← Back to 元史

卷一百八十二 列傳第六十九: 張起巖 歐陽玄 許有壬 宋本 謝端

Volume 182 Biographies 69: Zhang Qiyan, Ōuyang Xuan, Xu Youren, Song Ben, Xie Duan

Chapter 182 of 元史 · History of Yuan
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 182
Next Chapter →
1
Zhang Qiyan
2
Zhang Qiyan, whose style was Mengchen. His family came from Zhangqiu; during the Five Dynasties they fled the turmoil and settled in Yucheng. His great-grandfather Di served as deputy military superintendent on the commandery army's right wing, acted as temporary administrator of Jinan prefecture, and moved the family there. Late in the Jin dynasty Zhang Rong controlled Zhangqiu, Zouping, Jiyang, Changshan, Xinshi, Putai, Xincheng, and Zizhou. In the bingxu year he submitted to Taizu and remained loyal to the end; Di and his son Fu were among those who had supported him from the beginning. Fu held the posts of Jinan circuit military and civil pacification commissioner and troop controller, with acting charge of prefectural affairs. His son Duo became recorder-administrator of Dongchang; Duo's son Fan became associate director of the Sichuan branch secretariat Confucian school; Fan was Qiyan's father. While his mother Lady Qiu was pregnant, she saw a serpent many zhang long slip under the couch and then vanish. Startled by the omen, she gave birth to Qiyan.
3
使
As a boy he studied with his father. In his early twenties he was nominated and appointed instructor at the Fushan county school. When the magistrate left to conduct locust control, Qiyan was left to act as county administrator. Before long his decisions proved clear and fair, and the people said as one: "If Instructor Zhang were our real magistrate, what would we have to fear?" When his term succeeded, he was transferred to Anqiu. In the yimao year of Yanyou he took the jinshi degree as first in his class. He was appointed associate administrator of Dengzhou, then by special edict made a compiler in the Hall of Gathered Talents, became an erudite of the National University, rose to vice director of the directorate of education, and was promoted to Hanlin attendant-drafter with a concurrent post as national history compiler. After his mother's death he observed mourning, and when the mourning ended he was appointed investigating censor. Associate administrator of the central secretariat Yang Tingyu fell to a corruption case. By imperial order the censors arrested him in the council hall and turned him over to the judicial authorities. Chancellor Daula Shah resented the humiliation of his colleagues and accused the entire censorate of deceiving the throne, seeking to have them punished with the heaviest penalties. Qiyan had just been appointed and was still at the censorate. He submitted a forceful memorial arguing: "Censors investigate officials and debate court policy because that is their duty. To punish them for doing their jobs will break down discipline, silence the upright, and chill the hearts of the loyal. That is no way to run a flourishing age. Moreover Emperor Shizu established the censorate and opened the channels of remonstrance to sustain good government, and Your Majesty's accession edicts repeatedly invoke the example of the founding ancestors. Now the censors are being punished and public opinion is shut out—how is that following the ancestors!" He submitted the memorial three times and received no answer. Qiyan pressed his case in court with growing urgency until the emperor was moved. The crisis was averted, but the censors were still dismissed and sent home. He was made outer gentleman of the central secretariat's right department, then director of the left department, with a concurrent post as classics mat lecturer, and was appointed right assistant to the heir apparent. After his father's death he observed mourning, and when it ended he became chief commandant of the Prince of Yan's household and was appointed minister of rites.
4
使 使 西使 西 使 祿
When Emperor Wenzong performed the suburban sacrifice in person, Qiyan served as grand master of rites and guided the emperor's ascent and descent. His pace was measured, his robes hung evenly fore and aft, and the officials in attendance thought they were looking at a figure from an ancient painting. The emperor was greatly pleased and rewarded him generously. He was transferred to councilor of central secretariat affairs. After Emperor Ningzong died, a major case soon erupted in the Yan region. A reckless man filed a report accusing a circuit envoy of sedition, but investigation proved the charge false. The judicial office cited the 《Tang Code》: "One who reports rebellion is not punished in turn." Qiyan spoke forcefully to his colleagues: "The heir is not yet enthroned and the people are uneasy. Unless we execute this man at once to cut off conspiracy, I fear the great undertaking will be harmed." He pressed the authorities to conclude the case. The capital grew calm, and the crisis was soon resolved. During a central secretariat session on appointments, Qiyan recommended a capable scholar. The chancellor took offense, and Qiyan immediately gathered his robes and left. The chancellor regarded it as a personal affront. He was made Hanlin academician lecturer, drafter of proclamations, and concurrent national history compiler, edited the veritable records of three reigns, and was given additional charge of the classics mat. The censorate recommended him as surveillance commissioner of Western Zhe, but the appointment was denied. Soon afterward he was promoted to attending censor on the Shaanxi branch secretariat. Just as he was about to leave, he was kept on as academician lecturer. He was appointed attending censor on the Jiangnan branch secretariat, then summoned to the central censorate as attending censor. He was transferred to surveillance commissioner of Yan South. He prosecuted the powerful without leniency, and the poor at last had room to breathe. Flooding on the Hutuo River was harming Zhending. Qiyan argued that ennobling the river god as a marquis was misguided, sent an official rebuke, repaired the dikes, and dredged the choked channels until the floods subsided. He rose to vice censor-in-chief on the Jiangnan branch secretariat and was appointed Hanlin expositor-in-chief, drafter of proclamations, concurrent national history compiler, and director of the classics mat. Right Chancellor Bayinduq Baras Buqa was impeached by the censors and removed from office. Before long he returned as chancellor and urged the drafting officials to declare the censorial memorial mistaken. Qiyan refused, and those who heard of it took heart. Soon he was appointed vice censor-in-chief. His remonstrances were sharp and direct, without fear, and he often clashed with his superiors. When an edict ordered the compilation of the Liao, Jin, and Song histories, he was again appointed Hanlin expositor-in-chief and chief compiler, eventually rising to grand master for glorious happiness. Qiyan was deeply versed in Jin-dynasty precedents and the origins of Song Neo-Confucian learning. Whenever a history officer paraded his talent and wrote something unsound, Qiyan revised it on principle. His prose was weighty, refined, and lucid in argument. When the histories were finished he was sixty-five. He submitted a memorial asking to retire, and died four years later. He was given the posthumous title Wenmu.
5
Qiyan had a face like purple jade, a fine beard, and a square jaw, with clear, spirited brows and eyes. At a glance one could see he was a man of generous character. In office, once his mind was set against something, he stood firm as Mount Tai and could not be swayed. At times he would rebuke someone to his face until his own face and neck flushed with anger, never sparing him, and the court was wary of him. Those who knew him said he was gentle outwardly and firm within, could not be manipulated, and resembled Ouyang Xiu; his reputation reached the four quarters. When Annam sent tribute, its attendant ministers always inquired after Qiyan's health before delivering their crown prince's message. He was filial and devoted to his kin. In youth he lived in poverty, teaching behind closed curtains while personally carrying rice from a hundred li away to support his parents; he raised his younger brother Rushi and guided his education for official service with complete care. He arranged burial for more than twenty kinsmen who could not afford it and bought fields to support their sacrificial rites. Whenever he received salary or imperial gifts, he shared them with old friends and guests. When he died his granary held no surplus grain and his household no surplus wealth.
6
稿稿
Earlier, on the yihai day of the third month of the yiyou year of Zhiyuan, the court astronomer reported that the Wenchang star was bright and a literary age was about to dawn. Shizu was then traveling to the Upper Capital. The next day, on bingzi, the imperial grandson was born at Ruzhou. That same night Qiyan was born. Later that grandson came to the throne as Emperor Renzong and first restored the civil service examinations. At the palace examination Qiyan took first place, which commentators took as no accident. Qiyan was broadly learned and a fine writer, skilled in seal and clerical script. His 《Huafeng Casual Drafts》, 《Huafeng Classified Drafts》, and 《Jinling Collection》, each in several juan, were kept at home. He had two sons: Lin and Chen.
7
○ Ouyang Xuan
8
使
Ouyang Xuan, whose style was Yuangong, came from a Luling family of the same lineage as Ouyang Xiu, the Cultivated and Loyal Lord. His great-great-grandfather Xin was the first to move the family to Liuyang, so Xuan was counted as a native of Liuyang. As a child he was exceptionally bright. His mother Lady Li taught him the 《Classic of Filial Piety》, the 《Analects》, the Elementary Learning, and other texts herself. At eight he could recite them from memory. He then studied under the local teacher Zhang Guan, memorizing several thousand characters a day and learning to write prose almost at once. At ten a Daoist priest fixed his gaze on Xuan and told Guan: "This boy's spirit is concentrated and far-seeing, his eyes pierce like light. One day he will lead the world in letters—he is fit for high office." When he had spoken he left. They hurried after him to talk, but he had vanished. When a circuit envoy visited the county, Xuan was presented as a student and told to compose poems on plum blossom. He finished ten on the spot and, returning that evening, expanded them to a hundred. All who saw it were astonished. At fourteen he studied literary composition further with old Song scholars. Whatever he wrote came out as finished work, and in every school examination he took the top rank. In his early twenties he studied behind closed curtains for several years without showing his face in public. He studied the classics, histories, and the hundred schools without exception and was especially thorough in the origins of the Yi-Luo Neo-Confucians.
9
調 便 便
He was summoned as an erudite of the National University and promoted to vice director of the directorate of education. In the first year of Zhihe he was made Hanlin attendant-drafter with a concurrent post as national history compiler. War was then breaking out. Xuan took charge of the history office, attended court daily, and helped decide state affairs, drafting all edicts, proclamations, and dispatches for deployments near and far. When the reign title was changed to Tianli, he drafted the texts for suburban sacrifice, temple rites, the installation of the empress, the designation of the heir, and the general amnesty. He also submitted a sealed memorial listing several dozen policy recommendations, many of which were adopted. The next year the Kui Zhang Pavilion academician institute was established, with the Bureau of Literary Arts placed under it, both staffed by officials of high reputation. Emperor Wenzong personally appointed Xuan junior director of literary arts. By imperial order he helped compile the 《Comprehensive Statutes for Governing the Age》, was promoted to senior director, and was made commissioner for inspecting books. In the first year of Yuantong he became associate administrator of the court of imperial sacrifices and Hanlin academician direct, edited the veritable records of four reigns, and soon added the chancellorship of the National University. Summoned to the central capital for deliberation, he was promoted to academician lecturer while retaining the university chancellorship. In the fifth year of the renewed Zhizhi era his legs were afflicted with paralysis. He asked to return south for medical care, but the emperor refused. He was appointed Hanlin academician. Before long he earnestly asked to resign, but the emperor again refused, though he was excused from court congratulation ceremonies. When the Zhizheng era began and the court reorganized government, Xuan spoke frankly in palace deliberations on every difficult issue. The restoration of the civil service examinations met especially strong opposition, and Xuan argued for it with particular force. Soon he returned south. He was again appointed Hanlin academician but did not take up the post because of illness.
10
稿 使西 祿 輿
When an edict ordered the Liao, Jin, and Song histories, he was summoned as chief compiler, laid down principles and examples, and gave the writers a firm basis for their work. Some history officers were resentful show-offs whose judgments were unfair. Xuan did not argue with them in words but waited until they submitted drafts, then revised them himself until the narrative was sound. The discussions, encomia, tables, and memorials were all written by Xuan. In the fifth year the emperor, noting that Xuan had served through several reigns and had helped compile the three histories, instructed the chancellor to promote him beyond the usual ranks. He was proposed for Hanlin expositor-in-chief. When the appointment was reported to the throne, the emperor expressed his pleasure again and again. Soon he asked to retire, but the emperor again refused. The censorate recommended him as surveillance commissioner of Fujian. On the road, when he reached Western Zhe, his illness returned. He submitted a request to retire, built the Southern Mountain Hermitage, and lived at ease among the hills and streams, intending to end his days there. He was again appointed Hanlin expositor-in-chief, but Xuan repeatedly declined and could not obtain permission. By imperial order he helped fix the national code. Soon he asked to retire with an earnest memorial and was specially granted retirement as right chancellor of the Huguang branch secretariat, given a white-jade girdle, and provided salary and gifts for life. Just as he was about to leave, the emperor again refused and kept him as Hanlin expositor-in-chief, promoting him to grand master of splendid happiness. In the fourteenth year bandits rose in the Ru and Ying region and spread north and south until few prefectures and counties still had intact walls. Xuan submitted a plan of more than a thousand words for recruiting loyal forces and suppressing the rebels. It was thoroughly workable, but was not adopted at the time. In the spring of the seventeenth year he asked to retire. With the roads of the central plain blocked, he wished to return home through Shu, but the emperor again refused. A great amnesty was about to be proclaimed, and he was summoned to the inner palace. Xuan had been ill for a long time and could not walk. The chancellor relayed the emperor's order that he be carried in a sedan chair to the Yanchun Pavilion—an extraordinary honor. That year, on the wuxu day of the twelfth month, he died at his lodging in Chongjiao Lane at the age of eighty-five. The central secretariat reported his death. The emperor gave lavish funeral gifts and posthumously honored him as meritorious minister of honoring benevolence, illuminating virtue, promoting loyalty, and upholding rectitude, grand preceptor, and pillar of the state, enfeoffed him as Duke of Chu, and gave him the posthumous title Wen.
11
By nature Xuan was dignified and unhurried, broad-minded yet finely exact, frugal in his private life, and upright and even-handed in government. In more than forty years of service, he spent roughly three quarters of his career at court. He served three times at the Imperial University, twice as its rector, entered the Hanlin Academy six times, and three times was appointed expositor-in-chief. His work on the Veritable Records, the 《Grand Compendium》, and the Three Histories were all major state projects. He repeatedly oversaw the civil examinations and twice served as chief examiner and paper reader. Most of the court's grand ceremonial writings for the ancestral temple and state, and the edicts and proclamations sent throughout the realm, came from Xuan's pen. Nearly every year brought him gifts of gold, silk, and ceremonial wine cups from the throne. Across the empire, whether on famous mountains and rivers, in Buddhist and Daoist shrines, or on the tomb steles of princes and great nobles, to obtain a composition from Xuan was counted an honor. Even a stray line of his writing, passing among ordinary readers, was prized as something rare. In both literary accomplishment and moral stature he stood out as a figure of his age. He adorned the civil tradition and helped uphold the institutions of good government, and in this he earned lasting credit. Xuan had no son and adopted his nephew Daolao as heir, but Daolao died before him. His 《Guizhai Collected Works》, in several volumes, has been handed down to later generations.
12
○ Xu Youren
13
滿 使 西使
Xu Youren, styled Keyong, came from a family that originally lived in Ying and later moved to Tangyin. Youren was bright from childhood and could read five lines at a glance. Once he looked through the nearly thousand-word 《Jingju Monastery Stele》 from Hengzhou and recited it from memory in full after a single reading. At twenty, Chang Shiwen recommended him for the Hanlin Academy, but nothing came of it. He was appointed Confucian instructor for Kaining Circuit and promoted to professor, but before reporting he was recruited as a clerk in the Shanbei surveillance commission. In Yanyou 2 he passed the jinshi examination and was appointed associate intendant of Liaozhou. When trouble broke out in Guanzhong, neighboring prefectures let their people flee, and abandoned children lined the roads. Youren alone led his archers, shut the gates, and held the city until the danger passed without harm. For arrests in the prefecture he forbade runners from entering villages. He issued official tokens instead and had men on corvée duty summon those wanted. The people were left in peace and business still got done. He punished greedy and cruel men among the great families. Even settled cases of injustice he overturned and released the prisoners, and the prefecture came under firm and fair rule. In the sixth year, jiwei, he was appointed administrator of the Shanbei surveillance commission. In Zhizhi 1 he was transferred to chief clerk in the Ministry of Personnel. The next year he became investigating censor on the Jiangnan branch secretariat, toured Guangdong, and impeached Deputy Surveillance Commissioner Haqai Chaiyan for corruption, bringing about his dismissal. In Jiangxi he came upon Surveillance Commissioner Miao Haoqian supervising the destruction of worn banknotes. More than a hundred examiners worked each day. Fearing fraud, Haoqian had them whipped savagely. Terrified of punishment, they scraped genuine notes to look like counterfeits in order to please him. From the treasury clerks down, those flogged were left without a patch of whole skin, and in the end none could make good the supposed losses. Youren reviewed the notes himself, found them genuine, and had the men released. Powerful officials and predatory magnates whom people feared like wolves, Youren seized and punished to the full extent of the law, and his jurisdiction became orderly. He was summoned and appointed censor.
14
使
In the eighth month of the third year Emperor Yingzong died suddenly at Nanpo. The traitor Tie Shi sent envoys from Shangdu to seal the treasuries and seize the official seals. Sensing the urgency, Youren went at once to warn Censor-in-Chief Dong Shouyong, who replied that palace affairs were none of his business. Youren immediately memorialized against Shouyong, Administrator Duo'erzhiban, and Investigating Censor Guo Yesian Hudu for siding with Tie Shi, reserving their crimes for later judgment. In the tenth month Tie Shi was put to death. As Emperor Taiding left Shangdu, Grand Censor Niuze returned first to the capital, and Youren submitted a memorial from his sleeve at once. When the emperor arrived, he submitted another memorial: "Suonan, Temuder's son, took part in the great treason. I beg that he be executed according to law. His brothers should not be allowed to enter or leave the palace precincts. Grand Councillor Wang Yi and Right Vice Chancellor Gao Fang of the central secretariat were unjustly stripped of rank, and Grand Councillor Zhao Shiyan of the Sichuan branch secretariat suffered even more harshly. I ask that their names be cleared and their offices restored." He then submitted the Ten Items for a Correct Beginning: First, in supporting the crown prince, education should come first; Second, in choosing chief officials, training should come first; Third, in granting access to the palace precincts, high and low rank should be kept apart; Fourth, to tighten military authority, concurrent commands should be cut back; Fifth, with military readiness in decay, it should be restored and strengthened; Sixth, the wives and concubines of rebel ministers should be protected from seizure by powerful officials; Seventh, the earlier amnesty was a stopgap to end the crisis; a new edict should restore proper names and ranks; Eighth, the sons of Temuder should have their property confiscated as punishment for their crimes; Ninth, audit state expenditures to lighten the people's tax burdens; Tenth, cut wasteful spending to ease the strain on state finances. The emperor largely accepted his recommendations.
15
使 使 退
In Taiding 1, when the Household of the Heir Apparent was first established, he was chosen as a middle discussion officer and made left section vice director of the central secretariat. Famine struck the capital region, and Youren asked that grain be issued for relief. His colleagues objected: "What you say is well enough, but how can we afford to drain the treasury! Youren replied: "Not at all. The people are the foundation. If the people are not harmed, how can the state be harmed!" In the end he persuaded the chancellor to release four hundred thousand hu of grain for relief, and a great many people survived because of it. Under the old National University system, students were recommended for office in order of accumulated points. The chief ministers, following Supervisor Zhang Qiyan's proposal, wanted to abolish that system and select men on moral conduct alone. Youren objected: "The point system is not perfect, but it still yields broadly learned and literate men. Choosing on moral conduct alone sounds admirable, but one may end up with hypocrites skilled only in outward display, or dullards who cannot even read." The debate dragged on without resolution. In the sixth month of the third year he was promoted to right section director. The new policy was briefly adopted, then abandoned again. There were standing rewards for capturing bandits, but many suspected fraud, and some claims had waited more than forty years. A crowd appealed to him on the road. Youren said: "Banditry is raging. If we pick every claim apart, how can we get men to act when we need them! So long as the branch secretariat envoy has reviewed a case, grant the reward." Soon he was made left section director. In every public deliberation he argued forcefully over policy, cleared away long-standing backlogs, and left almost no papers pending. Director Song Ben withdrew and told others: "This is deliberation worthy of the Zhenguan and Kaiyuan eras." The next year he went into mourning for his father.
16
使 宿
In Tianli 3 he was appointed commissioner of the Two Huai regional salt transport commission. The salt laws had broken down, and the court felt that no one but Youren could set them right, which is why he received the appointment. Youren traced the abuses to their roots, drew up new regulations with room for practical adjustment, and state revenue rose. In the second month of Zhishun 2 he was summoned as participating secretary of the central secretariat, but soon left to mourn his mother. In Yuantong 1 he was again summoned as participating secretary. The next year, jiaxu, he was appointed secretary censor and made academician secretary of the Kui Zhang Pavilion Academy while still running censorate affairs. Qarachu darughachi Wanbu, relying on the chancellor's backing, served in the Eastern Palace guard. His conduct was grossly licentious. When censors impeached him, he hid in the censor-in-chief's house. Youren seized him and had him removed. In the ninth month he was appointed vice chancellor of the central secretariat and lecturer at the classics colloquium. The emperor ordered the ministers to discuss granting the empress dowager the title Grand Empress Dowager. Youren said: "The emperor and the empress dowager are mother and son. If she becomes Grand Empress Dowager, he becomes her grandson in title, which violates proper ritual." The assembly would not listen. Youren said: "Under current law, honors granted to grandparents rank one grade below those granted to parents. Favor is meant to weigh most heavily on those nearest. Making the empress dowager a grand empress dowager pushes the honor outward and actually makes it lighter. Is that what honoring her means!" They still would not listen. Grand Councillor Cherig Temur, nursing a private grudge, memorialized to abolish the jinshi examination. Youren fought the proposal fiercely at court but could not prevail, then claimed illness and stayed home. The emperor forced him back to office and appointed him attending censor. When Bang Hu rebelled at Runing, ministers hostile to Han officials spread rebel flags and forged edicts on the floor and asked: "What do you make of these?" They hoped Han officials would shrink from calling it rebellion so they could be blamed for it. Youren said: "They proclaimed a reign title, called themselves crown prince of Old Master Li, deployed troops, and fought the official army. The rebellion is plain enough. What more is there to say!" That silenced them. The court proposed reviving ancient mutilation punishments, establishing a mobile pacification commission, and forbidding Han Chinese and Southerners to study Mongol and Uyghur script. Youren fought each proposal and blocked them.
17
西
At the start of the renewed Zhizhi era, Han Gongpu of Changlu triggered a major case over weapons found in his home. It swept through the censorate and secretariat, and many officials fell on corruption charges, but Youren's name was never implicated, which only sharpened the resentment against him. Seeing that he could not remain, Youren returned to Zhangde and later traveled south through the Xiang and Han regions. In Zhizheng 6 he was recalled to the central secretariat as vice chancellor. The next year the era name was changed to Zhizheng. Youren argued forcefully that the emperor should sacrifice at the ancestral temple in person, that the empress dowager's seat should not be left vacant, that the Huizheng Office should be abolished, that the change of era and appointment of chancellors should be issued in one supreme edict, that redundant offices should be cut, and that spending on money and grain should be reduced—proposals of this kind, and more besides. Everyone approved of his proposals. He was transferred to left vice chancellor of the central secretariat. In the second year Nanggiyasun Baqu and Bolad Temur proposed opening Jinkou in the Western Hills and diverting the Hun River through the capital to Tongzhou to revive canal transport. Chancellor Toqto'a pushed the plan hard. Youren said: "The Hun River runs swift and fierce, breaks its banks easily, and can do great harm. It silts up quickly, blocks easily, and cannot carry boats; moreover the terrain rises and falls too sharply. It would only waste labor and money." They would not listen, and events later proved him right.
18
歿 西使
Earlier, while Youren's father Xizai was serving at Changsha, he founded a charity school to instruct students. After his death the students missed him and founded the Donggang Academy in his memory. The court granted a plaque, appointed officials, and made it a place to train talent. Mubarak Shah, investigating censor on the southern branch secretariat, nursed a petty grudge and argued that the academy should never have been founded. He fabricated slander against Youren and his younger brothers Youyi and Youfu. Youren then claimed illness and went home. In the fourth year he was appointed left vice chancellor of the Jiang-Zhe branch secretariat and declined. In the sixth year he was summoned as Hanlin academician, reported for duty, and declined again. Investigating censors repeatedly memorialized to clear the slander against him. Soon he was appointed surveillance commissioner of Western Zhe, but before reporting he was again summoned as Hanlin expositor-in-chief and still directed the classics colloquium. The next summer he was appointed vice censor-in-chief and given a white-jade girdle and a suit of imperial robes. Before long he again went home, claiming illness. Investigating Censor Dalan Buqa resented Youren and often spoke of his faults. He impeached him vigorously, but the charges were soon cleared.
19
使 祿
In the twelfth year bandits rose in Henan, their threat shaking the lands between the Yellow River and the northern frontier. Youren drafted fifteen measures for defense and preparedness and gave them to the local commanders, and the people were kept safe. In the thirteenth year he was recalled and appointed left vice chancellor of the Henan branch secretariat. The court sent generals on campaign. Around the Henan frontier, camps linked in the hundreds, and all fodder and provisions depended on supplies from Youren's province. He calmly kept affairs in order as if it were peacetime. In the fifteenth year he was made grand academician of the Hall of Gathered Worthies, soon transferred to vice director of the Military Affairs Commission, and again appointed left vice chancellor of the Secretariat. Speech was dangerous at the time, yet Youren spoke bluntly: the court pursued indulgence, rewarding heavily and punishing lightly, so soldiers plundered women, children, jade, and silk without any will to fight. He then urged a policy of accepting surrenders, though much of what he said went unrecorded. A monk named Kai came from Gaoyou claiming that Zhang Shicheng wished to surrender. Everyone hoped the war might end and rejoiced, but Youren alone doubted the story. He summoned the monk and questioned him; the man was speechless and could not answer. He was transferred to grand academician of the Hall of Gathered Worthies and concurrently left mentor to the heir apparent, rising to grand master of splendid happiness. Youren was a veteran minister of the previous reign, and the heir apparent treated him with great respect. One day when Youren came for an audience, the heir was amusing himself with a fierce hawk on his arm and hurriedly ordered his attendants to take it away. In the seventeenth year, citing old age and illness, he repeatedly begged to retire. Only after a long delay was he permitted to withdraw, with salary and gifts granted for the rest of his life. On the twenty-first day of the ninth month of the twenty-fourth year he died, at the age of seventy-eight.
20
便
Youren served seven reigns for nearly fifty years. Whenever the state faced a great crisis, he spoke without reserve, always grounding his words in principle and weighing them against human feeling. When powerful ministers ran rampant, the slightest offense could bring execution or banishment. Youren never tried to evade them by clever means. When policy went wrong, he argued clearly and remonstrated forcefully, heedless of life, death, gain, or harm. Men of integrity praised him for it. Youren was skilled in calligraphy and letters and excelled at literary composition. Ouyang Xuan prefaced his writings, calling them grand and lofty, surging like layered waves; pressed further, they proved deep, clear, and solid. He clearly thought very highly of him. His writings include the 《Collected Works of the Zhizheng Era》 in several fascicles. His posthumous title was Cultured and Loyal. He had one son, named Zhen.
21
○ Song Ben
22
使 宿
Song Ben, styled Chengfu, was a native of Dadu. From childhood he was unusually bright among his peers. Once he came of age, he gathered the classics and histories and read them day and night, probing every phrase and searching every character until he had mastered them completely. He once followed his father Zhen to an appointment at Jiangling. Wang Kuiwen of Jiangling was versed in the learning of human nature and moral principle. Ben went to him to test what he had learned, and his understanding grew deeper day by day. He was skilled at ancient-style prose. His language was always his own—severe, pure, and incisive, often laden with subtle meaning. At forty he returned to Yan for the first time. In the first year of the Zhizhi reign, the court examined scholars throughout the realm. Ben ranked first, received jinshi with honors, and was appointed Hanlin compiler. In spring of the first year of the Taiding reign he was appointed investigating censor. First he said: "The rebel Tieshi and others, though executed, their clique—the vice director of military affairs Asan—personally took part in regicide, yet by reporting the plot escaped death and was banished to Lingnan. I beg that heavenly punishment be promptly carried out." By national institution, spirit tablets for the ancestral temple were cast in pure gold, yet the tablet from Renzong's chamber was actually stolen. Ben said: "By law, when common people lose goods to theft, failure to capture the thief within the deadline still incurs punishment. The Court of Imperial Sacrifices failed in custodial duty, and the Beijing arrest officers all ought to be dismissed." Furthermore he said: "The chancellors of the Secretariat daily rush to the inner palace, clinging to favor and settling for safety. For ten days or more they do not come to the main hall, obstructing urgent business. I beg that officials be warned: except on days of palace guard duty, they must go to their offices to conduct affairs." None of these received response.
23
調 宿 使宿 使
After a month he was transferred to vice director of the Directorate of Education. In summer fierce winds and an earthquake struck. An edict ordered officials gathered to discuss various means of quelling the disaster. At the time palace guards who had come from the north were being sent home again. They banded together in groups of a hundred or ten and robbed and killed people on the road to Huanzhou. After they were arrested, Xumiejie memorialized to have them released. A Mongol chiliarch was sent to the capital and lodged at an inn. Just then the wife and daughter of a man surnamed Zhu passed the inn gate in a carriage. The chiliarch took a liking to them, and together with his followers seized them and carried them inside. Zhu wept and appealed to the Secretariat, but Xumiejie shielded the offenders and would not inquire. Ben happened to be present at the deliberation and again spoke out forcefully: "Tieshi's remaining clique has not been executed, the thief of Renzong's spirit tablet has not been captured, the Huanzhou bandits have not been punished, Zhu's grievance has not been redressed, criminal administration has lost its measure, the people are angry and Heaven is resentful—the appearance of portents and disasters arises from this." His words were fierce and impassioned, and all present listened in awe. In winter he was transferred to vice director of the Ministry of War. In the second year he was transferred to director of the left department of the Secretariat. At a conference on pacifying the stream-cave people, the son of the former general Li Laoshan had once borrowed the title minister of war and followed a prince in leading troops against the Yao people of Yulin Prefecture. Li took a concubine on the march, halted and would not advance, and returned after defeat. Vice director of military affairs Wang Buling said at the Secretariat: "Li pacified the Yao with merit and ought to be promoted." Ben said; "Li abandoned the army to take a concubine and delayed the campaign schedule. He ought swiftly to be punished by law—how much less ought he be given office!" Wang's color fell, and he no longer dared speak.
24
西西 稿
When Xumiejie died, left chancellor Daula Shah held state power and won the emperor's trust, together with central chancellor Ubaidullah—both were men of the Western Regions. A wealthy merchant of the Western Regions brought as tribute a strange stone from his country called Lan, valued at tens of thousands, yet its price was sometimes unpaid; some who had once been at fault and were stripped of office by the censorate, or some who had come from their households. In winter of the third year Ubaidullah came out from the inner palace to the Hall of Administration, gathered the chancellors and their staff, and ordered left department vice director Hu Yi to show Ben the draft edict. It was to pardon the realm on account of a comet and earthquake, still order the Secretariat to pay the prices of objects presented by successive reigns, and promote those stripped of office by the censorate from Emperor Yingzong's reign to the present. When Ben had finished reading, he reported: "Now we warn of portents and disasters, yet we fear the anger and resentment of those whose tribute objects have not been paid for. These are petty matters for the offices. To put them in an imperial edict will surely make the realm laugh. The censorate stripped office from the guilty according to the established statutes of Emperor Shizu. Since the present emperor ascended the throne, repeated edicts have ordered that law follow Shizu. Now to promote and employ them is to abolish the established statutes and go back on earlier edicts. Later, when wicked and corrupt men appear again, will you punish them? Or leave them unpunished?" When the chancellors heard Ben's words, they looked at one another, sighed, and withdrew. The next day, after the edict was fully promulgated, Ben then claimed illness and did not appear.
25
使 殿 西
In spring of the fourth year he was transferred to director of the Ministry of Rites. In winter of the first year of the Tianli reign he was promoted to vice minister of personnel. In the second year he was changed to vice minister of rites. That year Emperor Wenzong opened the Kuizhang Pavilion, established the Directorate of Literary Arts to inspect books, and Ben was promoted above director. In the first year of the Zhishun reign he was promoted to academician attendant of the Kuizhang Pavilion Academy. In winter of the second year he was sent out as vice surveillance commissioner of Hedong. Just as he was about to depart, he was promoted to minister of rites. In winter of the third year Emperor Ningzong died and Emperor Shundi had not yet arrived. The empress dowager was at Xingsheng Palace. At New Year's Day, following precedent, they deliberated on performing the court congratulation rites. Ben said: "It is fitting to submit a memorial at Xingsheng Palace and abolish the court congratulation at the Daming Hall." The assembly agreed and followed him. In the first year of the Yuantong reign he concurrently served as classics colloquium official. In winter he was appointed investigating censor of the Shaanxi branch secretariat but did not accept. He was again retained as drafting academician of the Kuizhang Pavilion Academy and still concurrently served as classics colloquium official. In summer of the second year he was transferred to direct academician of the Hall of Gathered Worthies, concurrently chancellor of the Directorate of Education, and his classics colloquium duties remained as before. That year, on the twenty-fifth day of the eleventh month, he died, at the age of fifty-four. His rank in office rose through ten steps from gentleman for court service to grand master for splendid happiness.
26
滿
By nature Ben was lofty and unyielding. He held to upright principles, conducted himself with pure integrity, and could not be swayed by private interest. Yet he was devoted to the duty of friendship, firm as gold and iron. If a man had even a small virtue, he praised it without stint. Above all he took upon himself the task of upholding civilization. When he supervised the examinations, he filled the quota of one hundred jinshi; as reading examiner he increased the first class to three men. When his father served in the south, they were poor and sold the house to depart. Ben, in office, maintained pure caution in self-conduct, sometimes scarcely having enough porridge. Before Ben had reached twenty, he gathered students to support his parents, for nearly twenty years. Though he rose through office to eminence, he still rented a house to live in. When he died, but for funeral gifts he could scarcely have afforded coffin and burial. Nearly two thousand men carried the mourning cord—all gentry officials, students, former subordinates, and students of the Directorate of Education. Never was there a single miscellaneous guest. People of the time honored him for it. Ben's writings include the 《Collected Works of the Zhizhi Reign》 in forty fascicles, circulated in the world. His posthumous title was Upright Presentation.
27
○ Xie Duan
28
滿
Xie Duan, styled Jingde, was a native of Suining in Shu. At the end of the Song, many scholars of Shu fled the warfare to Jiangling and settled there. Duan was precocious from childhood. At five or six he could recite poetry; at ten he could compose fu. At twenty he studied under the same teacher as Minister Song Ben, mastered moral principle, wrote ancient-style prose, and together they taught in Jiangling city. They were equally famed in letters, and people of the time called them "Xie and Song." Shi Geng, pacification commissioner of Jingnan, repeatedly extended him courtesy and recommended him to Yao Sui. Yao Sui, then proud of his great name in letters, seldom approved others. He showed Duan what he had written. Duan read it once and could point out where his meaning lay. Yao Sui sighed in admiration without end and told others: "Twenty years from now, will a man like Xie Duan be easy to find!" Through the recommender he was appointed a school official, but no response came. When the examination system was implemented, he took the test at the Henan branch secretariat and passed its examination, but because of mourning for his mother did not attend the palace examination. In the fifth year of the Yanyou reign he was finally selected as jinshi in the second class. He was appointed gentleman for court service and vice prefect of Xiangyin Prefecture on the Tanzhou circuit. When his term ended he entered service as doctor of the Directorate of Education, then was transferred to doctor of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices. Thieves entered the ancestral temple and the golden spirit tablet of the eighth chamber was lost. He was dismissed on that account. Duan was a ritual official, not a custodian by statute, and ought not to have been punished. Yet he did not argue the point. Soon he was appointed Hanlin compiler, promoted to attendant draftsman, selected as vice chancellor of the Directorate of Education, and then made direct Hanlin academician, with rank grand master for splendid happiness.
29
使
Duan was skilled at governing. When he first took office at Xiangyin, crafty clerks held their hands and dared not manipulate the law, and overbearing commoners and ruffians kept far away. When the circuit envoy made his inspection rounds, stalled lawsuits from neighboring prefectures were all referred to Duan for judgment. He decided them like flowing water, and his reputation spread widely. His literary compositions were strict and disciplined in method, preferring restraint and approaching spareness, without extravagant excess or confusion. He long served in the Hanlin Academy. From the Zhishun and Yuantong reigns onward, when the state honored imperial titles, when the empress dowager of utmost kindness was enshrined with former emperors, and when Confucius's parents received added enfeoffment, many of the edicts and patent letters came from his hand. He took part in compiling the Veritable Records of the Wenzong, Mingzong, and Ningzong reigns, and the collected biographies of meritorious ministers of successive reigns. People of the time said he had talent for history. Earlier, when Emperor Wenzong established the Kuizhang Pavilion and gathered talented men from within and without to place there, he once told Arong: "Among literary men today, I alone have not yet met Xie Duan." Before long Emperor Wenzong died, and in the end Duan was never employed. Duan also co-authored the 《Discourse on Legitimate Succession》 with Su Tianjue of Zhao Commandery, thoroughly arguing the legitimate succession of Jin and Song. The world widely circulated it. In the sixth year of the Zhizheng reign he died, at the age of sixty-two. Among Shu scholars famed for letters in the Yuan, Yu Ji was foremost, and Xie Duan was second.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →