← Back to 資治通鑑

卷230 唐紀四十六

Volume 230 Tang Records 46

Chapter 230 of 資治通鑑 · Comprehensive Mirror in Aid of Governance
← Previous Chapter
Chapter 230
Next Chapter →
1
230
Zizhi Tongjian, Volume 230.
2
滿
[Tang Annals 46] From the second month through the fourth month of this jiazi year—less than a full year's span.
3
Year 1 of Xingyuan, reign of Emperor Dezong, the Divinely Martial and Sagely Literate Emperor ( jiazi [784 CE])
4
In the second month, on the wushen day, the throne posthumously honored Duan Xiushi as Grand Mentor, gave him the posthumous name Zhonglie, and provided generous support for his household. Jia Yinlin had died by then; he too was posthumously made Left Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs, in recognition of his forthright counsel.
5
使使 使
Li Xilie marched fifty thousand men against Ningling and had the city flooded by diverting water against its walls. Liu Chang, the prefect of Puzhou, held the place with three thousand troops. Li Cheng, prefect of Huazhou, secretly sent envoys to offer his surrender, and the emperor agreed to make him military commissioner of Bian and Hua. Cheng still maintained outward allegiance to Xilie. Suspicious of Cheng, Xilie posted six hundred of his adopted sons at Baima and ordered Cheng to join the assault on Ningling. At Shizhu, Cheng had his men feign panic, burned the camp, and slipped away. He also prompted the adopted sons to loot; Cheng rounded them up and executed them, then reported the matter to Xilie, who could find no fault with him. Liu Chang held Ningling for forty-five days without once taking off his armor. Han Huang sent his general Wang Qiyao to reinforce Liu Qia against Xilie; Qiyao moved several thousand heavy crossbows along the Bian River and entered Ningling by night. The next day they shot from the walls at Xilie and hit the canopy over his seat. Xilie exclaimed in alarm, "The crossbowmen from Xuan and Run are here!" And at once he broke off the siege and withdrew.
6
西 使 使使
After Zhu Ci retreated in defeat from Fengtian, Li Sheng set out to recover Chang'an. Liu Dexin was stationed with Sheng at East Wei Bridge but refused to submit to his authority. Sheng seized the occasion when Dexin came to camp to charge him with the defeat at Hujian and with the looting along his march, and had him beheaded. He then rode into Dexin's camp with only a few horsemen, reassured the men, and none stirred against him; he absorbed the command at once, and his army's strength swelled. Li Huaiguang, having forced the court to remove Lu Qi and the others, grew uneasy in his own mind and began to turn disloyal. He also resented Li Sheng's independent command and, fearing his success, asked that their armies be combined. The throne approved. Sheng joined Huaiguang west of Xianyang at Chantaoxie; their ramparts were not yet finished when Ci's army came up in force. Sheng told Huaiguang, "If the rebels shut themselves inside the palace grounds, the siege may drag on and will not be easy to win. They have left their lair and dare meet us in the open—Heaven is delivering the enemy into your hands; we must not let this pass!" Huaiguang replied, "The army has only just come up—the horses are unfed and the men unfed. How can we fight so soon!" Sheng had no choice but to fall back behind the walls. Whenever they marched out together, Huaiguang's men looted cattle and horses freely, while Sheng's troops would not take even a straw. Huaiguang's soldiers resented the contrast and tried to share their loot with Sheng's men, who would never accept it. Huaiguang lingered at Xianyang for months without advancing. The emperor repeatedly sent palace envoys to hurry him forward; he pleaded exhausted troops and the need to rest and watch for an opening. The generals repeatedly urged an attack on Chang'an, but Huaiguang refused; he was secretly in contact with Zhu Ci, and the signs grew plain. Li Sheng memorialized again and again, fearing treachery and absorption into Huaiguang's command, and asked to shift his army to East Wei Bridge. The emperor still hoped to win Huaiguang back and use his strength, and set Sheng's memorial aside without acting on it. Huaiguang wished to stall the campaign and stir resentment among the other armies; he memorialized, "The other armies receive thin rations while the Shence alone is favored—such inequality makes united action impossible." Finances were already strained: matching every army to the Shence would be impossible, yet refusing would anger Huaiguang and risk discontent in the ranks. He sent Lu Zhi to Huaiguang's camp on a mission of reassurance and summoned Li Sheng to join the deliberation. Huaiguang hoped Sheng would volunteer a cut in his men's rations, lose their loyalty, and see his success undone; he said, "Men who fight side by side cannot be expected to fight as one when their pay differs!" Zhi said nothing and glanced repeatedly at Sheng. Sheng said, "You are supreme commander and may issue orders as you please; I lead one army and follow your direction alone. As for increasing or cutting rations and clothing, that is yours to decide." Huaiguang fell silent; unwilling to cut his own men's allowances, he dropped the matter.
7
The emperor had sent Cui Hanheng to Tibet to request troops; the Tibetan minister Shang Jiezan said, "By our law, we march only on the word of the chief commander named in the edict. This edict bears no signature from Huaiguang, so we dare not march." The emperor ordered Lu Zhi to persuade Huaiguang, but Huaiguang refused outright: "If we take the capital, the Tibetans will surely burn and loot—who can stop them! That is the first danger. An earlier edict promised one hundred strings of cash to every soldier who helped take the city; if they send fifty thousand men and claim that reward, where will five million strings of cash come from! That is the second danger. Even if their horsemen come, they will not fight first; they will hold their men back, watch our strength, share the glory if we win and turn treacherous if we lose—too cunning to trust. That is the third danger." In the end he would not sign the edict. Shang Jiezan likewise sent no troops.
8
使使 忿 便使 調
Returning from Xianyang, Lu Zhi memorialized, "The rebel Ci clings to the palace grounds with his strength spent and his allies gone, stealing day by day to survive. Huaiguang commands the loyal armies and holds every advantage; to sweep forward and cut the rebels down should be as easy as snapping dry wood—yet when the enemy flees he will not pursue, his army grows stale, and whenever the other commanders urge an advance he blocks them. By these signs his conduct is inexplicable; Your Majesty has sheltered him at every turn, yet nothing in his actions shows gratitude. Unless we adopt a separate strategy and begin to restrain him, seeking only peace through indulgence will end in disaster we cannot foresee. This is a moment of grave urgency and cannot be treated as an ordinary affair. Li Sheng has now asked to move his army; on my mission of reassurance to Huaiguang's camp he happened to raise the matter, and I asked in general terms what he thought best. Huaiguang said, 'If Li Sheng wants to go his own way, I want nothing from him.' I still feared he might change his mind and praised the strength of his army. Huaiguang swelled with pride and began to slight Sheng. I then asked gently, 'When I return, if His Majesty asks whether this may proceed, what is your final word?' Having spoken so freely, Huaiguang could not retract; he said, 'If the throne permits him to go, there is no objection.' The pledge was repeated and explicit; even if he wished to take it back, he would find it hard to explain away. I beg Your Majesty to send Li Sheng's memorial to the Secretariat at once, approve it by edict, and separately send Huaiguang a handwritten edict explaining why the troops are moving. The handwritten edict should say in substance: 'Yesterday Li Sheng memorialized asking to move east of the city to divide the rebel strength. We meant to consult you first; Lu Zhi has just reported that you discussed this and said his departure would do no harm, so we have ordered his army to grant the request.' Thus the wording is courteous yet clear and the logic plain; even if he harbors other designs, how can he take offense!" The emperor agreed. Sheng drew up his ranks at Xianyang and marched back to East Wei Bridge. Li Jianhui of Bin-Fang and Yang Huiyuan of the Shence field command were still in camp with Huaiguang. Lu Zhi memorialized again: "Huaiguang should be strong enough to subdue the rebels alone; his delay must have another cause. The trouble is that he is already too strong and needs no help. We have lately attached the armies of Li Sheng, Li Jianhui, and Yang Huiyuan to his camp—this helps victory not at all and only breeds trouble. Why? Four armies stand cheek by jowl while their commanders pull in different directions; in power they stand far apart in rank, and by office they answer to no single chain of command. Huaiguang despises Sheng and the others for their small armies and low rank and resents their refusal to obey him; they suspect him of coddling the rebels and resent his many slights. In camp they trade slanders; when battle is proposed each fears the other will steal the credit. Friction breeds suspicion, and if they remain together both cannot survive. The strong will perish once hatred has piled up; the weak will fall first in their peril—disaster waits on tiptoe! The old enemy is not yet subdued and a new danger rises—this is a grief that cuts to the heart. The wisest ruler removes trouble before it sprouts; the next best corrects it at the first sign. When the signs are already plain and disaster is at hand, how can we leave it unplanned and still hope to still the realm! Li Sheng saw the danger and moved east first; Jianhui and Huiyuan grow ever more isolated and will surely be swallowed—later plans may come too late to save them. To save them, the moment is now. Now that Sheng is willing to move, order the other two armies to march with him, alleging that his force is small and might be cut off by Ci's rebels, so that the three may support one another; announce the intent in secret, urge them to pack, and when the edict reaches camp let them march that day—Huaiguang may dislike it, but he will have no recourse. This is what it means to strike before the other can strike—thunder too swift to cover the ears against." To end a fight you must separate the fighters; to fight a fire you must act fast—the logic is complete here; I beg Your Majesty to act on it. The emperor said, "Your reasoning is excellent. Yet Li Sheng's move will surely leave Huaiguang resentful; if we send Jianhui and Huiyuan east as well, he may seize on it as a grievance and make matters harder to settle—let us wait another ten days."
9
使
On the xinyou day, Wang Wujun was made Associate Grand Councillor and concurrent military commissioner of Youzhou and Lulong.
10
Li Sheng argued, "Huaiguang's treason is already plain; we should prepare for the worst. The roads to Shu and Han must not be blocked—I ask that subordinates such as Zhao Guangxian be made prefects of Yang, Li, and Jian, each with five hundred men to guard against what may come." The emperor hesitated; he considered leading the palace armies personally to Xianyang on a mission of reassurance, to hurry the generals into action. Someone told Huaiguang, "This is the stratagem of the Han Founder's tour of Yunmeng!" Huaiguang was terrified, and his plans for rebellion grew bolder.
11
使 使 使 使使 使西 使
As the emperor was about to set out, Huaiguang's language grew ever more insolent; the emperor still suspected men of driving them apart. On the jiazi day he promoted Huaiguang to Grand Mentor, increased his income, granted an iron certificate, and sent Li Bian of the Shence Right Army and others to announce the imperial will. Huaiguang faced the envoys, threw the iron certificate to the ground, and said, "Does His Majesty suspect me? When a minister rebels, he is given an iron certificate; I have not rebelled—yet now you grant me one. You are forcing me to rebel!" His tone was openly defiant. Zhang Mingzhen, left army horse commissioner of Shuofang, shouted at the camp gate, "Grand Mentor, you will not let us strike the rebels and you treat the imperial envoy with contempt—do you mean to rebel after all! Your merit towers like Mount Tai, yet you throw it away in a day, destroy your own house, and enrich others—what good is that to you! Today I will dispute this with my life!" Huaiguang heard him and said, "I am not rebelling; the rebels are still strong, and we must husband our strength until the time is right." He added, "Where the Son of Heaven dwells there must be fortifications." He sent troops to fortify Xianyang and soon moved his army to hold the city. Zhang Mingzhen said, "You said you would not rebel—yet today you march your army here. Why? Why not attack Chang'an, kill Zhu Ci, win wealth and rank, and march the army back to Bin?" Huaiguang said, "Mingzhen has lost his mind!" He ordered his attendants to take him away and had him strangled. Shi Yanfen, army horse commissioner of the Right Martial Vanguard, was originally a man of the Western Regions whom Huaiguang had adopted as a son. Huaiguang was secretly in league with Zhu Ci; Yanfen sent his client Gao Chengyi to the traveling court to expose the plot and ask that Huaiguang be stripped of supreme command. Chengyi reached Fengtian and told Huaiguang's son Cui. Cui secretly informed his father. Huaiguang summoned Yanfen and rebuked him: "I took you as my son—how dare you seek to destroy my house! Today you betray me—are you willing to die for it?" Yanfen said, "The Son of Heaven made you his right arm, and you made me your trusted man; you have betrayed the Son of Heaven—how can I not betray you! I am a barbarian and cannot serve two masters; I know only to serve one man. If I may die without the name of traitor, I die content!" Huaiguang ordered his men to cut him to pieces; they all said, "A righteous man—let him die quickly!" They cut his throat and left him.
12
使 使使
Li Bian and the others returned and reported Huaiguang's arrogance; the traveling court then tightened security, and the officials all packed in secret against what might come. On the yichou day, Li Sheng was made military commissioner of Hezhong, Tong, and Jiang. The emperor still thought this insufficient; on the bingyin day he was also made Associate Grand Councillor. As the emperor prepared to go to Liangzhou, Yan Zhen, military commissioner of Shannan, sent envoys to Fengtian to welcome him and dispatched Zhang Yongcheng with five thousand men to Zhouzhi as escort. Yongcheng had been won over by Huaiguang and was secretly in league with him; when the emperor learned of this he was alarmed. Zhen then sent his adjutant Ma Xun with a memorial, and the emperor explained what had happened. Xun asked, "Let me go at once to Liangzhou for Commissioner Yan's tally to recall Yongcheng; if he refuses, I will kill him." The emperor said gladly, "When did you come back to us?" Xun fixed a day and hour and set out. With Yan's tally in hand, he took five strong men and went out through Luogu Valley. Yongcheng did not know the plot was exposed; he met Xun with several hundred horsemen, and Xun entered the post station with him. It was bitter cold; Xun lit many fires of wormwood outside the station, and the soldiers all went to warm themselves. Xun then calmly produced the tally from his breast and showed Yongcheng: "The Commissioner summons you." Yongcheng started up in alarm to flee; the stalwarts seized him from behind. Yongcheng's son was behind Xun and hacked at his head, wounding him. The stalwarts killed his son, threw Yongcheng down, straddled him, and held a blade to his throat: "Make a sound and you die!" Xun entered the camp; the soldiers had already armed themselves. Xun shouted, "Your parents, wives, and children are all in Hanzhong—you would abandon them in a day and rebel with Zhang Yongcheng; what good is that to you! The Commissioner sent me for Yongcheng alone—do not bring ruin on your own houses!" The men all submitted in fear. Xun sent Yongcheng to Liangzhou; Yan had him beaten to death and put a deputy in command of his troops. Xun wrapped up Yongcheng's head and reported to the traveling court, only half a day late.
13
使 使 使輿 西
Li Huaiguang sent men by night to overrun the armies of Li Jianhui and Yang Huiyuan; Jianhui escaped, but Huiyuan, fleeing toward Fengtian, was overtaken and killed. Huaiguang also proclaimed, "I am now allied with Zhu Ci; let the imperial carriage withdraw far and fast!" Huaiguang knew Han Yougui was a Shuofang general with troops at Fengtian and wrote inviting him to rebel; Yougui secretly reported it. The next day he wrote again to urge him on; Yougui reported again. The emperor praised his loyalty and asked, "What is your plan?" He replied, "Huaiguang commands the armies of all circuits and therefore dares rebel on the strength of his numbers. At Bin-Ning there is Zhang Xin; at Lingwu, Ning Jingxuan; at Hezhong, Lü Mingyue; at Zhenwu, Du Congzheng; at Tong Pass, Tang Chaochen; on the north bank of the Wei, Dou Kan—all garrison commanders. If Your Majesty gives each his troops and territory, honors Huaiguang in title but strips his command, the field generals will each answer to their own headquarters. Left alone, how can Huaiguang rebel!" The emperor said, "If we strip Huaiguang of command, what of Zhu Ci?" He replied, "Your Majesty has promised extraordinary rewards for taking the city; who among the troops would not gladly obey the Son of Heaven, strike the rebels, and win wealth and rank! The Bin troops number in the tens of thousands; give me command of them and they are enough to destroy Ci. And among the circuits there will surely be men who take the righteous side—Ci is nothing to fear!" The emperor agreed. On the dingmao day, Huaiguang sent his general Zhao Shengluan into Fengtian, planning that night for Dada Xiaojun to burn Qianling while Shengluan acted within as accomplice to terrify the emperor into flight. Shengluan went to Hun Jian and confessed; Jian reported at once and urged the emperor to flee to Liangzhou. The emperor ordered Jian to impose martial law; before Jian had finished mustering the troops, the emperor was already out the west gate, leaving Dai Xiuyan to hold Fengtian while courtiers and soldiers followed in disorder. Dai Xiuyan proclaimed through the ranks, "Huaiguang has rebelled!" And at once he manned the walls to defend the city.
14
使
When Zhu Ci declared himself emperor, Liu Nai, Vice Minister of War, lay ill at home; Ci summoned him, but he would not come. Ci sent Jiang Zhen to persuade him; Zhen went twice and saw he could not be moved, then sighed, "I too hold office in this ministry and could not give up my life, yet have come to this—how can I defile a worthy man with my own foulness!" He sobbed and went back. When Liu Nai heard the emperor had fled to Shannan, he beat his breast and cried out, threw himself on his bed, refused food, and died within days. Qiao Lin, Junior Preceptor to the Heir Apparent, followed the emperor to Zhouzhi, pleaded age and illness unfit for mountain roads, shaved his head as a monk, and hid in Xianyou Temple. Ci heard of it, summoned him to Chang'an, and made him Minister of Personnel. Thereafter many court officials who had been in hiding came out to serve Ci.
15
使 使使 紿
Huaiguang sent his generals Meng Bao, Hui Jingshou, and Sun Fuda with elite cavalry toward the Southern Mountains to intercept the emperor; at Zhouzhi they met Zhang Zeng, commissary for the armies' provisions. The three generals said, "He would make us traitors; we shall report we could not overtake the emperor—at worst he will only strip us of command." They signaled to Zeng: "The men have not eaten this morning—what shall we do?" Zeng deceived them: "A few li east is a Buddhist shrine where I have stored grain." The three generals led their men east and let them loot; meanwhile the officials with the emperor escaped into Luogu Valley. Reporting failure to overtake them, all three were dismissed by Huaiguang.
16
The Hedong generals Wang Quan and Ma Hui marched their troops back to Taiyuan.
17
宿
Li Sheng received his appointment, bowed and wept as he accepted it, and told his officers, "Chang'an holds the ancestral temples and is the root of the realm—if every general follows the emperor south, who will destroy the rebels!" He fortified his position, readied arms and armor, and set about recovering the capital. East Wei Bridge had held more than one hundred thousand bushels of grain; the revenue office had issued it all to Li Huaiguang's army. Huaiguang and Zhu Ci had joined forces; their power was formidable, the emperor had fled south, and the realm was in turmoil. Sheng stood alone between two powerful enemies, without supplies within or aid without; he moved his men only by loyalty and righteousness, and though his force was small its fighting spirit never waned. He also wrote to Huaiguang in humble, deferential terms, showing respect while explaining the consequences and urging him to redeem himself through merit. Huaiguang was shamed and could not bring himself to attack him. Sheng said, "Though the capital region has been ravaged by war, taxes can still be collected. To keep troops idle while the enemy grows strong is the greatest danger!" He appointed his aide Zhang Yu acting metropolitan governor, chose more than forty men as provisional officials to gather fodder and grain from the counties north of the Wei, and within ten days the stores were full. He wept as he swore before his army and resolved to crush the rebels.
18
使 使 穿 崿 崿 崿 使 崿 使 使 使 使 使
Tian Yue had lost battle after battle; six or seven tenths of his soldiers were dead, and his men were weary and bitter. The emperor appointed Kong Chaofu, Supervising Secretary, as pacification commissioner to Weibo. Chaofu was eloquent and learned; at Weizhou he addressed the troops on the rewards of loyalty and the cost of rebellion, and Yue and his men were pleased. Tian Xu, army horse commissioner and son of Tian Chengsi, was violent and erratic; Yue could not bring himself to execute him and had him beaten and imprisoned instead. Once Yue had submitted again to the throne, security was relaxed inside and out. In the third month, on the first day of the cycle, Yue feasted with Kong Chaofu; Xu complained bitterly about his younger kin, a nephew tried to restrain him, and Xu in anger killed the nephew, then said in remorse, "The Commissioner will surely kill me!" That evening, when Yue was drunk and asleep, Xu and his men broke through the rear wall, killed Yue along with his mother, wife, and more than ten others, and posted armed men in the inner passage of the central gate. At dawn he summoned, in Yue's name, the field marshal Hu E, aide Xu Shize, and chief registrar Jiang Ji to discuss business. The headquarters were deep within the compound and those outside knew nothing; Shize and Ji arrived first, were called in, and were hacked to death. Fearing exposure at daylight, Xu went out and met Yue's trusted general Liu Zhongxin forming ranks for inspection; Xu shouted to the men, "Liu Zhongxin and Hu E rebelled and stabbed the Commissioner last night!" The men were thrown into alarm and uproar. Before Zhongxin could defend himself, the men fell on him and killed him. Hu E came up to the halberd gate, found chaos, and rallied the troops; one third of the men followed him. Terrified, Xu mounted the wall and cried out to the troops: "I am the late Chancellor's son. You owe him your loyalty—if you make me commander, the cavalry commander gets two thousand strings of cash, senior generals half that, and every soldier down to the ranks one hundred strings. I will empty the treasury, public and private, and have it ready in five days." The troops wheeled about, killed Hu E, and rallied to Xu; the headquarters was secure. He sought confirmation from Kong Chaofu, who appointed Xu acting commander of the headquarters. Days later the men learned Xu had murdered his brother. They were furious, but he was already in power and they could do nothing. Xu then executed more than twenty of Yue's trusted generals, among them Xue Youlun. Li Baozhen and Wang Wujun were marching to relieve Beizhou, but when they heard of the upheaval they halted and would not go on. When Zhu Tao heard Yue was dead, he exclaimed with delight: "Yue betrayed his obligations—Heaven has struck through Xu!" He at once dispatched his Integrity Enforcement Grandee Zheng Jingji and others with five thousand infantry and cavalry to reinforce Ma Shi; their combined force of twelve thousand marched on Weizhou. Shi encamped on the Manghe River and sent his cavalry and Uyghur allies out to plunder on every side. Tao also sent an envoy into the city to win Xu over, offering him the military commission of his own circuit. Hard pressed, Xu sent his aide Hou Zang to Beizhou to submit to Tao. Tao was delighted, sent Zang back, and pressed for a swift alliance. By dawn Xu had secured the city. Li Baozhen and Wang Wujun sent envoys again, pledging relief on the same terms they had given Yue in his lifetime. Xu called his officers and staff to council. The advisers Zeng Mu and Lu Nanshi said: "War may honor force, but it must rest on benevolence and righteousness—only then can it succeed. The Youling troops now kill and loot without restraint until the fields are white with bones. The late commissioner may have broken faith, but what have his people done to deserve this! They are mighty for the moment, but their ruin can be watched for on tiptoe. Zhaoyi and Hengji are already striking them together—how can you, for a passing crisis, follow others into open rebellion! Better submit to the court. The Son of Heaven is still in exile; when he hears an envoy from Weibo has come he will rejoice, and rank and office will follow at once." Xu took their advice, sent envoys with a memorial to the imperial camp, and held the city awaiting the court's word.
19
使 使 使
When the emperor left Fengtian, Han Yougui took his eight hundred-odd followers back to Binzhou. Li Huaiguang, seeing Li Sheng's army grow stronger day by day, resented him and planned to march from Xianyang and strike Dongwei Bridge. Three times he ordered his men to move; they would not obey, whispering among themselves: "If he sends us against Zhu Ci, we will fight with all our strength; but if he means to rebel, we would rather die than follow him!" Huaiguang saw he could not compel them and asked his advisers for a plan. His circuit inspector Li Jinglue of Liangxiang said: "Take Chang'an, kill Zhu Ci, send the army back to their circuits, and ride alone to the emperor's camp. Your loyalty would stand intact and your reputation could still be saved." He pleaded again and again until tears ran down his face, and Huaiguang agreed. His chief adjutant Yan Yan and others urged him to move east, secure Hedong, and decide his course later. Huaiguang then told the troops: "We will camp at Jingyang for now, summon our families from Bin, and when they arrive we will all go on to Hedong together. When our spring gear is ready we can turn back and take Chang'an—it will not be too late. The eastern counties are all wealthy; on the day we march you may plunder as you please." The men agreed. Huaiguang then told Jinglue: "The army would not accept what you proposed just now. Leave at once, or you will soon be killed!" He sent a few horsemen to escort him out. Jinglue left the camp gate wailing: "I never thought this army would fall into treachery in a single day!" Huaiguang sent envoys to Binzhou ordering the acting commander Zhang Xin to march out every one of the ten thousand-odd troops still there, together with the families of the camp officers and men, to join him at Jingyang; he also sent General Liu Li and others with more than three thousand cavalry to force the move. Han Yougui urged Zhang Xin: "Lord Li the Grand Mentor threw away his great achievements and has already walked into ruin. Today you, Vice Commissioner, can win wealth and rank for yourself. Yougui asks leave to lead his men and follow you." Zhang Xin said: "I am a man of no account. I owe my position to Lord Li the Grand Mentor, and I cannot betray him!" Yougui pleaded illness and stayed indoors, secretly joining forces with the generals Gao Gu, Yang Huaibin, and others. Cui Hanheng had Tibetan troops camped south of Bin. Gao Gu said: "If Zhang Xin marches out with the army, Binzhou will be left defenseless." They forged a letter in Hun Jian's name summoning the Tibetans to press closer to the city. Zhang Xin and his party were terrified and in the end did not dare march out. Zhang Xin planned to kill any general who refused to obey. Yougui learned of it, rose first with Gao Gu and the others, and killed Zhang Xin. He sent Yang Huaibin with a memorial to the throne and a messenger to Cui Hanheng. Hanheng forged an edict appointing Yougui commander of the headquarters, and the army rejoiced. Huaiguang's son Min was at Bin. Yougui let him go. Someone said: "If you do not kill Min, how will you prove your loyalty to the court?" Yougui said: "Kill Min and Huaiguang will rage; his army will come at once. Better release him and let them flee." Yang Huaibin's son Chaocheng served in Huaiguang's army as commander of the right wing. When he heard the news he wept and told Huaiguang: "My father has served the state with merit. His son deserves execution and should not hold command." Huaiguang had him imprisoned. Yougui then held Binning; Dai Xiuyan Fengtian; Luo Yuanguang Zhaoying; Shang Ke'gu Lantian—all under Li Sheng's command. Sheng's prestige soared.
20
輿 使
At first, while Huaiguang was still strong, Zhu Ci feared him and wrote treating him as an elder brother, agreeing to divide the imperial domain in Guanzhong and remain neighbors forever. When Huaiguang turned rebel and drove the emperor south, many of his followers deserted him and his power waned. Ci then sent Huaiguang an edict addressing him as a subject and demanded his troops. Huaiguang burned with shame and rage, fearing mutiny within and Li Sheng without. He burned his camp and fled east, ravaging twelve counties including Jingyang until neither fowl nor dog remained. At Fuping, Generals Meng She and Duan Weiyong defected to Li Sheng with several thousand men; along the march troops deserted in an unbroken stream. At Hedong some urged the defending general Lü Mingyue to burn the bridge and hold him off, but Mingyue feared his small force could not resist and let him in; the prefect Li Qiyun abandoned the city and fled. Huaiguang sent General Zhao Guixian to build fortifications at Tongzhou. Prefect Li Shu fled in terror to the imperial camp. The staff officer Pei Xiang took charge of the prefecture, went to Guixian, and rebuked him with the rights and wrongs of loyalty and rebellion. Guixian was moved and offered to surrender; Tongzhou was saved intact. Pei Xiang was the son of Pei Zunqing. Huaiguang sent General Fu Yao to seize Fangzhou. Dou Gu, the Guanbei defender, led seven hundred hunter-soldiers to besiege him. Fu Yao asked to surrender. An edict made Dou Gu vice commander of the Guanbei campaign.
21
使
On dinghai Li Sheng was also appointed military commissioner of the Capital Region, Guanbei, Fu, Fang, Dan, and Yan.
22
On gengyin the imperial carriage reached Chenggu. Princess Tang'an died. She was the emperor's eldest daughter.
23
輿 祿 西 西 使
On the march, commoners brought melons and fruit as gifts. The emperor wished to reward them with probationary official titles and asked Lu Zhi. Zhi memorialized: "Rank and office must always be guarded and must never be dispensed lightly. A small beginning can breed great harm. Those who bring melons and fruit should receive only money and cloth, not office." The emperor said: "Probationary posts are empty titles. They do no harm." Zhi memorialized again in substance: "Since the war began, the treasury has not had enough for rewards, and offices have been used as bounty instead. Azure and vermilion badges crowd the ranks of clerks; gold and purple sashes are handed out to carriage men. Our trouble today is that rank has grown cheap. We strain to make it precious and still fear it is not honored enough—if Your Majesty now throws it away, how will you move anyone to serve! There are only two ways to move men: fame and gain. Fame is near to emptiness yet heavy in moral teaching; gain is near to substance yet light in virtue. Rely on gain alone without balancing it with fame, and the treasury is drained until goods run out. Rely on empty fame alone without real reward, and men see through the deceit and will not strive. The state therefore distinguishes office-holding posts, titular posts, merit posts, and noble titles—but only the office that carries duties and salary is substantive. That is how real gain is wrapped in empty fame. Merit titles, titular ranks, and noble names mostly govern dress and hereditary privilege alone. That is how empty fame assists real gain. Today's supernumerary and probationary posts resemble merit titles, titular ranks, and noble names. They carry no salary and do not fill regular quotas, yet men who break the enemy line and brave danger receive them, and men who exhaust themselves in service are repaid with them. If melon-bearers also receive probationary office, soldiers will say to one another: 'We won rank by risking our lives; they won rank by bringing melons. The state has made our lives worth no more than fruit.' Treat men like grass and wood, and who will still serve you willingly! Your Majesty now offers neither real reward to encourage service nor holds empty titles in esteem, yet dispenses them freely. Men have nothing to hold to. What reward will remain for those who earn merit hereafter!" Zhi served in the Hanlin and was the emperor's closest adviser. Though chancellors held office, in hardship the emperor consulted Zhi on every matter great and small. Men called him the inner chancellor; the emperor would not travel without him. The roads through Liang and Yang were treacherous. Once he lost Zhi for a whole night. The emperor wept in alarm and offered a thousand in gold to whoever brought him back. At last Zhi came. The emperor rejoiced, and from the crown prince down all offered congratulations. Yet Zhi spoke frankly again and again and often crossed the emperor's wishes. Though Lu Qi had been demoted, the emperor still sheltered him in his heart. Zhi insisted that Qi was treacherous and had brought on the rebellion. The emperor assented in appearance but was displeased at heart. Liu Congyi and Jiang Gongfu rose from humble posts to high office, while Zhi, for all his favor, never became chancellor. On renchen the imperial carriage reached Liangzhou. Shannan was thin soil and poor people. Since the An Lushan and Shi Siming rebellions, bandits had raided until more than half the households were gone. Though it governed fifteen prefectures, its tax yield did not match a few counties of the central plain. When the court halted there, grain and supplies ran very short. The emperor wished to go west to Chengdu. Yan Zhen said to him: "Shannan borders the capital region. Li Sheng is fighting to recover Chang'an. He needs the Six Armies as his rear. If Your Majesty goes to the western circuit, Sheng will have no hope of recovery." The court had not decided when Li Sheng's memorial arrived, saying: "Your Majesty's halt at Hanzhong holds the hearts of the empire and builds the momentum to destroy the rebels. If you choose the lesser and abandon the greater, moving the capital to Min and E, gentry and commoners will lose heart. Though you have fierce generals and wise advisers, none of their plans can be used!" The emperor thereupon abandoned the plan. Yan Zhen strained every device to gather revenue. The people did not sink into destitution, yet the court's needs were met. His military adjutant Yan Li, a younger cousin on his father's side, managed the transport of supplies and handled the work with great efficiency.
24
使使 使 輿 便 宿 使
Earlier, after the siege of Fengtian was lifted, Li Chuilin sent envoys with tribute. The emperor had no choice but to appoint him military commissioner of Fengxiang, though he loathed him. Advisers said Chuilin was brutal, treacherous, and changeable in loyalty, and that if he were not watched he might seize his chance. When several of Chuilin's envoys arrived, the emperor refused every audience and detained them without sending them home. Just after reaching Hanzhong, the emperor wished to replace Chuilin at Fengxiang with Hun Jian. Lu Zhi memorialized: "Chuilin's crime of murdering his commander to aid the rebels is grave, yet the throne is not restored, the chief rebel still lives, and the loyal armies are all in the capital region. Urgent orders must race against the clock. The Shangling road is long and roundabout; the Luogu road is held by bandits. Imperial orders barely pass—only through Baoxie remains. If that road too is blocked, north and south will be severed. The circuits stand in peril and doubt, pressed between two rebels who entice and coerce them. Popular feeling runs high, and each man wavers between loyalty and defection. If Chuilin should give way to resentment and rise in open violence, blocking the southern passes and joining the great rebel in the east, our throat would be choked and our heart and spine torn apart. Now Chuilin wavers between two sides. Heaven is turning his heart, clearing the road home, and he is ready to serve the great cause of restoration. Your Majesty should take this deeply to heart, treat him generously, and win his wavering loyalty. That alone would be enough to settle the matter. If you insist on probing every past deed and dredging up old faults, then no reform will ever atone for guilt and no repentance will ever redeem a crime. Which of today's generals and officials is without blemish? Every man looks inward and asks who can escape doubt and fear. Still more those who defied orders and those dragged along by force know they have failed in grace. How would they dare come back? The harm is no small matter. Your Majesty should act on it at once. I beg Your Majesty to keep the broad vision of a great ruler and not let a moment's resentment undermine the work of restoration." The emperor's anger lifted. He treated Chuilin's envoys kindly and sent a gracious edict to comfort them.
25
使
On dingyou Liu Qia, military commissioner of Xuanwu, was appointed associate grand councillor.
26
使使
On jihai Hun Jian, chief army controller at the mobile court, was made associate grand councillor and military commissioner of Shuofang, and deputy commander over the armies of Shuofang, Binning, Zhenwu, Yongping, and the Fengtian campaign.
27
使 便
On gengzi an edict listed Li Huaiguang's crimes, praised the loyalty and merit of the Shuofang troops, yet in view of his past service showed leniency. He was stripped of his posts as deputy commander, grand marshal, director of the Secretariat, governor of Hezhong, and all his military and surveillance commissions, and was named grand guardian of the heir apparent. His troops were left to the army to choose a leader of high merit and standing, to report at once for appointment with banner and staff, following the soldiers' will.
28
使使 使使
In summer, in the fourth month, on renyin Han Yougui was appointed military commissioner of Binning. On guimao Dai Xiuyan was appointed military commissioner of the Fengtian campaign.
29
Ning Jingxuan, the defending general at Lingwu, was building a mansion for Li Huaiguang. Another general, Li Ruxian, said, "Grand Marshal Li drove out the Son of Heaven, and Jingxuan builds him a house. That is rebellion too!" They attacked and killed him.
30
使
On jiachen Li Sheng was made deputy commander over Yanfang, the capital region, Weibei, and Shanghua. Sheng's household of a hundred souls and the families of his Shence troops were all in Chang'an, and Zhu Ci treated them kindly. When anyone in the army spoke of home, Sheng wept and said, "Where is the Son of Heaven? How dare you speak of family!" Ci sent one of Sheng's close attendants with a letter from his family, saying, "Your household is safe." Sheng raged, "You dare spy for the rebel!" He had him beheaded at once. The men had not received their spring clothing and in midsummer still wore furs and coarse cloth, yet never wavered in loyalty.
31
使使
On yisi Tang Zhaochen was appointed military commissioner of Hezhong, Tong, and Zhong. Li Qiyun, former governor of Hezhong, was made governor of Jingzhao to provision Sheng's army with grain and labor.
32
使使 西 西
On gengxu Tian Xu was appointed military commissioner of Weibo. Hun Jian led the armies out through Xié Valley. Cui Hanheng urged the Tibetans to send troops. Shang Jiezan said, "If the Binning army does not march out, they will strike us from behind." When Han Yougui heard this, he sent Cao Zida with three thousand men to join Hun Jian. The Tibetans sent Lun Mangluoyi with twenty thousand in support. Li Chuilin sent Shi Hong with seven hundred men to join Hun Jian and take Wugong. On gengxu Zhu Ci sent Han Min and others against Wugong. Hong brought his men over to the enemy. Hun Jian was beaten and withdrew his men to the western heights. Then Cao Zida arrived with the Tibetans, struck Han Min, and routed him at Wuting River. More than ten thousand heads were taken. Min barely escaped alive. Hun Jian then encamped at Fengtian, coordinating with Li Sheng from east and west to press Chang'an.
33
使
The emperor wished to build a pagoda for Princess Tang'an and give her a lavish burial. Jiang Gongfu, remonstrance counsellor and associate grand councillor, memorialized against it: "Shannan is no lasting home. The princess will one day be brought back to the capital. The burial should be modest to meet the army's urgent needs." The emperor sent word to Lu Zhi: "The pagoda for Tang'an costs very little. It is not a matter for a councillor to debate. Gongfu only wants to point out my faults and make a name for himself. When a councillor fails me like this, what should be done with him?" Zhi memorialized that Gongfu, as councillor, had done his duty in remonstrance and should not be punished. He wrote in part: "Gongfu and I were lately together in the Hanlin. If I argue for him I risk the charge of faction. If I yield to Your Majesty's wish I betray the duty of a true minister. To avoid suspicion would only spare my own skin. To violate righteousness would stain the grace shown to us all. To spare oneself and forget one's lord is a minister's shame!" He also wrote: "Only a ruler blind and confused lets complaint flood the realm yet refuses to hear it, lets foul conduct reach Heaven yet will not wake—until ruin comes and he still does not know his error." He also wrote: "One should ask whether the principle is right or wrong, not whether the matter is large or small! The Book of Yu says, 'Be diligent, be diligent—in one day, two days, ten thousand affairs.' In the age of Yao and Shun, though lord and ministers were sage and worthy, minute concerns still ran to ten thousand a day. If the minute could not be neglected then, how can Your Majesty dismiss it lightly now!" He also wrote: "If remonstrance is called fault-finding, then the lord who laid open his heart should not have been blamed by a wise king; if remonstrance is called fame-seeking, then the minister who gave his life for his lord should not stand as a model in the sacred canon." He also wrote: "Even if a minister meant to find fault and win fame, if Your Majesty hears good counsel and changes, welcomes remonstrance and does not resist, then what he points out will only display Your Majesty's great virtue, and what he gains will only add to Your Majesty's boundless blessing. You would profit by it—and greatly. But if you are angry at fault-finding and do not reform, Your Majesty will be blamed for hating honest counsel; if you dismiss him for seeking fame and will not hear him, Your Majesty will be blamed for rejecting counsel. You would hide your faults and make them more visible, wound his reputation and make it shine the brighter. If you act on that course, the loss will be great." The emperor remained angry. On jiayin Jiang Gongfu was demoted to left subordinate of the heir apparent.
34
西使
Zhang Yanshang, military commissioner of Xichuan, was made associate grand councillor in reward for keeping the court supplied without fail.
35
使使 使
Zhu Ci and Yao Lingyan sent envoys again and again to win over Feng Heqing, military commissioner of Jingyuan. Heqing beheaded every one. The senior general Tian Xijian secretly colluded with Zhu Ci, killed Heqing, and surrendered the command to the rebel. Zhu Ci appointed Tian Xijian military commissioner of Jingyuan.
36
The emperor asked Lu Zhi: "Lately the minor officials arriving from north of the mountains have mostly not been trustworthy. One Xing Jian spoke of the rebels' strength in the most alarmist terms. His conduct looks like reconnaissance. I have already detained him in one place. There are several more like him. If they are not pursued, I fear a treacherous plot may succeed. Consider what should be done instead." Zhi memorialized that while rebels hold the palace, those who brave danger to reach the mobile court should be rewarded generously. How can we suspect and imprison them again! He wrote in part: "To try with one man's eyes and ears to master every change under heaven, and with one man's caution to defeat the deceit of millions—the cleverer the effort, the further from the Way. Xiang Yu took in two hundred thousand Qin surrender troops, feared treachery, and buried them all alive at once. His caution could hardly have been greater. Gaozu of Han was open and magnanimous. When talent came to him from all the realm, he employed it without suspicion. His caution could hardly have been looser. Yet the house of Xiang was destroyed and the house of Liu rose. Hoarding suspicion and extending sincerity yield very different ends. The First Emperor of Qin was stern and deeply suspicious, yet Jing Ke carried out his secret plot; Emperor Guangwu was tolerant and generous, and Ma Yuan gave him his whole-hearted loyalty. Is it not because an open heart wins men, and men in turn wish to serve? While to rule by schemes alone leaves nothing truly loyal! When men feel welcome they are moved to devotion, and even enemies become loyal followers; when they feel rejected they fear and resist, and even kin become countless enemies." He also wrote: "Your Majesty's wisdom surpasses all others, yet there is a tendency to slight your ministers; your thought embraces every affair, and there is a wish to rule the realm alone; your plans swallow every scheme, and there is a guard of excessive caution; your clarity reads every mood, and there is foresight before events; you bind the hundred officials strictly, trusting punishment to bring order; you awe the four quarters, with a will to overcome cruelty by force alone. Hence the able resented being unused, the loyal grieved at suspicion, men of merit feared rejection, and the wavering were driven toward rebellion—until separation and disaster followed. What the Son of Heaven does, the realm watches as its model. Even small acts demand caution—how much more these! I beg Your Majesty to take the wreck of past carts as warning, for the boundless blessing of the dynasty."
37
使 使 使 使
On dingsi Jia Dan of Nanpi, former military commissioner of Shannan East Circuit, was appointed minister of works. Earlier Jia Dan had sent his campaign army marshal Fan Ze to report at the mobile court. Fan Ze had just reported back and a great banquet was under way when an urgent dispatch arrived appointing him to replace Jia Dan as military commissioner. Jia Dan slipped the dispatch into his robe, drank on as before, and never changed color. When the feast ended he summoned Fan Ze, told him the news, and ordered his officers to pay their respects to the new commissioner. His military adjutant Zhang Xianfu raged: "The campaign marshal was sent to inquire after the Son of Heaven's health for the minister, yet he dared scheme for the commission himself and seize the minister's territory. That is disloyal service. The men will not accept it. I ask leave to kill him." Jia Dan said, "What talk is this! Whom the Son of Heaven appoints is already military commissioner!" That same day he left the post, taking Zhang Xianfu with him, and the headquarters settled into peace.
38
Li Kui, left vice director, returning from Tibet, died at Fengzhou on jiazi.
39
Han Yougui led his troops to join Hun Jian at Fengtian.
40
使
On bingyin Li Na, military commissioner of Pinglu, was made associate grand councillor.
41
On dingmao Zhu Ci, Prince of Yi, died.
42
退西 輿 退
Zhu Tao besieged Beizhou for more than a hundred days, and Ma Shi besieged Weizhou for more than forty. Neither could take the city. Jia Lin again spoke for Li Baozhen to Li Wujun: "Zhu Tao aims to swallow Bei and Wei. Tian Yue has just been killed. If no relief comes within ten days, all of Weibo will fall to Tao. Once Weibo falls, Zhang Xiaozhong will surely submit to him. Tao will unite three circuits' armies, add the Uyghurs, and march on Changshan. Can you preserve your clan then? If Changshan falls, Zhaoyi will retreat to the western mountains, and all Hebei will pass to Zhu Tao. Better to act while Bei and Wei still hold out and join Zhaoyi in a relief army. Once Tao is destroyed, Guanzhong will lose heart; Zhu Ci will soon be executed; the throne will return to order—and among the generals, who will rank above you!" Wujun was pleased and agreed. On the wuchen day, Wujun encamped southeast of Nangong; Baozhen marched from Linming to join him, their camps ten li apart. The two armies still distrusted each other; the next day Baozhen rode to Wujun's camp with only a few horsemen. His staff urged him to stop, but he ordered his field marshal Lu Xuanqing to hold the troops ready and said, "This ride concerns the fate of the realm. If I do not return, take command and obey the court—that is yours; rouse the men to vengeance—that is yours as well." He finished and rode on. Wujun received him under strict guard; Baozhen spoke of the realm's disaster and the emperor's exile, seized Wujun, and wept until tears ran down his face. Wujun too was overcome with grief; those around him could not bear to look up. He pledged brotherhood with Wujun and swore to destroy the rebels together. Wujun said, "Your fame fills the four seas, Elder Brother; you once opened my eyes and let me turn from rebellion to loyalty, escape execution, and enjoy princely honors. Now you set aside the difference between us and Chinese and deign to be my brother—how can I ever repay you! Tao relies only on the Uyghurs—they are nothing to fear. On the day of battle, I ask you to hold your reins and watch; I will break them for you." Baozhen withdrew into Wujun's tent and slept deeply for a long while. Wujun was deeply moved and treated him with still greater respect; pointing to his heart he looked to heaven and said, "This life is already pledged to die for you!" They then united their camps and advanced together.
43
Shannan was hot; because the soldiers lacked spring clothing, the emperor himself wore layered garments.
44
CATEGORY:
Category: Zizhi Tongjian.
← Previous Chapter
Back to Chapters
Next Chapter →