-grandson Qiu, whose style name was Boyu, passed the jinshi examination and rose to Acting Investigating Censor. During Xiantian, when the Türks besieged Beiting, an edict ordered Qiu to bear the imperial staff and supervise the generals, and he defeated them. He was transferred to Attending Censor and appointed Vice Director in the Ministry of Rites. Yet his bearing remained stern and upright, no less than when he served at the Censorate.
39
Han Yuan, whose style name was Boyu, was a native of Sanyuan in Jingzhao. His father Zhongliang, at the beginning of Wude, helped codify laws and statutes and proposed, "Under Zhou law there were three thousand articles; after Qin and Han they were reduced to about five hundred. Following antiquity would make them cumbersome. I request honoring breadth and simplicity to show renewal. Thereupon they selected from the Kaihuang Code what suited the times and fixed it. He ended his career as Minister of Justice, Chief Administrator of the Qinzhou Military Governor's Office, and Duke of Yingchuan County.
40
Yuan from youth possessed integrity and strong moral character. He was broadly learned and understood administrative affairs. During Zhenguan he inherited the family title while serving as Vice Minister of War. In the third year of Yonghui he was transferred to Vice Director of the Yellow Gate. Shortly afterward he became Associate with the Three Departments at the rank of the Three Dukes and Supervisor of the national history. He was promoted to Palace Attendant and concurrently Guest of the Heir. When Empress Wang was to be deposed, Yuan wept openly and said, "The empress was taken in marriage by the late emperor when Your Majesty was still a prince. To depose her without crime is not a plan for the altars of state. The emperor did not accept this. The next day he remonstrated again, "When a king installs an empress, she matches Heaven and Earth and mirrors the sun and moon. Even common men and women know to choose one another—how much more the Son of Heaven? The Odes say, 'Splendid was the Zhou of the ancestors—Baosi destroyed it.' When I read to this point, I often put down the scroll and sigh deeply. I never expected to witness this calamity in our own dynasty. Will the ancestral temples not go without blood sacrifice! The emperor was furious and ordered him led out. After Chu Suiliang was demoted to Military Governor of Tanzhou, Yuan submitted a memorial the next year: "Suiliang received the late emperor's testamentary charge with undivided loyalty. In his daily counsel he was utterly sincere—how could he wish Your Majesty to fall behind Yao and Shun and stain the historical records? He has suffered thick slander, impairing Your Majesty's clarity and breaking the keen edge of men of resolve. Moreover, since his transfer he has passed through two cycles of cold and heat—his punishment is already sufficient. I hope the innocent may be pardoned to accord with the people's hearts. The emperor said, "I know Suiliang's feelings already. He is perverse and fond of offending his superiors. I reprove him—is there any fault in that?" Yuan said, "Suiliang is a minister of the altars of state. A fly can speck white and fabricate guilt. Formerly, once Weizi departed, Yin perished; if Zhang Hua had not died, Jin would not have reached disorder. Your Majesty possesses the four seas and rests in peace—will you not examine why you suddenly drive away old ministers? The emperor listened even less. Grieved and indignant, Yuan submitted a memorial requesting retirement to his fields; no reply was given.
41
使
In the second year of Xianqing, Xu Jingzong and Li Yifu memorialized, "Yuan gave Guizhou to Suiliang. Gui is a military region, and relying on him they plotted rebellion. Thereupon he was demoted to Prefect of Zhenzhou. After more than a year he died, aged fifty-four. After Zhangsun Wuji died, Yifu and others again memorialized that Yuan had conspired with him and sent envoys to kill him immediately; when they arrived Yuan was already dead. They opened the coffin to verify and then returned. His offices and titles were posthumously stripped, his household was registered, and his descendants were banished as official slaves in Guangzhou. At the beginning of Shenlong, Empress Wu's testamentary edict restored his offices and titles. From the time Yuan and Suiliang died in succession, frank speech was taboo at court and beyond for nearly twenty years. When the emperor built Fengtian Palace, Censor Li Shangan was the first to submit a bold memorial. People of the time rejoiced and called it "the phoenix crying toward the sun."
42
Lai Ji was a native of Jiangdu in Yangzhou. His father Huer was Left Majestic Guard General under the Sui. During the disaster of Yuwen Huaji the whole household perished, but Ji, still young, escaped. Wandering and displaced, he devoted himself to writing, was skilled in discourse, understood current affairs clearly, and passed the jinshi examination. During Zhenguan he rose in succession to Attendant of Affairs. When Crown Prince Chengqian failed, Taizong asked the attending ministers how to deal with him, but none dared reply. Ji said, "Your Majesty would not fail to be a loving father. If the crown prince is allowed to live out his natural years, that would be best. The emperor accepted this. He was appointed Vice Director in the Ministry of Personnel's Merit Office. In the eighteenth year the Heir's Remonstrance Official was first established with high selection standards, and Ji was appointed to it while also serving as Direct Academician of the Chongxian Hall. He was transferred to Drafting Attendant of the Secretariat. In the second year of Yonghui he was appointed Vice Director of the Secretariat, concurrently Academician of the Hongwen Hall, and Supervisor of the national history. Shortly afterward he became Associate with the Three Departments at the rank of the Three Dukes and was enfeoffed as Baron of Nanyang County. He was transferred to Director of the Secretariat and acting Minister of Personnel.
43
When the emperor was about to install Lady Wu as empress, Ji remonstrated, "A king installs an empress to inherit the ancestral temples and mother the realm. He ought to choose one from a ritually upright eminent clan—secluded, graceful, and virtuous—matching the hopes of the four seas and fulfilling the intent of the spirits. King Wen raised the Si clan, and the transforming influence of "Guansui" covered the common people—such was its blessing; Emperor Cheng indulged his desires and made a maidservant empress; the imperial line declined midway—such was its calamity. I urge Your Majesty to examine this carefully. At first, when Lady Wu was favored, the emperor specially titled her Imperial Consort. Ji and Han Yuan remonstrated, "Consorts have fixed quotas. To establish a separate title now cannot be done. After Lady Wu was installed as empress, she was not at ease. The empress falsely praised Ji and the others as loyal and blunt, claiming they might harbor unease because of their earlier remonstrances, and requested rewards and consolation for them—yet in fact she resented them. The emperor showed this to Ji and Yuan, and they grew even more fearful.
44
At the beginning of Xianqing he was concurrently Guest of the Heir and advanced in rank to Marquis. The emperor once casually asked what was fitting in governing subordinates. Ji said, "Formerly Duke Huan of Qi went on an outing, saw an old man, and ordered food for him. The man said, 'Please give food to the realm. He gave him clothing, and the man said, 'Please give clothing to the realm.' The duke said, 'My treasury is limited—how can I provide for all?' The old man said, 'If spring does not seize the farming season, there will be food;' if summer does not seize the silkworm workers, there will be clothing. From this it follows that reducing corvée labor is what is fitting in governing subordinates.' At that time corvée laborers east of the mountains numbered tens of thousands each year, and there was further discussion of substitute payments to compensate hired labor, causing widespread confusion—therefore Ji answered with this. In the second year he was concurrently Steward of the Heir. Soon he was implicated in Chu Suiliang's affair and demoted to Prefect of Taizhou. After a long time he was moved to Tingzhou. In the second year of Longshuo the Türks invaded. Ji gathered troops to resist them and said to his men, "I was once caught in the net of punishment and was spared death by pardon. Now I must use my body to fulfill my duty. He then rode against the enemy without armor and perished, aged fifty-three. He was posthumously made Prefect of Chuzhou, and a funeral carriage was granted to return him home.
45
調
At first Ji lodged with Gao Zhizhou, Hao Chujun, and Sun Chuyue at the home of Shi Zhonglan of Xuancheng. Zhonglan was wealthy and discerning, and treated the four men very generously. In private they spoke of their ambitions. Chujun said, "I wish to govern the realm. Ji and Zhizhou said the same. Chuyue said, "Grand councilor may be beyond hope. To be an Attendant of Affairs would be enough. Later, when Ji headed the Ministry of Personnel, Chuyue entered for assignment as a clerical assistant from Yingzhou. Ji immediately noted "as wished" and appointed Chuyue Attendant of Affairs. Later all reached the rank of grand councilor.
46
Half-brother by different mother: Heng.
47
Ji's half-brother Heng, during Shangyuan, was Vice Director of the Yellow Gate and Associate with the Three Departments at the rank of the Three Dukes. Their father had been a fierce general, yet Heng and Ji were both known for learning and conduct and successively managed state affairs. At the time Yu Shinan's son Chang had no talent or skill. He successively served as Vice Director of the Directorate for Palace Buildings and Vice Director in the Ministry of Works, overseeing construction. Xu Jingzong said, "Huer's son becomes chief minister, Shinan's son becomes a craftsman—can civil and military talent be inherited by breed?"
48
Li Yiyan.
49
西 姿 使
Li Yiyan was a native of Changle in Weizhou. His ancestors came from the Wang clan of Longxi. Upon passing the jinshi examination he was appointed Assistant Magistrate of Taiyuan. When Li Ji was military governor, his staff feared his authority, but Yiyan alone dared argue right and wrong in open court, and Ji treated him with great respect. He was transferred as Magistrate of Baishui, gained a reputation for ability, and was promoted to Vice Director in the Ministry of Justice. Yiyan was tall and distinguished in bearing, broadly learned, and possessed wisdom and discernment. He rose in succession to Vice Director of the Secretariat. During Shangyuan he was advanced to Associate with the Three Departments at the rank of the Three Dukes and concurrently Right Guardian of the Heir. When Gaozong wished to have Empress Wu administer state affairs, Yiyan and Hao Chujun firmly contested it, and the matter was dropped. When Crown Prince Zhanghuai was deposed, all palace officials' crimes were pardoned. Guardians such as Xue Yuanchao danced in joy, but Yiyan alone took blame upon himself and wept, and the gentry honored him for this. Whenever the emperor consulted him, he was always blunt and firm and did not yield. His residence had no proper main chamber. His younger brother Yijin purchased hall timber on the market and sent it to him. Yiyan said, "That I am made chief minister is already a source of shame to me. To still build a fine dwelling is to hasten my calamity—can this be love for me? Yijin said, "Even those who serve as assistant magistrates and captains still honor their residences. Elder brother's rank is high—how can he be pressed so low?" He answered, "That is not so. Matters are hard to complete fully; things do not flourish in pairs. To hold high office and also expand one's dwelling—without outstanding virtue, one will surely receive calamity." In the end he did not consent. Later the timber rotted and was discarded.
50
使 使 祿
Yiyan reburied his ancestors, making his maternal kin move their tombs so that he could establish his own burial site there. When the emperor heard this, he angrily said, "This man cannot be allowed to hold power. Yiyan feared this, pleaded illness and requested retirement, was granted the title of Grand Master of Splendid Happiness with the Silver Seal, permitted to retire, and returned to his fields. From grand councilors down all saw him off with a farewell feast outside Tonghua Gate. People of the time compared him to Shu Guang of Han. At the beginning of Chuigong he was recalled as Prefect of Huaizhou. Believing he had lost Empress Wu's favor, he declined the appointment and died.
51
Son: Chao.
52
殿 簿
His son Chao was bold and talented from youth, skilled at mounted archery, but did not attend to minor conduct. Yiyan once confined him and cut off his associations. Later he fled to the palace gates and submitted a memorial setting forth advantages and harms. He was appointed Investigating Censor, together with Li Yifu investigated the cases of Liu Shi and Han Yuan, and was transferred to the Palace Censorate. A memorial offended the imperial intent, and he was demoted to Registrar of Longbian.
53
Younger cousin by father's brother: Yichen.
54
使 使使 使
Yiyan's younger cousin Yichen. Yichen passed the jinshi examination and successively served as Investigating Censor. During Zhenguan, Princess Wencheng presented gold tribute. It was robbed at Qizhou, and the case could not be solved. Taizong summoned the censors and, looking at Yichen, said, "This man's spirit is bright and outstanding. He can be sent to investigate and capture them. Yichen went, and within several days captured the bandits. The emperor was pleased and promoted him seven ranks. When Yiyan was envoy to Goguryeo, its king summoned him while reclining on a couch. Yiyan did not bow and said, "I am the Son of Heaven's envoy, equal to the ruler of a small state—why receive me with such arrogance? The king apologized and showed him added courtesy. When Yichen went as envoy a second time, he too was summoned while seated, and Yichen crawled and prostrated himself. People of the time thus saw the brothers' relative merits.
55
He rose in succession to Vice Director in the Ministry of Justice. As Chief Administrator of Yongzhou, when the Guanzhong region suffered great famine, an edict ordered the poor to go for food to Shang and Deng. Yichen feared they would drift away and not return, and submitted a memorial firmly contesting this. He was demoted to Military Governor of Lizhou and ended his career as Prefect of Qizhou.
56
His son Wan served as Magistrate of Bairen with benevolent governance, and the county erected a shrine for him.
57
Shangguan Yi.
58
His son Tingzhi served as an official of the Prince of Zhou's household and was also killed. Tingzhi's daughter, who during Zhongzong's reign was a Lady of Bright Countenance, had Yi posthumously granted the titles of Director of the Secretariat, Military Governor of Qinzhou, and Duke of Chu; Tingzhi was made Vice Director of the Yellow Gate, Prefect of Qizhou, and Duke of Tianshui Commandery, and was reburied according to ritual.
59
Commentary.
60
使 使
The commentary says: Gaozong was no true ruler—how could one govern with him? Inwardly pulled by a favorite's shadow, outwardly seized by slanderous words—Wuji, his closest kin, and Suiliang, his loyal minister, both testamentary grand ministers, were in one day executed and cast out, and he endured this without reflection. He reversed Heaven's firmness and bent the brightness of the yang; in the end he let the hen crow at dawn and the throne pass to the empress's house—how pitiable! Heaven used the female warrior to divide Tang and rise. Though men of righteousness resisted with their lives, the dynasty could not be sustained. Yet Yuan, Ji, Yiyan, and Yi—the four of them—can be said to have known what to hold to. Alas! If Zhangsun had not driven away Jiangxia and harmed Prince Wu, and if Chu had not slandered Liu Ji to his death, could their great virtue have been even slightly faulted?
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →