← Back to 新五代史

卷十六 唐廢帝家人傳第四:

Volume 16: Family of the Tang Deposed Emperor

Chapter 16 of 新五代史 · New History of the Five Dynasties
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 16
Next Chapter →
1
Empress Liu, wife of the deposed Later Tang emperor.
2
The deposed emperor's two sons.
3
His sons bore the names Chongji and Chongmei; a daughter took vows as a nun under the sobriquet Youcheng. History does not record who bore any of them.
4
Alas! The norms that govern household and kin must be upheld. Ritual exists precisely to dispel doubt and bring fine distinctions to light. How far things had fallen! In the Five Dynasties the reciprocal duties of ruler and ruled, father and child, collapsed together; temple and palace alike were scenes where neither men nor shades kept their station—truly an era of disorder! Nothing like it appears in the earlier record. The house called Tang ruled under a single dynastic name yet passed through three clans; the house called Zhou did the same with two. Later Tang thus falls into three bloodlines: Taizu and Zhuangzong; Mingzong and the short-reigned Min emperor; and the deposed emperor alone. Later Zhou likewise splits in two: the line of Taizu and that of Shizong. Why, then, does the chronicle cleave the clans yet leave the dynastic label unchanged? For Later Tang the shared name exposes naked usurpation: each claimant seized the throne from the last. For Later Zhou the single title marks legitimate succession: the mandate was handed down within the alliance that founded the state. The separate "families" preserve the temple order of fathers and sons, near kin and far—lines that must not be blurred. Dynastic names may repeat; agnatic lines may not. That, again, is the work of ritual: clearing doubt and marking fine shades. Why, then, does the Later Liang record leave Bo Prince You Wen outside the neat partition of "families" that I have just defended? Because the historian means to expose the taproot: the founder of Later Liang brought ruin on himself starting with You Wen, and the deliberate ambiguity in the record is itself the lesson for posterity.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →