← Back to 資治通鑑

卷51 漢紀四十三

Volume 51 Han Records 43

Chapter 51 of 資治通鑑 · Comprehensive Mirror in Aid of Governance
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 51
Next Chapter →
1
051
Zizhi Tongjian, Volume 51.
2
【Han Records 43】 From the first year of the Zhanmeng cycle through the last year of the Zhaoyang cycle—nine years in all.
3
In spring, in the second month, on yihai day, Prince Hui of Xiapi Yan died.
4
On jiachen day the emperor made a southern tour.
5
In the third month, on the new moon of wuwu day, there was a solar eclipse.
6
輿
On gengshen day the emperor reached Wan and fell ill. On yichou day the emperor set out from Wan; on dingmao day he reached Ye and died in the imperial carriage. He was thirty-two years old.
7
殿
The empress, together with Yan Xian's brothers, Jiang Jing, Fan Feng, and the rest, plotted, saying, "The emperor has died on the road, and the Prince of Jibei is in the palace. If the grand ministers by chance install him, on our return it will be a great disaster." They thereupon falsely announced that "the emperor's illness is severe," moved him to the imperial sleeping carriage, and at each stop food was presented and inquiries after his health continued as before. They drove in haste for four days; on gengwu day they returned to the palace. On xinwei day Minister of Education Liu Xi was sent to the suburban altars, temples, and the altars of soil and grain to announce to Heaven and request mandate; that evening mourning was proclaimed. The empress was honored as empress dowager. The empress dowager presided over court. Xian was made General of Chariots and Cavalry with protocol equal to the Three Excellencies. The empress dowager wished to monopolize state affairs for long and was eager to install a young child. With Xian and the rest she fixed the succession within the inner palace and welcomed Prince Hui of Jibei's son, Marquis of North Village Yi, as heir. The Prince of Jibei, having been deposed, could not ascend the hall to attend the coffin in person. He wailed in grief and would not eat; officials within and without all grieved for him.
8
On jiaxu day Prince Xiao of Jinan Xiang died without heirs and the state was extinguished. On yiyou day the Marquis of North Village assumed the imperial throne.
9
In summer, in the fourth month, on dingyou day Grand Commandant Feng Shi became Grand Tutor; Minister of Education Liu Xi became Grand Commandant and participated in recording Masters of Writing affairs; former Minister of Works Li He became Minister of Education.
10
耀
Yan Xian resented Grand General Geng Bao's honored position and heavy power, his authority still felt from the former court. He therefore prompted the responsible offices to memorialize that "Bao and his faction, together with Palace Attendant Fan Feng, Colonel of the Rapid Tigers Xie Yun, Palace Attendant Zhou Guang, Prince of Yewang Wang Sheng, and Sheng's daughter Yong and the rest, repeatedly formed a clique, each making authority and blessing for himself—all were greatly unfilial." On xinmao day Feng, Yun, and Guang were all imprisoned and executed; their families were relocated to Bijing. Bao and his nephew Marquis of Linlu Cheng were both demoted to ting marquises and sent to their states; Bao killed himself on the road. Wang Sheng and his mother were relocated to Yanmen. Thereupon Yan Jing was made Commandant of the Guards, Yao Colonel of the City Gates, and Yan Bearer of the Gilded Mace; the brothers all held power posts, authority and blessing at their own disposal.
11
On jiyou day Emperor An was buried at Gong tomb; his temple name was Gongzong.
12
In the sixth month, on yisi day, the realm was pardoned.
13
西使
In autumn, in the seventh month, Western Regions Chief Clerk Ban Yong dispatched six thousand cavalry from Dunhuang, Zhangye, and Jiuquan, together with troops of Shanshan, Shule, and the Former Department of Cheshi, to strike the Later King Junjiu and routed him, taking more than eight thousand heads and captives. Junjiu and the Xiongnu envoy bearing credentials were captured alive, brought to the place where Suo Ban had died and beheaded, and the head was sent to the capital.
14
In winter, in the tenth month, on bingwu day, a mountain in Yuexi collapsed.
15
The Marquis of North Village's illness was grave. Palace Attendant Sun Cheng said to the Prince of Jibei's Chief of Ushers Xing Qu, "The prince, as legitimate heir, originally had no lost virtue. The former emperor listened to slander and deposed him. If the Marquis of North Village does not recover, let us together cut down Jiang Jing and Yan Xian—nothing will fail." Qu agreed. Also Central Yellow Gate Wang Kang of Nanyang, who had earlier been a clerk in the crown prince's household, and Chief Steward of Everlasting Joy Wang Guo of Jingzhao and the rest all joined Cheng's cause. Jiang Jing said to Yan Xian, "The Marquis of North Village's illness does not ease; the succession ought to be settled in time—why not early summon the various princes and choose whom to install!" Xian agreed. On xinhai day the Marquis of North Village died. Xian reported to the empress dowager, kept the death secret and did not proclaim mourning, and instead again summoned the various princes, closed the palace gates, and garrisoned troops to guard himself.
16
西 殿 西 使
In the eleventh month, on yimao day, Sun Cheng, Wang Kang, Wang Guo, together with Central Yellow Gates Huang Long, Peng Kai, Meng Shu, Li Jian, Wang Cheng, Zhang Xian, Shi Fan, Ma Guo, Wang Dao, Li Yuan, Yang Tuo, Chen Yu, Zhao Feng, Li Gang, Wei Meng, Miao Guang, and the rest gathered to plot beneath the Western Bell. All cut their unlined garments as oath. On dingsi day the capital and sixteen commanderies and kingdoms suffered earthquakes. That night Cheng and the rest met atop Chongde Hall and entered Zhangtai Gate. At the time Jiang Jing, Liu Fa, and Li Run and Chen Da and the rest were all seated beneath the Secretariat gate. Cheng and Wang Kang went together and beheaded Jing, An, and Da. Because Li Run's accumulated authority made him one whom those within the Secretariat obeyed, they wished to make him their leader and raised blades to coerce him, saying, "Now we must install the Prince of Jibei—none may stir!" Run said, "Yes." Thereupon they helped Run rise, and all together beneath the Western Bell welcomed the Prince of Jibei to the throne. He was then eleven years old. The Director of the Masters of Writing, Vice Director, and those below were summoned to follow the carriage to the Southern Palace. Cheng and the rest remained to guard the Secretariat gate, blocking access within and without. The emperor ascended Cloud Terrace, summoned the ducal ministers and the hundred officials, and ordered Rapid Tiger and Forest guards to garrison the gates of the Southern and Northern Palaces.
17
使 使
Yan Xian was then within the inner palace, distressed and at a loss. Junior Yellow Gate Fan Deng urged him, by the empress dowager's edict, to summon Colonel of the Rapid Cavalry Feng Shi and Colonel of the Rapid Tigers Yan Chong to lead troops and garrison Ping Gate to resist Cheng and the rest. Xian lured Shi into the Secretariat and said to him, "The Prince of Jibei's installation is not the empress dowager's intent. The seal and cord are here. If you exhaust your strength in service, you can be enfeoffed as marquis." The empress dowager sent someone to grant him a seal, saying, "Whoever can obtain the Prince of Jibei shall be enfeoffed as marquis of ten thousand households; whoever can obtain Li Run shall be enfeoffed as marquis of five thousand households." Shi and the rest all promised, excusing themselves that "the soldiers were suddenly summoned; the men I lead are few." Xian sent him with Deng to welcome officials and soldiers outside the Left Flank Gate. Shi thereupon struck and killed Deng, returned to camp, and garrisoned in defense.
18
使 宿
Xian's younger brother Commandant of the Guards Jing hastily returned from the Secretariat to the outer offices, gathered troops, and reached Shengde Gate. Sun Cheng transmitted summons to the various Masters of Writing to have Jing arrested. Master of Writing Guo Zhen was then ill in bed. Hearing of it, he immediately led the on-duty Forest guards out through the Southern Gate Where Chariots Stop, met Jing's following officials and soldiers drawing bright blades, and shouted, "None interfere with the troops!" Zhen immediately descended the carriage, held credentials, and proclaimed to him. Jing said, "What sort of proclamation!" He hacked at Zhen and missed. Zhen drew his sword, struck Jing, and knocked him from the carriage. His attendants pinned his chest with halberds, captured him, and sent him to the Minister of Justice's prison. That very night he died.
19
使殿耀
On wuwu day envoys were sent into the Secretariat and the seal and cord were seized. The emperor thereupon visited Jiade Hall, sent Attending Censors bearing credentials to arrest Yan Xian and his younger brothers Colonel of the City Gates Yao and Bearer of the Gilded Mace Yan, and all were imprisoned and executed; their families were all relocated to Bijing. The empress dowager was moved to a detached palace. On jiwei day the gates were opened and garrison troops were dismissed. On renxu day an edict to the Colonel of the Metropolitan Area said, "Only Yan Xian and Jiang Jing's close kin ought to bear guilt and suffer execution; the rest should be treated with generous leniency."
20
Sun Cheng and the rest were all enfeoffed as ranked marquises: Cheng's fief was ten thousand households; Wang Kang and Wang Guo nine thousand; Huang Long five thousand; Peng Kai, Meng Shu, and Li Jian four thousand two hundred; Wang Cheng, Zhang Xian, Shi Fan, Ma Guo, Wang Dao, Li Yuan, Yang Tuo, Chen Yu, Zhao Feng, and Li Gang four thousand; Wei Meng two thousand; Miao Guang one thousand—these were the nineteen marquises. Carriages, horses, gold, silver, cash, and silks were added as gifts, each according to rank; Li Run, because he had not been in on the plot from the start, was not enfeoffed. Sun Cheng was promoted to Colonel of Cavalry.
21
倀
Earlier, when Cheng and the rest entered Zhangtai Gate, Miao Guang alone did not enter. An edict ordered the recording of meritorious subjects and commanded Wang Kang to list names. Kang falsely listed Guang as having entered Zhangtai Gate. Guang had not received credentials and edicts; uneasy in heart, he went to the Yellow Gate Director to confess. The responsible offices memorialized that Kang and Guang had deceived the sovereign; an edict ordered that they not be questioned. Chief Artisan for Palace Construction Lai Li was made Commandant of the Guards. Di Feng, Liu Wei, Luqiu Hong, and the rest had died earlier; all their sons were appointed gentlemen. Zhu Chang, Shi Yan, Chen Guang, and Zhao Dai were all promoted; later they reached ducal rank. The families of Wang Nan and Bing Ji were summoned back to the capital and generously rewarded. When the emperor had been deposed, the junior yellow gates supervising the crown prince's household Ji Jian and Fu Gaofan, Chief of Everlasting Autumn Zhao Xi, Assistant Liang He, and Chief of Medicines Xia Zhen had all been charged and relocated to Shuofang; when the emperor took the throne, all were promoted to palace attendants.
22
使
Earlier Yan Xian recruited Cui □'s son Yuan as a clerk. Yuan, seeing the Marquis of North Village installed improperly, knew Xian would fail and wished to persuade him to depose and install, but Xian was daily deep in drink and could not be seen. He thereupon said to Chief Clerk Chen Chan, "Palace Attendants Jiang Jing and the rest deluded the former emperor, deposed the legitimate heir, and propped up a distant offshoot. The young emperor took the throne and fell ill in the ancestral temple—the sign of Zhou Bo appears again at this moment. Now I wish together with you to seek an audience and persuade the general, report to the empress dowager, arrest Jing and the rest, depose the young emperor, and install the Prince of Jibei. Above it will match Heaven's heart; below it will join human expectation. The achievements of Yi Yin and Huo Guang—won without leaving one's seat—then the general's brothers will transmit favor without end; if you reject Heaven's intent and long leave the throne vacant, you will be punished without guilt together with the chief villain. This is the meeting of fortune and calamity, the time to divide achievement." Chan hesitated and did not dare agree. It happened that Xian failed; Yuan was charged and dismissed; his student Su Zhi wished to submit a memorial stating the facts, but Yuan hastily stopped him. At the time Chen Chan was Colonel of the Metropolitan Area. He summoned Yuan and said, "Younger brother, let Zhi submit the memorial—I, Chan, ask to testify for it." Yuan said, "This is like a child concubine's whisper behind a screen—I beg you never speak of it again." He thereupon took leave and returned, and no longer responded to commandery and provincial orders.
23
On jimao day the Marquis of North Village was buried with the rites due a prince.
24
Minister of Works Liu Shou, for fawning on the wicked and rebellious and recruiting improper men, was impeached and dismissed.
25
In the twelfth month, on jiashen day, Intendant of the Palace Treasury Tao Dun of Henan was made Minister of Works.
26
Yang Zhen's students Yu Fang and Chen Yi came to court to pursue and plead Zhen's case; an edict appointed Zhen's two sons as gentlemen, bestowed a gift of a million cash, and by rite reburied him at Tong Pavilion in Huayin. From far and near all came. A large bird over a zhang tall gathered before Zhen's funeral; the commandery reported it to the throne. Moved by Zhen's loyalty and uprightness, the emperor ordered middle-grade sacrificial offerings restored for his worship. Consultation Gentleman Chen Chan argued: "Empress Dowager Yan and the emperor have no mother-son bond; she ought to be moved to a separate residence and court audiences ended." The ministers who discussed it all agreed. A clerk of the Minister over the Masses, Zhou Ju of Runan, said to Li He: "In the past Gusou often wished to kill Shun, yet Shun served him all the more carefully; Lady Wu of Zheng plotted to kill Duke Zhuang, and Duke Zhuang swore reunion only in the Yellow Springs; Qin Shihuang resented his mother's misconduct and long kept apart, then was moved by Ying Kaoshu and Mao Jiao and again practiced filial duty; the histories praise this. Now the Yan clan has just been executed and the empress dowager is secluded in a detached palace. If grief brings illness and she meets sudden misfortune, how will our lord command all under Heaven! If we follow Chan's proposal, later ages will blame Your Excellency. You ought secretly to memorialize the court, have the empress dowager honored, and lead the ministers in audience as before, to satisfy Heaven and answer public expectation!" He at once submitted a memorial setting this forth.
27
Emperor He, Part One.
28
In spring, in the first month, the emperor attended the empress dowager at the Eastern Palace, and her mind was eased.
29
On jiayin day all under Heaven was amnestied.
30
On xinwei day Empress Dowager Yan died.
31
On xinsi day Grand Tutor Feng Shi and Grand Commandant Liu Xi were dismissed for fawning on the powerful. Minister over the Masses Li He was dismissed.
32
In the second month, on jiashen day, Empress Ansi was buried.
33
倀
On bingxu day Grand Master of Ceremonies Huan Yan was made Grand Tutor; Grand Herald Zhu Chong of Jingzhao was made Grand Commandant and joined in recording Masters of Writing affairs; Changle Chamberlain Zhu Yi was made Minister over the Masses.
34
Master of Writing Guo Zhen was enfeoffed as Marquis of Dingying.
35
西
The Zhong Qiang of Longxi rebelled. Colonel Ma Xian attacked them at Lintao, took more than a thousand heads, and the Qiang all submitted; thereby Liang Province was again pacified.
36
In the sixth month, on jihai day, Xian, son of Prince Jian of Jinan Cuo, was enfeoffed as Prince of Jinan.
37
In autumn, in the seventh month, on gengwu day, Commandant of the Guards Lai Li was made General of Chariots and Cavalry.
38
歿
In the eighth month the Xianbei raided Dai Commandery; Administrator Li Chao died in battle.
39
殿
Within months of taking office as Director of Retainers, Yu Xu memorialized against Feng Shi and Liu Xi and had them dismissed. He also impeached Palace Attendants Cheng Huang, Chen Bing, Meng Sheng, Li Run, and others. Officials looked askance and called him harsh. The Three Excellencies impeached him: "Xu in midsummer often imprisoned the innocent, troubling officials and people." Xu memorialized in his own defense: "Law and prohibition are the dikes of custom; punishment is the bit and bridle of the people. Now the province leaves matters to the commandery and the commandery to the county—each passes responsibility farther off, and the people are worn with resentment; lax accommodation is deemed worthy and exhausting integrity foolish. Those I have impeached are guilty more than once. The Three Offices fear my reports and therefore add false charges. I will follow Shi Yu in death and use my corpse to remonstrate!" The emperor read his memorial and did not punish Xu. Palace Attendant Zhang Fang trafficked in power and took bribes through patronage; Xu investigated him, but the cases were repeatedly shelved without response. Unable to bear his anger, Xu bound himself and presented himself to the Commandant of Justice, memorializing: "In the past Emperor Xiao'an employed Fan Feng, who disturbed the legitimate succession and nearly destroyed the state. Now Zhang Fang again wields power; the state's calamity is about to return. I cannot bear to serve in court with Fang and respectfully bind myself to report this—do not let me follow Yang Zhen's fate!" When the memorial was submitted, Fang wept and pleaded to the emperor. Xu was sentenced and sent to the Left Corps; Fang was determined to destroy him. Within two days he was tortured in four prisons. The prison clerks urged Xu to kill himself. Xu said, "I would rather submit to the executioner's blade to show those far and near! to die by secret suicide—who then could tell right from wrong?" Marquis of Fuyang Sun Cheng and Marquis of Zhu'e Zhang Xian together begged audience. Cheng said, "When Your Majesty first undertook the enterprise with us, you hated treacherous ministers and knew they overturn states. Now, having taken the throne, you again act on your own—how is this unlike faulting the former emperor! Director of Retainers Yu Xu has been utterly loyal to Your Majesty, yet is imprisoned; Palace Attendant Zhang Fang's guilt is clear, yet he frames the loyal. Now a guest star guards Yulin; its omen is a treacherous minister within the palace; Your Majesty ought urgently to seize Fang and imprison him to stem Heaven's warning." At this time Fang stood behind the emperor. Cheng shouted at Fang: "Treacherous minister Zhang Fang—why do you not leave the hall!" Fang had no choice and hurried to the eastern side chamber. Cheng said, "Your Majesty, urgently seize Fang—do not let him seek favor through the foster mother!" The emperor asked the Masters of Writing. Master of Writing Jia Lang, who had long been friendly with Fang, attested to Xu's guilt; the emperor was doubtful and said to Cheng, "Withdraw for now—I am still considering it!" Thereupon Xu's son Yan and more than a hundred disciples raised banners and waited for Palace Attendant Gao Fan's carriage, knocking their heads until they bled and pleading wrongful imprisonment. Fan entered and reported. Fang was banished, and Jia Lang and six others were either executed or dismissed; that same day Xu was pardoned and released. Cheng again memorialized that Xu had great merit; his words were very cutting. The emperor was moved and again summoned him as Consultation Gentleman; within days he was made Vice Director of the Masters of Writing. Xu memorialized recommending Consultation Gentleman Zuo Xiong of Nanyang: "I see that among excellencies and ministers down, most keep silent, taking cultivation of favor as worthy and exhausting integrity as foolish—even warning one another, 'Do not touch white jade; easy compliance brings later blessing. I observe Consultation Gentleman Zuo Xiong, who has a king's minister's upright integrity; he ought to be promoted to a speaking office and will surely buttress the state." Thereupon Xiong was appointed Master of Writing.
40
殿 倀西 倀 祿 倀
Marquis of Fuyang Sun Cheng and others went up to the hall bearing memorials to dispute merit; the emperor was angry. The responsible officials impeached: "Cheng and others were disorderly and rebellious; Wang Guo and the rest are all Cheng's faction, long remaining in the capital and growing more arrogant." The emperor then dismissed Cheng and the rest from office and transferred all their enfeoffments to distant counties. He then sent the nineteen marquises to their states and ordered the magistrate of Luoyang to hasten their departure. Minister over the Masses clerk Zhou Ju urged Zhu Yi: "When the court was below the west bell, without Sun Cheng and the rest how could Your Majesty have been established! Now you forget their great merit and record their small faults. If they die on the road, Your Majesty will bear the reproach of killing meritorious servants. While they have not yet gone, you ought urgently to memorialize! Yi said, "The edict's intent is angry now; if I alone memorialize this I am sure to be punished." Ju said, "Your Excellency is past eighty and holds the highest rank—if not now you exhaust loyalty and serve the state, cherishing safety, what do you seek! Though salary and rank are preserved, you will fall into flattery and wickedness; to remonstrate and be punished still leaves a name for loyalty. If my words are not worth adopting, I beg to take my leave!" Yi then memorialized in remonstrance, and the emperor followed it. Cheng was transferred to Marquis of Yicheng. Reaching his state, resentful and indignant, he returned seal, ribbon, tally, and patent, fled back to the capital, and wandered in the mountains. An edict pursued him, restored his former rank and fief, bestowed carriage, horses, and clothing, and sent him back to his state.
41
In winter, in the tenth month, on dinghai day, Minister of Works Tao Dun was dismissed.
42
西
West of Shuofang many border barriers were ruined, and the Xianbei therefore repeatedly raided the Southern Xiongnu; the chanyu was anxious and memorialized begging repair of the barriers. On gengyin day an edict ordered: "Troops of the Liyang camp shall garrison the northern border of Zhongshan; order the border commanderies to add foot soldiers, garrison them below the passes, and teach battle and archery."
43
Commandant of Justice Zhang Hao was made Minister of Works.
44
使 使 使
Ban Yong again established the former prince of the Rear Kingdom of Cheshi, Jianute, as king. Yong also sent a separate colonel to execute the king of Eastern Qumi and again established a tribesman as king; thereby the six states of Cheshi were all pacified. Yong then mobilized the armies of the various states against the Xiongnu. King Huyan fled and more than twenty thousand of his followers submitted. They captured the chanyu's elder brother alive. Yong had Jianute personally behead him to seal the breach between Cheshi and the Xiongnu. The Northern Chanyu himself led more than ten thousand horsemen into the rear kingdom as far as Jinqie Valley; Yong sent Acting Major Cao Jun to rescue them. The chanyu withdrew and Jun pursued and killed his noble Guduhou. Thereupon King Huyan moved to the Kuwu River, and afterward Cheshi saw no further barbarian presence.
45
In spring, in the first month, Colonel Zhang Guo with the Southern Chanyu's troops attacked the Xianbei Qizhijian and defeated them. In the second month the Liaodong Xianbei raided Liaodong and Xuantu; Colonel of the Wuhuan Geng Ye mobilized border commandery troops and the Wuhuan beyond the pass to strike them, taking many heads and captives; and thirty thousand Xianbei came to Liaodong to submit.
46
In the third month there was drought.
47
Earlier, the emperor's mother Lady Li was buried north of Luoyang, and at first the emperor did not know; at this time those about him informed him. The emperor then expressed mourning, went in person to the burial place, and again interred her with full rites. In the sixth month, on yiyou day, she was posthumously titled Empress Gongmin and buried north of Gong Mausoleum.
48
西 西 使
The walled states of the Western Regions all submitted to Han; only King Yuan Meng of Yanqi had not submitted, and Ban Yong memorialized requesting an attack. Thereupon Administrator of Dunhuang Zhang Lang was sent to lead three thousand troops of the four Hexi commanderies to join Ban Yong, and troops of the various states totaling more than forty thousand were mobilized and divided into two columns to attack. Ban Yong took the southern route and Zhang Lang the northern, agreeing to arrive at Yanqi together on a set date. But Zhang Lang had earlier committed a crime and wished to win merit to redeem himself. He therefore arrived ahead of schedule at Jueli Pass, sent his Major with troops to fight in advance, and took more than two thousand heads and captives. Yuan Meng feared execution and beforehand sent envoys to beg submission. Zhang Lang went straight into Yanqi, accepted the surrender, and returned. Zhang Lang was spared execution. Ban Yong was summoned for being late, imprisoned, and dismissed.
49
In autumn, in the seventh month, on the first day jiaxu, there was a solar eclipse.
50
倀 祿
On renwu day, Grand Commandant Zhu Chong and Minister over the Masses Zhu Yi were dismissed. On gengzi day, Grand Master of Ceremonies Liu Guang was made Grand Commandant and Recorder of Matters Relating to the Masters of Writing, and Household Minister Xu Jing of Runan was made Minister over the Masses. Liu Guang was the younger brother of Liu Ju. Xu Jing served between the He and An reigns, when the Dou, Deng, and Yan clans were at their height, yet he bent to none; after the three houses had fallen many scholar-officials were stained, yet no slander reached Xu Jing, and the age for this held him in honor.
51
輿殿 使 祿 使 祿退
Earlier, Fan Ying of Nanyang from youth had learning and conduct and his fame was known within the seas. He dwelt on the southern slope of Mount Hu, and though provinces and commanderies repeatedly invited him with ceremony, he did not respond; the dukes and ministers recommended him as Worthy, Upright, and Possessed of the Way, yet he would not go; Emperor An bestowed a written summons and called him, but he did not come. That year the emperor again summoned Fan Ying with written summons and black-and-red silks and full ceremony, but Ying firmly pleaded grave illness. An edict sharply reproved the commanderies and counties, and he was carried in a carriage onto the road. Fan Ying had no choice but to arrive at the capital, claimed illness, and would not rise; he was forcibly carried into the hall, yet still could not be bent. The emperor had him go out to the Imperial Physician to nurse his illness, and each month sent mutton and wine. Afterward the emperor set up an altar for Fan Ying, ordered the Director of the Imperial Carriages to lead and the Masters of Writing to attend and conduct, bestowed an armrest and staff, treated him with the rites due a tutor, extended inquiry into gains and losses, and appointed him Colonel of the Five Offices. After several months Fan Ying claimed grave illness; an edict made him Household Minister, granted leave to return home, ordered the locality to send grain, and at the seasons to deliver oxen and wine. Fan Ying declined the rank and would not accept. An edict explained the intent and forbade refusal. When Fan Ying was first under the imperial summons, the multitude all thought he would surely not lower his resolve. Wang Yi of Nan commandery had long been friendly with Fan Ying and therefore wrote him a letter with many ancient analogies and persuasions, urging him to accept the appointment. Fan Ying followed Wang Yi's counsel and came; but afterward in his responses there were no extraordinary plans or deep policies, and those who discussed it felt disappointment. Zhang Kai of Henan was summoned together with Fan Ying and said to him, "All under heaven has two paths—going forth and staying put. I formerly thought that in your going forth you could assist this ruler and succor these people. Yet you first with an unblemished person angered a ruler of ten thousand chariots, and once you enjoyed rank and salary you were not heard to have methods of correction and rescue—going forth and staying put have no footing left."
52
Sima Guang remarks: The gentleman of old, when the state had the Way then served; when the state lacked the Way then hid. Hiding was not what the gentleman desired. No one knew him yet the Way could not be practiced; the wicked dwelt together and harm was about to reach his person—therefore he hid deep to avoid it. When kings raised reclusive subjects and exalted the obscure and lowly, it was truly because they benefited the state, not to please the eyes and ears of the vulgar world. Therefore if moral power was enough to honor the ruler and wisdom enough to shelter the people, wearing coarse cloth yet cherishing jade, hiding deep and not offering himself for sale—then the king ought with full rites to bring him, bow the body to descend to him, empty the mind to consult him, and restrain the self to follow him—only then could benefit and grace spread to the four quarters and merit and glory reach above and below. This was taking his Way, not taking the man; seeking the substance, not seeking the name.
53
耀 使 祿
If rites were complete yet he did not come, intent earnest yet he did not rise—then for the moment he turned inward to examine himself and did not dare force the man, saying, Is my virtue thin and not worth esteeming? Is government chaotic and not to be assisted? Are petty men in court and one dares not advance? Is sincere heart not arrived and one fears his words will not be used? Why do the worthy not follow me? If his virtue were already thick, government already ordered, petty men far off, and sincere heart arrived—then they would knock at the gate to offer themselves. How could there be earnest seeking yet failure to come! Xunzi said, "One who gathers cicadas with fire must make the fire bright and shake the tree—that is all; if the fire is not bright, though one shakes the tree, it is of no use. If today's ruler can make his virtue bright, then all under heaven will come to him, as cicadas come to bright fire." Some rulers, shamed that they cannot bring men, even entice them with high rank and threaten them with severe punishment. If they were truly gentlemen, then rank is not what they covet and punishment not what they fear—in the end they cannot be brought; those who can be brought are all men who covet rank and fear punishment—how are they worth honoring! As for those whose filial piety and brotherliness shine in the family and whose conduct and righteousness rise in the village lanes, who do not grasp profit at random or advance in office at random, who keep themselves pure and rest in their lot, passing the year at ease—though not enough to honor the ruler and shelter the people, these too are auspicious gentlemen of pure cultivation. Kings ought to praise, favor, settle, and nurture them, enabling them to fulfill their intent. Like Emperor Xiaozhao's treatment of Han Fu or Emperor Guangwu's meeting with Zhou Dang—to encourage integrity and shame and beautify custom—this too is fitting. One certainly should not, like Fan Sheng, slander them, nor, like Zhang Kai, press demands upon them. As for those who adorn falsehood to win praise, angle for the strange to startle the vulgar, refuse the ruler's salary yet contend for the butcher's and peddler's profit, decline petty office yet scheme for minister and chancellor rank—name and substance opposed, heart and tracks at odds—these are the sort of flashy gentlemen and Shao Zheng Mao. That they escape the sage king's punishment is already fortunate—how much less any summons to office!
54
At this time Yang Hou of Guanghan and Huang Qiong of Jiangxia were also summoned. Huang Qiong was the son of Huang Xiang. When Yang Hou had arrived he beforehand set forth that Han would have a calamity at three hundred fifty years as a warning, and was appointed Gentleman Consultant. As Huang Qiong was about to arrive, Li Gu with a letter went to meet and present it to him, saying, "The gentleman says Boyi was narrow and Liuxia Hui was not respectful. Neither narrow nor disrespectful, in the interval of yes and no—this is what sages and worthies treasure in placing themselves. If you truly wish to pillow the mountains and nest in valleys, taking as model the tracks of Chao and You, that may do; if you ought to assist government and succor the people, now is the time. From the birth of the people, good government has been few and chaotic custom many. To insist on waiting for rulers like Yao and Shun—then for scholars to practice their intent there will never be a time. I have often heard the saying, 'The towering is easily broken; the dazzling is easily stained.' Under great fame, the substance is hard to match. Recently the Master of Luyang, Fan Ying, was summoned. When he first arrived the court set up altar and mat as if awaiting a spirit. Though there was no great difference, in word and conduct what he upheld was not lacking; yet slander spread abroad and he was at once diminished—is it not because what observers hoped for was deep and his fame too great! Therefore vulgar opinion all says 'recluses purely steal empty fame.' I wish you, sir, would expand this far-reaching plan, make the multitude sigh in admiration, and once wash away this saying!" When Huang Qiong arrived he was appointed Gentleman Consultant and was gradually promoted to Vice Director of the Masters of Writing. Huang Qiong had formerly followed his father in the terrace offices and was practiced in precedents; when he later held office he was thoroughly versed in the bureaus. In debate at court none could withstand or overturn him. He several times submitted memorials on affairs, and the emperor quite adopted his proposals.
55
Li Gu was the son of Li He. From youth he loved learning, often changed his name, staff in hand drove a donkey, and carried a book box to follow teachers—not shrinking from a thousand li—and thus thoroughly perused the classics, becoming a great Confucian of the age. Whenever he reached the Imperial Academy he would secretly enter his father's offices to attend his parents morning and evening, not letting fellow students know he was Li He's son.
56
In spring, in the first month, on bingzi day, the capital had an earthquake.
57
In summer, in the sixth month, there was drought.
58
In autumn, in the seventh month, on dingyou day, the park lodge at Maoling Mausoleum burned.
59
In the ninth month the Xianbei raided Yuyang.
60
In winter, in the twelfth month, on jihai day, Grand Tutor Huan Yan was dismissed. General of Chariots and Cavalry Lai Li was dismissed.
61
The Southern Chanyu Ba died. His younger brother Xiuli was established as Chanyu Qute Ruoshizhu Jiu.
62
The emperor summoned Sun Cheng and the others all back to the capital.
63
In spring, in the first month, on bingyin day, all under heaven was pardoned.
64
On bingzi day the emperor performed the capping ceremony.
65
In summer, in the fifth month, on renchen day, an edict said, "Within the seas there are rather many disasters and portents. The court is reforming government, the Grand Provisioner has reduced meals, and precious curios are not used. Yet Administrator of Guiyang Wen Yin not only failed to exhaust loyalty and proclaim and extend this court, but from afar presented great pearls to seek favor and flattery—now they are sealed and returned to him!"
66
Five provinces had rain and flooding.
67
In autumn, in the eighth month, on dingsi day, Grand Commandant Liu Guang and Minister of Works Zhang Hao were dismissed.
68
Investigator of the Masters of Writing Yu Xu submitted a memorial, saying, "Anding, Beidi, and Shang commanderies have mountains and rivers perilous and narrow, fertile fields for a thousand li, soil fit for pasture, and water for irrigation and transport. Recently they suffered the common people's calamity. The many Qiang collapsed inward, and commanderies and counties were desolate from war for more than twenty years. To abandon the richness of fertile soil and cast away nature's wealth cannot be called profit; to leave the barriers of rivers and mountains and guard places without peril is hard to make secure. Now the three commanderies are not restored and the park mausoleums stand exposed alone, yet the dukes and ministers choose the timid, let the head pass and the body follow, spread excuses and set difficulties, reckoning only expense and not planning for security. Your sage hearing should be opened and what each excels at examined." In the ninth month an edict restored Anding, Beidi, and Shang commanderies to their former lands.
69
On guiyou day, Grand Herald Pang Can was made Grand Commandant and Recorder of Matters Relating to the Masters of Writing. Grand Master of Ceremonies Wang Gong was made Minister of Works.
70
In winter, in the eleventh month, on gengchen day, Minister over the Masses Xu Jing was dismissed.
71
The Xianbei raided Shuofang.
72
In the twelfth month, on sijimao day, Director of the Imperial Clan Liu Qi of Hongnong was made Minister over the Masses.
73
使
That year King Fangqian of Yutian killed King Xing of Jimi, installed his own son as king of Jimi, and sent envoys with tribute. Administrator of Dunhuang Xu You memorialized requesting that he be punished. The emperor pardoned Yutian's crime and ordered the return of the Jimi state; Fangqian refused.
74
In summer, in the fourth month, the capital suffered drought.
75
The capital and twelve commanderies and states suffered locusts.
76
忿
Marquis Dingyuan Ban Shi's grandson Shi married the emperor's paternal aunt, the Princess of Yincheng. The princess was arrogant, dissolute, and lawless; Shi accumulated resentment and anger, lay in wait with a blade, and killed the princess. In winter, in the tenth month, on yihai day, Shi was sentenced to execution at the waist, and all siblings born of the same mother were exposed in the market.
77
殿 使 祿
In spring, in the second month, on gengwu day, Filial King Kai of Hejian died; His son Zheng succeeded. Zheng was arrogant and defiant and did not follow the law. The emperor, because Attending Clerk Shen Jing of Wu commandery had strong ability, promoted him to Chancellor of Hejian. When Jing reached the state and called on the king, the king was not properly dressed and sat sprawled on the hall dais; a Gentleman Attendant prompted the bow of courtesy. Jing stood erect and made no courtesy, asking where the king was. A Tiger Brave said, "Is this not the king!" Jing said, "The king is not properly dressed—how is he different from an ordinary man! Now the chancellor calls on the king—does he call on one without courtesy!" The king was ashamed and changed into proper dress; Jing then bowed; Going out, he stopped outside the palace gate and summoned the king's tutor to reprove him, saying, "Before leaving the capital I had audience and received an edict, because the king was disrespectful, to have the chancellor inspect and supervise. You gentlemen vainly receive rank and salary yet utterly lack the duty of instruction and guidance!" Thereupon he memorialized to punish their offenses. An imperial edict reproved Zheng and sharply rebuked the tutor. Jing then arrested various wicked men, memorialized cases of their crimes, executed several tens of the most vicious, and released more than a hundred from unjust imprisonment. Zheng thereupon changed his conduct, repented of his faults, and cultivated himself.
78
西
The emperor, because Yiwu was fertile land lying close to the Western Regions and the Xiongnu relied on it for raiding and plunder, in the third month, on xinhai day, again ordered the opening of military colonies as in the Yongyuan period and stationed one Major of Yiwu.
79
Earlier Emperor An was slight toward literary arts. Erudites no longer lectured and studied, students looked at one another in idleness and dispersion, school buildings fell into ruin and turned into vegetable gardens, and herd boys and firewood gatherers cut fuel beneath them. Master of Works Zhai Pu submitted a memorial requesting renewed repair and ornament to attract and advance later students, and the emperor followed it. In autumn, in the ninth month, the Imperial University was repaired and raised. In all, two hundred forty chambers and one thousand eight hundred fifty rooms were built.
80
Colonel Protector of the Wuhuan Geng Tan sent troops to attack the Xianbei and defeated them.
81
Colonel Protector of the Qiang Han Hao moved the garrison farms of Huangzhong and established them between the Two Rivers to press the various Qiang. Hao was summoned because of an offense, and Administrator of Zhangye Ma Xu was made colonel in his place. The Qiang between the Two Rivers, because the garrison farms were near them, feared they would surely be plotted against. Thereupon they dissolved enmity and oath alliances and each took precautions; Xu memorialized to move the garrison farms back to Huangzhong, and the Qiang's minds then were at ease.
82
The emperor wished to establish an empress, but among honored ladies with favor there were four, and none knew whom to establish. Deliberation wished to draw lots to let the spirits fix the choice. Vice Director of the Secretariat Hu Guang of Nan commandery together with Directors Guo Qian of Fengyi and Shi Chang submitted a memorial remonstrating, saying, "Your servant has seen the edict, that establishing the empress is a great affair, and in great humility one would not decide alone, wishing to borrow lots and stratagems and let numinous spirits resolve doubt; What the classics and records note, the ancestral precedents, have never had this. Relying on spirits and trusting divination, one will not necessarily obtain the worthy; even if one happens on the right person, it is still not selection by virtue. Precocious intelligence takes form from nature; resemblance to heaven surely has an unusual appearance. It is fitting to consult good families, select and seek the virtuous—where virtue is equal, use age; where age is equal, use appearance; examine against the canonical classics and decide by the sage's deliberation." The emperor followed it. The niece of Empress Gonghuai, daughter of Marquis Shang of Chengyi, was selected into the Palace Rear Apartments as an Honored Lady and was often specially summoned for the emperor's company. She calmly declined, saying, "Yang takes broad bestowal as virtue; yin takes not being exclusive as righteousness. The "Zhongsi" is where the hundred blessings arise. Your servant wishes Your Majesty to think of the even moisture of cloud and rain, that your humble servant may escape offense." The emperor thereby regarded her as worthy.
83
In spring, in the first month, on yisi day, Honored Lady Liang was established as empress.
84
The capital suffered drought.
85
In the third month, demon bandits Zhang He and others of six Yangzhou commanderies raided forty-nine counties and killed and wounded chief officials.
86
On gengyin day, the realm was amnestied and the reign title was changed.
87
In summer, in the fourth month, Liang Shang was given the additional rank of Special Advance; before long he was appointed Commandant of Justice.
88
In winter, Geng Tan sent the Wuhuan Rongmomo and others to raid the Xianbei, gained greatly, and returned. The Xianbei again raided the Dependent State of Liaodong. Geng Tan moved his encampment to Wulü city in Liaodong to resist them.
89
使 祿 調 祿 滿 便
Director of the Secretariat Zuo Xiong submitted a memorial, saying, "Formerly Emperor Xuan held that if officials were repeatedly changed, then inferiors would not settle in their occupations; long in their affairs, then the people submit to transformation and instruction. Those who had good government were at once encouraged by imperial rescript with seal, given increased rank and bestowed gold. When public ministers and excellencies were vacant, they were used in order. Thus officials matched their duties and the people were secure in their occupations. Good officials of the Han age reached their greatest abundance then. Today those governing cities of a hundred li shift without constancy. Each harbors a one-time expedient and none considers the long term. They call killing the innocent "prestigious wind," and gathering and levying with tight preparation "worth and ability; they take governing oneself and securing the people as inferior weakness, and following law and adhering to principle as non-government. punishments of shaving and shackling arise from the glance of an eye; disasters of corpses heaped over one another are completed from joy and anger. They regard the people as bandit enemies and tax them like jackals and tigers. Supervisors and inspectors stand back to back in sight, sharing the same disease—seeing wrong and not reporting it, hearing evil and not investigating. They observe government at post stations and demand achievement within a month; speaking of goodness without weighing virtue, discussing merit without basing on fact. the empty and false gain praise; the restrained and careful meet slander; some, because of crime, draw themselves high; some, seeing the color, seek fame. Prefects do not review them. They compete in summoning and appointing, leaping and soaring upward, surpassing rank and exceeding peers. Some are examined and memorialized for arrest and trial yet flee and do not receive punishment. When an amnesty comes they go with bribes and are again washed clean—vermilion and purple the same color, clear and turbid undivided. Therefore the crafty and slippery run wild, lightly heed coming and going, appointments and dismissals flow like water, and vacancies stir by the hundreds. Village officers and department clerks have mean duties and thin salaries, yet carriage, horse, and clothing all come from the people—the honest take enough, the greedy fill their houses; special selections and forced levies follow one another without cease. The trouble and expense of seeing off and welcoming harm government and injure the people. Harmonious qi is not attained, disasters and omens are not dispelled—the blame all lies here. Your servant foolishly thinks that where prefects, chancellors, and chief officials have kindness and harmony with clear effect, one may increase their rank in place and not transfer them; except for parents' mourning they may not leave office. Those who do not follow legal prohibitions and do not model the king's command should be barred for life. Though they meet an amnesty edict, they may not be ranked in the roster. If impeached and memorialized yet they flee and do not submit to law, move their families to frontier commanderies to warn those who come after. As for officers of villages and departments who are close to the people, all should employ Confucian scholars who are pure and clear and fit for government, relax their tax assessments, and increase their rank and salary; only when an officer's duty is full for a year may the prefect's office, the commandery, or the province summon and recommend. If so, the road of authority and favor is blocked, the source of emptiness and falsehood is cut off, the labor of seeing off and welcoming is reduced, the spring of levies and collections is stilled, officers who follow principle can complete their transformation, and the people of the whole realm each secure their place." The emperor was moved by his words, again proclaimed the prohibition on leaving office without cause, and also ordered the relevant offices to examine officials' government for truth and falsehood, detailing what was implemented; " but the eunuchs found it inconvenient, and in the end it could not be carried out.
90
滿 便 便
Xiong again submitted words, "Confucius said, 'At forty one is free of doubt'; the Rites call it strong service. Your servant requests that from today Filial and Incorrupt candidates under forty years of age may not be examined and recommended. All should first go to the public offices—students tested on family learning, clerical officials examined on memorials and reports—copies posted at the Duan Gate to sift emptiness and substance, observe unusual ability, and beautify custom. Those who do not accept the regulations and orders—correct them by penal law. If there are flourishing talent and unusual conduct, naturally age need not be restricted." The emperor followed it. Hu Guang, Guo Qian, and Shi Chang submitted a memorial refuting it, saying, "In general selection and recommendation follow talent, without restriction to fixed regulations. The six marvelous stratagems did not come from classical learning; the government of Zheng and A was not necessarily by formal memorial; Gan and Qi were prominently employed though their years fell short of strong service; Zhong and Jia raised their fame also in the weak-capping years. From former ages until now, the system of tribute recommendation has had none who turned and reformed it. Now on one minister's words to cut and violate old statutes, the benefit is not clear and the hearts of the multitude are not satisfied. To straighten the bent and change the constant is what government weighs heavily, yet without consulting the terrace offices or deliberating with ministers and nobles—if after the matter is sent down deliberators peel away in difference, to differ is for the court to lose its convenience, to agree is for the king's words already to have gone forth. Your servant foolishly thinks it can be proclaimed down to the hundred officials, have them compare agreement and difference, and then survey and choose the winning and losing, carefully gathering the inner meaning." The emperor did not follow it.
91
On xinmao day, for the first time it was ordered: "Commanderies and states recommending Filial and Incorrupt are limited to forty years of age and above; Students had to master chapter-and-verse commentary and clerical officials had to be able to draft memorials—only then could they qualify for selection. Those with outstanding talent and exceptional conduct, such as Yan Yuan and Ziqi, were not bound by age limits. After some time, Xu Shu, a filial and incorrupt candidate recommended by Guangling, was not yet forty. A bureau gentleman interrogated him. He replied, "The edict says, 'For those like Yan Hui and Ziqi, do not bind by age. Therefore my native commandery recommended me to fill the selection." The gentleman could not refute him. Zuo Xiong interrogated him, saying, "Formerly Yan Hui heard one thing and knew ten—how many things does the filial candidate hear one and know?" Shu had no reply and was dismissed. The commandery administrator was dismissed from office.
92
使
Yuan Hong commented: To plan affairs and establish institutions, to govern the age and instruct things, one must make them practicable. In antiquity one took office at forty—this did not mean one had to put on one's cap in exactly that year. It was held that the time when one could handle affairs was in one's prime strength, so they took this upper limit as the people's standard. Moreover Yan Yuan and Ziqi appear perhaps once in an age—yet to take them as the standard, would that not be skewed! Yet Xiong was upright and keen, able to distinguish truth from falsehood, and resolved to carry it out. Before long, Hu Guang went out as Administrator of Jiyin, and more than ten commandery administrators including him were all dismissed for mistaken recommendations; only Chen Fan of Runan, Li Ying of Yingchuan, Chen Qiu of Xiapi, and more than thirty others were appointed as Palace Gentlemen. From this the governors and administrators were fearful and did not dare recommend lightly. Down to the Yongjia era, examinations and selections were clear and fair, and mostly obtained the right men.
93
In the intercalary month, on gengzi day, the hundred-zhang gallery of Gong Mausoleum caught fire.
94
The Emperor heard that Lang Gu, Gentleman of Beihai, was expert in yin-yang studies.
95
便 西 使
In spring, in the first month, an edict ordered the imperial carriage office to summon Gu and question him on calamities and prodigies. Gu submitted a memorial, saying, "The Three Excellencies correspond to the terrace steps, distinct from the sovereign; when government loses the Way, cold yin reverses the seasons. Those now in office compete in resting on lofty emptiness, receive stipends heaped like bells, and lack care for all under heaven. They linger reclining, feign illness and indulge in ease; given an edict of appointment and granted money, they rise at once—how easily illness vanishes and recovery is swift! To eliminate calamities on this basis and bring rising peace—how can it be obtained! Now in selecting governors and administrators, entrustment lies with the three offices; when subordinate officials are bad, blame falls on province and commandery; when province and commandery err, how can blame not return on those who recommended them! Yet Your Majesty honors them ever more generously, while slackness below grows ever worse—this is what is called 'the great net is coarse, the small net is dense. The Three Excellencies are not your servant's enemies, and your servant is no madman's scribbling. The reason I forget food in indignation and plead unceasingly is truly that I believe the court wishes to attain peace and thriving. Your servant's writing does not choose words; I dare not resent death!" Thereupon he set forth seven expedient measures: "First, the park-mausoleum fire—consider the people's toil and halt repair labor. Second, after spring begins yin-cold loses the seasons—select and employ good ministers to aid sagely transformation. Third, this year is a lesser yang year—spring should bring drought and summer will surely bring flood—follow former canons and be frugal and restrained. Fourth, last year in the eighth month Mars entered and left Xuanyuan—release palace women and let them marry as they will. Fifth, last year in the intercalary tenth month white vapors from the western Tianyuan rushed toward the left foot of Shen and entered Yujing—fearing that after Beginning of Autumn Qiang raiders may rebel—announce to all commanderies in advance and strictly prepare defenses. Sixth, on the fourteenth of this month, yimao, a white rainbow pierced the sun—order central and external offices to examine affairs only after Beginning of Autumn. Seventh, since Han rose it has been three hundred thirty-nine years—in the Odes' three periods—greatly reduce statutes and make changes. The king follows Heaven, like proceeding from spring to summer, changing green garments for red. From Emperor Wen's reduction of punishments, nearly three hundred years have passed, yet light minor prohibitions have gradually piled up. The king's law is like the Yangtze and Yellow River—it should be easy to avoid and hard to violate."
96
西
In the second month, Gu again memorialized recommending Huang Qiong and Li Gu as fitting for special promotion. He also said, "From winter through spring there has been no good rain; west wind has come several times, reversing the seasons. The court labors in anxiety, widely prays, offers sacrifice to mountains and rivers, exposes the dragon image, and moves the market. Your servant has heard that August Heaven is moved by things, not by pretense; prodigies respond to men—the key lies in blaming oneself. If rain could be requested and flood averted, then years without plague would follow and great peace could be awaited. Yet calamities do not cease—the trouble lies not here." The memorial was submitted; he was specially appointed Palace Gentleman; he pleaded illness and did not take the post.
97
使
In the third month, Envoy Zhao Chou, Colonel of the Xiongnu, sent staff to lead Southern Xiongnu troops beyond the passes to strike the Xianbei and routed them.
98
宿
Initially when the Emperor was established, wet nurse Song E shared in the plotting. The Emperor enfeoffed E as Lady of Shanyang and also enfeoffed Liang Ji's son as Marquis of Xiangyi. Director of the Secretariat Zuo Xiong submitted a sealed memorial, saying, "The Founding Emperor's covenant: none but Liu to be king, none without merit to be marquis. Emperor An enfeoffed Jiang Jing, Wang Sheng, and others, and thus brought earthquake prodigies. In Yongjian year 2, enfeoffing those who had plotted in secret also brought solar eclipse prodigies. Men of numerology all attributed it to enfeoffment. Now Qingzhou is famine-struck and empty and bandits are not yet quelled—it is truly inappropriate to chase small favors and lose the great canon." The edict was not heeded. Xiong remonstrated again, saying, "Your servant has heard that rulers all love loyalty and straightness and hate slander and flattery, yet through the ages the trouble has always been that the loyal and straight are punished while slanderers and flatterers receive favor—probably because hearing loyalty is hard and following flattery is easy. Punishment and penalty are what people greatly loathe; noble favor is what people greatly desire—thus in the times those who act loyal are few and those who practice flattery are many. Therefore rulers often hear their own praise and rarely know their faults, wander without awakening, and reach ruin. Your servant has seen the edict, recalling the foster mother's old virtue and long-standing grace and wishing to add special conspicuous reward. Checking Secretariat precedents, there is no institution of rank and fief for wet nurses—only under the former emperor foster mother Wang Sheng was made Lady of Yewang. Sheng gave birth to slanderers and the calamity of deposition and establishment; alive she was reviled by all under heaven, dead she was rejoiced over within the seas. Jie and Zhou were exalted as Sons of Heaven, yet common servants were ashamed to be compared with them because they lacked righteousness; Bo Yi and Shu Qi were base as commoners, yet kings and marquises competed to join their company because they had virtue. Now the foster mother personally practices thrift and restraint and leads those below by her example; officials and the masses all turn toward her example. Yet to share rank and title with Wang Sheng—I fear she would violate her original conduct and lose her constant wish. Your servant foolishly holds that ordinary men's hearts, in principle, are not far apart; what unsettles them is the same in antiquity and today. The people deeply punish Wang Sheng's overturning calamity; the common folk's lives were precarious as piled eggs. They constantly fear the age will again produce such a case; thoughts of dread have not left their hearts and words of fear have not ceased from their mouths. I beg as in the former proposal: grant ten million yearly for the foster mother's support—inwardly enough to fulfill affection's joy, outwardly not strange to officials and people. Liang Ji's enfeoffment is not an urgent matter—it should wait until the period when prodigies are watched has passed, then calmly debate whether it is permissible." Thereupon Ji's father Shang yielded and returned Ji's fief; more than ten memorials were submitted before the Emperor consented.
99
In summer, in the fourth month, on jihai day, the capital had an earthquake. In the fifth month, on gengzi day, an edict ordered all dukes and ministers to speak plainly of their faults, and each also to recommend one plain and honest gentleman. Zuo Xiong again memorialized, saying, "The former emperor enfeoffed Lady of Yewang and Hanyang had an earthquake; now enfeofing Lady of Shanyang and the capital again quakes—exclusive government lies in yin, and the calamity is especially great. Your servant's successive blind words: enfeoffment is extremely weighty—the king may give a person private wealth, not office. The foster mother's fief should be returned to block prodigies. Now Ji has loftily yielded; Lady of Shanyang should also honor her original integrity." Xiong's words were sharp and thorough; E also feared and pleaded to yield. Yet the Emperor clung fondly and could not stop; in the end he enfeoffed her. At this time Grand Minister of Agriculture Liu Ju was reprimanded for official matters, summoned to the Secretariat, urged by criers to quicken his step, and also beaten and flogged. Xiong memorialized, saying, "The Nine Ministers rank next to the three duties and are classed among great ministers; in walking they have the ritual of jade pendants and in movement the ceremony of ranked precedence. Emperor Ming first had beating punishment—none of this is ancient canon." The Emperor accepted it; thereafter the Nine Ministers were no longer beaten and flogged.
100
On wuwu day, Minister of Works Wang Gong was dismissed. In the sixth month, on xinwei day, Director of Ceremonies Kong Fu of Lu was made Minister of Works.
101
使 使 退 使 祿 便 使 穿 退殿
On dingchou day, the ground split at Xuande pavilion in Luoyang, eighty-five zhang long; the Emperor summoned the plain and honest gentlemen recommended by dukes and ministers, had them answer policy questions, and specially asked about present-day ills and what government should do. Li Gu replied, saying, "Formerly Emperor An overturned old canons, enfeoffed the foster mother, thereby creating prodigies, and altered and confused the legitimate heir, until Your Majesty was in distress and personally met hardship. Having been raised from peril, you arose and took the throne; all under heaven murmured and looked to your governance. After accumulated ills, renewal is easy to bring—truly one should abundantly think on the good Way, yet debaters still say 'affairs today are again the same as before. Your servant lies low in grass and marsh, heart pained and breast wounded! Truly since Han rose more than three hundred years, worthy sages succeeding one another through eighteen rulers—was there no foster-mother affection? Was noble rank's favor forgotten? Yet they revered Heaven's majesty above, bowed to the classics below, knew righteousness forbade it, and therefore did not enfeoff. Now Foster Mother Song, though she has great merit and diligent, careful virtue—only add rewards and gifts, enough to repay her toil; as for splitting land and opening a state, it truly violates old canon. I hear the foster mother's nature is modest—she will surely yield. Your Majesty should permit her lofty refusal of a state and thereby secure the blessing of lasting peace. That consort and empress families rarely end whole—is it their nature that it must be so? Only because rank and position are exalted, they monopolize authority. Heaven's Way hates fullness—they do not know self-reduction, and therefore fall. The former emperor favored the Yan clan and advanced rank and title too swiftly—thus their receiving calamity did not wait a turn of the hour. Laozi says, 'What advances sharply retreats swiftly. Now the Liang clan as kin of the inner chamber are what ritual does not make subjects—honoring them with high rank can still be acceptable; yet sons, younger brothers, and the whole lineage together add glory and display—the precedents of Yongping and Jianchu scarcely went this far. It would be fitting to have Infantry Commandant Liang Ji and the various Palace Attendants return to their Yellow Gate offices, so that power leaves the maternal kin and government returns to the state—would that not be excellent! Moreover, edicts forbid sons of Palace Attendants, Directors of the Secretariat, and inner eunuchs from holding office or being nominated as Filial and Incorrupt because they wield authority and accept private requests. Yet the Regular Palace Attendants stand beside the throne; their voices and power shake all under heaven, and their sons and younger kin receive salaries and appointments without limit. Though outwardly they profess humility and do not meddle in the provinces, flatterers and frauds advance at the wind of their reputation. Now one may set a standing prohibition, applying the same rule to inner eunuchs. Formerly when Princess Guantao sought a Gentleman rank for her son, Emperor Ming refused but gave ten million cash—the reason he lavished gifts yet withheld office lightly was that placing the unworthy in office harms the people. I have heard that Commander of the Chang River Wu Xuan, Gatekeeper of Kaiyang Yang Di, and others, without other merit or virtue, upon first appointment received full regular salary—though a small lapse, it gradually ruins the old regulations. The laws and institutions of the former sages ought to be firmly held; once government and teaching stumble, a hundred years will not restore them. The Odes says, "High God is topsy-turvy, the lower people will utterly sicken"—criticizing the Zhou king for changing ancestral law and causing the people below to be nearly all ill. That Your Majesty has Directors of the Secretariat is like heaven having the Northern Dipper. The Dipper is heaven's throat and tongue; the Directors are also Your Majesty's throat and tongue. The Dipper measures out primordial qi and moves through the four seasons; Directors receive and issue the king's commands and assign government to the four seas. With exalted authority and heavy power, responsibility rests on them; if they do not balance their hearts, calamities must come—Your Majesty should carefully choose such men to assist sage government. Those who today share the realm with Your Majesty are outwardly the Excellencies and Directors, inwardly the Regular Attendants and Yellow Gate—as in one household within one gate; in peace they share fortune and blessing, in danger they share misfortune and ruin. Inspectors and the two-thousand-dan officials outwardly oversee official duties and inwardly receive law and norms. When the sundial's shadow is crooked the image must be slant; when the source is clear the stream must be pure—like knocking the tree's trunk, a hundred branches all move. From this it follows: can the court's orders and proclamations stumble! The cords and net of all under heaven are the urgent business of the present age. When a lord has government it is like water having dikes and embankments. When dikes are complete, though great rain and flood come, they cannot change it. Once government and teaching are established, though a bad year comes temporarily, it is not worth worry. Truly if the dike defenses are pierced and leaking, ten thousand men with united strength cannot rescue them; once government and teaching are ruined, the worthy and wise scatter in flight and cannot return. Now the dike defenses, though solid, gradually have holes and cracks. It is like one person's body—the court is the heart and belly, the provinces and commanderies are the four limbs; when heart and belly are in pain the four limbs do not lift. Thus what your servant worries about is disease of heart and belly, not ailment of the four limbs. If one firmly builds dikes, devotes effort to government and teaching, first secures heart and belly and puts the court in order, though bandits and flood or drought come, it is not worth minding; truly if dike defenses break and leak and heart and belly have disease, though there is no flood or drought disaster, the realm can still be cause for worry. Further one should dismiss and demote eunuchs and remove their heavy authority, limiting Regular Palace Attendants to two upright men of virtue handling affairs at left and right, and five Junior Yellow Gate men of talent, wisdom, and refined manner to serve in the hall. Thus disputants would be satisfied and stopped, and an age of ascending peace could be attained!"
102
Ma Rong, Merit Officer of Fufeng, replied, "Now statutes and grades and the four seasons' prohibitions—what receives heaven and accords with the people—is all provided and complete; nothing can be added. Yet heaven still shows imbalance, and the people still sigh in complaint—the common people often hear the sound of grace but do not see the substance of benefit and harmony. Those of antiquity who made the people sufficient did not make every household rich so every man was full—they measured resources and expenditure and made institutions for them. Thus if marriage rites were frugal, those marrying did so in season; if mourning rites were restrained, the dead were buried and concealed; if their seasons were not seized, farmers profited. Wife and children burden the heart and property and estates weigh the ambition—abandon this and do wrong and there cannot be many!"
103
使 便使 宿
Grand Clerk Zhang Heng of Nanyang replied, "Since the first raising of Filial and Incorrupt, two hundred years have passed—all first required filial conduct; when conduct had surplus strength, only then they studied literary law. The xinmao edict took ability at clause commentary and memorial drafting as the limit; though there was utmost filial piety, still they did not meet the category—this abandons root and takes branch. Zengzi excelled in filial piety but was truly dull in Lu; in literary studies he did not match You or Xia, in government affairs he did not match Ran or Ji. Now wishing one man to combine all—if outwardly there is something to view, inwardly there must be lacks—then it violates the intent of selecting Filial and Incorrupt. Moreover the commandery and state governors and chancellors, who split tallies and secure the border as great ministers of the state—once more than ten were dismissed at a stroke. Clerks and people were exhausted by seeing-off and receiving duties; new and old alternated and public and private affairs overflowed. Some who governed conveniently for the people were dismissed for small faults—that is seizing the people's parents and making them wail. The Changes says not distant from restoration, the Analects says not fearing to change—even friends in contact do not lodge overnight over faults. How much more the Son of Heaven, who receives heaven's principle and governs things and takes the realm as public! In the interval prodigious stars have appeared above and earthquakes and cracks below—heaven's warning is detailed and should make one feel cold at heart. The enlightened extinguish calamity before it sprouts. Now that it has been seen, to repair government in fear and dread—then calamity turns to blessing."
104
The Emperor reviewed the various replies and ranked Li Gu first. He immediately sent the foster mother back to her quarters; all Regular Palace Attendants kowtowed begging pardon, and the court was solemn. Li Gu was made Remonstrating Censor; yet the foster mother and eunuchs all hated him and fabricated anonymous memorials to trap him in guilt. The matter followed the palace attendant's secret channel downward. Grand Minister of Agriculture Huang Shang of Nan commandery and others pleaded on his behalf to Liang Shang, and Vice Director Huang Qiong again clarified the matter. Only after a long time was he released and sent out as Magistrate of Luo. Gu abandoned office and returned to Hanzhong. Rong was broadly versed in the classics and fine in literary composition; for his reply memorial he was also made Remonstrating Censor. Heng was skilled at literary composition and thoroughly mastered the Six Arts. Though his talent surpassed the age, he had no arrogant disposition; he was skilled in ingenious devices and especially applied thought to astronomy, yin-yang, and calendrical reckoning; he made the armillary sphere and wrote Ling Xian. His nature was tranquil and unassuming; he did not court the present age; whatever office he held, for years he was not transferred.
105
Grand Commandant Dou Chong, among the Three Excellencies most famed for loyalty and straightness, was repeatedly slandered by those at the Emperor's side. It happened that those he recommended went against the Emperor's intent; the Director of the Secretariat followed the wind and investigated him. At the time it was time to convene Outstanding Talents and Filial and Incorrupt. Chong, because he had been impeached, claimed illness and did not attend. Duan Gong, reporting clerk of Guanghan at the annual accounting, took advantage to memorialize, saying, "I see travelers on the road, farmers, and weaving women all say, 'Grand Commandant Dou Chong exhausts loyalty and utmost integrity, only because the straight way cannot bend his heart. He stands alone among the throng of evils and places himself where he will be injured. To use slanderous flatterers to injure and destroy the loyal and upright—this is the great prohibition of Heaven and Earth and the utmost warning for a lord! Formerly when Bai Qi was granted death, the feudal lords raised cups and toasted one another in congratulation; when Jizi returned, the men of Lu rejoiced that their difficulty was relieved. The state is governed by the worthy; the lord is secured by the loyal. Now all under heaven rejoice that Your Majesty has this loyal worthy. We wish you finally to favor and entrust him to secure the altars of state." The memorial was submitted. An edict immediately sent a Junior Yellow Gate to visit Chong's illness, and the imperial physician presented lamb and wine. Later when Chong's wife fell ill, he threw his former wife into a well and killed her; Magistrate of Luoyang Zhu Liang memorialized Chong's crime. In autumn, in the seventh month, on jiwei day, Chong was in the end dismissed because of prodigies and anomalies.
106
In the eighth month, on jisi day, Minister Herald Shi Yan was made Grand Commandant.
107
The Xianbei raided Ma Castle. The Administrator of Dai commandery struck them but did not overcome them. Before long their chanyu died. The Xianbei thereby raided and plundered somewhat less.”
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →