← Back to 新唐書

卷一百五十三 列傳第七十八 段秀實 顏真卿

Volume 153 Biographies 78: Duan Xiushi, Yan Zhenqing

Chapter 153 of 新唐書 · New Book of Tang
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 153
Next Chapter →
1
Duan Xiushi, whose courtesy name was Chenggong, came from Guzang. His great-grandfather Shi Jun had served as prefect of Long Prefecture; he stayed in the region rather than return home, and the family thereafter counted as natives of Qianyang. When Xiushi was six, his mother fell gravely ill. For seven days he would not take so much as a spoonful of food or drink, and ate only after her condition improved. People called him the "Filial Boy." As he matured, he proved grave, steadfast, and decisive, with a fervent desire to serve the common good. He passed the Mingjing examination, but a friend urged him to change course. Xiushi said, "Picking through texts for quotations will never win real achievement. He left the scholarly path behind.
2
西使西 西
In Tianbao year 4 (745), he followed Anxi military commissioner Ma Lingzhao on a successful campaign against Humi and was appointed deputy general of the Anxi headquarters. After Lingzhao left office, he entered the service of Gao Xianzhi. Xianzhi marched against the Arabs and laid siege to Talas. When enemy reinforcements arrived, Xianzhi pulled his army back in disorder, and the troops were scattered. That night Xiushi heard the voice of deputy general Li Siye, recognized him, and rebuked him: "Running from the enemy out of fear is not courage; saving yourself while leaving the rest to perish is not humanity. Ashamed, Siye joined Xiushi in rallying the scattered troops, re-formed the army, and returned to Anxi, where he asked that Xiushi serve as his staff judge. He was promoted to guoyi of the Great Tui Office in Long Prefecture. He later followed Feng Changqing against Greater Bolü, encamped at Hesalao City, fought the enemy, and won. As Changqing pressed the pursuit northward, Xiushi said, "They have put out a weak detachment to lure us on. I ask that we search the area thoroughly. They uncovered every hidden ambush, and the enemy army was put to rout. He was appointed zhechong commandant of Suide Prefecture.
3
西 使 使 使 祿 使
While Emperor Suzong was at Lingwu, he ordered Siye to march five thousand Anxi troops posthaste to the imperial camp. Military commissioner Liang Zai wanted to delay departure and watch how events unfolded, and Siye quietly agreed. Xiushi rebuked him: "The Son of Heaven is in desperate straits, and you would sit idle? You call yourself a great man—today you act like a timid child. Siye pressed Zai until he yielded, and the army marched east with Xiushi as deputy. When Siye became military commissioner, Xiushi was still in mourning for his father; summoned from mourning, he was named Friend of the Prince of Yi and served as the commissioner's staff judge. When An Qingxu fled to Ye, Siye and the other generals besieged him, left the baggage train at Henei, and appointed Xiushi concurrently chief administrator of Huai Prefecture, with charge of prefectural affairs and acting rear commander. The army was exhausted and funds were running out; Xiushi supervised supply lines, recruited troops, and bought horses to keep the campaign going. At the battle of Chousigang, Siye was killed by a stray arrow, and the troops chose Lifei Yuanli to replace him. On hearing the news, Xiushi at once wrote to Bai Xiaode asking him to send troops to escort the coffin to Henei; he met the procession at the border with his officers and paid for the burial out of his own purse. Yuanli admired his conduct and memorialized that he be promoted on probation to Vice Director of the Imperial Household. Soon afterward Yuanli was killed by his own troops and many officers perished with him, but the soldiers trusted Xiushi and would not harm him; they lined up to pay him homage and instead chose Bai Xiaode as military commissioner. Having served three military headquarters in succession, Xiushi grew still more famous.
4
使 使
When Tibetans raided the capital and Emperor Daizong withdrew to Shaan, Xiushi urged Xiaode to march to the rescue without delay. When Xiaode was transferred to Binning, Xiushi was appointed deputy commissioner for logistics and military colonies. With Binning short of grain, he asked to encamp at Fengtian and draw supplies from the capital region. Public granaries were empty, county clerks fled in confusion, and troops scattered to plunder at will—Xiaode could not control them. Xiushi said, "Put me in charge as army overseer, and it would never come to this. Staff officer Wang Ji relayed the offer, and Xiushi was put in charge of the Fengtian field headquarters. His orders were strict and uniform, and discipline returned to the ranks. After the army returned, Xiaode recommended him as prefect of Jing and had him enfeoffed as Prince of Zhangye Commandery.
5
使 使 宿
Guo Ziyi was then deputy supreme commander at Pu; his son Xi, with the acting title of Minister, held field headquarters command and was encamped at Bin. His troops ran wild. Villains of Bin bribed their way into the ranks and did as they pleased, beyond any official's reach. By day they roamed the markets in gangs, extorting goods; anyone who refused was beaten. They smashed cookware until the streets were littered with debris, and even killed pregnant women. Xiaode dared not act. Xiushi reported from his prefecture to headquarters and asked to discuss the crisis. When he arrived he said, "The Son of Heaven entrusted these people to your care. You watch them suffer violence and do nothing—how long before total chaos? Xiaode said, "I will follow your guidance." Xiushi went on: "I cannot stand by while innocents are killed in peacetime and the frontier is thrown into chaos. Appoint me chief military police officer, and I will end this disorder for you." Xiaode issued the appointment at once and turned him over to the army. Soon seventeen of Xi's men went into the market for wine, stabbed the wine seller, and smashed his equipment. Xiushi seized them, beheaded them, and planted their heads on spears outside the market gate. The whole camp erupted in uproar and armed for battle. Terrified, Xiaode summoned Xiushi: "What now? Xiushi said, "Let me speak to them." He unbuckled his sword, chose one old veteran to hold his horse, and went alone to Xi's gate. Armored men rushed out. Xiushi smiled as he entered and said, "All this armor over one old soldier killed—why? I have come offering my own head. The soldiers stood stunned. He reasoned with them: "Has the Minister wronged you? Has the deputy supreme commander wronged you? Why would you destroy the Guo family through mutiny? When Xi came out, Xiushi said, "Your father's merit fills heaven and earth. He must see matters through to the end. You let your men run wild and throw the frontier into chaos—who will bear the blame? The guilt will reach your father. Vicious youths of Bin buy their way into your rolls and murder at will. How long before total chaos? The disorder will start with you. Everyone will say the Minister failed to restrain his men because of his father's rank. How much of the Guo family's fame and fortune will survive?" Xi bowed twice and said, "Thank you for your guidance. I will bring the army to heel." He ordered his men to remove their armor at once and declared, "Anyone who makes another uproar dies!" Xiushi said, "I have not eaten since mid-afternoon. Please set out a meal." After eating he said, "I feel ill and would like to stay the night at your gate." He lay down inside the camp. Xi was terrified and ordered the watch to strike the night clapper and guard him through the night. At dawn they went together to Xiaode's headquarters, where Xi apologized for his failure to control the troops. Bin was pacified from that day on.
6
使 輿 西
Earlier, while serving as military colony officer, Jing's senior general Jiao Lingchen had seized private fields, leased them to farmers, and demanded half the harvest. That year brought severe drought. When farmers reported no yield, Lingchen said, "I deal in harvests, not droughts. He pressed them hard for payment. Unable to pay, they appealed to Xiushi. Xiushi issued a document exempting them and sent a courteous message to Lingchen. Enraged, Lingchen summoned the farmers and demanded, "Do I fear Duan Xiushi? He pinned the document to their backs, gave each twenty heavy strokes of the staff, and had them carried into the courtyard. Xiushi wept and said, "I am the one who brought this on you. He tore his own robe to dress their wounds, applied medicine, and sold his horse to pay their debt. Huaixi officer Yin Shaorong, a man of fierce integrity, went in and cursed Lingchen: "Are you even human? The fields of Jing are bare as ochre, people are starving to death, yet you demand grain and beat the innocent. Lord Duan, a man of humanity and trust, had only one horse. He sold it to buy grain for you. Are you not ashamed to take it? A man who defies heaven's calamity, insults his betters, and beats the innocent—would he not blush before a slave? Hearing this, Lingchen flushed with shame and sweat and said, "I can never face Lord Duan again." That night he died of remorse.
7
稿 使
When Ma Lin replaced Xiaode, he consulted Xiushi on every matter. When Lin's decisions were wrong, Xiushi argued firmly and would not relent until Lin yielded. When Lin first fortified Jing, Xiushi served as acting rear commander and was promoted to Vice Censor-in-Chief for his labors. In Dali year 3 (768), the army was transferred to Jing. These troops had marched from the Four Garrisons and Beiting to save the dynasty and had won many victories; the sudden transfer stirred widespread resentment. Deputy general Wang Tongzhi plotted mutiny, agreeing that when the alarm drum sounded they would rise. Xiushi learned of the plot, summoned the drummer, feigned anger at a lapse, and warned, "Report each time the watch is fully counted." He delayed the watches by several quarters until all four night watches had sounded before dawn. The next day another informant said, "Tonight they will burn the hay stores and use the fire drill as cover for mutiny. Xiushi tightened security. Fire broke out in the night as predicted. He ordered the army, "Anyone who tries to fight the fire will be executed! Tongzhi, who was outside the camp, asked to enter and was refused. The next day he arrested Tongzhi and beheaded him with eight accomplices as a warning: "Anyone who mutinies again—his whole clan! The army then completed its transfer to Jing. Food stores were depleted and the city walls stood empty; the court was alarmed. Lin was ordered to draw supplies from Zheng and Ying to support the army, with Xiushi as acting rear commander. The army never wanted for supplies, and the two prefectures prospered. Lin praised his achievements and had him appointed campaigning staff marshal and overall commander of troops and horses.
8
使
When Tibetans raided the frontier, the army fought at Yancang and was defeated. Lin was cut off by the enemy and could not return. Commanders led the routed troops into camp ahead of him. Xiushi rebuked them: "By the art of war, when the general is lost, his subordinates are beheaded. You forget your duty to die with your commander, yet you wish to go home to your families? He mustered every soldier in the city, placed crack officers in command, deployed elite troops on the eastern plain, and made a show of readiness to give battle. The enemy saw this and dared not press the attack. Before long Lin made his way back.
9
使
When Lin fell ill, he asked Xiushi to serve as acting deputy military commissioner. Xiushi kept the army on alert. When Lin died, he put Colonel Ma Di in charge of the funeral and Li Hanhui in charge of receiving guests. He assigned places for family in the hall, clansmen in the courtyard, guest officers inside headquarters, and clerks and soldiers at camp—only kin might stand beside the bier. He attended morning and evening for three days, then stopped. Anyone among the clan who stood apart whispering was seized and imprisoned. Chief military police officer Shi Tinggan and staff generals Cui Zhen and Zhang Jinghua plotted mutiny. Xiushi sent Tinggan to the capital and transferred Zhen and Jinghua elsewhere, and the army was pacified.
10
使 使 殿 使
He was immediately appointed campaigning commander of the Four Garrisons and Beiting and military commissioner of Jingyuan, Zheng, and Ying. For several years the Tibetans dared not raid the frontier. He enforced regulations strictly: envoys received only half their usual stipends; he allowed music and wine only at official gatherings; his quarters held no singing girls or concubines, and he accumulated no private wealth; when guests and aides visited, they discussed military affairs only, never private matters. In year 13 he came to court and was received at Penglai Hall. When Emperor Daizong asked how to secure the frontier, he traced a map on the ground and laid out his plan item by item. The emperor was pleased, rewarded him generously, granted him a top-ranked residence, and gave him a substantive fief of one hundred households. He returned to his post. When Emperor Dezong acceded, he was additionally appointed Acting Minister of Rites. Early in the Jianzhong era, Chancellor Yang Yan revived Yuan Zai's plan to fortify Yuan Prefecture. When an imperial envoy came to inquire, Xiushi said, "Earthworks cannot begin in spring. Wait until the farming season ends. Yan took this as obstruction and summoned him to the capital as Director of the Imperial Granaries.
11
使 輿
When Zhu Ci rebelled, he reckoned that Xiushi, having lost his command, must be bitter, and that his long-standing reputation made him worth winning over. He sent horsemen to bring him in. Xiushi bade farewell to his sons and brothers and entered. Ci was delighted: "With you here, my cause is assured. Xiushi said, "The troops marched east and were poorly rewarded at the feast—that is the officials' fault. What has the Son of Heaven to do with it? You are known throughout the realm for loyalty. Now that crisis has struck, you should explain the stakes to the troops, purge the palace, and welcome back the emperor. That is your duty." Ci said nothing. Knowing persuasion had failed, Xiushi feigned compliance while secretly plotting with Generals Liu Haibin and Yao Lingyan and chief military police officer He Mingli to overthrow Ci. All three were men Xiushi had long favored. Yuan Xiu then urged Ci to feign welcoming the emperor and sent General Han Min with three thousand elite troops racing toward Fengtian. Xiushi saw that the dynasty's peril brooked no delay. He sent word to senior clerk Qi Lingyue to steal Lingyan's seal; when that failed, he used the Director of Granaries seal to issue a recall order. Min reached Luoyi Post Station, received the recall order, and turned back. Xiushi told Haibin, "When Min returns, none of us will survive. I will strike Ci down myself, or die in the attempt. They agreed that when the moment came the others would follow up, with Mingli responding from outside. The next day Ci summoned Xiushi to discuss strategy. Yuan Xiu, Yao Lingyan, Li Zhongchen, and Li Ziping were all present. Xiushi in military dress sat with Xiu discussing the usurpation. He suddenly rose, seized Xiu's wrist, snatched his ivory tablet, rushed forward, spat in Ci's face, and roared, "Mad traitor! You deserve to be torn limb from limb! Do you think I would follow you in rebellion? He struck Ci. Ci raised his arm to block the blow. The tablet struck his forehead, blood spattered his face, and he crawled away. The rebels dared not move, but Haibin and the others never came. Xiushi shouted, "I will not rebel with you—why not kill me! He was cut down. He was sixty-five. Haibin, Mingli, Lingyue, and the others were killed in turn by the rebels. At Fengtian the emperor wept in remorse, lamenting that he had never used Xiushi to the full measure of his ability.
12
When summoned from Jing, Xiushi warned his household, "If we pass through Qi, Zhu Ci will surely send gifts. Accept nothing. At Qi, Ci pressed three hundred bolts of fine silk on them. The household refused, and he failed. In the capital Xiushi said angrily, "I will never let this defile my home. He had it stored between the beams of the Director of Granaries' main hall. A clerk later told Ci, who came to inspect it. The wrapping was still intact and untouched.
13
Xiushi once warned the emperor that the imperial guard was too few and weak to meet emergencies: "In antiquity the Son of Heaven was called 'ten thousand chariots,' lords 'a thousand chariots,' and grandees 'a hundred chariots'—the large controls the small, and ten controls one. Barbarians defy us outside, defiant ministers plot inside, yet the guard is pitifully small. When crisis strikes, how will you meet it? A tiger terrifies all beasts because of its claws and fangs; remove them, and dogs and pigs become its enemies. The emperor ignored the advice. When the Jing troops mutinied and the Six Divine Strategy Armies were summoned, not one soldier came. The world then praised his foresight.
14
簿
In Xingyuan year 1 (784), an edict posthumously appointed him Grand Preceptor with the posthumous title Loyal and Fierce. He was granted a fief of five hundred households, a manor, and a residence; his eldest son third rank, his other sons fifth rank, all as regular appointees. When the emperor returned to the capital, he ordered sacrifices, honored his household gate, and personally inscribed his stele. In the Taihe era his son Bolun first established a ancestral temple. An edict granted imperial insignia, five hundred bolts of treasury silk, and sacrifices with the lesser tai la victims.
15
使
Bolun rose to Fujian observation commissioner and ended his career as Director of the Imperial Stud. Chancellor Li Shi asked Emperor Wenzong to add funeral gifts. Zheng Tan said, "From antiquity, none who gave his life for the state has equaled Xiushi. The emperor was deeply moved, dismissed court, and granted the request.
16
使西 使 紿
His grandsons Yi, Wenchu, and Ke were well known. Grandson Yi entered court from Zheng-Hua military commissioner as Grand General of the Right Jinwu Guard and was enfeoffed Duke of Xiping. At the Sweet Dew Incident, Yi faced execution. Pei Du argued that as descendant of a loyal minister he should be spared and had him demoted to marshal of Xun Prefecture. Grandson Wenchu served as defense commissioner of Yun Prefecture at the end of the Xiantong era. Li Guochang held Zhenwu; his son Keyong wanted Yunzhong, attacked, and killed Wenchu below the Cockfighting Terrace. The Shatuo disorders began here. Grandson Ke lived at Ying Prefecture under Emperor Xizong. When Huang Chao besieged Ying, the prefect wished to surrender. Ke recruited young men to resist. Townspeople brought provisions and volunteered to fight. The rebels broke and fled. Ke was appointed prefectural marshal. Appended biography: Liu Haibin of Pengcheng was renowned for righteous chivalry. He was a Jingyuan troop-and-horse officer and a close friend of Xiushi. He won repeated battle honors and was appointed Vice Censor-in-Chief. When Liu Wenxi rebelled and held Jing, Haibin and his son Guangguo tricked him with a request to memorialize the throne. At court they denounced the traitor's crimes and called for his execution. On their return Guangguo personally beheaded Wenxi and presented his head at court. He was appointed Grand General of the Left Xiaowei Guard and enfeoffed Prince of Wuyuan; Haibin was made Prince of Leping, posthumously appointed Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent, with a substantive fief of one hundred households. Yan Zhenqing, whose courtesy name was Qingchen, was a fifth-generation descendant of Secretariat Director Yan Shigu. Orphaned in youth, he was raised and taught by his mother, Lady Yin. As he grew up, he became broadly learned and skilled in letters, and deeply filial toward his parents.
17
調 使 使 殿 忿
During the Kaiyuan era he passed the jinshi examination and was also selected in the special decree examination. He was appointed magistrate of Liquan. He was promoted to investigating censor and sent on mission to the He and Long circuits. At Wuyuan a wrongful case had long gone unresolved while drought threatened. Zhenqing cleared the case and rain fell. The people called him "Censor Rain." Sent again to Hedong, he impeached Shuo magistrate Zheng Yanzuo for leaving his mother's body unburied for thirty years. An edict barred him from office for life. All who heard it were stunned. He was promoted to palace attendant censor. Censor Ji Wen framed Vice Censor Song Hun out of private spite and had him demoted to He Prefecture. Zhenqing said, "How can you, in a fit of anger, seek to destroy the descendants of Song Jing? Chancellor Yang Guozhong hated him and had Vice Censor Jiang Lie memorialize his transfer to Eastern Capital investigation staff judge, then to Vice Director of the Ministry of War. Guozhong finally got rid of him by sending him out as prefect of Pingyuan.
18
祿 祿 祿使
An Lushan's rebellious intent was already showing. Zhenqing judged he would surely rebel. Outwardly citing heavy rains, he raised walls, deepened moats, assessed able men, and stocked granaries. He spent his days boating and drinking with guests to allay Lushan's suspicions. Lushan took him for a mere scholar and never suspected him. When Lushan rebelled, every prefecture north of the Yellow River fell—only Pingyuan stood ready. Zhenqing sent staff officer Li Ping racing to court with the news. When Emperor Xuanzong first heard of the rebellion, he sighed: "Of Hebei's twenty-four commanderies, is there not one loyal minister? When Ping arrived, the emperor was overjoyed and said to his attendants, "I never knew what manner of man Zhenqing was—and see what he has done!" End of the emperor's words.
19
西 紿
Pingyuan had three thousand Jingsai troops. Zhenqing recruited until he had ten thousand men, put recording officer Li Zejiao in overall command, and appointed Diao Wansui, He Lin, Xu Hao, Ma Xiangru, Gao Kanglang, and others as generals to lead the units. At the west gate he treated his troops to a great banquet, weeping as he spoke with passion until all were stirred to renewed courage. Raoyang's Lu Quancheng, Jinan's Li Sui, Qinghe chief administrator Wang Huaizhong, Jingcheng's Li Wei, and Ye's Wang Tao all defected with their men. The court ordered Beihai prefect Helan Jinming to cross the Yellow River with five thousand crack troops to aid him. After the rebels captured Luoyang, they sent Duan Ziguang to display the severed heads of Li Zhi, Lu Yi, and Jiang Qing across Hebei. Fearing his men would lose heart, Zhenqing lied to his officers: "I knew Zhi and the others well—these heads are not theirs. With that he had Ziguang beheaded and hid the three heads from view. Later he had straw figures fashioned to stand in for the missing bodies, interred them with proper rites, arranged mourning seats, and led the lamentation.
20
使
About then his cousin Gaoqing, as prefect of Changshan, killed the rebel commanders Li Qintou and his fellows and reclaimed Tumen Pass. On a single day seventeen commanderies came over to the loyal side and chose Zhenqing as their alliance chief. With two hundred thousand men he severed rebel communications between Yan and Zhao. The throne at once made him vice minister of revenue to serve under Li Guangbi against the rebellion. He made Li Hui his second-in-command and appointed Li Xian, Jia Zai, and Shen Zhen as his staff officers. Soon he was also named commissioner for pacification and inspection in Hebei.
21
使崿崿 西'' 崿使 使
Qinghe's prefect dispatched a local man named Li E to request reinforcements. E said: "Word has spread that you were the first in Hebei to raise the banner of loyalty. All the north now treats you as their bulwark. Qinghe lies on your western flank. It holds Jianghuai grain and cloth reserves for the northern armies—known as the empire's northern storehouse. By its stockpiles alone it could supply three times what you have in Pingyuan, and its troops would more than double your current strength. Seize it and make it your strategic heartland, and every other city will answer your orders as readily as fingers move at a gesture of the hand. Zhenqing sent six thousand men and asked him: "My troops are on the move—what do you propose we do next? Li E replied: "The throne has Cheng Qianli leading a hundred thousand men eastward through the Taihang range. He means to debouch at Guo Pass and pin the rebels in place. If you strike Wei first, kill the rebel garrison commander Yuan Zhita, punch through Guo Pass with your best units, and dispatch the imperial forces against Ye and Youbei while Pingyuan and Qinghe combine a hundred thousand men to threaten Luoyang, then detach elite troops to hold the enemy's vital crossings— hold your lines and refuse battle. Within ten days their army will break apart and they will destroy each other. Zhenqing agreed that this was the plan. He notified Qinghe and neighboring commanderies, then sent his chief general Li Zejiao with deputies Fan Dongfu, He Lin, and Xu Hao and five thousand troops from Qinghe and Boping to garrison Tangyi. Yuan Zhita met them with twenty thousand men under Bai Sishen and Yi Shumeng. The rebels were routed; ten thousand were killed or captured, and Zhita fled to Ji.
22
使
Shi Siming blockaded Raoyang and sent mobile units to intercept relief from Pingyuan. Convinced he was outmatched, Zhenqing wrote to Helan Jinming, upbraiding him in his capacity as Hebei pacification commissioner. Jinming was beaten at Xindu. Liu Zhengchen of Pinglu had just brought Yuyang over to the loyal side. To cement his commitment, Zhenqing sent Jia Zai by sea with military supplies worth more than a hundred thousand cash—and pledged his son Po as surety. Po was only ten. His officers begged him to keep the boy back, but he refused.
23
使 使 崿使
By then Emperor Suzong had taken the throne at Lingwu. Zhenqing sent messenger after messenger with wax-sealed dispatches reporting on conditions in the north. He was made minister of works and chief censor, and once more named Hebei pacification commissioner. Military funds were running dry. Li E persuaded Zhenqing to monopolize Jingcheng salt and arrange mutual deliveries among the commanderies. From then on supplies never ran short. Diwu Qi was then serving in Jinming's command. He later adopted the same scheme on a wider scale, and the imperial armies grew flush with resources.
24
祿
Lushan seized the moment to hurl Siming and Yin Ziqi against Hebei. The commanderies fell again one by one; only Pingyuan, Boping, and Qinghe held out. Morale nonetheless collapsed, and the will to fight did not return. Zhenqing consulted his officers: "The enemy is too strong for us to stand against. To die here and disgrace the empire serves no purpose. Better to make our way directly to the emperor's camp. If the court holds us accountable for losing the north, I will accept death without regret. In the tenth month of Zhide 1 (756), he abandoned his post, crossed the Yellow River, and after a perilous journey reached Fengxiang to see the emperor. The court made him minister of justice, then chief censor.
25
使 使
Even while the court was still scrambling to establish itself, Zhenqing enforced order as rigorously as ever. Cui Yi, vice minister of war, and Li Heji, remonstrating advisor, were both impeached, dismissed, and demoted. When the Prince of Guangping took leave to reconquer Chang'an at the head of two hundred thousand men, he dismounted before the palace gate and did not remount until he had passed beyond the barrier. Guan Chongsi, chief commandant of the prince's household guard, rode out ahead of his lord. Zhenqing censured him for it. The emperor returned his memorial with a placating reply: "I instruct my son carefully whenever he leaves court. That is why he was so careful. Chongsi is old and slow-witted—for now, let it pass. From that day the whole court stood in awe of his integrity. After Chang'an and Luoyang were retaken, the emperor sent Li Xuan of the left secretariat to report to the ancestral shrine. The prayer was signed "Succession Emperor." Zhenqing asked the master of ceremonies, Cui Qi: "The former emperor is still in Shu—how can this be right? Qi immediately memorialized for a correction. The emperor praised his sound judgment. He also argued: "The Spring and Autumn Annals record that when Duke Cheng of Lu's new palace burned, he mourned for three days. The ancestral temple has been wrecked by the rebels. I propose that an altar be raised in the open, that His Majesty face east and weep for three days, and only then send envoys abroad. The court did not adopt the proposal. The chief ministers wearied of his admonitions and had him posted away as prefect of Fufeng. He was moved to Pu prefecture and ennobled as Viscount of Danyang. Censor Tang Min brought a trumped-up charge against him, and he was demoted to prefect of Raozhou.
26
西使 西
In 759 he was appointed military governor of Zhexi. When Liu Zhan was plotting rebellion, Zhenqing had already begun preparing defenses. Supreme commander Li Chan regarded this as inflammatory rather than as a personal failing on Zhenqing's part, but recalled him to the capital as vice minister of justice anyway. Liu Zhan did rebel and crossed the Huai River, and Li Chan fled into Jiangxi.
27
西 使
When Li Fuguo installed the retired emperor in the Western Palace, Zhenqing led the entire court to inquire after his health. Fuguo resented the gesture and had him demoted to chief administrator of Pengzhou. Upon Daizong's accession he was offered Lizhou prefecture but declined. He was soon transferred again to vice minister of the civil service. He was named governor of Jingnan but never took up the post; instead he was made vice director of the right secretariat.
28
使 紿
When the emperor returned from Shanzhou, Zhenqing urged that he visit the imperial tombs and shrines before entering the palace. Yuan Zai dismissed the suggestion as needlessly fussy. Zhenqing flared: "The throne decides who serves and who goes—what crime is there in offering counsel? But can the court survive your wrecking it a second time? Yuan Zai never forgave the rebuke. He was soon named acting minister of justice and pacification commissioner for the Shuofang campaign, but never left the capital. He was kept on to manage routine affairs and ennobled again as Duke of Lu. Zai was filling offices with his own men and feared open debate in court. He tricked the emperor: "Ministers who petition you often use their reports to spread slander. I propose that every petition pass first to a man's department head, then to the chief minister, who will judge its merits before anything reaches Your Majesty. Yan Zhenqing answered with a memorial:
29
使 使 使
The heads of the various departments are senior officials, each entitled to communicate directly with the emperor. Directors and censors are your eyes and ears in the field. They are dispatched across the empire to investigate every matter, great or small, and report back to you. This is the ancient ideal of extending sight and hearing in every direction. If Your Majesty now chooses to block your own eyes and ears and dull your understanding, what hope can the realm place in you? The Book of Songs says: "Buzzing blue flies, settling on the brambles; slander without end, sowing chaos among the four quarters of the realm. Because slander can turn white into black and black into white. The poet despised them, and wrote: "Seize those slanderers and throw them to wolves and tigers; if wolves and tigers refuse them, cast them to the northern wilds. In antiquity Bo Ming of Xia, Wuji of Chu, and Jiang Chong of Han were all notorious slanderers. Your Majesty is right to despise such men. Why not turn your mind to careful scrutiny instead? If a report proves false, its author is a slanderer and should be punished; if it proves true, its author is an upright man and should be rewarded. To abandon this course and give people reason to say that Your Majesty will no longer examine reports or heed counsel—that, I deeply regret, is exactly the pretext being offered.
30
使 使
Emperor Taizong once labored over every detail of government. His Gate Office regulations state: "Anyone without a gate pass who bears urgent business shall be escorted in for audience by the duty officers—no obstruction permitted. That was to guard against blocking access to the throne. He even kept two horses saddled at the gate for any official who needed to ride in on urgent business. That is how he kept the realm at peace. After the Tianbao era Li Linfu dominated the court. Officials who petitioned without consulting him first were destroyed on trumped-up charges—yet even he did not dare openly decree that every office must clear business with the chief minister first. The eunuch Yuan Siyi brought the emperor's orders to the Secretariat each day, so Linfu always knew the ruler's mind before anyone else and could frame his proposals accordingly. The emperor marveled at his prescience. Linfu's power swelled, and people feared even to meet one another's eyes in the street. The emperor's will no longer reached the realm, and the realm's grievances no longer reached the emperor. That is how a powerful minister blinds his sovereign—and it departs from Taizong's way of rule. The decay has continued to this day, and every affliction of the realm now falls upon Your Majesty. It did not happen all at once—it came by degrees. At the start of the rebellion the people were not yet ruined and good government could still have been restored. Instead Li Fuguo seized power, and chief ministers who followed him indulged one another in turn. They established the Three Offices to try collaborators and executed those deemed disloyal, driving scattered rebel commanders north toward the Tangut tribes. Brigands roamed unchecked, terror fed on terror, and Siming, fearing for his life, rose again. Luoyang fell, and the late emperor wore himself down with grief until his health broke. Whenever I reflect on this, grief pierces me to the bone.
31
退 便
The realm is still bleeding from its wounds and war grows daily. How can Your Majesty refuse to broaden your hearing with honest counsel—and instead cut off loyal remonstrance? When Your Majesty was at Shanzhou, anyone could petition regardless of rank, and the court believed Taizong's golden age was within reach. Moreover, upright men find it hard to speak up and easy to fall silent. Even when the court opens every avenue for frank speech, men still hesitate—how much more so when they sense indifference or hostility. If the chief minister alone decides what reaches you, and the Censorate writes rules barring direct access, from that day forward no one will petition at all. Your Majesty's knowledge of the realm will be confined to what a handful of men choose to tell you. Men of talent across the empire are already clamping shut their mouths. Your Majesty will conclude that nothing need be discussed—but they are silent from fear, not from contentment. This is how Linfu and Yang Guozhong rise again. I say that what is proposed today has no precedent in history. Even Linfu and Yang Guozhong never dared to do this openly. If Your Majesty does not see this now, you will gradually stand alone—and regret will come too late.
32
使
Eunuchs promptly spread word of the memorial throughout the palace and beyond. Later, while overseeing rites at the ancestral temple, he reported that the sacrificial vessels were ill kept. Zai treated this as slander and had him demoted to vice-prefect of Xiazhou. He was reassigned as military administrator of Jizhou, then promoted to prefect of Fu and Hu prefectures in succession. After Zai's execution Yang Wan recommended him. He was raised to minister of justice and then to minister of personnel. After the emperor's death, he was appointed Commissioner of Rites. He memorialized that the posthumous titles of successive emperors had grown excessive and asked that the original proposals stand. Yuan Cen blocked the request, and it was dropped without reply. After the civil wars, ritual law lay in ruins. Though Zhenqing was deeply learned and repeatedly proposed corrections, powerful ministers blocked him and most of his proposals never took effect.
33
使 使便
When Yang Yan dominated the government, his blunt integrity could not be tolerated. He was made Junior Tutor of the Heir Apparent but still headed the rites commission. Under Lu Qi he fared worse still. Qi made him Grand Tutor of the Heir Apparent, stripped him of the rites commission, and repeatedly asked which frontier post would suit him, clearly intending to exile him. Zhenqing went to see Qi and said, "When your father's head was brought to Pingyuan, the face was covered in blood. I would not wipe it with my robe but licked it clean with my own tongue. Can you truly refuse me a place? Qi started in alarm and bowed low, but from that day nursed a hatred to the bone.
34
退 使 使 使 祿
When Li Xilie captured Ru Prefecture, Qi proposed sending Zhenqing: "The realm trusts him. If he goes to reason with Xilie, we may settle this without an army. The edict approved the plan, and the high ministers turned pale. Li Mian saw it as losing a senior statesman and shaming the court. He secretly memorialized to keep Zhenqing back. At Henan, prefect Zheng Shuzhe, seeing Xilie's rebellion plainly, urged him not to proceed. Zhenqing answered, "Can one evade the ruler's command? When he met Xilie and announced the imperial edict, more than a thousand of Xilie's adopted sons drew swords and pressed forward. The generals cursed and reviled him and were ready to tear him apart. Zhenqing's face never changed. Xilie shielded him with his own body, waved the mob back, and lodged him in a guesthouse. They pressed him to memorialize the throne in Xilie's defense. Zhenqing refused. They sent Zhenqing's nephew Xian and several clerks in succession to plead for him. Emperor Dezong never answered. In letters to his sons he only urged them to tend the ancestral temple and care for the orphans. He wrote of nothing else. Xilie sent Li Yuanping to win him over. Zhenqing rebuked him: "The state entrusted you with office and you could not give your life for it. Because I have no troops to execute you, you dare come to persuade me? Xilie held a great assembly of his followers, summoned Zhenqing, and set entertainers to insult the court before him. Zhenqing said angrily, "You are a subject of the throne. How can you do this? He brushed his robe and walked out. Xilie was deeply shamed. Envoys of Zhu Tao, Wang Wujun, Tian Yue, and Li Na were present. They said to Xilie, "We have long heard of the Grand Preceptor's fame. You wish to proclaim an imperial title—yet when he arrives, who would you name chief minister ahead of him? Zhenqing rebuked them: "Have you heard of Yan of Changshan? My own elder brother. When Lushan rebelled, he was first to raise loyal troops. Though later captured, he never stopped cursing the rebels. I am nearly eighty and hold the rank of Grand Preceptor. I shall keep my integrity until death. Do you think I would bow to your threats?" The rebel envoys turned pale.
35
西 使
Xilie detained him under armed guard, dug a square pit in the courtyard, and spread word that he would bury him alive. Zhenqing told Xilie, "Life and death are already settled. Why all this trouble? When Zhang Boyi was defeated, Xilie had the imperial banners and severed heads brought to show him. Zhenqing wailed and threw himself to the ground. Some of his followers, Zhou Zeng and Kang Xiulin among them, plotted to strike Xilie and make Zhenqing their commander. The plot leaked. Zeng was killed, and Zhenqing was sent under guard to Cai Prefecture. Knowing he would die, he wrote his final memorial, tomb inscription, and funeral text, and pointing below the west wall of his chamber said, "This is where I shall lie in my coffin. When Xilie declared himself emperor and asked about court ritual, he answered, "I am an old man. I once managed the state's rites. I remember only how feudal lords attended the Son of Heaven!" End of his reply.
36
使 使
After Xingyuan the imperial armies rallied again. Fearful of a turn in events, the rebels sent generals Xin Jingzhen and An Hua to him, piled firewood in the courtyard, and said, "If you will not submit, you shall burn. Zhenqing rose and walked toward the flames. Jingzhen and the others hastily stopped him. Xilie's brother Xiqian was executed for ties to Zhu Ci. Xilie flew into a rage and sent eunuch attendants to kill Zhenqing, announcing, "There is an edict. Zhenqing performed the full obeisance. The attendant said, "You are granted death. He said, "This old minister deserves death. But when did an envoy come from Chang'an?" The attendant said, "From Daliang." He cursed, "You are a rebel traitor. What edict?" They strangled him. He was seventy-six. Prince Li Gao of Cao wept when he heard the news, and the whole army mourned. He memorialized Zhenqing's supreme loyalty. When Huai and Cai were pacified, his sons Yun and Shuo escorted the coffin home. The emperor suspended court for five days, posthumously appointed him Minister of Works with the title Cultured and Loyal, and granted enhanced funeral gifts.
37
祿
At court Zhenqing stood with stern dignity, firm yet courteous. Nothing that was not public truth and the straight Way ever stirred in his heart. The realm did not speak his personal name but called him only the Duke of Lu. Li Zhengji, Tian Shenggong, Dong Qin, Hou Xiyi, Wang Xuanzhi, and others were all first recruited by Zhenqing and later won distinction. He excelled in regular and cursive script, with a brush at once forceful and graceful. The world treasures his writing and passes it down. In Zhenyuan year 6 (790), an amnesty edict granted his son Yun a regular fifth-rank appointment. Early in the Kaicheng era, his great-grandson Hongshi was appointed military adjutant of Tong Prefecture. Commentary: Liu Zongyuan of Tang wrote, "When people speak of Grand Warden Duan, they usually take him for a soldier who once rushed heedless of death to win fame. That is wrong. The Grand Warden was gentle and unassuming, often walking with bowed head and clasped hands, speaking in a quiet, humble voice. He never met anyone with a harsh look; to all appearances he was a scholar. Yet when he met what could not be tolerated, he always achieved his purpose. That was no accident. Zongyuan did not praise people lightly. We may trust that he was right. Did not Confucius say that the humane man must have courage? When Lushan rebelled and swept all before him, the Duke of Lu alone met his armies with a hastily gathered force. Though he did not win lasting victory, his resolve deserves lasting praise. In his later years he was obstructed and driven out by treacherous ministers, and died at traitors' hands. His resolute spirit was broken but never bent. That may truly be called loyalty. Look closely at these two men's careers: their rulers never fully trusted them in ordinary times. Yet when the supreme test came, they met it without hesitation. Why? Loyal ministers do not wait to be trusted by others. They set their own conduct right first, find peace within, and then act. Alas! Though fifteen hundred years have passed, their heroic brightness still speaks as clearly as severe frost and blazing sun—awesome and worthy of reverence!
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →