← Back to 資治通鑑

卷72 魏紀四

Volume 72 Wei Records 4

Chapter 72 of 資治通鑑 · Comprehensive Mirror in Aid of Governance
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 72
Next Chapter →
1
==
Wei Records 4
2
Spanning from the year Zhongguang Dayuanxian through Yanfeng Shetige—a period of four years.
3
Emperor Ming the Illustrious Ancestor, Part Two (beginning)
4
1使 使
1. In spring, during the second month, Sun Quan lent Grand Master of Ceremonies Pan Jun his staff of authority and ordered him, together with Lü Dai, to lead fifty thousand troops against the Five Streams tribes. Jun's maternal cousin Jiang Wan served as Zhuge Liang's chief clerk. The administrator of Wuling, Wei Zheng, reported that Jun had sent secret messengers to contact Wan, evidently hoping to place himself under Shu's protection. Sun Quan said, "Chengming would never do such a thing." He at once sealed up Zheng's memorial and showed it to Jun, then recalled Zheng and removed him from office.
5
2
2. Wei Wen and Zhuge Zhi had been at sea for a year, and eight or nine soldiers in ten succumbed to disease. Danzhou proved too distant to reach; in the end they returned with several thousand captives from Yizhou. Wen and Zhi were condemned for their failure and put to death.
6
3 西
3. Zhuge Liang, chancellor of Han, appointed Li Yan Central Supervisor of the Army to administer headquarters affairs. Yan changed his personal name to Ping. Liang led his forces north, laid siege to Qishan, and supplied them with his wooden-ox transport. Grand Marshal Cao Zhen had fallen ill, so the emperor ordered Sima Yi to take up position at Chang'an and direct Generals Zhang He, Fei Yao, Dai Ling, Guo Huai, and others against the invasion.
7
4
4. In the third month, Cao Zhen, Marquis Yuan of Shaoling, died.
8
5
5. No rain had fallen since the tenth month, and the drought continued into this month.
9
6使西
6. Sima Yi left Fei Yao and Dai Ling with four thousand elite troops to hold Shanggui and marched west with the rest of his force to relieve Qishan. Zhang He wanted to detach troops to garrison Yong and Mei. Yi replied, "If you believe the vanguard can hold on its own, General, you are right. But if they cannot hold and you divide into front and rear, you will repeat how the three armies of Chu were taken by Qing Bu." He pressed forward. Liang detached troops to continue the siege of Qishan and marched in person to confront Yi at Shanggui. Guo Huai, Fei Yao, and others tried to intercept Liang, but he routed them and then reaped the wheat fields in force before meeting Yi east of Shanggui. Yi drew up his army on difficult ground so that neither side could close; Liang then withdrew.
10
使 使
Yi pursued Liang as far as Lucheng. Zhang He said, "They marched far to meet us and could not get us to fight; they will conclude we do not want battle and mean to wear them down over time. Besides, once Qishan learns the main army is near, its defenders will take heart. We should halt here, send a flanking force to threaten their rear, and not march up only to hang back—that would forfeit the army's confidence. Liang is isolated and short of food; he will withdraw before long." Yi refused and kept following Liang. On arrival they again took the high ground and dug in, still refusing to fight. Jia Xu and Wei Ping pressed repeatedly for battle, saying, "You fear Shu as though it were a tiger—what will you say when the world mocks you?" Yi was deeply annoyed. Every general clamored for battle. In summer, the fifth month, on the day Xinsi, Yi sent Zhang He against Supervisor of the Unconquered He Ping at the southern camp and marched on Liang himself along the central route. Liang sent Wei Yan, Gao Xiang, and Wu Ban to meet the attack; the Wei forces were routed, and the Han army captured three thousand suits of armor. Yi fell back to his camp.
11
退 ( ) )
In the sixth month, Liang withdrew for lack of supplies; Sima Yi sent Zhang He in pursuit. [He said, "Military law requires that a besieged city be left an escape route and that a retreating army not be pursued." Yi would not hear of it. .1 He pressed on to Mumen and fought Liang; [the Han] ( Shu) Shu)2 troops took the heights and set an ambush. Here Sima Guang did not change "Shu" to "Han" but altered the text directly. ; crossbows loosed in a storm, and a stray arrow struck He's right knee and killed him.
12
7
7. In autumn, the seventh month, on the day Yiyou, the prince Yin was born and a general amnesty was declared.
13
8 退使 鹿 使
8. Since the Huangchu era, the laws governing feudal princes had grown harsh. , until even close kin dared not visit one another.3 Cao Zhi, Prince of Dong'e, submitted a memorial: "Yao taught that one should honor kin before strangers, the near before the far. King Wen of Zhou began by disciplining himself before his humble wife, extended that example to his brothers, and so governed both family and realm. I humbly consider that Your Majesty possesses the reverent brilliance of Yao and Shun, embodies King Wen's cautious benevolence, extends grace to the inner palace, and makes kindness shine upon the nine degrees of kin. The feudal lords and hundred officials rotate in attendance without neglecting public business, while private feelings may still be shown at home—family ties are open, congratulations and condolences may be exchanged. This truly may be called governing others by forgiving oneself and spreading favor and grace. As for me, the bonds of human society are severed; I am confined in this enlightened age, and I grieve in secret. I dare not even hope to mingle with kindred spirits, cultivate human affairs, or put human relations in order. Of late even marriage ties are severed, brothers are estranged, inquiries after good or ill fortune are blocked, and the rites of congratulation and condolence have lapsed. The breach of bonds of grace is worse than with strangers on the road; the estrangement of separation is more extreme than between Hu and Yue. Under these blanket restrictions I have forever lost hope of audience at court; yet my heart is fixed on the throne and my feelings bound to the palace gates—the divine powers know this. Yet Heaven truly ordained this—what can one say! Reflecting in retirement, I know the princes often harbor anxious, earnest hearts. I pray Your Majesty will issue a sweeping edict so that the feudal states may exchange congratulations and inquiries, the four seasons may be observed, kinship's joyful grace may be renewed, and cordial, steadfast righteousness made whole. The households of consorts and concubines might receive gifts of toilet goods twice a year, equal in propriety to the noble clans and equal in grace to the hundred offices. Then what the ancients sighed over and what the Songs and Odes celebrate would live again in this sage age! I humbly reflect upon myself and find no use even for the point of a knife; yet observing those Your Majesty promotes and appoints, if I were treated as one of another surname, I venture to judge that I would not rank behind court officials. If I could leave distant exile, wear the military cap, lay aside the crimson sash, wear the blue ribbon, serve as Master of the Sidecar or Bearer of the Carriage, obtain some modest title, dwell securely in the capital, hold the whip and wear the writing tablet, go out following the ornate canopy and enter to attend the imperial carriage, answer Your questions and gather what others omit at Your side—that would be the utmost wish of my loyal heart, never absent from my dreams. From afar I admire the lord-and-minister feast of "Deer Cry"; within I chant the admonition of "Cherry-apple" that kin are not other; I do not think of the friendship of "Felling Trees"; I end by cherishing the boundless grief of "Smartweed-Eulalia." At each gathering of the four seasons I sit alone in isolation; at my side are only servants, my only companions my wife and children; there is no one with whom to unfold lofty discourse or refine meaning. Never have I heard music without striking my breast, or faced a cup without sighing. I humbly consider that the sincerity of dog and horse cannot move others, just as human sincerity cannot move Heaven; collapsing walls and falling frost—I once believed these, but measured against my heart they are empty words! Like sunflower and bean tendril turning their leaves to the sun—though they do not make it turn back its light, yet their turning is sincere. I compare myself in secret to sunflower and bean tendril; if there is one who bestows Heaven and Earth's grace and lets the three luminaries shine down, it is truly Your Majesty. I have heard in the Wenzi: "Do not be the first to bring fortune, do not be the first to bring calamity." The present estrangement grieves brothers alike, yet I alone speak out—not because I wish anything in this sage age to go unblessed, but because I desire Your Majesty to exalt the radiance of an age of harmony and proclaim the bright, illustrious virtue of glorious peace!" An edict in reply said, "Teaching and transformation each have their rise and decline; not all begin well and end badly—circumstances make it so. Brotherly feeling and ritual among the feudal states have grown slack, and gifts to consorts' households sparse—there was never an edict forbidding the states to exchange visits. Correcting the bent went too far; lower officials feared punishment, and matters came to this. I have already instructed the relevant offices according to what the prince pleaded."
14
使 歿 便 使
Zhi submitted another memorial: "When Emperor Wen of Han set out from Dai he suspected turmoil in the capital; Song Chang said, "Within are the kin of Zhuxu and Dongmou; without are Qi, Chu, Huainan, and Langye—these are bedrock clans; I pray Your Highness do not doubt. I humbly consider that Your Majesty looks far to King Wen of Zhou's support from the two Guo states, reflects on King Cheng of Zhou's assistance from the Duke of Shao and the Duke of Bi, and preserves below Song Chang's bedrock solidity. I have heard that a sheep in tiger's skin delights at the sight of grass but trembles at the sight of jackals, forgetting that its skin is tiger's. Now if the generals appointed are unfit, it is somewhat like this. Hence the saying: "The one who suffers the trouble does not understand it; the one who understands it cannot act." Formerly Guan and Cai were executed for rebellion, and the Duke of Zhou and the Duke of Shao served as assistants; Shuyu fell into punishment, yet Shuxiang aided the state. The offense of the Three Overseers—I should bear it myself; assistants like those of the Two Souths—sought, they cannot be far. Among the splendid clans, noble houses, and feudal princes there must be one fit for this role. What makes the world incline its ears and fix its eyes is whoever holds power. Thus counsel can sway the ruler and authority can awe subordinates. When powerful magnates hold government, kinship counts for nothing; where power lies, even the distant grow weighty; where influence departs, even kin are slighted. Those who seized Qi were the Tian clan, not the house of Lü; those who divided Jin were Zhao and Wei, not of the house of Ji. May Your Majesty examine this. If fortune attends those who monopolize their posts and disaster those who leave them, these are ministers of another surname. Those who desire the state's peace, pray for the clan's honor, share glory in life and share calamity in death—these are ministers of the imperial clan. Now the imperial clan is kept distant while those of other surnames are drawn near—I am privately perplexed. Now your servant and Your Majesty tread ice and walk on coals, climb mountains and ford streams, share cold and heat, dryness and damp, high and low—how could I leave Your Majesty! Unable to bear my indignation, I bow and present this memorial stating my feelings. If anything does not accord, I beg that it be stored for now in the archive and not lightly destroyed; after my death the matter may yet be pondered. If the slightest thing offends Your mind, I beg it be brought forth in court so that masters versed in antiquity may correct what in my memorial does not accord with right principle—then my wish would be fulfilled." The emperor only replied with soothing words and nothing more.
15
使
In the eighth month an edict said, "The late emperor issued an order that he did not wish princes to remain in the capital because, when a young ruler holds the throne and the empress dowager regents, guarding against trouble from the small and gradual bears on rise and decline. I reflect that I have not seen the princes for twelve years—how can my distant longing fail to stir my thoughts! Let the princes and the imperial clan's dukes and marquises each bring one legitimate son to court in the first month of next year; hereafter, when there is a young ruler and an empress dowager regent in the palace, follow the late emperor's order as before."
16
9 退 退便 退
9. When Zhuge Liang attacked Qishan, Li Ping remained behind and supervised transport. Heavy rains set in; Ping feared supplies could not keep up and sent Staff Officer Gu Zhong and Transport Supervisor Cheng Fan with instructions summoning Liang to return; Liang accepted this and withdrew the army. When Ping heard the army had withdrawn, he then openly feigned surprise, saying, "Army grain is abundant—why withdraw so soon!" He also wished to kill Transport Supervisor Cen Shu to absolve himself of failure in his duties. He also memorialized the Han ruler, saying, "The army feigned retreat to lure the enemy into battle." Liang produced in full his earlier and later handwritten letters and memorials, which contradicted each other from beginning to end. Ping's words were exhausted and his feelings spent; he bowed his head and acknowledged guilt. Thereupon Liang memorialized Ping's offenses past and present; he was dismissed from office, stripped of rank and fief, and moved to Zitong commandery. Liang again appointed Ping's son Feng as General of the Gentlemen of the Household and Staff Officer, issuing an instruction to him saying, "Your father and I joined forces to aid the Han house; I memorialized him as Area Commander-in-Chief governing Hanzhong and entrusted you at the eastern passes, thinking your utmost sincerity would hold from start to finish—who expected such a breach midway! If the Area Commander-in-Chief reflects on his betrayal, you and Fei Yi should deal with him in open sincerity—what is severed may be joined again, what has departed may return. Ponder this admonition carefully and understand my intent!"
17
使
Liang also wrote to Jiang Wan and Dong Yun: "Xiaoqi once told me that Li Yan has scales in his belly and that neighbors consider him unapproachable. I thought 'scales' meant only that one should not provoke him—who expected Su and Zhang tactics to emerge unexpectedly? You may let Xiaoqi know." Xiaoqi was Commandant of the Guards Chen Zhen of Nanyang.
18
10使 滿
10. In winter, the tenth month, Sun Quan sent General of the Gentlemen of the Household Sun Bu to feign surrender and lure Yang Province Inspector Wang Ling; Sun Quan stationed ambush troops at Fuling to await him. Bu sent someone to tell Ling, "The road is long and I cannot come in person; I beg troops to meet and welcome me." Ling forwarded Bu's letter and requested troops and horses to welcome him. Eastern Campaigning General Man Chong thought it must be a ruse and would not give troops, but wrote a reply for Ling saying, "Knowing right from wrong, wishing to flee calamity and follow what is fitting, leaving violence and returning to the Way—this is greatly to be praised. Now I wish to send troops to welcome you, yet if the force is small it will not suffice to protect you; if large, the affair will surely be heard far and wide. First make secret plans to accomplish your intent, then adjust measures as circumstances require." It happened that Chong was summoned to court by imperial letter; he ordered the chief clerk left at headquarters, "If Ling wishes to go welcome him, do not give troops." Later Ling requested troops but could not obtain them; he then sent alone one supervising general with seven hundred infantry and cavalry to welcome Bu. Bu raided by night; the supervising general fled in disorder, and more than half were killed or wounded. Ling was the son of Yun's elder brother.
19
Earlier Ling had memorialized that Chong was advanced in years and addicted to wine, unfit to hold a regional post. The emperor was about to summon Chong; Attendant Within the Yellow Gates Guo Mou said, "Chong served as Administrator of Runan and Inspector of Yuzhou for more than twenty years, with merit in the regions; when he garrisoned Huainan, the Wu people feared him. If he is not as the memorial states, he will be spied upon; he may be ordered back to court and questioned on eastern affairs to observe him." The emperor followed this. When he arrived, his constitution was robust and healthy; the emperor comforted him and sent him back.
20
11
11. In the eleventh month, on the last day of the cycle Wuxu, there was a solar eclipse.
21
12
12. In the twelfth month, on the day Wuwu, Hua Xin, Marquis Jing of Boping, died.
22
13
13. On the day Dingmao, Wu proclaimed a general amnesty and changed next year's era name to Jiahe.
23
1
1. In spring, the first month, Sun Quan's youngest son, Marquis of Jianchang Lü, died. Crown Prince Deng came from Wuchang to visit Sun Quan and confessed that long absence from regular attendance had left a gap in filial duty; he also stated that Lu Xun was loyal and diligent, leaving nothing to worry about. He then remained at Jianye.
24
2
2. In the second month, an edict changed the enfeoffments of feudal princes so that each took a commandery as his state.
25
3 便殿 西 使
3. The emperor's beloved daughter Shu died; the emperor grieved deeply, posthumously titled her Princess Yi of Pingyuan, erected a temple in Luoyang, and buried her at Nanling. He took Empress Zhen's collateral descendant Huang to be buried with her, posthumously enfeoffed Huang as a ranked marquis, established an heir for him, and had the title inherited. The emperor wished to attend the funeral in person and also wished to visit Xu. Minister of Works Chen Qun remonstrated: "Burial rites for a child who dies before eight are not provided for in ritual; moreover, not yet a full month old, yet you send her off with adult rites, add mourning garments, have the whole court in white, and mourn morning and evening—since antiquity there has been nothing like this. Yet you would again go in person to view the tomb and attend the sending-off rites! I pray Your Majesty restrain what is useless and harmful—this is the utmost hope of the realm. I also hear the imperial carriage wishes to visit Xuchang, and both palaces above and below would all move east together—the whole court great and small is startled and amazed. Some say you wish to avoid ill fortune, some say to facilitate moving palace quarters, some do not know the reason. I consider that fortune and misfortune have their mandate, calamity and blessing depend on people—moving about to seek safety is likewise of no use. If you must move to avoid harm, repairing the western palace at Jinyong and the separate palace at Mengjin could both serve as temporary halts—why expose the whole palace in the open countryside! Public and private trouble and expense cannot be calculated. Moreover, even worthy gentlemen do not lightly move their households, so as to settle their villages and leave no heart of fear—how much more the emperor, lord of ten thousand states: his comings and goings, his movements and stillness—how can they be lightly cast aside!" Minister Steward Yang Fu said, "When Emperor Wen and Empress Wuxuan died, Your Majesty did not attend the burials, thereby honoring the altars of soil and grain and guarding against the unforeseen; how could you go so far as to send off a suckling infant in burial!" The emperor would not listen to any of this. In the third month, on the day Guiyou, he made an eastern tour.
26
4
4. Sun Quan sent General Zhou He and Commandant Pei Qian by sea to Liaodong to request horses from Gongsun Yuan.
27
使
Earlier, Yu Fan's nature was blunt and upright; he often erred through drink and also liked to offend people, and was much slandered. Sun Quan once discussed immortals with Zhang Zhao; Fan pointed at Zhao and said, "Those are dead men speaking of immortals—are there immortals in the world!" Sun Quan's accumulated anger was not slight; he then moved Fan to Jiaozhou. When Zhou He and others went to Liaodong, Fan heard of it and thought the Five Streams should be attacked; Liaodong is utterly remote—even if they came to submit it would hardly be worth taking; now to send men and wealth for horses is neither national profit nor, I fear, likely to succeed. He wished to remonstrate but dared not; he drafted a memorial and showed it to Lü Dai, who did not reply. Reported by those who loved or hated him, he was again moved to Mengling in Cangwu.
28
5
5. In summer, the fourth month, on the day Renyin, the emperor went to Xuchang.
29
1
1. In the fifth month, the prince Yin died.
30
7
7. In autumn, the seventh month, Commandant of the Guards Dong Zhao was made Minister of Education.
31
8殿
8. In the ninth month, the emperor went to Mobei, repaired the palace at Xuchang, and erected the Jingfu and Chengguang halls.
32
9 使 使 使便
9. Gongsun Yuan secretly harbored disloyal intent and repeatedly communicated with Wu. The emperor sent Administrator of Runan Tian Yu to supervise Qing Province armies by the sea route and Inspector of You Wang Xiong by the land route to attack him. Regular Attendant Jiang Ji remonstrated: "Generally, states that are not devouring each other and subjects who do not invade or rebel should not be lightly attacked. To attack and fail to control them is to drive them to become bandits. Hence the saying: "When tigers and wolves block the road, do not bother with foxes." Remove the great harm first, and lesser harms will resolve themselves. Now the lands beyond the sea have for generations submitted allegiance, yearly selecting candidates for the provincial and filial-piety examinations, never failing in tribute—those who discuss policy put them first. Even if one stroke conquered them, gaining their people would not enrich the state, gaining their wealth would not make it rich; if things do not go as wished, this is to forge enmity and break faith." The emperor would not listen. Yu and the others went but all achieved nothing; an edict ordered the armies withdrawn.
33
使
Yu thought the Wu envoys Zhou He and others were about to return; late in the year winds are fierce and they would surely fear being driven by waves—the eastern route has no harbors and they would head for Chengshan; Chengshan has no place to hide ships, so he promptly stationed troops to hold Chengshan. He and the others returned to Chengshan, met wind, and Yu led troops to attack He and the others and beheaded them. Sun Quan heard of this and first reflected on Yu Fan's words; he then summoned Fan from Jiaozhou. It happened that Fan had already died; his coffin was brought back.
34
10
10. In the eleventh month, on the day Gengyin, Cao Zhi, Prince of Chen Si, died.
35
11
11. In the twelfth month, the emperor returned to the palace at Xuchang.
36
12
12. Palace Attendant Liu Ye was personally favored and esteemed by the emperor. The emperor was about to attack Shu; court officials within and without all said it could not be done. When Ye entered to discuss with the emperor, he said it could be attacked; when he went out and spoke to court officials, he said it could not. Ye had courage and wisdom; what he said always took concrete form. Central Army Commander Yang Ji was the emperor's intimate minister and also esteemed Ye; he held most firmly to the view that attack was impossible, and whenever he came out from within he would pass by Ye, and Ye would explain why it could not be done. Later Ji discussed attacking Shu with the emperor; Ji remonstrated urgently. The emperor said, "You are a bookish man—how would you know military affairs!" Ji apologized: "My words truly are not worth adopting; Palace Attendant Liu Ye, the late emperor's strategist, always said Shu could not be attacked." The emperor said, "Ye told me Shu could be attacked." Ji said, "Ye may be summoned to verify this." An edict summoned Ye; when the emperor questioned Ye, he said nothing in the end. Later, seeing him alone, Ye reproached the emperor: "Attacking a state is a great plan; having been allowed to hear a great plan, I constantly fear dozing or dreaming and leaking it to increase my guilt—how dare I speak of it to others! Warfare is the way of deception; before military affairs are launched, one cannot have too much secrecy. Your Majesty has openly exposed it—I fear the enemy state has already heard." The emperor then apologized to him. After Liu Ye left the audience, he rebuked Yang Ji: "When a fisherman hooks a large fish, he lets it run and follows it; only when he can control it does he haul it in—and then nothing gets away. A ruler's authority is no mere fish on the line! You are a loyal, forthright minister—but your scheme was not worth taking. You must think these matters through more carefully." Yang Ji apologized as well.
37
Someone told the emperor, "Liu Ye is not wholly loyal. He is adept at reading where Your Majesty's mind is tending and shaping his answers to match it. Your Majesty might test him by speaking with Liu Ye and asking the opposite of what you mean. If he always answers contrary to the question, that proves he habitually aligns with the imperial will. But if every question draws the same answer, Liu Ye's true disposition will have nowhere left to hide." The emperor tested him as advised, uncovered his true character, and from that time kept him at arm's length. Liu Ye soon went mad, was transferred out as Grand Herald of the Hong, and died of distress.
38
::
Fu Zi says: "Clever deceit cannot match plain sincerity—how true!" Given Liu Ye's intelligence and shrewd calculation, had he grounded himself in virtue and righteousness and acted in loyalty and good faith, what could the greatest sages of old have added to him! He relied on talent alone and did not cultivate sincere integrity. Within he lost the ruler's trust; without he was hemmed in by public opinion—and in the end endangered himself. Is that not a pity!
39
13
13. Liu Ye once accused Director of the Masters of Writing Chen Qiao of monopolizing power. Qiao was alarmed and told his son Qian. Qian said, "The sovereign is enlightened and sagacious, and you are a great minister. If you are out of favor for the moment, at worst you will simply not be enfeoffed as a duke." A few days later, the emperor's suspicions did indeed lift.
40
使 祿 使 使使 使 使退 使 使 使 使
Masters of Writing Attendant Lian Zhao of Le'an had won favor through ability. Zhao liked to ferret out petty faults among the ministers to ingratiate himself with the throne. Yellow Gate Attendant Du Shu submitted a memorial, saying, "I have observed that Lian Zhao impeached Left Assistant Director Cao Fan because punishment at the barrier gate was not carried out according to the edict, and he sits in judgment over the matter. He also wrote, 'All who merit punishment are to be reported separately.' Director Chen Qiao submitted on his own account that he dared not refuse punishment, yet dared not plead his case—his intent earnest and sincere. I cannot help grieving for the court over this! The reason emperors and kings of old could sustain the age and nurture the people was that none failed to win the people's hearts from afar and to draw fully on their ministers' intelligence close at hand. Today Your Majesty labors over ten thousand matters of state, sometimes even tending the lamps yourself, yet public affairs are not well ordered and law and discipline grow slack by the day. The root cause lies not only in ministers failing to give their full loyalty, but also in the ruler's inability to make use of them. Baili Xi seemed dull in Yu yet proved wise in Qin; Yu Rang bore humiliation under Zhonghang yet showed his integrity toward Zhi Bo—the ancients left clear proof of this. If Your Majesty believes that our age has no true talent and the court lacks worthy helpers, can you really look back to the distant footsteps of Hou Ji and Qi, and sit idle waiting for heroes of some future generation! Those now called worthy all hold high rank and draw heavy salaries—yet the discipline of serving the throne is not established, and hearts are not single-mindedly turned toward the public good, because delegated responsibility is not exclusive and because custom is thick with taboos. I believe loyal ministers need not be favorites, and favorite ministers need not be loyal. Today, when a memorial writer denounces someone, Your Majesty suspects private vengeance against an enemy; when one praises someone, Your Majesty suspects private favor toward a friend. Attendants at your side may then use this to feed talk of hatred and affection, until critics and praisers alike fall silent—and even the benefit or harm of policy comes under suspicion. Your Majesty should consider how to open the hearts of the court and earnestly foster the integrity of those who follow the Way, so that they may match the ancients of their own accord and leave their names in the histories—yet instead you allow men like Lian Zhao to sow disorder among them. I fear that senior ministers will then merely secure their persons and their posts, sitting by to watch what succeeds and what fails, and that this will stand as a warning to ages yet to come. Long ago the Duke of Zhou warned the Lord of Lu, saying, "Do not let great ministers resent that they are not put to use." The point is this: if a man is unworthy he should not be made a great minister; if he is made a great minister he must not be left unused. The Documents recount Shun's achievements and praise the banishment of the Four Evils—it does not say that whenever there is guilt, great or small alike, the guilty are removed. Today the court ministers do not think themselves incapable—they think Your Majesty will not employ them; they do not think themselves ignorant—they think Your Majesty does not ask. Why does Your Majesty not follow how the Duke of Zhou employed men and how great Shun removed the unfit—so that Palace Attendants and Directors of the Masters of Writing, when seated, attend within the curtains, and when you travel, follow the imperial carriage; face your questions in person, each stating what he knows—then the conduct of every minister can be known, the able advanced and the incompetent dismissed, and who would dare hang back and not give his utmost? With Your Majesty's sagely brilliance, debating policy with the ministers in person and letting each give his utmost—whether a man is worthy or foolish, able or not, all depends on whom Your Majesty puts to use. Governing in this way, what affair would not be settled; achieving merit in this way, what achievement would not be won! Whenever there is military business, edicts often say, "Who should worry over this?" I myself shall worry over it." A recent edict also said, "Those who forget self for the sake of the public surely do not exist; only put the public first and the private after, and you will manage it yourself." Reading these enlightened edicts with reverence, I know Your Majesty's mind reaches down to the feelings of those below—yet I also wonder that Your Majesty does not treat the root of the matter but troubles over the branches. Whether men are capable truly lies in their nature; even I think the court ministers do not all fill their posts. When an enlightened ruler employs men, he makes the able unable to withhold their strength, and the incapable men from holding posts beyond their capacity. To recommend someone unfit is not necessarily a crime; for the whole court together to tolerate someone unfit—that is what is truly strange. Your Majesty knows they do not exert themselves yet worries over their duties in their stead; knows they are incapable yet instructs them in how to govern their affairs—is this merely the ruler laboring while ministers take their ease? Even if sage and worthy lived in the same age, in the end the realm could not be governed this way! Your Majesty also worries that the terrace offices' prohibitions are not strict, that requests and patronage in appointments never cease, and has instituted rules for guests entering and leaving, with corrupt clerks guarding the gates—this truly has not yet struck at the root of the problem. In the reign of Emperor An of Han, Junior Steward Dou Jia recruited the nephew of Commandant of Justice Guo Gong, though he was guiltless, yet still was impeached, memorials of accusation flying thick; recently Director of Retainers Kong Xian recruited the younger brother of the Grand General, who was violent and rebellious, yet the responsible officials were silent, watching the wind and hoping to hit the mark—worse than taking patronage outright. This is recommendation not grounded in fact. Jia had the favor of kinship; Gong was not a pillar minister of state—and still it was so; judging the present by antiquity, Your Majesty yourself has not enforced punishments that must be carried out, to cut off the source of cliques. Rules for comings and goings, and corrupt clerks at the gates, are not the instruments of a well-governed age. If my words receive even a little of Your Majesty's scrutiny and acceptance, what worry is there that treachery will not be cut down—or that you would continue to nurture men like Lian Zhao! To expose and impeach treachery and villainy is a loyal act; yet the age hates petty men who do it, because they disregard principle and recklessly seek favor and advancement. If Your Majesty no longer examines how such conduct begins and ends, and must take opposing the multitude and going against the world as serving the public, and secret denunciation as exhausting loyalty—are there men of broad talent and great ability who could not do this? They simply heed principle—and refuse. To make all under Heaven turn their backs on the Way and rush toward profit is what a ruler dreads most—what pleasure can Your Majesty take in that!" Du Shu was the son of Du Ji.
41
退
The emperor once arrived unannounced at the gate of the Masters of Writing. Chen Qiao knelt and asked, "Your Majesty, where are you going?" The emperor said, "I only wish to look over the documents in transit." Qiao said, "That is my duty as a minister—not something Your Majesty should attend to in person. If I am not equal to my post, then dismiss me—but Your Majesty should go back." The emperor was ashamed, turned his carriage, and withdrew. The emperor once asked Qiao, "The Lord Marshal is loyal and steadfast—can he be called a pillar of state?" Qiao said, "He is the court's hope; whether he is a pillar of state remains to be seen."
42
14 滿
14. In Wu, Lu Xun led troops toward Lujiang; opinion held that relief should be sent swiftly. Man Chong said, "Lujiang is small, but its commanders are strong and its troops elite. If it is held, the enemy will pass by. Moreover, the enemy abandoned their boats two hundred li away; their rear is empty and cut off. Even if they did not come, we would still wish to lure them in. Now we should let them advance as they will. I only fear they may flee before we can catch them." He thereupon arrayed his army and hastened to Yangyikou. When the Wu forces heard of it, they fled by night.
43
滿 西便
At this time the Wu forces every year planned raids. Man Chong submitted a memorial, saying, "Hefei lies south against rivers and lakes, and north is far from Shouchun. When rebels attack and besiege it, they can use the water to their advantage; when government troops go to relieve it, they must first break the enemy's main force before the siege can be lifted. The enemy can advance easily, yet relief troops advance with great difficulty. The troops within the city should be moved thirty li west, where there is excellent terrain to rely on, and a new city built to hold fast—this lures the enemy onto level ground and cuts their line of retreat. For strategy it is the better course." Protector-General Jiang Ji argued that "this would already show weakness to all under Heaven, and we would be watching the enemy's signal fires while tearing down our own walls—this is abandoning a city before it is even attacked; once matters reach that point, plunder will know no limit, and we will surely be reduced to defending only north of the Huai." The emperor did not approve. Chong submitted another memorial, saying, "Master Sun said, 'Warfare is the way of deception; therefore be able yet show unable; entice with profit, display with awe'—meaning appearance and reality need not match. He also said, 'One who skillfully moves the enemy gives him form.' Now the enemy has not arrived, yet we move the city and withdraw inward—this is precisely what is called giving form to lure them. Draw the enemy away from the water, choose the moment of advantage and strike, win everything abroad, and blessing will arise at home!" Director of the Masters of Writing Zhao Zi judged Chong's plan superior, and an edict approved it.
44
1
[End editorial note.] The emperor went to Mobei to see the dragon and changed the era name.4
45
2宿 使 忿
2. Gongsun Yuan sent Commandant Su Shu and Master of Ceremonies Sun Zong to submit a memorial declaring himself a subject of Wu; the King of Wu was greatly pleased and proclaimed a general amnesty. In the third month, the King of Wu sent Grand Master of Ceremonies Zhang Mi, Bearer of the Mace Xu Yan, and General He Da to lead ten thousand men with gold, treasures, precious goods, and the full regalia of the Nine Bestowals across the sea to invest Yuan as King of Yan. The court ministers from Gu Yong down all remonstrated, saying, "Yuan cannot yet be trusted, and the favor shown him is too great. It is enough to send officials and troops to escort Shu and Zong home." The King of Wu would not listen. Zhang Zhao said, "Yuan turned against Wei in fear of punishment and came from afar seeking aid—this was not his original intent. If Yuan changes his plan and wishes to show his loyalty to Wei, and both envoys fail to return, will we not become a laughingstock to all under Heaven!" The King of Wu argued back and forth with Zhao; Zhao's remonstrance grew all the more urgent. The King of Wu could not endure it. He seized his knife and said angrily, "Wu gentlemen enter the palace and bow to me, leave the palace and bow to you—my respect for you has reached the utmost, yet you repeatedly shame me before the multitude. I constantly fear I may lose my temper!" Zhang Zhao fixed his gaze on the King of Wu and said, "Though I know my words go unheeded, each time I exhaust my foolish loyalty—it is because when the empress dowager lay dying she called this old minister to her bedside, and her testamentary charge still rings in my ears." Tears then streamed down his face. The King of Wu cast his knife aside and wept with him face to face. Yet in the end he still sent Zhang Mi and Xu Yan on their mission. Zhang Zhao, furious that his advice went unheeded, claimed illness and stopped attending court. The King of Wu, in resentment, had earth piled against his gate; Zhang Zhao in turn walled himself in with earth from inside.
46
3
3. In summer, the fifth month, on day Wuyin, Prince Rui of Beihai died.
47
4
4. In the intercalary month, on the first day Gengyin of the cycle, a solar eclipse occurred.
48
5
5. In the sixth month, the ball-court chamber in the Luoyang palace burned.
49
6 ( ) )
6. The Xianbei chieftain Kebineng drew the frontier-guarding Xianbei Budugen into a close marriage alliance and personally led ten thousand horsemen north of the Xing Pass to receive Budugen's kin and baggage train. Bing ( Jing) Jing)5 Editorial note: In the phrase "the inspector memorialized to march out at once," Sima Guang's text used one province name; this is emended according to Zhang's commentary and the Annals of Emperor Ming in the History of Wei. [End editorial note.] He would threaten Kebineng from without and keep Budugen in check within. The Emperor reviewed the memorial and said, "Budugen has already been won over by Kebineng and is liable to turn suspicious on his own. Now that Bi Gui takes the field, take care not to cross the frontier passes beyond Juzhu." By the time the edict arrived, Bi Gui had already advanced and encamped at Yinguan, dispatching Generals Su Shang and Dong Bi to pursue the Xianbei. Kebineng sent his son with over a thousand riders to welcome Budugen's people; they met Shang and Bi at Loufan and both Wei generals were killed; Budugen and Xiégūní's tribes fled beyond the passes and joined Kebineng in border raids. The Emperor sent Valiant Cavalry General Qin Lang at the head of the central army to suppress them; Kebineng fled north beyond the tents, and Xiégūní brought his people in to surrender. Before long Budugen was killed by Kebineng.
50
7
7. Gongsun Yuan, seeing that Wu was far away and unreliable, beheaded Zhang Mi, Xu Yan, and their party, sent the heads to the Wei capital, and seized all their troops, supplies, and treasure. In winter, the twelfth month, an edict made Yuan Grand Marshal and enfeoffed him Duke of Lelang.
51
When the King of Wu heard this he flew into a rage and said, "I am sixty years old; of hardship and ease in this world there is nothing I have not known. To be turned back lately by a wretched mouse of a foe makes my fury surge like a mountain. If I do not cut off that rat's head myself and cast it into the sea, I have no face to rule the realm again. Even if I am ruined, I will not regret it!"
52
姿西 忿 𨵦 使
Lu Xun submitted a memorial saying, "Your Majesty, with divine martial prowess, received Heaven's mandate, broke Cao Cao at Wulin, defeated Liu Bei at Xiling, and captured Guan Yu in Jingzhou. These three foes were the greatest men of the age, yet Your Majesty broke every one of them. Where your sacred rule reaches, the land bows for ten thousand li; you are on the verge of pacifying the Central Plains and uniting the realm under one design. Now, unwilling to endure a slight affront, you unleash thunderous wrath, ignore the admonition not to stand where a beam might fall, and lightly risk the weight of the imperial chariot—this is what perplexes your servant. I have heard that one who travels ten thousand li does not stop halfway, and one who plots to master the four seas does not let small grievances spoil the great design. With powerful enemies on the frontier and distant lands not yet paying court, if Your Majesty sails on a distant campaign you will invite opportunists; when calamity strikes you will grieve—and regret will come too late. If the great enterprise advances in its season, Yuan will submit without your needing to punish him. Now you begrudge Liaodong's distant men and horses—how can you be willing to throw away Jiangdong's foundation of lasting peace and feel no regret!"
53
洿 忿
Vice Director of the Masters of Writing Xue Zong submitted a memorial saying, "Formerly Emperor Yuan of Han wished to board a tower ship; Xue Guangde offered to cut his throat and dye the carriage with his blood. Why? Water and fire are utmost peril—not what an emperor should brave. Liaodong is a petty barbarian state without stout walls or proper defenses; its arms are crude, its people unruly sheep and dogs—as Your Majesty's edict says, conquest would be easy. Yet the land is cold and barren, grain will not grow, and the people live on horseback, wandering without fixed abode; at news of a great army they will scatter like startled beasts—no man or horse to be found; though you seize empty territory, holding it profits nothing—first, the campaign cannot succeed. Moreover the seas run vast and treacherous, with dangers like Chengsheng Mountain; voyages have no fixed course and storms are unavoidable—in an instant ship and crew may part fates; even Yao and Shun's virtue could not avail, even Ben and Yu's courage could not be used—second, the campaign cannot succeed. Add dense fog overhead and brackish vapors below, breeding sores that spread from man to man—few who sail the sea escape such sickness—third, the campaign cannot succeed. Heaven born the sacred ruler—he should seize the hour to pacify disorder and comfort the people. Now the rebel is nearly destroyed and the realm almost settled—yet you abandon the sure design for utmost peril, neglect the security of the nine provinces, and indulge a morning's wrath; this is no plan for the altars of state, nor anything tried since the realm was founded—no wonder your ministers hold their breath, eat without savor, and sleep without rest."
54
忿 使 使
Director of Selection Lu Kai submitted a memorial saying, "The northern enemy borders our land; if a gap opens they will strike at the first chance. We cross the sea and court Yuan only to meet today's urgent need and remove the disease at our heart. Yet now you abandon the root for the branch, neglect what is near to govern what is far, change course in anger and rouse the host—this is what cunning foes hope to hear, not Great Wu's supreme strategy. Moreover war wears foes down through toil while matching fatigue against ease; in the balance of gain and loss much becomes clear. Tazhu is still far from Yuan; once ashore the army must split three ways—strongest to attack, next to guard the ships, last to haul grain; though many march, few can be fully employed. Men must carry grain on foot deep into enemy country where horses abound and ambushes strike without warning. If Yuan is cunning and still tied to the north, the day you mobilize they will aid each other like lip and teeth; if he stands utterly alone he may flee in terror and prove hard to destroy at once—Heaven's punishment lingering on the northern wastes while mountain tribes rise in the breach—I fear that is no plan for lasting peace!" The King of Wu would not agree.
55
Lu Kai submitted again, saying, "Arms and armor are what former ages used to punish violence and awe the four barbarians. But they are deployed only after traitors are gone and the realm is at peace—when one deliberates at leisure in the ancestral hall. When the heartland boils and the nine domains clash, one must deepen roots and spare strength—never in such a time has a ruler cast off the near to govern the far and exhaust his armies. When Zhao Tuo rebelled and styled himself emperor, the realm was at peace and the people prosperous—yet Emperor Wen still deemed distant campaigns arduous and contented himself with admonition. Fierce foes are not yet destroyed and the borders still alarmed—Yuan should not come first. I beg Your Majesty to curb your wrath and trust to strategy, for a time rest the six armies, lay plans in silence, and look to what follows—the realm would be greatly fortunate!" The King of Wu then desisted.
56
使
The King of Wu repeatedly sent envoys to comfort and apologize to Zhang Zhao; Zhao still would not attend court. The King of Wu went out himself, passed Zhao's gate, and called to him; Zhao pleaded grave illness. The King of Wu set fire to his gate to frighten him; Zhao still would not emerge. The King of Wu had the fire put out and waited at the gate a long while. Zhao's sons helped him up together; the King of Wu carried him back to the palace and reproached himself deeply. Zhao could not refuse, and thereafter returned to court.
57
使 便 使 簿紿 使
Earlier, when Zhang Mi, Xu Yan, and their party reached Xiangping, Gongsun Yuan planned against them and first dispersed their officials and troops, placing palace agents Qin Dan, Zhang Qun, Du De, Huang Qiang, and sixty officials and soldiers in Xuantu. Xuantu lay two hundred li northeast of Liaodong; Prefect Wang Zan governed two hundred households; Dan and the others were lodged with common families and lived on their charity for some forty days. Dan and Qun and the others discussed among themselves, saying, "We have come far and disgraced our state's command, abandoned in this place—we are as good as dead. This commandery is very weak; if we unite at once, burn its towns, kill its officials to avenge our state, and then accept death, we shall have no regret. How is that worse than clinging to life and remaining captives forever!" Qun and the others agreed. They secretly agreed to rise on the night of the nineteenth of the eighth month. At noon that day Zhang Song of the commandery reported them; Zan gathered his men and shut the gates; Dan, Qun, De, and Qiang climbed the walls and fled. Qun was ill with a carbuncle on his knee and could not keep up; De often supported him through rugged hills for six or seven hundred li until the wound worsened and he could go no farther; they lay in the grass, guarding each other and weeping. Qun said, "My wound is grave and death near; you should hurry on and hope to get through; to stay and die together in this ravine—what good is that!" De said, "We have wandered ten thousand li from home and share life and death—we cannot abandon you." They pushed Dan and Qiang onward; De alone stayed with Qun, gathering wild plants to eat. After several days Dan and Qiang reached Goguryeo and proclaimed the King of Wu's edict to King Weigong and his registrar, falsely claiming that gifts had been seized by Liaodong. [End editorial note.] They sent twenty-five men in black robes to escort Dan and the others back to Wu, with a memorial declaring subjection and tribute of a thousand sable pelts and ten suits of hawk-skin.6 When Dan and the others saw the King of Wu, joy and grief overwhelmed them beyond bearing. The King of Wu praised their courage and appointed them all Commandants.
58
8 滿 耀 耀 使
8. That year the King of Wu marched out intending to besiege Xincheng; the crossing was long and for more than twenty days he dared not land. Man Chong told his generals, "Sun Quan, learning that we shifted the city, will surely boast to his troops. He comes in force seeking a single decisive stroke; though he may not dare come all the way, he will surely land and parade his troops to show he has strength to spare." He secretly posted six thousand infantry and cavalry in ambush along the Fei River to await them. The King of Wu did land and parade his troops; Chong's ambush rose and struck, beheading several hundred, some drowning as they fled into the water. The King of Wu also sent Quan Zong to attack Liu'an, but he too failed.
59
9( ) ) 西 退
9. Han ( Shu) Shu)7 Editorial note: In the title Director of Laijiang Zhang Yi, Sima Guang had not changed "Shu" to "Han" but emended the text directly. [End editorial note.] He enforced the law harshly, and the southern Yi chieftain Liu Zhou rebelled. Chancellor Zhuge Liang appointed Staff Officer Ma Zhong of Baxi to replace Yi and summoned Yi back. People told Yi he should hurry back and accept punishment. Yi said, "Not so—I return because the barbarians stirred in folly and I was not equal to my post. But my replacement has not yet arrived. I am still at the front and ought to move grain and build up stores for destroying the enemy. How could I abandon the state's business just because I have been dismissed and recalled!" He pressed on without slackening his command; only when his replacement arrived did he set out. Ma Zhong built on the groundwork Zhang Yi had laid, defeated Liu Gou, and beheaded him.
60
10
Zhuge Liang encouraged agriculture and military training, devised the wooden ox and the flowing horse, hauled grain to stock the mouth of the Xie Valley, and built granaries there; he let the people and the troops recover, and only after three years put them to use.
61
1使
In spring, the second month, Zhuge Liang led his entire army of one hundred thousand through the Xie Valley to invade and sent envoys to coordinate a major simultaneous strike with Wu.
62
3
In the third month, on the day Gengyin, the Duke of Shanyang died; the emperor went into mourning dress and proclaimed the funeral rites.
63
4
On the day Jiyou, a general amnesty was declared.
64
4
In summer, the fourth month, a great epidemic broke out.
65
5殿
Chonghua Hall burned.
66
6 西
Zhuge Liang reached Mei and encamped south of the Wei River. Sima Yi led his army across the Wei, built fortifications with the river at his back to hold them off, and told his generals, "If Liang comes out through Wugong and marches east along the mountains, that would be genuinely alarming; if he climbs west to Wuzhang Plains, you generals will have nothing to fear;" Liang did indeed encamp at Wuzhang Plains.
67
使
Guo Huai, Inspector of Yong Province, said to Sima Yi, "Liang is certain to fight for the northern plain—we should seize it first." Most in council disagreed. Guo Huai said, "If Liang crosses the Wei and takes the plain, links with Beishan, severs the Long route, and stirs both Chinese settlers and tribal peoples, that will not serve the state." Sima Yi then sent Guo Huai to hold the northern plain. Before the trenches and ramparts were finished, Han forces arrived in strength; Guo Huai counterattacked and drove them back.
68
使
Because his earlier campaigns had all stalled for lack of grain and his plans had never come to fruition, Liang now divided troops to farm garrison fields as a foundation for a long stay. The soldiers farming mingled among the people along the Wei, yet the locals lived in peace and the army took nothing for private gain.
69
7 滿 使 便
In the fifth month, Sun Quan moved into Chaohu mouth and advanced on Hefei New City at the head of forces said to number one hundred thousand; he also sent Lu Xun and Zhuge Jin with more than ten thousand men into Jiangxia and Hankou toward Xiangyang; and Generals Sun Shao and Zhang Cheng pushed into the Huai toward Guangling and Huaiyin. In the sixth month, Man Chong wanted to lead the armies to relieve New City. General Who Exterminates Barbarians Tian Yu said, "The enemy have committed their full strength—not for petty gain but to hold New City hostage and lure our main army. We should let them besiege the city and blunt their fighting spirit—not meet them head-on. If they cannot take the city, their troops are sure to grow weary and slack; and once they are weary and slack, we can strike and win a great victory. If the enemy see through the plan, they will surely not besiege the city and will withdraw on their own. If we advance at once, we walk straight into their trap."
70
便
At that time the officials and soldiers of the east were all on leave. Man Chong memorialized asking that the central army be called up and all men on leave recalled to muster for an attack. Regular Attendant Liu Shao of Guangping argued, "The enemy have just arrived, focused and sharp. Man Chong, with few men fighting on their own ground—if he attacks at once, he surely cannot control them. Man Chong's request to wait for reinforcements has cost nothing. He proposes sending five thousand infantry and three thousand picked cavalry ahead of the main army, raising the cry of advance to overawe the enemy. When the cavalry reach Hefei, they should spread the column thin, multiply banners and drums, display troops below the walls, draw the enemy out behind them, threaten their line of retreat, and cut their grain route. When the enemy hear the great army is coming and cavalry cut their rear, they are sure to be shaken and flee in terror, defeating themselves without a fight." The emperor accepted this plan.
71
西 使退 滿 退
Man Chong wanted to abandon New City and lure the enemy toward Shouchun. The emperor refused and said, "Long ago Emperor Guangwu of Han sent troops to hold Lueyang and in the end destroyed Wei Xiao; the Former Emperor placed Hefei in the east, guarded Xiangyang in the south, and secured Qishan in the west. Whenever bandits came they were broken below these three cities because the ground was ground they had to contest. Even if Sun Quan attacks New City, he surely cannot take it. Order the generals to hold firm. I shall campaign in person—by the time I arrive, I fear Sun Quan will already have fled." He then sent Protector of the Army for the Shu Campaign Qin Lang to command twenty thousand foot and horse to aid Sima Yi against Zhuge Liang, instructing Yi, "Only fortify and hold to blunt their edge. If they cannot advance to their wish and retreat with no one to fight, a long halt will exhaust their grain; they will plunder nothing and must flee; flee—and then pursue. That is the way to complete victory." The emperor sailed east on a dragon boat to campaign.8 Man Chong recruited stalwarts to burn Wu siege engines and shot dead Sun Quan's younger clansman Sun Tai; and many Wu officers and soldiers fell ill. Before the emperor had come within several hundred li, decoy troops arrived first. Sun Quan had first believed the emperor could not come out; when he heard the great army had arrived, he fled at once, and Sun Shao withdrew as well.
72
便退 便 西
Lu Xun sent a kinsman, Han Bian, to present a memorial to Sun Quan; enemy scouts captured him. Zhuge Jin was greatly alarmed when he heard and wrote to Lu Xun, "The imperial carriage has returned; the enemy captured Han Bian and know our full disposition, and the water is drying—we ought to withdraw at once." Lu Xun did not reply but was urging men to plant turnips and beans and, with his generals, played chess and archery as usual. Jin said, "Boyan is full of stratagems—he must have some plan." He then came in person to see Lu Xun. Lu Xun said, "The enemy know the imperial carriage has returned and need fear nothing else—they can concentrate on us. They already hold the vital points, and our officers and men are unsettled. We must first steady ourselves, lay stratagems, and only then withdraw. If we show retreat now, the enemy will think we are afraid and will press us hard—a posture sure to bring defeat." He then secretly formed a plan with Jin: Jin was to command the boats while Lu Xun led all troops and horses toward Xiangyang. The Wei forces had long feared Lu Xun's name and hurried back to the city. Jin then led the boats out; Lu Xun slowly reformed his ranks, inflated their posture, and marched toward the boats—and the Wei men did not dare press him. Reaching Baiwei, he claimed to go hunting but secretly sent Generals Zhou Jun and Zhang Liang and others to strike Jiangxia, Xinshi, Anlu, and Shiyang, killing and capturing more than a thousand before returning. The courtiers thought Sima Yi was still locked in stalemate with Zhuge Liang and urged that the imperial carriage proceed west to Chang'an. The emperor said, "Sun Quan has fled; Liang's courage is broken—the great army is enough to control him. I have no worry." He then advanced to Shouchun, recorded the generals' merits, and enfeoffed and rewarded each according to rank.
73
8
In the eighth month, on the day Renshen, Emperor Xian of Han was buried at Shan's Tomb.
74
9
On the day Xinsi, the emperor returned to Xuchang.
75
10 使
Sima Yi and Zhuge Liang faced each other for more than a hundred days. Liang repeatedly challenged him to battle; Yi would not come out. Liang then sent Yi women's headscarves and gowns. Yi was enraged and memorialized requesting battle. The emperor sent Director of the Guards Xin Pi with the staff of authority as army mentor to restrain him. Protector of the Army Jiang Wei said to Liang, "Assistant Director Xin has arrived with the staff—the enemy will not come out again." Liang said, "They had no mind for battle from the start; they asked for battle only to show martial spirit to their troops. When the general is in the field, the sovereign's command is not always obeyed. If they could control me, would they ask for battle from a thousand li away?"
76
使 使
Liang sent an envoy to Yi's camp. Yi asked about his eating and sleeping and how pressing his affairs were—not military matters. The envoy replied, "Director Zhuge rises early and retires late; whenever the penalty is twenty lashes or more, he inspects it in person; the food he eats does not amount to several sheng." Yi told others, "Zhuge Kongming eats little and has many affairs—how long can he last?"
77
使
and consulted him on the great affairs of state.9 Fu arrived; when he had finished speaking with Liang he left, but returned after several days. Liang said, "I know why you have come back. Though we talked for days lately, there was still something left unsaid—your return was already decided. As for what you asked—Gongyan is the right man." Fu apologized, "Before, I truly failed to ask—as when Your Excellency passes on, who can take the great affairs? So I came back. I beg to ask again: after Jiang Wan, who can take the post?" Liang said, "Wenwei can succeed him." Asked who would come next, Liang did not answer.
78
退
That month Liang died in the army. Chief Clerk Yang Yi marshaled the army and withdrew. The people ran to tell Sima Yi, and Yi pursued. Jiang Wei had Yang Yi turn the flags and beat the drums as if about to strike Yi; Yi drew in his army and retreated, not daring to press. Thereupon Yang Yi formed battle order and withdrew; only after entering the valley did they proclaim the mourning. The people made a saying of it: "Dead Zhuge scares off living Zhongda." When Yi heard it, he laughed and said, "I can gauge the living—I could not gauge the dead." Yi inspected the sites of Liang's camps and fortifications and sighed, "A rare genius under Heaven!" He pursued to Red Bank but could not overtake them and turned back.
79
便 忿
Earlier, Han Front Army Mentor Wei Yan was fiercer than any other man and skilled at nurturing troops. Whenever he followed Liang on campaign he wished to request ten thousand men and meet Liang by another route at Tong Pass, as Han Xin had done—but Liang restrained him and would not permit it. Yan often called Liang timid and lamented that his own talents were not fully used. Yang Yi was capable and quick; whenever Liang took the field Yi would plan deployments and calculate grain stores without long deliberation—done in an instant—and military regulation drew on Yi. Yan was proud and overbearing; everyone at the time deferred to him except Yi, who would not indulge him—and Yan regarded this as the deepest resentment, like fire and water. Liang deeply prized both men's talents and could not bear to favor one and discard the other.
80
使 忿
Fei Yi was sent to Wu; Sun Quan, drunk, asked Yi, "Yang Yi and Wei Yan are rustic petty men. Though they once barked to some benefit for the times, now that they are in post their station must not be slighted. If Zhuge Liang were gone tomorrow, calamity and disorder would surely follow. You are all asleep at the switch, with no thought of guarding against this—what became of securing blessing for your descendants?" Yi replied, "The friction between Yi and Yan is nothing but private spite; neither harbors the unruliness of a Ying Bu or a Han Xin. We are in the midst of crushing our enemies and reuniting the realm; achievement rests on talent, and enterprise expands through talent. To cast such men aside and withhold office for fear of later trouble is like stocking for storms and then throwing away your boat—no strategy for the long haul."
81
歿退 便 便 紿
As his illness worsened, Liang worked out with Yang Yi, Chief Clerk Fei Yi, and others the plan for withdrawing after his death: Wei Yan was to cover the retreat, with Jiang Wei behind him; If Yan refused to obey, the army was to march on without him. When Liang died, Yi concealed the news and sent Fei Yi to probe Wei Yan's intentions. Yan said, "The Chancellor may be dead, but I am still alive. His staff may escort the coffin home for burial—I will lead the armies against the enemy myself; how can the death of one man halt the affairs of the realm! And who is Wei Yan, to take orders from Yang Yi as rear-guard general!" He drafted marching orders with Fei Yi, had Yi write them out and countersign, and sent them down to the generals. Yi deceived Yan, saying, "I will go back and reason with Chief Clerk Yang. He is a civil officer with little military experience—he will surely obey." Yi left the gate and galloped away. Yan soon regretted it, but it was too late.
82
使 宿
Yan sent scouts to watch Yi and the others, intending to follow Liang's plan as the camps withdrew in turn. Furious, he marched out before Yi had moved, led his troops south ahead of the main body, and burned the plank roads wherever he passed. Yan and Yi each denounced the other as a traitor; within a day urgent dispatches flew back and forth. The Han ruler consulted Dong Yun, Attendant-in-Ordinary, and Jiang Wan, Chief Clerk left at the capital; both vouched for Yi and suspected Yan. Yi's party cut timbers to open a mountain road and marched day and night, pressing on Yan's heels. Yan arrived first, seized the Southern Valley Pass, and sent troops to meet Yi head-on; Yi ordered General He Ping to block Yan. Ping shouted to the vanguard: "Our lord is dead and his body not yet cold—how dare you behave like this!" Yan's men knew the fault was his and would not fight; they scattered. Yan fled to Hanzhong with only his son and a few followers; Yi sent Ma Dai in pursuit to behead him and exterminated his clan to the third degree. Jiang Wan led the capital-guard camps north toward the crisis; after marching several tens of li, news of Yan's death arrived and he turned back. At first Yan had meant to kill Yi and the rest, hoping opinion would make him Zhuge's successor; that is why he did not defect to Wei but marched south against Yi—he had no real intent to rebel.
83
使
The armies returned to Chengdu. A general amnesty was proclaimed, and Zhuge Liang was posthumously titled Loyal Martial Marquis. Earlier Liang had told the Han ruler, "In Chengdu I have eight hundred mulberry trees and fifteen qing of thin fields—enough that my sons and brothers live with a modest surplus. I have not set up a separate household to grow my fortune. If when I die there is surplus silk within or surplus wealth without, I will have failed Your Majesty." At his death it was exactly as he had said.
84
Chief Clerk Zhang Yi often said of Liang, "He rewards without overlooking the distant, punishes without favoring kin; rank cannot be taken without merit, and punishment cannot be bought with status—that is why worthy and simple alike give themselves wholly to him!"
85
::
Chen Shou remarked: As Chancellor, Zhuge Liang comforted the people, displayed ritual norms, streamlined offices, followed expedient measures, opened sincere hearts, and spread impartial justice; those loyal in service were rewarded even if they had been enemies; those negligent in office were punished even if they were kin; those who confessed honestly were released even for grave offenses; those who wove excuses were executed even for light ones; no good deed, however small, went unrewarded; no fault, however slight, went undisciplined; affairs were handled with precision, causes traced to their roots, titles matched to deeds, and the insincere found no place. Within the realm all feared and loved him alike; though punishments were stern, none bore resentment—because his heart was even and his warnings clear. He may be called a master of governance, second only to Guan Zhong and Xiao He!
86
11
11. Earlier, Colonel of the Long Water Liao Li had deemed his talent and reputation fit to make him Zhuge Liang's deputy; finding his post idle, he grumbled and slandered without cease. Liang stripped him of office and exiled him to Wenshan. When Liang died, Liao wept and said, "I am doomed to wear the barbarian lapel at last!" Li Ping heard of it and also fell ill and died. Ping had long hoped Liang would take him back; he had reckoned that those who came after could not.
87
:: 使
Xi Zuochi wrote: Long ago Guan Zhong seized three hundred households of Pian from Bo Shi, and Bo Shi bore no complaint to his dying day—the sage deemed that difficult. That Zhuge Liang could bring Liao Li to tears and Li Yan to his death—was that merely bearing no complaint? Water at its level gives the crooked their standard; a mirror at its brightness lets the ugly forget rage; water and mirror can lay all things bare without breeding resentment because they are without selfishness. Even water and mirror, though without selfishness, still escape slander—how much more when great men cherish life, extend compassion, enforce law only where it must be enforced, punish only self-incurred guilt, grant rank without favoritism, and execute without wrath: who under heaven would not submit?
88
12( ) )
12. Han ( Shu) Shu)10 Editorial note: In the phrase "wherever they went, the people petitioned to erect temples to Zhuge Liang," Sima Guang had not changed "Shu" to "Han"; this has been directly emended. , but the Han ruler would not consent. The people then offered private seasonal sacrifices at crossroads; Colonel of Foot Soldiers Xi Long and others memorialized, "We ask to build a temple near his tomb at Mianyang and end private worship." The Han ruler agreed.
89
The Han ruler made Left General Wu Yi General of Chariots and Cavalry, with acting staff, to command Hanzhong; he made Chief Clerk Jiang Wan Director of the Masters of Writing to oversee state affairs, and soon added Acting Protector-General with acting staff and governorship of Yi Province. The realm had just lost its commander; near and far were shaken. Wan stood out among the officials, yet showed neither grief nor elation—his bearing was as on any other day, and so the court gradually took heart.
90
( ) ) 使使西西 西
When Wu heard that Zhuge Liang had died, they feared Wei would exploit the weakness to seize Han ( Shu) Shu) “Here Sima Guang left Shu unaltered; the text is emended to Han. and reinforced Baqiu with ten thousand men—partly to stand ready to aid Han, partly to seize an opening for partition.” When Han heard of it, they reinforced Yong'an against any surprise. The Han ruler sent Zong Yu, Right Gentleman-of-the-Interior, to Wu. Sun Quan asked, "East and west are one household—yet I hear you have strengthened White Emperor City. Why?" Yu replied, "I take it that your strengthening Baqiu and our strengthening White Emperor are both what circumstances require—neither is grounds for reproach." Sun Quan laughed aloud, admired his blunt completeness, and honored him second only to Deng Zhi.
91
13 宿 使
13. In Wu, Zhuge Ke noted that Danyang's mountains were rugged and its people fierce; past campaigns had rounded up only the lowland commoners. Those in the deep hills could not be taken; he repeatedly asked to go in person and in three years could raise forty thousand armored men. The council argued: "Danyang is rugged, bordering Wu, Kuaiji, Xindu, and Poyang—hundreds of li of folded valleys. Its secluded inhabitants had never seen a walled town; they met officials armed and wild, white-haired in the woods; fugitives and hardened criminals fled together. The hills yielded copper and iron, and they forged their own arms. They loved war and prized strength; climbing cliffs and charging through thorns, they moved like fish in a pool or apes in the trees. They watched for openings to raid; whenever troops came, they vanished into their lairs. In battle they swarmed; in defeat they scattered like birds—no dynasty had ever bridled them." All deemed it too hard. Ke's father Jin heard and judged the venture would fail; he sighed, "If Ke does not exalt our house, he will stain it red!" Ke pressed that victory was certain; Sun Quan made him General Who Pacifies the Yue and Administrator of Danyang and let him try.
92
14
14. In winter, the eleventh month, Luoyang was shaken by an earthquake.
93
15
15. In Wu, Pan Jun campaigned against the Wuling tribes for years, killing or capturing tens of thousands. The tribes weakened thereafter and the region grew quiet. In the eleventh month, Jun returned to Wuchang.
94
==
= Collation Note = (editorial references section for variant readings and source citations in this volume)

Footnotes

  1. Forced to advance]
  2. troops took the heights and set an ambush
  3. [Official scrutiny was relentless]
  4. In spring, during the first month, on the day Jiashen, an azure dragon was seen in the well at Mobei. In the second month, on the day Dingyou
  5. provincial inspector Bi Gui memorialized for an immediate march
  6. Weigong and his court were delighted and received the edict at once, ordering men to follow Dan back to welcome Qun and [De]
  7. Director of Laijiang Zhang Yi
  8. In autumn, the seventh month, [Renyin]
  9. Liang's illness was grave; the Han [lord] sent Vice Director of the Masters of Writing Li Fu to attend his bedside
  10. Wherever they went, the people petitioned to erect temples to Zhuge Liang
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →